Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, Dave was doing family stuff like a nerd, so Sarge asked his buddy Maynerd to come and hang out. In this episode we discuss the real life inspiration for Edgar Allen Poe's story "The Cask Of Amontillado". This story takes place on Castle Island in Boston Harbor. It's one hell of a ride and strangely involves Fallout 4. I hope you like it.
Jul 07, 2025•29 min•Season 5Ep. 116
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, we are joined by a very special guest, the voice behind our theme song and lead singer of Killed By A Yeti, Dipper Satterfield! In this episode, we dive into one of the more interesting Cold War-era alien visitation stories, Valiant Thor! Go listen to Killed By A Yeti on whatever your preferred music platform may be.
Jun 30, 2025•35 min•Season 5Ep. 115
Fear Daily takes you into the shadows of the past, unearthing the 1990's most terrifying tales of monsters, madness, and life after death. Join us as we explore the ghost stories and supernatural encounters left on an old online bulletin board that continues to operate somewhere in an unknown part of the Pennsylvania Rust Belt - a time capsule of society's greatest fears. Written by Brennan Storr, creator of The Ghost Story Guys, and hosted by Brandon Schexnayder, creator of Southern Gothic... F...
Jun 26, 2025•24 min
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, we dive into some relatively recent Scottish folklore and talk about the absolutely nightmarish entity known as the Gurning Man of Glasgow. Is he just a man? A ghost? Or something interdimensional? We have no idea. But we try to figure out!
Jun 23, 2025•46 min•Season 5Ep. 114
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, Dave decided he wanted to learn about the origins of everyone's favorite cursed day, Friday the 13th, which means you all have to learn about it as well!
Jun 16, 2025•32 min•Season 5Ep. 113
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, we are diving into the untold horrors that reside at 50 Berkeley Square in the Mayfair neighborhood of London, England. Once a posh and upscale home, it is now the center of some of the most terrifying tales to come out of this well-to-do area. Is it haunted? Is it a home to some sort of cryptid? Or is there something behind those walls much worse? Well, give it a listen and tell us what you think! Enjoy!
Jun 09, 2025•36 min•Season 4Ep. 112
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party and the beginning of our new ongoing series "DEBUNKED" where we break down conspiracy theories and discuss why they are absolutely and undeniably false. This week, we are covering one of the most famous conspiracies outside of the JFK assassination, the conspiracy that 9/11 was an inside job! Enjoy!
Jun 02, 2025•53 min•Season 4Ep. 111
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we dive into one of the older urban legends you can find hiding on the internet, the red night vision demons of the Vietnam War! Full disclosure, we may or may not have started drinking well before we started recording so hopefully you enjoy!
May 26, 2025•34 min•Season 4Ep. 110
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, we are joined by Chuck Staton of the Funbearable Podcast to unravel a the decades old mystery known as the Toynbee Tiles. We cover the possible meaning behind their cryptic messages, how they were placed, and who may have been behind it. This episode was a ton of fun so sit back and enjoy! Be sure to check out Funbearable and if you happen to be in the New England area on June 1st, make sure you snag tickets to their live show...
May 19, 2025•42 min•Season 4Ep. 109
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, in honor of Mothers Day, we thought we would celebrate some of our favorite mothers of folklore and legend by doing a special episode dedicated to them. We cover everyone's favorite La Llorona and some lesser-known Ghost Moms - Oiwa, Rusalka, and Ubume. All creepy and all certified tiger moms! Enjoy.
May 12, 2025•28 min•Season 4Ep. 108
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, Dave is violently hungover, so it's time for another redux episode. This time, we're going back over the case of The Grafton Monster! There are some new facts, some old, and it's Sarge's first time hearing it, so give it a listen and enjoy!
May 05, 2025•28 min•Season 4Ep. 107
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, we dive deep into the Glimmer Man. A possible cryptid/alien/spirit/military experiment that has been haunting the world for almost four decades. And it may or may not be the Predator. Whatever it is, it sucks. Enjoy!
Apr 27, 2025•37 min•Season 4Ep. 106
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, we close out our two-part series on Mark Richards with what really happened to land this man behind bars. No, it wasn't some shadowy cabal of reptilian overlords or some government cover-up; it was the fact that he murdered a man in cold blood to fund his plot to take over a chunk of California and declare himself king! So... that's pretty fun!
Apr 21, 2025•58 min•Season 4Ep. 105
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, we dive into the world of Captain Mark Richards and his journey rising through the ranks of the Secret Space Program. From saving the world multiple times over to being the first human ever successfully to pilot the sentient spacecraft known as Minerva! This story is wild, so strap in and brace yourselves
Apr 14, 2025•53 min•Season 4Ep. 104
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, we decided to try something a little different and dip our toes into the world of cults and discuss the 1950s UFO doomsday cult known as The Seekers, who not only ended up being 100% wrong about their predictions but, also ended up being the case study for the theory of cognitive dissonance! So that's cool!
Apr 07, 2025•43 min•Season 4Ep. 103
Brother Sarge, Father Maynerd, and Sister Laura from Citizen's Guide To The Supernormal discuss the unholy beasts of Appalachia in this, the first episode of Christian Cocktail Party.
Apr 01, 2025•42 min•Season 4Ep. 102
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we are joined by comedian Rob Crean to talk about TikTok and Reddits favorite cryptid, the Not-Deer! What is a Not-Deer you may be asking yourselves? Well...what isn't!? That is the real question you should be asking. Find Rob Crean and his comedy right here
Mar 25, 2025•43 min•Season 4Ep. 101
Welcome to the 100th episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we are joined by Chris and Ed of Scared All The Time to discuss one of the wildest and less known CIA psyops where an elite team of operatives used the Filipino legend of the Aswang against 300 communist rebels. Find where to listen to and follow Scared All The Time here
Mar 17, 2025•1 hr•Season 4Ep. 100
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, we are joined by Nash Hoover of Chasing Legends to discuss one of the most requested topics we have ever had...Mokele-Mbembe!
Mar 10, 2025•47 min•Season 4Ep. 99
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, we are joined by friend of the show Mike Dionne, better known as Eyenine. On this episode, we cover ANOTHER alien encounter in Soviet era Russia. We are headed to the city of Voronezh to discuss one of the more controversial extraterrestrial encounters in modern time, the Voronezh UFO Encounter! Find Eyenine on Spotify here Follow Eyenine on Instagram...
Mar 03, 2025•36 min•Season 4Ep. 98
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This weeks episode is really...just for us. But if you wanna listen it’s about the phenomenon known as Spontaneous Human Combustion! We go over a whole range of cases dating all the way back to the 1400s up to the more famous cases of the 20th and 21st centuries. Its a scorcher of an episode if I do say so myself. Enjoy
Feb 24, 2025•49 min•Season 4Ep. 97
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we are joined by Ed Larson of Last Podcast On The Left but more importantly...of Florida! So we decided we would take a nice tour of his home state and cover some of the weirder and lesser known legends and lore of the Sunshine State. We cover the Lovebug Conspiracy, the Carnivorous Pink Mist, and the North Port Devils! Buy tickets to catch the Invasive Species Tour here: eddietunes.com...
Feb 17, 2025•59 min•Season 4Ep. 96
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we dive into religion, specifically, Mormonism. We give a crash course on the founding and beginnings of the LDS, their beliefs on the Garden of Eden, Cain and Abel, and how Cain may or may not have been cursed by God to roam the Earth as...Bigfoot. Enjoy!
Feb 09, 2025•35 min•Season 4Ep. 95
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, we’re diving deep—literally—into one of the strangest underwater encounters ever reported. In the murky depths of Russia’s Lake Baikal, the deepest freshwater lake on Earth, Soviet military divers allegedly came face-to-face with something they were never meant to see: massive, humanoid creatures in silvery suits, gliding effortlessly through the frigid water. What did these "swimmers" want? Were they extraterrestrial visitors...
Feb 03, 2025•34 min•Season 4Ep. 94
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! Kind of... it's our two-year anniversary this episode, so we thought it would be fun to revisit our first episode ever and give it a little glow up. So we retooled it, punched it up, and are giving you a better and updated version of everyones favorite cryptid, the Flatwoods Monster! Listen to me talk shit on The Spooky Shed: Part 1 and Part 2...
Jan 27, 2025•43 min•Season 4Ep. 93
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, we are joined by friend of the show Jeremy London (Mallrats, Party Of Five) to discuss one of, and I say this all the time but really mean it, the wildest alien abduction stories to come out of Japan—or anywhere, for that matter. For real. So...enjoy!
Jan 20, 2025•49 min•Season 4Ep. 92
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week, Dave took the day off and left Sarge unattended. Hours later, covered in sweat, and his mind exploding with information, Sarge tells his best friend and long suffering neighbor, Maynerd, about the phenomenon of gangstalking. If you or a family member suffers from symptoms associated with gangstalking, please check out these resources: https://www.samhsa.gov/
Jan 13, 2025•35 min•Season 4Ep. 91
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we kick off 2025 strong, not really, with an alien abduction case that we feel is underrated, sick as hell, and rad as fuck, but also changed how people in the community looked at group abductions. This week we cover...the Allagash Abductions (as well as some of the myths on Hypnotic Regression Therapy) Enjoy!
Jan 06, 2025•40 min•Season 3Ep. 90
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we are covering one of Dave's all-time favorite theories...Hollow Moon! Is it a space station built by an ancient alien civilization? Was it built by humans in the distant future and brought back through time and placed here to save humanity? Or is it a hologram meant to shield us from the truth? I dunno. Maybe to all of it? Give it a listen, enjoy, and let us know what you think the moon REALLY is!
Dec 30, 2024•57 min•Season 3Ep. 89
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we celebrate the Winter Solstice and cover one of the most well-known and terrifying figures of holiday folklore...Krampus! The goat-horned demon of Pagan turned Christian tradition known for his horrifying imagery and harsh punishments. His story and journey through the centuries is wildly fascinating and super fun so sit back and enjoy! Snag a Krampusnacht box here: www.thehellmouthparanormal.com...
Dec 23, 2024•35 min•Season 3Ep. 88
