It's Tracy Turnblad herself! The OG from the Tony Award-winning Broadway Musical! Strap in and get ready for a fun ride with Marissa Jaret Winokur! The Tony Award winner shares her journey to becoming Tracy Turnblad on Broadway, and her stories have Jenna and Kevin laughing the whole time! From heading to L.A. for the very first time thanks to Lucy Lawless, booking a small role in a huge Oscar-winning movie, showing up to Hollywood parties uninvited, to getting seen by the right people that led ...
Oct 02, 2025•50 min
50 years later, and ‘The Rocky Horror Picture Show’ is still going strong! Jenna and Kevin are doing the Time Warp and exploring the cult classic musical! They share their appreciation for the film and Glee’s ode to the musical, dive into the controversy surrounding the movie, their initial thoughts when they first saw the movie, and their dream casting for a possible remake. Hint - you might go gaga for their suggestions! Plus, Jenna and Kevin are celebrating their friendiversary! For fun, excl...
Sep 29, 2025•59 min
It's a new era for ATWYRM! Tune in as Jenna and Kevin answer all your note-worthy questions about this new adventure! From the musicals they plan on watching, to whether 'KPop Demon Hunters' will be included on their watch list, their upcoming guests, and the musicals that first made them fall in love with the genre! Plus, Jenna opens up about her time performing and recording alongside future stars with Broadway Kids! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagr...
Sep 26, 2025•15 min
He was pitch-perfect on the small screen in ‘Glee’ and ‘Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist!’ The one and only Skylar Astin shares fun behind-the-scenes stories with Jenna and Kevin about his time on both TV musical shows! Like, which show had more rehearsal time, how much live singing they actually did on Zoey’s, the performance he calls a career highlight, and a story that gives Jenna chills! Plus, tales from Broadway, including an actor’s worst nightmare! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-...
Sep 25, 2025•56 min
Kevin and Jenna are back with their next recap, the TV musical series, “Zoey’s Extraordinary Playlist.” The lead of the show can hear people sing their inner feelings or “heart songs” as she calls them. The show has a lot of heart, and there are a lot of Glee crossovers! The duo shares their thoughts on the live performances, the premise, the cast, and their experience auditioning for the show! Including the role Kevin was being considered for that went to another Glee alum! For fun, exclusive c...
Sep 22, 2025•52 min
Reunited and it feels so good! The 'Glee' cast had a mini-reunion on 'Celebrity Weakest Link' and a gleeful time was had! Jenna brought her A-game to the competition series and has all the behind-the-scenes scoop! From how it all came together, what the cast wasn't told, to how they reacted to seeing Jane Lynch back in her Sue Sylvester tracksuit, and what it was like to hang out and compete with castmates like Heather Morris, Chord Overstreet, Amber Riley, and more! Plus, the reality show Jenna...
Sep 19, 2025•21 min
Get ready for some great behind-the-scenes scoop about the making of 2007's Hairspray from the man who was at the helm of the film! Producer, Choreographer, and Director Adam Shankman joins Jenna and Kevin to share some great stories about his toe-tapping and delightful musical, including the lengths he went to in order to assemble his A-list cast, like his memorable 1 AM dinner with John Travolta! Brittany Snow and Zac Efron bombing their first audition, the actor he initially didn't want, and ...
Sep 18, 2025•1 hr 23 min
Kevin and Jenna are back with another musical deep dive - this time it’s 2007’s Hairspray! And the Glee connections are everywhere: Adam Shankman’s direction, Zach Woodlee’s choreography, and even songs later covered on Glee. They break down the stacked cast - John Travolta, Christopher Walken, Queen Latifah, Zac Efron, and more - plus Jenna’s surprising 180 from not remembering she liked the movie to having the time of her life on rewatch. Kevin also shares his personal connection to Elijah Kel...
Sep 15, 2025•1 hr 9 min
Get-cha Head In the Game because Coach Bolton from 'High School Musical' is on the pod! He's the MVP Dad and Coach of East High, but he almost didn't score the part! Bart Johnson joins Jenna and Kevin to share great behind-the-scenes stories from "High School Musical," including how he got the role after first missing his shot, the impact the movie had on his career, and the moment he knew HSM was more than just a small Disney Channel movie! Plus, the scoop on his brand new podcast, "Get Your He...
Sep 12, 2025•40 min
"High School Musical" premiered on the Disney Channel almost 20 years ago, introducing a new generation to musicals and catapulting the young cast to international stardom! Scene stealer 'Ryan Evans' aka Lucas Grabeel joins Jenna and Kevin to talk about the smash hit musical that became a pop cultural phenomenon! From his initial audition for the role of 'Troy,' to working with Kenny Ortega to develop his character, and the reality of living in a moldy apartment while the movie was blowing up! H...
Sep 11, 2025•59 min
It's the post-Glee era and the start of something new! Kevin and Jenna are back with the rewatch podcast format you know and love, but this time, they're focusing on iconic musicals! First up, the Disney movie that introduced musicals to a whole new generation - “High School Musical!” The duo shares their thoughts on the casting, performances, plot, soundtrack, and their obsession with the legendary Kenny Ortega! Plus, the Glee connection! Kevin shares his audition story for HSM, singing the sou...
Sep 08, 2025•53 min
What is the feeling that Glee leaves you with? We've heard from the cast and crew, but now it's time to hear from you! Kevin and Jenna turn the podcast over to the "Glee" community, and the community has responded! Hope, pride, and joy are just a few of the adjectives that kept popping up. Plus, the characters fans connected with and why, the personal inspiration drawn from the show, and the valuable lessons learned. For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram...
Sep 04, 2025•35 min
Glee took viewers on an emotional rollercoaster ride every week, but what feelings did it leave the cast and crew with? It’s the question Kevin and Jenna wrap up every guest interview with: What is the feeling that Glee leaves you with? Now, they’re revisiting some of their favorite answers from cast and crew - including Matthew Morrison, Dianna Agron, Darren Criss, Amber Riley, Jane Lynch, and more. And for the first time, they finally share their own answers too! For fun, exclusive content, an...
Sep 01, 2025•38 min
Naya Rivera and Santana Lopez left an indelible mark on Glee fans, so it's only right to hear from you, the fans! Kevin and Jenna turn the podcast over to Glee fans from all over the globe for their heartfelt memories of Naya, favorite Santana moments, and how she made people feel seen for the first time ever with her trailblazing role as a Latina LGBTQ+ character. Naya Rivera’s legacy continues and will continue to shine brightly. For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow ...
Aug 28, 2025•41 min
On Glee, Santana was a shining star who commanded attention with her undeniable talent, charisma, and spark (and snark) brought to life by the one and only Naya Rivera. Kevin and Jenna are honoring and celebrating Naya’s talent, professionalism, magnetic personality, and impact on the cast and crew. They share their favorite memories of Naya from on and off the set, and we hear fond memories from some of the Glee cast and crew, including Heather Morris and Jane Lynch. For fun, exclusive content,...
Aug 25, 2025•34 min
Could this be the tour of all gleeking tours?! Gleek of the Week Podcast’s Andrew McGuire is back and blows Jenna and Kevin away with his dream Glee reunion tour with a full-on McKinley High experience! The guest stars, the Cheerios, the lockers! They are dreaming big! Like Vegas Residency at the Sphere, big! It’s so good that they wouldn’t be mad if fans started a petition to make it a reality! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @ andthatswhatyoureal...
Aug 21, 2025•46 min
The votes are in, and they're surprising! Now that all six seasons have been recapped, it’s time for the final rankings. Yes, the ultimate picks for favorite character, episodes, performances, and more! And let’s just say Jenna and Kevin were very surprised by some of the picks and what did and didn’t make the cut! Plus, the final ranking of the seasons! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @ andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureal...
Aug 18, 2025•38 min
This is not a drill! The one and only Quinn Fabray is here! Yes, the fan's most requested guest is finally on the pod! Dianna Agron is back with Jenna and Kevin to share more stories about her time on Glee! Including what it was like slapping Rachel and Santana, her big literal flop on set that left her with rug burns, where Quinn is now, and she shares her fond memories and a super sweet story about Cory Monteith. Plus, how she's putting everything she learned on Glee to use on the projects she...
Aug 14, 2025•49 min
This is not a drill! The one and only Quinn Fabray is here! Yes, the fan's most requested guest is finally on the pod! Dianna Agron joins Jenna and Kevin to share stories about her time on Glee! From her audition song to the funny way she found out about Quinn's pregnancy storyline, the hardest scene for her to shoot, and her reaction to the "Say A Little Prayer" TikTok trend! Plus, the trio shares their first impressions of each other, and you won't believe what they say! Stay tuned for part tw...
Aug 11, 2025•33 min
What do Full House and Glee have in common? Tune in to find out on this pod swap! Yes, it's a Full House and Glee crossover! Jodie Sweetin & Andrea Barber from Full House and the podcast How Rude, Tanneritos! pod swap with Jenna and Kevin, and the laughs and revelations are nonstop! Get ready to find out why Jenna and Kevin freaked out at a party John Stamos invited them to, and the differences between Full House's and Glee's final season that had them all saying, 'How rude!' Plus, the group...
Aug 08, 2025•35 min
Glee’s Matt Rutherford is on the pod! Producer, actor, singer, and director Dijon Talton joins Jenna and Kevin to talk about being a part of Glee's first season and the emotional impact of his sudden departure before season two. He also shares memories of his time working with Harry Shum Jr., Naya Rivera, and Heather Morris, his favorite show performances, and what it was like returning for the final season of the show. For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instag...
Aug 07, 2025•26 min
We’ve crossed the finish line, and now it’s time for the post-analysis! Jenna and Kevin are back with their final thoughts on season 6 and, of course, fan votes! You’ll want to tune in to hear their picks for best pitch-perfect songs, the couples that made beautiful music together, and the episodes that hit the right notes! Plus, Jenna finds some of the viewer votes “fascinating,” why they have mixed feelings about the season, and one of Kevin’s picks makes Jenna say, “Eww!” For fun, exclusive c...
Aug 04, 2025•26 min
You've heard Brad Buecker's name mentioned over and over on this podcast! He was there from the very beginning of Glee as an editor on the Pilot to directing the very final episode of the series. The Emmy-nominated Director and Executive Producer joins Jenna and Kevin to share many great behind-the-scenes stories, like revealing one of the "dumbest things he's ever said" to Ryan Murphy that will shock you! Plus, the time he caught two actors doing something they weren't supposed to be doing whil...
Jul 31, 2025•1 hr 4 min
They came, they saw, and they conquered the ratings, the charts, and our hearts! Yes, we have come to the end of the road! Jenna and Kevin are back to recap Glee's series finale, and they have so many memories to share! They spill the tea on the tears shed (so many tears), the party atmosphere, the tequila, and behind-the-scenes stories about the performances! Plus, they reveal what they each stole from the set, and what they really think of the episode! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-th...
Jul 28, 2025•57 min
Emmy-winning director Paris Barclay is back to talk about directing Glee’s penultimate episode, “2009!” The highly acclaimed director and producer opens up to Kevin and Jenna about the emotional and technical challenges of shooting 2009, his pick for show MVP, why he thinks the series should have ended with 2009, and a list of easter eggs you might have missed! Plus, his hot take on “The Quarterback,” and a shout-out to the unsung heroes of the show - the editors! And that’s what you really miss...
Jul 24, 2025•49 min
It’s the penultimate episode of Glee! Jenna and Kevin travel back in time to 2009, where we see how our favorite misfits came to join the Glee Club! The duo has loads of memories, including what it was like revisiting the original versions of their characters, how the Finn scenes mirrored real life, the behind-the-scenes scoop on Tina’s performance of “I Kissed a Girl” and Artie’s “Pony.” Plus, the scene they couldn’t get through because they were all laughing so hard! For fun, exclusive content...
Jul 21, 2025•50 min
Get ready for the Most Fun Episode You Shouldn't Miss! In the spirit of wrapping up their Glee rewatch, Jenna and Kevin are assigning Yearbook Superlatives to Glee characters, their castmates, and even episodes! Find out who they crown, Class Clown, Teacher's Pet, Biggest On-Set Prankster, Most Unhinged Plot, and so much more! Plus, it's not just them having all the fun ... listeners weigh in with their own superlatives, and some are truly creative, such as "Most Dramatic Hallway Confrontation" ...
Jul 17, 2025•25 min
It’s the last Glee sectionals ever! It’s New Directions vs Vocal Adrenaline, and the winner is... the viewers! Jenna and Kevin love the performances with the newbies and share their thoughts and feelings about the winners, the song choices, and this being the only competition episode they weren’t a part of! Plus, they break down Rachel’s big decision, spill on the scene inspired by Glee’s real-life choreographer, the return of Jesse St. James, and the “gut punch” scene that got to Kevin and Jenn...
Jul 14, 2025•36 min
It's getting hot in herre! Get ready to start fanning yourselves, because Jenna and Kevin are back with some sizzling hot fan-submitted hot takes! Yes, they are reading your notes, DM's, and playing your voice messages, and whoa, so many of you are against Tina and Artie being end game! The duo reacts to who the fans think they should have ended up with. Plus, a hilarious pitch for a Glee reboot starring Brittany as a teacher, Faberry for the win, Klaine heading towards divorce, and the hill Jen...
Jul 10, 2025•22 min
Lies are exposed, Geraldo Rivera gets slapped and Michel Bolton pops up?! Things are getting a little wacky as we near the end! Kevin and Jenna are back with their recap and have mixed feelings about this episode. From the return of Sue’s ‘Hurt Locker’ to Rachel’s confusing storyline (the duo disagrees on this), the song choices, the guest stars, and the scene Kevin found so distracting because he swears everyone was reading off cue cards! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips,...
Jul 07, 2025•37 min
