Happy 4th of July! Let the sparks fly! Jenna and Kevin are back with a fun-sized episode, chatting about their plans for the fourth! Kevin has a date with Beyoncé, and for Jenna, if the sun's out, the buns are out … hamburger buns that is! Plus, they talk about getting close to the end of their recaps and what that means to them. May the fourth be with you! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes scoops, be sure to follow on Instagram @ andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod! See omnystudio.co...
Jun 30, 2025•19 min
Josie Totah grew up watching Glee as a kid, and then, at the age of 13, she lived out her dreams by being cast on the show as “Myron Muskovitz!” Josie is all grown up now and joins Jenna and Kevin to chat about her time on the show, including her audition process, the crazy way she learned she was going to be on the show for the rest of the season, the Glee actor she connected with immediately, and getting real about feeling overwhelmed on set and the labor-intensive schedule! Josie also talks a...
Jun 26, 2025•55 min
It’s the episode that sends Sue back to her Hurt Locker and introduces some new faces! Yes! It’s the debut of Josie Totah and Finneas! Jenna and Kevin are blown away by 13-year-old Josie’s over-the-top Myron! And Jenna had no clue Finneas was on Glee until recently!! They also share the performances they really liked, the storyline they loved, and the cringy one they didn’t care for! Plus, they get real about not being in this episode and what it was like watching others carrying the baton! For ...
Jun 23, 2025•41 min
For old times' sake ... Jenna and Kevin are back answering fan questions for the last time before they finish watching the series! And the questions are good!! They reveal the cast members they haven't kissed, the flirtiest on set, Kevin's idea for a Glee reunion special, and share whether their thoughts on a Glee reboot have changed now that they've watched (almost) the whole series! Plus, so much more! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes scoops, be sure to follow on Instagram @an...
Jun 19, 2025•17 min
Going to the chapel! Or, in this case, a barn for a gleeful double wedding! Traditionally, you pop the champagne for a toast, but it was tequila behind the scenes! Jenna and Kevin have all the scoop on this star-studded episode, including Jenna’s tales from the bridal scene, getting tied up in knots watching Gloria Estefan in action, why Jennifer Coolidge told Kevin to sue FOX, and the scene where they were all losing it that took the cake! Plus, their thoughts on the double wedding storyline, w...
Jun 16, 2025•55 min
While "Glee" definitely had some pretty unhinged storylines, it was also a groundbreaking show that put LGBTQ+ stories front and center on prime-time TV! The actor at the center of the season six episode, "Transitioning," is back on the pod! Yes, Dot Marie Jones joins Jenna and Kevin to talk about her portrayal of Coach Beiste's transition to Sheldon. Dot reveals the many conflicted emotions she experienced when she received the script, fear of letting the trans community down, and the reaction ...
Jun 12, 2025•35 min
The end is near, and Glee is going out big! It’s Sheldon's debut and the return of Emma and Unique! Yes, Coach Beiste (Dot Marie Jones) makes his debut as ‘Sheldon’ and Jenna and Kevin have thoughts on how the writers handled the subject matter. Kevin remembers the powerful Alex Newell performance featuring a 200-member transgender choir and its effect on the crew. Plus, behind-the-scenes fun during Rachel’s basement party, and a hilarious Amber Riley story! For fun, exclusive content, and behin...
Jun 09, 2025•45 min
The biggest Gleek and NLT fan is on the Pod! Singer-songwriter Betty Who is bringing the heat this summer with her 'Out of the Darkness Tour,' but first, a pit stop with Jenna and Kevin to talk about her song "Somebody Loves You" being featured on Glee's sixth season! She shares how she found out her single was going to be used on the show, her obsession with NLT (Kevin's boy band), her big Broadway debut, and the biggest revelation ever!! She auditioned for Glee! Hear all about the 'Tina' inspi...
Jun 05, 2025•58 min
Wishing and hoping there were more than six episodes left, but we're at the halfway point of the sixth and final season of Glee! Jenna and Kevin are back with fascinating fun facts and stats about this episode, like it's the final tribute episode ever (Burt Bacharach) and the final 'Fondue for Two!' Plus, the rumor about this episode that leaves Jenna in shock, the return of Mercedes, the debut of Jennifer Coolidge and Ken Jeong as Brittany's parents, and what Kevin found terrifyingly disturbing...
Jun 02, 2025•45 min
Get ready for even more fascinating behind-the-scenes stories about the most unhinged Glee episodes from the man who was in the room where it happened! Glee co-creator and writer Ian Brennan joins Jenna and Kevin to talk about "The Hurt Locker" Parts One & Two, including how his friendship with Saw creator Leigh Whannell led to Jigsaw Sue, how he remembers everyone treating these episodes, and where his idea for Glee came from. Plus, he reveals how the show should have really ended! Will you...
May 29, 2025•43 min
If you thought Sue was unhinged in the last episode, you ain’t seen nothing yet! Jenna and Kevin are back and ready for the craziness of this episode, like Klaine stuck in an elevator thanks to Jigsaw Sue, the character they didn’t realize was back on the show, their thoughts on the performances and the scene Kevin says is one of his “favorite moments of Glee EVER!” No hints, but it’s a scene that still makes them laugh hysterically! Plus, Kevin talks about starring in the revival of Stephen Son...
May 26, 2025•45 min
Get ready for some fascinating behind-the-scenes stories about seasons five and six from the man who was in the room where it happened! Glee co-creator and writer Ian Brennan is dropping truth bombs on Jenna and Kevin! He gets honest about the hard pivot the show had to make after Cory Monteith passed away, the storylines he wishes they never did, the seasons that were the easiest and hardest to write, and why. Plus, he reveals his ranking of the seasons, which shocks Jenna and Kevin to their co...
May 22, 2025•37 min
Who knew a plastic fork could cause such a downward spiral! Sue Sylvester is gunning for Will Schuester in what fans consider one of the most unhinged Glee episodes ever! Jenna and Kevin weigh in on what they liked, what they found kinda creepy, what made them laugh, and Kevin’s theory on why the writers wrote this particular episode! Plus, their thoughts on Rachel and Sam, that Klaine shrine, and what guest star Harry Hamlin was like in person! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes ...
May 19, 2025•31 min
It’s time to catch up with another season six newbie - Spencer Porter! Yes, Marshall Williams is on the pod with stories from his time on Glee, including what it was like filming his very first scene opposite Jane Lynch, why he thinks the writers wrote a broken leg for him, and working with Chord Overstreet! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, be sure to follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod! See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information....
May 15, 2025•34 min
It’s an Alanis Morissette and Carole King mashup episode! Rachel and Kurt are not on the same page, Becky has a new boyfriend everyone is concerned about, and Brittana takes their relationship to the next level! Kevin and Jenna have a lot of thoughts, including being underwhelmed by one of the storylines, the scene that ticked off Kevin, and the scene that still has them laughing uncontrollably! Plus, the inside scoop on Santana’s brutal Kurt takedown, and Kevin's reflection on the show’s decisi...
May 12, 2025•48 min
Season six newbie, Billy Lewis Jr., spills all about his time playing the quirky 'Mason McCarthy' on Glee! Billy's got stories! Get ready to hear all about his 'surreal' screen test, why he was freaking out before his second audition, and how crew members would react to different Glee cast members! He also shares what it was like working with the OGs, the actor who was like a mother hen to the newbies, and why his story about 'Annabelle' has Kevin and Jenna laughing out loud! Plus, Billy has ano...
May 08, 2025•1 hr 3 min
The gang's all back together for McKinley High's Homecoming! Yes, it's a reunion with the original Glee Club members! Jenna and Kevin have loads of personal memories from shooting this special episode, including the mood on the set with everyone back, how Naya Rivera felt having to perform Ariana Grande's "Problem" (IYKYK), meeting the newbies, the actor that fell flat on his face during their "Take On Me" number and so much more! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips that you ...
May 05, 2025•45 min
His performances were divinely good in season six, and now 'Roderick Meeks' himself is gracing the pod with his presence! Glee alum Noah Guthrie is one of the first season six 'newbies' to appear on the pod with Jenna and Kevin! He reveals what joining the show in its sixth and final season was like, why he thought Ryan Murphy wasn't impressed with his audition, meeting all of the original cast members for the very first time, and what all the season six 'newbies' did after a long day of filming...
May 01, 2025•1 hr 1 min
It’s the beginning of the end ... the first episode of the sixth and final season of Glee! Jenna and Kevin unpack their feelings about returning to the halls of McKinley High, Rachel being back to square one, the flashbacks, and Blaine and Karofsky dating!! Plus, Kevin explains how one decision alerted them that the writing was on the wall for the show. For fun, exclusive content and behind-the-scenes clips, be sure to follow us on Instagram @ andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod! See omnystudio.com/l...
Apr 28, 2025•45 min
A Glee TikTok trend has inspired this very potentially controversial episode! Could Kevin and Jenna's friendship be put to the test? Maybe not, but they definitely do not see eye to eye as they pick the Glee songs they feel are better than the original and the performances that cause them "physical pain." Get ready to clutch your pearls at some of the bold statements made (Swifties don't @ us), and they address the elephant in the room ... IYKYK. Fans and friends also weigh in with their picks! ...
Apr 24, 2025•55 min
Podcast worlds collide when Recovering Gleek visits ATWYRM! Get ready for a gleeking fun time when Jenna and Kevin meet with fellow rewatch podcasters Lena and Ian. They share and compare their rankings of the seasons, favorite characters, and favorite songs! Some choices shock Jenna and Kevin, but nothing surprises them more than the original Tina jingle Lena and Ian play for them. Their reactions are priceless! For fun, exclusive content and behind-the-scenes clips, be sure to follow us on Ins...
Apr 21, 2025•1 hr
It's a Desperate Housewives and Glee mashup! Jenna and Kevin welcome their bestie actress Andrea Bowen to the pod! The best buds swap stories about their experiences growing up in front of the camera on hit shows, what Kevin learned from Andrea about interacting with fans, the time Andrea's brother was Jenna's first date (yes, we get all the deets), and you won't gleeking believe it! Andrea reveals she auditioned for Glee! She breaks down her experience, including the tune she sang! Plus, Andrea...
Apr 17, 2025•58 min
Pop culture guru, OG to the podcast game, and Glee superfan DJ Bob Runkel is bringing his unique brand of fun to the pod! As a wheelchair user with Cerebral Palsy, DJ Bob reflects on what it meant to him to see a main character like Artie on-screen and shares his thoughts on Kevin playing the role. Bob reveals the episode that inspired him to work hard in physical therapy so he could walk across the stage at his high school graduation, the fun story of crossing paths with Kevin during his NLT da...
Apr 14, 2025•1 hr 8 min
Get ready to sparkle with Glee when superfan Dylan Mulvaney stops by to spread joy and share some hilarious stories involving the show! The author and influencer admits what Glee meant to her growing up, going to the live tour in San Diego after suffering an unforgettable hair color mishap, singing and partying with Chris Colfer, and the reveal of all reveals ... the gleeking roles she auditioned for which send Jenna and Kevin into hysterics! Plus, Dylan details what's come true on her vision bo...
Apr 10, 2025•1 hr 5 min
Santana singing “Don’t Rain on My Parade, live dogs roaming the arena, and an actual wrecking ball?? Yes, it’s the dream tour setlist for season five! Andrew McGuire from Gleek of the Week Podcast joins Kevin and Jenna to workshop what might be the most “unhinged” tour yet! The trio shares a lot of laughs, some inspiring ideas that cause goosebumps, and differences of opinion on song choices. Will you agree with their choices, surprise appearances, and opening and closing numbers? Tune in to fin...
Apr 07, 2025•52 min
Sam Evans himself is back on the pod! Chord Overstreet joins Jenna and Kevin to share his memories of season five, including what it was like shooting in NY, reflecting on some of the riskier and crazier moments of the show, the actor he would channel when he needed to "go big," and what it took to stay in ab-solutely great shape for those shirtless scenes. Plus, he spills on the story behind his new single and the new music on the way, working with Ryan Murphy again on the medical drama "Dr. Od...
Apr 03, 2025•54 min
Season five has come and gone, and now it's time for final thoughts and fan votes! Yes, the votes are in, and Jenna and Kevin are shocked to discover which episode was ranked as the top episode by the fans. They share their theories, thoughts, and picks, including which songs hit the right notes, the pitch-perfect couples, and the episodes that struck the right chords! Will the fan votes align with the duo's picks? You'll have to tune in to find out! For fun clips and more inside scoop, don't fo...
Mar 31, 2025•34 min
What a gleeking treat! Inside stories from the folks who were in the room where it happened! Glee's set costumer, Jennifer Iizuka Palmer, and the show's sound production mixer, Phillip Palmer, join Jenna and Kevin to share hilarious behind-the-scenes stories from the set, including wardrobe malfunctions, mishaps, and mixups, the things the mic accidentally picked up in between takes and Kevin's apology for an "unprofessional" on-set prank! Plus, Phillip and Jenn's Glee love story has Jenna and K...
Mar 27, 2025•1 hr 7 min
We're here! It's the final episode of Season Five! It seems everyone is going in new directions ... Samcedes breaks up, Rachel is going to LA, and Brittany returns, but does this really feel like a finale episode? There is much to go over and dissect, like Mercedes' original song, Sam's model dreams, their interpretations of that final scene with Rachel, and, of course, the performances! There are so many fun ones, but Jenna kinda shocks Kevin when she reveals she was not a fan of one of their s...
Mar 24, 2025•50 min
This week's Gleek of the Week is all the way from New Zealand, and he came prepared! Jacob Kyon went from "annoying theater kid" to Glee stan to now being a vocal coach! He impresses Jenna and Kevin with his hot takes, his fave performances he uses to try to convert his friends to Gleeks, and he calls out the duo for a mistake they made in an earlier podcast episode regarding a tribute episode... For fun clips and more inside scoop, don't forget to follow us on Instagram @ andthatswhatyoureallym...
Mar 21, 2025•21 min
