Episode description
After Jesse regales Katie with his famous Boston Bit (tm) and Katie catches Jesse up on every single thing that has happened on Twitter since he left, the two discuss the case of DoNotPay and Joshua Browder. Are we on the brink of robot lawyers effortlessly guiding underprivileged clients through difficult legal proceedings? Or is, like, literally none of that going to happen?
Show notes/Links
Anti-Italian hate crime
https://www.washingtonpost.com/food/2023/03/23/tiktok-pasta-blender-reaction/
Beware The Hard R:
“Chatbot lawyer overturns 160,000 parking tickets in London and New York”
Browder <3 Buffett
Above The Law on the then-new version of DoNotPay
The legal actions offered on DoNotPay cover an impressive range. One feature allows users to file a claim in any small claims court in the country, including all 3,000 counties in the 50 states. Perhaps even more significant in the current political climate, DoNotPay includes a service that claims to help users obtain green cards and visas, eliminating the usual service fees. Other service offerings include searching for hidden class action settlements you’re owed, fighting credit card and overdraft fees, suing tech companies for data breaches, and collecting money from hotel and airline bookings through price protection guarantees. And, of course, you can still fight parking tickets, which is how DoNotPay got its start in the first place.
The Verge in 2022
https://www.theverge.com/2022/12/13/23505873/donotpay-negotiate-bills-ai-chatbot
DoNotPay, the company that bills itself as “the world’s first robot lawyer,” is launching a new AI-powered chatbot that can help you negotiate bills and cancel subscriptions without having to deal with customer service. In a demo of the tool posted by DoNotPay CEO Joshua Browder, the chatbot manages to get a discount on a Comcast internet bill through Xfinity’s live chat. Once it connects with a customer service representative, the bot asks for a better rate using account details provided by the customer. The chatbot cites problems with Xfinity’s services and threatens to take legal action, to which the representative responds by offering to take $10 off the customer’s monthly internet bill.
HISTORY COMING Y’ALL
Techdirt weighs in
HMMM
People also point out a rather straightforward obstacle to Browder’s plan now memorialized in one of those helpful boxes
GO BIG OR GO HOME
Kathryn Tewson
https://twitter.com/KathrynTewson
Deleted tweet
More on deleted tweets
In one tweet, Browder apparently said that his team had issued a subpoena written by the AI to get the officer involved to appear in court
Not strictly against the rules
Not “outright illegal”
The website no work
“Hey - thank you for signing up for donotpay. We have good intentions and are happy to respond to your feedback.” [REBLOCKS]
“Good morning! Bad news”
incredibly exciting announcements
HMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM
NPR covers the aborted robot lawyer attempt
Actual legal experts
https://blog.simplejustice.us/2023/01/22/a-i-for-the-defense/
It gets worse
Very literal phrasing
STOP! STOP! HE’S ALREADY DEAD
Might as well look into earlier claims too
The Guardian’s source for this claim is… a Medium post from Browder himself.
TechDirt notes that they’d been suspicious of those same claims way back in 2017, but decided not to run the story
https://www.techdirt.com/2023/02/07/heres-the-article-we-didnt-run-back-in-2017-about-donotpay/
So recently Browder went on the LawNext podcast and it didn’t go well — he calls the controversy “A Bit Of A Nothingburger”
Tewson actually went on the very next episode
Ruh roh
https://www.courthousenews.com/robot-lawyers-not-yet-lawsuit-says/
All’s well that ends well?
Dead cougar or whatever
Image: “robot lawyer in court” via DALL-E 2
This is a public episode. If you’d like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.blockedandreported.org/subscribe