Episode 306: This week, we discuss the shooting death of American Mark Harshbarger during a 2006 hunting trip to Newfoundland. The Meshoppen, Pennsylvania, man was shot by his wife, Mary Beth Harshbarger, who claims she thought he was a black bear. In 2010, Harshbarger was extradited to Newfoundland, where she stood trial for criminal negligence causing death. The prosecution cited insurance money as Mary Beth’s motive for the killing. After two weeks of hearings in September, the presiding judge found her not guilty.
The shooting death of Mark Harshbarger has been a source of controversy since it occurred. Some people believe that Mary Beth Harshbarger was guilty of first-degree murder, while others believe that she was justified in shooting her husband because she thought he was a bear.
It is important to remember that this topic is very sensitive for many people. The family and friends of Mark Harshbarger are still grieving his death, and Mary Beth Harshbarger has gone through a great deal. Mark’s children have lost their father. We aim to be respectful of all parties involved when discussing this case.
Sources:
Hunting | The Canadian Encyclopedia
Fur Trade in Canada | The Canadian Encyclopedia
Town of Buchans Newfoundland & Labrador
Guide describes fatal shot in U.S. hunter's trial | CBC News
Official Newfoundland Hunter Safety Course | HunterCourse.com
Inside The Harshbarger Family Case | CBC — True Crime Canada
Public Advisory: 2023-24 Hunting and Trapping Guide Available Online - News Releases
Regulation Summaries - 2022-23 Hunting and Trapping Guide
Mark Harshbarger (1963-2006) | Find-a-Grave
2010 NLTD 152 (CanLII) | R. v. Harshbarger | CanLII
Another Fine Day Afield | Outdoor Canada
Extradition looms for hunter who shot husband | Outdoor Canada
Harshbarger's father speaks out about widow's upcoming shooting trial - News - The Times-Tribune
Judge throws out PFA order that had been lodged against Mary Beth Harshbarger - News - Daily Review
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
The Tragic Death of Mark Harshbarger | Dark Poutine - True Crime and Dark History podcast - Listen or read transcript on Metacast
