Overkillers with Brooke Makenna

Brooke Makenna

We’re OVER the killers on this true crime podcast. In fact, we’re focused on victims and survivors over killers. Brooke Makenna YouTube Instagram

Last refreshed: March 14th, 2026 at 11:29 AM ⓘ

Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.

Follow on

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

RSS

Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app

Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

Missing Mom FOUND ALIVE After 24 Years ARRESTED

Back in 2001, Michelle Hundley Smith was a 38 year old married mother of 3 living in Eden, NC. She had a 19 year old daughter, a 14 year old daughter and a 7 year old son. ON December 9th 2001, she left her home to go Christmas shopping for the kids. She was allegedly headed to a nearby Wal-Mart. She left around 8:30pm and headed to the shopping area in Martinsville, VA which was about 17 miles away from the home. She took her green 1995 Pontiac TransSport Van and went alone. She never made it h...

Mar 08, 2026•33 min

Kidnapped Child Found Alive After 19 YEARS & 9 Children

Rula patients typically pay $15 per session when using insurance. Connect with quality therapists and mental health experts who specialize in you at https://www.rula.com/makenna #rulapod When a woman walked into the American Consulate in Mexico with 8 children in tow, no one had any idea they were looking at a woman who had been kidnapped 19 years prior. This woman was not even yet a pre-teen when she vanished from the states, now she begged for help to return and escape her captor. Back in 1997...

Mar 01, 2026•36 min•Season 1Ep. 9

3 Teens Murdered, 14 Year Old Killer Vanished, Should His DAD Pay the Price?

On December 26th 2021 police were called to a Texaco gas station in Garland Texas. Garland PD arrived at 730 W Walnut St that evening to find 4 victims. They all appeared to be teenagers. CCTV footage of the incident was located in the gas station. The victims deceased inside were found to be 14 year old Xavier Gonzales, 6 year old Ivan Noyola and 17 year old Rafael Garcia. Now, upon full examination of the CCTV footage, Detective Lucas Shupe, the lead on the case would explain that when the whi...

Feb 24, 2026•41 min

Online “Cult” Leader Linked to 6 Disappearances & Murders Still Posting From PRISON?

Back in 2023, 6 people were renting a home together in Berkeley, MO. This was nearby St.Louis and the international airport. 29 year old Naaman Williams, 23 year old Mikayla Thompson, 26 year old mother Gerielle German and her 3-year-old son Ashton Mitchell as well as 25 year old mother Ma’Kayla Wickerson and her 3-year daughter Malaiyah. A mother of one of the victims pointed detectives in the direction of an online group, often referred to as a tiktok and YouTube cult. This was led by a man wi...

Feb 15, 2026•44 min

Murdered Father, Missing Preteen Sons - Framed OR Killer Kids?

This is a deep dive into the massive compilation of information regarding a murder discovered within a house fire and teenage sons gone missing. Two separate trials, 3 suspects but outcomes you would never expect. Present in this case is manipulation, false statements, sick behavior, past trauma, past convictions and many different versions of the same story. The murder of Terry King and the conviction of his preteen sons Derek King and Alex King. Back on November 26th 2001 in Cantonment, Florid...

Feb 08, 2026•1 hr 4 min

House Party Horror: Found in Attic, 2nd Suspicious Death, NO Arrests

Back in 2021, Derontae Martin was a 19 year old living in Madison County, MO. On the evening of Saturday April 24th 2021, he had gone to a birthday party at a rural home belonging to James "Jimmy" Wade. Jimmy pointed the officer to the stairs and they went to the second floor. As they entered the bedroom, Jimmy pointed to a door that led to an unfinished area. He had to step on the rafters for footing because there was no floor. Then the deputy saw the body of a Black male between the rafters. H...

Feb 01, 2026•57 min

MISSING TEEN HELD 25 YEARS IN “PRISON CELL ROOM” FOUND ALIVE

On March 15th 2021, a call for help escaped a prison-like room created to hold the victim inside for the last two decades. A man then called the police stating that he was concerned for the welfare of an individual and gave the address. This was a home in Twekesbury, Gloucestershire, England. Police responded to the call that evening and inside the residence, found a frightened and gaunt victim who smelled strongly of body odor. They would learn that a 40 year old woman had been held captive her...

Jan 29, 2026•34 min•Season 1Ep. 4

TEEN SURVIVORS OF FAMILY ANNIHILATORS

Are family murders on the rise? What is causing this? In this episode, we're discussing two eerily similar survivor stories. On December 17th 2024, in West Valley City, Utah 5 bodies were found shot inside of a home. A mother, father and 3 children were deceased but the eldest son, Sha Reh, was breathing. He would survive, blinded by the murder-suicide committed by his own father. Then on December 22nd 2025, another teen would be shot in the face by her family and survive. This time she would na...

Jan 25, 2026•37 min

The Body In the Tank: Fugitive Detective, Missing Witnesses, What REALLY Happened to Dee Warner?

What REALLY Happened to Dee Warner? On April 25th 2021 Dee Ann Warner was believed to go missing. Her daughter Rikkell would state that during her last conversation with her mother the night prior, Dee had declared that she was leaving Dale, for good. Now, Rikkell made sure to add that it was common for Dee to leave Dale only for a couple of days to cool down after a fight. However, she never stopped speaking to her children and she always took her little sister Angelica. She never went no conta...

Jan 19, 2026•40 min•Season 1Ep. 2

“Troubled” Classmate Killed 2 High School Girls Then Went Live on YouTube

Maria Niotis and Isabella Salas were high school best friends before they were mowed down while riding an e-bike on September 29th 2025. The hit and run ended in the death of both teens but was determined to not be accidental. New Jersey 17 year old Vincent Battiloro was charged with murder and his livestreams were uncovered from a day after the murder. We're focused on victims OVER killers here in this true crime community. Join and become a genuine gem :) xoxo Brooke Makenna Sign up for the Ge...

Jan 13, 2026•45 min•Season 1Ep. 1

Hosted on Megaphone by Spotify

For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android