Hello, add lots listeners. I'm Stephen Carroll, the host of Bloomberg's Here's Why podcast, where we break down a key story in the news. We borrow Joe for our latest episode, so we thought we'd share it with you. If you like what you hear, you could subscribe to Here's Why wherever you usually get your podcasts. Enjoy Bloomberg Audio Studios, podcasts, radio news. I haven't seen yet a sense of Okay, where's my safe haven? Where do I go and park myself?
The US is benefiting right now from kind of the safe haven trade at the moment. If you can find me a safe haven in this market, I'd be the first one to sign up for that. We do see some of the safe havens seems doesn't perform as good as we expect it. For example, go and silver, Japanese here and the bones. In times of trouble, investors often look for safer ground. During previous crises, that's meant to rush into assets like US treasuries, the dollar, the Swiss
franc or gold. But the turmoil caused by President Trump's trade taras last year the traditional safe haven trades as investor has turned away from US assets and the latest conflict in the Middle East has seen another shift. Here's why the Iran war is prompting a safe haven rethink. Joe Eisenthal House to Bloomberg's Odd Lots podcast joins us now for more. Joe, great to talk to you. Can you help us understand first of all the background here?
What makes a good safe haven asset? Why are treasuries or the Swiss frank or gold considered a place to shelter from market turmoil.
The thing that investors are always looking for is some sort of asset that is not strictly correlated to growth or to risk asset. So what is a risk asset or risk asset is an asset that goes up when things are going well. So stock market classic risk asset. You're feeling optimistic, you think the world is going to be good all things equal, you want to buy more stocks,
gas st is. Then you have other assets that are characterized as safe havens, and so there's something about their properties in which you expect to be paid back, you expect to hold their value even if things aren't going great. So gold obviously a classic one. People have been using it for money for thousands of years and so by and large you expect them. It'll still have monetary possibilities in a thousand years. The performance of gold is not
contingent on things going particularly well in the economy. Treasuries are another example. The US is you know, maybe it's changed a little bit, but by a large stable and the coupon payments are simply contingent on legally required payments from the US government, and so again those payments will happen regardless of whether the economy is strong or bad or whatever it is. So that has safe haven properties
all around the world. Generally speaking, the US has had very little inflation over the years, certainly relative to many countries, and so therefore the dollar holds its value relatively well. It's accepted almost everywhere, and so it is safe haven property. So basically, what people gravitate to in times of stress, and it's a little different are assets that are not correlated to the business cycle, that can perform and hold their value even if things aren't going well.
So what was different than during the tariff turmoil of last year because some of these traditional safe havens seemed a bit less attractive.
Yeah, So I think the way to think about it is that you know, safe havenness is something that kicks in at specific times. And so let's go back to the tariffs. Did it create a true crisis? Crisis is in like a run on the banks, et cetera. No, not really. There was a lot of anxiety and so forth. But the net effect of tariffs where for many people around the world, the US looked like a less attractive
place to invest. It would be more costly to do business here, and so forth, and so well, in this environment you saw the dollar weakening.
Right.
This really did not have much to do with its safe haven properties per se. It was just the dollar being another currency, and investors around the world look and say, okay, this is not great for economic management. I don't really want to put more assets on the ground in the US because importing goods in the factories and so for it'll be more expensive, and so then they sell dollars. Now you fast forward to the war in Iran, and this is very different. The dimensions of the currency are
not about broader conditions. This is there is a war going on. We do not know how long this war is going to go on. War spiral out of control, even if they're meant to be contained. This is a historical fact. In that environment, people are not thinking about is the US a good place to invest right now? They're thinking, I am scared. I want to have my money and something that is likely to roughly retain its value for a year and now five years from now,
et cetera. And by that measure, the dollar is a relatively attractive option. So at times, these what we call save haven assets performed differently. In twenty twenty five, the dollar performed like an investment asset. Oh, I don't really want to hold it so much, because the US is a less attractive environment. Today the dollar looks good. It's a safe haven asset, not because the US is a great place to invest per se, but because those properties, those safe haven properties have kicked in.
So how does that work then in this moment for treasuries.
Yeah, another great question. What makes treasuries a safe haven? Obviously, it's the fact that the US is very credit worthy, that the US borrows in its own currency, so therefore there is no prospect of the treasury like running out of money. It can always print it and so forth. And so what gives treasuries a safe haven property is the fact that that payment is guaranteed by the US government. Now,
another factor in the pricing of treasuries is inflation. And so if you have, like I say, you know treasury that it pays a four percent coupon, you get a four percent yield every year. But inflation, let's say it goes to six percent, that is a money losing investment, right, The real value of that treasury, that coupon payment is not keeping up with inflation, so you don't on to hold it. With the war, people are worried about inflation.
I mean, obviously we've seen oil prices spike. Wars are costly just from a sort of budgetary standpoint, They require more fiscal expenditure, They put strains on resources of all sorts. We may have to massively ramp up missile production, that puts strains on the real economy. All of these things taken to be per se inflationary. So then you look and you're like, if you're an investor, someone's selling you a treasury, You're thinking, you know what, I want to
hire yield to compensate for this inflation. So it's the type of thing once again where the same ass but in a different environment. The safe haven properties aren't kicking in for that moment. Now, I do think it's worth noting that, like you can watch, say like the VIX for example, a measure of financial conditions and sort of a pure measure of how anxious people are feeling. If you get a major VIX spike, there is a good chance that people will buy treasuries. And so what I'm
saying is I mentioned all the concerns with treasuries. However, maybe that's a price people are willing to pay just for that security, and so there's a push pull here. I like the fact that the payment is guaranteed. I don't like the fact that the payment is going to keep up with inflation. If things are really breaking down, you might say, you know what, I'm willing to take
a price loss. I'm willing to accept a coupon payment that is less than inflation because the fact that I get paid anything at all, and the fact that I will get my principle back at the end of the term, whether it's a ten year treasury, is worth so much to me in this period of extreme anxiety that I will use a treasury as a safe haven, even if it's a money losing investment. An analogy that I like to make is a safe deposit box. You pay the bank for the right to hold something in a safe
deposit box. De facto, that means that a safe deposit box has a negative yield, and yet it is often part of someone's safe haven portfolio. I'm going to put my values balls in there, despite the fact that it costs me a little bit of money every year, because the fact that I will be able to take them out one day is worth quite a bit of peace of mind.
Can you then explain to us what happened with gold, because if we look at a gold chart for the past few years, and we've talked about at length, you know number go up to absolutely quote our hike sekbox and it's book of our crypto. But this time around, we haven't seen the same rally in gold during the Iran war.
Why so, first of all, as you said, gold has rallied a lot over the last several years, and it's rally during a period of I would say, sustained high inflation. The rate of inflation has come down, but inflation all around the world is still fairly high. People are worried
about the you know, paper currencies holding their valume. It's gone up during a period of geopolitical attention, obviously multiple wars around the world since twenty twenty two, and so once again, you know, there's this anxiety about like sovereignty and some pretty fundamental questions, and so this is the type of environment in which people want to reach for an asset that once again, it transcends time, it transcends space,
it transcends nation states, and so forth. It's a form of money that's kind of understood everywhere in the world and throughout history. So the last several years have been a really good environment for people wanting to have some
allocations that people want to hold a dollar alternative. If you think back to twenty twenty two, Russia got sanctioned and lost access to a lot of the dollars that it had, and I think people around the world world, we're looking at that and you're like, you know what, maybe I want to hold fewer dollars because this could happen to me too one day, and so I want to hold gold in a vault. Now we get the war and gold hasn't done as well. I think there's
probably a couple of factors you know. Something that happens in an extreme spike, and this is a little bit counterintuitive, is when you have real fear, dollars suddenly become more interesting to you because you start thinking, I have a rent bill to pay, I have a Bloomberg bill to pay, I have to pay for my terminal, I have to pay for the lights, I have to like pay for everything. You want to just survive to the next month, and the way you survive to the next month is making
sure that your bills are paid. Can't pay your bills in gold, and so you think to yourself, Okay, there's big liquidations happening. I do want to hold gold long term, but in the short term I need to come up with some dollars. And so gold, having done extremely well over the last few years, it may be something that you sell in this environment. There's another drawback to gold, which is that it's costly to move right having it's heavy on like say bitcoin, or on like say the dollar,
you can't just withdraw it anywhere in the world. If you have your gold in a vault in Switzerland and you move to Singapore, that gold is not available to you at a moment's notice. And so you have to think about how are you going to get it there? Or if things really go bad, how do you get your gold out of that vault. These are questions that
gold investors actually have to think about sometimes. And I do wonder, given the closure of the strait of hor Moves and give it the fact that we don't know how wide the war is going to spend, maybe there is a little bit of cost to holding something in which the ability to physically move it to where you
are is part of its appeal. And so perhaps at the margins this is a negative factor in gold, which is here is a type of money that has to be physically moved at a time when physical movement is under stress.
Joe, fascinating stuff. Thanks so much for joining us, Joe Wisenthal Houst of Bloomberg's Odd Lots podcast. For more explanations like this from our team of three thousand journalists and analysts around the world, go to bloomberg dot com slash Explainers. I'm Stephen Carol. This is Here's why. I'll be back next week with more. Thanks for listening.