Jessie Pray and Andie Cassette team up each week to tell stories of love and relationships gone fatally wrong. This show is all about seemingly normal people driven to terrible madness by passion and rage. Hang out with your new best friends each week to discover how someone can go from sweet to murderous in the blink of an eye, and to hear all the ways murder can give love a real bad name.
Last refreshed: ⓘ
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more
When a recent parolee driven insane by jealousy brutally murders four innocent people in 2010, the authorities dig into his past to discover that the quadruple murder wasn't his first homicide. Tune in this week to learn why you should never hurt opossums, why some people have terrible taste in prison penpals, and why sometimes, even the most heroic efforts of a kindly neighbor aren't enough to stop the madness of murderers. Key Players: Michael Eric Ballard, Denise Mehri, Dennis Marsh, Alvin Ma...
When a body is found slain in church, suspicion immediately turns to the debonair and charismatic pastor. The truth of the story leads detectives down a path of jealousy, hoarding and even more unsolved cases. Tune in to learn why you should never keep your dead pets in the freezer, why wigs that look just like your regular hair are surprisingly convenient, and why envy is truly the deadliest sin. Key Players: Mary Jane Fonder, Rhonda Smith, Gregory Shreaves Find LOVE MURDER online: Website: lov...
A devastating discovery in Nebraska on Christmas Eve 1985 leads investigators on a diabolical odyssey laden with bodies, booze, drugs, sex and murder, as well as the most unexpected perpetrator imaginable. Welcome to the Amish Serial Killer, or for fans of Love Murder Episode 15, Amish Murder 2: Non-Electric Buggy-Loo. One of the most wild and twisting cases we've ever covered. Key Players: Eli Stutzman, Glen Pritchett, David Tyler, Dennis Slaeter, Danny Stutzman Find LOVE MURDER online: Website...
When a young couple is brutally murdered in their home, the mother still clutching their baby boy, the authorities eventually uncover a tangled web of Facebook feuding and one killer catfish as the culprit. Tune in this week to learn why the internet can be deadly and you should never buy the story that the CIA is emailing you to make fun of your neighbors. Key Players: Janelle Potter, Marvin "Buddy" Potter, Barbara Potter, Billie-Jean Hayworth, Billy Payne Find LOVE MURDER online: Website: love...
When an upstanding police sergeant's much younger fourth wife disappears under mysterious circumstances, new light is shed on his third wife's so-called accidental death. Dirty cop or just bad luck in the wife department? Tune in this week to find out! Key Players: Drew Peterson, Stacy Peterson, Kathleen Savio Find LOVE MURDER online: Website: lovemurder.love Instagram: @lovemurderpod Twitter: @lovemurderpod Facebook: LoveMrdrPod Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices Lea...
When a turn of the century supermodel becomes the favored companion to the rich and famous her life becomes front page fodder rife with scandal, rape, powerful men, murder, the trial of the century and even an escape from a mental asylum. Tune in this week to meet the world’s first and worst Kris Jenner, experience lifestyles of ye olde rich and famous and hold your horses for a surprising twist at the very last minute! Key Players: Evelyn Nesbit, Harry Thaw, Stanford White NOTE: If you would li...
A truly gory super grisly Valentines Day treat. Today we cover Katherine Knight, the world’s craziest ex girlfriend and cannibal killer. Join us this week to hear about why you may not want to mess with a woman whose first love is her knives, what root vegetables complement a literal rump roast and why carnations are always a poor choice. Find LOVE MURDER online: Website: lovemurder.love Instagram: @lovemurderpod Twitter: @lovemurderpod Facebook: LoveMrdrPod Learn more about your ad choices. Vis...
A jilted lover's rage ignites a fiery inferno that results in the most deadly arson in United States history. This is the devastating story of a love gone wrong that claimed the lives of 87 innocent people, some barely in their teens, celebrating Punta Carnivale in a Bronx Social Club in 1990. Find LOVE MURDER online: Website: lovemurder.love Instagram: @lovemurderpod Twitter: @lovemurderpod Facebook: LoveMrdrPod Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices Learn more about you...
A good looking, fun loving, hard-living mother of six is accused of murdering not one, but two husbands and attempting to murder a couple more for good measure. Was she a cold-blooded, money hungry black widow? Or an abused woman responding to a lifetime of trauma? Find out today as we explore the infamous Texas black widow, Betty Lou Beets! Find LOVE MURDER online: Website: lovemurder.love Instagram: @lovemurderpod Twitter: @lovemurderpod Facebook: LoveMrdrPod Learn more about your ad choices. ...
A torrid affair leads to massive family drama that leaves one man brutally beaten & murdered. When the police dig into the messy clan responsible, eight people are sent to prison for their participation in the deadly deed. Tune in discover why dating your kid’s ex is NEVER a good idea Key Players: Bryan Carson, Ryan Carson, Teresa Carson, Nicole Walker Find LOVE MURDER online: Website: lovemurder.love Instagram: @lovemurderpod Twitter: @lovemurderpod Facebook: LoveMrdrPod Learn more about yo...
A bizarre and bewildering missing persons case leads a Michigan police chief down a twisty road of sex, jealousy, potential cannibalism, two murdered men in different states and perhaps many more to still be discovered. Tune in this week to hear the world’s worst novel outline, discover a beautiful romance inside of a devastating case and find out when is the right time to just say “no” to the neighbors’ cooking. Key Players: Erin Corwin, Jon Corwin, Christopher Lee Find LOVE MURDER online: Webs...
When a pregnant nineteen year old Marine’s wife disappears in Joshua Tree in the Mojave Desert suspicion falls on her young husband. As authorities dig deeper they uncover a devastating double life that tragically led to the innocent young woman’s death. Tune in to uncover the mystery of the marine’s wife murder, be awed by the amazing search efforts of law enforcement & volunteer cavers and learn why owning a potato gun in California might be a bad idea. NOTE: If you would like to support S...
After a man's new girlfriend mysteriously disappears, he and his ex become the targets of intense stalking, vandalism, and death threats, seemingly from the vanished woman. This true crime story unravels a bizarre web of online harassment, attempted murder, and arson, culminating in a shocking discovery and the unmasking of the true perpetrator through groundbreaking digital forensics. It's a cautionary tale about trusting your gut and the dangers of online obsession.
Over the Christmas Holiday in 1987 Ronald Gene Simmons went on a deadly murder spree, killing 16 people and injuring 4 others. Fourteen of those people were his own loved ones who had gathered for Christmas to celebrate together, including the daughter he had impregnated. Merry bloody Christmas, lovers! Key Players: Ronald Gene Simmons Find LOVE MURDER online: Website: lovemurder.love Instagram: @lovemurderpod Twitter: @lovemurderpod Facebook: LoveMrdrPod Learn more about your ad choices. Visit ...
Welcome to Part 2 of Love Murder's Hellmark Holiday Special - a two-part bonus series featuring some of the wildest Christmas crimes and murders. In this edition, Andie & Jessie tell the story of: The most famous Santa Claus bank robbery in Texas history A Los Angeles Christmas murder house remains vacant to this day A man on bath salts was found decorating his neighbor's house Find LOVE MURDER online: Website: lovemurder.love Instagram: @lovemurderpod Twitter: @lovemurderpod Facebook: LoveM...
Diabolical Nannie Doss killed up to 12 men, women & children over a 30 year period and hid in plain sight while literally getting away with murder- until one wily doctor caught on to her evil ways. Join us this week to be turned off stewed sweet prunes forever and discover why you shouldn’t cheat on your wife- especially if she’s a serial killer. Key Players: Nannie Doss Find LOVE MURDER online: Website: lovemurder.love Instagram: @lovemurderpod Twitter: @lovemurderpod Facebook: LoveMrdrPod ...
Welcome to Love Murder's Hellmark Holiday Special - a two-part bonus series featuring some of the wildest Christmas crimes and murders. In part 1, Andie & Jessie tell the story of: Santa Burgler gets stuck in the chimney A poor slain woman hidden under the Christmas presents Man attacked with ceramic squirrel for failing to bring home beer on Christmas Find LOVE MURDER online: Website: lovemurder.love Instagram: @lovemurderpod Twitter: @lovemurderpod Facebook: LoveMrdrPod Learn more about yo...
When a pillar of the community and loving mother is murdered and found in the backseat of her luxury SUV, suspicion eventually falls on her upstanding Rotary Club president husband. When the investigators look closer, they reveal an obsession with BDSM, secret sex slaves, financial disaster and more bizarre sex details than you ever wanted to know about (seriously). Tune in to our first ever Hometown Deep Dive to hear Jessie & Andie give mashed potatoes a bad name and learn what special gift...
A horrifying and brutal murder takes place in Jack the Ripper’s backyard a year after his reign of terror. Has the Ripper returned or is the grisly double murder the result of garden variety obsessive love & indecent lust? Join us this week to learn about the Hampstead Murderess, Mary Eleanor Pearcey, who slayed her lover’s wife and wee child and paid the ultimate price for her dark deed. Key Players: Mary Eleanor Pearcey, Phoebe Hogg, Tiggie Hogg, Frank Hogg Find LOVE MURDER online: Website...
Faced with mounting financial hardship, John List takes the cowardly way out and massacres his entire family in 1971. He remains on the run for 18 years, building a double life and ensnaring another woman with his false identity. It would take a determined cold case detective, a nosy neighbor and a hit television series to finally bring him to justice. Tune in to find out some super exciting news about Andie & Jessie and also how the FBI used Preparation H to attempt to catch a mass murderer...
A Thanksgiving-themed Love Murder Quickie counting down four heinous Thanksgiving Murders: 4. The Bludgeoning 3. Chores Turn Murderous 2. A Deadly Drive in Reno 1. Pumpkin Pie Before Murder (Oh My!) Find LOVE MURDER online: Website: lovemurder.love Instagram: @lovemurderpod Twitter: @lovemurderpod Facebook: LoveMrdrPod Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and C...
When an industrious, beloved family man is killed in cold blood, suspicion turns to his lovely wife and her secrets are revealed - both theirs and hers alone. The wild investigation would uncover an unconventional sex life, a passionate affair that the two adulterating cheaters believed was “ordained by God”, a nefarious death plot, and even (gasp!) the poisoning of a pet pooch. Key Players: Robert Limon, Sabrina Limon, Jonathan Hearn Find LOVE MURDER online: Website: lovemurder.love Instagram: ...
An unlikely tipster blows the whistle on a couple of good ol’ down home serial killing septuagenarians. These farmers have more than next year’s crop buried in their fields! Tune in to find out why the worst evidence is a murder quilt and for a reminder that the traditional present for a 50th wedding anniversary is gold, not steel handcuffs (or even worse, dead bodies). Key Players: Faye Copeland, Raye Copeland Find LOVE MURDER online: Website: lovemurder.love Instagram: @lovemurderpod Twitter: ...
When a beloved middle aged mother is gunned down leaving choir practice in a church parking lot the investigation reveals a diabolical web of deceit, political corruption, illicit affairs and deadly secrets. Tune in to discover the seedy second meaning of “starburst”, how to wile your way into some sneaky DNA and how to catch a cheating spouse in the 90’s (if you’re a cop). Key Players: Susan Fassett, Fred Andros, Dawn Silvernail Find LOVE MURDER online: Website: lovemurder.love Instagram: @love...
Creepy “Count” von Cosel became obsessed with a beautiful, young tuberculosis patient named Elena Milagro Hoyos. When she passed, he decided their love affair was far from over. This is a story of enduring obsession and affection, grave-robbing, bizarre scientific experiments and, yes, necrophilia. Get ready to get creeped out for this super spooky, extremely morbid and ghoulishly undead love story. Key Players: Count Carl Tanzler von Cosel, Elena Milagro Hoyos, Corpse Bride Find LOVE MURDER onl...
Cucktoberfest is a series of October bonus episodes about the cheated-upon getting revenge on the cheaters. In this fourth and final episode, Andie and Jessie tell the story of: 1) When a husband is found naked cheating with his wife's twin sister, the wife drives away leaving the lewd couple exposed in a parking lot in broad daylight. Read more. 2) A husband turned insane with jealousy kills his wife's lover then makes her behead the corpse to try to avoid getting caught. Spoiler alert: it didn...
Leonarda Cianciulli was born a product of rape and cursed by her own mother. After various dark prophecies told by Romani fortune tellers seemed to be coming true, Leonarda would go to any lengths to protect those she loved- even serial murder and human sacrifice. Tune in to hear the spookiest, creepiest, most otherworldly tale ever told on Love Murder and get regaled with Jessie’s near-death experience: attempted murder by swine. Key Players: Leonarda Cianciulli Find LOVE MURDER online: Website...
Cucktoberfest is a series of October bonus episodes about the cheated-upon getting revenge on the cheaters. In this third episode, Andie and Jessie tell the story of: 1) An orthodontist who gets run over mercilessly by his spurned wife. Read more 2) A multi-time philanderer whose many mistresses get revenge in the stickiest way possible. Read more . Find LOVE MURDER online: Website: lovemurder.love Instagram: @lovemurderpod Twitter: @lovemurderpod Facebook: LoveMrdrPod Learn more about your ad c...
When a multimillionaire is shot by his trophy wife's lesbian lover, it reveals a wild web of deception. Tune in to hear how not to make friends and influence people, learn a surprising meaning for the acronym BMW & why insurance fraud will always get ya in the end. Key Players: Celeste Beard, Steven Beard, Tracey Tarlton Find LOVE MURDER online: Website: lovemurder.love Instagram: @lovemurderpod Twitter: @lovemurderpod Facebook: LoveMrdrPod Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.f...
Cucktoberfest is a series of October bonus episodes about the cheated-upon getting revenge on the cheaters. In this second episode, Andie and Jessie tell the story of: 1) A woman who gleefully gets revenge through a series of pranks with her (now ex) boyfriends things. It begs the question: are only men allowed to get revenge? Read more 2) A skydiving club love triangle ends in a parachute murder, brutally caught on tape via GoPro. Read more Key Players: Els Van Doren, Marcel "Mars" Somers, Els ...
