Ecommerce Playbook: Numbers, Struggles & Growth - podcast cover

Ecommerce Playbook: Numbers, Struggles & Growth

Common Thread Collectivewww.commonthreadco.com
2020 transformed the world of ecommerce forever. For the modern DTC brand, the rewards have never been greater. But the waters have also never been choppier, and the way forward has never been more uncertain. So how do you navigate this dangerous new reality? No matter how you do it, you’d better not do it alone. That’s where the Ecommerce Playbook Podcast comes in — join Common Thread Collective’s Taylor Holiday & Richard Gaffin as they bring you guiding insights from across CTC’s portfolio of growing DTC businesses. Whether you need a clear view on the macro issues affecting the world of ecommerce, or want to reorient your business around groundbreaking new big-picture strategies, Taylor & Richard are here to help answer the tough questions about what it takes to scale — and sustain — an ecommerce business.
Last refreshed:
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

The Secret That Prepares Accelerator Brands for 8-Figure Success

As brands approach the $1M–$10M revenue range, they often find themselves stuck—still hustling, but with slower growth and rising costs. That’s where CTC’s Global Accelerator comes in. In this episode, Richard Gaffin is joined by Joy Sharma and Jan Almuni to share the blueprint for how seven-figure brands break through to eight.They reveal the step-by-step playbook used across dozens of brands in the Accelerator program—and why the secret to scaling isn’t one big move, but the right next move at...

Aug 07, 202548 min

Last Week’s Podcast Crushed on X—Here’s Why It Did

In this episode of the E-Commerce Playbook Podcast, Taylor Holiday and Richard Gaffin unpack the surprising success of last week’s episode—and explore what it reveals about content that actually resonates.What about the convo with Taylor and Andrew led to such a positive response?Turns out, the answer has less to do with tactics—and everything to do with time, unique perspective, and story.If you’re trying to build content that lasts (not just goes viral), this one’s for you. Ready to solve your...

Aug 05, 202534 min

We Ran Incrementality Tests... Meta’s Tool Didn’t Win

After months of speculation, testing, and internal debate, CTC put Meta’s new Incremental Attribution Tool to the test—three times. In this episode, Richard Gaffin sits down with VP of Paid Media Tony Chopp to break down what really happened across those tests, including a final geo holdout study using actual Shopify revenue. The result? You’ll learn: - What CTC’s 3 incrementality tests revealed about Meta’s new attribution tool - Why Meta’s results may be overstating impact—especially on new cu...

Jul 31, 202520 min

Lessons from 11 Years of Building an Agency — and What Happened After

In this episode of The Random Show, Taylor Holiday and Andrew Faris sit down for a moment of focus—because something big just happened.Common Thread Collective has a new growth partner. Taylor breaks down what the deal really means, why it isn’t a retirement plan, and how private equity views agencies differently than eComm brands.• Why service businesses generate more cash (and get better multiples)• How CTC nearly collapsed—and what saved it• The real reason agency owners burn out (and how to ...

Jul 29, 20251 hr 54 min

Lessons from 11 Years of Building an Agency — and What Happened After

In this episode of The Random Show, Taylor Holiday and Andrew Faris sit down for a moment of focus—because something big just happened.Common Thread Collective has a new growth partner. Taylor breaks down what the deal really means, why it isn’t a retirement plan, and how private equity views agencies differently than eComm brands.• Why service businesses generate more cash (and get better multiples)• How CTC nearly collapsed—and what saved it• The real reason agency owners burn out (and how to ...

Jul 29, 20251 hr 54 min

Summit Recap: Lessons You Only Learn From Talking with Clients In Person

At CTC’s recent Client Summit, Taylor Holiday and Richard Gaffin sat down to unpack what happens when you get out from behind Zoom and into a room with the people you work with. The result? Honest conversations, unexpected insights, and a clearer picture of what brands really need right now. From creative volume challenges to leadership struggles, this episode explores the unspoken truths that surface when vendors and clients share space—and why in-person connection is still one of the most powe...

Jul 24, 202522 min

CTC Summit: Why 2025 eCom Is a Tale of Two Cities: Winners & Losers

The Tale of Two Cities in E-Commerce: Winners and Losers in 2025At CTC’s Client Summit, Taylor Holiday shares an unfiltered perspective on where the economy, the world, and the e-commerce landscape are headed—and why the future will be defined by a sharp divide between winners and losers.From macroeconomic pressures to changing consumer behavior, Taylor explains why the current environment isn’t creating a level playing field—and what separates the brands that will thrive from those that will st...

Jul 22, 20251 hr 6 min

14 Days, $1.28M: We CRUSHED Our Million-Dollar Challenge!

Can you turn 14 days into $1.28 million? We did—and we're breaking down exactly how we crushed our million-dollar challenge! In this episode, join Richard and Luke as they unpack the intense 14-day journey that led to massive revenue success. You'll learn: How we strategically turned a critical marketing moment into explosive growth. The day-by-day breakdown of how we overcame a nearly half-million-dollar gap in just four days. Why forecasting, clarity, and a well-engineered brand collaboration ...

Jul 17, 202524 min

Inside CTC’s New Strategic Partnership: What's Next?

Discover the next chapter in Common Thread Collective’s story as Taylor Holiday takes you behind the scenes of our 12-year journey from a tiny IKEA furnished office and our first Facebook ad experiments with QALO, to the seismic shifts of COVID and our reinvention as a “profit agency.” In this special episode of the podcast, you’ll hear: How CTC evolved from a passion project into a mission-driven agency focused on connecting marketing efforts to real financial outcomes The cultural transformati...

Jul 15, 202531 min

Meta's Attribution Settings Don't Matter Anymore

In this episode of the podcast, we dismantle the old school attribution windows holding your ad strategy hostage and reveal a simple framework for measuring true incremental ROAS. What you’ll discover: Why standard “7-day click” and “1-day view” settings both mislead you How to run a zero cost geo holdout test for real incremental data When to stick with your current settings and how to apply a correction factor What Meta’s new incremental conversion optimization means for your campaigns Buildin...

Jul 10, 202518 min

3 Moves to Save Your Brand From Financial Collapse

Is your brand feeling the squeeze? You’re not alone. In today’s episode, we break down three essential moves every DTC and ecommerce brand must make to survive—and thrive—amid rising bankruptcy rates and tightening capital markets. You’ll learn: Why capital constraints are killing growth—and how to turn your supplier into a lender How to generate organic demand by tapping into pop culture and community The critical Q4 inventory planning strategy that could save your cash flow We’re seeing a tale...

Jul 08, 202519 min

Are Ecommerce Brands Suddenly Failing?

Ecommerce brands are quietly shutting their doors, but what's really behind this sudden wave of closures? In this episode, we dive deep into exclusive industry data, consumer trends, and expert analysis to uncover what's truly happening behind the scenes in the ecommerce space.Join our panel of industry experts as we reveal: Why more brands than ever are filing for bankruptcy. The surprising trends impacting consumer spending. How major economic factors like tariffs and inflation are shaping the...

Jul 03, 202545 min

6 Questions That Expose Weak Brands

Are you building a resilient brand or just delaying the inevitable? In this episode of the Podcast, we tackle six hard hitting questions every founder and operator needs to answer right now. From survival mode decision making to brand building under pressure, we break down what separates strong, adaptable brands from those on the edge of collapse. Topics We Cover: When to cut (and when to protect) your marketing spend How to justify brand investments under financial pressure What “healthy” CAC e...

Jul 01, 202511 min

Can We Save the $1M Challenge? – We’re $577K Short

We’re $423K into our 14-day, $1M revenue challenge—and the pressure is mounting. With just 6 days left, we’re $577K short of our goal. In this episode, Luke Austin breaks down: What’s working (returning customers are showing up) What’s not (new customer revenue is lagging) Why our efficiency is solid, but volume is the problem The high-stakes brand collab launching on June 26th that could make or break the challenge Can we still pull this off? The next few days are everything. Show Notes: Explor...

Jun 26, 202510 min

The Future of Ads According to Meta (Straight from the Summit)

What’s next for Meta ads? We just got back from Meta’s Performance Summit, and the future is clear: incrementality, AI tuning, creative velocity, and less button pushing, more strategy. In this episode of the Podcast, VP of Paid Media, Tony Chopp, shares an exclusive insider recap of what Meta’s top brass revealed about the evolving ad platform and what it means for performance marketers. You’ll learn: Why Meta is obsessed with incrementality (and how it’s changing measurement forever) How creat...

Jun 24, 202546 min

Meta's New Setting Beat Our Old Campaign by 18%

Meta just rolled out a brand new attribution setting called Incremental Attribution and we put it to the test. In this episode of the Podcast, Richard is joined by Tony and McCay to break down the results of a real A/B test comparing Meta’s new setting vs. standard 7-day click attribution. The outcome? An 18% lift in conversion value—from the exact same ads and budget. We’ll cover: What Incremental Attribution actually is Why it might replace geo holdouts How it works under the hood The exact te...

Jun 19, 202518 min

2 Weeks to Make $1,000,000—Here’s the Plan

We’re attempting something BIG. Over the next two weeks, our VP of Ecommerce Strategy, Luke Austin, is taking on a real-time challenge to generate an additional $1,000,000 in revenue profitably for one of our clients. Every day, we’ll document the actions, strategy shifts, wins, and losses required to hit this massive goal. No fluff. No filters. Just real execution and behind-the-scenes access to how we actually grow brands at scale. What You’ll Learn: How to structure a revenue forecast and dai...

Jun 17, 202511 min

May Report Card Shocker: Under Budget but Over Profit?

How did our clients perform in May against their forecasted targets? In this episode, we analyze the latest client report card—detailing key insights from over 60 brands we manage. We dive into: How we managed to underspend budget but still exceeded contribution margin forecasts. Real examples of price testing and rapid flash sale strategies. Actionable insights from our growth strategists on driving profit despite revenue misses. Discover what worked, what didn't, and how transparent accountabi...

Jun 12, 202517 min

Story vs. Volume: The Creative Conflict Killing Your Ads

Is your marketing stuck between creating meaningful stories and pumping out endless ad variations? This episode of Podcast breaks down the critical tension between creative storytelling and the high volume ads required for success on platforms like Meta. Join Richard and Taylor as they discuss: How the best DTC brands successfully balance creative depth with ad volume. Why two distinct marketing rhythms are essential to growing your business. Practical strategies to empower your internal team wh...

Jun 10, 202527 min

I Almost Lost My Business — Here's Exactly How I Fixed It

In this episode, Tara Austin, founder and CEO of Ruthie Grace, reveals the raw and honest story of how she nearly lost her seven figure ecommerce business—and exactly what she did to turn it around. From facing a payroll crisis that nearly shut her doors, to completely transforming her team's culture and operating systems, Tara shares powerful lessons on leadership, communication, and resilience. You'll discover: The pivotal moments that almost ended her business How transparent leadership radic...

Jun 05, 202556 min

Taylor & Andrew Break Baseball Cards & Break Down DTC in 2025

In this episode of The Random Show, Taylor Holiday and Andrew Faris are back—new set, same chaos. They dive into the uncomfortable truths of e-commerce: zero barriers to entry, infinite competition, and the creative treadmill that never stops. If you’ve ever felt like you’re sprinting just to stay in place, you’re not alone. Why ecom profits get competed down to zero How “just take a thousand shots” became the default creative strategy What Andrew’s new brand launch reveals about market belief Y...

Jun 03, 20251 hr 41 min

Meta’s New Attribution Model Will Blow Up Your Ad Strategy—Here’s Why

Meta just dropped a game changing attribution feature, and it could completely upend how you measure ad performance. In this episode of the Podcast, CTC’s VP of Paid Media Tony Chopp and Paid Social Manager McCay Rasmussen join Richard to break down Meta’s new incremental attribution setting—a behind-the-scenes update that uses continuous holdout testing to determine true incremental conversions in real time. We cover: What incremental attribution actually is How it compares to 1-day click, 7-da...

May 29, 202533 min

CMOs: Stop Measuring, Start Creating Moments

In this solo episode of the Podcast, Taylor shares a powerful lesson from Cozy Earth’s CMO, who broke free from the measurement rabbit hole to create a viral TikTok challenge that earned 10M+ impressions over Memorial Day weekend. If you’re a CMO, marketing leader, or operator stuck in the endless loop of attribution models and incrementality debates, this episode is your permission slip to zoom out. Taylor introduces the concept of “Best Available Truth”—a mindset shift that allows you to act w...

May 27, 202512 min

Diagnose Your Ecommerce Growth Potential in 5 Minutes

Is your brand truly set up for growth? Or just treading water? In this episode of the Podcast, Taylor and Richard introduce CTC’s brand new Strategic Growth Scorecard—a 7-metric framework designed to help you quickly assess the strength of your growth engine. You’ll learn: Why we replaced ROAS with IMR (Incremental Marginal Return) The key metrics behind sustainable, efficient growth How to identify red flags in your customer acquisition strategy What separates brands that scale from those that ...

May 22, 202532 min

95% of Ecommerce Businesses Are Worth NOTHING

95% of ecommerce brands are worth ZERO. Why? In this episode, we unpack the harsh reality behind most DTC businesses, why logical decisions don’t drive entrepreneurship—and what actually does. Taylor and Richard dive deep into: The real odds of building a valuable brand Why success in ecommerce is often delusional by design How to align your business model with your personal financial goals The traits that separate the 5% from everyone else If you’ve ever wondered whether your business is on the...

May 20, 202531 min

Daily Ad Tweaks Are Wasting Your Budget

Are you obsessively tweaking your ad campaigns only to see flat results? In this episode of the Podcast, Richard sits down with Luke Austin, to expose why daily bid and budget changes are wasting your time and money. They dive into the root issue behind inconsistent performance: a lack of belief in the data. Luke shares the system CTC uses to align teams, set targets with confidence, and stop the reactive cycle. You’ll learn why geo holdout testing is the most trustworthy signal in media buying,...

May 15, 202533 min

Inside the $10M+ Brand Growth Workflow (Real Client Example)

Ever wonder how $10M+ ecommerce brands make their next move? In this episode of the Podcast, Taylor and Richard walk through a real world growth scenario pulled directly from CTC’s work with a 9-figure brand. Using live data from our proprietary platform, Statlas, we break down exactly how our team evaluates performance, spots hidden opportunities, and decides what to do next. What You’ll Learn: What to do when you’re overperforming Why beating your forecast might signal a problem How a growth s...

May 13, 202524 min

We Killed the Growth Map! Here’s What Replaces It

We just did something radical: we killed the Growth Map—CTC’s signature media buying tool used for years across hundreds of ecommerce brands. Why? Because AI changed the game. In this episode of the Podcast, we break down why our old system no longer works, how AI is reshaping the future of media buying, and what we’re building to replace human limitations with 24/7 omnipresence. Learn about: Why the Growth Map is dead What “circadian media buying” is (and why it’s obsolete) How AI forecasts spe...

May 08, 202526 min

Growth Is a Muscle—Here’s How to Train It

Most brands think they have a growth problem—but what they really have is a DOING problem. In this episode, we break down why volume of action is the single greatest predictor of business growth—and how to build a system that trains this muscle every day. From 400+ ads to 52 product launches a year, we’ll show you what it takes to build momentum, create consistently, and generate real results. You’ll learn: Why most brands dramatically underestimate the effort required The 3-stage framework: Qua...

May 06, 202521 min

How Skullcandy Used a Competitor to Win New Customer

What happens when you collaborate with a competitor instead of competing with them? In this episode of the Podcast, we sit down with Skullcandy CEO Brian Garofalow to unpack the bold business strategy behind their surprising partnership with Bose. From leveraging “product as marketing” to rebranding perception, launching at $99, and turning retail into a megaphone, this episode is a masterclass in how to create buzz, distribution, and long-term brand equity. You’ll learn: Why Skullcandy teamed u...

May 01, 202538 min
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android