Danielle Houchins – Cold Case Solved

of a cold case turned solved. This is the story of Danielle Houchin's.

check out everyone who has message just and everything. So shout out to you, thank you and sorry if we were unable to share yours, but we seriously appreciate you just the same.

let's get going. It was Saturday, September twenty first, nineteen ninety six. Fifteen year old Danielle or Danny Houchins asked her mom for permission to drive out to a nearby Cameron Bridge fishing access site. Now it's a popular spot along the Gallatin River just a few miles from her home. Danny was a sophomore. She was an honor student who had a big dream of becoming a biological engineer one

day now. She was also very outdoorsy adventurous. She was a teen who loved hiking, rock climbing, river rafting, skiing, and listening to grunge music. She even had a playful streak, known for pulling some pranks on friends and family. In many ways, Dan he was a typical nineteen nineties teenager with her whole life still ahead of her. But on this day, Danny reportedly wanted to blow off some steam after a little argument at home, and a little solo trip to the river was how she chose to try

and cool down. Her mother, Cheryl agreed and even lent Danny her watch so she could keep track of time and be back by mid afternoon. The family was expecting company around two PM, and Danny had promised to return by then. Now. She left home at around eleven am that morning, driving her pickup truck towards that Cameron Bridge. She was dressed in blue denim jeans and a gray sweatshirt and wore a knee brace on her left knee.

Now that brace was due to a minor injury she'd gotten horsing around on a street dance with a few friends weeks earlier, but it didn't slower down much and it wasn't anything like extremely serious. At fifteen, Danny was an active and athletic girl who spent a lot of time outdoors, so a quick trip to a little scenic fishing spot by a bridge wasn't out of the ordinary

for her or anything. She strapped on the gold elastic band watch that her mom lent her and cheerfully promised to be back in a couple hours, and with that she headed off in her truck, leaving the small town of Belgrade, Montana, in Gatlin County for the short drive to Cameron Bridge. It was just another Saturday adventure. As the clock ticked away and ticked past two pm. With guests arriving at the houch and home, Danny was nowhere to be seen. At first, her family wasn't exactly panic though.

Danny was in fact of a very responsible teen and it wasn't like her to be terribly late, so perhaps she just lost track of time or whatever, and she'd be, you know, coming through the front door at any moment. But by three pm, worry began to set in, so her mother, Cheryl, decided to go to Cameron Bridge herself to check in on Danny. She brought along one of the family friends and together they drove the route that Danny would have taken, hoping to you know, maybe pass

her on the way there or find her. When they arrived, still relaxing the river, not realizing what time it was, when hold into the dirt parking area at the Cameron Bridge, Cheryl immediately spotted Danny's truck. It was parked where visitors often leave their vehicles, but something was off. When they approached the truck, the doors were unlocked and Danny was nowhere in sight. Cheryl also saw Danny's belongings inside a

stack of her CDs and even her father's laptop. The fact that the truck was left unlocked with these valuables inside it was very unlike her, and a prickling sense of dread began to form in Cheryl's stomach. Now it was nearby. As the search began. That on a little trail leading from the parking area towards the river, Cheryl and her friend made an alarming discovery. They found Danny's water bottle and her keys laying on the ground. Now Cheryl knew that her daughter wouldn't just abandon her keys

in water like that and wander off the trail. Something seemed to clearly be wrong. They continued searching the area, calling out Danny's name, hoping for a response. For an exp of what's going on now. The Cameron Bridge site spans a mix of open fields brush patches of wood near the river, and there's footpaths, boat launches, and river banks all over, plenty of ground to cover, and as minutes ticked by with no trace of Danny, their search

became increasingly frantic. For two hours, they scoured the vicinity with growing desperation as they went, and by five PM, with daylight starting to wane and an ominous feeling that you know, they might not be able to find her on their own, Cheryl made the decision to call the authorities for help. Once she contacted the Gatland County Sheriff's office, search efforts ramped up quickly. Sheriff deputies arrived at the Cameron Bridge site, and soon Gatland County Search and Rescue

teams and local volunteers joined the hunt. The community mobilized fast. This was a small Montana town and a missing local teenager prompted immediate concern. Volunteers who knew the train came to help, and sheriff personnel coordinated the whole search in the wooded area, the marshy area, around the river, all of it. They're doing their best to try and find this missing teenager. As the following afternoon turned to evening, searchers spread out along the river's edge, through stands of

trees and into the tall grasses of the marshland. But as the sun dipped low, the conditions grew challenging. The bridges area also includes swampy overgrown sections. It's all along the river's edge, and losing daylight might be dangerous to continue trudging through that difficult terrain, and after hours of fruitless searching, the organized effort was reluctantly called off for the night once darkness fell, with plans to resume at first light.

personal for that family. At the urging of that sun, the brothers decided to continue the search on their own that night. So armed with flashlights and an intimate knowledge of that local train, the brothers navigated the shadows and muck along the river. It was around nine thirty PM, roughly forty five minutes after they began their private search, when one of the brothers made a heartbreaking discovery. They're only about two hundred feet from where Danny's truck was parked.

They spotted a figure in a very swampy, marshy patch of ground near the river's edge. The flashlight illuminated the devastating site. There was Danny Houchin's lifeless body lying face down in a shallow pool of water.

this spot. One of her shoes, which was reportedly a sandal, was missing from her foot, but it was later found not far away, as it had fallen off from a potential struggle. The watch that Danny had borrowed from her mother will. It had been pulled up part way off of her hand, as though someone might have been yanking on her arm, and the watch could have possibly slidden

off part way. The brothers who found her ran right away to get help, and one of them on his way out while he coincidentally encountered Danny's father, who was also out searching that evening too, Rex Houchins, he was, you know, out there for a last last search attempt of his own, and in an agonizing exchange from one father to another, the man delivered the news no parents should ever hear was found and she was clearly dead. Detectives secured the scene in the darkness and began collecting

whatever evidence they could find around Danny's body. Investigators recovered at least four strands of hair from Danny's body, hairs that did not appear to belong to her.

bit disturbed as well. It was obvious something terrible had been done to her. The entire Houchin family was devastated to learn these things. A memorial service for Danny was held only a few days later, on September twenty fifth, nineteen ninety six, drawing over four hundred mourners who came to pay their respects to a young life cut way too short. Everyone assumed this was obviously a murder, a heinous sexual assault and killing of a teenage girl in

what should have been a safe outdoor haven. However, shockingly, the early official handling of this case did not reflect the urgency and focused you would expect in a homicide investigation. In fact, within days of the body being discovered, Gatlin County authorities seemed to portray that they were not entirely sure what had even happened to Danny, even entertaining the

possibility that this might be an accident instead. Now, an autopsy was performed on September twenty third, nineteen ninety six, by the Montana State Crime Lab. The medical examiner's findings, well, they were quite perplexing, and to Danny's family they were infuriating because, on one hand, the autopsy revealed clear signs of assault. Because there was muddy material quote on quote found in Danny's stomach as well as in her airway, suggesting she had inhaled an even swallowed mud and water

while she was still alive. Now, this is not something that happens in a simple accidental slip and fall drowning scenario. It indicated that her face had been forced down into the marsh repeatedly or for a prolonged amount of time. And in addition, the autopsy had also noted a recent vaginal laceration, which was evidence of sexual trauma. All of these details screamed homicide to anyone who looked at them,

and yet the officials well. Their conclusion from state medical examiner Gary Dale, was that danny Her cause of death was drowning, with the manner of the death being unlisted as undetermined. In other words, the forensic report did not label it a homicide nor definitively an accident. As well, it left the case open to interpretation despite the tailtale signs clearly a violence.

The very next day after the autotopsy, Gatlin County Sheriff Bill Slaughter spoke to the press and downplayed the likelihood of murder, citing the fact that Danny's body supposedly didn't have any obvious cuts or bruises, saying, quote, I think we've got to be prepared for the fact that this may have been an accidental drowning. Now he even speculated that perhaps Danny, who had the knee brace on, might have slipped, been unable to get up, and drowned in

only a few inches of water. Just as your face shows, you're a little bit shocked. Danny's family. While they were shocked to at any suggestion that her death was accidental, the evidence of a sexual assault alone should have put the accident theory to rest. But to make things worse, Danny's parents were initially told by investigators that their daughter quote died a virgin, which was a blatant lie given the autopsy findings of vaginal injuries.

Frustration with the investigation only grew as time passed. No suspect was immediately identified in nineteen ninety six, and given the initial undetermined ruling, it seemed the case lacked the urgency of any sort of murder hunt, Sheriff Slaughter and his administration, according to later critiques, just didn't pursue with vigor.

One of the first deputies on scene, Keith Farquhar, recalled feeling that his department's leadership was too quick to dismiss the death as an accident or hint at the possibility of suicide, and that it never felt like they were treating it as a full on homicide investigation.

of thing, right. But despite these internal doubts, though official officially, the case well, it just sat stale and with no arrests and no public naming of even a person of interest, Danny's murder simply became a cold case. But that didn't mean it was forgotten, not entirely anyways. Over the years, some investigators, like Detective Bodick would circle back to the case.

turned into decades. Sheriff Bill Slaughter retired in the year two thousand. Subsequent sheriffs inherited the cold case, but as I already kind of eluded, they made little headway, and the question of who killed Danny Houchins lingered quietly in the background. All the while. Stephanie Houchin's especially was deeply scarred by the loss of her sister and the lack

of closure. She was only twelve years old when Danny died, and Stephanie grew up under the shadow of this trauma, involving nightmares, waking up sobbing in the middle of the night, those sort of things. Like most everyone else, she always knew it couldn't have been an accident. She knew it had to have been a murder, and by late twenty tens, over twenty years had passed since Danny's death, but Stephanie had not given up hope that her sister's killer could

be found. In fact, a revolutionary development in another case would soon inspire her to urge a new approach to Danny's Colt case. It was April of twenty eighteen when true crime history was made with California authorities announcing the arrest of the infamous Golden State Killer after decades of eluding justice. And it was all thanks to a cutting edge technique known as forensic genetic genealogy.

murdered her sister in nineteen ninety six. So Stephanie began contacting the Gatlin County Sheriff's office repeatedly in twenty eighteen and twenty nineteen, urging them to consider using DNA genealogy for Danny's cold case. At first, she just got mild in lukewarm responses, but Stephanie did not let up. She knew there was DNA evidence from the crime scene, the strands of hair being found and possibly preserved all those years, so she was determined to see it tested with the

latest methods. Her persistence coincided with some changes in the Sheriff's office, too, and that would ultimately prove to be crucial. It was twenty nineteen when a new sheriff, Captain Max Boxmeyer, took an interest in the Houchin's case. He quietly began

reinvestigating the final that year. He even reached out to the Houchin's family in early twenty twenty to discuss the sensitive prospect of you know reopening the case, knowing it would mean stirring up some old pain, but the family, well, they quickly agreed they could deal with those old wounds being reopened if it meant finding the truth. However, lingering distrust in authorities left them with some hesitation, but nonetheless they were still willing to work with any officers who

were genuinely committed to solving Danny's case. So now a significant turning point came. In twenty twenty one, Dan Springer, who had actually been a young deputy in the department at the time of Danny's murder, was elected as the

new Gatlin County Sheriff. Springer had never forgotten the case that occurred just five days after he was sworn in back in nineteen ninety six, and upon becoming sheriff, Springer vowed to bring fresh eyes to this cold case, and he assembled a small team dedicated to going wherever, and I mean wherever the evidence led, no matter how much

time has passed. One of Sheriff Springer's first moves was to bring in outside expertise, and by early twenty twenty three, he connected with Thomas Elfmont, a retired LAPD homicide captain, who had relocated to Montana. Now, Alfmont had decades of investigative experience and now ran a global security firm, and he was willing to lend his skills to help crack

this mystery death of Danny Springer. Swore Elfmont in as a special deputy, granting him full authority to investigate this case with a fresh perspective, and together they also enlisted Sergeant Court Dupwig from Newport Beach, California, who was an

expert in solving cold homicide cases with DNA technology. This new investigative team re examined everything they combed through the old case files, evidence on toops of reports, all of it uncovering in the process some shocking oversights from previous

investigators and authorities. For instance, in mid twenty twenty three, while reviewing physical evidence, they discovered something that had been missed or not reported publicly for decades, which was the fact that traces of seamen were found on Danny's underwear.

which typically have only trace amounts of DNA. But technology had advanced dramatically since the nineties, and the lab Arstea Forensics managed to extract enough genetic material from one of the hairs to build a partial DNA profile of the potential suspect.

and many others in recent years. It worked by taking DNA profile from the crime scene evidence and uploading it to commercial as ancestry databases, the one that I mentioned like ancestry dot com. Right, So this is going to

find relatives of the unknown suspect. Basically, if any distant cousin or aunt or uncle, anyone who may have you know what, submitted their own DNA to a public genealogy service and they are related to the killer, they might show up as a match, maybe a second cousin, whatever, And then by finding these family matches, skilled genealogists can now build out a family tree and zero in on the suspect from there. So to tackle this complex task, the Gatlin County team turned to one of the country's

best known genetic genealogists, CC Moore. Now CC was working with Parabon Nanolabs in Virginia. They had helped solve dozens of cases using this technology before and when the detailed DNA from Danny's case was passed to them, well, the painstaking research began. Months went by as CC and her colleagues analyzed the genetic profile from these armhairs and search for any notable matches in any databases. Bit by bit, they piece together a possible family tree for Danny's unknown killer.

This is very time consuming work. They don't just plunk it in and just get a family tree on a website and say, oh, well, there's the killer. This often involves historical records, obituaries, public documents, and sometimes even contacting family members directly to ask about their extended family and relatives. In this case, the genetic genealogist was able to connect DNA from the crime scene to four of the suspects, the unknown suspects grandparents, so they were able to confirm

whoever did the killing. These are their grandparents.

graduate student at Montana State University in Bozeman. He had only recently moved to the area around the time that Danny was killed. He wasn't a known troublemaker. In fact, he had no criminal history at all. Paul went on built a quiet life, a respectable life, even, you may argue. He earned a master's degree in Fisheries and Wildlife biology and eventually took a job with the US Bureau of

Land Management or BLM as a fisheries biologist. By twenty ten's he was working out of Dylan, Montana, roughly one hundred miles southeast of where Danny was killed, and he'd been working with BLM for twenty two years. Paul was also married for over two decades and had two kids, and by all outward accounts, he was a stable family man and an avid out doorsman. It was a profile

that stunned investigators when they figured this out. Could this fifty five year old husband, father biologist really be the person who raped and killed a fifteen year old girl back in nineteen ninety six. It was hard to reconcile, and yet the science was pointing directly at him. Sheriff Springer's team gathered more intelligence on Paul. Quietly, they confirmed that in September of nineteen ninety six, he indeed lived in Bozeman for grad school, placing him in the vicinity

of the crime. If he frequented outdoor spots, you know what, it's conceivable that he might have gone fishing or exploring at Cameron Bridge, where he may have randomly encountered Danny that day. Investigators theorized that this was a chance encounter, a crime of opportunity by a predator who saw young girl alone and seized the moment. Since there was no evidence that connected Danny to Paul, he didn't know her

or anything. They were just complete strangers. By the summer of twenty twenty four, the Gatlin County Sheriff's Office had enough confidence in the DNA and genealogical evidence. However, they based a challenge because the DNA profile from the hair technically was a partial profile and not yet confirmed with one hundred percent certainty that it was in fact Paul Hutchinson. They didn't have probable cause to just go simply arrest

him or take a DNA swamp to test. What they did need, though, was DNA to test and actually compare the two to see. So legally they needed more and ideally they wanted to obtain his DNA for that direct comparison, but doing so can take time, you know, having people trail him wait around for the right opportunity of a discarded cup that he'd been drinking from, or a cigarette butt or something. So instead of waiting, they decided on a different approach. They wanted to confront him in an

interview and gage his reaction. Sometimes a suspects behavior under questioning can be quite revealing, and in the best case, he might even volunteer a DNA sample or you know what, admit to his crimes. So on July twenty third, twenty twenty four, investigators made their move. They drove to Dylan, Montana, where Paul worked, to interview him. Unexpectedly, there they found Paul outside the BLM Field office unloading a pickup truck

with a couple of coworkers. They approached him with badges in hand, you know saying who they are, and asked to speak with them. The effect on Paul was reportedly instantaneous, as he turned pale white immediately. Paul rarely agreed to the interview, and for nearly two hours in a conference room or an office at his workplace, the detectives questioned Paul about the events on September twenty one, nineteen ninety six. Now, they deliberately did not mention that he was under arrest,

because he wasn't. This was a voluntary conversation. The goal, though, was partly to observe his demeanor and possibly prompt you a confession or at least inconsistencies in his story to strengthen their investigation. Now, Paul did not confess, but his body language spoke volumes. According to investigators, he was a

wreck during the interview. He was extremely nervous start to finish, sweating profusely, biting or chewing on his hand, and repeatedly scratching on his face in an agitated manner.

ever that they had the right guy. They still couldn't make an arrest, though they needed to directly match his DNA first, otherwise their case could fall apart. In court after the interview, Officers kept a very close eye on him as he drove off, and interestingly, Paul didn't just

head straight home calmly. Instead, he drove his vehicle in a strange, erratic pattern, possibly even checking if he was being followed, and investigators described it as if he were performing counter surveillance maneuvers, perhaps a sign that he was paranoid about being tailed and indeed he was subtly.

regroup and figure out how to get a definitive DNA sample. Then, in the early predawn hours of the very next day, July twenty fourth, twenty twenty four, as detectives were now strategizing their next move, Paul Hutchinson made a decision of his own. Sometime around four am, he phoned the Beaverhead County Sheriff's office, which is the local county for Dylan.

He phoned from his cell phone and in a brief, odd call, he stated that he needed some assistance with his vehicle, gave a location, and then abruptly hung up. After police received the strange phone call from Paul, they were dispatched to the spot where he said he was having vehicle trouble, which was a roadside area west of Dylan. What they found there ended any hope of a traditional path to justice because they found Paul Hutchinson dead sitting

in his car. He had shot himself with a thirty eight caliber pistol, ending his life in an apparent suicide.

But on the other hand, if this was true, then his death meant there would be no arrest, no trial, no public reckoning in a courtroom, nothing. Investigators quickly moved Paul's body into custody, and crucially, they collected DNA samples from him during post mortem procedures.

with essentially one hundred percent certainty. The statistical odds of it being anyone else was astronomically small.

but that possibility remains open. On August eighth, twenty twenty four, at the Gatlin County Sheriff's office held a press conference that Danny's family had waited for twenty eight years. Flanked by photos of Danny and aided by the diligent team that cracked the case, Sheriff Dan Springer announced to the world that the nineteen ninety six murder of Danielle Danny Houchins had been solved and that the killer was identified as Paul Nathaniel Hutchinson, who was fifty five years old.

He was a man who tragically would never face justice in court because he had taken his own life shortly after being identified. And standing besides the sheriff when he announced all this was Stephanie Houchins or now Stephanie Mullett,

Danny's sister, who was thirty nine years old. Stephanie had been the driving force from the family side, never letting authorities forget Danny's case, and when it was her turn to speak, Stephanie delivered a very powerful and emotionally charged statement on behalf of her family and her long lost sister. In her speech, she vividly described what happened to Danny, how this man had raped her and then held her down in the marsh until she choked on mud and died.

She also spoke about Paul's suicide and didn't hold back, saying, quote, when the time came to face up and account for his violence, he instead chose to end his life. He knew of his guilt and couldn't face my family or his family and the pain he caused. End quote. In those words, she labeled him as a coward, without using the word itself, a man who literally ran from justice in the final hour. Importantly, though, Stephanie did not shy away from criticizing how the case was handled back in

nineteen ninety six either. She recounted the many ways that the system failed her sister and her family. She reminded everyone that the evidence of the homicide had always been there.

There was, in fact, bruising on the back of Danny's neck indicating that she was forced down, the mud found in her stomach, the state of her clothing, the hair samples found the seaman that was recovered from her underwear, Yet those in charge in nineteen ninety six chose to label the death as undetermined and even lie to her parents about the sexual assault. She also revealed that some evidence had been mishandled or lost over the years, such

as the seamen that was never mentioned. Such as the very watch that her mother lent Danny that day, the crime lab reportedly somehow lost it. Even the very crucial hair evidence that was ultimately the thing that solved the case. It had been misfiled for years, an astounding error that delayed justice even further. Still, Stephanie, she expressed deep gratitude for those who finally stepped up and refused to let

Danny's case remain unsolved. Danny's family at last had an answer of who did it, a huge weight off their shoulders, but they were left to process a very fresh wave of grief from Danny. As for Paul's wife of twenty four years and his two children, they were stunned by this revelation. By all accounts, he had been a good husband and father in their eyes. They never had an inkling that back in nineteen ninety six, before he even met his wife, and birthed his kids he had committed

such a horrible act. His wife posted a public message of condolence to the Houchin's family after learning the entire truth, saying, quote, our hearts go out to the Houchin's family. They will let last be able to find the closure they deserve. She also described being absolutely heartbroken and said that the news made their own grieving from their loss so much more complicated, as they now had to reconcile that the

man they loved was secretly a monster. In the community of Belgrade and Bozeman, people remember that fifteen year old girl with a bright smile from nineteen ninety six and felt comforted that at long last, the question of who killed her was finally answered. Danny's case is just one of several across the country and even more in recent years, where a suspect identified through genetic genius died by suicide

before they could ever be arrested. It's a growing trend that showcases both the power of these new tools and the tragic reality that some offenders, when finally cornered after years, choose to escape legal consequences through death. In the end, it's important to remember who was at the heart of this story, Danielle Danny Houchins herself. Today, Danny would be forty five years old. If she was alive, she might have become a biological engineer like she once aspired to be.

Or perhaps she would have followed a different path, maybe using her love of outdoors in an environmental career or starting a family of her own. But unfortunately we'll never know, because a vicious crime cut her life short at just fifteen years old. But those who knew and loved her while they keep her memory alive, and they have throughout

all these years. At the Cameron Bridge fishing access site across stands with the words Justice for Danny written across it, a tribute to a young life lost and a demand for her killer to be found, which thankfully has now after twenty eight years, that justice has been realized in the only way left possible now. Danny's story is an example of how crucial it is for law enforcement to listen to victim's families and never give up on finding

the truth. It also showcases the remarkable power of modern forensic science. How a few tiny rootless hairs saved in an evidence file for decades held the key to solving a crime that once seemed unsolvable. Danny Houchin's case will forever be part of Montana's history, not just because of the tragedy that occurred, but because of the hard won

resolution that followed. Now, while the ending was not the conventional justice system outcome, the truth was still uncovered and in remembering Danny, those who knew her her as a fun, loving, kind and ambitious girl who brought joy to those around her.

She deserved so much more in life. Though nothing can bring her back, one hope remains that she can now truly rest in peace, and that her family can sleep a little easier at night, knowing that the mystery that plagued them for decades has finally been put to rest. Danny's story shows us that no matter how much time passes, determination can light the way to justice, and even the darkest secrets can eventually see the light of day. And that's the story of Danielle Houchin's.

independently produced, independently owned, written, researched, hosted. All of it is done by us in our tiny home, next to our two dogs who are curled up waiting for the show to end so they can go outside and maybe go for a walk and have treats and stuff like that.