Chelsea Perkins - Revenge Murder

into one's own hands. This is the tragic and convoluted story of Matthew Dunmyer and Chelsea Perkins.

off the main path. And that's when they saw him, a man lying face down in the leaves, just off that path and laying perfectly still.

He had a single gunshot wound to the back of his head. There was no weapon laying nearby, there was no shell casing on the ground, and no sign that he had tried to defend himself. It was just simple and what appeared to be an execution. However, even if that's what it seemed like, nothing could be ruled out. Accidents happened in strange ways, for example, and suicides, while unlikely in this situation given the placement and nothing found

around him, still had to be considered. Homicide was, of course the most possible, but without a suspect or motive, or even an identity, it was still just a theory. Now, because the death occurred inside a national park, federal jurisdiction

kicked in almost immediately. The FBI joined the investigation. Alongside local authorities and investigators while they began working to identify the man, and with dental records and missing persons reports, they soon confirmed his identity as thirty one year old Matthew Dunmyer, a Virginia native who had been living in Ohio. But even with a name, the mystery only continued to deepen. Why was he alone in a remote area of the National Park, Why had someone shot him from behind? And

who had been with him before he died? Who had shot him? How? Why? All these questions began to pile up. Investigators shifted their focus from the crime scene to try and figure out those questions and of course, his final known movements. Now they had discovered that Matthew had moved from Virginia to Ohio in an attempt to do a bit of a fresh start on his life. He was living near Hudson, working at a screen printing shop and spending most of his time with coworkers who had become

his main social circle. Now to them, Matthew came across as laid back. He was creative and easy to get along with. He played guitar, loved music, and often talked about his kids back home in Virginia. On the evening of Friday, March fifth, Matthew went out with his coworkers to a bar called Teaky Underground. It wasn't unusual for the group to grab drinks after work, and nothing about the night really seemed off, at least not at first. At some point during the evening, Matthew mentioned that he

had plans for the weekend. A woman he knew from Virginia was in town and they were going to go spend time together. Now, not long after that, his phone lit up with a message. Matthew glanced down, smiled, and told the group that she had arrived, and so he stood up, grabbed his coat, and headed outside. Now, one of his supervisors followed him on his way out to say goodbye and you know, wish him a good weekend

sort of thing. So as they talked, the supervisor noticed a small white car idling in the parking lot and a woman with dark hair sitting in the driver's seat. Matthew smiled a big grin and shook his supervisor's hand, then got into the passenger seat of the car as it pulled away. That was the last time anyone at the bar would ever see Matthew alive.

Later that night, cameras near a sandwich shop captured Matthew and a woman together casually grabbing food before returning to that airbnb. Cell Phone data placed both of them inside the rental overnight. The next morning, Saturday, March sixth, Matthew sent several text messages to his girlfriend back in Virginia. Now, his girlfriend knew he was meeting this girl as it seemed like it was a meetup of potentially an old friend or something like that, So she was aware of this.

I'll see you in a little while now. Investigators would later determine that message was sent from inside Coya Huga Valley National Park, the same place where he was found dead, and of course Matthew never made it home. Now, as detectives pieced together the timeline, it was obvious Matthew hadn't gone into the woods alone. Somewhere between the bar, the airbnb, and the park, someone else had been with him, and whoever that person was had vanished since without a trace.

But for now all investigators had was a car, a woman in town for the weekend, and a growing sense that this wasn't a spontaneous act. So as investigators continued to work back through Matthew's final hours, new information began to surface from people who had been inside Cyahuga Valley National Park that same morning, and they were well. They were first hand encounters that placed another person in the woods at the exact same time that Matthew seemed to disappear.

Late in the morning on March sixth, a couple walking along the trails near the Terra Vista Natural Study Area reported hearing a single sharp sound that echoed through the trees. It sounded to them like a gunshot, and the noise was unsettling enough that they turned around and left the area immediately and did not continue with their plans.

but she didn't really look relaxed. Something else was an air about her to say. When the hiker spoke to her, she said that she was lost and she was trying to find the cemetery. Her tone was flat and calm, and after a brief exchange, she turned and walked away. Now, at the time, it didn't feel like much more than an encounter in the woods with someone dressed all in black. People get lost in the park time to time. It's not out of the ordinary. People look for a cemetery

or other landmarks. But once Matthew's body was discovered days later, those interactions took a much heavier weight because well, she had been seen near the exact area where Matthew's body would later be found, and witnesses could place her within a narrow window of time.

came from Matthew's workplace. His coworkers at the screen printing shop in Hudson, Ohio told investigators about the night that

he disappeared. That on March fifth, Matthew had gone out with them to the local bar, the Teaky Underground, when they mentioned, you know, the meeting of the woman in the parking lot from out of town for the weekend, and when it came time to leave, supervisor walked him outside and said goodbye, and the details of him climbing in the small white car parked outside the bar came

to light. It had been an out of state car because it had the plates from another state and the person behind the wheel appeared to be a woman with dark hair. Surveillance footage from the nearby cameras backed up that account, and from there investigators began tracing the vehicle's movements using traffic cameras, toll readers, and license plate recognition systems.

The white smart car appeared again at a gas station, then later moving through Cleveland neighborhoods the trail didn't stop at city limits, though records show the same car had traveled from Ohio to Virginia on March fifth, just hours before Matthew was seen alive. Toll data confirmed a very deliberate multi state drive that aligned precisely with his final moments.

Now after his death, the following morning, the vehicle left Ohio again, crossing into Michigan before eventually returning to Virginia. What had initially looked like an isolated killing on a hiking trail was now clearly part of a larger, planned sequence. Someone had driven hundreds of miles to reach Matthew, to stay overnight with him, and then left the state within hours of his death. The case was no longer confined to this national park. It had crossed state lines, involved

federal land, and pointed to planning rather than chance. Investigators soon identified the owner of that white smart car, and it was a man by the name of John Perkins. He was a man living in Virginia, but records quickly showed he hadn't been in Ohio that weekend, and it was obvious he was not the person seen driving. So the next step was to figure out who had been behind the wheel. Now John did have a wife, and her name was Chelsea Perkins. As agents began pulling records

on her name, things started surfacing. Travel data showed she had driven from Virginia to Ohio on March fifth, twenty twenty one, arriving just hours before Matthew had left the bar with her. The timeline fit way too cleanly to ignore. Clearly she was the one driving that car. Now, the Airbnb Matthew stayed in that night wasn't booked under his name, nor was it a fake name or even a third party. It had been reserved under Chelsea Perkins's name, confirming that

she was in fact there. Also, she used her own credit card.

wasn't this mysterious woman anymore. She was a confirmed part of Matthew's final days, and at this point, while she wasn't under arrest, In fact, she didn't even know that she was at the center of an expanding federal investigation. But behind the scenes, agents began quietly building their profile and started digging into her background deeper, and what they found was not at all what they expected. As it turns out, Chelsea Perkins was a former US Coast Guard

service member. She was also married, as we know, and she also had children. Now after leaving the military, Chelsea Perkins had built a public online persona alongside her private life as a wife and mother. She was active on social media and earned an income through online adult content platforms,

including one such as OnlyFans, operating under a different name. Now, to investigators, this wasn't evidence of wrongdoing by any means, but it did explain her extensive digital footprint and why her online activity would later become part of this investigation. So there was nothing about her that suggested a history of violence or criminal behavior. There's no prior arrests, no obvious red flags. A mother, a wife, an adult content creator.

That's about it. And as agents shifted their focus to Chelsea Perkins, it began securing court authorization to examine the digital trail surrounding her movements. They got a hold of her phone provider and looked through all the information, which included app data and location data. Now through this they began reconstructing her movements digitally. GPS data placed her in Cleveland on the evening of March fifth, lining up with

surveillance footage and toll records and everything else. Cell Phone tower pings confirmed she stayed overnight near the airbnb, which by morning of March sixth, both her phone and Matthews were then moving in sync. Her social media added more to this. Still, in the days before the trip, Chelsea had posted an interesting and perhaps cryptic message that read

quote dead men tell no tales end quote. Now on its own, that might mean nothing, but paired with everything else, it lands a little bit differently, almost as if there's a bit of a hidden meaning behind it.

There's all this surrounding it, but there's nothing tying her to the exact crime scene and the exact crime Yeah, that's true.

sudden confrontation. Whatever happened out there, it was over quickly, like he was with someone he knew or trusted. Yes, again still circumstantial. But near Matthew's body, investigators found a partially full Aquafina water bottle, and forensic testing would turn it into one of the most important pieces of evidence in this case because DNA analysis revealed two profiles on the bottle, Matthew's and Chelsea's. Oh and Matthew is seen on surveillance purchasing an Aquafina water bottle with her.

the woods. Now they had digital records placing Chelsea at the scene, they really do, but pulling the trigger murdering someone is a different story. They had witnesses who saw her in the woods immediately after a gunshot DNA tying her there. But now, up until this point in the investigation, it had focused almost entirely in what happened that day

in March, and rightfully so. But as agents continued digging into Chelsea's background, they uncovered a piece of history that reframed the case in a way no one saw coming. And in March of twenty seventeen, Chelsea herself had walked into a police station in Virginia Beach and made a very serious accusation. She reported that Matthew Dunmyer, the murder victim and someone she had known for years, had actually sexually assaulted and raped her. Now, the details of that

report were never publicly released, but police did investigate. Matthew admitted that he had been together sexually with her, but he claimed the encounter was consensual, and ultimately charges were not filed citing insufficient evidence.

and a possible motive for a crime. Now, importantly, investigators were careful how this information was handled, the twenty seventeen allegation had never resulted in charges, and Matthew was never convicted of a crime. That legal reality remained unchanged. What the history did show, however, was that Chelsea and Matthew did not reconnect as strangers or casual acquaintances. They reconnected, yes, but with unresolved trauma, anger and a pass that had

never been settled in court. So with everything they had, investigators now needed to try and prove what they thought to be true, which was that Chelsea had murdered Matthew. So on March thirtieth, federal agents executed a search warrant at her home in Arlington, Virginia, carefully documenting everything they found inside the residents, agents recovered several firearms, including a

Springfield Armory nine millimeter pistol registered to Chelsea. One of the weapons was located alongside her personal identification, leaving no question about the ownership or access, and ammunition was of

course seized as well. Now, the bullet recovered from Matthew's skull was also a nine millimeter round, and test firings were of course conducted soon thereafter, and the markings on the test bullets were compared to the bullet taken from Matthew's bullet body and guess what it was an undeniable match. Oh no, they literally have a smoking gun.

Because like she went to go visit him as a friend, so were they they were in his mind still on like friend grounds here, I don't know, and it wouldn't have been weird or alarming or I don't know, okay, because yeah, just sitting here, I'm like, that's so odd that a to anyone in her life, she would be able to go visit him and that would be okay and be like that he wouldn't think that's fishy, you know that she wants to come meet up with him.

days in advance, not arranged on a whim. But most damning of all, forensic analysis also recovered deleted data from her phone that included a draft note written from Matthew's point of view. It was a suicide note.

for nearly nine months while the investigation continued behind the scenes. Now, the delay was not due to uncertainty about her involvement. It was pretty clear what slowed the process down was procedures. The crime had taken place on federal land, which places it under federal jurisdiction, while Chelsea lived in another state, So every step required coordination between agencies, extensive forensic testing too, and careful legal review, and all of that takes a

lot of time. Now, DNA analysis in particular, it took a while samples collected from the water bottle, for example, Like, that's not something to pick up the water bottle and just know the DNA's there.

was ever the focus in a major investigation. She knew she was, though, because they had executed a warrant on her place, right, she knew she was under the microscope.

in place. All that remained was an arrest. So in a quiet day in December of twenty twenty one, nearly nine months after Matthew Dunmyer was killed in the Woods, federal agents arrived at Chelsea's home in Virginia and placed her under arrest. There was no dramatic standoff, no attempt to flee. Neighbors simply watched as she was quietly taken into custody, with many of those neighbors unaware of what she had done and why she was being led away

in the first place. Chelsea was charged with first degree murder on federal land, along with a firearms violation tied to the use and discharge of a weapon during a crime of violence, meaning if convicted at trial, she was facing possible life in prison plus additional time for weapons charges.

spend his final night with. But why he was doing so is a whole other conversation which you were kind of already touching on, which we don't really know. Perhaps it was to reconcile past actions, Maybe we don't know. Maybe it was driven by desires of more infidelity. Maybe it was simply platonic. We just do not know.

discovery of his body, her grief hardened into obsession. Convinced that the system was moving far too slowly, she began conducting her own investigation, pouring over information and trying to identify who she believed was responsible for Matthew's murder, and by November of twenty twenty one, Tommy Lynn believed she had found the person who killed her son. But she

was wrong. She didn't know she was wrong, and accompanied by her husband, John McQuillan, she traveled to Washington, d c. Convinced that this woman she had found was living there just in peace, being Matthew's killer. The plan she had was simple. She was dressed as a ups driver, carrying

a fake package and a concealed firearm. John waited nearby as a getaway driver, and as they knocked on the door to deliver said package, the door opened and Tommy Lynn pulled the trigger and fired two shots into the innocent woman's stomach.

Lynn remained sitting inside the vehicle. But moments later, there was another sharp pop sound as she pulled the trigger and took her own life with the same gun she used in the shooting. Oh no, So, in the span of a single night, Matthew's family lost a second life and an innocent woman was nearly killed.

someone took those matters into their own hands. They got too blinded by what they were fixated on, and the truth is always not exactly so easy to see anyways. After her arrest, Chelsea Perkins was transferred to federal custody

and the folks shifted to prosecution. The evidence against her, well, it was extensive, to say the least, and prosecutors made it very clear early on that they had things like the smoking gun and it was going to be a slam dunk case, their surveillance footage, DNA ballistics, all of it.

show premeditation. Now, for years, the case moved slowly through the federal system. Pre trial motions were filed, evidence was reviewed and challenged, but all the while, prosecutors remained confident, while the defense weighed the growing reality that the jury

might see the case very differently than they hoped. Then, finally, in March of twenty twenty five, just weeks before her case was scheduled to go to trial, Chelsea Perkins changed course, and, after years of denying criminal intent and rejecting earlier plea offers, she entered a guilty plea to second degree murder and to using and discharging a firearm during a crime of

violence on federal property. As part of the agreement, prosecutors dropped the first degree murder charge, and the decision spared both sides a very lengthy trial, but it did not soften the reality of what Chelsea admitted to doing. In court, she acknowledged that she had shot Matthew Dunmyer in the woods of Cuyahouga Valley National Park. When asked directly if

she committed the act, she answered quietly quote yes. At sentencing in September of twenty twenty five, the judge described the case as one of the most difficult ones he had to preside over. He acknowledged the history of trauma presented by the defense and recognized that Chelsea's actions were motivated by revenge rather than financial or impulsive gain, or anything along those lines, but at the same time he

emphasized that the crime was in fact very deliberate. It involved planning, and resulted in the execution style killing of an unarmed man. Chelsea Perkins was sentenced to twenty two and a half year in federal prison. The court allowed her to serve her time in a facility closer to her family, which was a small concession with credit for time served, so she will likely be in her mid

to late fifties before she's eligible for release. Chelsea at sentencing stood firm, and she told the court she accepted responsibility for her actions, and when she was led away to begin her sentence, the legal system considered the case finished. For everyone else involved, The impact was only beginning, though.

Matthew Dunmyer, while he was thirty one years old when he was killed, he never saw his children grow up, and whatever complexities existed in his life, whatever allegations followed him, his death froze everything in place. His children would come to know their father through memories through secondhand stories in court records rather than presents. His absence created a void

that no ruling or sentence could ever repair. Chelsea's children, while they were young when their mother was arrested, they are now watching her through prison visits. It's media coverage and legal headlines instead of everyday life. By the time she's eligible for release, they will be adults who spent most of their formative years without her. The consequences of her decision extended far beyond the man that she killed. Now, this case offers no clean moral resolution like many of

our cases actually do. Instead, though this one forces some very uncomfortable questions about trauma, justice and the limits of the legal system. Chelsea Perkins reported that Matthew dun Meyer had sexually assaulted and raped her years earlier. Prosecutors reviewed the allegations and declined to file charges, citing insufficient evidence, and Matthew Dunmeyer was never convicted of that crime. For many survivors of sexual violence, this outcome is painfully familiar.

Most assaults are never reported. Of those that are few, while the few resultant charges or convictions, victims have a fear of retaliation, how they're going to be pursued, and the burden of proof. Well, it often leaves victims feeling very exposed and very unprotected. So when justice feels out of reach, the emotional weight does not disappear. It lingers, and it simmers, and it results in people taking matter

into their own hands. And there is an old saying, I will put it here just for context, because hey, I think it fits dramatically. Two wrongs do not make a right. Whether Matthew did what Chelsea alleged is never going to be known. But what we do know is people who commit crimes like that get away with it far too often. And Chelsea clearly felt a need to take matters into her own hands, just like well Matthew's mother did. What followed in this case was not justice,

though many people sought to find it. It was instead escalation. Planning replaced accountability, revenge replaced due process. And for that reason, I do not think anyone is guilt free in this story. It's just too hard to let someone walk away with a crime. The trail where Matthew was found eventually returned to silence. Hikers passed through once again. Seasons have changed, but for the people left behind, the story has not faded.

It became something they carried forward, a reminder of how quickly unresolved trauma can spiral into irreversible harm, and how violence, once unleashed, rarely remains contained. The law closed this file, but the consequences did not. And that's the story of Matthew Dunmeyer and Chelsea Perkins.

put forth. Those never made it public. And in Chelsea's case, she took a plea deal, So her story on what their meeting was about or how things began again, we'll never see the light of day because it didn't go to trial to become public information. Right, So all that is taped away in boxes through her accounts that she may never tell and will not We won't know unless she chooses to speak out.

you need to still be able to prove things. But at the same time, of course, people don't want to speak up. It's becomes a story of their word versus their word. It's such a convoluted situation. There is no right answer. But certainly taking matters into your own hands is going to result in other shit happening, not necessarily just to you, but other people too. It's not going to end the way you think.

a street, And do you have that perspective? Authorities just, well, it's bias. And so now people who hear these stories of biasness, well, they don't want to come forward because they don't want to be rejected or ridiculed. Of course, even if you have a situation of two individuals that the police will respect and listen to equally, it becomes their word versus your word. What evidence do you have? Sexual assaults? Guess what, they don't happen right in front

of a camera. You don't have a rape kit or anything like that. You're not doing an interview with them, trying to get like secret audio of like tell me you're raping me right now so I can give it to evident like that. It just doesn't happen. What evidence can you find?

this podcast. We really appreciate you being here. Because of you, we get to keep doing what we do. We're an independent podcast, researched, host it, produce all of it. It's us. We are a team. There's no one pulling the strings.