In Which Murderer’s eighth episode of Season 6, the girls cover people who were Murdered Over Opinions . Mel starts us off with the sad story of Brianna Ghey before Holly tells you all about the case involving Shannon Brandt. Shoutout to our good friend Betty for the suggestion! She probably won’t listen though so instead, the girls will thank themselves for being such great friends. In this episode the girls discuss their drinks for that night including Mel’s ‘classy’ new cocktail discovery, ho...
Aug 25, 2023•32 min•Season 6Ep. 8
In Which Murderer’s seventh episode of Season 6 the girls cover the extremely hard to research topic of Office Party Murders . Holly starts us off with killers Rizwan Farook & Tashfeen Malik before Mel tells you all about the frustrating case of Melanie Hall . Shoutout to Kirsty for the suggestion! Never torture us like this again. In this episode the girls are for once grateful about all their dental records, Mel diligently researches a fictional murder case, some red flags are at various l...
Aug 18, 2023•30 min•Season 6Ep. 7
In Which Murderer’s sixth episode of Season 6 the girls cover the fascinating topic of Familial DNA Murders . Mel starts us off with murderer Lonnie David Franklin Jr. before Holly tells you all about the eventually solved case involving Joseph Kappen. Shoutout to Cheryl for the suggestion! In this episode the girls talk about Holly’s new electric wheels, how men are the absolute worst (when it comes to buying cars) and they advise all you children who should definitely not be listening to DO TH...
Aug 11, 2023•26 min•Season 6Ep. 6
In Which Murderer’s fifth episode of Season 6 the girls cover Gravedigger Murders . Holly starts us off with the murder of Thomas Hollran who was run out of town before Mel tells you all about the hit TV show based on the case of Larry Hall. Shoutout to Karen for the suggestion! In this episode the girls are having some morning issues due to the fact they are organising, hosting and taking part in an outdoor festival, there are some case updates from Holly and you will go on a vocabulary journey...
Aug 03, 2023•26 min•Season 6Ep. 5
In Which Murderer’s fourth episode of Season 6 the girls cover Military Murders. Mel starts us off with the infuriating murder of Vanessa Guillen before Holly tells you all about the emotional rollercoaster case of Frank Vanessa Guillen. Shoutout to Kirsty for the suggestion! Are you twin one or twin two? In this episode the girls are confident they have reached the peak of low, there is a great amount of yawning, Mel gets super annoyed with the US Military and Holly lists off a bunch of random ...
Jul 28, 2023•32 min•Season 6Ep. 4
In Which Murderer’s third episode of Season 6 the girls cover Wrestler Murders. Holly starts us off with the gangland style murder of Dino Bravo before Mel tells you all about the soapy murder of Frank Goodish. No shoiwer meetings! Shoutout to Emma Jo for the suggestion! In this episode the girls experience flashbacks to the glory days of professional wrestling, Holly pulls a muscle sitting, Mel is off to France and it turns out Hulk Hogan is alive after all. Production, recording and post produ...
Jul 21, 2023•29 min•Season 6Ep. 3
In Which Murderer’s second episode of Season 6 the girls cover Celebrities Who Murder . Mel starts us off with the very famous case of Oscar Pistorius before Holly tells you all about the actor Michael Andrew Jace. Shoutout to Caitlin for the suggestion! Your baby has an excellent head. In this episode the girls are throwing Royalist Parties and Lodge Weekends, there is a mutual hatred for Mel’s celebrity and Holly is not a fan of bombings as it turns out. Production, recording and post producti...
Jul 14, 2023•34 min•Season 6Ep. 2
WELCOME TO WHICH MURDERER SEASON 6! In Which Murderer’s first episode of Season 6 the girls cover Murdered by Authority . Holly starts us off with the case of Grant Hardin before Mel tells the mind twisting tale of Daniel Morgan. Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion! In this episode the girls start off as they usually do in a cloud of confusion, Mel celebrates the start of her third season with the podcast, Holly swallows a filling just prior to recording which leads us all down a rather unplea...
Jul 07, 2023•23 min•Season 6Ep. 1
BONUS EPISODE Which Murderer will return for Season 6 on 7 July, 2023. In Season 4 Episode 13 the girls cover a suggested topic from Season 1-3 Co-host Gemma – Incels Who Murder. AKA Involuntary Celibates. Holly starts things off with the poster boy for this group who was responsible for the 2014 Isla Vista murders before Mel chats through the case of Alek Minassian. Shout-out to Carrie for her lovely comments about Mel who is doing much better at checking Facebook occasionally. The girls are up...
Jun 30, 2023•41 min
BONUS EPISODE Which Murderer will return for Season 6 on 7 July, 2023. In Season 4 Episode 36 the girls tackle another listener suggestion and tell you about Murders Solved by Psychics. What a great idea! Mel kicks it off with the sad story of Melanie Uribe before Holly tells you about a lovely man named Andre Daigle. Shoutout to Cheryl for this week’s suggestion! Keep them coming…..you guys are doing a fantastic job. Mel is on the running bandwagon while Holly remains on a health not-kick, we l...
Jun 23, 2023•42 min
BONUS EPISODE Which Murderer will return for Season 6 on 7 July, 2023 In Season 4 Episode 24 the girls talk about Dentists Who Murder - perfectly timed to be just before Mel’s dental appointment. Mel chats about Colin Howell before Holly tells you about Tony Protopappas. Shoutouts to listeners Mark and Robyn! KEEP SENDING YOUR TOPIC SUGGESTIONS. We are lazy. There are more updates on how dark it is in Scotland, dental traumas are revisited, Mel forgets major surgery that she had and the girls wo...
Jun 16, 2023•40 min
WHICH MURDERER SEASON 5 FINALE! Thank you to all our amazing listeners, our lovely support teams at Spreaker, iHeart Radio, iTunes , Spotify and of course to our families who put up with us forcing them to watch True Crime at every opportunity. We will be taking a 3 week break (which you will hear us debating in this episode!) voted on by you , our listeners, in an online poll. We will be relaunching some of our favourite episodes during the break so stay tuned for those. In Which Murderer’s Epi...
Jun 09, 2023•30 min•Season 5Ep. 52
A message from the Which Murderer Team: It has been brought to our attention that ad space was sold to a political party in the US who released a campaign message we absolutely do not endorse. We apologise to our listeners and have worked with our network to remove all future Political ad options from our podcast feed. In Which Murderer’s Episode 51 Season 5 the girls cover Hospital Porter Murders. Holly starts us off with the brutal murder of David Hamilton before Mel tells the extremely distur...
Jun 02, 2023•27 min•Season 5Ep. 51
In Which Murderer’s Episode 50 Season 5 the girls cover Rising Star Murders . Mel starts us off with the tragic murder of Christina Grimmie before Holly tells the story of Lebanese rising star Suzanne Tamim. Shoutout to Natalie for the suggestion! Also Joanne - a blast from Mel’s past and new listener! In this episode the girls are so professional they forgot they were professional and became unprofessional rather quickly, Finland is cursed over listening figures, there is a long awaited sad pig...
May 26, 2023•32 min•Season 5Ep. 50
In Which Murderer’s Episode 49 Season 5 the girls cover House Party Murders . Holly starts us off with the killing of Luke Moran before Mel tells the story of parent killer Tyler Hadley. Shoutout to Caitlin for the suggestion! Also Karen and Emma Jo for all the other suggestions coming in! In this episode the girls are tired and broken, specifically Mel who cannot shower without a carer anymore, Holly tells you about a 12 hour unexpected border crossing, the girls reveal some personal house part...
May 19, 2023•26 min•Season 5Ep. 49
In Which Murderer’s Episode 48 Season 5 the girls cover Social Media Influencer Murders. Mel starts us off with the subject of a recent Netflix documentary, Caleb McGillvary before Holly recounts the story of an incel named Brandon Andrew Clark. Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion! Also Sarah from Alaska for her lovely message to us on Instagram. In this episode Mel pulls herself together to delivery a professional into which Holly ruins with her shockingly poor memory, there is crying over th...
May 12, 2023•27 min•Season 5Ep. 48
In Which Murderer’s Episode 47 Season 5 the girls cover Secret Society Murders. Holly starts us off with the history of the The Molly Maguires before Mel covers the recent scandal surrounding NXIVM. Shoutout to Carrie for the suggestion! Or Natalie. It was a rough night. In this episode buckle up for poor overworked Mel’s brain, some pretty great TV recommendations, a podcast recommendations and you’ll witness Consulting Producer Craig roll over in his grave. Despite still being alive. Oh and th...
May 05, 2023•31 min•Season 5Ep. 45
In Which Murderer’s Episode 46 Season 5 the girls cover the challenging topic Florist Murders. Mel starts us off cheeky with the case of Norman Flowers (see what she did there) before Holly covers the unsolved case of Jacob Bornkamp. Shoutout to Karen for the suggestion! If you have any information regarding the Jacob Bornkamp case please contact Crime Stoppers immediately. In this episode Mel is blind and doesn’t care how Holly is feeling, you are invited to visit a new place called ‘Nervada’, ...
Apr 28, 2023•29 min•Season 5Ep. 46
WARNING! THIS EPISODE CONTAINS DETAILS OF CRIMES THAT ARE GRAPHIC AND EXTREMELY DISTURBING. LISTEN WITH CAUTION. In Which Murderer’s Episode 45 Season 5 the girls cover Bodies in Concrete. Holly starts us off with a very recent case in Scotland involving Andrew Innes before Mel retells the tale of poor Junko Furata. Shoutout to Natalie for the suggestion! In this episode the girls come to you from different furniture, Mel manages to complain despite being in a bed, surrounded by pillows and unde...
Apr 21, 2023•39 min•Season 5Ep. 45
In Which Murderer’s Episode 44 Season 5 the girls finally cover Witch Murders. Mel starts us off with Ama Hemmah from Ghana before Holly goes into the complicated case of Lawrence Harris. Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion! In this episode the girls decide who the next James Bond will be and what TV Witches they want to drink some tea with, Mel is very clearly making up the name of her murderer entirely, Holly is queen of fire and the girls once again deliberate through worst fears. Not inclu...
Apr 14, 2023•31 min•Season 5Ep. 44
In Which Murderer’s Episode 43 Season 5 the girls cover heartbreaking cases of people Murdered in Care. Holly starts us off with wee Marcus Fiesel before Mel goes into the story of Leiland James Corkhill. Shoutout to Emma Jo for the suggestion! In this episode you will hear about old news updates that are now also probably old news, Mel learns that there is fruit that doesn’t come out of tins, a serious discussion on Adoption takes place as well as a good old fashioned ranty rant from Mel. Produ...
Apr 07, 2023•34 min•Season 5Ep. 43
In Which Murderer’s Episode 42 Season 5 the girls cover super awful cases of people Murdered by Gas. Mel starts us off with war criminal Joseph Mengele before Holly goes into the real time case of Genivaldo de Jesus Santo. Shoutout to Ricky who probably doesn’t listen to the podcast, for the suggestion. In this episode you will witness a very rare professional start, Holly has some door dramas then her car is used for stranger napping, Mel shares her booze fueled mishaps and you all get the educ...
Mar 31, 2023•37 min•Season 5Ep. 42
In Which Murderer’s Episode 41 Season 5 the girls cover chilling cases of Children Who Murder. Holly starts us off with the shocking case of Alyssa Bustamonte before Mel goes into the unbelievable murder by Amarjeet Sada. Shoutout to Saraid for the suggestion! Blink twice if you are in danger. In this episode you will go around the world with a tour of German foods (that actually aren’t German) and apologies to India…again. Mel gets pretty mad at numbers, you will get education you didn’t ask fo...
Mar 24, 2023•37 min•Season 5Ep. 41
In Which Murderer’s Episode 40 Season 5 the girls cover Murders Solved with DNA. Mel starts us off with the very sad case of Anna Palmer before Holly goes into the murder by Terrence Miller. Shoutout to Michelle for the suggestion! In this episode there are more challenges to recording such as Mels face and Holly’s knees, you will hear all about Holly’s adorable new animals, TV Recommendations are made whether you want them or not, there is some weird breath holding followed by medical advice on...
Mar 17, 2023•27 min•Season 5Ep. 40
In Which Murderer’s Episode 39 Season 5 the girls cover Grifter Murders. What is a Grifter Murder you ask? You’ll have to listen. Holly starts us off with the retelling of the case of Sante Kimes before Mel goes into the murder by Christian Gerhartsteiter. Shoutout to Natalie for the suggestion! In this episode Mel has to be physically removed from her phone, Holly is murdered by a chair which results in the girls using their one brain cell to come up with their own topic idea, Which Murderer be...
Mar 10, 2023•36 min•Season 5Ep. 39
In Which Murderer’s Episode 38 Season 5 the girls cover Nurses Who Murder. Mel starts us off with the incredibly tragic case of Beverly Allitt before Holly goes into the horrible murders by Niels Högel. Shoutout to Kirsty for the suggestion! In this episode Mel is eating candy as per usual, Holly reveals her false teeth plan, you’ll learn more about how Holly’s body defies life and Mel brings out her character ‘Arm Flailer’. Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who has of...
Mar 03, 2023•35 min•Season 5Ep. 38
In Which Murderer’s Episode 37 Season 5 the girls cover Musical Murders. Holly starts us off with the surprising story of Marvin Gaye Jr. before Mel goes into the famous death of Beatle John Lennon. Shoutout to Caitlin for the suggestion! In this episode Holly makes third party baby demands, the podcast gets some lovely feedback from a victim’s daughter, Mel has on purpose chosen a case with a lot of work involved and you will be judged hard if you’ve never been to Liverpool apparently. Producti...
Feb 24, 2023•41 min•Season 5Ep. 37
In Which Murderer’s Episode 36 Season 5 the girls cover Cooking Murders. Mel starts us off with the unbelievably horrific and sad case of Lamora Williams before Holly goes into the tragic death of Elivelton Dias. Shoutout to Saraid for the really interesting suggestion! And also to Natalie for more excellent memes. You are experiencing the 4th recording in a row this episode so buckle up, there are some revisited kitchen wars, a theme may or may not have been completely misinterpreted by Mel, Ho...
Feb 17, 2023•28 min•Season 5Ep. 36
In Which Murderer’s Episode 35 Season 5 the girls cover people who were Murdered on a Plane. Holly starts us off with the grand-daddy of plane murderers Earnest P. Pletch before Mel goes into the Canadian murderer Albert Guay . Shoutout to Cheryl for the great suggestion! Who knew we could be even more afraid of air travel. Mel starts off with some unexpected professionalism followed by a current affairs update on a very hateable person who got caught via pizza - dumb prison story dude, Holly’s ...
Feb 10, 2023•32 min•Season 5Ep. 35
In Which Murderer’s Episode 34 Season 5 the girls cover the important topic of Prejudice Murders. Mel starts us off with the tragic and historically important story of Emmett Till before Holly goes into the ongoing case of the Tree of Life Synagogue shooting. Shoutout to NEW MUMMY Caitlin for the great suggestion! And congrats on your beautiful baby boy. Also shoutouts to Mark and Emma Jo - thanks so much for the feedback and suggestions. In this episode you will get your long awaited squirrel a...
Feb 03, 2023•35 min
