In Season 3 Episode 22 the Which Murderer Team are dealing with a bit of an unexpected situation so are revisiting some older episodes for the next few weeks. This week we went for Interesting Body Disposals from Season 2 Episode 17 Your intro from Holly includes: Bitterness. Complaints. Whining. A bad accent. In Episode 17 Season 2, Gemma and Holly cover murderers with 'Interesting Body Disposals'. Gemma covers the strange tale of Jim Smith who way back in oldie times ended up in an aquarium si...
Oct 23, 2020•29 min
In Season 3 Episode 21 the Which Murderer Team are dealing with a bit of an unexpected situation so are revisiting some older episodes for the next few weeks. This week we went for Murderers on TV from Season 1 Episode 46 Your intro from Holly includes: Bitterness. Complaints. Whining. A bad accent. In **Episode 46** Gemma and Holly cover murderers who have been on the silver screen, but not for their crimes. Gemma speaks about the worst gameshow prize ever, Rodney Alcala and Holly talks about a...
Oct 16, 2020•30 min
In Season 3 Episode 20 the Which Murderer Team are dealing with a bit of an unexpected situation so are revisiting some older episodes for the next few weeks. First up its Murders at Sea from Season 1. Two REALLY good cases. Your intro from Holly includes: Bitterness. Complaints. Whining. A bad accent. The term '100%' 7 too many times. As well as… Shoutouts for Crime Monthly Magazine, Facebook Group Members Carrie and Kristy, two great reviews from Saza and Stephen and a really entertaining emai...
Oct 09, 2020•32 min
In Season 3 Episode 19 – Murder Solved Through Exhumation – Holly speaks about Donnie Rudd, then James Otto Earhart Shoutouts for Transcripted Podcasts, Storyglass Media and Generation Why Podcast In this episode Holly and Gemma criticize three countries, Holly hates ‘Intro Holly’ and it’s revealed the girls might have been drunk during that clip, it’s the days of never-ending rain, the girls emphasize that you shouldn’t dick name your twins, and Holly has bludgeoning on the mind. Production, re...
Oct 02, 2020•34 min
In Season 3 Episode 18 – Mean Girl Murders – Gemma covers the Canadian case of Reena Virk from Holly’s Island and Holly goes on to speak about Skylar Neese. Shoutouts to Canadian Dani for the suggested theme and to our Facebook fan who we aren’t sure meant to pop up but we see you! In this episode Holly is a cookie feeder….some may say monster, the girls find out a superfan likes war and Gemma’s phobia makes a late appearance. Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig...
Sep 25, 2020•27 min
In Season 3 Episode 17 – Bollywood Murders – Holly covers the horrific murder of Meenakshi Thapa and Gemma goes through the story of Brijmohan Sadanah. Shoutouts to our good friend Oliver (you cute little binger you…), Canadian Facebooker Graham and Canadian Dani who likes a little sneeze. In this episode everyone is distracted by the scheduled Pub lunch about to happen, the girls struggle very hard with all the names…and places….and basically everything in this episode, there is some serious de...
Sep 18, 2020•24 min
In Season 3 Episode 16 – Thrill Killers – Gemma covers the brutal murderers Christopher Jones and James Roughan from Australia and Holly talks through the horrific Toolbox Killers case. WARNING: This is a particularly disturbing episode with extreme graphic violence. Listener discretion is advised. Shoutouts to Superfan Catriona, a fabulous recommender and a lovely reviewer. In this episode Gemma is suffering a little with a hangover and Holly is overmassaged. The postman also stops by mid-recor...
Sep 11, 2020•32 min
In Season 3 Episode 15 –Gold Diggers Who Murder – Holly starts us off with the story of a pretty poor excuse of a human named Desmond Campbell. Then Gemma goes on to tell us all about Vicky Efandis who had a George fixation. This episode launches rather aggressively before Holly goes on to declare war on Scottish insects. They are the worst. Both girls cheat a little on research and end up using the same source….and Gemma tries to charge people with mothers. Which might in fact be a very effecti...
Sep 04, 2020•28 min
In Season 3 Episode 14 –1970’s Murder – Gemma covers ‘Bad Man’ Randy Kraft while Holly tells you all about Robert John Maudsley who we might like a little? Shoutouts for some lovely iTunes reviewers including ‘Canadian Danni and Super Husband Clive’ In this episode Gemma goes and ruins Holly’s favourite pasta, Holly gives some amazing Serial Killer pro tips, three entire adults fail to math, we conclude that 12 kids is too many kids and there are no pet budgies allowed in prison. Production, rec...
Aug 28, 2020•37 min
In Season 3 Episode 13 – Framing Others for Murder – Holly tells the story of Rod Covlin who just so happens to be the king of assholes. Gemma then covers the story of Floyd Bledsoe who possibly has the worst family ever. In this episode Holly is very excited and scares her team, the English language continues to die via this podcast, names don’t get any easier and the US justice system takes a pretty big telling off. Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig who has ...
Aug 21, 2020•28 min
In Season 3 Episode 12 –Doctors who Murder – Gemma takes on the bizarre story of Walter Freeman who was most definitely a fan of scrambled eggs, while Holly attempts to share the store of Marcell Petiot. Shoutouts to @podchaser and @behindthebastards In this episode the girls are finally reunited for recording and Holly is once again being produced by Producer Craig in the flesh. Gemma faces a dilemma when Holly tries to shoulder in on date night, Producer Craig is getting hard side eye and goin...
Aug 14, 2020•33 min
In Season 3 Episode 11 – Solved Their Own Murders – Holly tells the story of Grace May Brown who helped convict her killer after her death before Gemma goes on to tell the sad story of Simon Ng who blogged his murderer into a conviction. Shoutout to Natalie in Canada – thanks for recommending us! And thoughts go out to Holly’s Mom who is going through a hard time. In this episode we learn that Producer Craig has planted clues already to solve his own murder via Alexa, the girls figure out a numb...
Aug 07, 2020•29 min
In Season 3 Episode 10 – Murdered by Police, Gemma covers the tragic and horrifying death of Elliot Williams who died in custody after prolonged suffering. Holly then goes over the story of murderer Kevin Gregson in Canada. Shoutouts for some lovely fans who left five star reviews and a plug for the gorgeous new boutique shop @etonmessboutique The girls start out with a therapy session surrounding Holly’s conception….thanks mom….there are more English language struggles, Holly can sense the judg...
Jul 31, 2020•38 min
In Season 3 Episode 9 – Homophobic Murder, Holly tells the story of Colin Ireland who was known as the ‘Gay Slayer’ and Gemma goes over the murders surrounding the Bondi Beach Attacks. In this episode Holly longs to be touched and stalks her nail people, Gemma broadcasts her lunch around the UK (possibly) and there are yet more math arguments. Math continues to be the source of all evils. Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig who was rather fickle with his favouri...
Jul 24, 2020•32 min
In Season 3 Episode 8 – Jealousy and Murder, Gemma covers the tale of Melanie Smith – not to be confused with SuperFan Mel…. although it was very exciting times for Holly briefly. Holly then goes on to break Gemma’s heart and mind with the horrific tale of murderer Gertrude Baniszewski. Shoutout to a lovely Facebook follower who is well on the way to SuperFan status and to True Crime Zone who added us to a fabulous list. Holly love list. https://www.truecrimezone.com/media/true-crime-podcasts/ H...
Jul 17, 2020•31 min
In Season 3 Episode 7 – Edinburgh Unsolved Murders, Holly kicks off the local tales of Murder with the sad story of the lovely Anne Ballantine. Gemma then goes on to cover the murder of Helen Kane – with some pretty big potential serial killer links. Shoutout to a lovely Facebook follower who gave some feedback on our ‘Murders that Shocked the World’ episode – she spells her name very Irishy. There are opposite weather conditions in Edinburgh as per usual, math makes another unwelcome appearance...
Jul 10, 2020•27 min
In Season 3 Episode 6 – Serial Killers Released Early from Prison – Gemma starts with the Lainz Angels of Death which Holly correctly predicted she would (because nurses) and then Holly tells the tale of Charlene Gallego who did not find the third time lucky in the husband category of life. Shoutouts to lovely listeners who leave excellent reviews on iTunes (you give us life right now) and longtime listener Fleda who is our Canadian True Crime keeper straighter who sent us a couple messages whic...
Jul 03, 2020•29 min
In Season 3 Episode 5 – Vampire Murderers are covered by the girls after Gemma finds her perfect case. Holly starts off with James Riva who lived in a state Holly refuses to spell. Gemma then goes on to tell the tale of Peter Kurten who was a bad bad man. Shoutouts to Holly’s Mother who did not give her murder information and Holly might have yelled at her a little….and a Facebook Fan shout-out who lifted our spirits. Holly is having a very bad apocalypse but has been given hope with her beans, ...
Jun 26, 2020•35 min
In Season 3 Episode 4 – Gemma and Holly cover ‘Murders that Shocked the World’. Gemma starts things off with the really sad story of James Bulger which was an unbelievable tragedy. Holly then rounds off the sadness with the murder of JonBenet Ramsey. Holly has a nervous breakdown at being late but firmly blames someone else all the way, there are sirens and mild panic, Gemma wins a contest while pushing her luck on her Tesco delivery and Cleo the cat runs to stop whatever drama is going on outsi...
Jun 19, 2020•45 min
In Season 3 Episode 3 – Holly and Gemma cover Sexually Motivated Murderers. Holly starts off with David Williams and his Canadian based murders. Gemma then goes over the story of Christopher Wilder…. which Holly almost covered as well. Despite being told clearly in writing that Gemma was covering it. Shoutouts for Superfan Natalie who left a lovely review and the quarantine episode from Fair City Podcast has dropped so Holly orders everyone to listen. https://www.fcpod.net/ Gemma is at war with ...
Jun 12, 2020•35 min
In Season 3 Episode 2 – Gemma and Holly talk about people who Murder in Small Towns. Gemma starts things off with some informative information that Holly screws up before Gemma covers the story of William Immon. Holly then takes things super close to home on a street where she spent some time as a child….and the murder of Vesna Soos. Shout out to friend-fan Diane who was not bullied into listening but was tortured with a photo of Holly. Holly rolls out of a trash heap called home improvements an...
Jun 05, 2020•30 min
Welcome to Season 3! In the Season 3 premiere - Episode 1 - Holly and Gemma talk about people who wanted their parents dead…not to be confused with Patricide…which is not to be confused with Pesticide. It’s a bit of a rabbit hole. Holly kicks things off with the story of Patricia (Patty) Columbo who had worse taste in men than Holly. Which is saying a lot. Then Gemma heads over to Canada to talk about Jennifer Pan who had super pushy parents up until the point she had them assassinated. Gemma co...
May 29, 2020•36 min
In Episode 52, Season 2, Gemma and Holly celebrate the end of their second season and the beginning of Season 3 and their 2 year anniversary, which they then realise are all essentially the same thing. Gemma covers Russian serial killer Alexander Pichushkin, who loved a game of chess and pushing people. Holly covers earthquake preventer Herbert Mullin, who somehow couldn’t convince people of his legitimate mental illness. The girls struggle with time zones this week, there is an illegal block pa...
May 22, 2020•37 min
In the Season 2 penultimate Episode - 51 - Holly and Gemma talk about Deathbed Murder Confessions from their lonely & ‘not coping well’ corners of the city. First Holly goes over the murder case of Christine Kett before Gemma launches into the horrific murder of Joan Harrison in 1975. In this episode Gemma struggles to make words escape her brain, Holly revisits her hatred for time travel when discussing a collaboration with the Fair City Podcast and a line is crossed with some definite advi...
May 15, 2020•31 min
In Episode 50 Season 2 Gemma and Holly take another two-parter to cover Televised Trials. In Part One Gemma goes over the worst brother duo in the Menendez case and in Part Two Holly takes a dive into the cannibalistic world of Jeffrey Dahmer. Both cases very famously had televised trials. In this episode we learn how Holly is now a vegetable farmer, Gemma is helping to support her local community during the pandemic by ordering baked goods. Holly also decides she wants her own damn trial, Gemma...
May 08, 2020•36 min
In Episode 50 Season 2 Gemma and Holly take another two-parter to cover Televised Trials. In Part One Gemma goes over the worst brother duo in the Menendez case and in Part Two Holly takes a dive into the cannibalistic world of Jeffrey Dahmer. Both cases very famously had televised trials. In this episode we learn how Holly is now a vegetable farmer, Gemma is helping to support her local community during the pandemic by ordering baked goods. Holly also decides she wants her own damn trial, Gemma...
May 08, 2020•24 min
In Episode 49 Season 2 Holly and Gemma are looking for some ideas to keep Holly from becoming a very well researched murderer….and are also covering Murderers who had Early Warning Signs. Holly covers the story of Carroll Edward Cole who came from a family of androgynous namers. Gemma then goes into the case of David Berkowitz who had some interesting ‘head’ friends. There is a shout-out for Superfan Mel, some updates on how the girls have been affected by the pandemic (hint you should mail Holl...
May 01, 2020•29 min
In Episode 48 Season 2 – OUR 100TH EPISODE OVERALL – Gemma and Holly are recording far away from each other due to the dumbest virus ever but are super excited to be covering their personal choices for WORST MURDERS FROM SEASON ONE. Gemma heads back to Episode 14, Season 1 (Matricide) for clips from the story of Ed Kemper. Then Holly springs back to Episode 31, Season 1 (Cannibals) to discuss Armin Meiwes. There are some fan shout-outs to some wonderful people, time travel for one birthday girl,...
Apr 24, 2020•53 min
In Episode 47 Season 2, Holly and Gemma (still pre-lockdown) cover the intriguing topic of Secrets and Murder. Holly talks through fellow Canadian Brett Ryan (aka the ‘Crossbow Killer’) who was a complicated mix of good guy and murderer. Gemma then covers Mark Hacking who did the unimaginable to his closest connection. Holly struggles to describe this episode’s topic then yells at Gemma, Gemma is obsessed with a series about death and lying – Producer Craig has concerns, the girls point out the ...
Apr 17, 2020•29 min
In Episode 46 Season 2, Gemma and Holly still have no idea life is about to get much more complicated with a virus and are cheerfully recording face to face to cover 1920's Murders. Gemma starts off with the messed up story of Gordon Stewart Northcott - who unfortunately was Canadian. Holly then chats through the spooky Hex House Murder which was a bit awkward. In this episode Producer Craig thinks the 1920's were good years. He is wrong. There is a lot of 'perking' going on this episode, naming...
Apr 10, 2020•24 min
