Thanks for the reply, I was hoping to join the roundtable. So I'll be here. The workbench tonight, that's at 8 o'clock local and the roundtable is at 8 on Thursday so we'll look forward to having you join us to roundtable. This is WA3VEA. that gentleman, Ron, was at Field Day. I think he's retired from Bell Labs. if that's the case, sir, great to hear you on my repeater. W3GMS. Yes, Joe, you're right. I met you guys on Sunday morning. It was a fun time. Thank you.
Okay, I won't get in the way of the net, but this is the workbench that we're talking about. It's great to hear you, and we'll talk later. 73, W3GMS, clear. The workbench. I'm located in Westchester, Pennsylvania. We meet every Monday at 8 p.m. on the W3GMS Parkesburg repeater.
Frequency is 146.985 with a negative 600 kilohertz offset, and the PL tone is 100 hertz. For those who use the Tone Squelch while receiving, the repeater transmits a squelch tone of 94.8, which comes especially handy if you have a rig that handles that when there are band openings. Newcomers are very welcome. We encourage all stations to check in, especially the station that just checked in. A warm welcome to you here on 985 and to the workbench. Take look
at the repeater website located at www.w3gmsrepeater.com. It has lots of information including technical articles, of 985 users in action, and repeater etiquette and history. Please be aware that on occasion the repeater experiences intermod interference. Now is a good time to switch to maximum power or to be prepared to check in digitally through EchoLink or All-Star. We want to hear you. To be able to use EchoLink or All-Star on 985, you do need to register
with us. Directions for doing so can be found On the website, again, that's w3gmsrepeater.com. Also, when Intermod is present before starting any transmission, please give a short call out to the net control, happens to be me, am I getting in OK? Once the host confirms that, then you can share your longer comments. Here on the workbench, we focus on answering general questions of radio theory and operations. Additionally, we invite each station to briefly comment on
your amateur radio activity in the past week. When checking in, please indicate if you have a question for the workbench. If you don't have a question, please still check in. After all stations have checked in, we will first share what we've done this past week in amateur radio using a roundtable format. Please write down the call to the station that checks in right after you. When you have finished your comments, turn the mic over to that station.
Once we have made our comments, we will start the question and answer portion of the workbench operating as a directed net. I will call on the station that indicated having a question then for stations who wish to respond to that question. Wait to be recognized by net control before beginning a transmission. Also, this is the point where you, at the first part of this net, if you're new to this, This is where you just say you have a question, don't
post a question. We will call for the actual question in the second part of the work batch. At times, help for two stations to pass the mic back and forth to help clarify the situation to pass information. Feel free to do that as needed. Pass the mic back to net control. Also, it's a good rule to follow all the time. Don't be too quick to talk. Pause a couple seconds before hitting the press the talk switch. This is good repeater etiquette and the pauses
are especially helpful for those on all star and echo lengths. When you do click the PTT button, wait a second or two before starting to talk. You don't want to miss what you have to say. It takes a moment for the repeater to process your PL tone. Also, the repeater has a three-minute timer. If you talk more than three minutes without letting up on your mic button, the repeater completely shuts down until you release your PTT switch. So every
two to three minutes, release the mic button just for a moment, just like this. and then you can continue. You don't need to let the repeater carrier drop. Before we begin, I want to say thanks to all of our Workbench hosts. They're the ones that make this happen. If you may be interested in hosting a Workbench, please contact Jim AF3Z or any one of us and we'll help you get started. Lastly, please join us this Thursday at 8 p.m. for the 985 roundtable.
At this time we're going to start the check-in process. Remember to indicate if you have a question for the group. So, digital stations, digital stations only, those using EchoLink or All Star. It's time for you to check in and I will leave long pauses. So hopefully you don't need to check the O-bit column. I will be back. But I leave long pauses to make it easier for those, especially on EchoLink, to check in. Digital stations only. Those using
EchoLink are all-star. This is WA3VE and you're listening to the 985 workbench. Please check in now. Digital only. I one comment quickly, Ron. Right ahead. Did you start the net when I was talking to our new guest? At 8 o'clock in about 6 seconds. to make a final transmission to him and when I signed, you were talking. I that was an accident. I didn't hear anything. I did not hear anything. That's why I started the net. I figured something
like that happened. Not an issue. you must not have heard me because I knew you would not do it. But especially as the owner of the repeater, if I'm talking to somebody at eight o'clock, then that can start at eight o'clock plus 15 seconds. Now there must have been a technical defuglity which happens. Have fun, take care, and thank you very, very much for running the workbench tonight. Whiskey 8, Charlie Romeo Whiskey, CR, no question. I have a question.
Alpha Charlie 2 Echo Golf, no question. Alpha Alpha 3, Lima Hotel, no question, we just got a bad thunderstorm. Oh, Keelan Victor 3, Julia Gulf Bravo. question. So far we have WHCRW, KC3HQZ, with a question. We have Alpha Charlie 2 Echo Golf, Alpha Alpha 3 Lima Hotel, and we have KV3JGB. Any other digital question, any other digital check-ins, please call now. KC3SQI with a question. KC3WWC with a question. any additional digital check-ins. This is WA3VE.
go to RF check-ins now. is WA3VE and this is the 985 workbench. Please call out. 23TYX NA-3CW, no question. KC30K, no question. Kilo Delta 3, Echo Mike Sierra, no question. Alpha Foxtrot 3 Zulu, no question. Jeez, nope. KD3AIS with a question. Okay, any additional check-ins before we run down the list and get started? This is WA3 VEE. a roundtable session in a moment. This is the list that I have here. remember who follows
you in this list and turn it over to them. WHCRW, KC3HQZ with a question, AC2EQ, AA3LH, KV3JGB, KC3SQI, KC3WWC, and Wayne and John both have questions. KC3TYX, NA3CW, KC3OOK, KD3EMS, AF3Z, W3KZG, and finally KD3AIS with a question. One last call for check-ins before we get started. This is WA3VEE. Please call now. Okay, take one minute and explain what we did in the last, each of us explain what we did in the last week in amateur radio and CR you can kick us off. WHCRW, WA3VE.
Thanks Ron, and thanks for taking the chair. And you got a long list, so I'm going to make it quick. 985 activities, but the highlight was field day weekend. And the highlight of the highlight was Gene's Scrapple and Egg Sandwich. Speaking of Gene, KC3HQZ, pick it up. WHCRW. Go ahead. Thanks, CRW. KCGH, she said. Yeah, that was kind of a highlight. I cooked for everybody and they all enjoyed it. And I was glad. And that's why I cook. OK. No question.
OK. But we did have a good weekend. We really enjoyed ourselves. I'm not sure who was next. Echo, Echo Go. This is Alpha Charlie 2 Echo Golf. Name here is Eric. And my activity this week was introducing myself to the group and getting out the field day. I want to thank everyone there for their hospitality and introducing me to all the things the repeater group does. I'm hoping to get on the air soon. And doing it the hard way. I'm trying to. build my own stuff rather
than buy it but I'll still be around as long as there's an echo link. That's all for now. I'll pass the baton to AA3L8. Yeah. Good evening everybody. This is AAH308. Yeah. Highlights. Field Day. Man, I like field days. I went out there and tried making some contacts Sunday afternoon and I got dupes. Almost all of them were dupes. I made one official legal contact. And I was not a dude, but I have fun. It's fun running field day. I just, I just enjoy that. And we have a thunder, heavy
thunderstorm going on. got bloomers. I thank the Lord and I thank you for having echo links so we can still talk. Other that we would not be on the repeater tonight because she's not banging away outside. Uh, that's all I have. We have a lot of questions. I'm going to let it go at that. Okay. Yeah. Who did I write down here, I'm not sure. If you ever follow me, go ahead. A308. Thank you, Leon KV3, JGB, Mountain Valley. Like everybody said, got a lot of questions and
a lot of people, so I'll keep it brief. 95 repeater activity and of course field day. Unfortunately, some personal things prevented me from attending and actually even operating at field day. But sounds like it didn't even that much. We had a great field day and I was able to make it up. Brought Chester County Commissioner, Eric Grow up there. He was really excited to listen to a lot of people talk, including Ron, talk about all the emergency benefits of amateur
radio. So that is it for me and I'll hand it over to KC3SQI, KB3JGB. uh... thank you very much this case c three s q i uh... the uh... thirty-meter new antenna mast about ready to go and about ready to set up gotta put the uh... crossmember on it and uh... settled up right but it is uh... put together and ready to go as soon as the weather breaks a little bit so that I can work out there without sweating to death. So with that, I'll turn it over to KC3WWC. This is KC3SQI.
KC3WWC, can you tell me if I'm getting in on You are, John. Just go ahead. was John in Lannister. For my past couple weeks I was traveling, I was in California, so I got to activate a park twice. One day I hiked my gear in a mile and half on my back and then the next day I was out there I biked a couple miles in and up a mountain so I wasn't down in the... field day so I kept it QRP, emergency power on the patio here at home so my 50 contacts
turned into 650. Over to Vic, KC3TYX, this is KC3WWC. Thank you, John. KC3WWC. This is KC3TYX, Nick. I'll keep it pretty short. Got a long list here. Ended up doing field day with the State Line Radio Club down in Rising Sun, Maryland this year. And it was pretty good time. Weather wasn't as bad as we thought it might be, so I was happy with it. I didn't say earlier, but I have no question. And I will now pass it on to... NA3CW from KC3TYX.
We're making it in OK and A3CW. Copy, Chuck, go ahead. Very good. Standing here with my HT. We've got a thunder boomy going on outside. So I disconnected everything and shut all the equipment off. So since I am within HT distance of the repeater, I got that luxury. I'll keep it short because of the lifts. Ham radio this week was field day, field day prep, field day operations, and field day cleanup. And of course, 985 operations and the PMAM net on Sunday.
So, let's see, that would be next to Bill, KC30, okay, this is NA3CW. in the air. Tonight I prompt, I hosted a... Both have. computer was down, but we were able to get, I guess, five or six people on the 985 Simplex. KC3EMS. KC3OK. Good evening everybody. Bill, great to meet you on Saturday. So yeah, the highlight will definitely be, will definitely be field day for myself. With only being a ham for a couple of months, that was my first field day. And what an experience. I cannot
say enough about AO3Z Jim. I got the chance to sit down next to him for a good, probably 20 minutes to half an hour and just learn so, much. Definitely also from Chuck, N-E-3-C-W, doing the go to station. What an experience that was. It definitely makes me want to get my general sooner than later. it was my first contact on HF and I got a good seven or eight contacts on Saturday. So once again, thanks everybody, even the people that are here tonight,
as well as... What was the other gentleman's name? K3YVIJack was also extremely helpful as well. yeah, this definitely boosted my urge to get my general license and move on. So I believe I'm actually going to pass it back over to AVZ3... AF3Z. Okay, very good Chris. Yeah, it good to get to talk with you as well. And yeah, that was fun. Field day was good. A little warmer than I'd like, but it really wasn't too oppressive
this year. And got some good CW in, worked with Luke for a while there, logging and sending or whatever. forget who was doing what when, but we had a good time. I did a good pratfall and survived it quite well. I remember very carefully setting up, putting the wires and trying to get them neat. We had cones up so people wouldn't trip over them. So who but me would come walking by eating some food and totally forget about it and fall flat on my
face almost. But I really survived it quite well, thanks to Tom. I'm not sure on that. Anyway, Tom was my doctor and helped patch me up, but I'm really doing quite well. So anyway, yeah, thanks to everybody and all the people who put a lot of work into getting ready for that. Good time. So after me comes Scott. Good to see you and Dylan both over the weekend too. W3KZG, AF3Z. F3Z, this is W3KZG. Am I getting into the repeater room? Beautifully, Scott. Go right ahead.
This week in radio. My first. He had done field day up there before and a few times. and this was the first one. actually I think everything went pretty smooth. Cheers. a few more little things here and there that would make it a little easier. And that is all I have for now. W3K03AIS, this is W3KZJ. W3KZG, is KD3AIS, Tim and Malvern. In the last week, I unfortunately missed field day, but when I got home, I was able to listen to the 20 meter band. Thank you all.
that, I will send it back to Ron, WA-3. Good Tim, excellent, all the way around. So before we get started with the question section, let me ask if there are other additional check-ins, digital or RF? This is the 985 workbench and this is WA3VE. Additional check-ins, any mood, please call now. 3SC1. 3QP, no question. Okay, last call for check-ins before we go to Luke and Tim for their comments on what they did in Ham Radio for the last weekend. Last call for check-ins. This is WA3VE.
W3MFB? No question. Okay, very good. Luke, it's the last check-ins here, KC3SKY, W3QP, W3MFB. So Luke, one minute on what you did in ham radio in the last week. This is WA3VEE and this is the 985 workbench. Thanks for hosting. I was working with George and... and I need a lot of... for field day. internet logging system which Like we had the coax all set up. thought, well, of course I was in there to set up Friday. So because I was at camp, was, I didn't know what happened then,
I thought everything went pretty smoothly, so... Anyways... just been working on my CW and I plan to operate the 13 colonies event. I think at 8 a.m. hopefully I can... on one band. hope to make at least half because more people have told me work them early in the morning instead of late in the afternoon because that's when all the pilots are. So anyways, over to Tim. W3QP. This is KC3SKY.
C3 SCY this is W3 QP also field day for my activity for this past week I've been busy with stuff around the house so not too many projects but I guess one thing I wanted to mention is there is a special event station K3H that's going to happen up at the Eastern Pennsylvania Homestead Festival which is up in Oh, hang on a second, Kutztown. So in Kutztown this coming weekend, Thursday through Sunday, they're looking for operators to come
up and do two-hour shifts. Joe sent an email out about it, but if you're not on the email list, I'm good on QRZ. Drop me a note and I can get you the information. That is all for me. Over to W3MFP, think it was. This is W3QP.
everybody on the workbench 95 workbench this is whiskey three mike fox bravo um torndale mike uh... had part of field day uh... spent a few hours on saturday and a few hours on sunday operating bronze radio the ft-nine ninety one alpha that was for six meter and two meters sideband got a kick uh... cranking up that tower or that math i should say uh... Sunday morning, I was sitting at home and noticed there was an opening, a band opening on the PHF propagation,
the packet propagation. We were in the yellow and the orange and red. And I was like, Oh God, I said, I gotta get up there. I bet you that station's still locked down from when we shut it down, when we heard the lightning and all on Saturday evening, Saturday night. So I got that going up in the morning. So made a few contacts here and there, two meter sideband and six meters. Six meter was the kicker. Had a few on too. Enjoyed talking to each operator.
Actually made the contact, hit enter, logged them in and then said hello and how are conditions and got reports from people. Some people were giving me, giving me bearings. uh... from my
location to try to look for a few people uh... and actually work was able to uh... to make some more contacts by that information so it's great to be friendly and uh... and help each other out for sure so had a great time on six uh... it was more fun and and then just be given your uh... your information your classes section and you're gone you know so we had some fun along with making some contacts for the log book. No question tonight, so I will
pass it over to Ron so we can get this shindig started. WA3VEW3MFB on EchoStink. First of I want to thank all those who participated in Field Day this weekend. A lot of work, but a great team effort. And my understanding is we had 1,400 contacts at least. So, or thereabouts, plus or minus. And if anyone has any videos or pictures, please, if you like,
to have those posted on SmugMug like I usually do, please send them over to me. If there are many... I have Google Drive, I have Dropbox, so I can take large, large, large files for sure. So almost never get pictures anymore over email, definitely. So Google Drive or Dropbox will work wonderfully. OK, now we'll begin the roundtable session. And we'll start with the questions and answers. And I'll go over who has questions here in a second. We
encourage all stations to make comments, observations, and share experiences. Don't assume that your level of experience and knowledge isn't enough. We can all learn from each other and contribute to our discussions. So feel free to pick up the mic and have some fun and share your experiences. So right now I've got Gene, KC3HQZ, with a question. I've got KC3SQI with a question. KC3WWCJohn. And I have Tim, KD3AIS, with a question. Is there anyone on, who has checked
in, who I missed, who has a question? Go ahead. You're first. KC3HQZWA3VEE. What's your question? Okay K23HQZ, thanks Ron. My question is why does a PODA station have a different call sign than the rest of the field day activities? Yeah, field day activities I guess I want to Okay, why does the Pota station have a different call sign than the field day activity? Did I get the question correct?
Yes, just wondered. Those who want to respond to Gene's question, this is WA3VEE, please call now. KC3WWC. KC3WWCWA3VE rolled in here so I switched back to digital. I did see a couple POTA stations while I was operating. was on digital, I was doing FT8 because I just had a few hours. I assume they just didn't want to participate. I know there was some discussion. People were like, oh, the bands are going to be useless because of field day. The field day exchanges were different.
You were doing the classes and counts and your section. that's not the POTA exchange. So maybe they just wanted to stick to POTA and ignore field day. That's my guess. Back to you, KC3, WWC. Additional comments for Gene, this is WA3VE, please call now. AF3Z here, Click twice here. Question, I guess. Were we talking about the GODA station? Why a GODA was W3GTS and the others were W3R? I'm not sure, but I think that maybe was the
question, AF3Z. Yeah, that's a good point there, Jim. Gene, KC3HQZ, WA3VE, did you mean the GODA station? Go ahead. The G word. The G word. That's a different question. Okay, great. So why does our go to station have a different call sign than the Whiskey 3 Romeo? People want to respond to that. Go ahead. AF3Z. Go Jim, thanks for pointing that out. I didn't catch that at all at first for sure. Jim, AF3Z, WA3VEA.
All right, very good. And I don't have the answer, but I'll tell you my supposition, my guess or whatever. The go to station is very much to encourage new hams and not yet hams, people who may get licenses eventually, to get on the air. And it's meant to be one of the major efforts of field day in a way. So I assume it's kept kind of separate so that it's Well, and the contacts made on the GoTo station also count more. I think it's like five points rather
than one or two for SideBanner CW. So anyway, I think it's to encourage groups to have a GoTo station and really emphasize that. And so by keeping it a separate call sign or something, it doesn't add in to how many stations we say we have operating. So it's kind of a bonus station. for our field day effort and it's a bonus station for getting the word out and
getting people a little experience on ham radio. So that's the way I understand it. I don't know if there's any other big reason for a different call sign but I've been wrong at least once or twice. Back to you Ron, AF3Z. Very good. Any additional comments on why GODA has a different call sign than the rest of field day? W3MFB. So a little muffled, don't know what's going on there, but you're copyable. So go ahead, this is WA3VE.
Sorry about that, Ron. I will try to annunciate W3MFB here. I'm thinking, like Jim said as well, having a different call sign to be able to track those Go-Tas, Go-Tas contacts. As Jim said, they're going to be having more points so you can tally up all the Go-Tas stations and contacts that you have. Keeping it separate from Whiskey 3 Romeo is a good
point. because then you will have the operators initials in underneath the call sign. So you'll be able to track also how many non-licensed or just newly licensed operators were at the go to station. So I believe it's good for metrics as well, keeping track of visitors and newly licensed to get on the air and experience and have fun. So I think that's another good reason to have the other calls on as well. back to you Ron, hopefully I came through okay on the
echo link. WA3VEE in the group, W3MFB. That's what it is. Yeah, very good, Mike. Excellent. Any additional comments for Jean before I turn it back to her? This is WA3VE and this is the 985 workbench. WC3HQZ, WA3VE, do we answer the question? Yes, you did answer my question. Thanks so much. think I understand now. It's more the good.
It's more of a training session and the regular call sign is for the experienced guys and the ones that are working to get point and the good is for you to learn how to do this and get on. So I thank you very much. I understand. KK60HQZ. Good Gene, excellent. Well glad we answered your question and we should have gotten you over there to actually see what was going on but you'll see some videos and also lot of
photographs when they go to station. Okay next up is Wayne, KC3SQI, WA3VE with the workbench. Your question please. Okay, thank you Ron, WA3VEE. This is KC3SQI. My question is I'm looking at possibly going from a Windham to a hex beam and the hex beam only weighs 25 pounds. and it will have about a one foot base pole on it to work for the rotor. Now, since I'm only going up thirty feet, would a small TV antenna rotor work with that without a thrust bearing?
So, try to find out or figure out about what I would need for us to not have to have a thrust bearing. go through all of the uh... things that you have to do for that. Back to you. Very good. or remarks for Wayne. This is WA3VE. C3OK, comment. Bell KC3 OK WA3 VEE go ahead. Thanks, Ron. Well, everyone knows I'm new to this world of beams. about it but my first reaction would be that weighing 25 pounds is actually pretty good weight for an ant. really darn pretty darn cheap.
The A's over. It might do it, but I don't think it would hold up for a long time. But that's just my guess. I'll be curious to hear what WRAD W3PEKC30K. input. Additional comments for Wayne. is WA3 VEE. W3MFB 3MFB WA3 VEE, go ahead. Thank you Ron. I'd have to agree with Bill on that one. mean, know there's Wayne, I know
there's some that you can get at the local Home Depot or Lowe's RCA makes one. Now our buddy Aaron, he had one TV rotor on his homemade six meter dipole, horizontal dipole that he made. So it was just PVC and six gauge. solid-gauge wire. It was great for six meter, but it didn't weigh a lot. And he had that sitting in the concrete, like a five gallon bucket, up on the flat roof and some PVC pipe. So it really didn't do the job. I mean, it did the job for
that. It's a light thing. It only weighed like six pounds or whatever, right? Just the antenna were less. Most TV HD... antennas they're going to be from the 10 pound like the residential ones that you see around here some Yagi shape some different shapes but I would imagine they're probably like 10 12 or 10 pounds or less and I agree with Bill on the dexterity of of the consumer market rotors uh... back to run w a three p e w three msd
Very, very good. Additional comments for Wayne. Good question, Wayne, for sure. This is WA3VE, additional comments. Good entry OGF your comments please this is WA3VE Radio Shack, Wavies Radio Shack, in central road. The first one I had a four helmet course craft mounted horizontal, high wind
that destroyed it. Two mounted on it and a six-feet of coach grip horizontally on two different ones and they were flying, but the first one, it got the sprouting high wind with a four-elm and coach grip and field gyf. Good. N3OGF, remember correctly your name is John. Did I get that right? did, Ron. Me name is John. I met you last year, uh, no day. I could not make it this year because I'm medically restricted from driving. NPOGF. Well, look for the photographs. We'll be glad to share
with what we did. Excellent comments. Other comments for Wayne and the rotor question. This is WA3VE. 3KZG. W3KZGWA3VEE, go ahead please. So I looked up the specs on a Channel Master TV rotor, I'm guessing that's the version or... They don't have a weight rating for the weight of the antenna. They just tell you what the rotor's capable of doing. If you were going to do it, I don't see it not working, but I would put the antenna as close to the rotor as possible.
Don't put a big piece of pipe above the rotor to give it extra wind torque on the rotor itself. Just put the antenna right above the rotor, maybe a foot, and keep it as close to the rotor as possible. And you should be okay. I don't know how many years of service
it'll give you, but it should work. But 25 pounds, that seems pretty heavy for, I don't know what the antenna is, I haven't looked that up, but yeah, I would keep it as close to the rotor as possible to keep wind torque off of it because they have very small, I don't even think they use bearings, I think they use plastic bushings on their main shaft in those ones. consider the light duty rotor. Like I said, I don't know the antenna and the wind load it's going to put on it, but I
would keep it as close to the rotor as possible. This is W3K's edgy. Scott, thank you so much. Any additional comments for Wayne? through my two centavos or three zwoti in here. Basically, I'm looking up also, generally a question, usually put a question like this right to Google and it comes up. Channel master, and this is one model, do not know again if this is what you're considering, but says the channel master 9521A is designed for antennas weighing approximately 15 pounds with a mass
of about three feet. Again, these are consumer grade, they're light duty, so not sure it would really handle. And also consider ice. It's one thing that this time of year with thunderstorms outside and heat and ice unless it's in a glass with iced tea or whatever your preferred beverage is, we normally don't think about ice. But that adds an additional weight load. So my suggestion would be go for a light or medium duty YASU, not something to cheap
out on. So one last call for comments for Wayne. This is WA3VE. KC3SQI WA3VEE. Do we answer your question, Wayne? Good evening everybody. Yes you did and I think I will also put the thrust bearing on it and put that to the top of the inch and a half rigid conduit and that should keep it where it work for you know, go with the light duty Yates and thrust bearings. So thank you for that and I will turn it back to you Ron, KC3SQI. Clear.
Very good Wayne, excellent. John, you're next. KC3WWC with a question. This is WA3VE with the workbench. Thanks for on this KC3WWC, am I still making it in on digital? Beautiful, full copy and almost full quieting, go right ahead. getting an NFED half wave here for 80 meters. It breaks occasionally and I put it back up and I'm having a little trouble getting it to like tune on all the, or not tune, but get
resonance on all the bands, all the harmonics. It doesn't quite line up. You know, I've got a capacitor in there that I've put in and out and I was like, I saw what that does. But I end up using the tuner on the radio to touch it up and use it that way. So I'm wondering if I'm getting my... it. Is there much benefit over just a... favorite 71. same tree and use the tuner the same way. There doesn't make much difference between the NFED half
wave and the NFED random wire if I'm not quite hitting all the resonances. Back to you. Very, very good. Comments for John. This is WA3VEA. Random thoughts, NA-3CW. And A3CW, WA3VE, please proceed with randomness thought. Yeah, I assume your NFET half wave has a transformer. Yes, I've built it with a 49 to one and I think I have a 64 to one that I wound that I'm using right now. Okay, and therefore you have a coax feed from that transformer to your tuner.
Correct, coax feed, probably about 50 feet of coax and I do have a counterpoise on the antennas. kind of mismatch are you getting? It's thick, it's towards three to one in some of the places and I'll touch it up to get it down closer to two and a half or two to one. There are a couple that go up to like... Okay, I assume it's okay to go back and forth, Ron. When you had the wire going directly to your tuner, did you have any, I mean, what made you change it from that to an infant halfway?
Oh, just like to change things occasionally and experiment. I had always done random wires here, but I realized I had enough space. could just eke out the 40 meter long wire to that tree. So I gave it a shot. Okay, so I'll roll it all up here. So you have the tuner, you got 50 feet of coax running at a high SWR and you've got a transformer that may or may not be running in its efficient range. I would say if the way you had it was you were able to tune it to all the bands
you want satisfactorily without anything in the middle. I'm thinking it's probably more efficient, assuming you had no issues with RF in the wrong places and all that sort of thing. But from a loss standpoint, you're eliminating a transformer and eliminating 50 feet of coax that's running at highest WR. I'd to hear some other comments on that from others. Back to NET, NA-3CW. This is WA3VEE, please. be clear, I swapped antennas around, but I'm using the same radio with the same built-in
tuner and the same run of coax. Just at the end of the coax, I am swapping the transformer and the wire. Back to you. 3CW WA3VE. Chuck, you want to respond to that or, well let me ask you that first question first. Do you want to respond to that? Not sure I heard all of it or understood what I heard. You want to say all that again, please? Okay, yeah, thanks Chuck. This is KC3WWC. I have the same radio with the same built-in
tuner and the same run of coax for any of my antenna setups. Then the transformer and the wire changes. That's it. So the coax is involved and the counterpoise is involved in everything. Back to you. So you were tuning your random wire at the end of a piece of coax, yes? It just, I thought I could go a little bit longer, let's try something else. in here for a second. John, you're clipping the very first part of your transmission, so
again, give it a couple seconds after you press the PTT. We missed the first couple syllables there, which is said, I think was, Chuck was asking you a yes-no question, we totally missed that, so I think he asked if you're tuning, you're tuning the antenna at the end of that coax. So give it a little bit of delay before you respond. KC3WWCWA3VEA. Yep, sorry about that. I got excited, but I'm on digital. I am, yeah, it's the same radio
with tuner to coax to transformer to wire. So the tuner is always at the radio end of the coax. Back to you. So back when you were doing your random wire, you had a random wire at the end of that coax as opposed to the so-called inset halfway with the transformer. Is that correct? And again, click then talk.
Yes, the random wire was at the end of the coax and there was a 9 to 1 transformer in between instead of the 49 to 1 for the NFET or for the NFET Yeah, I wish you had said you had a tuner out at the end, but you don't. I guess one last question, what size is your co-ac? Um, have to... It is, it's not the thin, thin stuff, but it's not LMR 400. It's probably... or whatever it is. Okay, yeah, you have a combination of inefficiencies there. Running high SWR on RG58 versus say
an RG8 family. You got a lot of loss there. Yeah, this is a more complicated question than maybe we have time for. Generally speaking, you don't want to be tuning a high SWR load through a piece of coax, especially small coax, and that's what that is for this purpose. Generally, a remote tuner is the ticket for what you want to do, the remote tuner and a piece of wire. The that you have difficulty getting a transformer down to a decent SWR
with the 49 to 1 and you're trying various remote tweaks at that. Yeah, that's difficult situation. And yeah, I think I'm rambling. Back to NET. Good. Let me stop there and let me ask first of all, John, is this making any sense and are you looking for additional comments? KC3WWCWA3VEA. I am all for experimenting and stuff, and that's what I've been doing, but I ask questions along the way so I can see if I understand it a little bit better. I understand that it would be
better to tune at the other end. I do put the Nano VNA on my Enfit Halfwave, and I try to lengthen it and bump it around to try to get all the bands closer, but there's still some that aren't, and I need the tuner. So the question is, if I've got my NFET half wave and I'm still needing the tuner for some of those bands, am I any better off than if it was just a random wire that would work just fine too, you know, on the coax with the
same inefficiencies and all that same feed inefficiencies? Yeah, so just wondered is there, should I stick with the NFET or is it fine at that point to just go back to the random wire and try that again? I'll see how it does, how it performs. Back to you, KC3WWC. 3QP? Tim, go ahead, W3QP WA3VEA. W3V and the group W3QP. I certainly agree with everything Chuck's saying. I think to try to get at the question you're asking, you talked about having trouble getting the
half wave to line up on all the handbands. That is super normal, especially when you're running in trees. Everything reacts with everything. And so what I get on my property and what you get on your property is very likely to be different. So that's pretty normal. I do not know off the top of my head what the efficiency of a 9 to 1 and what the efficiency is of a
49 to 1 from a transformer perspective. taking everything out of the equation, if, and I'm making numbers up because I don't know, if the 49 is 90 % efficiency and the 9 to 1 is 99 % efficiency, obviously there's an advantage there. I don't know. I do know with the half waves you can stack cores to handle more power, but it also affects the efficiency. I'll have to dig around and see if I can find the article that I have that gets into the
efficiency there. There are ways of measuring that with your nano VNA, but I don't know the details off the top of my head. As for the individual bands. It really depends on what SWR you're pulling on the individual bands. Again, I'll make up numbers. If you're at 1.5 to 1 on 20 meters with the half wave and you're 1.6 to 1 on 20 meters with the random wire, then for that band, your half wave is a little bit more efficient. Again, you have
to look at the transformer side of things. So it just really depends on what bands you're using. what the efficiency is for that particular band. The transformers are not going to be the same efficiency across all the bands. So it really gets down and you're going to have to measure and dig out the numbers. Somebody on the internet might have answers for you, but I certainly don't know. I don't know if that helps point you in a direction, if that
answers your question. I will turn it back over to Nat. This is W3QP. Very good. John, let me turn it back to you and see if we gave you enough information to go on there. KC3WWCWA3VEE Yes, Tim, thank you, and Chuck, thank you. It gives me some things to think about, especially the efficiency of the transformer that I've built, and swapping them in and out, and what they might be doing. I did play around with a 49 to 1 and a 64 to 1 as I was trying to
make things happen. But it's good also to know that it's not uncommon for them to just be a little, just for some of the bands to be a little off when I look at the tunings. I'll do the experiment, I'll report back. Maybe the 71 foot wire is, well I'll look back and realize it doesn't perform near as well. But I'll give it a shot and I'll see what I can measure. Thank you. KC3WWC. Very good. Last question for the evening is Tim, KD3AIS WA3VEA.
Tim had a power failure out there. K-E-3-A-I-S-W-A-3-V-E-E. I'm going check the PICO outage map. KD3AIS, sorry I stepped away at the wrong time. My apologies. Tim, go ahead with your question. My question is a newer ham who's not a general yet and trying to listen to the traffic on field day, just on 20 meters, because that was the easiest for me to do. I'm on a Yehsu FT-991A and I started thinking about, I wonder if a computer screen is helpful, or some kind
of screen is helpful at all in trying to navigate. HF, sure there's plenty of people that will say never use it. can look at all the pictures of people, stations that have no screens. So I'm sure it's possible to do without a computer screen. But I was just interested, has anybody ever found it beneficial to use a computer screen and or maybe this is why people get a second radio and then it has a slightly bigger screen. So my question is, is a screen helpful at all?
and looking at tuning in HF, your thoughts. Thank you. W3MFB. Comments for Tim. This is WA3VEA. Sorry, Ron. W3MFD, comment? W-A-3-V-E-E-I Mike. thank you ron you know working uh... echo link on the phone is uh... and haven't done in a
while it's a little difficult uh... i have uh... also have their radio and uh... operated on field day for six meter into the inside there had every year of where we one hundred water you have had since i've been a m since nineteen uh... honestly Alright, so the waterfall on the 991 is like looking at the NES Super Mario Brother 8-bit, you know? And then you see all the other modern Yee-Soo or i-Com 7300, whatever. And it's like, you know, PlayStation 4 or 5,
right? Honestly, yes, it's nice when you're, say you're on a frequency and you're finishing up your Q-So, whatever, and then you see some activity down below. uh... but are fully i'd use it yes but do what i put on the computer screen no uh... personally i would not do that because i'm listening i'm using my ears because i'm turning that dial i'm using my ears and turning that dial because if you don't have the waterfall you don't have a spectrum
scope on your radio or whatever uh... You're just using your ears and turning the dial and you're listening for good stations that you can copy, especially on field day or a contest. always make sure that I am able to first, I listen. don't just jump at the, my God, there's somebody in Washington who cares? Okay. I'm going to listen and make sure that I can understand their call sign. and understand the information they're giving, it's powder or something like
that, what the number is. I usually write all that stuff down first and then once I can hear them fine, then I make the contact. Yes, all the technology that these newer radios have is excellent, but me personally, guess, I'm new school to him, but old school in thinking. I don't think it's necessary, but that's just my point of view. uh... w three m f p back to row Hey, very good, Mike. Other comments for Tim? This is WA3VE. You're listening to
the 985 Workbench. Other comments, please? W-A-H-C-R-W W-A-H-C-R-W W-A-3-V-E-E-G-S-G-R agree with Mike, but I would say I have a 19 inch monitor connected to my Yee-Soo FT-DX10. And it makes looking at the screen a lot easier. It's not necessary, but I call it a bonus. Back to that. Okay, very good CR. Other comments for Tim? WA3VE here. KZG. 3KZG WA3VEE, you got it I with CR. I also have a DX10. Now it's not, I think the DX10 screen is actually.
did have the screen hooked up to my DX10 for, I would say... of Saturday on field day and then I had to give up the power cord for that monitor to my brother so he could recharge his batteries that he was running his 7300 off of because we had only brought one computer plug cable. used so I went the rest of field day without the big screen and it didn't seem to inhibit me at all. So it is nice looking at the big monitor though, especially if you
have aging eyes or wear glasses. is easier to see. Not, not needed. warned so many times just be sure to use a DBI. sure you don't backfeed voltage into the radio. If you would use like an H- Absolutely very true. Additional comments for Tim. This is WA3VE. CW. 3CW WA3 VEE. in the immortal words of KFC. Okay. This weekend I had Ron's 710 and it has a little screen
on it and he plugged it into a big screen. Now, I agree that the bigger screen makes it easier to see your settings and look at the S meter and frequency is right there in front of you and especially with all the visitors we had, it was a wonderful thing, especially with all the visitors. But as far as the band scope went, The general condition was so noisy
and so packed with stations that the band scope was pretty much useless. Because you're getting perfectly, I won't say perfectly copyable, but copyable stations that were down in the grass that did not show themselves above the general hash at the bottom of the screen any more than just the noise was. It didn't point anything out, it didn't provide any new information.
Again, this is just the band scope thing, but like I said, it was great PR. Now, if you're in a band, I won't say no experience on six, but I have the next best thing to know experience on six. Now, in a band like six or ten, which comes and goes, and... activity that you don't know about and you're not necessarily scanning your VFO up and down the band, it may be useful to say, oh, there's some activity down here that I didn't know about. So you
go dial, dial, dial, and you see them and hear them and you can work them. In that case, the band scope I think would be useful in a sparse band when you're waiting for things to pop up. In a crowded band, it's just a zoo. It's just grass on the screen. from what I can see. you know, it's like Scott said, it would be nice to have, but as far as enhancing operation, especially with the band scope, it depends on what you're doing and what band
you're on. Back to NET, NA-3CW. Very good. Excellent. All the way around. Great, great questions and great answers here and great comments. Final comments for Tim. This is WA3VE. KC3WWC. WCWA3VE, go ahead John. My little HF radio here has a pretty big screen. It's mostly screen. And they'll be sitting there on all the time. And I use the waterfall a lot because I'm not necessarily paying attention to it, but I can glance over and see the CW band on fire. You know, I know I'm like, oh,
there's some kind of contest. I should go listening. You know, I should tune around a little bit and listen to some CW. It's cool for just monitoring, I think. And it helps. zero in on a signal real fast if you're scrolling around. Back to you. Very good. Excellent. Tim, KD3AIS, do we answer your question? WA3VE.
Yes, Ron, everybody did and thank you very much for all the feedback. And I think my, would just say I have, normally have my radio on with the volume all the way down because I have it at my desk when I'm working during the day. And so maybe I've developed a lazy habit to watch that waterfall to see when somebody's talking. But that said, I think my takeaway
from this, this is great. limit on my tendency to just go out and buy something. And I think my takeaway from this is to maybe my time is better spent rather than driving down to HRO and buying a screen or buying a different radio to actually study for the general exam and pass it. So thank you to the NET. This is KD3AIS back to WA3VE. Very, very good. Is there anyone else with a question out there who's checked in already? WA3VE, last call for questions.
Before we close down the workbench for the evening, let's see if we have anyone else who wants to check in. So if you've been listening or just tuned in, we'd like to hear from you. Last call for check-ins just to get on the log. W-A-3-V-E-E. Hey Ron, W3MFB. I did have a question real quick and you can answer it very quickly. Go ahead Mike, W3MFB, WA3VEA.
Thank you very much. Real quick question. Up at the Field Day site, hey, is that a six meter and two meter beam up there all the time for use? Who wants to answer Mike's question about the 6 and 2 meter beam? This is WA3VEA. Chuck, go ahead, A3CW, WA3VE. I'm not speaking for George, but I think as long as it's up, it's available. The only issue is you'll have to put coax on it because there's no coax on either of those antennas right now. Very good. Mike, back to you. W3MSB WA3VE. Go ahead.
Alright, thank you very much Chuck and that answers the question, no problem. Alright, I appreciate it. Thank you. W3MFB. Excellent, very, very good. Thanks to all stations tonight for checking into the 985 workbench. And a big thank you to Joe, W3GMS, for making the 985 repeater available for the workbench. You are invited to use the repeater often. It's a great way to show that you appreciate the gift of 985 to the amateur radio community. Finally,
we hope to hear you again on Thursday evening at 8 p.m. during the 985 roundtable. This concludes the workbench for tonight. Feel free to stick around and continue the discussion on 985 if you like. Have a good night. Great week ahead. 73, this is W3, WA3. VEE, I'll be clear. And QRT.