Season 08 Episode 27: Let's Dance - podcast episode cover

Season 08 Episode 27: Let's Dance

Apr 25, 202531 min
--:--
--:--
Download Metacast podcast app
Listen to this episode in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episode description

One hot day in the summer of 1518, in the city of Strasbourg, a woman left her home in a strange trance and headed straight for the town square. There she began to dance, and dance, and dance. Something was terribly wrong and then, it began to spread...

Written by Emma Dibdin and Richard MacLean Smith

Find us at youtube.com/@unexplainedpod, tiktok.com/@unexplainedpodcast, twitter @unexplainedpod, facebook.com/unexplainedpodcast or www.unexplainedpodcast.com for more info. Thank you for listening.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcript

Speaker 1

In the middle of July fifteen eighteen, the eastern French city of Strasbourg was in the grip of a heat wave. It had been going on for weeks, and the population had adapted accordingly. Residents changed their daily routines to avoid the hottest parts of the day, going out to run errands at dawn or at dusk, and staying in the shade for the rest of the time. On the fourteenth of July, as it approached midday, the baking sun inching ever higher into the sky, the streets were mostly empty.

The only people out in the sweltering heat were those who didn't have a choice, the farmers and laborers who had to be outside come rain or shine. In a quiet cobble street, the echoes of a distant church bell could be heard striking noon. Just then, a door open and a young woman appeared in the door frame, her face fixed in an odd, vacant expression. When she stepped out onto the street, it was as if she was

being called to something. She didn't even stop to close the front door before heading off briskly towards the town's central square. Nobody in the square looked twice at the young woman when she first arrived, but then something strange began to happen. The woman started to dance on the spot, her body twisting and twirling in time to some imaginary soundtrack that only she could hear. She seemed utterly oblivious to the sun beating down on her and to the

curious glances of passers by who stopped to stare. At first, people were amused. This must be some kind of performance, they thought, although the lack of music struck them as strange. A few people dropped coins into a pile next to her, assuming that she was a busker, but before long began to notice some unsettling details. Despite the strange chigs she was dancing, the look on the young woman's face was anything but merry. Her features were contorted into a strange grimace,

as if she was in terrible pain. As the temperature climbed above thirty degrees celsius, sweat began to pour down her face and arms, but the woman refused to stop. After more than an hour of continuous dancing, she was still going. People began to exchange nervous glances. Then a city worker approached the woman and tried to get her to pause, offering her water. She ignored him completely, and when he put his hands on her shoulders, her dancing

became even more frenetic. She flung her arms wildly at him, forcing him to beat a hasty retreat. All afternoon she continued non stop, her legs and arms flailing about, hopping from one foot to the next. By the ear evening, every inch of the young woman's exposed skin was sunburnt, her face bright red, and her matted hair drenched in sweat. By now a sizeable crowd had gathered to watch this bizarre spectacle underneath the setting sun. It was now obvious

that this was no street performance. There was something terribly wrong with this woman, and nobody seemed to know how to help her. Her name was Frau Trofia, and soon she would not be the only one you're listening to Unexplained, and I'm Richard McLean Smith. By the morning of July fifteenth, Frau Trofia had been dancing NonStop for close to twenty hours. She hadn't stopped to sleep, to eat, or even to

rest for a moment. Word had spread all over the city and that the doctor was called to make sense of what was happening. When the doctor arrived, he found an even more bizarre scene than he'd expected. There was still a crowd gathered around Frautrofia, but now they weren't

all just onlookers. At some point in the previous few hours, two others had begun dancing too, their faces locked into the same rictus grimace, their bodies contorting into the same strange jig, incredibly like an especially outlandish m night Shire Marlin plot. Whatever this was appeared to be contagious. At first, it looked like they were mocking Frautrofia, but their dancing went on for too long to be a joke, and for the rest of the day, the trio kept up

their wild moods, ignoring all efforts to make them stop. Finally, shortly before five pm that evening, Frautropia collapsed to the ground. It seemed exhaustion had finally got the best of her, and everybody around her breathed a sigh of relief. Whatever this strange fever was, it must be breaking, they thought. But then Frau Trothia's legs and arms began to twitch weakly, and soon they were wriggling again. Fearing she was dying.

One onlooker rushed forward to give her some water. No sooner had frow Trothia managed a few small SIPs, She steadily got back to her feet, and the dance began once again, more manically than ever. This time, the horrified crowd could only watch on as blood from her feet began to seep through the straps of her sandals, creating

streaks of bloody footprints on the stony ground. It was as if she was no longer in control of her own body, compelled to keep moving by some hidden, all powerful puppet master, as if her mind had been given over to the King of the fairies. Soon after, concerned city officials appeared on the scene and forced the crowd to disperse. Terrified that more citizens might suddenly catch the dancing fever, they cordoned off the square in a desperate effort to prevent anyone else from being able to see

the dancers, but it was too late. Over the course of the next few days, dozens more people across Strasbourg began spontaneously dancing. When their alarmed relatives and friends tried to intervene more reason with them, the victims were completely unresponsive,

locked in the same bizarre trance as Frautrophia. Doctors ordered friends and family to physically restrain the afflicted just so they could examine them, but it was impossible to even get close to them, and in any event, the examinations when they could conduct them, proved pointless. The physicians were completely baffled with things threatening to get out of hand. Officials implored the doctors to come up with a theory

as to what was happening. Though they had no concrete proof, it seemed reasonable to assume that the frantic flailing of the victims arms and legs had a medical explanation. With this in mind, the doctors suggested that the victims simply be left alone to effectively dance the sickness out of their systems. It was a dubious idea, but it was the only one they had. Officials began putting plans together to manage the ever growing number of inflicted, believing the

disease would be best dealt with outside. Specific areas of the city became designated as dancing zones, such as the open air grain market, the guild hall, and a local fair ground. Officials also took the extraordinary decision to try and make everything seem as normal as possible, hoping that whatever this strange virus was, it would be less effectively

transmitted if it was harder to discern. To that end, the areas were completely cleared out so stages could be erected for the afflicted to dance on, and musicians were even hired to accompany them. What resulted, however, was a grimm tableau, like a hyernomous bosh painting come to life. The dancing zones became scenes of surreal, nightmarish chaos. The afflicted jerked and twisted endlessly under the baking sun, their faces aching with distress. They groaned and cried out in pain.

Some screamed out for God to save them, but the ones who were silent were the more disturbing to watch. They looked terrified, as though stuck in a nightmare they couldn't wake up from. All the while, groups of perfectly healthy musicians accompanied them with a muddled chorus of drum beats and pipes. As an ever growing crowd of horrified

townspeople turned up to stare. It was, as one eyewitness described it, as though the dancers created the impression of people attempting to keep their legs and feet from burning, as if they were poised above a fire. City officials also hired professional dancers to perform alongside the victims to try and keep them dancing or prop them up when they grew too exhausted to stand, convinced that would help eradicate the virus. Over the next few weeks, more and

more victims followed in frou Trophia's footsteps. First, they were seized by the uncontrollable urge to die, which they did non stop for a period of hours or days, and depending on their age and physical condition, they would inevitably dance themselves into exhaustion. After six days of almost non stop dancing, Frautrophia finally collapsed into unconsciousness and her limbs stopped moving. The following day, another dancer keeled over and died.

The cause was a massive heart attack brought on by the sheer physical toll of the dancing. And still more people continued to join the throng of tormented dancers, and those who hadn't yet been affected were in their own grip of terror, petrified at the thought that they would be next. By now, the medical consensus was that the dancing was being caused by overheated blood on the brain. Due to the heat, weve, but rumblings had begun suggesting

that perhaps there was a much darker explanation. By the end of that summer of fifteen eighteen, some four hundred people had fallen victim to the dancing plague of Strasbourg. Dozens had danced themselves to death, and though the physicians were stumped as to what was happening, for the town's religious leaders, the explanation was becoming increasingly clear. Back in two hundred ninety CE, the Roman emperor of the day was Diocletian, but his empire was crumbling as a new

god had begun to challenge the old powers. That year, in the shadowed corners of Sicily, a boy named Vitus was born into a prestigious Roman pagan family at the age of seven. Vitus is said to have been convinced to become a follower of Jesus by the family nurse, who also baptized him Secretly. His father, Hylas, a local senator, was quick to notice a change in his son. He

refused to bow before the household gods. He murmured quietly to himself when they sat down to eat, and whenever they went for a walk, Hilas would catch his son gazing wistfully up to the sky. In three hundred three c E, Emperor Diocletian issued an edict against Christians, who were steadily growing in number. The edict demanded that all

Christians renounce their faith or faith severe punishment. Terrified of what it might mean for his son, Hilas insisted that Vitus comply, But as the story goes, the boy refused, even when Hylas resorted to beating and imprisoning him. In fact, each punishment seemed only to strengthen Vitus's conviction. Then strange things began to happen. Hylas's arm would seemingly become temporarily

paralyzed whenever he raised it to strike the boy. Then, a magistrate sent to interrogate Fightus on behalf of the emperor died unexpectedly. One morning, while out walking in a market with his nurse, Fitus found himself drawn to a blind beggar. The young boy placed his small hands on the blind man's face, and the man gasped, blinking rapidly, when he felt a sudden flood of light rush into

his eyes. It's a miracle, he said, I can see. Meanwhile, at the Emperor's palace in Nicomedia, in what is present day Turkey, Diocletian's son was in the grip of something terrifying. He writhed about in his bed in a horrifying seizure, as foam flecked his lips. The emperor's advisers stood over the boy and gave their ominous assessment. There was no doubt about it. The Emperor's son was possessed by a demon.

So when the Emperor learned of a peculiar boy in Sicily who was said to have extraordinary healing powers, he sent for him immediately. As the legend goes, it took Vitus only a matter of minutes to cure the emperor's son and bring an end to his and his father's torture, but it would come at a great cost. Though grateful for Vitas's help, Diocletian was unwavering in his edict against Christians. When he demanded that Vitus renounce his faith once again,

the young boy steadfastly refused. Vitus was swiftly imprisoned and then beheaded by five hundred CE, Vitus was being widely recognized as a saint. Then, sometime in the fourteenth century, in the Rhine Valley in Germany, some farmers began suffering from a mysterious affliction characterized by uncontrollable dancing and twitching. But when they began praying to Saint Vitus, the affliction stopped.

And with this association came its dark inversion. If Saint Vitus could stop the dance, could he not also start it? As the religious leaders of Strasbourg looked about their town, the explanation for the dancing plague, as it would come to be known, was simple. It wasn't just the dancers that were sick. It was all of them. The entire society sick with the sin of debauchery, and now Saint

Vitus was punishing them for it. With nothing to lose, the city council embraced the theory and swiftly ordered the dancers to be confined to their homes out of public view. Once this was done, they went on a mission to rid Strasbourg of any activity that could be considered sinful. They imprisoned sex workers and gamblers, and banned known drunkards

from taverns in their efforts to purify the city. When this failed to do anything, a period of enforced penance was initiated, during which all forms of music and dancing were banned in public. All present victims of the dancing plague were rounded up and taken to stay at the shrine of Saint Vitus on a mountaintop just outside the city. One by one, they arrived, hopping and jerking at the

hillside shrine, their feet blistered and bleeding. Each was sanctified with holy oil and water, and given a cross to wear around their necks and a pair of red shoes gently placed on their ravaged feet. Then, every day, beside a wooden figure of Saint Vitus, the local priest conducted a mass exorcism, crying out to Saint Vitus to relent with his punishment and grant absolution. Then something extraordinary happened.

The victims began to recover. They regained the ability to control their movements, and although they were still sometimes gripped by the sudden urge to dance, the episodes lasted for minutes rather than days. Finally, by the end of September fifteen eighteen, the dancing plague including for Frau Trofia, who had survived. The whole ordeal was all but over. In the five centuries that have passed, there has never been a conclusive explanation for what happened, but there's been no

shortage of theories. Some have tried to explain it away as a purely sociological phenomenon. The dancers were members of a religious cult. Some suggested enacting some kind of ritual, but this doesn't tally with any of the eye witness accounts. The afflicted seemed distressed and desperate, and were clearly dancing against their will to the point where their feet bled and their bodies collapsed. No cult could sustain that kind of power. Another possibility is that the victims were all

poisoned by some kind of toxin. Ergot is a type of toxic fungus that grows on damp rye, which grew plentifully in the field surrounding Strasbourg. Eating at once isn't a problem, but long term poisoning can cause hallucinations and muscle spasms. If the city's bread supply was contaminated by ergot, this might have caused widespread poisoning, but this theory doesn't really hold water either. Hallucinations and spasms don't tally with

an insatiable urge to dance. In order to really understand what happened during the Dancing plague, it's important to understand what was happening in Strasbourg before it started. The early fifteen hundreds had been a terrible time for the city. Multiple harvest failures had caused wheat prices to soar, leaving many people on the brink of starvation. A number of terrifying new diseases had also begun to spread widely during

this period, including syphilis and the bubonic plague. Homeless shelters, hospitals, and orphanages were besieged, and the streets were full of people begging for food. In short, people were desperate, grief stricken, and struggling to see any light at the end of the tunnel. One moralizing book written by city chancellor Sebastian Brandt about twenty years before, titled Das Narrenschiff The Ship of Falls, also seemed to have seeped into the public imagination.

In it, he wrote that dance and sin are one in kind. All of this created the ideal conditions for a mass psychogenic illness, more commonly known as mass hysteria, a situation that occurs when there's a rapid onset of similar or identical symptoms among members of a group. Importantly, mass psychogenic illness only occurs in the context of some plausible threat, which provokes anxiety and panic within the group. The existence of this threat is what makes the spread

of mass hysteria possible. Just as being sleep deprived or malnourished can suppress your immune system and make you more susceptible to getting ill, feeling constantly anxious and threatened can make you more psychologically suggestible. In the case of the people of Strasbourg, they'd lived under constant threat from famine, disease,

and social upheaval for years. Even for the lucky ones, those who still had a roof over their heads, enough food on the table, and whose loved ones were all still alive, daily life was still fraught and filled with reminders of just how bad things could get under these conditions. It's possible that Frau Trophia essentially became patient zero. Her bizarre, uncontrollable dancing spread like the symptoms of a physical illness

among the unsettled residents. Of Strasbourg, resulting in the dancing plague. But mass hysteria is only half the story. The idea of a dancing plague in itself didn't come from nowhere, but from a very specific superstition that had existed in Europe for centuries. The vast majority of people in sixteenth century Europe were strongly religious, believing not only in a Christian God, but also in a variety of related saints

and deities. One of these was the aforementioned Saint Vitus, who became known as the Saint of entertainment and dance, who legend said, punished sinners by cursing them to dance relentlessly. This superstition is so widely known that it even inspired medical terminology as an auto immune condition called Sydonym's corrier, involving frantic and uncontrollable jerking movements in the hands and feet. The alternative name for this affliction is Saint Vitus's dance.

Surrounded by distress and misfortune, the people of Strasbourg had every reason to believe that God and all of his saints were angry with them, so it wasn't much of a leap for a few people to also start believing that Saint Vitus had cursed them personally. If this is indeed what happened, then the city council couldn't possibly have

chosen a worse response. By erecting stages in multiple spaces and encouraging the afflicted to continue dancing as crowds of spectators watched on, they ensured maximum exposure to the emotional virus. In effect, these public dancing zones were daily psychological super spreader events. Even if people were going out of their way to avoid seeing the dancers, it was almost impossible.

They were in the most public areas of the city, from the Guildhall to the grain Market, and because the afflicted were so inescapable, so visible, the townspeople had no choice but to reflect on the possibility that they could be next. This fear would have been especially pronounced for anybody who was naturally anxious or prone to self recrimination. Of course, the authorities were only following the medical advice

they'd been given. This was two centuries before the emergence of psychiatry, and doctors unfortunately had no concept of social contagion or collective trauma when they recommended that the victims be encouraged to dance until they were satiated. They were thinking only about the effect on the individual, not on

society as a whole. There have been no other recorded incidents of a dancing plague since that strange summer of fifteen eighteen, but mass psychogenic illness is now broadly accepted phenomenon. It's been widely recorded in other forms, from mass spouts of illness to supposed multiple demonic possessions, and even epidemics of uncontrollable laughter. Has once occurred in East Africa in

the nineteen sixties. The psychological contagion theory is the closest will likely ever get to an explanation of what happened for now, The dancing plague at Strasbourg was a bizarre and haunting occurrence that remains to this day unexplained. This episode was written by Emma Dibden and Richard McLain Smith. Thank you, as ever for listening to the show. Please subscribe and rate it if you haven't already done so. You can also now find us on TikTok at TikTok

dot com. Forward slash at Unexplained podcast. Unexplained as an AV Club Productions podcast created by Richard McClain smith. All other elements of the podcast, including the music, are also produced by me Richard McClain smith. Unexplained. The book and audiobook is now available to buy worldwide. You can purchase

from Amazon, Barnes and Noble, Waterstones and other bookstores. Please subscribe to and rate the show wherever you get your podcasts, and feel free to get in touch with any thoughts or ideas regarding the stories you've heard on the show. Perhaps you have an explanation of your own you'd like to share. You can find out more at Unexplained podcast dot com and reach us online through Twitter at Unexplained Pod and Facebook at Facebook dot com, Forward slash Unexplained Podcast d.

Speaker 2

A, then then then then on the

Transcript source: Provided by creator in RSS feed: download file
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android