Life in China vs Western Myths - podcast episode cover

Life in China vs Western Myths

Dec 05, 20251 hr 1 min
--:--
--:--
Download Metacast podcast app
Listen to this episode in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episode description

The UK Column is an independent media organisation. It receives no corporate or foundation funding. We rely on the generosity of individual readers, viewers and listeners. If you enjoy our quality reporting, please consider supporting us.


🌐 Explore all our written and video content on the UK Column website https://www.ukcolumn.org


💪 Support our independent journalism here https://support.ukcolumn.org


🛍️ Check out our shop here https://shop.ukcolumn.org


American expat and radio host Jason Smith joins Carl Zha to provide a ground-level view of life in China, directly countering prevalent Western media narratives. From debunking the "social credit score" dystopia and discussing China's remarkable safety to analyzing the tangible improvements in daily life and infrastructure over the past decade, Smith offers a perspective based on 12 years of living in Beijing. The conversation delves into the real impact of the US-China trade war on Chinese society, the stark affordability and quality of life, and concludes with a nuanced outlook on the future of US-China relations, including potential pathways to cooperation.

Transcript

Hello and welcome to another episode of the Silk and Steel Podcast. I am your host, Carl Zar. Today we have a very special guest from Beijing. Jason, I have known you for a long time, Jason Smith For the people who don't know you, for the people I don't know why they would know you, but for for people who might not know you. Jason, could you do a very brief intro of who you are and what you do? Well, my name is Jason Smith.

I am a radio show host, which I think is special because I think I'm the only actual American U.S. citizen radio show host in China. So if you turn on the radio in some cities, you're going to hear my voice, which I think is special. I, I, my podcast is called The Bridge to China. You can find us on all podcasting platforms. I recently wrote this book. And so I'm kind of studying like what China is doing with other developing countries around the world.

And now I'm working on another book, which is studying poverty alleviation in China. I'm very interested. I go to like small villages that used to be impoverished and I study how they've become more prosperous. Well, that what that road has been like and how they did it. And I want to I want to do that for other developing countries, but also because I think some of those techniques can actually be replicated back home in the States. And I think that would be cool. Yeah, I can.

You just read out the title of the book because it's it's backwards when you hold it up the the title, it's kind of hard to read because it's backwards. But what does the title say? A world beyond poverty, China's road map to a shared future. This is I wouldn't recommend this for people who don't like difficult books because this is like a a compendium. It's like an encyclopedia of projects from around the world. It's not like a book about, oh, my experience of no, it's just

one project after another. What did China build? How much did it cost? Was it a grant? Was it a loan? What were the terms, you know, what is China actually doing in Laos or what is China actually doing in Egypt? You know, what is it did it actually do? Because a lot of people have weird ideas that China is debt trapping countries and it's it's just not true. So I wanted to produce a book that explicitly shows what China is actually up to in a lot of

these developing countries. What's it, what is it building, and what are those countries getting and what are they giving in return? Well, the reason I invited to my show, Jason, is to provide easy, accessible information to my audience. So what I so you know, because I like to do it in the podcast for much like you you, but I I'm kind of interested. How does American boy like you ended up in China in the first place?

Well, I, I got a master's degree in California and it was in modern world history, but like most Americans, I've never actually seen the world outside of North America, right. So I was like, OK, well, I need to go see the world if I'm going to pretend that I understand what it's like. So I moved to South Korea and, you know, that wasn't for me. It was a great, it's a great country, wonderful food, wonderful people, but it, I wasn't the right fit for me.

Then I moved to China and I, my intention at that point was I'm gonna move every two or three years to a new country. And then I just got soaked. This was 2012 July when I moved to China and I, I fell in love with China and then I just couldn't leave. And now I now I'm just here. You're stuck. You you. You met your wife in China. That's right. Yeah. We we met in Shandong.

She's from Shandong and we were immediately a couple and we're we got married the next year and now she's asleep in in the bedroom. She sleeps during the day. I don't know. Well, you, you, you, you, you have much compliment on your wife's taste on on the on the beautiful background you have. That's right. This is her. Yeah. Yeah, the traditional Chinese painting of cranes. That looks very nice and so OK. So how did you get into the

radio business? You know, I, that's not my was never my intention to be in media, but around 2018-2019, you know, we're both from the United States. So like, you know, before 2017, China was not really even in the media. And when it was, it was like, oh, it's polluted and that's or pandas and that's all you heard right. And then 2017, 18, the US media turned just 180 on China and everything China was bad.

All of a sudden, I was shocked by this, you know, as an American living in China, because a lot of this stuff, almost all of the stuff that I saw in the media was completely false or highly inaccurate or just used a grain of truth to just talk about all these other weird accusations. And so I was like, whoa, whoa, whoa. I want to say why that's not true.

So I started going onto social media and saying, you know, making videos in China. Actually I was in Chinese social media at 1st and saying, hey, you know, I appreciate you. I'm sorry that US is saying this stuff and it got really popular. And then CGTN, which is a China Global Television News, a network, it's a huge agency here.

It's the the largest English speaking television channel, maybe the only real major English speaking television channel, reached out to me and said, would you like to be on TV? And I said no. But then they were like, oh, we have radio. And I was like, Oh yeah, that sounds great because there's CDT

and radio, formerly CRI. And so actually I went to work for CRI as a radio show host doing podcast the the Bridge to China. And then I, I at that, just before then, I sort of switched my media to the West and gone on X and all of these other platforms. And so my, my social media personality on X, that's me. I couldn't get away with that. If that was an official CGTN platform. A lot of people say, oh, you say this stuff because you're paid by the CGTN.

Now the radio show is CGTN, but my comments on social media are my comments. So all that crazy stuff, you know, actually, I like you. You referred to yourself one time six months ago or a year ago as a as a shit poster. And I thought I always. Refer to myself as. A shit poster. I saw that and I thought, oh, I like that. You know, I want to run with that because I don't I want to just be able to say anything.

I don't want to have to be really official and like very formal and like stick to the rules. I just wanted to just go crazy. And I thought when you, when I saw you post that, I thought that's my model for how I'm going to be. And I, I, I really have just, you know, call out BS online about China. And it's easy for me because people will say, well, China's like this. I can walk outside in Beijing and film and show that it's not like that.

So it's easy for me to win a lot of these arguments because people will say, well, this is what China's like. And I can literally just go like 5 minutes down, down stairs and start filming and show why that's not true. And so that you know, that's. People will and people will say if China is great, why don't you go live in? China. Yeah, exactly. I get that every single day. And you're like, I'm in Beijing. Right. Yeah. It's so strange. Yeah.

It was really made straight. Go ahead, go ahead. Go. No, no, no. Go ahead, Go ahead. What makes it strange is that X has this new find where you are location thing. And because, you know, we use VPNs in China, Sometimes I'm in Finland, sometimes I'm in Macedonia, and it moves around. So different times when people click on my X account, they say you're in the United States, you're lying about living in China or you're in Macedonia, you're lying about it.

It's it's there is no China option. So X does not have the technical capability to tell where people actually are. So that's been really frustrating. I'm currently based in Bali. I have been living here since the pandemic and now some people use that as a gotcha. It's like, ah, you are Indonesia. Why are you talking about China? I'm like, people do travel around, you know, Chinese people do get around, they, they travel around the world.

You know, I've been, I also been living in the United States for almost 30 years. And so, but, but people, people just assume I'm some sort of Chinese bot. So I have to tell people I'm the latest generation Chinese AI. That's very realistic. How so? How's you know, you know, obviously you have settled in your life in Beijing. Has the kind of the downturn in the Sino American relationship affect you in, you know, your everyday living in China? You know, not really.

People are still very friendly. When I got here, I was, I was very curious as an American, what do Chinese people think of America, right. So I asked around and at that time, 2012 to 2016, everyone was like, oh, we look up to America. You know, we want to, you know, develop like America. People were very open, you know, they owe to my American friend after Trump's initiated his first trade war 2017. Like people we're still like, we like America, but we don't like

this trade war, you know. So people in China are really friendly. I mean, I'm sure that there are like outlier people who are really upset about it. Maybe they they were exporters and it hurt them or something. But the general person on the street is very friendly to foreigners of all kinds. Wherever you're from, you're from Kazakhstan, great. You're from England, great. You're from US, great. You know, like, so it's, you know, my daily life is really nice.

People are really polite and nice to me. Nothing's really changed. Actually, I would say if anything, what's happened is from the period 10 years ago to now, China has become safer. My own thinking about this is that it's because there's a lot more prosperity. You know, people who used to be impoverished are less less likely to be impoverished today. People who made less money before make more money today. You know, the infrastructure is

great. So I think people are just, you know, because there's prosperity, because there's a lack of poverty like there used to be. I go outside and I feel safer than ever. You know, when I first moved to China, I was like, OK, you know, I still need to keep my guard up a little maybe. And I don't want to buy bike stolen. I need to lock it up. Like I was in the US. It didn't notice a massive difference. But today, my gosh, like I could just leave my bike in the middle

of the the street. People will just leave it there, whatever, It doesn't matter. It's, it's so incredibly safe. It's incredibly safe feeling at night, walking around anywhere in any city, rural, urban, doesn't matter. It's just so I would say over the same period of time, I've actually just become more comfortable despite the trade war. Hopefully, you know, that'll be walked back a little bit. There were some agreements made recently when President Xi and President Trump met.

And I'm hoping that the relationship can get back on track a little bit, become more normalized. Yeah, I mean, that's my hope too. I'm I'm a Chinese American. You know, for me, I have always hope had hope to see a better relationship between the two countries because especially for me that that would be good for me and my family. But unfortunately, you know, things hasn't hasn't turned out so rosy for the last eight, 7-8

years. But you know what you mentioned about the safety issue, You know, I've seen so many videos online of like people leaving cell phone or laptop, a coffee like Starbucks in China and then come back and it's still there. I actually experienced that myself. I was in Shanghai a couple months ago and I left my Xiaomi phone charging in a like a Community Center, you know, in a residential compound where my friend lived.

And then I, I, I totally forgot. I, I, we, we wandered off for like 2 hours and I'm like, where's my phone? And I'm like, oh wait, I left it charging at a Community Center. We went back, the phone was still there, but I have to say that was not the case back in 1980s when I, I lived in China, but back then that that phone will be gone, It'll be long gone. So I think I agree with you. I think it's part of the, the, the prosperity, the general prosperity. Now people are generally don't

need to do that. And and also they there's, there's also, you know, a lot of things also got better. General etiquette is getting is developing like in 1980s. I can tell you there's no such thing as keowing. There's no such thing as lining up. I mean, like I like, because I remember one time just back, back in, in my days to make a phone call to my dad who was studying for PhD in United States. Might we didn't have a phone in our in our apartment.

So we actually have to travel to downtown Fengqing to get to go to like a China post office or something that where the heck we can, we can do international calls, right, right. So, so, so it's a whole day trip. On the way back, we have to catch a bus to go back home. And I remember it was during rush hour.

The bus comes and the whole before there was some kind of semi line and but when the bus as soon as a bus door open, the crowd just like swore the bus and and there's like some young guys like 20 something, they will climb through the window open when yeah, me and my my mom's like, oh, OK, my God, there's no way we could get out that bus. Let's just walk. We have to walk. Like several. Blocks to the next bus stop to catch a a different bus. But that was kind of the

experience in the 1980s. I was pleasantly surprised when I went back to China in 2019, just before the pandemic. That's I think when I first noticed about the behavior change. I was like, wow, people actually stopping at the red light. You know, people actually have made the signals there today, you know, rather than treating it as like a, you know, a mere suggestion. So, so I think people, some people attribute that to the

prevalence of cameras. May, I mean, maybe plays part of it, but I generally appreciate the change. You know, I appreciate that things are getting nicer now and, and safer and very, very safe. You know, people, I don't know what your experience, but from my my experience in China is that I don't feel, yes, there are a lot of cameras, but I don't feel like a lot of people really care about it. They they, they see camera as like safety, provide safety. Yeah.

Because I I me too. Because I remember, yeah, because I remember walking out long trails in the Great Wall, like really kind of secluded part of Great Wall. They have cameras along the trail and, and, and, and for a lot of Chinese people, that's, that's safety. That's, you know, like they, they know they will be safe even there alone walking a trail in the in the wild Great Wall. Yeah. So I think that there's that,

there's that. So there's just a lot of very different perceptions because I think what what it is is when people talk about China, you know, from the West in particular, a lot of times they're not really talking about China. They're talking about a projection in their mind of like their own worst fears about their own society. So, you know, rather than the real China that existed out there, you know, I think, I think this is sometimes it's kind of frustrating.

I I understand it must be frustrating for you try to kind of, you know, convey what China is really like. You know what it's not? It's not just that it's frustrating, it's that there is, it seems to be deliberate disinformation, whether it's from state actors or from individuals who are just full of hate. Wherever it's coming from, there's a lot of disinformation like the social credit score thing. This is actually outside of my home. There is a camera. I noticed yesterday.

It is a bunch of cameras and one of them points straight at the road. And one of the things I read this morning when I woke up under one of my tweets was, oh, if you jaywalk, your social credit score goes down. So I'm going to set up my camera on a tripod outside and I'm going to walk back and forth across the street numerous times like to show that, you know, it doesn't affect me in any kind of way because there is something called a social credit score.

That's what's confusing in China, they have multiple credit score systems and one of them is called a social credit score. But actually it's for your credit. It's like not dissimilar from AUS credit system. So if you take a loan and you don't pay it, guess what, you have difficulty getting another loan, same as the the US. But if you jaywalk or like, I don't know, post something about Winnie the Pooh online or whatever the lie is right now,

nothing happens to you. There's I've even read people say like, oh, because this person jaywalked when they went to the store, they couldn't buy milk because they have to pay with their face. And there's so many like little tiny pieces of things that are accurate that it can be confusing to someone who doesn't understand. For example, if you choose to, you can set up facial payment at a lot of stores so you could actually pay for your groceries.

But that's not what people do. People use their phone and QR codes. But like that, the idea that something in your behavior is going to prevent you from buying food or prevent you from getting into your home is insane. It's completely ludicrous. Nothing like that exists. I could jaywalk all day long. I could probably spend 12 hours jaywalking back and forth. Nothing. No credit system is going to notice that.

It doesn't matter, the police won't even notice, they'll probably just think there's someone completely out of their mind if they do notice that the guy walking back and forth on the little bubble or something. Like actually I don't think anyone even watches the cameras, not even AI. The people who have. No no. This is interesting. I want to point this out because

I wanted Full disclosure. People do have things like can't stay in a five star hotel, can't take high speed rail, can't take first class airplanes, can't have a passport to go abroad. Those people are called frauds and they have scammed people out of millions of RMB. Have have they? Maybe they haven't paid 50 employees at their factory or something. That also didn't happen by a app. It wasn't like AI made that decision. They were brought before a

judge. The judge said, hey, you have, you know, you owe 9 million RMB to your employees that you haven't paid for three months. Guess what, we're going to, you can't leave the country because you may have embezzled that money and hid it in the Cayman Islands. We don't want you to just go there and live a happy life. You have to stay here and these are your limitations until you

pay that debt back. And that those people, you can actually also, because they, I've seen this, they've, oh, I found them on an app, all the people with low social social credit scores. Yes, there are in fact apps where you can find people who have are fraudulent scammers. And it's like Megan's Law in California. You're from California, right? So in California we have a law called Megan's Law. And for these people who are

pedophiles? They, you can find them on Megan's Law in your neighborhood. So you can make sure, hey, I don't want my kids playing over there, right? So they have an app for that In China, there is an app to find people with The Who are fraudulent scammers. And it's to make sure that you don't go into business with them not knowing Full disclosure, this person owes 20 million RMB because they did they, you know, they were scamming other people, but that that's it.

It doesn't affect normal people. Grandma, you know, walking across the street in the wrong place or saying something to her neighbor about not liking some government policy doesn't affect anything at all. And that's one of the things I find most frustrating. People find little tiny things that are true, like, oh, their facial recognition can be used to pay groceries, and they mix it with a pack of lies, and then they try to sell it to people. Like that's what China's like

when it's nothing like that. And that's really frustrating. That that's why I tell people seeing is believing just come to China and see for yourself. You know, I, I was travelling with a South African guy germs, you know, so I, I just took him on a bicycle ride. We got those rideshare bikes. You know where you stand your with Alipay QR code and then you can rent it for like a 1.5 RMB for next hour. So we, we were riding around Shanghai and we're waiting at

the, the, the, the stop. Like you see, you see those two guys just drove their scooter without helmet, right? And like right did, did a, did a total illegal, illegal turn on the red. You see that, you know, like, you know, you use the West. They will think they'll be ZAB or something like because this is not on camera and social credit. But no, let that that still happens. You know, unfortunately there's still rule Breakers. You know, very.

Late rule Breakers. And, you know, it's not, yeah, that that social credit dystopia stuff, you know, it's, yeah. So there's a lot of projection, I guess. I think there are a lot of surveillances in the West. So This is why I tried to tell people, look, yeah, they're cameras in China. Yes, they're equally among. There's just as many cameras in City of London, right. And guess what? At least in China, you're safe. You have all the cameras, you're still not safe.

But yeah, that's the difference. You know, that's a really good point. A lot of people say, oh, the reason people don't when I I post, oh, China is one of the safest places in the world. I put statistics up. People say, oh, that's just because there's cameras everywhere. And actually your response that, hey, London's also filled with an insane amount of cameras, but there are stabbings and, you know, people are robbed in broad daylight or in the in the subway systems.

It's clearly not just because of the cameras. There's something else going on. I think it is, you know, no offense to the UK or the United States, They are very developed countries, but in a in a lot of ways, it's becoming harder for their middle class in these developed countries. In the United States, people are struggling, people are living paycheck to paycheck and you know, rent is out, you know, inflation, all these things. So it actually creates

criminality. That's where criminals come from. Criminals come from need, and in China, there is still need. You know, there's still some degree of poverty in some rural areas that it needs to be corrected and is being corrected. But the difference is they're better off today than they were five years ago or 10 years ago or 20 years ago. And so there's a feeling of upward mobility here in China. That is a very good point because I have experienced that

myself. You know, I lived in China in 1980s, as I often tell people, you know, I, I live in a times when, you know, we need ration papers to buy everything, right? Cooking oil to like, to like rise to close. And, and, and I saw that, you know, gradually that was being phased out and there were plenty of goods in the market.

You can, yes, you can. You can buy as long as you have money, you know, whereas you know, back in the days that you have to go line up at the designated government stores with ration papers. You know, there, there used to be such a thing called friendship stores where they will sell imported goods, foreign goods. And you cannot even use, you cannot even buy with R&B the Chinese money. You have to have like what they call the foreign exchange certificate.

And you want to get the foreign exchange certificate. If you take like a hard currency, like foreign currency, go to the People's Bank of China to trade it in for R&B and then they give you the the French, the foreign currency exchange certificate. And with that then you will be able to purchase imported foreign goods. There's one like 1980s but but, but you know that soon changed goes to the come 1990s two thousand and everything is made

in China anyway. So, you know, you don't need, you don't need to buy imported goods anymore unless, you know, you really want to buy like that, that Ferrari or so or Porsche or something. Yeah. You know, you mentioned another thing that really makes life convenient here and a lot of people get frustrated, you know, economists in the West like, oh, China's inflation is, you know, only like .8 if you take out electricity and food. So it's it's very slow. That's great.

You know, my wife, I love her to death, but she has bought and I'm not exaggerating, something like 10 purses in the last month because she just, I suddenly just went, I had won all these purses and she's ordering purses and sending them back, but keeping some of them. And the thing about it is everything's made in China. So I'm like, Oh my gosh, that purse looks really expensive. How much is it? 60 RMB, which is like less than 10 bucks.

And it's like something that would cost hundreds in the United States, you know, because of tariffs and because of profiteers and middle men and stores and whatever. So like we get amazing deals living in China. So, you know, if you want to buy a laptop or whatever, you can get everything like way less expensive than in the West. It's one of the perks of living in China. It's just like so they make so much stuff.

Yeah, everything, everything price at least double S when they leave China. Like I, I know because I just bought a Chinese EV here in Indonesia and I know for the same brand, same spec of car in China, that car cost like like 1/2 of what I've just paid, You know, just just because, you know, tariffs and, and like, and the company could make a profit because there's less competition for other Chinese EV makers.

There's not that many brands here yet, whereas China they have insane amount of competition. So that, that competition keeps the price stop. And so, you know, it's, it's great time to be a Chinese consumer today. This is another thing I, I wish people understand is that China, despite its very developed infrastructure, in many ways even surpassing the developed W, the price is still very affordable.

Like, like, like the hotel, especially hotels, like some very nice hotels that would cost like go for like 4-5 hundred dollars in, in, in, in, in New York or Los Angeles in here. You can't, you know, it's like you, you go for like 10, that price, maybe like 40 from 40 to $80. You can have. I mean, it's amazing. People. People should just talk to China. Yeah, go.

Ahead Oh yeah, I Oh yeah. I, I mean, I don't, I, I'd like the I, I want people to come visit for a week or two and that's going to change a lot of minds. And, you know, people who do are going to go back home with a completely different perspective. But I think living here is also really would be helpful in some cases. You, you mentioned cars. I was also thinking about used internal combustion engines.

Used ICE cars are so cheap. So like if you want to buy like a A5 year old Porsche in China, it costs like 10% of a new Porsche. So you go on these apps and what's what's happening is they're selling as many as they can in China. And then actually they're taking all these used cars and shipping them to other countries to sell used cars in those countries because you can't sell them for any real value in China anymore because everyone's switching to

EVs. So you can go online and find like a Mercedes from five years ago and get it for 10% of the cost of a brand new Mercedes. And so, like, all these people who couldn't afford cars before, like not only are they buying EVs, which are, you know, like more than half of all of the cars in China now, but like, they're also buying used ICE cars. And like, oh, I have a Mercedes now, but they're like, you know, lower middle class. Nice. Yeah. That's really nice. I Yeah.

I wish people really understood that. But you, you, you don't really get to experience it until you see it. You know, seeing is still believing. This is why I encourage anybody just travel to China. See for yourself. Even the China haters at least understand what you're hating. You know, like, like right now you're just hating A abstract. A abstract concept that only exists in your mind. Yeah. So you know what's really funny? The haters. I'm sorry, I drew real quick.

The haters, actually, they film things that are not what they seem and then they show it as something else. There's a very famous video that's going around right now that a lot of the people who dislike China are posting, trying to prove that there are homeless people in China. I'm sure that there are some homeless people in China, but it's very rare. But they show these videos of like people sleeping in front of the train station, right?

You know, in the 30 minutes or an hour before it opens in the morning. And they're like proof that China has homeless people. And it's like most people don't even look homeless. They're just like on a mat, like kind of reading their phone like it, you know, they were right in front of a train station. Those people are clearly just waiting to get into the train station Or other examples. I'm sure you can find video of real homeless people in China.

But you know, I live in Beijing. As far as I know, when I visit, I travel around a lot. There's one guy I know of this for sure homeless one guy. So like, maybe there's somewhere else or something, but you know, I ride a bike, so I see everything, you know, I go through all kinds of different neighborhoods. There's one guy who's clearly

has some kind of issue. He's completely unkempt and he plays the arhu with a can in front of him with a QR code on it. He's the only guy I know in all of Beijing that is for sure homeless. So like, yes, maybe homelessness does exist, but the it's such an outlier. That's like .000 whatever statistical phenomenon that these people are. You know, you go to San Francisco and you know, it's like homeless person, homeless person, homeless person, homeless person. It's not the same at all.

So people who are clearly just, you know, I do, I want people who dislike China to come to China because I think it'll change a lot of minds. But for some people, they're just going to keep making up lies no matter what. Sure. Yeah. I think a lot of these lies are basically, you know, Copian,

Copian and opium. Because as US is experiencing its own very serious structural problems, you know, as some people say, US is going to decline and as China rise, there will be a lot of people who are trying to seek comfort in trying, trying to know all China is just as bad. So like, like, like US may be bad, may be getting worse, but China is even worse, right that that. It's. I think it's that kind of mentality that kind of fuels all these production of Copian that

we see on social media. And and I think it's gonna get worse, you know, when US experiencing more problems, unfortunately. And yeah, yeah. The only, only I think the only way is for people to actually be in China to see what it is for themselves and then to decide to for themselves. This is, you know, what is really going on here. And it's and you know, it's slightly not not for Americans yet, but it's a lot easier for

Europeans nowadays. You know many of these country already have 30 days visa free to visit to China. I think most European countries now now do. But unfortunately Americans still have to have to go go to the Chinese consulate to get a visa. But but I got my 10 year multi entry visa that's still valid until like 2029 so I'm good. Wow, Yeah, that's nice.

Yeah, I I also want to point out that I think that they I think the reason that U.S. citizens haven't been given the visa free thing is because I mean, the reality you're a geopolitical analyst is that the United States meddles in the internal

affairs of other countries. If China just gave blank checks for people to come to China for 30 days and from the United States, I think the concern is that American that the United States or the state government and whatever would use that as an opportunity to metal in China. So I think the United States sort of does did it to itself made it difficult for Americans to come to China. But I mean, it's actually also easier than ever before.

Like it used to be you have to go to the the the consulate to apply and then you have to go to back to the consulate to get the visa. And you also had used to have to book your hotels in advance and book your plane ticket in advance. Now you don't have to do any of that. Now you can apply online. You don't need a travel itinerary, you don't need a plan. You don't need any kind of weird health check or anything. You just apply online.

If you get approved, you go to the embassy one time to get your visa. So it's still easier for Americans, but it's not just, like as easy for the other, you know, dozens of countries that can just come to China whenever they want. Yeah, yeah, but I, I, I, I just recommend the people who do have the visa free privilege, you know, take advantage of it. Why not, you know, just yeah to visit. Totally. And and then China is, is such a huge country.

It actually has a lot to offer in terms of sightseeing for for traveler. Yeah, we're not sponsored by the Chinese tourism board, by the way. Yeah. But we're we're just speaking from experience because I actually I'm go. Ahead. Go ahead. You go ahead. No, no, no. I keep on interrupting you. You're my no. No, no, OK, all right, fine. I, I was going to add to your point about like there's a lot to see. So you like city is great. Go to Shenzhen, right?

You want to see the robots, you want to see flying cars and all that. Go to Shenzhen. If you want to see like the desert, you can got the, you can go to the Gobi Desert or the Taklamakan Desert, the sea of death, you know, if that's your thing, if you want it rain forest, you can go to Sichuan, which also has pandas, you know, and it also the cities that light up like Christmas trees, right? They're everywhere.

So whichever city you're going to, you're probably going to run into that Qingdao, Wuhan, Changsha, Shenzhen, Shanghai, even parts of downtown Beijing are like that now. So you're going to find that wherever you go, you or you want to go and you want to see traditional like Chinese culture, You can go to like Xi'an or you can go to Dali and Yunnan, or you actually want to go to Shangri-La. Guess what, it exists. I actually been doing some research on it. There's a city called Shangri-La

in you none. And I was like, oh, is this the real Shangri-La? So I looked at the book that's written like 1937 and the there's a couple movies and they're actually talking about a place that in the local Tibetan dialect. That's the name it's called like the the Valley of the Moon and Sun. And that's actually Shangri-La. That's the translation.

And so when they changed the name from from the Mandarin name to Shangri-La, it was to reflect, yes, that there is this Western obsession with this place called Shangri-La, but it was actually also the moniker of the city that in the Tibetan local dialect for the city. So it is actually Shangri-La. So if you want to go to Shangri-La, it's here. So like, I mean, there's so many different cool things to see. There's amazing little villages you can stay in.

Like what is it called? Huangling village in Xiangxi. It is paradiseic. You will not want to leave. I, after I left, I just now, I don't think my life can ever be as satisfying knowing that that place is there. And I'm not like it's, there's so many places in China to see. And then you got beaches, you know, you can go to Sanya, you, you know, Sanya Island. And you also have that in Fuji, and you also have a lot of that in Guangdong.

I mean, whatever kind of food you're into, you like spicy food, Sichuan, Chongqing, where you're from, like there's so many amazing places in China that whatever you're into, they have it. Yeah, people need to understand China is like US. It's a continental size country. It it it it's has great variety and and it has a lot of different cultural variations. People should, should, should

just come visit. Now, having said all of that, all everything, now I want to pick your brain a little bit, You know, what is your outlook for the future Sino American relationship? Now, obviously both of us wanted to see the relationship improve, but given the current trajectory, where do you do you see in the aftermath of she Trump meeting in Korea? You know, where do you think,

where do you think it's going? This is such a complex question because I, I, I generally try not to tell the future, but I also do this to all my guests. So I ask, I have, like you, all these brilliant people like Warwick Powell and other economists onto my show and I ask them the same thing constantly. What I understand and what I think is that the United States is in fact trying to provoke a

regional conflict in Asia. the United States is trying to use Japan, the Philippines and other nations near China to create the conditions for a regional conflict which would weaken Asia and potentially continue to prop up the Western, you know, LED order that's existed for the last several centuries and under imperialism or whatever we want to call what's going on now, neo colonialism, whatever it is. So, but I also think China is really playing the long game here.

And China hasn't had a war like since 1979, a real full out war. And that was one month. There have been some border skirmishes here and there with India, with the Philippines and stuff, but there hasn't been a major conflict. China's really just playing it out. If China can just wait 20 more years and not have any kind of military, major military conflict with anyone, the West will wither away. So we have our, I mean, not wither away, but be right sized in the international community.

Because I mean, just look back in the 1990s, what major powers were there in the world? It was the Europe, the United States, maybe Japan. That's kind of it, that those were the big boys on the chess board. Today, it's not like that. I mean, this concept of multipolarity is real. Even though they can't stop the conflict in, in the Middle East, you know, the war crimes that Israel's committing, there is still a multipolar world.

I mean, Southeast Asia, ASEAN is incredibly powerful in the in today's world and, and Japan continues to be, although that has its own economic problems. South Korea, China, India is even starting to really rise up now. There's a lot of development in some countries in Africa, the Middle East, the Central Asia, South America, you know, it's not the imperial LED world to some extent. So if China really wants. To have the advantage. China's economy is still growing.

And you know, everyone said, oh, China is going to grow at 4.2%. Then it was upgraded to 4.6%. Then it was upgraded to 4.8%. Now it's upgraded by Goldman Sachs at forecast to 5%. I still think it's going to be 5.2. I've been saying that the entire year from the beginning. I'm right. And I mean, time has proven that

I'm right. And every year I've been more, what's the word, bullish on China and every year I've been proven correct because China really has this ambition to grow at 4.7 GDP growth rate from 2020 to 2035 and it needs to maintain at least 5% for the next few years in order to make that happen. That's part of the common prosperity campaign. When China says we're doing something, they mean that's what's going to happen.

All of their five year plans and 10 year plans, they always come to fruition because China will, you know, move the gears around it's a planned economy. You know, a lot of it is you have a, you have a free economy, you have a vibrant market economy, but you also have a planned economy working in tandem. And when China says we're going to double GDP from 2020 to 2035, GDP for the entire country by growing at 4.7% every year, that means it's going to happen.

So what my point is in, in this context, the fact that China is growing at 5%, maybe more this year and probably at least 4.7 or 4.8, I think it's going to be more like 4.9 next year, means that the United States economy is still only growing at about around 2%. So China's growing at more than double the United States and a lot of other Western allies of the United States and Eastern allies are in decline and they're actually economies are contracting or close to

contracting, are barely growing at all and they're financialized. So that really means it probably is contracting in their real economies. So if China wants to, you know, rejoin all of its provinces, it would be much easier to do that through diplomacy and waiting because if a regional conflict occurs, the United States goal will be to use a Ukraine like situation to destroy not just

China, but all of his allies over here too. the United States isn't thinking like, hey, we're going to back you Japan, you're going to be more powerful. the United States really and the realpolitik secret circles are thinking we'll use Japan and China to destroy each other and then we'll be able to walk through and take over everything in Asia. So this is not in the interest of Japan. It's not in the interest of the Philippines. It's not in the interest of China.

All the region has to do, the most prosperous region, region, the most peaceful region in the world and has been for decades, is stay peaceful for the next decade or two. And all of the European powers in the United States will just become less relevant. And I think that is the play that they should go. But what's going to happen? I can't answer that question. What options are on the table? You know, like it can there be a major conflict?

the United States might try to create false flags and all of these, you know, situations to create conflict. So it's possible that that could happen. But really all China needs to do is what it's doing now. Just sit back, watch the West slowly become less relevant. So I mean, no one can tell the future, but you can see what what's on the table, what might happen. Yeah, I I think I agree with you. The time time is on China's side.

You know, China can afford to wait out US, you know, given the US current trajectory, it's besetted by a lot of domestic problems and, and even and in the I think we are slowly finally reaching a boiling point, you know, like maybe not boiling over yet, but we're getting there. You know, you have seen, you know, even Trump's own support base, MAGA is essentially having a civil war right now. So China just need to, you know, do what China does best, which

is to grow its own prosperity. By doing so, China's relative strength will strengthen year after year vis A vis United States. And, and so far, I think China is on the on the right path. I don't think China will be very easily baited into a war in East Asia because China, you know, Chinese leadership, not, they're not stupid, right?

They, they, they understand what the intentions of the Washington is. And you know, they, they, they have been, and they have a long tradition of strategic heritage that, you know, they, they thousands of years. They, they have, you know, they, they, they see, they have seen the, the playbook, you know, they, so, so I, I, I, I, I, I'm not too worried about a major war breaking out in East Asia, at least in the immediate future, you know, in 20 years,

who knows? But I, I think for next 5-10 years, I, you know, I think we're just going to witnessing more of the same, which is the steady progress of China itself, a more regional integration China with, particularly with ASEAN countries, you know, as, as a regional supply chain getting further integrated, you know, tie anchored with the Chinese market in the, in the middle. I think, I think that that's, that's what's going to happen.

I mean, this is the whole point of China building the Belden Rd. project, right? I mean, it's to build global connectivity points, but all these connected points all connects to China, and it makes China the center of this new network power. This is something that US has been trying to sabotage, but with without much success because ultimately China is bringing money to the table and US is not offering the alternatives.

You know, like the US is like, OK, the best I can do is military bases and some Typhoon missiles. But but people, but countries, yeah, globally needs development and, and, and infrastructure much more. So, you know, so, so China is winning on that front. So I, I, I, I, I agree with your assessment. And what but, but, but, but, but back to the China, US, China relationship though. Like do you think there could be a return quote UN quote to normalcy sometimes in the

future? You know, I have to think, I have to say I, I used to be less optimistic than am I? I am now. There's a man teaches at Princeton University, assistant professor. His name is Kyle Chan. And the fact that he even works at the Rand Corporation gives me hope because this man, he really

wants. Yeah. Just the fact that he works there at all makes me think, oh, there are sane people in the echo chamber, you know, like Mitch Presnick teaches at Harvard and Kyle Chan teaches at Princeton University. And there's a few other, you know, sane people in the United States who are in positions to influence policy. Unfortunately, none of them are in in politics. You know, these are real

academic people. They're just studying the numbers and the economy and how it can work that, you know, no offense. I'm not trying to insult them. I'm trying to compliment them. They are nerds. So they, you know, they're just people who are erudite and read a lot and study a lot and they're like, this is the best possible future. Let's go that direction.

And both of these gentlemen and other people like them want to see better economic integration, which would be in the which would be advantageous to the United States.

For example, there is a factory in Ohio that was created with a Chinese company called Lomi. And it's, I can't remember the, the, the American name of the company, but they make solar panels and they hired US workers using Chinese technology with Chinese and American investment and a joint venture to make solar by Americans in America for America. And that is the kind of thing that the United States could

benefit from. You know what, I, I, I actually really think this, you know, I'm, I'm just saying hope optimistically, we could see greater economic integration. And you know, at, at there's some point Japanese factories came to the United States and it was, it was great for the United States. It created a lot of jobs. And then we, we're at the point where Chinese technology is the best in the world. And I know there are people who disagree with that. They're wrong.

So if we could get Chinese technology built in America by Americans for America, that would be advantageous for the United States because it's not just buying products make made in China, which is also advantageous for the United States because cheap goods like. So actually there are a lot of ways that the United States and China complement one another. the United States is a highly financialized institution and the dollar remains pre eminent for now.

So as the United, as long as the United States wants to continue to buy products from China, it can. And that's to the advantage of US consumers. And building factories in the United States isn't working without China. But guess what? If China came in, China are the world experts on how to build factories. So like we could build factories. I mean, if it's about like, oh, we don't want them to own land or oh, we don't want them too close to US base, fine. Why can't we have special

economic zones? That's what we should have. We should have two or three special economic zones near ports in the United States, not just for China, for any companies around the world who want to come and hire American workers to make things in America, for America, or even for export. I guarantee you Chinese companies would line up for that. There would be tons of investment.

We'd be talking about 10s of billions of dollars being poured into the United States year after year after year after year after year to build in the United States and hire American workers. You know, so there are these voices who say things like this. I hope that's what happens. But unfortunately, America is a game of political football and whoever's making the decisions isn't making the decisions for very long. And so I'm not really. I don't know what the United States is gonna do.

Is Trump. Are Trump and XI in April when they meet in China, gonna make a better deal? I think so. My own feeling is that Trump is the kind of person who wants to be a winner, and that's how he sees himself. He sees himself as a winner. And if he can sit down, the two most powerful leaders in the world can sit down and make a deal that's advantageous for both countries. Trump wants to walk out of China saying, oh, my best friend, President Xi and I just made

this great deal. It's going to be great for America. And it can't just be on paper. He needs a win because the trade war has been going so badly for the United States. So if Trump could walk out of Beijing with a deal that helps America, I think he wants to do that. So hopefully Besant is setting the, you know, situation up for that. Unfortunately, you have people like Rubio who are in the in the administration and they are very hawkish on China.

So it's a mixed bag really. Yeah, I think I, I don't think the, the US will change its trajectory easily. I mean, I, I'm, but I, I agree with you. There is a little bit of vibe shift already. You are seeing some part of the elite are starting to recognize that China is a peer that cannot be pushed around anymore. And I think that maybe, maybe we'll take a whole generation for United States to go through the, you know, whatever it needs to go through to resolve its own domestic problems.

Because a lot of these blaming China, anti China stuff come from ultimately the own, the EU s s own weakness, The, the, the, the, the, the domestic structural problems, the real structural problem that's affecting U.S. economy. And I, I think as long as these won't be resolved, there will always be tensions in the US China relationship. And, you know, I expect this might, it might take a whole generation to fix United States. You know, like, like this is a

long term project. It's not going to be done in next four years or, or, or five years or even 10 years. This could usually be like a 25 years, 30-40 year project to fix United States. And, and, and so, so if that does happen, I think there could be, you know, US and China can be back on right footing, so to speak, to have a normal relationship between normal countries. You know, one of the problem is I think US is not a normal

country right now. It's, it's, it's, it's, it's, it needs, it's needs to cure of its sickness. And, and once that happens, you can deal with China on a more confident, more confident place. And, you know, a lot, lot of the lot of these anger, anxiety and fear is really derived from ultimately the American weakness. I think, you know, once that that that thing is getting resolved, I think two countries will be fine.

So I, I, I, I unfortunately, I think China is the rational player here and and China has been, you know, playing this game very patiently, just continue to grow its own strength. Now China's not seeking to you replace United States as a global hedge amount as many people fear that China just want to build a better China be the best China that that China can be.

States could learn from China. You know, if if US just invest on itself, focus on its internal development, you know, you will being a much healthier place and, and you know, you know, if you really, really us really want to compete with China, it needs to fix itself. It needs to look internally, not not looking to try to handicap China's progress. You know, like the Tonya Harden approach of recapping your

competitor. But but but really focus on your own skills sets to to develop your invest in your home, own human capital. And then, you know, then there will be more a chance or equal chance, But you know, you, you, you require people to take the long approach, the long term approach. You know, one of the unfortunately one of the problem in the US is like, everything is kind of very short term oriented, right? So all about quarterly earning reports and the next election

cycle. So that's one of the thing that needs to be ironed out as well. So I I expect this to be a long term generational project to fix USI think, I think once that's done, the US and China can have a healthy, normal relationship. Yeah, I think that's a really good point. I mean, I also think that, you know, the UK used to was formerly the world power. The United States became the world power following that cycle.

And what's really interesting is about the UK was special in that it was sort of like, oh, you're going to be the new real world power. You're my best buddy. And, you know, I think that was an interesting strategy.

I think the United States has an interesting opportunity to see if, you know, it's obvious to anyone who actually knows the facts, not the people who are just making stuff up and lying about the reality of the situation, that China is going to be the major economy for the next century. So if the United States really wants to benefit and, you know, the short, mid and long term, hitching its boat to the China is actually a really good idea. I Yeah, I hope, I hope you know

from. From your words to to the God's mouth, you know, I hope, I hope some people in Washington, you know, can finally get come to their senses, you know? Maybe. Maybe. If anybody's watching our show, make sure people take Jason's words to the relevant people. But really, I, I think I, I, you know, 100% agree with you. You know, you're fascinated. Go ahead. Yeah. No. No, I was just going to say it's

really interesting. That the United States has chosen this really bizarre framework because I think this has to do with game theory. Honestly, I think I'm gonna blame game theory. Like the whole idea in the West is that everything is a game. Everyone wants to win and this is the objectives. And I think that, you know, we've you know, John Mearsheimer argument that's been going around, right? The John. Mearsheimer China wants to rule the world. Because everyone wants to rule the world.

This is not a Tears For Fears song, guys. This is the world. And China has 1000 years. Jeffrey Sachs just pointed out China has 1000 years of not invading its neighbors, you know, 10 centuries of not invading its neighbors. And then, you know, actually China is actually an introvert for a lot of that. It's like, we don't want to even want to trade with you. You know, when the trade ambassador showed up to China, China was like, you know, we're just not into that right now.

Like we're doing our own thing. China is not eager to take over the world. You know, China, like you said, wants to develop itself and make itself very prosperous. That's its goal. That is its goal. So what we need to do is rethink in DC and, you know, and Langley, what is China's goal? China is China's goal is not

world domination. China's goal is to become the most, you know, prosperous version of itself that it can be and fulfill, you know, thousands of years of that goal of having everyone be really prosperous and successful. And the idea that the United States is surrounding China with all these bases and China's going to break out any moment is kind of crazy. Really. It's like, you know, the bully at school. School is like that kid is working out. They're going to become the next bully.

Everyone we're going to form a gang and surround them and they're just working out. It's like just because they're working out doesn't mean they want to fight. Like it's, it's, it's really kind of crazy. Yeah. I I think. I think maybe hopefully they can't get into their heads that United States does not have to be a global hedge fund to be a successful country because USUS has US is very secure. It has two oceans as its borders.

You know it, it's not, it's not facing any imminent invasions threat from anyone. And so it, it can't afford to develop itself. And, and you know, like, like, like as this example that you gave UK, it gave up its empire. But the British people, people are living far better today than they were under the British imperial days.

You know, that can still happen that that can still happen for for Americans, you know, it's still a real possibility for United States. It just require you to give up this kind of 0 sum mindset. And there's this kind of the the world domination mental bug, But you know, that will take time. That will take time. So hopefully, hopefully we'll, we'll we'll we'll be we'll still be around to win this change.

But I, I really enjoy having this conversation with you, Jason. Likewise, you know, we could yeah, then we could talk about this for for hours. But but anyway, this is an ongoing story still evolving. And you know, we'll probably, I would like to have invite you back in the future, you know, probably before the XI Trump

visit. In Beijing and and just to to kind of geek out on this because US China relationship really is the most important bilateral relationship in the world right now and and and for the future so you know it's you know and this is I can geek out geek out on this for hours but it's been fun for people who want to follow you Jason where would they go well if you're on X it's. Shengguan Tia one that's going to be difficult to to find.

Yeah. Or just spell if you're American. But if you just want to find my podcast, you can find the Bridge to China podcast and type in the Bridge to China podcast and Google will pop right up. That's a great name, by the way. And I thank you, thank you for making the time to to, to be on my show. We'd love to have you back on our podcast, too. So we'll be reaching out as well, anytime, any time. I love to talk, man. If you did notice, so for for

people who've been watching. The show thank you for. Tuning in until next time, bye bye.

Transcript source: Provided by creator in RSS feed: download file
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android