TRUE CRIME CHRONICLES-Volume 2-Mike Rothmiller - podcast episode cover

TRUE CRIME CHRONICLES-Volume 2-Mike Rothmiller

Jan 28, 20211 hr 5 minEp. 556
--:--
--:--
Download Metacast podcast app
Listen to this episode in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episode description

They were all subjects of true crime newspaper reporting in the 1800s. And now these stories and that of many others are brought together in their original form in a two-volume set: TRUE CRIME CHRONICLES: ​Serial Killers, Outlaws, and Justice ... Real Crime Stories From The 1800s.

Compiled and commented on by New York Times bestselling author and former detective Mike Rothmiller, these classic works of journalism resurrect astonishing stories that will take the reader on a fascinating journey back in time to when these horrific tales mesmerized a nation. Some may find these articles and their descriptions of people and crimes shocking by today’s standards, but they are representative of the most colorful true crime stories of the day

TRUE CRIME CHRONICLES, Volume Two, includes stories about Billy the Kid, Jesse James, the legendary “Jack the Ripper,” Lizzie Halliday, Anna Maria Zwanziger, Jack the Haircutter, Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, The Nebraska Murderer, and many more shocking stories. Follow along as these reporters from another century visit the crime scenes, interview witnesses, and pen the stories of murder, evil, and swift frontier justice. TRUE CRIME CHRONICLES-Volume Two: Serial Killers, Outlaws And Justice....Real Crime Stories from the 1800's-Mike Rothmiller Follow and comment on Facebook-TRUE MURDER: The Most Shocking Killers in True Crime History   https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100064697978510Check out TRUE MURDER PODCAST @ truemurderpodcast.com

Transcript

Speaker 1

Judy was boring.

Speaker 2

Hello.

Speaker 3

Then Judy discovered chumpacasino dot com.

Speaker 1

It's my little escape.

Speaker 3

Now Judy is the life of the party.

Speaker 1

Oh baby mama is bringing home the bacon.

Speaker 3

WHOA, take it easy, Judy, The chump of life's for everybody. So go to chumpacasino dot com and play over one hundred casino style games. Join today and play for free for your chance to redeem some serious prices. Jump chumpacasino dot com. Noe's necessarily, we're poittedt by montem lost terms and condition to plaice.

Speaker 4

What's every details?

Speaker 1

Step into the world of power, loyalty and luck.

Speaker 5

I'm gonna make him an offer you can't refuse.

Speaker 1

With family canoli's and spins mean everything? Now you want to get mixed up in the family business, Introducing the Godfather at champacasino dot com. Test your luck in the shadowy world at the Godfather Slough.

Speaker 5

Someday I will call upon you to do a service for me.

Speaker 1

Play the Godfather now at chumpacasino dot com. Welcome to the Family vdW group. NOPERD is necessary if we were pribitted by loss he terms and conditions eighteen plus.

Speaker 2

You are now listening to True Murder the most shocking killers in true crime history and the authors that have written about them Gasey, Bundy, Dahmer, The Nightstalker VTK Every week another fascinating author talking about the most shocking and infamous killers in true crime history.

Speaker 5

True Murder with your host, journalist and author Dan Zupanski, Good Evening. What do Jack the Ripper, Jesse James, the Texas Servant, Girl Annihilator, Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid

and Jack the Kisser have in common? They were all subjects of true crime newspaper reporting in the eighteen hundreds, and now these stories and that of many others, are brought together in their original form in a two volume set True Crime Chronicles, Serial Killers, Outlaws and Justice, Real crime stories from the eighteen hundreds, compiled and commented on by New York Times bestselling author and former detective Mike Rothmiller.

These classic works of journalism resurrect astonishing stories that will take the reader on a fascinating journey back in time to when these horrific tales mesmerized a nation. Some may find these articles and their descriptions of people and crimes shocking by today's standards, but they are representative of the

most colorful true crime stories of the day. True Crime Chronicles Volume two include stories about Billy the Kidd, Jesse James, the Legendary, Jack the Ripper, Lizzie Halliday, Anna, Marie Swanzigger, Jack the Haircutter, Butch Cassidy, and the Sundance Kid, the Nebraska Murderer, and many more. Shocking stories follow along as these reporters from another century visit the crime scenes, interview witnesses, and pen the stories of murder, evil and swift frontier justice.

The book that we're featuring this evening is True Crime Chronicles Volume two, Serial Killers, Outlaws and Justice, Real crime stories from the eighteen hundreds, with my special guest journalist and author and true crime historian Mike Rothmiller. Welcome back to the program, and thank you so much for this interview. Mike Rothmiller.

Speaker 4

It's my pleasure to be here.

Speaker 5

Thank you so much. This is a fascinating, fascinating book. Let's talk about For those that didn't hear the earlier interview this month for the volume one, maybe you can just repeat or reiterate basically the intention of this and the unique format used to convey these incredible stories.

Speaker 4

Sure, a little bit of background on it. I was researching another book in various archives, and I kept coming across fascinating stories that were written in newspapers regarding serial killers and other albumos and so forth, and the way they were written. They were very dramatic, very detailed, and very grisly in some cases, and they just fascinated me. And I thought that was rather interesting because those stories

mesmerized the country at the time. So I decided to bring those forward, resurrect those stories as they were written, because I couldn't do a better job describing it. And if I did, on some of these serial killers, people would say, well, jeez, that that sounds crazy. How do you notice, Well, this is from the reporters who were there at the scene and attended the trials and the

lynchings and everything, so it was first hand information. In some cases it ends up being witnessed testimony, and it's just absolutely fascinating the detail they get into what they were able to cover. In what I'm speaking of. Then, when I was a detective, there are certain things that you told the press, but you held back a lot.

In these stories, nothing was held back they talked about the type of crime, the injuries, They described them in great detail, to the victims, They described the weapons used, where the bodies were found, how they were found, and ones that were mutilated how they're mutilated. So it's a fascinating read. It gets into a great deal of detail that people just don't read today unless it's in a novel somewhere. But you certainly would not read that type

of information in a newspaper today. So with that in mind, I decided to keep the stories as they were written and then provide a commentary from my perspective about these stories and why they were significant or what made them very very strange beyond what was written. And I wrote that from a historian and the detective's point of view to basically all the stories that are in both the books, volume one and volume two.

Speaker 5

Right now, in terms of the contents, you have the intro, then you have serial killers, the Other Jacks, the Old West, the assassination of President Abraham Lincoln, and you have short crime stories. Yeah, so let's start with Let's start with and you mentioned that you usually have a commentary here before the story or afterwards. You start off with, of course, the most infamous true crime story ever and character Jack

the Ripper. What does give us your commentary that you provide for the articles that you present about Jack the Ripper.

Speaker 4

Well, one, I introduced the crime itself because there's some people, even though it's very, very famous, they do not know about Jack the Ripper, and so I had to provide some background about that in the time frame and where it was occurring, and what this person was doing, and how many basically female prostitutes were rerually murdered and a lot of them dismembered by him, and sometimes it's just some very strange things that he did to their body.

So I lay that out. I lay out what happened in that area Whitechapel in New York and why a pardon me not New York in London, and why it was considered a lower class area where there're prostitutes, a lot of criminals and so forth. And then I get into the issue of people who are identifying various men said, I think this guy's Jack the Ripper, and that guy's Jack the Ripper. And the first guy they labeled was

called the leather Apron, who was the first killing. And that's because they found a leather apron at one scene and they said, well, gee, there must be this s guy and so they start calling the leather apron killer.

So that's background information for people that's very useful. And then I get into one of the articles too regarding the Chief of Detectives for Scotland Yard who headed up the investigation and what he had to say during his interview about Jack the Ripper, and ultimately he states, and I've been able to verify a lot of it since then, that they did in fact capture Jack the Ripper, and I talked about it in there, but they didn't have

enough to convict him in a criminal court. So under the power of the Crown, which was the power of the Queen, they decided okay, they went to their Secretary of State basically and said, this is the guy who's been doing it. He's insane, and so with a single stroke of a pen, he was put into a mental hospital for the criminally insane, and they called it the

Lunatic Asylum. And so this is where I get into and all the stories talk about this who Jack the Ripper was, the revelations about him made by the Chief of Detectives, and if quite Frankly, if anybody knew about Jack the Ripper, it's going to be the chief of detectives who handled it at the time, and so his interview was in there about the entire story.

Speaker 5

Yeah, it's interesting. I had never actually read that conclusion that they had captured Jack the Ripper and then put him in a same asylum. I never read that conclusion. And as many Jack the Ripper books have been featured on this program.

Speaker 4

So yes, I know, And like I said, since then, I have a colleague. We've co written a book that will come out in July in London, and we've dug up more information confirming it that Jack the Ripper was in fact captured by Scotland Yard and put into the

broad More Lunatic Asylum as they call it. So we're going to dig a little bit deeper still and we'll probably i think within another few months once there archives opened up for people to go and we'll probably be able to identify who Jack the Ripper was.

Speaker 5

Wow, that's incredible. You have a section called the Other Jacks. What is the other Jacks about?

Speaker 4

Well, the other Jack's that, if anything, that was a little lighter part of Jack. And they called several different people, and they went through time, but mainly in the East Coast. But one was Jack the Haircutter, Jack the Kisser, Jack the hugger, and Jack the Cutter, and basically what it was during the eighteen hundreds, primarily in New York and Washington and some other areas on the East Coast, Jack the Haircutter. There were a lot of want to be

Jack the haircutters once the word got out. But when a woman or a girl would be walking down the streets, he's got long hair, ponytails. These guys would run up to them, grab them and generally with the straight razor scissors, cut off their ponytails, keep the ponytails and the long hair and run away. And this was not uncommon. A lot of copycats going on. So that is Jack the Haircutter, and the stories are in there about him. Jack the

Kisser was just what it says. Once again, there were copycats in the same locations and they would ride their buggies or a horse that they're walking down the street and they'd see a girl or a woman they would grab her and then kiss her. And the one guy, the main guy, would generally end up with a poem he would tell him some poem and then they would take off, they would disappear. So that was very popular.

Jack the Hugger, as it states, these guys would see a woman and they would run up to her and hug her, and the woman would fight, try to get away. They keep hugging her. Then they would let her go and they would run away. And that was a very popular if you want to say, it was a crime in a sense. But sometimes I think a lot of these the articles were they were maybe joking, but there

were copycats. Jack the Cutter was a interesting character who did not like long dresses on women that were dragging on the ground. So those are primarily in Washington, d c. That this occurred. But he would see some moment with a long skirt and if it was dragging on the ground, he would jump out with a pair of scissors shears. He'd run up to them, he'd grab them and he would cut their dresses off another six or seven inches

so they would and drag on the ground. And so that was more of a sounds like more of a fetish in some bizarre way. So that was Jack the Cutter. So when I was doing the research, quite Frankly, I didn't know about any of these other Jacks, and I thought the stories are so interesting because they all occurred around the same period of time, and I just thought I had to include them because they were so unusual and so different. So that's how all the other Jacks ended up being in the book.

Speaker 5

Let's go to a far more incredible story. September eleventh, eighteen ninety three, and you have the Courier News and the headline A murderous maniac. And for the audience this the term maniac is used in these articles all the time, it seems. Anyway, this is a crimes charged against Lizzie Holliday and a mania. Like Jack the Ripper, she killed and mutilated her first husband in same manner as second, and then the McQuillan women were murdered through a thirst

for blood. Tell us what do you have to say about Lizzie Halliday and why this story was so compelling.

Speaker 4

Well, Lizzie, well, the primary reason. There are very few serial killers who were women through time, generally their man and in most cases younger men, so was of interest immediately. And then when I started reading the articles about her, I realized that she was probably for most of her life, she would be considered insane and she just would kill. She killed a couple of her husbands, and she would kill for a variety of reasons, but truly they were

never known. And so she was eventually convicted and imprisoned. And there was one woman who basically was like a warden they call them, and their guards who pretty much befriended her and was able to control her because she was just really wild. She would attack people for no reason,

or whatever her reason was, nobody really knew. And so when this woman finally told her that she was leaving the prison system, Lizzie got upset and just decided to go ahead and try to stab her to death in prison, and she just attacked her, and then Lizzie ended up after she was convicted of these other murders of Sarah Quinlan and Eloquent mcquinland. She was the first woman to be electrocuted in the United States to receive the death penalty.

So she was very very strange, very diabolical, and as some of the articles pointed out, they said that she was the worst woman on earth because they pretty much narrowed it down that she killed five people her husband's step son, two women friends, and then the nurse in the asylum where she was sentenced. So she was very very different, very bizarre. And as far as the story of very interesting story.

Speaker 5

You include the Texas Servant Girl annihilator eighteen eighty four in Austin, Texas and this city in a state of panic, and the seven or more women were murdered apparently by the serial killer using an axe or a knife. Tell us a little bit more about this Texas Servant Girl.

Speaker 4

Yeah, in most cases the women were African American, and in many cases they were young. And what they were was they were for better term, acting as live in maids, live in cooks, and so forth, and some wealthy or upper class white families. And this guy would come in at night when everybody was asleep, and generally speaking killed them in their bed with an axe. You would split their skulls wide open, and the articles talk about how the brains are all over the room and so forth.

But he would do this, and they believed eventually, and all the other resorts said that he was probably an African American man, but there weren't quite sure. And so he went into This guy went into one room with whether he was a copycat or not. And there were two women in there, two white girls in the attack them in the same way, who'd either cut their throats, but generally an axe was used and he would go

for the head or go for the neck. A few times bodies were taken outside of the bedroom where the initial attack occurred. He would drag him off, maybe fifty sixty hundred yards and then he would just go at him with an axe or a knife and leave the body. But he was never caught. They had suspicions. One time they had a descript of a guy who did attack these two girls who were both white, but once again

they never caught him and he took off. But the Texas Servant Girl Annihilator was that's what they called name in the newspaper articles, and that's what he did. He just annihilated servant girls. And then there was question worried because all of a sudden, the murders stopped and they start happening in other locations, and they were very concerned that this is the Texas Servant Girl Annihilator and he's just relocated to another city, and it was reoccurring. Whether

that's true or not. Nobody knows at this time. It may have been the same person and may have been a copycat. They just don't know. But a very interesting story about a man who used an axe most cases and just would brutally, brutally murder people in their bedroom.

Speaker 5

You have a story of Anna Maria zwanziger And born in seventeen sixty and beheaded September eighteen eleven for murder. And this is she worked in several German homes as a housekeeper and cook. What was her preference for people she worked with and people she killed.

Speaker 4

Her preference was generally she wanted to work for judges and upper middle class people. And her favorite way of taking out people was with poison. And so she would poison people and they would get very ill and should pretend that she's nursing them back to health and so forth. A few times that worked, many times the person died.

And so they were able to check for various poisons back then, their various corners around the world, and they kept coming of Arsenic was a very favorite poison to use them, and they would find it, and they eventually convicted her, and as you said, she was executed, but she just had a passion for using poison as opposed to a knife or a gun or anything else. But she was just a very very disturbed and very interesting woman.

Speaker 5

Yes, absolutely, you have a story called the Nebraska Killer. What's the most notable characteristic or thing about this killer that you noted and you included in this?

Speaker 4

He was very cold and calculating, and when he was arrested, they were taking him by train back to Nebraska to stand trial, and some reporters got on the train with them, and as I said, they would just go ahead and conduct interviews, and the police would say, hey, this is great, go ahead and talk to the guy. And in most cases these people would come out with a confession, say yeah, I did this, I did that. But he ended up killing six people that they know of and that they

prosecuted him for. He is only in his early twenties, but he was extremely cool and collected when he was talking to reporters. But the one thing he was really interested in is that there was no spinning in these stories, no spinning by the reporters, no embellishment, and no fake news. He just wanted the facts to come out about him what he did. And if you want to say his reasoning,

his reasoning for doing it. But he was just a very very disturbed into visual once again, and he would just matter of fact talk to the reporters, very slow, very cunning. And one of the people that he killed after he killed this family was a baby, and the baby continued to cry, and so he just got mad and he killed the baby. And they said, oh, basically, why did you kill the babies? Well, it wouldn't shut up,

kept crying, and so he did that. Then he basically dumped the bodies next to the house and cover them up and took off. But a very cold calculated character. And reading his interview from those reporters, it really gets into his mind how he worked. And obviously he was a serial killer at that stage. He murdered quite a few. And then you just step back and you say, hey, this is his logic, this is what he's saying. It is very bizarre because you're in these stories. It's actually

that you're listening to him. You're sitting there as the reporter listening to him talk about this and making his confession and so forth, and you walk away from going this guy was nuts and very deadly, and it just it's kind of frightening to a lot of people people like that today.

Speaker 5

Yeah, yeah, it's interesting, especially because he wanted only the truth to be had by these reporters, to document the truth. And yet that's inconsistent with the barbarity of the crimes that he did. You would think with someone where would be questionable the crime somewhat and he would be worried

about the perception by the public. But it didn't make sense his request that they'd be accurate, especially given the again the brutality of these murders, you know, a baby and with than iron in the face and crushing skulls.

Speaker 4

Yes, and so when you step back and look said, wait a minute, it's how is his brain working and what is the logic behind this? Like a lot of these serial killers, like Lizzie, she was insane, This guy, you can say is insane, but like a lot of them, he probably wasn't. And you just wonder, Okay, now he knows, or he has to anticipate, he's going to be found guilty,

he's going to be executed. So why is he so concerned about this at this stage and insistent that hey, you print the facts, you know, not the nonsense, just the facts, and so once again it takes you into the mind of a killer and how they thought about their situation at the time. And some of these people are like this guy. You wouldn't want to meet him on a dark night anywhere. You know. He's just like

the Texas Servant Girl, Nihilator and so forth. Very scary people, very brutal, and very dangerous.

Speaker 5

In this section, you still call serial killers. We've covered this with an author in January, the Atlanta Ripper, but it's worth mentioning again because the incredible nature of these crimes. The Atlanta Ripper is named because there is some association with Jack the Ripper. Tell us a little bit about the incredible Atlanta Ripper.

Speaker 4

Yeah, he was basically during the early nineteen it's about nineteen ten, somewhere around in nineteen eleven. He would basically work like Jack the Ripper did. He would work the streets and a lot of times hit alleys, and he would attack women, not just prostitutes, but any woman walking along of any age. It could be a mother, working class woman. And all of his victims were black, and basically he would attack them on deserted streets in very

dark places. He would ambush them. Obviously they wouldn't see him coming, and all of them were killed there on the scene. A lot of times he would what they're expecting that he would use an axe, hand acts or hard object and hit them in the head, probably kill them outright, if not, certainly cause issues, and then he would just go ahead and cut the throat or let him bleed out, or behead them. And the murders generally always occurred on Saturday night and the bodies were discovered

on Sunday mornings. So in Atlanta at the time, there were loads of men who were arrested on suspicion and they were all were let go. And the killer remains unknown to this day. Whether it was one person working alone or two or what. Nobody knows. But he's just another I'm saying he assuming was. He's just another serial killer that just vanished and nobody was ever proven to

be that person. They have it up to at least eighteen girls females were killed by him, but they don't know if that's a complete number or truly how accurate is because a lot of them they just found the bodies and they said, well, we think it's him, but we really can't be sure, but it sent a panic through that entire community, especially for women who were working into the evening, whether they were servants in a home or at a factory or whatever, and when they were

going home, especially African American women, they were the targets, and so they were terrified at night. And it went on for a while until finally he just kind of vanished.

Speaker 5

You talk about the New York Ripper. Excuse me when I found most interesting was you talk of the fear of Jack the Ripper leaving London and traveling to other parts of the world. Yeah, this is what the New York Ripper is about. Just tell us about that.

Speaker 4

Yeah, that was an interesting case. It was right after a few years after Jack the Ripper was active in Whitechapel in London, and they start having some deaths occurring of primarily prostitutes who are found nearly killed in the same fascist Jack the Ripper and London, and I mean their bodies are mutilated. I know there was one that the guy absuming the guide removed the woman's intestines and coiled them up on a table next to it, removed organs.

Some of the organs of these people were missing so he took time to not only kill them, but to dismember them. And by taking the various body parts, you're assuming that he's taking a trophy, because I know a few of the murders I dealt with as a detective that they would take sometimes clothing, sometimes part of the body as a souvenir as a reminder of this murder

they committed. And so what was really sad about that there was a guy this thing in a hotel, Middle Eastern fellow was not fluent in English, and he was basically down the hall from this one woman that was found mutilated, and his name was Frenchy, And for some reason the detectives, probably because of pressure there getting arrested him and he was charged and so forth. But as it turned out, and all the information's in here and how it happened went down, he was not the murderer.

But they were just fine with having him go to prison and probably be executed. They were thinking in the beginning, and he was not the guy. And so what happened was there a number of reporters who were at the scene, and the detective claimed that there was a blood trail leading from that room. In his room and they were there right when the detective was and they said, wait a minute, there was no blood trail and other things

that he talked about. The detective it so finally they brought this up, and the governor pardoned this man after a number of years. And why the detective or detectives falsified the information and the evidence to convict this guy, You'll just never know. And you know, it's something that's horrible because this guy could have been easily executed, and even today things like that occur. But the New York Ripper, as this guy was known as, just vanished once again. Nobody knows who he was.

Speaker 5

Lessi's is an opportunity to stop for this break for our sponsor, which is Best Fiends. My favorite guilty pleasure right now is watching Netflix true crime docs like the recent The night Stalker. Another guilty pleasure right now is playing Best Fiends. It's always a lot of fun to play. Best Fiends is a unique match three puzzle game with literally thousands of levels and new content added constantly. I've just started playing a few weeks ago and I'm already

on level fifty and obsessed. There are more and more tough challenges It's easy to play, but you want badly to get more levels. Playing Best Beanes has been a great way to get my mind off all the serious stuff I read every day. The characters to kill the evil slugs are very entertaining, but the increasing challenges make me want to continue. I love the challenges. I think my listeners might love it too. With over one hundred million downloads, this Live Star rated mobile puzzle game is

definitely a must play. Once you download Best Fnes, you'll get used to telling yourself just one more level. With more levels, events and challenges added every month so you can binge and binge and never be bored. Download Best Friends Best Fiends free today on the Apple App Store

or Google Play. That's Friends without the r best themes. Now, Mike, the next section in your book is the Old West, and remarkably and incredibly you talk about all of the people that we think we know through movies like Butch Casting and The Sundance Kid. In nineteen sixty nine, Paul Newman and Robert Redford portrayed these outlaws in this feature film. You have a commentary for Butch Casting and the Sundance Kid. What is that?

Speaker 4

Well, basically, it's their true story. I said, We've seen the movies, we've read books, we've heard stories, and in most cases they're wrong. Yeah, these guys were outlaws, they were doing various things. But what was always interesting is that in the movie they were you know, read and Newman portrayed these guys. Yeah, they were criminals, but they were kind of just fun loving guys. You know. Yeah, they were pulling some robberies in this, but they really

didn't want to hurt anybody. With a romantic twist. Well, that's what most people believe, but these articles get into it. They weren't fun loving guys. They were roofless criminals, and they killed a lot of people. And they're always involved in criminal activity for a long time. They had from some of the articles they're talking about, how butch Cassidy for a better term ran if you want to say, a small army in the Rocky Mountains of about five hundred outlaws.

Speaker 5

Wow.

Speaker 4

Yeah, And then they would move through different areas. But then finally there was a secret conference that was conducted with the governors of Colorado, Utah, Wyoming, and I believe was Idaho that they had to stop Cassidy and they had for a better term, had to put together their

group of people to try to hunt them down. And so it gets into the whole story about how bad these fellows really were, and it goes from for better term, from their beginning to their end in Bolivia and basically what happened after they were being chased down here in the early nineteen hundreds and a lot of their if you want to say, their captains of their outlaw gang, were captured or killed and kind of went their own way.

They took off and went to first through Mexico and Central America, and they ended up Bolivia and then they started up robbing people again, robbing training, stage coaches or whatever it was, and they killed several people in Bolivia, and then they were running again as they're being chased down into Argentina in that area. But it ended up in Bolivia where they found them hiding out and they had a shootout with some troops military troops, and they

were killed at the time. But what is interesting is that even today a lot of people believe that they escaped and that they made it back to the US and continued just a quiet life. That is interesting. But the Bolivians, the people they soldiers. They killed two guys and they buried them down there, and everybody, all historians, I say, believe that that is absolutely true that they were buried, and the rest of it is just folklore. That they made it back to the States and they

lived quietly ever after. But this sets the record straight because these stories were written at the time, and it gets into what bad guys they truly were, them and their gang, and how long they terrorized a section of the country. So it will enlighten a lot of people.

Speaker 5

Absolutely. You include a story called the Manketto executions particularly disturbing. Thirty eight Siu Indians hung eighteen sixty two while the Civil War in the US was raging. Tell us about this story.

Speaker 4

And the cover, yes, really really well, the press coverage was nothing. It was literally two sentences and that was it. And what happened was around eighteen sixty two, the Sioux nation up in the Dakotas for bedroom, They're being invaded by a lot of settlers moving in, taking their lands,

killing off all the game that they survived on. And a hunting party was out one day and they rans people and they hunting party about five or six Sioux and they killed these people, these white people that were there. So that got everybody obviously very upset that the Sioux were doing this, and the Civil War was raging. It wasn't going well for Lincoln and the Union, and so Lincoln had to do something, and he was getting pressured heavily because this could be the start of another war

with the Indian nations. And then he was worried that, well, if they start fighting the Sioux, they've got to pull soldiers away from fighting the Confederates. And then he was concerned that the other Indian nations may join the Sioux. And quite frankly, at the time, the Plains Indians were the best horsemen around and probably the best soldiers around. And so he authorized to have the army going there and basically try to make a deal and bring these

people in. And they said, okay, they'll do that. So they went out. They kind of negotiated with this one chief and he brought in his warriors and they're arrested. They brought in basically about four to five hundred. The records aren't completely clear on that, but they brought him in, they surrendered, and then they decide, okay, we're going to put all these guys on trial, all these Sioux Indians.

So they have a military tribunal. Some of the trials of these fellows were about a minute long or thirty seconds. Said what's your name? They give the Indian name. They say, fine, you're guilty, You're going to die, and the next guy please. So they ran through this. They send a letter to Abraham Lincoln. This general does with all these Indian names. He wants to hang all of them, all of them and found guilty. He wants execute all of them. And it was over four hundred. Lincoln, look, I said, none

on a way. We can't just arbitrarily hang you know, four to five hundred Sioux Indians, because that will not go well in the country, especially within the Indian nation. So he narrows it down. He says, well, just give me the ones that raped white women. So that came down a very short list, just a couple. He says, well, that's not good. We've got to execute more to show that we're serious about this and to try to dissuade them from killing more whites. So he personally selected thirty

eight names Indian names to hang them. He issued the order. It goes up so they have a massive gallows built to hang all of them at one time. They bring in the soldiers, they surround the area. They start calling off the names of the Sioux to take their place under the hangman's news, and they call them off, and they walk up there and they start singing the death song and the death chant, and they hang them all. Boom,

they're done, thirty eight of them. Well, they find out later that two of them that they hung they hung by mistake. There were young kids, and it's just that when this soldier called them off the names, the kids said, well, that's me because he mispronounced it. So they walked up and they were hung by mistake. They're completely innocent. So they take the bodies, they bury them in the sand

down by the river. And then some other people going afterwards, some whites for souvenirs for body parts, and they take bodies to sell them to doctors and to for better medical schools so they could perform autopsies on these cadavers and just learn from them. So they do that. So all these people are killed as the largest mass execution in American history. Yet in eighteen sixty three, I think it was the Summit County Beacon. They basically had six

words about it. It's just on the date, thirty six Sioux Indians hung in Minnesota. That was it. And then in eighteen eighty one there was an article about one of the boards or the two by fours or four by fours that were used from the gallows to hanged Indians that it was being donated to the State University of Museum in Saint Paul, and that was a great artifact.

They're proud to have it. And then later on in eighteen ninety there's an article about a guy coming into town and he has a scalp from one of the Sioux that was hung back then. He got it from his brother in law, who is a soldier. So what's interesting is that it's the larger mass execution in US history, and yet the first article was all of about six words. That's it. And that just shows you how Native Americans

at the time were looked at. I mean, if they killed thirty six dogs or something, or cattle, it would have probably had the same response in the newspaper. So it just takes you back to a time and you can understand how Native Americans were looked at at the time, and we still had years down the road the Indian Wars. But you just look at and say, wow, it's only six words. When they hung all these people and two of them by mistake, two kids, and that's all a warranted in the media. Yes, incredible.

Speaker 5

Let's talk about another person that is immortalized and fictionalized and Billy the Kid. Tell us what you found out about Billy the Kid that poses the mythology.

Speaker 4

Well, really the true story about him, and a lot of it, some of them we've heard about a lot of it's, if you want to say, twisted because different people didn't have the information or they want to write the story of the book in a different fashion. But

these articles were written at the time. They were written by reporters who spoke to some of the people that were around him over the years and really talking about how many people he killed and how many his gang ended up killing, and how ruthless he was, and then eventually he was killed. That's the way it's been reported

in these newspapers too. By Sheriff Pat Garrett. When Billy was hiding out at a ranch after he escaped killed to law enforced two deputies in town, and he escaped, went up to this ranch and they went out and at dark snuck upon the house and Garrett went into the room and that's when he saw the person he said, it was Billy the Kid walk in and that's when he shot him. So it gets into what really occurred at the time, not what contemporary stories say or television.

But it gives you a good look at well Pat Garrett, the sheriff at the time, and the history of Billy the Kid, when he started out and through his life, what he did, and how many people he did kill, and how ruthefless he was.

Speaker 5

You also debunked the story, or at least you discussed the story that even some newspapers spoke about the idea that he had escaped and went on to live his life somewhere else, and that that Pat Garrett's former friend, the sheriff who had shot him apparently just substituted a different corpse. It was so you talk about that that story, we talked.

Speaker 4

Well, that's what some people start saying is that when Billy was shot out of Las Vegas, New Mexico, that it really wasn't him, that it was somebody else. And Garrett decided to bring this body and say no, this is him, because there was a reward then, but also for the note to writing he wanted them killed that escape. But the odds are it it was once again it

was Billy the kid. And just setting you know, history straight is that this was written at the time and these reporters were crawling there and talked to him, talk to the people that were out there when he was shot and so forth, and so there's no doubt that in my mind that Billy was killed.

Speaker 5

Then absolutely. You also talk about Jesse James, and you have a particular commentary about Jesse James. Again one of those people that one of those outlaws that people believe through some movies and thumb stories that they know about Jesse James. And you set the record straight, tell us about a little bit about Jesse James.

Speaker 4

Yet, Jesse started out really killing people with Quantrell's Raiders during the Civil War. He first went there after there was killing at his parents ranch and so forth, and his brother Frank was already writing with Quantrell's Raiders, and so Jesse went one time. He wanted to join this to know, you're too young to get out of here.

He came back later when he was still young and while I'm saying, yeah, I'm timber six fifteen sixteen seventeen, and he joined Quantrell's Raiders, and they were a band affiliated with the Confederacy, and they would raid various cities, mainly belong in Kansas in that area, and he bragged that he killed, you know, at least thirty six to forty people in this one raid in Lawrence, Kansas when they went in there, and they basically killed all of the men and all the boys in that town, and

it was approaching about two hundred maybe a little bit more than that. And as a result of that, the Confederacy, for a better term, pulled their support from Quantrelle because they didn't want people just being slaughtered, just to be slaughtered, especially boys and so forth and innocent men, and so Jesse in that raid claimed he killed thirty six. Probably did maybe more, maybe a few less, but it's just

a matter of he was very, very vicious. And then he went on with his brother Frank James and so forth, and they formed their own gang and they started pulling robberies and so forth, of banks, of stage coaches and so forth, because that's what they knew from writing with Clontreille that that's what they would do, and finally he was.

He and this group were so sought after and terrorizing that area of the nation that the governor basically was hiring people to go out and find him for a better term, almost like private detectives and so forth, and other criminals, and to eliminate him. And so eventually that's exactly what happened. There were a couple of guys who were no better than Jesse came to the house as friends.

He knew him in the past, and when they were in the living room chatting, Jesse wanted to straighten a picture on the wall and dust it off, and he was shot from behind and by one of these friends of his, And so eventually they were both, if you want to say, and dieted put on trial. It was very rapid, it was over quickly. But there's no doubt in anybody's mind that the governor knew about this well

in advance. And these articles talk about this, how he knew these two guys and basically was talking about, yeah, go out and see if you can get him. But then they go into the body of Jesse, and when they're describing the body. The reporters or this particular porter had a fascination with him and talking about he had a magnificent physique and this is when he's laying laid out dead, and that he's you know, it's in this pride of health and strength, and he is a commanding

figure and all this sort of stuff. And so even then the legend of Jesse James was being built by some of the reporters that were there, the way they described everything and examining the body and so forth. So it's a very interesting story about the history of Jesse and Frank James and so forth, and it brings up a lot of areas that, excuse me, just are not covered in other books or stories, television and so forth.

Speaker 5

It's fascinating that you talk about the tenth thousand dollars reward and then the motivation for this Robert and Charles to be able to try to kill this person that they knew and they hooked up with the detective as you write, and said, listen, we know these guys. I've known him for four or five years, so they could identify them. But they also knew the country, they knew the layout, the countryside, and so they figured between them

that they had to kill him. There was no way they were going to take this guy prisoner, so they wanted to get close to him. And it was lucky that Jesse James needed some people for a bank robbery. He hadn't robbed a bank in a while and was low on funds, so they gained his trust that way. And it's fascinating to as you write that they had to wait till his back was turned and he had no access to weapons, so to make sure that they could kill this person and get that reward.

Speaker 4

And yeah, they were. They were terrified of him. I believe that's why they Because there were two of them, they could have pulled their guns on him anytime when he's standing there the day before or whatever, but they didn't, so they waited until he was turned us back they shot him. His wife was in another room in the house. She ran into that living room aria and realized what happened,

and these two guys took off. But they went basically to the sheriff after that and said, hey, we just killed Jesse James and that was pretty much the end of it. But in a sense they became heroes. The sum and villains to other because a lot of people who at the time they were intrigued by Jesse James as they were with a lot of other outlaws, and especially if they were supporters of the Confederacy, and they knew that they were with the Confederacy fighting with them.

So it's interesting. It brings both sides into play. It brings the true horrible outlaw that they were in killers, but then you also see the other side of how some people and especially the reporters viewed them. Yeah, they were criminals, but kind of romantic criminals in a sense. So it's it's very interesting the way the stories are written, because as I mentioned earlier, they don't hold anything back. They talk in detail about the wounds and what went

on and so forth. So it's just it takes people to a different level. Regarding the history of Jesse and Frank James.

Speaker 5

You also write that when Jesse was fourteen and his older brother was in the Quandtrails, that they wouldn't allow them into these into the into the gang. But then his stepfather, doctor Samuels, you write a pronounced secessionist. He had a visit from the He had the visit from these Union soldiers and so they strung him up. Rope was produced and strung him up, and he was later

cut down. But Jesse's mother and sister were imprisoned, and so that at fourteen, see as you write, it set him off on his murderous future, didn't it.

Speaker 4

Yes, it did. He at that stage he obviously he hated the Union more than he had in the past, and after he saw a personal attack by the soldiers on his family, that was it. He did whatever snapped in him or didn't snap her, that was his decision. He said, Okay, I am going to go with my brother and for better term seek retribution for my family on the Union people of the Union at the time and not the Confederacy. So yeah, for young boy at the time, he was ruthless.

Speaker 5

Yes, absolutely. You include at the end of this book several true crime stories. We don't have time to go into them. But what are some of these stories, these articles, these headlines, what do they indicate and tell you? And why were they included?

Speaker 4

Okay, well, the one I have in there about Lincoln's assassination. But in the short stories, they're interesting because some of them were now most of them only maybe one hundred words are very short, but they get into society at the time, what was, if you want to say acceptable, what was not acceptable, and how people were to react to it. Like there's one I have in there. This gal was dating this guy and he was also dating another woman, and so he took this other woman out

for a buggy ride. This other woman she knows they're going out, so she gets in a buggy. She goes after him, and she catches other shoots and kills both of them. So is jealousy at play what you see today. And there was one truly interesting story, but it was repeated many times in other stories, and that was it sounds crazy, but the deadly blue gum negro, which they said and what they believe was that if an African American had blue gums, his bite was as deadly as

a rattlesnake. And so I found numerous articles about this back then, and I put this one in how they want to rest the sky. He bit some people and they died afterwards. They said, see that proves that he's a blue gum Negroes are as deadly as rattlesnakes. And it was folklore that was leave for many, many years and as I put in there, here's the story, but then also put in there from the Cleveland Clinic about human bites, how how they can become badly infected, and

especially then the no antibiotics. You break the skin with no antibiotics, especially from a human bite, there's a chance that's going to become infected and then you're going to die from the infection. So that was one I found very interesting. There's another where typical con men they had them back then, where they pull in and they're well dressed.

They see this guy sitting on his sports basically a rancher, and they want to buy it, and they pulled out some gold bricks and said, here's what we're going to buy it with. So they cut the deal, they get some cash in advance, and the guy finds out these

bricks are not gold. He was scammed. And there's some really kind of interesting ones where there's a they found his body and they didn't know if it was a joke or murder, because it was was all pretty well mutilated, but they pretty much determined that it was cadaver from a medical school that some guys took out and chopped it up and shot it up and dumped it in

the river. But the most interesting one at the very end I closed the book with was a defense of a woman in Washington, d C. During the Civil War. And she was captured by the Union aiding and a bedding acting as a spy in an aid for the Confederacy. So each time they'd catch her, they would go and that was execution then, and so shortly afterwards the general in charge that was holding her would receive a notice

from Washington, d C. Release her. So this happened several times, and obviously was puzzling to this journal because everybody else would be hung or shot. Well. As it turned out, she was running a brothel and an abortion clinic and was in DC, and and so what she did she would She was servicing a lot of the politicians, high ranking polity maybe Secretary of State, ands of congressman, senators, and she was also performing the abortions on their girlfriends.

And so this is why she kept getting off as a Confederate spy. But then she actually shoots somebody, a guy she was blackmailing. She gets on a for better turn to trolley and she shoots at him. She misses, kills the guy next to him and wounds this other one. And she goes on trial and she's found not guilty

of this. And what is interesting is that the what got me onto is having been in court many times, you know, testifying, is that the defense attorney basically wanted her to be found insane because then she would go free. And so the question was asked, well, how insane, he said, well, just insane enough to get her off, you know, I mean it just that attorneys then that's what they do today, you know. So, yeah, but the backstory on her is truly fascinating. They wrote her entire backstory in.

Speaker 5

There, absolutely the disguises and yeah, just all the people she slept with that she blackmailed, and the incredible amount of people that she had ties with in Washington at that time.

Speaker 4

Yes, yes, and she was always dressed like a man when she was going down to bring different supplies and information to the Confederates. So it was truly she's a story in herself, you know.

Speaker 5

Absolutely. I want to thank you very much for coming on and talking about True Crime Chronicles Volume two, Serial Killers, Outlaws Injustice, Real crime stories from the eighteen hundreds for people that might want to take a look at other work. Where can they go? And this is a Wild Blue Press release and tell us about your upcoming HH Holmes release.

Speaker 4

Oh yes, well to find out more about me and my books, they're all available on Amazon, so just go to Amazon Books and so forth. And one just came out with it's doing really well. Is I obtained the if you want to say, written confession, but it's kind of a confession and non confession of HH Holmes that he wrote while he was in prison awaiting trial and he eventually executed for it. But it gets into it's

absolutely it comes from him. It's his words and they're they're in their entirety, and it's just fascinating because it takes you inside of that guy's mind and he thought that well, he was very intelligent, but he probably thought that he could outwit everybody. But was he setting the record straight knowing he would die or did he actually leave this But if anything, it was his way of trying to pass judgment on himself that he was really

an innocent guy. So that's out. And I said it is for a better term his diary about killing people and so forth, and why he was truly innocent. So it gives another perspective, it goes inside of a serial killer's mind.

Speaker 5

That will be fascinating. I'm very very anxious to read that and anxious to discuss that with you on the program very very soon. I want to thank you very much, Mike roth Miller for coming on and talking about True Crime Chronicles, Volume two, Serial Killers, Outlaws and Justice, Real crime stories from the eighteen hundreds. It's been an absolute pleasure. Thank you so much, Mike. You have a great evening.

Speaker 4

Good night, You're welcome. Take care, take care,

Transcript source: Provided by creator in RSS feed: download file
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android