In 1977, bus loads of girl scouts descended on Camp Scott located in Locust Grove, Oklahoma. This camp experience was supposed to be two weeks of swimming, hiking, arts and crafts. But on the second night there was a horrific triple murder that would shock everyone. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the facts of this infamous unsolved case. Items at the scene would tie the murders to a Cherokee man named Gene Leroy Hart. Hart had been a fugitive from justice after escaping from prison 4 years ...
Oct 15, 2017•1 hr 6 min
Bob Crane was an entertainer from a very early age. He would go from being a disc jockey, to a radio host, to the star of a popular sitcom in the late 1960s. He had an accomplished career in entertainment. On June 29th, 1978 Bob was found murdered in his apartment in Scottsdale, Arizona. Bob's secret fetishes would come out publicly after his murder. He, along with his friend John Carpenter, enjoyed the company of scores of women and they would photograph and videotape their trysts. After Bob's ...
Oct 08, 2017•1 hr 9 min
12 year old Stephanie Crowe was found murdered in early 1998 in her bedroom. The early police investigation would focus on a group a young teens, one in particular would be Stephanie's older brother. But another suspect would emerge that had been on police radar the whole time. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the tragic murder of Stephanie Crowe. Did police develop tunnel vision in focusing in on the brother and his friends? The facts would come out about another suspect that police had from...
Oct 01, 2017•51 min
In 1963, 15 year old Patty Rebholz was found murdered in a vacant lot in a town near Cincinnati, Ohio. She was a popular cheerleader who was loved by everyone. Patty had a 15 year old boyfriend named Mike who was a popular football player. The police would zero in on a suspect very early on in the investigation but the case would go cold for more than 35 years. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss this case and how cold case investigators would reignite the case after 35 years and prosecutors wou...
Sep 24, 2017•59 min
In the early morning of November 18th, 1992, Mischelle Lawless was found in her car bludgeoned and shot to death. The police would zero in on a suspect fairly quickly but as sometimes happens they would make some major mistakes in developing this type of tunnel vision. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the tragic murder of this warm, kind, and loving 19 year old girl. But another tragedy would unfold as prosecutors would convict a man named Joshua Kezer for the murder based on flimsy evidence,...
Sep 17, 2017•1 hr 4 min
Q&A episode - Join Mike and Gibby as they answer listener questions and talk about the growth of the show. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Sep 14, 2017•1 hr
Maria Ridulph was a seven year old girl who was out playing with her friend Kathy one day in 1957 when she vanished and was ultimately found murdered. Kathy was able to tell police that Maria was last seen with a mystery man named Johnny. But this case would go cold for nearly 50 years before it would heat up. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the details of this tragic case. This is a case that would be solved 55 years after it happened. But it would not stayed solved as the man convicted of ...
Sep 10, 2017•59 min
Amy Gellert's mother and step-father were attacked inside their home in March of 1994. As Amy pulled into her driveway, the assailant stabbed her to death. Her mother and step-father lived through their attacks to give police what information they could about the attacker. This is a mystifying cold case that has stumped investigators for 23 years. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the details of this tragic case, the investigation, the clues, and the suspects. Was the attempted robbery of the ...
Sep 03, 2017•1 hr 3 min
In September of 2006, firefighters and police found the bodies of three individuals. All three had been murdered and then burned. Two of the bodies were found inside the house while a third was found in a burning wheelbarrow outside of the home. This was a gruesome triple homicide. Suspects would emerge but nothing substantial would happen in this case for many years. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss this sad but intriguing case. We talk about the victims, the possible suspects, and how peopl...
Aug 27, 2017•1 hr 10 min
Two teenage girls are found murdered on the same beach 6 years apart. Barbara Nantais is murdered in 1978 and Claire Hough is murdered in 1984. The specifics of the murders are very similar but police can't connect the two and can't find a viable suspect for either crime. It would not be until many years later when advancements in DNA technology would help shed some light on these mysterious murders. But what does the DNA actually tell investigators about who committed these murders? Join Mike a...
Aug 20, 2017•1 hr 8 min
The Highway of Tears is a long stretch of Highway 16 between Prince George and Prince Rupert, British Columbia, Canada. Since 1969, a large number of women have gone missing or have been found dead along this highway. No one knows what the exact number is but many believe it is much higher than official counts show. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss one of Canada's biggest mysteries. The victims will be discussed along with possible suspects. How many different killers / serial killers may be ...
Aug 13, 2017•1 hr 7 min
Early on the morning of August 2nd, 2005, Greg and Bernadette Ohlemacher were shot and killed in their Albuquerque, NM home. Their 20 year old daughter was in the house that morning when the murder took place. She would call 911 to report that she heard gunshots but would soon come under scrutiny from both the police and her extended family. The next year an unlikely suspect would emerge in this case. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the strange circumstances surrounding the murder of the Ohl...
Aug 06, 2017•1 hr 15 min
Claudia Elizabeth Lawrence was a 35 year old chef when she suddenly disappeared from her hometown of Malton in North Yorkshire England in 2009. Over the years there have been a number of men arrested on suspicion of the murder of Claudia. Join Mike and Gibby as they track the movements of Claudia Lawrence in the days leading up to her disappearance. They also discuss how the police have handled the investigation, including the numerous arrests that have been made which have to date not led to a ...
Jul 30, 2017•1 hr 2 min
Seymour and Arlene Tankleff were murdered in 1988. Their 17 year old son Marty was charged and convicted of the murders. Marty was exonerated after serving 17 years in prison leaving his parents murders unsolved. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the twists and turns of this tragic case. Two loving parents were murdered and their son was wrongfully convicted. How did everything in this case go so wrong in the beginning and did those missteps allow the real killers to get away with murder? Visi...
Jul 23, 2017•1 hr 4 min
The family of 7 year old Jaclyn Dowaliby woke up one morning in 1988 to find that Jaclyn was missing. Someone had come into their home near Chicago, Illinois in the middle of the night and had taken her. The evidence initially pointed to someone within the home and the police began to focus their attention on Jaclyn's family members. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the facts of this tragic case which has many elements that are eerily similar to the Jon Benet Ramsey case. Did the police get t...
Jul 16, 2017•1 hr 4 min
Melinda McGhee returned home on the morning of March 24th, 2003 after working third shift at her job. She made a few phone calls and then was never heard from or seen again. Join Mike and Gibby as they talk through the facts of Melinda's disappearance. There were a couple of serial killers active during the time she went missing. Could she have been one of their victims? Or was it someone the knew her and that had targeted her? Visit the show's website at truecrimeallthetime.com for contact and ...
Jul 09, 2017•46 min
A serial killer was on the loose in the New Bedford area of Massachusetts in the late 1980s. He is believed to have claimed 11 victims, 9 women whose bodies have been found, and 2 that are still missing to this day. All of the women shared some similar characteristics and some of the women knew each other. Join Mike and Gibby as they walk through the facts of the case, the victims, the timeline of the murders, and the possible suspects. Visit the show's website at truerimeallthetime.com for cont...
Jul 02, 2017•38 min
In the early 1970s, New York was terrorized by an unknown serial killer. This killer was targeting young African-American boys and along with murder would commit atrocious acts of mutilation. It is this fact that caused people around New York to give this serial killer the nickname of Charlie Chop Off. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the details of this horrific but fascinating unsolved case. They go in depth about the crimes, the victims, and the possible suspects. One in particular is so c...
Jun 25, 2017•1 hr 5 min
In the late 1990s young African-American males started showing up dead in Jefferson Parish, Louisiana. There is a lot of information that ties these individuals together to point towards the fact that an unknown serial killer was operating and targeting these individuals. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the details of the case. There have been a number of these cluster type killings down in Louisiana over the years pointing to the fact that there may have been many different serial killers i...
Jun 18, 2017•1 hr 3 min
On September 11th, 2011 three men were brutally murdered inside an apartment in Waltham, MA. One was an MMA fighter, one a bodybuilder, and one was a physical trainer. These were not men you would want to pick a fight with. The murders were so vicious that all three were nearly decapitated. Rivaling the intrigue into the murders is who the suspects would turn out to be. They would infamous individuals well known for their role in one of Boston's most horrific crimes in recent years. Join Mike an...
Jun 11, 2017•53 min
An unknown serial killer stalked couples in Virginia along the Colonial Parkway in the late 1980s. From 1986 - 1989 4 couples, 8 people total, were murdered. The killer appeared to strike the couples as they were sitting in their car in a "lover's lane" type situation. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss this baffling case. They touch on the details of each murder, possible motives, possible suspects, and how the various law enforcement agencies handled the case. Could this killer have pretended...
Jun 04, 2017•1 hr 15 min
8 young women were murdered in and around the town of Madison, Wisconsin. These murders began in 1968 and stretched to 1984. Many of the women had ties to the University of Wiscon in Madison and some were actually killed on school property. Join Mike and Gibby as they delve into these mysterious deaths that have now become cold cases. Are all or some of these the work of an unknown serial killer? Could some of these have been committed by a well known deadly duo of serial killers that made some ...
May 28, 2017•55 min
When you think of Daytona Beach, Florida you think of sun, sand, surf, and maybe even their famous Bike Week. The Daytona Beach Killer murdered at least four women between 2005 and 2007 and left the community to wonder who could have committed these vicious murders. The signature aspeccts of each murder left little doubt that all four were connected. Join Mike and Gibby as they talk about the murders in detail, the victims, and the similarities that helped investigators tie these all together. T...
May 21, 2017•1 hr 8 min
An unidentified assailant often known as the Texarkana Phantom Killer committed a number of murders and assaults in Texarkana (Miller County, Arkansas, and Bowie County, Texas) through the spring of 1946. Five people were killed, and three were wounded. In this second and last part of the Texarkana Phantom series, Mike and Gibby explore the rumors surrounding the murders and the panic that ensued in the Texarkana area. They also explore some of the more viable suspects as well as a few that are ...
May 14, 2017•1 hr 21 min
The Texarkana Phantom killer is an unidentified serial killer who terrorized the Texarkana area back in 1946. In some cases he targeted couples parked at a lover's lane much like the Zodiac would do over 20 years later. The killer wore a burlap sack over his face with slits cut out for the eyes and mouth. This must have been a terrifying experience for those few that lived to tell about what they had witnessed. Join Mike and Gibby as they talk about the facts of the case. In this part 1 all of t...
May 07, 2017•1 hr 19 min
When most people think of Hawaii they think of a vacation destination. But in the mid 1980's the island of Oahu was in the grips of what is thought to be Hawaii's first serial killer. Dubbed the Honolulu Strangler, this unknown serial killer would murder 5 women in the exact same brutal fashion. There was no doubt that all 5 murders were connected. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the facts of the case, the victims, the MO of the killer, and the best suspect tied to the murders. Visit our web...
Apr 30, 2017•1 hr 14 min
The Jennings 8 case (also known as the Jeff Davis 8 case) centers around 8 women who were found murdered in various places around Jennings, Louisiana. These women had many connections to each other. There have been many allegations in this case involving drug rings and possible law enforcement involvement. Join Mike and Gibby as they dive into the details of this fascinating but tragic case of 8 women whose killer (or killers) have yet to be identified. Is this a serial killer who has yet to hav...
Apr 23, 2017•1 hr 32 min
Leticia Hernandez was a sweet and bubbly 7 year old who disappeared from in front of her Oceanside, CA apartment building in December of 1989. The outpouring of support and assistance was both swift and massive. There were multiple witnesses who saw Leticia get into a car with multiple people and were able to provide descriptions to police. Tips would begin pouring in and would stretch all the way from California to Florida. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the facts of the case, the numerous...
Apr 16, 2017•1 hr 7 min
We are doing our first unsolved case out of Canada. Christine Jessop was abducted and murdered in 1984. The police zeroed in on a neighbor of the Jessop family. Many say that this "tunnel vision" caused the police to miss the chance to find the Christine's killer. Join Mike and Gibby as they lay out the details of the case including how the police handled or mishandled it. There were suspects not followed up on, convictions, and acquittals. This is a fascinating case but the tragedy is that Chri...
Apr 09, 2017•1 hr 12 min
In 1985, two separate murders occurred involving couples in the Pacific Northwest. These unsolved murders had many similarities that tied them together. The most interesting being that a tube sock involved in each incident. Join Mike and Gibby as they talk about this fascinating unsolved set of murders. They go into detail about each of the murders as well as other murders in the area that have some similarities as well. As always with the unsolved cases there are suspects to talk about and go t...
Apr 02, 2017•1 hr 10 min
