Those Murder Girls Podcast - podcast cover

Those Murder Girls Podcast

Those Murder Girls Podcast is your new favorite Friday true crime podcast. Join Reyna each week for a lessor known true crime case. Follow us on Facebook and Instagram at Those Murder Girls Podcast for episode teasers, coverage, discussion, headlines and more! Facebook: @TMGirlspodcast Instagram: @thosemurdergirlspodcast
Last refreshed:
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

Thomas Eugene Creech - Idaho State Penitentiary

Thomas Eugene Creech , a self-proclaimed serial killer, is ruthless with 42 murders to his name, 11 of which have been confirmed. Now Idaho's longest living death row inmate, a life on death row couldn't stop him from killing. Ways to support the show: Become a Patreon! With five levels to choose from you can support Those Murder Girls Podcast with a monthly donation, that will go a long ways. And, any donation over $3 will get you a shoutout on the show! Want to make a one-time donation? You ca...

Apr 08, 202223 minEp. 85

Laurie Potter - San Diego//Temecula, California

A set of human legs were found discarded in a Southern California dumpster, with no clues as to who they could have belong to in sight. The case sat on a cold case shelf for almost twenty years, that was until a determined investigator was assigned to the case.

Mar 25, 202210 minEp. 84

IN THE VAULT - //REMASTERED// Michael Sandoval - Montrose, Colorado

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. Michael Sandoval, a 17-year-old was found deceased under suspicious circumstances in his family's Colorado home. Local law enforcement quickly ruled Michael's death a suicide, but Michael's family, friends, and members of the community believe there is much more that lead to his untimely death. This...

Mar 18, 202231 minEp. 83

IN THE VAULT - The Colts Neck Family Murders - Colts Neck Township, New Jersey

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. Could a brother who grew up best friends with his sibling also be their killer? A mansion fire in Colts Neck Township killed a family of four just days before Thanksgiving 2018 and now a brother will soon stand trial for arson, all four murders and a ton of additional charges....

Mar 12, 202235 minEp. 82

IN THE VAULT - The Mashy #5! - Las Vegas, Nevada and Brooklyn, New York

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. National Domestic Violence Hotline Call: 800.799.SAFE SafeNest - Call or Text (Confidential) 702-646-4981

Mar 04, 202218 minEp. 81

IN THE VAULT - Michael Roak & Tiffany York - Fort. Stewart, Georgia

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. Michael Roak and Tiffany York were lovers with a bright future ahead of them, that was until a group of extremist soldiers from Fort Stewart, Georgia felt the need to kill them in an effort to keep their plans of destruction and assassination a secret.

Feb 25, 202228 minEp. 80

IN THE VAULT - The Mashy! #4 Larry O'neil & Joshlyn Johnson // Rocio Duncan

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. We! Are! Live! Your Murder Girls have a Mashup for you today in episode 80, with stories on the tragic cases involving Larry O'neil and his sister Joshlyn Johnson and another on beloved California teacher Rocio Duncan....

Feb 18, 202221 minEp. 79

IN THE VAULT - Isabella Hellman - Delray Beach, Florida

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. Newlyweds Isabella Hellman and Lewis Bennett would board a sailboat for a honeymoon some could only dream of spring 2017. Little did Isabella know the man she had recently exchanged vows with had much more planned than just a romantic getaway.

Feb 15, 202221 minEp. 78

IN THE VAULT - Matthew Cecchi - Oceanside // Oroville, California

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. In 1998 Matthew Cecchi was killed in a chance encounter with a psychopathic maniac on a southern California beach. *This episode is extremely graphic. Listener discretion is advised.

Feb 05, 202245 minEp. 77

IN THE VAULT - Karlie Guse -Bishop, California

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. Where is Karlie Lain Guse? The blonde hair blue-eyed 16-year-old went missing from her home in Mono County California in October 2018. Karlie was last seen the early morning of October 12th by her stepmother, before vanishing without a trace, leaving everything behind. There have been no signs of Ka...

Jan 28, 202234 minEp. 76

IN THE VAULT - Michael Shaver - Clermont, Florida

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. Buried in his own backyard!? When 33-year-old Michael Shaver was last seen in late 2015, those close to him were told by Michael's wife Laurie, that he simply up and left his family and moved away to start a new life. But was that really the case? It would take years before Laurie Shaver's house of ...

Jan 24, 202237 minEp. 75

IN THE VAULT - Pedro Alonso Lopez - The Monster of the Andes

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. Columbian-born serial killer Pedro Alonso Lopez, also known as the Monster of the Andes, killed hundreds across Ecuador, Columbia, and Peru between 1969-2002, only being convicted for less than a third of his crimes.

Jan 14, 202227 minEp. 74

IN THE VAULT - Ryan Rogers - Palm Beach Gardens, Florida

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. A 14-year-old high school freshman heads out for an evening bike ride in his tight-knit Florida neighborhood and something goes terribly wrong. Sadly, on this evening, Ryan Rogers would not return home. He would be found brutally murdered the following morning just three miles from home....

Dec 31, 202114 minEp. 73

IN THE VAULT - James and Michelle Butler - Padre Island, Texas

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. In 2018 James and Michelle Butler left it all behind and set out on a cross-country trip of a lifetime. This trip would be tragically cut short at the hands of two strangers.

Dec 10, 202120 minEp. 72

IN THE VAULT - Yolandi Botes - South Africa

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. The Botes Family is offering a $50,000 reward for any information into the disappearance and murder of their beloved Yolandi, who went missing on a trip to visit her three children. Parts of Yolandi's dismembered body were found by a fisherman in the Vaal River, not far from her last known whereabou...

Dec 03, 202119 minEp. 71

IN THE VAULT - Omaima Nelson - Orange County, California

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. Omaima Nelson, an Egyptian model, is a convicted murderer serving time for butchering her husband of just a couple weeks, cooking and eating him on Thanksgiving 1991. Still in prison today, we can only guess she was less than thrilled with her prison issued Thanksgiving meal last night....

Nov 27, 202125 minEp. 70

IN THE VAULT - Isabella Kalua - Honolulu, Hawaii

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. A six-year-old girl from Hawaii was one of the many lucky children that be adopted into her forever home in 2019. Though this forever home would sadly end in her murder. Isabella Kalua was tragically murdered by her monster adoptive parents and her body remains missing to this day. Tune in as Reyna ...

Nov 22, 202121 minEp. 69

IN THE VAULT - Toni Lopez Wells - Brooklyn, New York

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. Listener Suggestion! A young wife was brutally murdered at the hands of her abusive husband after she bravely finds the courage to leave him to start her life over. Related Instagram Accounts ellie_tonie_charlie nyc_2_la takeactionfortonie iamatonieproject The Domestic Violence Hotline Text: 88788 C...

Nov 12, 202138 minEp. 68

IN THE VAULT - Matthew Weaver - Malibu, California

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. 21-year-old Matthew Weaver went missing in August 2018 after being spotted on CCTV driving up Topanga Tower Motorway, arriving at Rosa’s Outlook in Southern California. What happened after he arrived there in the early morning hours of August 10, 2018, remains a mystery to this day. What happened to...

Nov 05, 202123 minEp. 67

IN THE VAULT - Eliza Delacruz - Long Beach, California

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. The short life and senseless death of three-week-old Eliza Delacruz.

Oct 29, 202116 minEp. 66

IN THE VAULT - Lindsay Harris - Henderson, Nevada

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. 21-year-old Lindsay Harris moves from New York to Las Vegas to settle in with her boyfriend, to start a new chapter in her life. When she went missing in 2005 without a trace, no one could imagine what happened to the bright-eyed blonde. As the investigation into her disappearance begins, a sinister...

Oct 23, 202122 minEp. 65

IN THE VAULT - Sun Family Murders - Cypress, Texas

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. A family of 4 was murdered in cold blood in their Texas home, a crime that has gone unsolved for more than seven years. Will this murder ever be solved? Download now to see where this case stands today. Do you have information on the Sun Family murders? Report them to either of the following agencie...

Oct 15, 202113 minEp. 64

IN THE VAULT - Jelani Day - Bloomington, Illinois

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. What happened to 25 year old Jelani Day? Jelani was a bright doctoral student who went missing without a trace this past August only for his body to be found in the Illinois river over a week later. Little to no evidence was recovered from the scene. Jelani's heartbroken mother wants to know, what h...

Oct 08, 202121 minEp. 63

IN THE VAULT - Jake Bush - Ventura, California

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. A 16-year-old boy is tragically murdered in his own home in a burglary gone wrong.

Oct 02, 202130 minEp. 62

IN THE VAULT - Daniel Robinson - Buckeye, Arizona

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. Three months after his mysterious disappearance from a job site in Buckeye, Arizona, there is still no trace of 24-year-old Daniel Robinson. **Case updates start of the episode to 7:59. **Daniel’s story starts at the 8:00 mark. Anyone with information on Daniel's case is urged to contact the Buckeye...

Sep 24, 202121 minEp. 61

IN THE VAULT - Gabby Petito - North Port, Florida

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. Where is Gabby Petito? That is the question everyone in the country is wondering, especially her family who is worried sick. A 22-year-old woman from Florida goes missing on a cross-country road trip of a lifetime, yet her boyfriend whom she was traveling with makes it home perfectly safe?! Why is h...

Sep 17, 202130 minEp. 60

IN THE VAULT - The Murdaugh Updates! - Islandton, South Carolina

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. You thought episodes 51 and 52 left you with questions?? Oh man, we have all the updates on the Murdaugh case that is currently spiraling out of control in South Carolina! Over the past couple of months, we’ve had zero answers to our questions, and this week we’ve been left with even more!!! **Be su...

Sep 10, 202115 minEp. 58

IN THE VAULT - Valerie Cincinelli - Long Island, New York

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. How far would you go to get rid of someone in your way? Murder? Well, that's exactly what this former NYPD officer decided to do… Tune in today to hear the story of Valerie Cincinelli, the (not so) devoted wife, mother, and protector of law, and her very far fall from grace....

Sep 03, 202123 minEp. 57

IN THE VAULT - Who Killed Greg? - Maple Valley, Washington

ARCHIVE - This is an archived episode that was recorded by Reyna and Marie in the original podcast format. In 2022 Reyna became the solo host of Those Murder Girls Podcast beginning with episode #84. The hunt is on for a motorist involved in a hit-and-run fatality in Maple Valley, Washington. * Official website: whokilledgreg.com Gofundme: https://www.gofundme.com/f/reward-fund-to-find-greg-moores-hit-run-driver?qid=e6d9bdaf15de2d68f489be9a847e1692 Crime Stoppers: https://www.p3tips.com/communit...

Aug 28, 202116 minEp. 56
Hosted on Buzzsprout
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android