On this episode of The SoJo Files (Season 3) we will be reading & discussing newspaper articles published within the first week of Melissa Witt's 1994 disappearance. We will read each article & then discuss / critically think through, what I consider to be, misinformation, misleading information, & everything in-between. FOR THIS SEASONS VIRTUAL MAP & MEDIA CLICK HERE >>>> HERE <<<< Special thanks to this seasons production team: Season 3 was written, rese...
Jan 27, 2025•27 min•Season 3Ep. 5
On season 3 episode 4 we will be discussion the discovery of the blood evidence in the Bowling World parking lot found after police left from towing Melissa Witt's car from that very parking lot just hours earlier. From images of police after discovering Melissa Witt's car is clear officers walked right over the blood evidence multiple times after finding Melissa's car & towing it yet failed to notice blood spanning over 100 feet in the Bowling World parking lot. On this episode we will dive...
Dec 10, 2024•32 min•Season 3Ep. 4
On this episode we will be discussing the discovery of Melissa Ann Witt's 1995 white Mitsubishi Mirage Coupe that was located in the Bowling World parking lot December 4th 1994. Bowling World was only 6.7 miles from the Witt home. Arguably one of the first places you would think to look. A place searchers without a doubt would have driven by or near. Yet, no one claims to have thought to look there nor seen the car just sitting there nonstop for 3 days until 8:30am on December 4th 1994. Then hou...
Dec 04, 2024•29 min•Season 3Ep. 3
Episode two will be taking a closer look into the initials hours following the disappearance of Melissa Ann Witt on December 1st 1994. This episode will look at the days that followed, December 2nd & 3rd 1994, & what Melissa's friends & family did to try to locate their loved one without police assistance. We will discuss how friends passed out fliers, one flier in particular, Fort Smith police departments response or lack there of, & local news media coverage in the initial hour...
Dec 02, 2024•33 min•Season 3Ep. 2
Welcome to season 3 of SoJo! On this season we will be diving in to the 30 year old cold case of Melissa Ann Witt out of Fort Smith, Arkansas . Which makes today, December 1st 2024, the 30 year anniversary of Melissa's disappearance , the perfect day to launch this season! Melissa Ann Witt was 19 years old living a very simple southern life when everything changed on December 1st 1994. Melissa was going about her normal daily routine when her killer decided to abduct her, there was no sign of Me...
Dec 01, 2024•22 min•Season 3Ep. 1
A letter to listeners from Sue, Deb Shreeve's best friend! Support the show
Mar 24, 2023•6 min•Season 2Ep. 38
A letter to listeners from Deb Shreeve, Jordan Shreeve's mother. Support the show
Mar 24, 2023•8 min•Season 2Ep. 37
A letter to listeners from Liz Shreeve, Jordan Shreeve's sister in law. Support the show
Mar 24, 2023•8 min•Season 2Ep. 36
This episode is a letter to listeners from 11 year old Maddie Shreeve! Jordan Shreeve's first child & only daughter! Special thanks to everyone who helps make this podcast possible & special thanks to Maddie Shreeve for being so brave! If you would like to send Maddie words of encouragement you can email TheSoJoFiles@gmail.com with the subject line For Maddie & I will personally make sure she gets the love! Support the show...
Mar 23, 2023•6 min•Season 2Ep. 35
Chad Atwell presents his case against Eva Millard for the charge of murder in the 1st degree for the the death of her daughter Olivia Soto. Support the show
Mar 21, 2023•36 min•Season 2Ep. 34
Laura Carwile presents her case for murder charges against Eva Millard for the murder of her daughter Olivia Soto. Support the show
Mar 20, 2023•45 min•Season 2Ep. 33
Case against Eva Millard for the charge of murder in first degree for the death her daughter Olivia Soto as told by Chris Carwile. Support the show
Mar 18, 2023•14 min•Season 2Ep. 32
On the last episode you heard a secret tape featuring Eva Millard discussing evidence in this case. I thought it would be both appropriate & fun for myself (SoJo), Chris Carwile, Laura Carwile, & Chad Atwell to each present our case against Eva Millard for the charge of Murder in the 1st degree. I'll go first... Support the show
Mar 17, 2023•28 min•Season 2Ep. 31
On this episode you will be hearing another secretly recorded conversation between Deb Shreeve & Eva Millard. Support the show
Mar 12, 2023•11 min
This is last episode in the "evidence as collected by officers written reports" for November 8th 2018! On this episode you will hear from SoJo, Jordan's defense attorneys Chad Atwell & Laura Carwile as well as ex homicide detective turned private investigator Billy Turnbough discussing the milk bottle in crime scene photos for November 8th 2018 that was NOT COLLECTED by officers. Support the show
Mar 10, 2023•28 min•Season 2Ep. 29
On February 15th, 2023, after a year on the run, Eva Millard was apprehended in California by US Marshals Service. Eva was then taken into custody at the San Louis Obispo Sheriff's Office detention center. Eva then had an extradition hearing in California where she waived extradition agreeing to be extradited back to Arkansas. Eva Millard was extradited back to Arkansas on March 2nd, 2023. She is currently in the custody of Sebastian County Sheriff's office awaiting her first appearance in Crawf...
Mar 09, 2023•15 min•Season 2Ep. 28
On this episode you will be introduced to Billy Turnbough. Billy is a retired law enforcement officer who worked as a detective, including in homicide. Billy worked in the Criminal Investigation Division of the Springdale, Arkansas police department from '98-'11, he was then a traffic collision investigator from '11-'13 & in the midst of that started his on Private investigation firm in 2012. Billy left law enforcement to join the private sector of investigating & for the past ten years ...
Dec 19, 2022•39 min•Season 2Ep. 27
On this episode we will be discussing Jordan Shreeve's truck which was collected as evidence on November 8th 2018. We are almost done with evidence from the 8th where we move on to the madness in the days that followed! If you enjoy listening to The SoJo Files make sure you listen to the sister podcast, The SHITuation, where we discuss current ongoing cases & trending true crime topics! Special thanks to all of the social media manager who make all of this possible! Support the show...
Dec 09, 2022•25 min•Season 2Ep. 26
Today is November 8, 2022. The four year anniversary to the homicide of Olivia Soto. Four years of lives that have been ruined or forever touched. Four years without justice for Olivia Soto. On this episode SoJo, Laura Carwile & Chad Atwell discuss the bedding from evidence in the Shreeve case. Support the show
Nov 09, 2022•37 min•Season 2Ep. 25
On this weeks episode SoJo, Chad Atwell & Laura Carwile discuss "the pill" that was allegedly found by officer Wesley Marsh on November 8, 2018. "The pill" that doesn't exist in any pictures, was never sent off for testing, & never saw the light of day. The YouTube version of this episode will air 24-72 hours after the podcast version! Season two is hosted by SoJo, Chad Atwell, Laura Carwile & Chris Carwile! Special thanks to the social media managers Lex, Erin, Valetta, Sierra, &...
Oct 28, 2022•26 min•Season 2Ep. 28
According to the Van Buren, Arkansas police department's incident reports for November 8, 2018, officer Wesley Marsh identified 4 locations in the home that contained possible blood evidence. Officer Johnathan Wear then collected swabs from two of those four locations. Yet, somehow, there are more swab entries in evidence than swabs admitted to be collected on the 8th. On this episode SoJo, Chad Atwell, & Laura Carwile discuss the swabs that were collected from the Olivia Soto homicide crime...
Oct 21, 2022•39 min•Season 2Ep. 27
On this episode SoJo, Laura Carwile & Chad Atwell will be discussing the couch, as well as the cutting from the couch cushion, that was taken into evidence for the homicide investigation of Olivia Soto on November 8, 2018. If you remember, from the interrogation tapes, Eva Millard mentions, multiple times, Olivia being placed on the couch. Eva Millard changed her version of who put Olivia on the couch & why numerous times. However, Jordan mentioned during his interrogation tapes that he ...
Oct 10, 2022•30 min•Season 2Ep. 26
On this weeks episode SoJo, Chad, Chris, & Laura will be taking an in depth look at the EKG strip that was collected as evidence on November 8, 2018 in the homicide investigation of Olivia Soto. The YouTube version of this episode will launch within 72 hours. Season 2 of The SoJo Files is hosted by SoJo, Chad Atwell, Chris Carwile & Laura Carwile. Special thanks to Sierra, Lex, Erin, Valetta, & Kim, the social media manager, that help make my life easier & help make all of this p...
Sep 30, 2022•45 min•Season 2Ep. 25
This week we officially start covering evidence in the Shreeve case. On this episode I will be reading for you all, directly from Van Buren Police Department Incident Reports from November 8th 2018. I will read exactly what officer Wear & Marsh say about evidence collected from the crime scene on the 8th as well as what they claim to have collected on the 8th. A very special thanks to the social media managers for The SoJo Files Lex, Sierra, Valetta, Erin & Kim! They make life easier &am...
Sep 23, 2022•15 min•Season 2Ep. 24
In the previous two episodes we covered all of the different versions of the story Eva Millard told for the events that occurred on November 8th 2018. On this third & final installment of Eva's Story Changes we will be listening to Eva continue to change her story. In this episode we won't be hearing what she says to police on the scene or at her interrogation, we will be listening to what she said to Deb Shreeve, Jordan's mother, when she thought no one would ever hear. Special thanks to De...
Sep 18, 2022•42 min•Season 2Ep. 23
Last week we started breaking down all of the different versions of events for November 8th 2018 as told my Eva Millard. This week, on part 2, we will be picking up right where we left off exploring all the changes to Eva's story. Clips for this episode are featured from Eva's interrogation tapes at the Van Buren, Arkansas police department conducted November 8th 2018. The YouTube version of this episode will premier 72 hours following the launch of the Podcast version of this episode. Special t...
Sep 13, 2022•54 min•Season 2Ep. 22
This week I decided to add an addition segment, before embarking on evidence, going over all of the different version's of Eva Millard's story for the events that occurred November 8th 2018. I realize you all have already listened to the interrogation tapes! However, the interrogation tapes are hours worth of content & I felt it would help listeners to grasp just how many different versions there are of Eva's story if I compacted them into a segment! This episode will cover the version of ev...
Sep 10, 2022•39 min•Season 2Ep. 21
On this episode you will be introduced to two members of Jordan Shreeve's defense team; Chad Atwell & Chris Carwile. Chad, Chris & I will be discussing key points from the interrogation tapes as we compare & contrast the interrogation of Jordan Shreeve & Eva Millard. If you're a member of TheSoJoFiles.com you can fact check this episodes with the time stamps of each interrogation video clips used to produce this episode as well as what page in the transcript you can find the refe...
Sep 01, 2022•1 hr 36 min•Season 2Ep. 20
On this episode you will hear the third installment of the secret tapes! These tapes were recorded by Deb Shreeve during conversations with Eva Millard. In this tape you will hear Eva talk about her version of events for the morning of November 8, 2018. This tape was the moment that Deb realized, in her opinion, that Eva was guilty. You will also hear Eva discuss allegations of prior abuse made against her, injuries on Olivia that also, allegedly, happened as a result of falling out of the pack ...
Aug 20, 2022•20 min•Season 2Ep. 19
Last week on The SoJo Files you got the first of many secret tapes recorded by Jordan's mother, Deb! She took these secret tapes in an effort to preserve conversations between herself & Eva where Eva continuously discussed the case in an immense effort to get the truth. Her hard work paid off! On this second secret tape you will hear Eva discussing her version of events for the interrogation. Support the show
Aug 19, 2022•15 min•Season 2Ep. 18
