Behind The Christian Mask: The Dennis Myers Case - podcast episode cover

Behind The Christian Mask: The Dennis Myers Case

Apr 19, 202612 min
--:--
--:--
Download Metacast podcast app
Listen to this episode in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episode description

If you enjoy this episode, we’re sure you will enjoy more content like this on The Occult Rejects.  In fact, we have curated playlists on occult topics like grimoires, esoteric concepts and phenomena, occult history, analyzing true crime and cults with an occult lens, Para politics, and occultism in music. Whether you enjoy consuming your content visually or via audio, we’ve got you covered - and it will always be provided free of charge.  So, if you enjoy what we do and want to support our work of providing accessible, free content on various platforms, please consider making a donation to the links provided below.  
Thank you and enjoy the episode!

Links For The Occult Rejects
https://linktr.ee/theoccultrejects

Occult Research Institute
https://www.occultresearchinstitute.org/

Cash App
https://cash.app/$theoccultrejects

Venmo
@TheOccultRejects

Buy Me A Coffee
buymeacoffee.com/TheOccultRejects

Patreon
https://www.patreon.com/TheOccultRejects

Primary sources
  • U.S. Attorney’s Office, Western District of Missouri. “Former youth pastor indicted for child porn.” December 12, 2012. This is the key source for the original three-count federal indictment, the April 1–September 16, 2011 viewing window, and the identification of Assistant U.S. Attorney Katharine Fincham and the Blue Springs Police Department.
  • U.S. Attorney’s Office, Western District of Missouri. “Former Youth Director Indicted on Additional Child Exploitation Charges.” February 20, 2013. This is the core source for the five-count superseding indictment and the added transportation counts tied to Jane Doe #1.
  • U.S. Attorney’s Office, Western District of Missouri. “Blue Springs Man Pleads Guilty Illegal Sexual Activity, Child Pornography.” May 1, 2013. This is the main source for the federal guilty plea announcement, the reference to U.S. Magistrate Judge John T. Maughmer, the Jackson County plea obligations, and the stated federal sentencing range of 5 to 30 years plus up to a $500,000 fine.
  • U.S. Attorney’s Office, Western District of Missouri. “Former Church Youth Director Sentenced to 30 Years for Child Exploitation and Pornography.” May 16, 2014. This is the main sentencing source for the 30-year sentence, the “statutory maximum” language, the court’s pattern findings, and much of the detail about additional victims and settings.
  • United States v. Dennis W. Myers, No. 14-2243 (8th Cir. Dec. 22, 2014), unpublished per curiam opinion. This is the source for the appeal being submitted on December 10, 2014, filed on December 22, 2014, the Smith-Bowman-Colloton panel, the Anders posture, the affirmance, counsel’s withdrawal, and denial of new counsel.
  • U.S. Department of Justice. “Project Safe Childhood.” General program page. Useful for a short explanatory note when you mention the DOJ initiative in narration or show notes.
  • U.S. Department of Justice. “Fact Sheet: Project Safe Childhood.” February 21, 2012. This is the clearest source for the point that the initiative began in 2006 and was expanded in May 2011 to cover all federal crimes involving the sexual exploitation of a minor.
Supplementary contemporary reporting
  • KMBC. “Former church youth director sentenced in sex case.” August 5, 2013. This is worth using as a supplementary local source because it contemporaneously reported the plea and the parallel Jackson County exposure. 


Also want to remind people about the website, if you're into reading we have tons of information by multiple contributors, and we got t-shirts up on the site if you're interested. Fun fact, the art is all based on the eyeball. A

Transcript

Speaker 1

You see, something's going to happen. What's going to happen? What I tonight? I want to tell you a story about a man whose name could fit so easily into the kind of town where people stop expecting anything unusual to the public. Guy Dennis W. Myers looked like he belonged to the ordinary life of the church. He fit into the printed bulletin, the calendar hanging on the wall, the fellowship rooms where young people gathered, the rhythms of

ministry that families come to know by heart. Later, the Federal Record would describe him as a former youth director at Christ United Methodist Church in Independence, Missouri, and at First United Methodist Church in Springdale, Arkansas. And you know how that happens in church life. After a while, people do not just know a person by name, They know them by roll. A position becomes a reputation, a title

becomes an introduction. Nobody even has to say anymore. The weeks move along in familiar patterns, meetings and announcements, Bible studies and youth gatherings, church trips and overnight events, and that easy comfort of saying why we have seen him around for years? In time, Myers left church employment and

started a dj business. The Department of Justice would later place that change somewhere around nineteen ninety three to nineteen ninety four, and years after that he was living in Blue Springs, Missouri, another suburb in the orbit of Kansas City, another place where a life can look plain and ordinary from the outside. And that is how the story appears at first glance. That is how it looks before anybody

has opened a court file. That is how it's zounds, before the record is read, before the facts come into the light. But then in September twenty eleven, the public story stopped being only about where he had worked and who he had once appeared to be. In September twenty eleven, following complaints by two adolescents about inappropriate sexual activity, law enforcement officers searched Meyer's home in Blue Springs, His computer was seized, and the story moved from community memory into

criminal investigation. Forensic examiners found a video of child pornography that had been downloaded from the Internet and viewed on that computer. On December twelfth, twenty twelve, a federal grand jury in Kansas City returned a three count indictment against marrs then described as fifty two years old and living

in Blue Springs. That incident alleged he accessed the Internet in order to view the child pornography between April first and September sixteenth, twenty and eleven, charged one count of receiving a video of child pornography over the Internet and

one count of possessing child pornography. Contemporaneous local reporting sharpened that timeline even further, stating investigators alleged he knowingly received a video file on April thirteenth, twenty eleven, and that on September fifteenth, twenty eleven, he was found in possession of at least one item of child pornography. The prosecutor identified in the federal releases was Assistant US Attorney Catherine Fincham, and the investigating agency named in the DOJ materials was

the Blue Springs Police Department. At that point, the case was already serious, but it was still not the full case. On February twentieth, twenty thirteen, the U. S Attorney's Office for the Western District of Missouri announced a five count superseding indictment. Myers was again described at fifty two years

old in living in Blue Springs. The superseding indictment replaced the December twenty twelve indictment and kept its three original counts, but it also added two additional counts, transporting a minor

across state lines for illegal sexual activity. According to that DOJ announcement, the two new transportation counts alleged that, on separate occasions between November nineteen ninety three and November nineteen ninety five, Myers transported a child victim identified as Jane Doe number one across state lines to engage in sexual activity for which he could be charged under the Missouri law.

The superseding indictment repeated the original allegations that he accessed the Internet in order to view child pornography between April first and September sixteenth, twenty eleven, and that he was charged with receipt and possession. In other words, what had first looked like a case rooted only in a twenty eleven computer seizure widened into something much older. That older thread centered on Jane Doe number one. According to the DOJ, Myers met her while he was a youth director at

First United Methodist Church in Springdale, Arkansas. The sentencing record states that sexual activity began when she was fourteen to

fifteen years old and in the eighth grade. Both the plea and sentencing releases report that he had left church employment and started a DJA business and approximately nineteen ninety three to nineteen ninety four when Jay Doe number one was fifteen years old, and that from November nineteen ninety four to November nineteen ninety five, when she was approximately sixteen, he transported her from Arkansas to the Kansas City area,

where they had sexual intercourse. The sentencing release also included a specific allegation about the end of the relationship. It stated that court documents reported Myers provided Jane Doe number one an excessive amount of wine and raped her as she cried and tried to fight him off. There is another detail in the sentencing record that deepens the church

dimension of this case. According to federal prosecutors, in nineteen ninety four, Victim and Independence wrote to the church in Arkansas to disclose Meyer's activities while he had been youth director. And Independence the DOJA stated that Myers, working at the Arkansas church in that time, intercepted the mail, wrote to the victim and tried to persuade her not to disclose, telling her that it would bring scandal to the church.

That detail matters because it suggests not only abuse, but active pressure against disclosure inside the same institutional world that had helped establish his credibility in the first place. That is also what gives the opening of the story its weight. Once the latest sentencing facts are known, the church world at the beginning no longer stays ordinary. The title of youth director is no longer just a description of employment. It becomes part of the mechanism by which trust, access

and concealment were made possible. The public record later tied additional victims to overnight church lock in and a church camping trip. Those were not incidental settings. They were part of the environment in which Myers had already been normalized

and trusted. On May one, twenty thirteen, the DOJ announced that Myers, now described as fifty three years old, pleaded guilty in federal court that day before US magistrate judged John T. Morgamer to transporting a minor across state lines for legal sexual activity and to receiving child pornography over the internet. That plea announcement also embedded a second track

of accountability. Under the terms of the federal plea agreement, Myers was required to plead guilty in the Circuit Court of Jackson County, Missouri, to first degree statutory sodomy and attempted enticement of a child. The Jackson County Prosecutor's office, the plea release said, would recommend ten year sentences on each of the two state counts to run concurrently with

each other and with federal sentence. The same DOJ release stated the federal sentencing exposure a mandatory minimum sentence of five years in federal prison without role, up to thirty years in federal prison with parole, plus a fine up to five hundred thousand dollars at sentencing. The DOJ said the district court treated Myers as a serial abuser based on a pattern involving six additional miners beyond Jane do

number one. According to the sentencing release, that patron included the Jackson County case where he digitally penetrated one twelve year old girl and fondled another twelve year old girl,

both occurring in his home. The sentencing release then listed other instances of sexual abuse or exploitation described in court documents including the fondling of a thirteen year old victim on an overnight church lock in, the fondling of a sixteen to seventeen year old victim on a church camping trip, the fondling of a fifteen to six year old victim at his apartment, and producing in his Blue Springs home a pornographic image of a pre pubescent girl identified in

the release as a seventh victim. The same sentencing release also noted that the government offered evidence of other inappropriate and suspicious, although not criminal, interactions between Myers and his neighbor's girls. This is the point where the case stops reading like a prosecution built around one victim and one computer seizure. It becomes something broader, a pattern spread across years,

settings and victims. On May sixteenth, twenty fourteen, US Chief District Judge Greg Kay's sentenced Myers to thirty years in federal prison without parole, which the DJ described as the statutory maximum sentence that matters. Because the plea release had already laid out the sentencing range clearly five years at the floor thirty years at the ceiling, the court imposed the ceiling. The DLJ framed the case as part of Project Safe Childhood, a nationwide initiative launched in May two

thousand and six. DOJ materials also state that Project Safe Childhood was expanded in twenty eleven to include all federal child sexual exploitation offenses, not only Internet related ones. Meyers appealed on December twenty second, twenty fourteen. The Appellate Court concluded that sentences were not unreasonable. It noted that the district court considered extensive evidence and arguments and explicitly, carefully and at length explained its reasons for varying upward to

the statutory maximum. The Eighth Circuit granted council leave to withdraw and denied Mar's motion for appointment of new council. Now, this is what people have to understand. The cross does not make a monster holy. A church title does not make a predator safe. A public profession of faith does

not make a corrupt man clean. Somebody can call themselves a Christian, stand in a sanctuary, work around children, talk about God, and still be sick, still be depraved, still be hiding rot underneath religious language and a respectable face. Because some of the people do not stand behind the cross in reverence they hide behind it. They use it

like cover. They use the trust it creates to use the hesitation people feel when it comes time to question somebody who sounds righteous, looks respectable, and belongs to the right institution. That is how the disguise works, not by looking demonic, by looking familiar. So no, this is not an attack on every Christian. It is an attack on the fantasy that Christianity by itself is guaranteed of morale safety. It is not. The cross on the wall means nothing

if the man standing under it is rotten. The title means nothing if the purse holding it is corrupt. Belief claimed out loud is worthless when the life behind it is poisoned. And that is why stories like this matter, because they remind people that evil can sing hymns, evil can quote scripture, Evil can shake your hand in a fellowship hole and ask your family how is everybody doing. Evil can hide behind the cross until the drags it out into the light. And that is what happened here,

and that is the story until the next one. Everybody be well later,

Transcript source: Provided by creator in RSS feed: download file
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android