Support for this podcast and the following message come from the NPR Wine Club, which has generated over $1.75 million to support NPR programming. Whether buying a few bottles or joining the club, you can learn more at nprwineclub.org slash podcast. Must be 21 or older to purchase. Hi, this is Morgan from Lexington, Kentucky.
I found out this week that after five years of general surgery residency, a year of research, a year of breast surgery fellowship, and countless hours of studying, I passed my general surgery oral boards, and I'm now board certified. This podcast was recorded at 1.35 p.m. Eastern Time on Wednesday, December 4th, 2024. Things may have changed by the time you listen, but I'll finally be picking out frames for all of my degrees and diplomas, including my board certification. Okay, here's the show.
Wow, congratulations. That's no small feat. That's awesome. So much work. Yeah. Hey there, it's the NPR Politics Podcast. I'm Ashley Lopez. I cover voting. And I'm Domenico Montanaro, Senior Political Editor and Correspondent. And today we also have NPR's Jasmine Garz, who's with us. She covers immigration for us. Hey, Jasmine. Hi. So today on the show, we're going to be talking about how immigration policy in the U.S. may change when President-elect Donald Trump takes office. Jasmine.
I want you to remind us of some of the things Trump campaigned on. Obviously, immigration was a huge issue for his campaign. What do we know about what he had his sights set on when it comes to changing immigration policy? Yeah, I mean, I would say it was. like the centerpiece of his campaign. And a couple of things that he's promised is namely mass deportations. He's said he's going to enact the biggest deportation in U.S. history.
And then, of course, securing the border, closing down the border, which I'm at the border right now. And Trump is inheriting a very quiet border, actually. But that's like the promise that he's. going to really make it more secure. Yeah. And I know you've been talking to folks who are likely to be impacted by these actions. How are they reacting to all this? What are you hearing from them?
I mean, the big thing I'm hearing is, you know, people reading up and studying on their rights. And I've also been spending a lot of time with mixed status families, meaning. You know, mom is undocumented or husband is undocumented, wife is undocumented, and kids are a citizen. And what I'm hearing a lot of is people preparing for the worst case scenario. Estimated 11 million American citizens are part of a mixed status family. And so...
That's a lot of people. And what I've been hearing is these plan B preparations. You know, what the kids should do if the parents don't make it back home. You know, what to do with the savings. A lot of contingency plans. that I'm hearing about. And Domenico, I wonder what...
this says about how much of a mandate Donald Trump has when it comes to immigration. Voters have said consistently during, you know, running up to the election that this was a main issue for them and that they trusted Trump obviously more than his main opponent, Vice President Kamala Harris. What do you make of like how much of a mandate he has coming into next year?
Well, I mean, I think that mandates are always overread by presidents, especially presidents who don't get 50 percent of the vote. And even when they do, I mean, in the modern era, you don't really get a very large percentage, certainly nothing in the 60s like we may have seen.
decades earlier. And even then, scholars have said that they feel like those mandates are overread, but that doesn't stop presidents from using their victory to say that they have a mandate. And we've seen that from presidents in both parties. And certainly Trump was more
favored by the general electorate when it comes to how to handle immigration. And he thinks that he has the wind at his back on this, especially with his base. It has been the animating issue since Trump came on the political scene. It's worth noting comprehensive immigration reform has long been on the wish list for Congress, but there's been little to no appetite to actually address it. But Trump also would not be the first president to take action from the White House.
I mean, you know, Congress has been unable to pass comprehensive immigration reform in a very long time. And so the response to that has been executive actions, right? I mean, whether it's former President Barack Obama. with DACA or, you know, even this year, we saw a string of executive actions from President Joe Biden about virtually closing down the border to asylum seekers and executive actions. to offer certain protections.
to mixed status marriages. And so Congress is so unable to do any kind of bipartisan legislation or reform that the executive action has kind of become the only way to budge. Yeah, look, I mean, a comprehensive immigration overhaul is really the only way through what's kind of a very messy situation. I mean, the fact is there are far too few judges in this country who adjudicate.
whether or not somebody should be in the country or not, or if they have an asylum exemption. And people are in the country for extended periods of time before they can get a hearing before a judge. The 2013 legislation that former President Obama pushed for would have added a significant number.
of immigration judges. It would have done a lot on border security, and it would have had a pathway for citizenship for the millions of people who are in the country illegally. And there were some pretty strict restrictions on... how they would be able to achieve that. And it did appeal to the U.S. Senate. It got 68 votes. Almost nothing gets 68 votes nowadays, but it was killed by the Republican-controlled House. And ever since then, there really has been no movement.
to change that. You know, President Obama, when he won reelection, the Republican National Committee put out a growth and opportunity project point to say that in 2013, that without. Being in favor of comprehensive immigration reform, that the party would shrink to a base that was that was only people who were as part of a smaller and smaller share of the Republican base.
Nominate Donald Trump went in a very different direction, and yet Trump won a record share of the Latino vote, 46 percent in this election. So I don't think the lesson that Republicans are going to take from the 2024 election is that they need to be. more backing or more in favor of a comprehensive overhaul. Okay, well, let's take a quick break more in a moment.
This message comes from WISE, the app for doing things in other currencies. Send, spend, or receive money internationally and always get the real-time mid-market exchange rate with no hidden fees. Download the WISE app today or visit wise.com. T's and C's apply. This message comes from NPR sponsor, the UK government. It's time to make your UK visa digital.
If you have a BRP card that expires on the 31st of December, 2024, or a stamp or vignette sticker in your passport, you should change to an eVisa now. This means it will never be lost and can be accessed online at any time to prove your right to live, work or study in the UK. It's free and your immigration status won't be affected. Find out more now at gov.uk forward slash e-visa.
From the online trends that dominated 2024. On the spectrum of rat to demure. Where are you right now? To spicy TikTok viral reads. These romance fantasy books about dragons. NPR kept you up to speed on pop culture. Hi, it's Mariel Segarra from LifeKid. There's a first time for everything. including giving to NPR. Whether you're a brand new listener or a longtime fan, please join the community of NPR network supporters today. Make your gift at donate.npr.org. And thank you.
And we're back. Jasmine, another thing that is kind of an open question here is how cities are going to react to some of these immigration policies. Right. A number of cities mostly run by Democrats have already said that they wouldn't use local law enforcement. to assist in federal immigration activities. How are you seeing cities as well as states sort of responding ahead of inauguration? Yeah, I think we're going to see a patchwork. I mean, we see Republican cities and states who...
you know, have already for quite some time now been attempting to pass their own take on immigration enforcement, really jumping on the Trump administration bandwagon. Places like Florida. like Texas, right? In the case of Florida, you know, Florida has some of the most stringent immigration policy in the country already. So those states are fully in support. And then we're already seeing blue states.
and cities pushing back. We have the mayor of Denver saying we're not going to allow these mass deportation programs here in Denver. And I think that's going to be one of the really big... that we're going to be seeing almost as soon as Trump takes office is these blue cities and states pushing back against immigration enforcement. I do want to take a moment to talk about the optics of all this.
In Trump's first term, he did get a lot of criticism for his administration's family separation policy, which split up migrant families as they entered the U.S. without prior authorization. Jasmine, in your reporting, do you see the incoming administration's members, maybe drawing lessons from all that and how they're messaging what they want to do starting next year? Yeah, 100%. I mean, one thing that has been really striking to me is to hear.
Tom Homan, the new border czar appointed by President-elect Donald Trump. Talk about immigration enforcement. A lot of what he has said has to do with child trafficking.
human trafficking. And when I hear that, I definitely think that the Republican Party has kind of taken a cue from what happened in the last Trump administration, which were these terrible optics of children being sat... from their family, I think there's a reality which is, you know... people who voted or who support mass deportation and what that's going to look like on the ground, especially with, you know, businesses and the economic impact. I think it's one thing to...
wish for that or envision that. And I think it's another to find that suddenly the food chain is disrupted or there are less employees available at a business. And I think that is another thing. That could be a really challenging optic. I really think that it's going to depend on how this plays out. I don't think that we have any real sense of the way people are going to react if they're watching images on television of children.
being ripped from their arms of their parents and sent away. And then those stories are followed later. If you don't see a lot of that, then it's going to be something that Trump is going to say that he did a good job on, of course. This is really where sort of, as the cliche goes, the rubber hits the road because people have really contradictory views when it comes to immigration. I mean, views really aren't fully formed in public opinion on this. I mean, take, for example, our NPR PBS news.
Marist poll from late September, early October, 59 percent said that all immigrants in the U.S. illegally should be deported. But in the same poll, 57 percent said that America's openness. to people from all over the world is essential to who we are as a nation.
And then in the exit polls in an election that Donald Trump won, 56 percent said that immigrants in the U.S. illegally should be offered the chance to apply for legal status. Just 40 percent said that they should be deported. And I think that what that says is that when.
things are not that consistent, that it's possible to change people's minds, that there's room for this to go sideways or for people to be in favor of people being deported. Yeah, I think there are a lot of instances where the politics of this seem to be.
Kind of all over the place. I mean, a good example, Jasmine, is in New York City. The mayor there, Eric Adams, has expressed that he plans on working with the Trump administration, you know, when it comes to immigration. What are you hearing from folks in New York? I mean, yeah, I think that we are going to see some of that. I mean, New York.
Kind of its whole identity is based on immigration and the myth of the immigrant who comes and pulls himself up from his bootstraps. And Adams has for a long time been kind of defying that stance. You know, it is also true that there was a very concerted campaign to overwhelm cities like New York City, like Chicago with newly arrived migrants. And on the other hand, Adams has been more and more. aligning himself with a Trump administration.
You know, what I'm hearing is people just bracing, preparing themselves in the immigrant community and not assuming that New York is this safe space for immigrants that it's always been, just preparing to kind of put up a fight.
And, you know, even anecdotally, just really interesting is whenever I've talked to Trump supporters in New York, in other parts of the country, and we really get down to the nitty gritty of mass deportations, at least in a intimate conversation, I usually hear, you know, at the end of the day, this would be something that would collapse our economy, it would severely
disrupt the food chain. It's not feasible. So there is kind of this acknowledgement of a fantasy versus a reality in practice and what that will look like. Well, I think we'll leave it there for today. Jasmine, thank you so much for bringing your reporting to the podcast. Thank you. Thanks for having me. I'm Ashley Lopez. I cover voting. I'm Domenico Montanaro, senior political editor and correspondent. And thank you for listening to the NPR Politics Podcast.
This is Eric Glass. On This American Life, we specialize in compelling stories. from everyday life. I was like, wow, you literally just died and came back. And the first thing you ask is, do you need any money? Your life stories, really good ones in your podcast feed. This American Life. Hi, I'm Laurel Wamsley and I cover personal finance for NPR.
That means I report on some of the questions that might keep you or your loved ones up at night. Like, will I ever be able to buy a home? What about retirement? As interest rates drop, where should I put my money? Economic headlines can be confusing, but NPR is here to help you make sense of them. To support this coverage, please give today at donate.npr.org.
Listen to this podcast sponsor free on Amazon Music with a Prime membership or any podcast app by subscribing to NPR Politics Plus at plus.npr.org. That's plus.npr.org.