Parental Rights vs. State Decisions - podcast episode cover

Parental Rights vs. State Decisions

Jan 25, 202419 minSeason 23Ep. 302
--:--
--:--
Download Metacast podcast app
Listen to this episode in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episode description

A transgender teen wanted to update his school records. Oklahoma created a rule to stop him., NBC News, by Tyler Kingkade, on Jan. 9, 2024, https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/oklahoma-ryan-walters-transgender-teen-school-records-rule-rcna130816

The Non-Prophets, Episode 23.03.2 featuring Phoebe Rose, Infidel64, Jimmy Jr and Kelley


In the midst of a legal battle in Oklahoma, a courageous teen finds himself entangled in a clash with the state's educational system, led by the controversial superintendent, Ryan Walters. The superintendent is accused of personal bias, discrimination, and violating due process, setting the stage for a complex and contentious situation.


Walters wields significant influence, using it to have a petition for changes denied by the Oklahoma State Board of Education. Under his influence, an emergency rule demanding state approval for alterations is passed, sparking a lawsuit that accuses Walters of overstepping and infringing on parental rights.


The broader implications of this clash shed light on the challenges faced by transgender individuals in navigating conservative policies. Walters' stance on transgender issues, rooted in what critics call bigotry, exemplifies the broader struggles of the transgender community in the face of discriminatory practices.


Oklahoma's education system, already under scrutiny, is further brought into question. Ranked 45th for educational attainment among states, the system faces criticism for its apparent prioritization of religion over education. Walters, criticized for accepting funds from certain sources while opposing others, faces allegations of inconsistency and bias in his leadership.


The clash also unveils a pattern of controversial decisions by Walters, including his opposition to receiving international funding from a competitor country. This opposition, critics argue, came after facing scrutiny, indicating a potential attempt to divert attention and save face.


As the discussion unfolds, it becomes apparent that the issues extend beyond the specific legal battle. The controversy exposes deeper problems within Oklahoma's education system, raising questions about the transparency, ethics, and priorities of those in positions of power.


The broader impact of discriminatory practices on marginalized groups becomes evident, with the clash reflecting a larger societal struggle for equality and justice. As the legal battles continue, the situation highlights the need for reform and a more inclusive approach to education in Oklahoma.


In summary, the clash in Oklahoma encapsulates a multifaceted narrative involving legal battles, discrimination, and broader issues within the education system. It serves as a microcosm of the challenges faced by marginalized communities and underscores the urgent need for reform and equity in education.


Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-non-prophets--3254964/support.

Transcript

A courageous Oklahoma team finds himself entangled in a legal battle against the state's educational system, led by the controversial superintended of bigotry, Ryan Walters. Walterers uses influence to have their petition denied by the Oklahoma State Board of Education. Under walters influence, an emergency rule demanded state approval for such changes was passed. A lawsuit now accuses Walter a personal, biased discrimination and blatant violation of due

process and pronal rights. The class sheds light on the broader challenges faced by transgender people and navigating conservative led policies that, in this case, appear to be driven by Walterers' biggotest stance on transgender issues. This story is from NBC News by Tyler Kincaid on January ninth, twenty twenty four. Oklahoma, Oklahoma, Oh, Oklahoma. What do we do with Oklahoma? What do we do with Oklahomer? What do we do with Ryan Walter's or what do we

do with Ryan Wolf? He is a real problem. He is a genuine issue in this day and age. I mean from dance scholarship, theft to Bibles in classrooms, to not knowing the first thing about actual education. To what we see here is analogous to Oklahoma creating a bill of a tainder. Those you who don't know what a bill are attainder is. It was medieval Britain used to use bill of attainders. Henry the Eighth's liked quite a lot.

He would have his parliament past legislation to remove civil rights and in some cases, the right to life from people he didn't like. They were. Mainly you could mainly tell who they were because they were Catholic. You could mainly tell those people because they'd slept with his wife or something, or he

wanted a new wife. You could usually tell things like that. But Oklahoma, and you know, good old Riah Walters is doing the same thing here, taking a group of people and removing the civil rights and declaring them guilty of existing incorrectly, which is absolute pettiness, an absurdity. I mean, Kansas has been to the punch on some of these bill of attainers. I mean Kansas passed an entire piece of legislation to stop one person playing sports,

one person playing sports. It's absolute utter CODs. What policies we see coming from Superintendent Wishy Washy Walter's here. It's absolute fast. Shall we say, he comes along not knowing the first thing about what he's supposed to be doing. As I say, he is the superintendent of the education system, the title should give him some clue that he's supposed to be doing. Education. Doesn't do that. He does religion. Religion, that's what he does.

He does bigod tree. The word that's missing there is education. It's missing here. But the problem that Ray Walters has created here is that he's created an Oklahoma education system that's laughable. Out of the fifty states in the Union, Oklahoma sits forty fifth for educational attainment, just Arkansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, and West Virginia, not the least religious of places on earth. In fact, probably as not as religious, if not more religious than Oklahoma,

all below them. So I'm sensing a correlation here, not necessarily a causation, but I'm sensing a definite correlation here. Kelly, Yeah, there is definitely a correlation. And I noticed that all of those states tend to be in a certain geographical area of the United States too, at which I find West Virginia is not saying it's a conversation of West Virginia is fiftieth. Yeah, And I don't know if anybody knows who who mister Ryan Walters is.

But I did do a little dig into finding out exactly what he stands for some of the things he's done in his political career, and in nineteen or in nineteen, in twenty Book of Me in twenty twenty two, he probably he is from the part yes, and sometimes my brain gets stuck back there.

So but while he was campaigning in twenty twenty two, he did promagate the old litter boxes in high school bathrooms Hopes, which I thought was really funny because I've made it no secret that I live in an area where there's very few people, and in like a twenty five mile radius, we have three small towns. All three towns have their own high school, and that rumor was going around, but it was always at that other two high schools.

It was never at the high school that they of the town you were in, you know, So if you were in my town, it was in the other two high schools, And I thought that was really funny. None of the high schools actually had it happening. It was the other high schools that were but almost as soon as he got into office. Because I'm

just digressing here, so let's get back. He did fire two teachers because they were They were very critical publicly of a bill that had just been passed by the Oklahoma legislature that was what they could teach about gender and race, sex and race. So they were kind of pissed off about that and wanted

to change it, and sure enough he fired them. In twenty twenty three, he spoke at a Mom's for Liberty you may have heard of them, at their national summit in Philadelphia, and he advocated eliminading, eliminating the United

States Department of Education, and he also criticized teachers' unions. Then then in a July just a month later, town hall, he was asked, how does the Tulsa race massacre not fall under the definition of being taught as critical for a critical as an example of critical race theory, and he responded, let's not tie it to skin color and say that skin color determined what happened at the Tulsa that in that incident. Yes, yes, you're right,

he is a bigot. Yes, people did vote for him. Hey, you know what, you can't use that word on here, even if it does rime with dark get out of here. So this guy has got a long, a long history of being bigoted, and not only bigoted against gender, but of race as well. So I mean, what we're seeing here this time, it doesn't surprise me at all. I mean, it's just

powerful the course of what this guy is like. I've got some more things, but I don't want to take up all the time, So I'm going to pass it on to Jimmy and I'll go over some more when it comes back to me. You're you're quite the thespian you and your your duck acting partner. I don't know how I'll follow that, but I don't think that there's a whole lot I would disagree with all of you on either. I think I found my own correlation and perhaps not causation. And I don't know

if the timing of this law is a coincidence or not. But you know, on the very same meeting agenda, in fact, the very the very item preceding discussion of this law at the September twenty eighth, twenty twenty three meeting of the State Board of Education, it was that the Tulsa Board of Education was still accepting Chinese government funding after the Confucius Institute program had been deemed a subversive Chinese foreign mission by the State Department in two thousand and nine.

And so the real problem with this funding, which I don't know if it's necessarily illegal, but I certainly frowned upon, in that all one hundred and almost all one hundred and forty three recipients of this funding have ceased their contracts except for seven. And not only that, but the Tulsa Board of Education was covering up receiving these funds and not informing parents, and instead they were

receiving funds from a kind of through a shadow organization in Texas. And this report, there was a report done by Parents Defending Education that found that this funding was being masked. And I just think it's significant because this discussion, the discussion of passing this law took place kind of right after this. Walters had to justify why the Tulsa Board was still accepting money. He actually had to answer to Congress because of this due to in depth investigation that was taking

place there. And I think that we're seeing the transgender community perhaps be a scapegoat. We've seen that before. Minorities or disparaged groups just kind of thrown under the bus to take the heat off of government officials for I don't know other reasons, and so I don't know if this is correlation. It's probably

not causation. But being under fire for accepting funds from a foreign shadow organization through a domestic shadow organization that aimed to indoctrinate children should not be met with more harm to other children by denying them their rights. And so all in all, the Oklahoma education system just seems to be falling apart in multiple facets and just can't get anything right. So, Infidel, what do you say? Ryan Walters has demonstrated himself to be quite usedless character on more than one

occasion. We've covered him on nonprofits. But I think you really nailed something there, Jimmy, when you're talking about how you know, we okay, we had a mistake, we're having to answer far it let me distract you with something else. I see this time and again with even family members who you know, it's like, yeah, but what about you know, Europe or Hillary's emails or whatever little popular distraction that can get someone away from their

own shortcoming. And obviously he's not going to want to approach that. But one thing I did listen to very carefully was one thing that Walters made a comment on Real America's Voice. It's a rather right wing media organization, but he said, parents absolutely know what's best for kids, and anyone who doesn't understand has no business being involved in education whatsoever. Ryan Walters, there,

a man, I'm with you. This coming sup you there, because in the article itself, the parents of this child, one a conservative political leaning father and one a god fearing church going mother, both support him. So Ryan Waters the doors over there, don't let it hit you on the way out. Absolutely. I mean, this is a guy. And when we think about an emergency rule, this is six grown people sitting in a room making a decision that's going to impact this teen boy. And they're overriding not

only a parent's decision, but a court order. What could possibly be so important? I do know that in their statement they claim that they wanted to protect the accuracy of historic records for future use. Were damn y. Let's let's let's let's see some let's see some literacy. Let's see some literacy in Oklahoma. So someone could even read those records. But seriously, what could be the result if a student in Oklahoma was allowed to update their records.

That would require six people to make this such a priority. And if they've been with the schools at forty fifth in the nation, how many people could read those records. Yes, absolutely, let's focus on teaching your kids, and let's not worry about six people who are being paid by the state to bully a young kid without even seeing him. You know, so much for knowing what's best for the parents, knowing absolutely what's best for their child.

You know, I think that only applies when the parents agree with Walters. But you know another thing that I found totally sickening is quoting Walters again. He said, we're not going to do the transgender game of back and forth, back and forth. That is such a dishonest statement. You know, you would think that people got up and said, well, what kind of cereal and what gender do you want to go through the courts today to decide

you're going to be this This is so dishonest on so many levels. But this puts Ryan Walters right back where it belongs, and that is where he thinks what he knows is best is the right one. Brian Waters doesn't care

about children. He's busy. I think to remember here, though, is who do these documents affect apart from the student themselves, who in this day and age, no one on this panel, nobody watching unless the actual students themselves is watching, or is an educator that's going to receive their high school transcripts is watching. Is affected by this in any way, not even in

the slightest. But for him it is more important about his grandstanding than him and his unwillingness to accept people not as they are, but how he decides they need to be. You know, it was touched on the Tulsa Race massacre and how let's not bring color into that. And he's even said that separation of church and state is a myth, so it's in the titles occurred. But then again, the religion foundation is this state sponsored atheism according to

him. So in Ryan Walters World ran the world is what Ryan Walters wanted it to be and what his supporters wanted to be in their delusion to well, essentially run scared and insidious thing here though, the most insidious thing that I picked up this was the echoes that you hear from the same people who said you will want a slave, I don't recognize you as a free post to trans people who say I don't recognize you as the sex that you actually

are. What they're saying is you were once assigned to be the property of somebody else, and they're saying to trans people, you will once assigned a sex of birth. Don't matter if it was accurate, don't if you had

any choice in it. Those are the same rhetorics, and people need to realize racism and transphobia go hand in hand, and until people like Ryan Walters are chased away from the education system and chased away from ruining people's lives, it's going to continue because you're going to have court orders that are defied. You're going to have lives ruined because THERESO if we watched protective, historically accurate records, because you were assigning something that you had no choice in in the

same way that slaves were assigned property at birth of somebody else. And what makes it even more egregious is that trans people were denied the right to get married for years, and slaves were also denied the right to get married in the same way that free people were because it wasn't just their vows that said till death do us part, it was till death or distance to us part.

Because they weren't seen as having been assigned correctly within the system. And when you see these parallels, I am physically sick that it is still going on in the twenty first century in the most industrialized nation on earth. Yep. I wanted to, you know, Jimmy mentioned the whole thing that was going on with China, and he actually opposed that a lot. He was very outspoken about that Chinese funding from what I understood. However, when he

did give an okay too. And we just mentioned this earlier this week in an earlier story, Prager you came to Oklahoma school districts and wanted to provide curriculum with funding from gas and oil companies that had a little bit of propaganda in it. And during congressional hearings, Representative rolb Riyalva I always have a hard time saying his name as to Walter's about allowing the oil and gas industry to influens climate change curriculum through prager you, and he responded, these are

American companies that are a benefit to the American economy. So I don't see any issue with them having influence on our education system. So it kind of was like to me, it was like this two face thing. We don't want these people having influence, but it's okay to let these people do it. And he also he also wanted to sue the FFRF the Freedom from Religion for a Foundation for sending a letter to an Oklahoma school district asking them to

stop using prayer in the school curriculum. The FFRF then issued an open letter to Walters saying, you regularly misuse the official governmental social media afforded to your public office and treat it as a pulpit from which to preach your personal or religious views and Christian nationalist propaganda. And that was just seven weeks ago than weeks ago that they issued that statement. So this is not a nice guy. This is not the kind of guy that we want in charge of our

children. So yeah, I just don't I don't even know why these people in Oklahoma would have this guy there. So I think his opposition to receiving international funding from a competitor country came after he was after he was confronted about it, in which he had to kind of stand up and save face continue his grandstanding. You know, the Tulsa School District makes a million dollars a year through this program, and having found other donors to take that place is

not a surprise at all. And I still stand by the idea that, you know, it's probably it's probably pretty likely that you know, he kind of replaced this one scandal with another one that I think he can get a lot more political support for. And so I want to I want to go to answering Phoebe's question about you know, do we think education is being forgotten. I don't think it's being forgotten. I think it's being weaponized. I

think it's very much on the front burner. I think everybody has their eye on education and they're trying to find a way to manipulate it, to use it in their favor, at least at least where I think, you know, white Christian nationalism excuse me, white Christian nationalism is concerned. I would have to say that I agree with the thought that education is very much a priority for people like this. More accurately, perhaps I should say miseducation.

But there is a goal, there is very much an agenda and a plan that they have an effect with this. This isn't just idle chitchat now. Admittedly I think they bounce from target to target because in this type of environment you always need somebody to say the them to somebody else's to somebody. We can disparage and as Phoebe pointed out, quite literally dehumanize, And that's what's going on there. You need that enemy. In nineteen eighty four, Europo

was friends with this one and enemies with that one. Up now it's where friends with you know, Eurasia and enemies with you know. They always bounced around and then that's what they're doing. They're they're bouncing from enemy to enemy here. And really, at the end of the day, education shouldn't be a weapon, but it has become that. And Phoebe I will just say this to Ryan Walter's directly. If you want to teach religion, go and teach at your local Sunday school,

Transcript source: Provided by creator in RSS feed: download file
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android