Nobody wins in DeSantis’ war on woke - podcast episode cover

Nobody wins in DeSantis’ war on woke

Nov 14, 202316 minSeason 22Ep. 451
--:--
--:--
Download Metacast podcast app
Listen to this episode in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episode description

Nobody wins in DeSantis’ war on woke

Sun Sentinel, by Rae Leiner, on Oct. 29 2023, https://www.sun-sentinel.com/2023/10/29/nobody-wins-in-desantis-war-on-woke-opinion/

The Non-Prophets, Episode 22.45.1 featuring Kelley Laughlin, Cindy Plaza, Jimmy Jr. and Aaron Jensen

In the Sunshine State, Governor Ron DeSantis has declared a "war on woke," targeting teachers, medical providers, and marginalized communities, turning schools into political battlegrounds. This results in an exodus of educators and a plummeting teacher-to-population ratio.

Jimmy Jr appreciated the author's use of "incubator" to describe harmful laws spreading across states. He criticized warlike language, emphasizing its impact on marginalized communities, causing fear and divisiveness. Cindy characterized the GOP as rooted in fascist principles, relying on strongman narratives and vague terms like "woke."

Kelley pushed back against the idea that the war on woke originated solely in Florida, asserting it is a nationwide phenomenon. DeSantis is following a pre-established playbook trying to gain attention, and is becoming more radical in his presidential aspirations. Kelley mentioned DeSantis' endorsement by the governor of Iowa, indicating broader adoption of these strategies among Republicans.

Aaron defended the concept of being "woke," emphasizing kindness and empathy. He criticized the GOP for lacking a substantive policy platform and resorting to culture wars. Aaron stressed countering these ideas through collective efforts to make the country better.
Jimmy Jr agreed with Cindy's analysis, linking the GOP's need for a strongman to a playbook mentality. DeSantis, facing challenges in achieving his goals, adopts a more aggressive approach. He acknowledged the impact on teachers, doctors, and students, emphasizing the need to combat divisive rhetoric.

Cindy added that DeSantis is trapped by extreme positions he adopted to secure his initial election. She expressed curiosity about the governor's mindset and the challenge of maintaining these positions while navigating broader public sentiment.

Kelley shifted the discussion to the shortage of OBGYNs in Florida, debunking the idea that the war on woke directly causes this issue. He attributes the shortage to economic factors, including lower doctor pay. Kelley highlights the population increase in Florida, exacerbating the problem.

The panel briefly touched on the war on woke's impact on minority communities, expressing concern about the marginalization of these groups and potential long-term consequences.
In the final segment, the panel reflected on the harm caused by the war on woke. Aaron emphasized the decline in our ability to listen, believe others, and work towards compromise. Jimmy Jr predicted a decline in education quality due to the mass exodus of teachers. Cindy echoed concerns about the societal shift away from collaboration.

As the conversation was closing, Kelley noted that war on woke candidates did not fare well in recent school board elections, providing a glimmer of hope. The panel emphasized countering divisive rhetoric and working collectively to address challenges posed by the war on woke.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-non-prophets--3254964/support.

Transcript

Over in the Sunshine State. Ronda Santis has declared himself a general in the War on Woke, and he's attacking teachers, medical providers, and marginalized communities all to score political points. Schools have become political battlefields, and educators are fleeing faster than Floridians in a rainstorm. Florida's teacher to population ratio has plummeting

faster than a roller coast. Also, strict anti abortion and anti translaws are scaring away medical provider leading to longer wait times than ers and less attention in Classter. It's like a never ending roller coaster over there in Florida, and these battles are leaving more scorched earth than sunny days. But grab your popcorn and stay tuned for more drama. This article is from The Sun Sentinel by Ray Liner from October twenty ninth, twenty twenty three. Jimmy Junior, what

do you have to say? I thought that the author's comment that these policies and laws have created an incubator for harm in similar states was really brilliant, because I've never really associated the term incubator with kind of the birthplaces, if you will, of some of these more harmful laws that seem to transcend state lines. And so we know that a lot of these states that share maybe similar values, similar demographics, kind of have these same harmful laws taking effect.

They've seen it all across maybe the Deep South. But I really don't want to harp too much on that because I want to pivot to another point. Just a personal pet peeve of mine, and that's hearing politicians, among

others, use warlike terms and inflammatory rhetoric to describe issues regarding legislation. So when I hear like athletes, for example, talking about, you know, we're at war or we're bringing out the big guns, or hear certain groups taking a certain position, politicians, you know, political parties, whatever that may be, it always strikes me as like being a little bit cringe worthy.

Might be due to some of my military service, maybe some of the images that I have in mind, but whatever the case, I try not to romanticize this kind of thinking or this kind of imagery or stance. But while it may not necessarily be warlike, or I think it might be cringe worthy. Like I said, on the other hand, this kind of thinking really does make it warlike for the people that are being victimized and who are

on the receiving end. So we have like members of the African American or LGBTQ excuse me, LGBTQ communities that have really been impacted by harsh laws that really seek to discriminate people, and so they might feel like they are in some kind of crisis, some existential threat is taking place because they have people with this warlike combative mindset. And I really just think that it's this kind of language and this kind of attitude that causes people to fear for their own

safety, their own futures, their children, really is quite divisive. So I'm sick and tired of hearing politicians equate legislation to battlefield because it does nothing but put other people on edge and makes everybody anxious, and it's really just inappropriate in my mind. What do you think? Yeah, I think the entire JOPI movement right now is based on fascist principles and nothing else, the

main one being the strong man defense. You know that you need, you absolutely need a strong man in order to get out of whatever solution situation you are right now, and the idea that only a strong man can solve the party or the country's issues. It runs deep in the US is psyche. Uh, it's because it's intertwined with the gun culture, exceptionalism, misogyny, and and other deeply deeply rooted ways of thinking. And you know, every hero needs a villain, so if you don't have a villain, you just

make one up. And that's what the UP has been doing since pretty much Reagan, with increasing strength and precision. Work is great because it's a vay word, and every time you see on camera a right winger asked to define it, they just can't because it's too vague, and so it's it's it's it's really great for for for them because you can ascribe to it whatever you want, whatever you don't like. So it's pretty much like communism back in

the day, the previous iteration of the same trigger world. So it's not surprising to realize that this so called war on woke basically shoots itself in the foot because the population is meant to attract is already known to vote against its

own interest very very often. They're against socialism, as they say, well at the same time being the population with the highest use of footstems and federal assistance so yeah, you have one population that's flamed up with with the use of that of that world so that they can vote against their own interest by people who just want to rule them and not lead them. So it's I don't see how the US can can get out of this in the current situation.

One quick point note that Jimmy Jr. You were talking about the warlike language, and it always seems like the people who use that kind of language aren't the people who have actually been there, So you know, it's kind of a weird dichotomy to me. But I'm going to be the odd man out on this segment. I think one of the things I really had a real problem with this article about was that the author seems to think that the

whole thing started in Florida. It's all about Florida. The whole war on woke is Florida, and it's just spreading out from Florida, And that's not the case. DeSantis is just following a playbook that was already established. Has he been able to implement it better? Yes, Because he's the governor of a large state. He's gotten a lot of press lately because he's running for president. As he runs for president and he's losing. He's getting a little

bit more radical and a little bit more anti woke. But I don't think we can blame this all on DeSantis. I don't think he's a good guy in any way, shape or form. But I think we have to remember that this isn't just a Florida thing. This is a nationwide thing. And just this week he was endorsed by the governor of Iowa, of all places, Kim Reynolds, and she's been overseeing her state in pretty much the same exact way. So, like I say, I want to make it clear

that this is not just Ron DeSantis. This is going on everywhere, and I'm going to pass it down to Aaron. Yeah. So don't forget that the word woke they seem to kind of be using as a pejorative, but what really means just being kind to people and listening to what they have to say, and listening and believing them when they share their experiences, When they when they share their experiences that are negative in the world and that cause them pain, we just we just need to they want us. We need to

listen and help them and make the world a better place for everybody. And this war on Woke is really annoying at best because it just shows that the GOP really they really have no policy platform anymore. They really have no laws

that they want to put forth other than culture war bs. They just they want they want people to be who they want them to be instead of trying to make this country a better place and pass laws that actually help people, laws that actually help move us forward and make our country a better place. And how do we get out of this mess? I think Cindy asked that is going to take a lot of work from a lot of people to combat these ideas and to stand up and show up and and and and you know,

counteract these policies and these these ideas. Jimmy, Yeah, I like that you kind of pointed to Cindy's analysis because I thought it was very astute. And I think the idea of needing a strong man, especially in the

GOP or what we understand now to be the GOP. I think that some former Republicans would argue that the Republican Party is dead and is long gone, but what we identify now as the Republican Party, I think it's it's very much in their playbook and to Kelly's point about Rod DeSantis becoming more enraged, more more boisterous in his approach to how he kind of sends his message out,

I think is very much the playbook as well. I think we're seeing a person that realizes they're probably not gonna achieve the goals that they want,

I'll say that, and so they're just reacting harshly. I also think that while it's not spreading in Florida, or not necessarily only in Florida, Kelly, I will say that the Governor of Iowa's endorsement is probably just made in an attempt to kind of divert away from the MAGA crowd, and they probably see DeSantis is the only real alternative instead of going down the road of MAGA, which surprisingly I think a lot of Republicans actually don't want to do.

Probably many of them feel compelled to do it. But anyway, what I wanted to get to though, was that this all is not in just Florida. To Kelly's point, you know a lot of these states are attacking doctors,

they're attacking teachers. The mass exodus of teachers that this article references is something that is incredibly important I think to our country because as we see them, as we see them move on because they're expected to take on more for not any increased pay, things like you know, expecting to provide security and overall health and welfare to children, when when they're really not getting recognized for

those things, they're dealing with heavy government intervention telling them how they can and can't teach, what they can and can't do in the classroom. That is so far outside of what's expected for a teacher. You know, a teacher should be able to relate to their students, but this kind of anti woke

legislation is preventing them from doing that. And so we're starting to see that this warlike tone, this strong man trying to lash out at whoever they can, often victimizing teachers and doctors and students in states like Florida, but not only Florida, And so I think everybody's analysis kind of comes together in that

way. How does this relate to what we do at the ACA, Well, it's because Christianity and these rights wingers tend to hijack the moral high ground and kind of point the finger at the rest of us who don't agree with him and call us woke. As a pejorative like Aaron manche Sidney. Yeah, the summer thing that I wanted to address. The first one is the reason why the article calls Florida the incubator of this war on woke is because

the scientists made it his trademark and he was elected for that. And remember he was elected in a landslide. So on one hand, it's what he wants, But on the other hand, he's also stuck now because even though he realizes that many of his positions are too extreme to be accepted by most of the population of Florida, he's stuck with it because people ask for it, and he knows that if he doesn't provide, he won't be re elected and he wants to be president one day, so he cannot fail. So

he is stuck right now. And I would love to be in his inner circle, to be able to speak to him and see what's what's in his mind, because how do you succeed in in flaming people if you don't believe yourself what you're selling. I mean, it's and I'm not trying to evoke sympathy for him because he really doesn't deserve it, but it's still quite interesting

a position to be in in my opinion. So yeah, Kelly, Well, I did do a little bit of diving into some of the problems that were mentioned in this and one of them was that there was a shortage of obgy obgyns in Florida. And it turns out it's not about the war and

woke and it's again something that's happening all across the United States. In fact, the US Department of Health and Human Services estimates the will be a shortage of into it, there'll be a shortage of five thousand obgyns and twenty thirty all across the country. And this isn't a new trend either. It's been going on for decades because of the ever increasing population, and Florida is one of the states where the population has been increasing the fastest and the longer the

problem goes on. The more people are being born, and they just aren't getting enough people to do the doctoring, which may be an economic problem since the job doesn't pay as well as it did, say thirty years ago. Cost of education insurance is skyrocketed. Doctor Ashley Hill with Advent Health in Florida, whose job it is to recruit obgyns says the lack of doctors applying to these programs in central Florida has little to do with state restrictions and more to

do with the population. In fact, she says, one of the reasons we have a shortage is we are not training enough younger doctors who are taking the place of older doctors who are retiring and all of the people moving into this area. And then she goes on to say that only a handful of prospective recruits have actually mentioned Florida as abortion restriction, so apparently that's not causing

a shortage of doctors in the area. However, and you mentioned it, teachers, this has on the other side of the coin, this has hurt edge vucation really really bigly on the Is there a single school with or library board actually anywhere in the country that hasn't experienced something like this or had to

deal with somebody. I live in a place where there's like very few people on our library board and our local school board has both had war on woke people running for the boards been very vocal at meetings and yeah, it's happening everywhere, just everywhere. I want to get like quick thirty second answers and ask because I think education is probably what's hurt been hurt the most, but I'd like to get a quick thirty second answer from the panel to see what

they think. Aaron, what do you think has been hurt the most by the war on Woke? Well, education certainly has been hurt. Education is critical to a functioning democracy. I think the war on Woke is just our ability. The biggest thing that's been hit is our ability to listen and believe people and compromise and try to make the world a better place. I mean, when you when you turn other people's experiences into a war, that's you're

just You're not going to be able to move forward. You're not going to

be able to be harmonious and come together. Jimmy, I think the quality of education that students are going to receive is going to decline, if it hasn't already having a mass exodus of teachers who have already gone through the training and education to be able to do their job leave, who are they getting replaced with people that are you know, fast tracking their training or who maybe are not as qualified and a probably the second or third tier in the hiring

pool. And so I think that the education system as a whole, especially in these states that have these laws that target teachers, are probably going to suffer. Sure, I think that'll be a long term problem to analyze, but it's certainly not a good thing when one of the professions that's so critically undermanned starts to see a mass excidity. Yeah. I agree that education is going to suffer a lot. But to me, the worst thing about this so called on woke is that, as Aaron said earlier, Walk is just

trying to be nice. And when this is uh turning too being the bad the bad guy, it means that the assholes are being the nice ones and and and and that reverse is to me, uh, the scariest part of of all of this, because suddenly you live in a society where collaboration is not seen as neither beneficial or even even a good thing. So the US is already very very uh a place where being competitive and uh and where singiler

people are are always always a better view than than collectivities. And so I think that this is getting worse, much worse, And and I again I don't see how you can go back against that. All right, thanks, And nobody mentioned the marginal as of minority communities, including the LGBTQ community, which I think is a big problem to you. I'm not sure which is worse that one or the education, but they're right up there with each other.

To me quick update, in the recent elections, the War on WO candidates did not do very well in school board elections all across the country, so that's maybe a hopeful thing. And I want to mention that if you want to check out lots of cool ACA merchandise, you can go to tiny dot cc Aca merch

Transcript source: Provided by creator in RSS feed: download file
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android