Faith and Fraud: Churches Fleecing the Flock - podcast episode cover

Faith and Fraud: Churches Fleecing the Flock

Apr 06, 202420 minSeason 23Ep. 1304
--:--
--:--
Download Metacast podcast app
Listen to this episode in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episode description

Researchers say Christian leaders will embezzle an estimated $86 billion in 2024
The Friendly Atheist, By Hemant Mehta, on Mar 20, 2024


https://www.friendlyatheist.com/p/researchers-say-christian-leaders

The discussion delved into the issue of financial transparency and accountability within Christian organizations, particularly regarding the embezzlement of funds.


Kelley Laughlin shed light on the alarming statistic that Christian leaders may embezzle over $80 billion annually by 2024, as reported by the Center for the Study of Global Christianity and the Trinity Foundation. This embezzlement includes practices like skimming from offering plates and diverting mission donations to personal expenses.


The panelists highlighted the lack of financial oversight and transparency within religious institutions, emphasizing the need for routine audits, transparency measures, and consequences for illegal activities. They also discussed the pervasive influence of Christianity in American society, particularly in politics, and the challenges of holding religious organizations accountable due to societal norms and biases.


Suggestions for addressing the issue included implementing stricter financial regulations, promoting transparency, and demanding accountability from religious institutions.


 Additionally, there were calls for reparations to congregations affected by financial mismanagement, including refunds or evidence of funds being used for their intended purposes.

In a lighter tone, the panelists humorously proposed reparations in the form of amusement park trips and tangible improvements to church facilities, highlighting the long-standing issue of unfulfilled promises made to congregations for various projects.


Overall, the conversation underscored the importance of financial integrity and accountability within religious institutions and called for greater scrutiny and regulation to prevent financial misconduct and protect congregational assets.


The Non-Prophets, Episode 23.13.4 featuring Jimmy Jr., Blatant Blatheist , Cynthia McDonald and Kelley Laughlin


Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-non-prophets--3254964/support.

Transcript

Hello, viewers, this is the nonprofits, but we are not making a profit, not like your Christian church anyway. Do you know where your tithe is going? How do you even track all the money that you are pouring into your congregation or do you at all? You may want to start after hearing this segment, because Kelly Laughlin is with us and he is going to fill us in on how Christian leaders may very well embezzel over eighty billion in

twenty twenty four. Kelly, how do we arrive at such an astronomical number? Well, Jimmy, that figure comes from the Center for the Study of Global Christianity, part of the Gordon Conwell Theological Seminary. It's a religious organization, so this isn't an anti religion group, but they say that the churches will embezzle some three hundred and ninety billion dollars annually by twenty fifty. Now.

The Trinity Foundation, which is another religious group that's a watchdog group of other religious organizations, attributes those financial losses to skimming from our offering plates, diverting mission donations to personal expense accounts, and even international cash mouddeling, which they actually have cases of. While it isn't always easy to track how these statistics on crime that isn't caught. These Christian researchers say they have come up

with a good formula to figure it out. And what they've done is they've taken the amount of money that was generated by the economy and figured out the percentage of fraud from that, and then use that percentage to the amount of money brought in by churches. So it seems like a pretty good formula, and they are warning people within their faith to be wary of their church leaders.

Excellent point. And I like that you mentioned that the Christians doing this research and watchdogging, or excuse me, the people doing this research and watchdogging are in fact Christian. Yes, because you might think, well, the bias would typically swing in the other direction, right, But I think that this is a perfect example of Christians needing to be concerned about where their money is going. This is not our job. Heck, I wouldn't mind if

they stole from each other. To be honest with you, I'd like to see the whole system come crashing down. But as a person with their button the pews every week, you might want to be concerned asking the questions about, hey, where is that actually going? Blaydon, I want to ask you, do you think that there's a double standard between religious organizations the way that the account thing is done, and humanist organizations, let's say, or

non religious organizations. How do you reconcile the differences between how they account for their funds. I think the fact that churches don't have to file any financial disclosures with IRS is already insane. Like that alone makes it almost impossible to even quantify how much they actually take from people. And then the research in this article shows that Christians all over the world will give about one point three

trillion trillion dollars to Christian causes just in twenty twenty four. So imagine if we had that kind of money taken towards a humanist effort, like we could change the fucking world with that, you know what I mean, Like we would do so much with that. And I mean this, we're human. So even if it is a humanist effort going towards this, there's going to be some fraud. People are people's let's be honest. But I mean you have to think about that number is eighty six billion with a B That is

lost. So I feel like, can we just regulate these people? Can we get some kind of governmental infrastructure to come in and just say, hey, guys, where'd that money go? Like it's that so hard? Yeah, And that's a good point. I mean, can we bring in some oversight? Right? But how much is too much? What would be fair? And Cynthia, I want to turn to you and ask you, you

know, how much transparency should actually be required to the fullest. It's church, I mean, like, these are the people's that's the leaders of these people's immortal soul. You go to church every week in order for you to sit your butt in a pew and listen to somebody tell you about what Jesus did and why you should do it too, and if you don't, you're

going to hell or purgatory if you're Catholic. So it's absolutely pertinent in my opinion that there should be more transparency in how people are being told about how their money is being spent. I mean, like, I think that one of the things that the article actually even points out that it's not just mega churches that's doing this. We're still having issues even with smaller dioceses, smaller

churches that are still going to be caught in the fray of embezzling. And man, when you even talked about blatant that one point three trillion dollar of money figure that's going to like you know, Christian organizations and and also you know other causes. I'm my dang, that's a down payment on reparations. But I digress. Yeah, yeah, yeah, totally totally, yeah,

yeah, totally totally. We will get that going. But yeah, but like but seriously, it's it's just so sobering when you actually just think about like how the how churches and of themselves can be able to you know, take the money, put it in their coffers and do whatever they want to do with that with it without even telling the I R S. That's insane.

I mean, like we even covered like how the Morgan Church has a multi billion dollar war chest that is within their ranks, even though they have been accused of all types of heinous acts by their by their eldership, their leadership and and the like. Especially when I even think about like how they are still telling and going into poor country and telling people that they need to give and they need to tie even when they don't have it, and because

people feel that, oh, this is my immortal soul. You know, Jesus will reward me and my afterlife blah blah blah, you know, twelve gates to the city type stuff. Then I'm going to yeah, exactly, pie in the sky until you die. You're right, yep. And and

it's it's so egretous. It's such a loud high before you die is a big fat lie, Okay, And I gosh, and I just I really just wish that this whole like protection that the United States government gives to faith based organizations, which is completely go away because if you are a five oh one C three that is secular in orient and an orientation, you're not going to get that protection. It's just faith based organizations because Jesus said absolutely,

and we see that. Uh. You know, even in our own organization, we are five to one seed three nonprofit and we stick to the rules pretty thoroughly. While we also know that there are there's plenty of political preaching and ideology emanating from many pulpits across this country trying to sway voters, if you will, either left or right, probably not left too often, but

in any case, you know, why is it that the churches. Why is it that Christian or religious organizations in general are just kind of hands off. I think that for somebody that wants to control societies to such such extremes, that they should have the equal extremes placed on them when it comes to watchdogging. You know, there's some other things that I wanted to add on. Y Citia you you brought up a great points about how money is being

used. Let's not forget you know, the Catholic Church has a fund that is set aside to defend perpetrators of sexual assault or those that are accused or alleged. Why should any organization have a pot of money that is set aside to defend child molesters. It is an awful thing to think about, and it really doesn't compute and if it had the kind of oversight that we are we're looking for, if these organizations did, they might not even need something

like that, and they can actually do some good. You know, we saw, excuse me, after Notre Dame burned down, how much money was raised within a matter of twenty four hours. We couldn't get that to help the poor. But this is an organization that tells you, well, Jesus said, give all your things away. We got to help the poor. No, they just want Jesus or excuse me, they just want you to give your things to Jesus. But they'll collect it for them, and don't

worry about where the money goes. You know, we'll take good care of it. I think that there is a pretty pervasive nature to steal words from Cynthia. You know, I know that you came into the show mentioning that you think that the whuch as a pervasive nature. I think that the fact they pay no taxes, They've got huge acres of land that are just being used as grass beds. Essentially, there's not helping the economy. They're not doing any good for anybody. You know, I wanted to kick it over

to Kelly and Blatant. You know, what are some of the ways that you think the nature of religious institutions can be pervasive? Blatant, you want to go first? Sure. I think one of the most glaring and obvious ways that is pervasive is again looking at our politics. How many elected officials come in just literally their first thing is to say, well, I'm a good Christian man and I follow the Bible and that literally brings in people because

people are so damn indoctrinated. That's literally all you have to say is I'm a Christian. So I mean, like, how many has there ever been a non Christian president? No? No, no, So I mean that is the pervasive nature of this entire system, that it gets into everything because it already is in everything, and the people that are running the system are part of this exact same thing. So of course it's going to be. It's not even pervasive, is just what is because you're not getting into it.

It already is there. Yeah, And I think one of the big problems there is that the people who are in this system all think that everybody else in the system is just on the up and up just like they are. Right, because there are good people within that system, you know, I'm not going to deny that, but those good people aren't stopping the bad people because they're under the assumption that those bad people are good people too.

Otherwise, why would they be working at the church. Of Course they're good people. They're with the church, of course they're good people. And that's a huge problem. That's a huge problem. Yeah, there is this idea that you can say the simple buzzwords and you have checked boxes and you're one of the good guys. And I don't know how that overpowers or overshadows the

many atrocity that come out of these same organizations. And I just, you know, I guess I want to kind of pick your brains a little bit. You know, what do you think it is about the American psyche about and that is consistent I think across all races in the country. I mean, we've in our recording tonight talked about a few racial issues, and it's

easy to point to the divides. But what I see as a trend, and ironically so because of the divides that exist within Christianity, is that, you know, regardless of what your ethnic background is, as long as someone says a right Jesus, Czech Church, Czech Bible check, they're one of the good guys, and maybe we should support that person. I don't know how do our panelists tonight feel like we get to that point? Cynthia,

any thoughts on that? You know, I believe it just goes back to how we as a society is overwhelmingly Christian, and especially in the black community, is super uber Christian, and along with that comes with indoctrination. Even if they're not necessarily like Christian, you still have an overwhelming point overwhelming popular

populus. Rather that is still theist. And when you and I'm sorry theists, I'm just gonna tell you my opinion, but when you actually put a living sky Daddy in your life and instead of instead of like looking past that and looking within yourself and just looking at human beings that's who they are, you devoid yourself from critical thinking and skepticism. You know, as you just said, Jimmy, okay, I got the church check. You got my pastor check in. My pastor said check. You know, and if pastor

said, dad, I mean it's right. You know what I'm saying, And I mean like, and that's something that we see a lot in in place in people who happen to be especially i would say, like in more charismatic evangelical settings, they are super under that thumb of pastor said is right because Jesus said it's right, and man of God hears from Jesus, and therefore there go I you know, And I'm glad that at least that we have a trend of people actually kind of falling away from the church, and

we do have a rise of the nons right, the irreligious, and even having like more people who happen to be more agnostic and atheistic in their point of views, because at least if they start to look at the religion in of itself and how it can be more so of a fetter of a bond, especially on the mind, than they can kind of cast those things away and start to think for themselves and not necessarily be pulled in per se to being able to go along with the norm and do things like throw away on

your day on money, gentlemen, any comments on that go ahead. I was afraid you were going to say that one of the things that I did, Well, that's okay, I mean, I've got a question. No, no, okay, okay. I was gonna see one of the things

that we didn't bring up. Well, we did kind of bring it up, but I wanted I got it in my notes, so I wanted to mention it that the Trinity Foundation did give a list of solutions for the problem, and they included things like just normal things like routine audits, transparency, more oversight of the people who are in control of the church funds, maybe getting insurance to cover fraud, and the big one actually taking actions when there

are suspicions of illegal activity instead of thinking, oh, this person's on the up and up, so this just must be a mistake in the books, probably just a mistaken arithmetic. Maybe actually look into it, and I mean, that's that's I think is really really important. These are things that any any other nonprofit has to do. For the most part, we have we have to do that at the ACA. We have to have transparency, we

have to have oversite, we have to have routine audits. This is the toughest stuff that nonprofits do, and I don't understand why the church is able to get away without doing these things. Yeah, you know, Blaytant, I wanted to reflect on something you mentioned and that was, excuse me, the usual suspects that this is not a case of the usual suspects, is

it. When I think of eighty six billion dollars going missing, I think of a pope in a bulletproof car or on a golden throne, you know, I think of a bunch of men in really expensive garb that probably came from all over the world, you know, kind of just sniveling with each other. Haha, we did it again. But that's not the case, is it. What do you think now, No, it's not our usual suspects. It's not those Rick Flair preachers, you know, the stylin profile

and limousine riding, jet flying. It's not those guys. That's who you think it would be. But no, it's the people that actually handle the finances in these small churches and make a churches, whatever size the church. It's the people that have their hands and all of this stuff. People that understand the system, the trustees, the first lady, people that just do the day to day operations. These are the people that know all the intricacies

of the church. And again without any actual oversight, it's never going to stop. So like we keep saying, tie that your own risk, and it's symbolic anyway. It works just like prayer. It makes you feel like you've done something without actually doing anything. So yeah, and you know, on that note, as we wrap it up, I just want to go across the paddle with all this money that's being taken place, and this can be a fun one or excuse me, being taken this could be a fun

one if you'd like. I want to start with blatant and then work towards Kelly, I what is the number one thing that the church owes its congregation after stealing all this money from them? What do you think as much as minorities, black people in particular have given to the church. I feel like, just like Cynthia said, they can start our reparations by themselves. Great point, Cynthia, what are your thoughts on that? Reparations and a trip to six Flags? Like every church? Well yeah, I mean like in

your respective area. You know, some amusement park. All churches you need to take them in and the children too. You need to do it. And we want lunch, dinner, travel, and we also want to stay in sweets you can afford. If they're taking children, I want chaperones. Yeah, yes, yes, of course, of course. No, don't say the children go along. I'm not leaving my kids with the screw that. No, I'm going with them. Kelly, what do you think what

does the church owe us? I mean I have donated to church before when I was under their under their influence. What do you think you think they owe us the money they took our money, Give me the money back, or at least give us the receipts for where you are going to spend the money in the future. Right, start making that money back, make it do what you have to do to make that money back, and actually spend it on the things that you were supposed to spend it on them. I

think that is the best way to pay it. Pay it back, you know. I think you know what the church, The Church ows us evidence that what we were given to is a real thing. I want to I want Jesus to be standing up there like, hey, I appreciate y'all good stuff. That's what they owe us, because I think throughout my entire from age seven to like fifteen, they were working on the chapel or something,

and I'm like, what are they going to fix this thing? You know, I watch everybody put their hands in the jar and drop off money every week for years, and this thing was still beating up. So I don't know, I don't know what that money was being skimmed. Maybe that's why it took so long. You never know exactly. Listen, let me just say really quick, we ain't gonna talk about and blaytant. You can co sign on this. How long Black Church has been send money for the building

fund. May. We got to get that ball afixed. Yeah, come on Wednesday, we gotta get that ball afixed. Great, it is still cold, sir, on a coat in service. When the ball are going to be fixed? Sir? Twenty years later, twenty years later. A great discussion tonight, very lively at the end. I love ending the show that way, viewers. We've talked about a lot of things tonight. We've talked about some of the different segments that we recorded tonight that aren't part of this one.

Transcript source: Provided by creator in RSS feed: download file
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android