The Next Supremes: An American Horror Story Podcast - podcast cover

The Next Supremes: An American Horror Story Podcast

Anna Bogutskaya and Clarisse Loughrey
A weekly podcast where hosts Clarisse Loughrey and Anna Bogutskaya re-watch and discuss all of American Horror Story, one episode at a time.
Last refreshed:
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

5.07 Flicker

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. The episode we've been waiting for. Where Hollywood film god Rudolph "The Great Lover" Valentino turns out to be a vampire and The Countess' great love. Digressions include: F.W. Murnau's skull still missing, Rudolph Valentino's beyond-the-grave big dick energy, who might be a vampire in Hollywood now, Mr. Darcy's hand-flex, facts...

Jan 06, 20221 hr 12 minSeason 5Ep. 7

5.06 Room 33

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, Liz and Tristan fall in love, and the Countess' only weakness is revealed. Digressions include: the crying-laughing emoji, hot people dying. Every week, we pick our favourite Quote of the Episode, Bomer Boner Award for Horniest Moment, MVP of the Episode and Insensitive Historical Reference of the Week. We discuss...

Dec 29, 202142 minSeason 5Ep. 6

BONUS • American Horror Stories • Game Over

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, we review the final episode of American Horror Stories , Game Over. Anna and Clarisse pitch their dream episodes of AHSs. Digressions include: Seth Rogen's Yearbook , Zendaya, the AHS/MCU crossover no one except us wants, death by IP, sexy Mothman. → Follow us on Twitter @nextsupremespod → Follow Clarisse on @clar...

Dec 29, 202136 min

BONUS • American Horror Stories • Feral

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, we review the sixth episode of American Horror Stories , Feral. Digressions include: Aaron Tveit's Tony nomination, Cody Fern's accent, our pitch for Australian Horror Story and casting sexy Bigfoot spin-off series. → Follow us on Twitter @nextsupremespod → Follow Clarisse on @clarisselou and Anna on @annabdemente...

Dec 15, 202132 min

BONUS • American Horror Stories • Ba'al

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, we review the fifth episode of American Horror Stories: Ba'al (or Discount Rosemary's Baby). Digressions include: White Woman's Instagram → Follow us on Twitter @nextsupremespod → Follow Clarisse on @clarisselou and Anna on @annabdemented...

Dec 01, 202125 min

BONUS • American Horror Stories • The Naughty List

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, we review the third episode of American Horror Stories: The Naughty List Digressions include: YouTube drama, TikTok breakups, TooTurntTony and our own naughty lists. → Follow us on Twitter @nextsupremespod → Follow Clarisse on @clarisselou and Anna on @annabdemented...

Nov 24, 202135 min

BONUS • American Horror Stories • Drive-In

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, we review the third episode of American Horror Stories: Drive-in Digressions include: Glass Animals, which streaming service you'd like to be murdered by, and the mystery of two Glass Animals vinyls found by the bins. → Follow us on Twitter @nextsupremespod → Follow Clarisse on @clarisselou and Anna on @annabdemen...

Nov 17, 202142 min

5.05 Room Service

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, tiny vampires become a pandemic, and hipsters arrive at The Cortez. Digressions include: blood cheese, hipster hotels, vampires eating things, a lot of simping for Lady Gaga. Every week, we pick our favourite Quote of the Episode, Bomer Boner Award for Horniest Moment, MVP of the Episode and Insensitive Historical...

Jul 28, 202145 minSeason 5Ep. 5

5.04 Devil's Night

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, a spooky Halloween dinner party with your favourite American serial killers. Digressions include: matching The Avengers to serial killers, Dahmer , Loki hairflips, Every week, we pick our favourite Quote of the Episode, Bomer Boner Award for Horniest Moment, MVP of the Episode and Insensitive Historical Reference ...

Jul 21, 20211 hr 2 minSeason 5Ep. 4

BONUS • American Horror Stories • Rubber (Wo)Man

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, we review the first two episodes of American Horror Stories: Rubber (Wo)Man. Digressions include: sperm and the Haunted Mansion Disneyland ride. → Follow us on Twitter @nextsupremespod → Follow Clarisse on @clarisselou and Anna on @annabdemented...

Jul 20, 202151 min

BONUS • American Horror Story: Double Feature Coming Soon

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, we discuss everything we know about American Horror Story: Double Feature and speculate about what we can expect from it. → Follow us on Twitter @nextsupremespod → Follow Clarisse on @clarisselou and Anna on @annabdemented...

Jul 16, 202126 min

5.03 Mommy

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, everyone goes deep into their mommy issues. Digressions include: vampires getting high in What We Do in the Shadows and True Blood , people who are attractive to everyone, Labyrinth, Kyle MacLachlan, and ultra-specific dating profiles. Every week, we pick our favourite Quote of the Episode, Bomer Boner Award for H...

Jul 14, 202150 minSeason 5Ep. 3

5.02 Chutes and Ladders

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, everyone simps for Gaga. Understandably. Digressions include: terrible fashions, the TikTok room, The Sims, 1940s glamour, 1970s decadence, debunking Bianca Jagger on a horse, Andy, Keith and Robert (which Robert?!). Every week, we pick our favourite Quote of the Episode, Bomer Boner Award for Horniest Moment, MVP...

Jul 07, 202155 minSeason 5Ep. 2

5.01 Checking In

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In the first episode of a new season, Hotel, and the horniness is out of control. Digressions include: Lady Gaga as an auteur, the Fast and the Furious ride, Haunted Mansion, vampires, jawline season. Every week, we pick our favourite Quote of the Episode, Bomer Boner Award for Horniest Moment, MVP of the Episode and Insensitive H...

Jun 30, 20211 hr 12 minSeason 5Ep. 1

The Dandys

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. To round off the end of the rewatch of American Horror Story: Freak Show, Clarisse and Anna invite you to the totally objective, hyper-specific Dandy Awards, sponsored by Mott Frozen Goods. Featuring such suitably trashy categories as the Dandy Award for Best Line, the Bomer Boner Award for Horniest Moment, the Dandiest Dandy Mome...

Jun 16, 202133 minSeason 4Ep. 14

4.13 Curtain Call

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In finale of Freak Show, Dandy Mott rebrands the Cabinet of Curiosities and Elsa's time in Hollywood comes to an end. Digressions include: horses are weird, ponies are betters but donkeys reign supreme, Sir Top Hat is back, Titanic, Cabaret casting news. Introducing new weekly categories: Bomer Boner Moment, Paulson v Paulson, Big...

May 19, 202154 minSeason 4Ep. 13

4.12 Show Stoppers

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, Chester the Magician unravels, Stanley gets his comeuppance and Clarisse's Pinocchio theory is vindicated. Digressions include: Pinocchio, a Flex Tape callback, a cinephile murder mystery that Anna's definitely going to write, NPH and Clarisse's stage magic podcast, and an unforgivable omission from the AHS univer...

May 12, 202140 minSeason 4Ep. 12

4.11 Magical Thinking

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, Chester the Magician (Neil Patrick Harris) arrives at the Freak Show with his best friend Marjorie and his many chameleons. Digressions include: the Line of Duty finale, Magic (1978), some magic history, spoilers for The Prestige (2006), the unlikely influence of Dandy Mott on Zemo Introducing new weekly categorie...

May 05, 202142 minSeason 4Ep. 11

4.10 Orphans

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, Pepper loses her soulmate and Freak Show meets Asylum. Digressions include: Clarisse's distate of tissues, Newsies, monkeys with guns, Link , the joys of stage magic, Piffles the Dog Who Knows Introducing new weekly categories: Bomer Boner Moment, Paulson v Paulson, Big Feels for Big Drama, alongside the regular s...

Apr 28, 202141 minSeason 4Ep. 10

4.09 Tupperware Party Massacre

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, Dandy goes full murder and Jimmy is very depressed and making bad decisions. Digressions include: Clarisse's secret history as an Avon lady, the questionable horniness of this entire episode, Dandy-themed spinoffs Dandy in Paris, Dandy xoxo and The Dandy Diaries. Introducing new weekly categories: Bomer Boner Mome...

Apr 21, 202141 minSeason 4Ep. 9

4.08 Blood Bath

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, Dandy goes to therapy, Ethel and Elsa's conflict comes to a head. Digressions include: a failed segue from facial hair to feathers, dating revenge fantasies, looking for a rat king on dating apps, that girl power scene in Avengers: Endgame, Anna's cat confronts Clarisse, Gene Wilder as a turtle. Introducing new we...

Apr 14, 202144 minSeason 4Ep. 8

4.07 Test of Strength

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, Jimmy confronts Dell about being a terrible father. Digressions include: American Crime Story: Nirvana, Evan Peters playing Kurt Cobain, unethical tattooing, Introducing new weekly categories: Bomer Boner Moment, Paulson v Paulson, Big Feels for Big Drama, alongside the regular sections of Insensitive Historical R...

Apr 07, 202134 minSeason 4Ep. 7

4.06 Bullseye

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, Dandy gets dramatic, Paul falls in love and Elsa is a massive hypocrite. Digressions include: DragRace All Stars, prestige TV, TikTok AHS mashups Introducing new weekly categories: Bomer Boner Moment, Paulson v Paulson, Big Feels for Big Drama, alongside the regular sections of Insensitive Historical Reference of ...

Apr 01, 202142 minSeason 4Ep. 6

4.05 Pink Cupcakes

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, Dandy Mott does a monologue in his underwear while working out. Some other stuff happens. Digressions include: Dorian Gray, Jack the Ripper conspiracy theories, aliens, Ripperologists, Introducing new weekly categories: Bomer Boner Moment, Paulson v Paulson, Big Feels for Big Drama, alongside the regular sections ...

Mar 24, 202155 minSeason 4Ep. 5

4.04 Edward Mordrake Part II

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, the mysterious gentleman with a top hat, Edward Mordrake, continues on his interviews for the position of... being dead. Digressions include: Edward Mordrake as a boss, the Edward Mordrake Adventures spin-off, WTF with Edward Mordrake, 8mm and Hardcore. Introducing new weekly categories: Bomer Boner Moment, Paulso...

Mar 17, 202144 minSeason 4Ep. 4

4.03 Edward Mordrake Part I

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, we meet the mysterious gentleman with a top hat, a smoke machine and a sympathetic nod: Edward Mordrake and his demon face, Jared. Digressions include: naming Edward Mordrake's demon head, emo nostalgia, shrines to celebrities, the TikToks that make us question everything, the Matt Bomer Scale of Male Beauty and w...

Mar 17, 202144 minSeason 4Ep. 3

4.02 Massacres and Matinees

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In this episode, Dandy's intensity is bumming out Twisty's murder vibes. Digressions include: Scream Queens , Dandy and Twisty Murder Pals spin-off show, and ruining The Little Mermaid forever. Introducing new weekly categories: Bomer Boner Moment, Paulson v Paulson, Big Feels for Big Drama, alongside We discuss the episode in det...

Mar 03, 202136 minSeason 4Ep. 2

4.01 Monsters Among Us

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. For the start of a new season, we give you super-sized episode for a super-sized season premiere for American Horror Story: Freak Show where we are introduced to the main characters and antagonists of Fraülein Elsa Mars's Cabinet of Curiosities. Digressions include: an apology to Finn Wittrock, demonic Furbys, Baltimore accents, r...

Feb 24, 20211 hr 13 minSeason 4Ep. 1

Coven Awards

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. To round off the end of the rewatch of American Horror Story: Coven, Clarisse and Anna give out the hyper-specific, ultra-ridiculous Golden Melon Baller Coven Awards, brought to you by BALENCIAGAAAA. Featuring such suitably trashy categories as the Golden Melon Award for Most Bitchy Line, the Golden Melon Award for the Best Good B...

Feb 17, 202139 minSeason 3Ep. 14

3.13 The Seven Wonders

Film critic Clarisse Loughrey and film programmer Anna Bogutskaya, American Horror Story super-fans, discuss and dissect every episode of AHS, from the very beginning. In the finale of the season, the Seven Wonders are performed, the Next Supreme is revealed and not a lot of characters are left alive. Digressions include: Cardi B's new video, tiny-tiny hands, our magical powers, Clarisse's family curse Introducing new weekly categories: Best Quote, Best Song, Best Witch Pun, Best Fit, MVP of the...

Feb 10, 202145 minSeason 3Ep. 13
Hosted on Transistor
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android