The Development Dilemma - podcast cover

The Development Dilemma

Arnavafripods.com
Lets talk about the elephant in the room: the world of international development is run by two actors, expats and nationals, who don't seem to talk. They work in the same organisations with similar goals but expats fly in and out carrying a sense of superiority and nationals become disgruntled and disillusioned with their work. Where development is ultimately about people, this lack of strong relationships and local knowledge means that much aid leads to little impact. But we can do better, so let start to talk! Follow on Twitter: @dev_dilemma and Instagram: thedevelopmentdilemma This podcast brings together interesting voices to have honest and empathetic conversations on development dilemmas like hiring and pay practices; beneficiary voice; race dynamics; the history and role of aid and the impact of it all. Subscribe to hear concrete real life examples of what's going wrong but also the potential for more collaborative, democratic and, ultimately, impactful work. Welcome to The Development Dilemma podcast!
Last refreshed:
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

From Buzzwords to Blueprints: Building a More Equitable and Transparent Funding System

Frustrated by empty calls for change in the INGO sector? This episode dives deep into the practical steps needed to make a difference! I speak with Christine Sow, CEO at Humentum , about: 1. Turning pay & funding equity into reality: We go beyond lofty goals and explore concrete solutions for tackling systemic inequalities. 2) Localization vs. locally-led development: Unraveling the nuances and uncovering what true community ownership means. 3) Boosting transparency & accountability: Unm...

Feb 28, 202444 min

Breaking the Silence on NGOs

Mary Njeri, Minoo Kyaa and Wanjira Wanjiru are three brave, powerful and caring women that are part of the Organic Intellectuals Network, a group composed of members who live in informal settlements like Mathare and work towards the betterment of their community. They present their chapters from the book, Breaking the Silence on NGOs in Africa by the Organic Intellectuals Network, which can be found here: https://darajapress.com/2023/03/14/breaking-the-silence-on-ngos-in-africa We talk about how...

Oct 25, 202346 min

Where is the Dignity in Aid?

Live from Nairobi, I was joined by three great panelists, Caroline Teti from GiveDirectly, Tom Wein from IDinsight and Kanyi Wyban from Mathare Green Movement to tackle three questions: what is dignity? why should people care about dignity in aid? what does it mean to implement aid with more dignified? You can subscribe to our newsletter through this link: http://eepurl.com/hMbM3T Instagram: thedevelopmentdilemma; Twitter: @dev_dilemma; Music credits: Juliani, 'Kama sa Sisi'...

Sep 20, 202349 min

Going from Knowledge to Leadership

In Part 2 of my conversation with Professor Funmi Olonisakin we explore how the global security interests perpetuate colonial approaches in Africa, and Funmi also up about her experiences as a black woman in UK academia and the power of the decolonising and black lives movements. You can subscribe to our newsletter through this link: http://eepurl.com/hMbM3T Instagram: thedevelopmentdilemma; Twitter: @dev_dilemma; Music credits: Juliani, 'Kama sa Sisi'...

Jul 05, 202336 min

Building African power for Africans

This episode is a conversation about power, how it is created, enforced and could be disrupted by young African leaders. I was honoured to host Professor Funmi Olonisakin, an activist at heart from her days of student protest in Nigeria, a Professor of Security, Leadership and Development at King's College London and a founding Director of the African Leadership Centre (ALC). http://funmiolonisakin.com/ We delve into why Funmi believes young African leaders need to study and understand circles o...

Jun 11, 202341 min

Let's unpack White Saviourism

We hear the term 'White Saviourism' and think it only applies to the egregious examples we see on Social Media but it applies much broader to include brown saviours, many development institutions, certain forms of Western knowledge and perhaps even you! Themrise Khan, Dickson Kanakulya and Maïka Sondarjee have put together a great book to address this, White Saviorism in International Development: Theories, Practices and Lived Experiences . If you enjoy this episode, you can get your copy here: ...

Apr 25, 202343 min

Trust, Pay and Openness: Promoting Local leadership in a Global Organisation with Ruth Levine

It is a real honour to bring to you my discussion with Ruth Levine, the CEO of IDinsight - a research and advisory organization that works with global development leaders to improve their social impact. As an organisation with 6 offices spread across 5 regions in Africa and Asia, I think Ruth is keenly aware of the complexities of cultural differences and sensitivities and how they impact meaningful collaboration. So in this episode we tackle the challenges she and IDinsight faced to hiring tale...

Nov 17, 202245 min

Making hard tradeoffs in the face of inequities

This is Part Two of my discussion with Shiro and Phuthi, two African students at the University of Stanford. If you haven't listened to Part 1, I would recommend giving it a listen first. Here we explore Shiro and Phuthi's internal struggles at work balancing competing priorities of justice for fellow Africans with pursuit of personal goals; what more expats and those workplaces should do to address this trade-off and finish with a discussion about the inequities in fundraising and the need for ...

Sep 27, 202234 min

The View from the Top ain't that great! Experiences and challenges from Stanford

Shiro Wachira and Phuthi Tsatsi are two brilliant African graduate students at the University of Stanford, with plenty of experience in development organisations in Kenya and South Africa. But after time with both, they are quite disillusioned. Why have they found Stanford at times disappointing and a hard place to be? Why do they no longer want to work in development organisations? In this Part 1 of 2, we tackle this and more! Instagram: thedevelopmentdilemma; Twitter: @dev_dilemma; Music credi...

Jul 11, 202228 min

The Kenyan Techpreneur and Ecosystem, who does it benefit?

The Kenyan technology ecosystem is growing rapidly, countless new startups emerge and multinationals keep pouring in. What is the history of this space? Where did it come from and who benefits from the system today? In other words, who is overlooked and what needs to change? Angela Okune & Leo Mutuku bring their experiences as tech entrepreneurs, researchers as well as founding members of the Ihub to a paper they recently wrote entitled: Becoming an African Techpreneur: geopolitics of invest...

Jun 07, 202243 min

Whats going wrong with Kenyan-Expat relationships: social, romantic and more

What are the challenges in Kenyan-Expat friendships? What are the inequities in the Kenyan-Expat romantic relationships? What do we need to be more aware of? This episode with Alexandria Njenga and Conor Walsh comes from a live panel event held on March 10th in Nairobi. It was a fun event where Alex & Conor brough nuance to this sensitive topic and their critiques. Enjoy this episode and if you know a friend who is in such a relationship or someone that really needs to hear this advice, shar...

Apr 28, 202240 min

Inhabiting Injustice with Jim Chuchu

This podcast with Jim Chuchu comes from the panel event held in Nairobi on the topic 'Let's talk about Inhabiting Injustice'. This was a powerful, hard and uncomfortable conversation - the kind I hoped for when starting this podcast. It is thought-provoking and worth discussing with others - come to my next panel event on March 10th to do so. Many thanks to Jim for tackling this with me! Check out the show notes here: https://tinyurl.com/jimchuchu Find more of Jim's work here: https://www.jimchu...

Feb 24, 20221 hr 19 min

The Good, the Bad and the Ugly of Grant Funding

This episode features Dr. Wangui Kimari. Wangui wears many hats and I know her best for her role as a key part of establishing and supporting the Mathare Social Justice Centre (referred to as MSJC) in Nairobi. MSJC began in 2014 by young members of the community to promote social justic in an area of Nairobi where residents face many daily forms of violence from forced evictions, police abuse to extrajudicial killings. They are involved in a number of initiatives, most notably documenting extraj...

Jan 18, 202243 min

Who should we listen to?

This episode comes from the first live event for this podcast on the 3rd of October (as a result the sound quality varies). This was a great panel discussion event with Lorraine (from episode 1) and Sarika (episode 4) where we discussed some of the reasons it is so hard to have this discussion in the first place. It was lively and was followed by even more engagement in the following unrecorded break-out rooms. Based on this energy, I will be hosting the next event in Nairobi on the 6th November...

Oct 26, 202144 min

Everyone has a role to play in the revolution

The aid system needs a revolution but criticising it requires nuance. In this episode, I speak with Arbie Baguios. As the founder of the initiative Aid Re-imagined and as a vocal critique of the aid industry on social media, he is a leading voice in the decolonisation movement. At the same time, Arbie walks the line between critiquing the ills of international actors and also pushing for constructive change with them. Building on the last episode, we can pick up on the focus on aid structures, n...

Aug 19, 202149 min

How to get everyone rowing the boat in the same direction?

In this episode, I wanted to bring in a perspective from the private sector because the challenge of running multi-cultural teams of foreigners and nationals is not limited to the development sector. I speak with Shakeel Hassanali who is the Managing Director of JW Seagon - an international insurance broker with offices in Kenya. We explore the mistrust and bias he faced when he arrived and how collectively, they managed to build a shared organisational culture and put in structures which recogn...

Jul 26, 202144 min

How do we Bridge the Gap?

Why is there a Gap between Expats and Kenyans in the social and work space? What consequences does this have for our work and collaboration? What can we do to change this? In this episode, I explore these questions with Vandana Thottoli. Vandana is an Indian who has lived in Kenya for 7 years, forming close friendships with both Expats and Kenyans and in so doing straddling the gap between them. From an Indian background, she has some familiarity with Kenyan culture and systems and yet has found...

Jun 15, 202141 min

Why is African start-up funding reserved for Expats?

Only 6% of Kenyan start-ups in 2019 that received over 1m USD of funding were led by locals. It is clear the investing space is disproportionately skewed to expats whilst local entrepreneurs seem to be crowded out. In this discussion with Efayomi Carr, we explore in detail why the ecosystem of funders, investors and entrepreneurs leads to this and what needs to change. We discuss the bias towards trusted networks but also why Efayomi believes change is arising and why he would caution judging to...

Apr 28, 202145 min

What is wrong with our Language of Development?

Sarika Bansal is an editor and storyteller, I first came across her work in the BRIGHT Magazine which you hear referenced frequently on this podcast. As founder & editor-in-chief, they told fresh, solutions-oriented stories about social change which I learnt a lot from and would highly recommend to check it out. As I admired her work with BRIGHT Magazine and writings, it was a real honour to have her on the podcast. One particular area of interest has been on the language we use in the inter...

Mar 16, 202143 min

Don't come here to help, come here to work

In this episode, Marion shares her perspective of how expats like myself should come to Kenya, with a mentality of doing work rather than helping. With this, expats shouldn't feel any guilt to enjoy the beauties of Kenya but at the same time, they then should be held accountable for this. 'We tried' isn't good enough. We also delve into the different treatment of expats and Kenyans in the workplace, how she navigated this and the system it created of picking the easy route and hiring expat consu...

Feb 27, 202144 min

The Expat who left

Sarah came to Kenya in 2018 as an expat hoping to make a difference. After 6 months, she left disillusioned. In this episode, Sarah and I cover her journey to Kenya and her unique approach of coming to observe and learn first; her surprise at the expat bubbles she found herself in; the complexities of working for an expat-led NGO and the condescension that is implicit in the narrative of 'skill-transfer to Kenyans'; why she decided that in the end, her place for 'impact' was not in Kenya and the...

Jan 19, 202139 min

Starting the Conversation

In the inaugural episode, I speak with close friend of mine, Lorraine. It was from discussions over the past 2 years with Lorraine that this podcast came to fruition and it was a delight to start it with her. In this open & honest conversation, we touch upon two key questions: 1) What do Expats get wrong about Kenyans? and 2) What do Kenyans get wrong about Expats? Sharing from her experiences as a Kenyan working in International Development, we exchange stories of the dynamics between Kenya...

Jan 16, 202141 min

The Introduction

In this introduction to The Development Dilemma, I lay out who your host is (hint: me - Arnav Kapur); the origins of this show; who this is for (you!) and what to be excited about. Please listen, review, share and send me any feedback! I can be reached on: Twitter: @dev_dilemma; Instagram: thedevelopmentdilemma; Email: arnavskapur@gmail.com. Music credits to Juliani, 'Kama sa Sisi' Instagram: thedevelopmentdilemma; Twitter: @dev_dilemma; Music credits: Juliani, 'Kama sa Sisi'

Jan 01, 20216 min
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android