The Angel at the Starlite Motel - podcast cover

The Angel at the Starlite Motel

Adam Heath Avitablewww.patreon.com
In January 2020, sex worker Mandi May Jackson was sentenced to two consecutive life sentences for the murder of strip club manager James Mulrenin. One anonymous man thinks she's innocent and has written a book detailing his most intimate experiences with Mandi. He loves her, he despises her, and he is desperate to set her free.

Your host, Adam Heath Avitable, received a copy of this book and is sharing it with the world, chapter by chapter. Don't miss this sordid tale about the angel at the Starlite Motel.

Send all inquiries to angelmurderpodcast@gmail.com.
Last refreshed:
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

0311: Girls in Jail Tell Complicated Elaborate Stories

The author tells a story of two convicts, one current, one former, and the stories they told him, leading up to a discussion of jailhouse informants and their blatant lack of credibility. Check out some of the actual notes written by inmates snitching on other girls on our Patreon at http://www.patreon.com/angelmurder ! The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered around an anonymous man and his intimate encounters with ex-sex worker Mandi May Jackson, who was convicted of the 2016 murd...

Dec 05, 202255 min

0310: Representing Car Wax and Lawsuits

Starting section four of the book with a chapter dedicated to Casey Anthony's lawyer, Jose Baez, and the author's attempts to hire the notorious sleazeball (in our opinion), we start to learn more about why Mandi's jailhouse informants were less than credible. Don't forget to visit our Patreon at http://www.patreon.com/angelmurder to catch up on the hours of materials, free and otherwise, available to slake your thirst for knowledge! The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered around a...

Nov 07, 20221 hr 31 min

0309: The Ugliest Girl in Science Class Finally Got Her Revenge

Breaking News! You're not going to want to miss the second half of this episode, where Adam Avitable and Jessica Jackson share some current information on Mandi's appeal. The direction of the podcast for the future is discussed, and all of the skipped chapters are posted on Patreon at http://www.patreon.com/angelmurder for the missing chapters if you want to read them for free! The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered around an anonymous man and his intimate encounters with ex-sex w...

Oct 17, 20221 hr 6 min

0308: Mulrenin Overate Sin At His Own Buffet

Skipping six chapters to avoid redundancy and repetitive content, we start with chapter 16 and a discussion of the inconsistencies between the 911 call and initial reports vs Detective Sprague's insistence in pursuing a narrative where Mandi is a killer. Check out the Patreon at http://www.patreon.com/angelmurder for the missing chapters if you want to read them for free! The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered around an anonymous man and his intimate encounters with ex-sex worker ...

Oct 03, 20221 hr 27 min

0307: A Lot of Coffee or Something

This is a quick episode that covers two chapters all recapping the issues with the video evidence - we'll have to make some editorial decisions soon because some of the content is beginning to be redundant, so stay tuned! Also in this episode, an email from someone who knew Scott Love on the inside sheds some light on his relationship with Mandi! The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered around an anonymous man and his intimate encounters with ex-sex worker Mandi May Jackson, who was...

Sep 12, 202249 min

0306: Filled With Cute Lawyer Girls

The author drops a bombshell about the existence of video that wasn't used at Mandi's trial, showing how Scott Love entered the apartment building. Is there an entire hard drive of video that could exonerate Mandi? Listen to find out and check out the depositions of two of the officers today on Patreon! The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered around an anonymous man and his intimate encounters with ex-sex worker Mandi May Jackson, who was convicted of the 2016 murder of strip club ...

Aug 28, 20221 hr 14 min

0305: A Girl Is Born Naked With Everything She Needs

We skipped chapter four, which is simply the police report, and focused on chapter five of the book this week, detailing the video evidence provided by the police and all of the many flaws with this evidence. No timestamps? No video of Scott Love leaving the building? No real evidence of an actual robbery? Adam and Jessica talk about the faulty evidence, the author's anger towards this podcast, and the relationship between Jessica and her sister Mandi. Don't forget to see the evidence for yourse...

Aug 14, 20221 hr 26 min

0304: The Safest Day in a Lemon's Life

The author uses this chapter to explain his theories involving Mandi's travels the days before Mulrenin's death using cell tower data provided by T-Mobile, and extrapolates this data to include suppositions about drug running, Mandi's motivations towards her friends, and the nature of Dollhouse staff's knowledge of Mandi and her various strip club activities. Adam and Mandi's sister Jessica dig up some fatal flaws in his logic - listen and see if you agree! The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a p...

Jul 31, 20221 hr 45 min

0303: A Divining Stick For Failures And Scumbags

This episode, listen to the arrest affidavit filed by Detective Sprague identifying the evidence his investigation uncovered and his conclusion that Mandi May Jackson and Scott Love should be arrested. The author disagrees with many of his assertions, but do we agree with him? Listen and find out! The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered around an anonymous man and his intimate encounters with ex-sex worker Mandi May Jackson, who was convicted of the 2016 murder of strip club manage...

Jul 10, 20222 hr 1 min

0302: When The Aliens Land

A new section of the book continues, summarizing the evidence against Mandi, issues with juror misconduct, and Stephen's thoughts about the presumption of innocence in the American justice system. The commentary, an extra-long look with Mandi's sister Jessica at the accuracy of the reading, is a fascinating glance at what evidence Mandi truly faced during her trial. Check out James Mulrenin's toxicology report and more on Patreon today. The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered aroun...

Jun 26, 20221 hr 34 min

0301: Lesser of Two Evils

Welcome to Season Three! This season will take a new path for the podcast, as a SPECIAL NEW CO-HOST joins us for the duration of the show. Don't miss out on what she has to say about the last two seasons and the truth about Mandi going forward! Also this week, learn the true name of the author and hear some details about his interactions with Mandi's family that have never been shared before. Going forward, expect new episodes every two weeks and join our Patreon for extras! The Angel at the Sta...

Jun 12, 20221 hr 21 min

0212: The Victim of a Private Room Scam in His Own House

After a lengthy delay, the season 2 finale has arrived. David doesn't wrap up much but introduces more questions into what happened at Dollhouse the night before Mulrenin's murder. Quick note: The commentary was recorded in May 2021, when Adam was still in Orlando. There will be a season three, and more episodes on an ongoing basis, so stay tuned. The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered around an anonymous man and his intimate encounters with ex-sex worker Mandi May Jackson, who wa...

Feb 09, 20221 hr 15 min

0211: I Am Neely Dockpost

In the penultimate episode for season two, we find out about the seedy world of underage prostitution in Miami, as detailed by David and a young model he befriends. Plus, Shaquille O'Neal gets a random mention! The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered around an anonymous man and his intimate encounters with ex-sex worker Mandi May Jackson, who was convicted of the 2016 murder of strip club manager Jimmy Mulrenin in 2020, as detailed in the anonymous man's book which was shared with ...

Apr 08, 20211 hr 21 min

0210: Teenage Ecstasy Slut

In this double chapter episode, David explains his theory that every stripper has at least one random guy following her around at all times, ready to rescue her from anything. Does his theory hold water? Listen and find out! The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered around an anonymous man and his intimate encounters with ex-sex worker Mandi May Jackson, who was convicted of the 2016 murder of strip club manager Jimmy Mulrenin in 2020, as detailed in the anonymous man's book which wa...

Mar 25, 20211 hr 12 min

0209: Why Drug A CEO When You Can F*ck Him?

David discovers what he considers the motivation behind Mandi's reputation being trashed by the other Dollhouse dancers after Mulrenin's death. Was it the "Hustlers at Scores" article, or was it something more nefarious? Listen to this relatively brief chapter with more commentary thanks to new co-host Marcela! Want more info? Get behind-the-scenes info on our Patreon at Patreon.com/angelmurder! The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered around an anonymous man and his intimate encoun...

Mar 11, 202144 min

0208: Stop Them Twelve Inches Apart

In this episode, David dives into his history with sex workers to talk about the criminality of sex acts at strip clubs, in an attempt to understand why Mulrenin was so concerned about the law. Want more info? Get behind-the-scenes info on our Patreon at Patreon.com/angelmurder! The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered around an anonymous man and his intimate encounters with ex-sex worker Mandi May Jackson, who was convicted of the 2016 murder of strip club manager Jimmy Mulrenin in...

Feb 25, 20211 hr 5 min

0207: The New Concept of Sexual Harassment

David meets James Mulrenin, the murder victim in our case, in a long and sometimes rambling chapter about his various encounters with the "angry, well-dressed doorman." Butting heads with management, being stalked, and getting strippers and bartenders fired left and right, David may have finally met his match. Want more? Get behind-the-scenes info on our Patreon at Patreon.com/angelmurder! To those of you who have been waiting since November for a new episode, I apologize for the delay, but we'r...

Feb 11, 20212 hr 2 min

0206: That Shampoo Hair Smell

The origin story of David the author keeps going! We get to hear more about his early pre-Mandi life as he starts to learn about the strip clubs in Orlando and has some good, bad and arguably neutral experiences in various clubs throughout Orlando. David's life is arguably as interesting as Mandi's, even if it has little to do with the murder of James Mulrenin. Want more? Get behind-the-scenes info on our Patreon at Patreon.com/angelmurder! The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered a...

Nov 19, 202048 min

0205: A Tense Date At Sushi Samba

Arguably our favorite chapter this season, David gives his origin story. Where did the obsession with strippers and strip clubs come from? Why the distaste for sex workers? Was Mandi May Jackson the first girl he ever had sex with? Was she the prettiest, according to him? A lot of groundwork is laid for us to understand the mentality and sometimes odd perspective of our anonymous author. The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered around an anonymous man and his intimate encounters wit...

Nov 05, 202050 min

0204: The Human Ken Doll

This chapter seems to lay the groundwork for explaining why everyone is so quick to assume that Mandi May Jackson killed James Mulrenin. In a not-so-clear flashback, David recounts a conversation he has with an employee of Thee Dollhouse about Mulrenin's death and how it was treated by the police who visited the club. Was Mulrenin a predator who forced dancers to go home with him? Or was Mandi a willing visitor to his place that fateful night? We'll begin to find out as the book continues. And d...

Oct 22, 202051 min

0203: Run On a Brain-Damaged Young Girl

David wants you to understand why Mandi didn't see anything wrong with spending money with the deceased Mulrenin's credit cards, and lays out his theories and analysis in great detail in this week's episode. Was Mulrenin a scam artist who trained Mandi too well? Or does she understand the difference between plastic and cash? Listen and decide! And if you want more details and behind-the-scenes information never before seen, as well as access to episodes before they're available to the general pu...

Oct 08, 202057 min

0202: She Was The Fresh Strawberry

In the second episode of season 2, our author starts to piece together why Mandi was arrested, and begins his investigation into the background of murder victim James Mulrenin. Is his theory about Mandi and Mulrenin correct? Is Google a common denominator? Listen and find out! And if you want more details and behind-the-scenes information never before seen, become a patron at Patreon.com/angelmurder today! The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered around an anonymous man and his inti...

Sep 24, 202047 min

0201: Uniquely Benighted White Trash Lowlifes

Welcome to the first episode of Season Two of the Angel at the Starlite Motel, which covers the first two chapters of Part 2 of David's book. This part of the book will delve into the circumstances leading up to the murder of Jimmy Mulrenin, and promises to get darker with each episode. Want more after each episode? Become a patron at Patreon.com/angelmurder today! The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered around an anonymous man and his intimate encounters with ex-sex worker Mandi M...

Sep 09, 202050 min

0114 Season One Finale: A Knock At My Door

"Fuck, look at me, David. I'm still fucking Mandi's life up five years after she made it clear she doesn't like me. Five years, 200 guys, 100 pounds, and two life sentences." We've reached the Season One finale of the Angel at the Starlite Motel. Season Two will begin in late August/early September, so stay tuned! In the meantime, you can get behind-the-scenes content and bonus episodes by joining the AATSM Patreon at Patreon.com/angelmurder! In this season finale, the author continues to wrestl...

Jul 30, 202038 min

0113: Drunk Middle-Aged Psycho

"I sent her a message that I didn't believe her photos and captions were sincere. The look on her face was role-playing, acting. I had seen the same look in the picture she showed me with her pimp." The penultimate episode of Season One finds the author losing touch with Mandi after the restraining order. She goes incognito online, and he's desperately trying to hold onto whatever control he can. His world is crumbling, and his sanity doesn't stand a chance. The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a ...

Jul 23, 202057 min

0112: The Shattered Pieces Of Her Hope Chest

"It just made me so angry. It's like they were gangbanging her over there, and they wouldn't even let her bring a stuffed animal in the house! And she preferred that over me!" As we near the end of Season One of the Angel at the Starlite Motel, Mandi's new relationship begins to chip at the author's sanity. His plans fail and he has no choice but to make desperate moves to regain some semblance of control over Mandi's life. Cracks begin to appear, and the whole thing starts to fall apart. The An...

Jul 16, 202051 min

0111: The Way Sex Was Meant To Be

"She told me that it is not the real thing unless it burns when you put it on your tongue. So I let her put it on her tongue, and it burned. She was ecstatic. . . " This week we learn a lot about the drug butanediol, although Adam still doesn't quite understand the appeal. Mandi talks about a new sex position, our author David uses her favorite drug as a solvent, and Mandi pukes. Twice. Plus, is this the end to sex between the author and Mandi? We'll see! The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a pod...

Jul 09, 202040 min

0110: Poodle Boy

"When I realized she was about to leave, I couldn't resist. 'How much to fuck you?' She said $500. I said, I don't have it how about $400? She said okay. On that day I got to have sex with the cutest prettiest sexiest hottest most beautiful girl ever born." In this episode, our author gets a name! Plus, we have jealousy, parental interference, stalking, streaming, and you'll never look at your Nana the same again. As you'll hear, we had a recording issue about halfway through the commentary, and...

Jul 02, 20201 hr 9 min

0109: My Little Drug Kingpin

"Every old guy wanted to have sex with her. Most guys didn't want her to have sex with other guys. Nobody else wanted her to have sex with old guys. And everybody wanted everything kept secret. So she told her high-school friends she was selling drugs, which was a socially acceptable explanation of where her money came from." Last week we found out that Mandi got arrested in Georgia. In this episode, we learn what happened, as well as a valuable lesson that you are the company you keep. After th...

Jun 25, 20201 hr 3 min

0108: Showing Up in Short Shorts

"I said, 'Our relationship is weird.' Mandi had a fit, and just about burst into tears. She said, 'It's not weird. I'm your ho.'" Mandi has a secret, and someone is jealous. From strip clubs to servings of cocaine, Mandi's latest adventure causes some havoc with the author. And what a cliffhanger! Your host and narrator Adam Heath Avitable once again breaks down what he just read with some post-reading commentary with Lisa Crawford. The Angel at the Starlite Motel is a podcast centered around an...

Jun 18, 202051 min
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android