Talking Talmud - podcast cover

Talking Talmud

Yardaena Osband & Anne Gordon
Learning the daf? We have something for you to think about. Not learning the daf? We have something for you to think about! (Along with a taste of the daf...) Join the conversation with us!
Last refreshed:
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

Megillah 16: The Many Layers of Narrative in the Megillah

More on the personalities of the Megillah. Starting with Haman and Mordechai and an extensive expansion on how Haman must do the king's will and honor Mordechai. Also, connecting the story of Yosef and Binyamin to that of Esther, beginning with the clothing.

Dec 28, 202130 minSeason 11Ep. 16

Megillah 15: Strengths of Mordechai and Esther

On the last of the prophets, and the way the Gemara affiliates Mordechai with Malakhi. Which leads to an investigation of the big names of the day and their chronologies, specifically during this era of Shivat Zion. Again, with the conservation of biblical personalities. Also, the 4 exceptionally beautiful (apparently) women. What really links these 4? Plus, when Esther braves an audience with Ahashverosh, and she's supported by angels, and he then extends his scepter to her, in parallel to the ...

Dec 27, 202138 minSeason 11Ep. 15

Megillah 14: The 7 Prophetesses

The list of the 7 prophetesses, and the sources that prove them to be such: Sarah, Miriam, Devorah, Avigayil, Chana, Huldah, Esther. With lots of little tidbits about what it means to be a prophet, and nuggets if information about the women. Including one amora's apparent ambivalence with at least a couple of these prophetesses.

Dec 26, 202125 minSeason 11Ep. 14

Megillah 13: What Was Esther's Real Name, Anyway?

On Mordechai... and his generation. On Esther... and why she is called both Esther and Hadassah. And what was her relationship with Mordechai? Also, the modesty of Rachel and her generosity with regard to her sister Leah, and the inheritance of that same trait. Plus, the justification of Yaakov's trickery before Lavan. And how that led to the modesty of Esther.

Dec 25, 202120 minSeason 11Ep. 13

Megillah 12: Inserting God into Vashti's Removal

More explication of Megillat Esther, from the description of the king's feast, his guests from Persia and Medea (or the reverse, as the case may be). Plus, the decree against the Jews. Also, extensive discussion on the Vashti story, and why Ahashverosh was so angry with her. Plus, the sources for all the midrashim about how the beautiful Vashti became ugly.

Dec 24, 202122 minSeason 11Ep. 12

Megillah 11: Wicked by Association

Explicating the name "Ahashverosh," and connecting its owner to Nebuchadnezzar. Plus, the 127 provinces of his realm. Also, how do we calculate the 70 years of the Babylonian Exile? When is the starting point, and when did it end? Chronologies and kings' genealogies work it out.

Dec 23, 202127 minSeason 11Ep. 11

Megillah 10: Transportable Religion

More distinctions between "this" and "that," in this case, Shiloh vs. Jerusalem. Plus, exegesis of the Megillah text, beginning with, "It was in the days of Ahashverosh," and how much meaning can be ascribed to the wording of "vayehi."

Dec 22, 202122 minSeason 11Ep. 10

Megillah 9: Translation by the 70

On the Torah scrolls themselves - beginning with the scribal arts, and what it takes to make sure that writing is a holy book. Plus, the Targum. Also, the Gemara's presentation of the story of how the Torah was translated into Greek. Plus, 2 more mishnayot of "ein bein" distinctions.

Dec 21, 202122 minSeason 11Ep. 9

Megillah 8: The "Only" Distinction(s)

5 mishnayot, comparing and contrasting and delineating... For a variety of unexpected topics, including oaths, bodily fluids, and scribal requirements for a Sefer Torah and more.

Dec 20, 202114 minSeason 11Ep. 8

Megillah 7: The Year Rabbi Zeira Woke Up Dead after Purim

Establishing Purim as a holiday for the generations, and Esther as a book to be read. Plus, including the Book of Esther in the canon of Tanakh. Also, how to give matanot la-evyonim and mishloach manot. And some narrative to flesh out the expected generosity in the above. Also, the story of Rabbah and Rabbi Zeira's excess on Purim that lead to a miracle and a refusal to rely on a miracle thereafter (perhaps getting drunk on Purim isn't such a good plan - or obligation). Also, a couple of mishnay...

Dec 19, 202124 minSeason 11Ep. 7

Megillah 6: Adar I vs. Adar II

Aligning Tiberias and Tzipori (and Ginosar) with other places named in the Bible (of course, debatable). One of the ways of proving the case was from eulogies for those who had enough renown to be mourned in both Israel and Babylonia. Plus, a note that Edom was used as a stand-in for Rome, and antipathy to Edom reflected Chazal's antipathy to Rome. Also, differences between Adar I and Adar II. And the special parshiot that are read a few weeks before Purim and thereafter. (What if you goof in th...

Dec 18, 202122 minSeason 11Ep. 6

Megillah 5: Rabbi Yehudah HaNasi: Mishnah Compiler and... Gardener

A new mishnah! What is considered a "large city"? [Including What's What on the "10 batlanim"] And how these days of gathering carry implications as joyous days (with regard to fasting and eulogies). Plus, several statements in the name of R. Abba (and R. Shmuel), on how we keep track of time. Also, the actions of R. Yehudah HaNasi... On Purim specifically, and the many actions that bring joy... and when we fast, and more. Why was planting on Purim acceptable?

Dec 17, 202124 minSeason 11Ep. 5

Megillah 4: Rabbinic Megillah Reading (by definition)

The Gemara notes: The women were part of the miracle of Purim, and are therefore obligated in reading the megillah. Also, speaking about the specific day on the given day. Plus, a question on intergenerational Gemara conversation. And reading the megillah at night and in the day. Also, questioning the mishnah's moving of the day megillah would be read. Plus, why we don't read megillah on Shabbat, ever.

Dec 16, 202115 minSeason 11Ep. 4

Megillah 3: Translation Is Interpretation

Translations of the Torah into Aramaic, the vernacular of the time - the authoritative versions were ascribed to Onkelos (on Torah) and Yonatan ben Uziel (on Prophets). [Who's Who - for both of them] Also, the place of reading the megillah in comparison to other mitzvot, from learning Torah to caring for a "meit mitzvah" to welcoming a bride. Plus, the factor of publicizing a miracle.

Dec 15, 202127 minSeason 11Ep. 3

Megillah 2: So Many Days of Reading the Megillah

Introducing... Megillah. What are the dates when Megillat Esther may be read - beyond the 14th (Purim) and 15th (Shushan Purim). Which brings us the categories of the cities, towns, walled cities, and villages. Plus, the linguistic analysis that allows for all those possible dates.

Dec 14, 202123 minSeason 11Ep. 2

Taanit 31: Dancing for Salvation

Closing the tractate with the joy of the 15th of Av, including the burial of Beitar, and the girls dancing in the vineyard, with the young men who seek them out - a little less selfless and judgemental than we might have thought. Plus, the dancing of the righteous, and the salvation wrought by God, for them.

Dec 13, 202118 minSeason 10Ep. 31

Taaanit 30: The Mourning of Tisha B'Av

The mourning practices of Tisha B'Av, a clear prescription for the experience of the day. Including not learning Torah. Plus, customs for Erev Tisha B'Av. And the impact of the mourning practices. Also, shifting to happy days - the 15th of Av and Yom Kippur, including why these days are considered joyous - some reasons as the essence of the given day, and the historical events affiliated with the day.

Dec 12, 202123 minSeason 10Ep. 30

Taanit 29: Grim History

The various historical events that took place, as accepted by tradition, on the 9th of Av, including some wrenching stories, including on the topic of intentional martyrdom.

Dec 11, 202124 minSeason 10Ep. 29

Taanit 28: Liturgical Growth

Rosh Chodesh Tevet had no ma'amad service. Why would this day be exempt? What was to be expected on Rosh Chodesh? Plus, Hanukkah. How is it different from Nisan? Where does Hallel fit in? Plus, what happened on the 17th of Tammuz

Dec 10, 202117 minSeason 10Ep. 28

Taanit 27: Sourcing the Ma'amadot

Ma'amadot - and their Torah source. The cycle of groups coming from Jerusalem, Jericho, and locations throughout the Land of Israel. Plus, what is essential for the korban to happen? As connected to the songs that were sung in the Temple every day. Also, the connection between Creation and the ma'amadot, and the interaction between Avraham and God, at the brit bein ha-betarim. Also, reading korbanot as part of davening in the morning. And who gets prayed for when. Among other tidbits.

Dec 09, 202119 minSeason 10Ep. 27

Taanit 26: No Drunk Duchening (aka Birkat Kohanim)

The fourth and final chapter - including the historical fasts. Another very long mishnah, beginning with Birkat Kohanim, the mishmarot, ma'amadot, and more. With a Gemara dive into the Birkat Kohanim (which is at the beginning at the mishnah, but also shifts focus to Yom Kippur, which is also at the end of the mishnah).

Dec 08, 202131 minSeason 10Ep. 26

Taanit 25: Fasting, Praying, and Provoking God

R. Hanina Ben Dosa, pious miracle worker, appears here again. Plus, back to rain... When a rabbinic leader decrees a fast, and the outcomes are different. What accounts for that, and what kind of pleading with - or rebuke to - God brings the rain? Also, depictions of the heavens and the clouds as choosing what to do, where to go. Plus, the comparison of righteous people to a date palm and a cedar tree, and why both metaphors are necessary. [Who's Who: Shmuel HaKatan] Also, regarding his decrees,...

Dec 07, 202119 minSeason 10Ep. 25

Taanit 24: Who Wants a Miracle?

The charity collectors would hide from Elazar of Birta, because he would divest himself of everything, and they didn't want to let him go that far. Even when he was looking to buy a dowry for his daughter, and he only brings home some wheat - which multiplies exponentially. But he won't accept the goodness of that miracle either. Also, more miracles... which seems lesser, as compared to the natural progression of things. Which means we pray for nature to go our way, without supernatural interven...

Dec 06, 202119 minSeason 10Ep. 24

Taanit 23: Much More Than a Jewish Rip Van Winkle

More of Choni (or Honi) the Circle-Maker's story, including the rest of his life, and the inheritance (or presumed inheritance) as told with regard to his grandchildren. Which includes discussion of his righteousness, his scholarship, and his miracles, of course. A much more poignant sad story than we usually think of this figure. Which complicates matters for his grandchildren, as presumed heirs to the affinity for rain.

Dec 05, 202133 minSeason 10Ep. 23

Taanit 22: Are We in Danger Yet?

More narrative. Rabbi Beroka and Elijah the prophet - when they met, first in the marketplace... Plus, the significance of black shoes as non-Jewish attire. And the accomplishment of those who cheer people up, with comedy. Also, what events call for crying out? Including for Shabbat? Of course, it's a machloket how quickly the situation is considered dangerous.

Dec 04, 202121 minSeason 10Ep. 22

Taanit 21: All for the Best

The potential positive impact of the righteous. Beginning with Nachum Ish Gamzu, who was blind, and a 4-limb amputee, with boils, in a bed with its feet in water to keep away the ants, in a dilapidated building, no less. He knows the building won't fall on him. But when they take him out, it indeed falls on everything inside. But why did he suffer like this? The Gemara says he said - he brought it on himself with an act lacking in compassion that he couldn't fix. Note also that Nachum Ish Gamzu ...

Dec 03, 202117 minSeason 10Ep. 21

Taanit 20: The Strength of the Reed

A daf of stories... Nakdimon, and trading in water, when no rain had fallen. In comparison and contrast to Choni ha-Me'agael. Also, a presentation of curses, which are then turned into blessing - Achiyah HaShiloni, in contrast to Balaam. His words - those of the Jewish prophet - are more welcome than those coming from the non-Jew. Plus, another "ugly rabbi" story - and the value of flexibility. Also, what it means when R. Huna appeared to rely on a miracle...

Dec 02, 202128 minSeason 10Ep. 20

Taanit 19: Beyond Rain

A new chapter, with a new marathon mishnah: The long process of increased severity of fasting and going public with it, etc., only applies to troubles from a lack of rain. But when it comes to plague, for example, God forbid, the most extreme crying out is put into play right away. Plus, the environs around a city that is going through this process join in. Also, the story of Choni the Circle-Maker. With some if the Gemara's discussion on this long mishnah, including some of the theology, what w...

Dec 01, 202127 minSeason 10Ep. 19

Taanit 18: Bad for the Jews

A potential conflict between the days when one can read Megilat Esther and days that are dedicated to Nikanor and to Trajan. What are these days (Yom Nikanor and Yom Turianos), and whatever happened to them?

Nov 30, 202115 minSeason 10Ep. 18

Taanit 17: The King's Daily Haircut

More working off the long mishnah - beginning with discussion of the watches of the kohanim, and when they would need to cut their hair and launder their clothes - to make sure they're presentable while on the watch. Among other populations, and how frequently they cut their hair to make sure they don't get scruffy in appearance. Based on nazir. Also, days when eulogizing is not permitted, as connected to the daily offering (even in its absence), and the dynamic with the Sadducees. The month of ...

Nov 29, 202116 minSeason 10Ep. 17
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android