Talking Talmud - podcast cover

Talking Talmud

Yardaena Osband & Anne Gordon
Learning the daf? We have something for you to think about. Not learning the daf? We have something for you to think about! (Along with a taste of the daf...) Join the conversation with us!
Last refreshed:
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

Shabbat 32: Scare Tactics

Three sins for which women die in childbirth - from "women's mitzvot," such as they are. Why these are so severe, and the cautionary mishnah. Also: Rabbi Yannai and not relying on miracles. Plus: Theodicy (again). And: Cause and effect between sins and negative outcomes for society.

Apr 07, 202020 minSeason 2Ep. 32

Shabbat 31: "Go and learn!"

Hillel and Shammai themselves, the famous stories. The dare to anger Hillel, who takes every question seriously, patiently. "Convert me while I stand on one foot." The ways Hillel and Shammai were so different, and yet also the same. Also: The value of Yirat Hashem.

Apr 06, 202024 minSeason 2Ep. 31

Shabbat 30: When King David Tried to Cheat the Angel of Death

Extinguishing a flame to prevent the flame from being seen vs doing so to save the candle... For example, saving a life... Or improving the sick person's situation. Also: King David's death and what God doesn't tell man, and how nobody outsmarts the Angel of Death, not really. Plus: The effort to keep Kohelet (Ecclesiastes) out of the canon of the Bible, and why it didn't work.

Apr 05, 202027 minSeason 2Ep. 30

Shabbat 29: MacGyvering Shabbat Candles

Repurposing a garment to be wicks - yea or nay? Plus: The prohibition of getting up an oil dispenser for candle from an egg shell (never mind the challenge in securing eggs in Israel right now), and it would be permitted. Also: The need for context in understanding halakhah and how psak works (including what happens on social media).

Apr 04, 202022 minSeason 2Ep. 29

Shabbat 28: It's a Unicorn!

Still talking about ritual impurity... Including non-kosher animals. Holy endeavors must use a kosher animal, and the Gemara explains where this rational doesn't apply to tefillin, which are defined by Halakhah le-Moshe mi-Sinai - and no argument. Plus: The "tachash" - an unknown animal (kosher? unkosher?) used in making this Mishkan.

Apr 03, 202022 minSeason 2Ep. 28

Shabbat 27: Strange and Stranger Mitzvot, and What We Learn from Them

The impurity of Tzara'at and the impurity of the creepy-crawlies -- can one be inferred from the other? Different ways one happens upon tumah - vs. the tumah and experience of Tzara'at. Also: Tzitzit. With Sha'atnez. Literally. Plus: Learning from verses in proximity to each other. And: Some musing on the surreality of the discussions of these mitzvot (and Yardaena's story of sha'atnez). Also: why the blind are obligated in Tzitzit.

Apr 02, 202023 minSeason 2Ep. 27

Shabbat 26: Don't Let Your Daughter-in-Law Catch on Fire

The audio is a little wonky today - with gaps and overlaps - we don't know why (why tried to fix it) - we are sorry about that....... Back to the oils for Shabbat candle use (or not-use, as the case may be). And: a very strange drama that illustrates the volatility (flammability) of balsam oil and some family dynamics... What if you don't have olive oil? Because plenty of locales did not.

Apr 01, 202017 minSeason 2Ep. 26

Shabbat 25: Who Is Rich? Those Who Have Indoor Plumbing

Some basic terms of what invalidates kodshim - the sanctified offerings - including immediate mourners who cannot partake. Also: welcoming Shabbat with nice candles, with washing in hot water. Preparing for Shabbat, with a focus on what matters. The complications of the current era and our changes under the coronavirus. Who's Who: R. Yehuda bar Ilai.

Mar 31, 202024 minSeason 2Ep. 25

Shabbat 23: Like It or Not, People Gossip

Blessing the "commandment" of Chanukah. Lighting at every entrance to prevent suspicions. Pe'ah - leaving gleanings the right way. Also: human nature. And concern for community norms and well-being. Plus triage for when you can't afford everything, and don't want to diminish the value of any mitzvah.

Mar 29, 202023 minSeason 2Ep. 23

Shabbat 22: Repurposing Chanukah Candles? Nope

How do we treat ritual objects? Disgracing a mitzvah. Are the tools and byproducts of a mitzvah inherently holy? 3 debates between Rav and Shmuel, including R. Shimon's opinion on the physical outcome of melakhah.

Mar 28, 202015 minSeason 2Ep. 22

Shabbat 21: There's No Masekhet Chanukah

Bad oil, bad wicks. Also: Chanukah! Embarking on everything you wanted to know about the holiday and its halakhot, at least from the texts of the Sages.

Mar 27, 202023 minSeason 2Ep. 21

Shabbat 20: Does My Toast Have Crunch?

What does it mean for something to be cooked? How much must be cooked before Shabbat starts? The measurement of Ben Dorsai. Welcoming Shabbat - to exclude a whole host of possible candle materials (ch. 2). Plus a discussion of vocabulary.

Mar 26, 202022 minSeason 2Ep. 20

Shabbat 19: Your Dog Can Break Shabbos

All kinds of things come together: Jew/non-Jew interaction, Pesach, selling chametz... Kutach. Shabbat responsibility (when those who are not obligated in Shabbat do what would be violating Shabbat for Jews). Plus: Passive Shabbat "violation." And: When the talmudic text is absent and that changes psak. Also: Muktzah, and the limits of local authority (or: how halakhah is supposed to function).

Mar 25, 202025 minSeason 2Ep. 19

Shabbat 18: "Set It and Forget It" - A Daf of Modern Shabbat Issues

A new mishnah, a new machloket between Beit Hillel and Beit Shammai: beginning a process before shabbat that continues into shabbat, with no new involvement on your part. Namely letting your tools and vessels rest on shabbat. Plus: the concept of a "shabbos clock" (timer). And the concept of mar'it ayin (the appearance gives the wrong impression). Also, the beginning of the conversation of Jew/non-Jew interactions when it comes to shabbat.

Mar 24, 202023 minSeason 2Ep. 18

Shabbat 17: The Sword in the Study Hall

Hillel and Shammai. Harvesting grapes in purity, sure, but what about olives? Preserving Hillel's honor in the face of Shammai's decree. Also: the passions riding high when it comes to figuring out the last of the 18 decrees, including using and avoiding non-Jews.

Mar 23, 202022 minSeason 2Ep. 17

Shabbat 16: When All of the Vessels in the Palace Were Impure

The oddity of the decree to make vessels made of metal impure. Breaking vessels to renew their pure status. What makes rain Waters become standing water, and the significance of intent. Plus: A very strange decree rendering the Kutim/Samaritans impure. Also: the impulse to protect the halakhah with stringent decrees.

Mar 22, 202024 minSeason 2Ep. 16

Shabbat 15: When Rabbinic Decrees Create Stability

Impure land - who said, and when? Six decrees out of Usha (Who's Who and What's What). What's the purpose of a rabbinic decree? Specifically: When terumah comes in contact with possibly impure ground, garments, vessels, spit, or urine.

Mar 21, 202020 minSeason 2Ep. 15

Shabbat 14: Making the Torah Off-Limits

The impurity of the Sefer Torah - what? Why?! Busy hands. With a note that pure/impure are not value judgements. Now, who decided what? What was ascribed to Beit Hillel and Beit Shammai was really Hillel and Shammai themselves - and those great men really got along.

Mar 20, 202023 minSeason 2Ep. 14

Shabbat 12: Did Rabbi Yishmael ben Elisha Break Shabbos?!

Tefillin on erev Shabbat, and the message of awareness of God at all time. Bikur Holim, and God's presence in the visit. Rabbi Yishmael ben Elisha - and the prohibition against adjusting a candle on Shabbat (was he an "adam chashuv" or not?).

Mar 18, 202024 minSeason 2Ep. 12

Shabbat 11: If All the Seas Were Ink

A powerful statement that encompasses the Talmud's action, in full. Then, small actions to avoid on erev Shabbat, lest you forget, into shabbat (the Mishnah picks up where the last one left off). Who's Who (what): Matos Mechasya. What's What: Seyag - a fence for the Torah.

Mar 17, 202023 minSeason 2Ep. 11

Shabbat 10: Is Prayer Like a Good Meal?

Rav Kahana's exceptional approach to prayer - and the fact that we can turn to God in different frames of mind. Plus: The potential conflict between prayer and learning Torah - coming down heavily on the side of the eternal life earned in talmud Torah (with an aside for the proper mentality for prayer).

Mar 16, 202019 minSeason 2Ep. 10

Shabbat 9: Get Your Hair Done in the Morning

Examining the essence of the threshold - inside, outside, fluctuating? Establishing space before time... And now on to time: What activities to avoid before Mincha, until after you have davened. What's What: Sha'ot Zmaniot, Minchah Gedolah, Minchah Ketanah.

Mar 15, 202018 minSeason 2Ep. 9

Shabbat 8: It Doesn't Matter How You Use Your Domain

The definitions and oddities of these four domains, from a large barrel to a basket -- objects vs. domains. Also some reflections on our definitions of space in this challenging time of redefining space, inside and outside of quarantine, closing of public spaces, and ongoing community.

Mar 14, 202017 minSeason 2Ep. 8

Shabbat 7: Throw a Juicy Cake of Figs against a Wall

The Karmalit - defining what it is and what it is not, in relation to reshut ha-rabim and reshut ha-yachid. Plus: Exploring the outer parameters of the karmalit, including why the Gemara cares about throwing that juicy cake of figs. And why we care about the karmalit.

Mar 13, 202023 minSeason 2Ep. 7

Shabbat 5: What If You Never Stop Walking?

Answering Rabbi Akiva (from Shabbat 4). The importance of one's hands in completing the act of Hotza'ah. Probing what counts as a resting place to constitute completed "hanachah." What's What: Teiku

Mar 11, 202020 minSeason 2Ep. 5

Shabbat 3: Uprooting and Letting Rest - Carrying in Halakhah

Each tractate is a unit unto itself. Levels of violation of Shabbat. Who's Who: Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi, Rav, Rav Hiya. What's What (Shabbat edition): Mezid, Shogeg, Patur aval asur. Melakhah definition: Hotza'ah

Mar 09, 202027 minSeason 2Ep. 3
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android