The sisters are excited to finally be back in 2022. Anne bakes up easy, delicious Oatmeal Cream Pies that put Little Debbie's to shame. Karen recounts the harrowing case of Ginger Hayes and her son, Nicholas. Then, Anne reveals the appalling story of Catherine Beard from Ord, Nebraska. Promo: Super Familiar with the Wilsons Podcast #murderpodcast #oatmealcreampie #kidnapping #victimology #lifesentence #killavanilla #recipeingredients
Jan 23, 2022•57 min•Ep. 94
There is a mental health trigger warning for this story as well as a trigger for the gruesomeness of the crime. #mentalhealth #cannibalfratboy #jupiterfl #christmasrecipe #gingerbreadcheesecake Sources: https://heavy.com/news/2016/08/michelle-mishcon-stevens-john-stevens-iii-austin-harrouff-victims-state-university-face-biting-married-couple-murder-jupiter-florida-fraternity-photos-bath-salts-flakka-drugs/ http://archive.tcpalm.com/news/crime/martin-county/who-were-john-stevens-and-michelle-mish...
Jan 12, 2022•45 min•Ep. 93
Happy Holidays to the Sugar Squad from Karen & Anne! As a bonus episode, the sisters allow the Murder Incorporated Podcast to take over an episode! Two best friends, Harley and Buddy, bring you the case or Paul Bernardo. They bring you into the muck of a twisted killer with a little humor to lighten the mood. You can find Murder Incorporated on all your favorite listening apps.
Dec 20, 2021•1 hr 20 min•Ep. 92
Anne & Karen welcome true crime author, Joni West, to the show. Joni has written a thrilling book called Full Frontal Murder Memoir. She talks about what is what like having a dad that committed murder and how his medical affliction played a role in his court case and made history. While Joni and the sisters discuss astonishing relationship with her family, Karen rolls up some delectable bourbon balls. You can buy Joni's riveting book at Amazon, Barnes & Noble, WalMart, and most major bo...
Dec 16, 2021•1 hr 26 min•Ep. 91
In this week's episode, the Sugar Sisters are talking about Ladies Gone Bad! While Anne makes Almond Crescent Cookies for Momma's goodie box (these are Momma's favorite Christmas cookies), Karen starts off by unraveling the horrific mystery of Christian Rojas's brutal slaying. Then, Anne describes the life and death of sweet Abraham Shakespeare who hit it big in the lottery which started nefarious plans in motion and lead to his death. Also, 2 promos are included for some fellow podcasters we wa...
Dec 09, 2021•1 hr 1 min•Ep. 90
In this Slaying in the Kitchen episode, we welcome Liz from Coffee Convos with Liz Podcast. We discuss the unsolved mystery of the disappearance of Jennifer Dulos in CT while creating yummy Apple Pie Tacos with homemade mason jar whipped cream. Use Liz's linktree below to find all the ways to listen and contact her: https://linktr.ee/CoffeeConvosLiz #killavanilla #applepierecipes #desserttacos #masonjarwhippedcream...
Dec 02, 2021•34 min•Ep. 89
Yummy Bourbon Banana Cake with Bourbon Caramel Frosting is the recipe on tap for this episode. Anne recounts the tragic murder of Jack Smith, a well-respected jeweler from Franklin, VA. Then Karen gives her account of the murder of Terri Brickey Brantley from Windsor, VA, who was murdered by Karen's classmate during high school. The recipe Karen follows is from http://www.thegandmkitchen.com Part of the Oracl3 Network http://www.oracl3network.com TRCXQotuncW8TBhhUfPk Smith case sources: https://...
Nov 16, 2021•1 hr 23 min•Ep. 88
The sisters are back in the kitchen and back into the bourbon! Anne Varner uses Killa Vanilla as she bakes incredible Apple Pie Bars with have a shortbread crust and are topped with fresh apples, gooey stuff, and a drizzle of salted caramel. Karen describes the case of what Jasmine "Jazzy" Gilbert bore witness to as her mom, Tina Towler, and Tina's boyfriend, James Ferguson, suffered at the foot as Jazzy's bed as she laid listening. Then, Anne recounts the many untruths that Roberta Snyder's hus...
Nov 08, 2021•1 hr 6 min•Ep. 87
In this OctoBoo episode, the sisters are joined by their favorite storyteller, Andrea St. Amand. Andrea takes them through some downtown Charleston haunts and spins some incredibly creepy tales of ghostly hauntings. #charelstonhauntings #historicalghosts #spookystories #ghosthunting #andreastamand
Oct 20, 2021•37 min•Ep. 86
In this special episode of the OctoBoo series, the sisters drag Noah out to the Angel Oak tree on John's Island, SC at night. Spookiness occurs and ends with Karen's car high-tailing it out of the creepy woods. #angeloaktree #spookyseason #hauntings #ghosthunting #halloween
Oct 13, 2021•21 min•Ep. 85
In this introductory episode to the 2021 OctoBoo series, the sisters take a nighttime field trip to hunt for a ghostly light. Needless to say, Anne nor Karen have a future career in ghost hunting! According to https://thehauntingsofsc.blogspot.com/2013/12/jacksonboro-light.html The legend goes like this: "...a little girl had wondered off a bit to far from her house, considering this road is heavily wooded on both sides and it was getting darker by the minute, the family grew frantic, so the pre...
Oct 06, 2021•21 min•Ep. 84
In this episode, Karen bakes a tasty Italian Cherry Pound Cake that is baked in a loaf pan for easy slicing and serving. Anne informs us about the tragic, twisty murder case of Meghan Landowski in Portsmouth, VA. Karen describes the crazy case of Billy Staton and Leticia Castro in LaFeria, TX, also known as the Tape Recorder Murders. The sisters sip on Basil Hayden's Bourbon and tongue twisting and new word creation commences! #ItalianCherryPoundCake #cherries #bourbon #portsmouthva #laferiatx R...
Sep 27, 2021•1 hr 3 min•Ep. 83
In this episode the vodka drinks are flowing. There is talk of how Kenny Chesney's chest might taste as the sisters sip/guzzle on a tropical drink after a quick bourbon tasting. Anne bakes up incredible Dreamy Chocolate cupcakes that are filled with vanilla cream and topped with shiny, dark ganache. Karen chronicles the senseless murder of a couple in Texas, then Anne unravels the mysterious death of Kay Parsons in Georgia. #kennychesney #bluechairrum #chocolatecupcakes #ganache #vanillacream #g...
Sep 14, 2021•50 min•Ep. 82
Karen is in the kitchen this week and she baked up some yummy Key Lime Cupcakes. Instead of buttercream, she opted for a Key Lime Glaze with a crushed Graham Cracker topping. Anne recounts the story of sweet high school student, Mujey Dumbuya, from Michigan. Once the cupcakes are read,y, Karen unravels the case of the death of Ted Binion from Nevada. #keylime #glaze #recipeingredients #homebaked #michigan #nevada #disappeared #missing SOURCES: Dumbuya case: Wwmt.com Michbar.org Mlive.com Binion ...
Aug 27, 2021•53 min•Ep. 81
The sisters welcome Debbie Q from The Right Shoe Podcast in another episode of Slaying in the Kitchen. In this episode, Anne helps Debbie slay a yummy recipe for Bananas Foster Muffins. Karen leads the discussion of the kidnapping and murder of Denise Amber Lee in Florida. Sugar Coated Murder Podcast is proud to be a part of the Oracle Network www.oracl3network.com #911 #deniseamberlee #bananasfoster #muffins #collaboration #slay #recipeingredients
Aug 15, 2021•58 min•Ep. 80
The sisters are still on vacation having their Hot Podcasters Summer. They have recycled 2 Shorty episode, combining them to make 1 Biggie. Please enjoy 'Rona Dating with Sarah and Suzi's Balls. #recycle #repurpose #reuse
Aug 05, 2021•47 min•Ep. 79
Enjoy this recycled episode. The sisters have repurposed 2 cases that they each handpicked. Stitched together are the Roundy murder case and the Tiner murder case. Bourbon seems to play a part in the telling of each of the cases. Do we sense a theme? #recycle #repurpose #reuse
Aug 04, 2021•1 hr 16 min•Ep. 78
Anne chooses a no-bake option due to the heat of the Lowcountry Summer. She whips up a cool recipe for Cookies & Cream Pie. Karen unpacks the troubling Boston murder case of Amy Roman. Next, Anne takes us on a crazy journey in Momma's hometown of Buena Vista, VA, in the murder case of Vernon Staton that is followed by a circus of court actions. #cookiesandcream #pie #buenavista #bostonma #nobakerecipe #oreos Sugar Coated Murder is proud to be a part of the Oracle Network....
Jul 20, 2021•1 hr 6 min•Ep. 77
In this special episode of Slaying in the Kitchen, the ladies welcome Connor Flynn of Bigfoot Anonymous to discuss his explorations, findings, and sightings of Sasquatch himself as well as his experiences and knowledge of other cryptids. Along with the discussions about Connor's discoveries, Karen and Connor bake up a scrumptious Key Lime Pound Cake together. Shots are flowing and things are bumping in the night. #shots #coconutrum #poundcake #keylime #cryptids #bigfootsightings
Jul 11, 2021•1 hr 23 min•Ep. 76
In this episode, Anne creates magic with a recipe for Pecan Spinwheels Bread Pudding. Who knew you could elevate a gas station snack food? Karen reveals the case of Dzong Ngoc Tu and makes sure she is no longer the forgotten victim of serial killer Michael Bruce Ross from Cornell University. Then, Anne covers the case of Etta Jean Westbrook and her friends Geraldine and Hazel, who formed a church-going sisterhood and looked after each other in their twilight years. #recipeingredients #breadpuddi...
Jul 05, 2021•59 min•Ep. 75
In this zany episode Karen DeVanie cooks up some delicious Bananas Foster and serves it over decadent vanilla ice cream. Yummy! While Karen cooks Anne Varner stirs up trouble with the awful story of the murders of Susan (Missy) MacIvor and her husband Michael. While the sisters enjoy the kitchen yummies, Karen DeVanie bewilders us with the tale of a nefarious killer in Nebraska. Oh and Karen renames the state because...why not?! #nebraska #floridakeys #bananasfoster #rum #flambe #icecream...
Jun 28, 2021•1 hr 13 min•Ep. 74
In this episode, Anne Varner bakes scrumptious recipe of Strawberry Muffins. Karen DeVanie describes the horrifying details of the Tammy Jo Steinert murder in Courtland, VA. This is another hometown homicide case from where the sisters grew up. Then, Anne weaves the grotesque tale of the Acid Bath Killer from Yorkshire, Great Britain. #strawberrymuffins #recipeingredients #kitchen #murder #killer #domesticviolence #restrainingorder #hostage #standoff #funny #popularpodcast Sugar Coated Murder is...
Jun 16, 2021•57 min•Ep. 73
In this episode, Karen bakes a delicious Butterscoth Krimpet Cake. The recipe mimics the Tasty Cake Butterscotch Krimpets. Anne unravels the fan-sent murder case of Paul Jandreau in Moyock, NC. Next, Karen reveals the mystery of the disappearance and murder of Allison Alvarez at the Atlanta Motor Speedway in Atlanta, GA. #charleston #southcarolina #recipeingredients #butterscotchcake #murdermystery #butterscotchbuttercream #funny #murdershewrote Sugar Coated Murder podcast is proud to be a part ...
Jun 11, 2021•1 hr 6 min•Ep. 72
In this episode, the Broads introduce a new series called Slaying in the Kitchen. They welcome their first slayer, Lyndon, who has a great true crime podcast called Murder At Bedtime with Lyndon. Anne leads Lyndon as they bake vanilla scones together. While the baking unfolds, all three discuss the exasperating tale of Keith Jesperson, also known as The Happy Face Killer. Can success be claimed if a serial killer has to write into the media to claim his victims because police keep getting it wro...
Jun 02, 2021•54 min•Ep. 71
Hey yall! In this episode Karen bakes up Mexican Hot Chocolate Cookies while Anne Varner tells the ridiculous story of the Corn Rake Killer. While the girls enjoy a delicious cocktail Karen DeVanie unwinds the story of the Taco Bell Strangler. Was the killer a serial killer or not? Sugar Coates Murder is proud to be a part of the Oracle Network. www.oracl3network.com #iowa #charlottenc #mexicanhotchocolate #cookies #blowtorch #toastedmarshmallows...
May 21, 2021•1 hr 13 min•Ep. 70
In this episode, Anne bakes Honey Butter Rolls that turn out to be pillows of love. Karen unravels the craziness of the murder of Kendra Hatcher in Dallas, TX. Then, Anne gives us the horrible Soham Murders from the Soham, Cambridgeshire, England. #sallysbakingaddiction #honey #butter #dinnerrolls #dentist #kendrahatcher #sohammurders #cambridgeshire #pillowsoflove
May 13, 2021•1 hr 5 min•Ep. 69
This episode is dedicated to CJ at the Beyond the Rainbow Podcast for helping Karen with her Twittering. Tonight, Karen assembles a Lady Finger Cake to celebrate Mother's Day. Anne presents the senseless murder of Robby Mast by Lindsay Haugen in Montanna. Then, Karen discusses a lady killer in Mexico that preyed upon elderly women. Known as Mataviajitas, Juana Brazzana started out as a professional wrestler in the lucha libra community of Mexico City, Mexico. Unfortunately, she chooses violence ...
May 07, 2021•56 min•Ep. 68
In this episode, Anne Varner makes Bread & Butter Pickles in the microwave, which turns out to be quite amazing!! Karen presents the senseless murder of Florida attorney Melissa Lewis. Then, Anne unravels the crazy story of a murdered man that did not know he was dead. This one is a wild ride! #microwave #bread&butterpickles #ftlauderdale #florida #newyork #porco
May 02, 2021•59 min•Ep. 67
Karen bakes up a favorite of Momma's, Pecan Divinity, which gets re-named DeVanie's Divine Divinity. Anne presents the murder of Simeonette Mapes-Crupi in Staten Island, NY. Then Karen discusses the double homicide of the Parkers in Conway, SC. Trout misbehaves as the evening winds down. #newyork #statenisland #simeonettemapes #doublehomicide #wronglyconvicted #conway #southcarolina #missing #zoemcilwain
Apr 22, 2021•1 hr 6 min•Ep. 66
In this episode, Anne tries a gluten-free recipe for fan, Julie, and bakes up a delicious, gooey flourless chocolate torte. Karen takes us on the wild ride of the San Francisco Witch Killers, and Anne tells the tale of the senseless murder of Kathy Chou in Washington state. Anne highlights the mission persons case of Tammy Russell Kingery from North Augusta, SC. #flourlesschocolatetorte #tammyrussellkingery #missinginsc #missingpersons #glutenfree #sanfrancisco #witchkillers #kathychou...
Apr 15, 2021•1 hr 7 min•Ep. 65
