In this very special episode, the sisters welcome author and coach, Liz Bullard! Liz has written many books, some mystery/thriller and some fantasy. She has books for everyone! She currently has a Kickstarter Campaign and can use our support. Liz and Karen bake up an exceptional recipe sent in by Luke of Howdy Beans podcast. Check out Luke's podcast at www.youtube.com/@TheHowdyBeansPodcast or https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-howdy-beans-podcast/id1781351772 The Millionaire's Shortbread ...
Jun 29, 2025•1 hr 23 min•Ep. 154
It's Anne's turn in the kitchen and she does not disappoint! She bakes us some delicious Cinnamon Roll Cruffins (https://iambaker.net/cinnamon-roll-cruffins/#wprm-recipe-container-177616). The sisters discuss their fossil hunting adventure with Capt. Ashby from Charleston Fossil Adventures. Follow him on Instagram or go to his website (chsfossiladventures.com) and book a trip today!! Karen takes us on a deep dive of the Menendez Brothers, Lyle and Eric. From the first trial to the second trial a...
Jun 12, 2025•1 hr 3 min•Ep. 153
The sisters are finally successful at recording the episode with actual sound! Karen tries out a recipe for Low Sugar Sweet Potato Bread and it turns out fluffy and nutty with warm spices. It would make a delicious breakfast bread! She found the recipe in a Better Homes and Garden magazine (Cut the Sugar issue) and then tweaked it to make it her own. Of course she used Killa Vanilla! Anne unpacks the victimology of Samantha Burns and Alice Donovan and how a political decision made years later af...
May 08, 2025•55 min•Ep. 152
Karen performs for Anne. Anne pours strong drinks. Karen and Anne get tipsy. Anne bakes up delicious Chocolate Bourbon Mini Bundt Cakes. We got too tipsy and forgot to taste them during the episode. Karen tells the harrowing tale of a double homicide of two ladies who were living their lives and working their jobs. This story will make your blood boil! The ladies start the episode off with a Happy Birthday to Anne shot of #screwballpeanutbutterwhiskey and follow up with smooth and daring #Yellow...
Feb 06, 2025•51 min•Ep. 151
Welcome to our 150th episode!!! It's Karen's turn to bake this week and she doesn't disappoint. She shares the recipe for a festive green Pistachio Pound Cake with Cherry Glaze. First, Karen unpacks the details of the betrayal and murder of Brittney Gregory. Next, Anne presents the case of how the case of Heather Saul brings down a monster lurking in the shadows. For the full recipe, email us at murder.sugarcoated@gmail.com Watch this episode here: https://youtu.be/2NJ6exYmSII #pistachiocake #fe...
Dec 10, 2024•1 hr 4 min•Ep. 150
It's our first full video episode! Anne shares her recipe for freshly baked Brown Butter Sugar Cookies. They turned out so yummy! Karen narrates the story of how a psychic in Ohio solved a mystery unraveling in Arizona. This is the case of Stacy Hendrickson. Next, Anne covers the tragic case of Priscilla Gustafson. Please find our you tube channel - Sugar Coated in the House - and like, subscribe, comment, review, rate, follow, bless. Whatever love you got for us; pour it on us! https://youtu.be...
Nov 21, 2024•59 min•Ep. 149
In this episode, the ovens are off because it is way too hot to cook right now in the Lowcountry! First, Anne Varner unpacks the case of Gayle McCaffrey, who went missing under suspicious circumstances. Listen to see if Gayle ever got the justice she needs. Next, Karen discusses the tragic story of how Kendy Howard lost her life. Indie Pod promos: The Mystery Frequency https://linktr.ee/mysteryfrequency?utm_source=linktree_profile_share&ltsid=31a16c90-6fed-4c1c-82b1-a05cbe88ae11 Rewatch Reca...
Jul 02, 2024•1 hr 19 min•Ep. 148
In this new episode, Anne conquers one of her bucket list recipe challenges - Baked Alaska. This one has a chocolatey brownie bottom, topped with creamy mint chip ice cream and sealed under a dome of Swiss Buttercream Meringue. So Delicious! Karen walks the listeners down a murderous path that ends up with a young man from a hit reality series shot dead on the steps of a complex in St. Louis, Missouri. #brownie #recipeshare #bakedalaska #bakingbucketlist #mintchip #swissmeringue
May 11, 2024•40 min•Ep. 147
Michael Colucci, a Summerville SC jeweler, stands accused of the 2015 murder of his wife, Sara Lynn Moore-Colucci. The original trial ended in a hung jury. Now, after over five years, Colucci is facing a retrial, scheduled to begin on May 13. In this episode, Anne reviews the mysterious death of Sara Lynn and the first murder trial. Karen bakes up some deliciously special Blondies. This recipe comes from Karen's best friend from college, Beth, who became known for these scrumptious treats. The r...
Apr 26, 2024•55 min•Ep. 146
Karen covers the case of the Disappearance and Murder of little Justin Lee Turner from Moncks Corner, SC. In celebration of Karen's birthday, Anne bakes scrumptious Meyer Lemon Cupcakes with Vanilla Rum Glaze. #recipeswap #missingchild #justinleeturner #delayedjustice
Apr 04, 2024•25 min•Ep. 145
Karen whips up a delicious, easy recipe for Tiramisu. This creamy, coffee-spiked dessert is simple and refreshing. Anne presents the darkest day for the family of Marilyn and Bobby Blewer who were food servers at the Iowa State Fair. Indie podcast spotlight: Casting Views The Movie Wire Show #coffeedessert #tiramisu #easyrecipe #IowaStateFair #FunnelCakes #murder
Mar 30, 2024•30 min•Ep. 144
The Sugar Sisters are back with a new episode. Anne makes delicious Banana Cupcakes with scrumptious Cinnamon Cream Cheese Frosting. Karen recounts the story of who killed Rashawn Berry and what the motive was. Anne's recipe came from Sally's Baking Addiction, once again proving we are obsessed with Sally! Indie Pod Promos: Back to the Balcony (https://www.youtube.com/@back2thebalcony) F**ck My Work Life (https://linktr.ee/fmwlpod) #truecrime #unscripted #baking #cupcakes #womeninpodcasting #dar...
Mar 22, 2024•24 min•Ep. 143
Our interview with Dr. Kinsey continues in this episode. Did a ghost visit Dr. Kinsey? Was he intimidated by Alex Murdaugh at the trial? What did Dr. K think of the Strawberry Cake Roll we served him? These burning questions and more are covered in our talk with him. #specialguest #interview #kennethkinsey #jellyroll #killavanilla #karendevanie #annevarner Indie Pod promo: The Movie Wire Show - The Movie Wire | Podcast on Spotify...
Jan 18, 2024•49 min•Ep. 142
In this special episode, Karen and Anne welcome a crime scene expert, weapons expert, trial testified, an equalizer for the prosecution, and a co-star in the Alex Murdaugh murder trial - DR. KENNY KINSEY! In this part 1 of 2, we interview him and ask the pressing questions others won't ask like "have you ever had a paranormal experience at a crime scene" and many others. Of course, when you host a special guest, you serve a special treat, so the co-bakers turn out and share a recipe for a Strawb...
Jan 12, 2024•43 min•Ep. 141
Anne recaps the story of Gypsy Rose Blanchard who was convicted of 2nd degree murder of her mother, Dee Dee. Gypsy has just been granted parole after serving 8 years of her 10-year sentence. Gypsy Rose suffered unspeakable horrors at the hands of her mother who was thought to have had Munchausen By Proxy syndrome. Dee Dee had even lied to Gypsy about what age she actually was. Karen bakes up a delicious and practical dish - New Year's Morning Breakfast Casserole. It is a make-ahead egg dish that...
Dec 30, 2023•44 min•Ep. 140
Anne bakes up memory-inducing Mini Powdered Donut Muffins that remind the sisters of their youth. These powdery pillows of softness are perfect for Christmas morning. Karen recounts the horrifying details of the kidnapping and torturous killing of Amy Robinson in Arlington, Texas. Amy was kind, dependable, and dedicated to her future; she was preyed upon by two heartless beasts. This case begs the question: Are murderers born to kill, or does their environment make them killers? #TurnersSyndrome...
Dec 21, 2023•28 min•Ep. 139
Still stuffed from Thanksgiving, Karen opts to skip the kitchen in this episode and discuss various foods she enjoyed over the holiday. She describes the Pilgrim sandwiches that were her favorite meal. Anne unwinds the twisted case of the demise of Iron Mike Malloy, the man who wouldn't die. The case occurred during the Great Depression and Prohibition in a dirty speakeasy in Bronx, NY. Mike thought his life had taken a lucky turn, but his friends had other plans. In desperate times when money i...
Dec 02, 2023•33 min•Ep. 138
In this episode, Anne bakes up a recipe for Apple Caramel Upside Down Cake and kicks it up with a secret ingredient. Karen unpacks the case of the Heidt murders out of Georgia, where a tight-knit family has a jealous, nefarious member lurking for the opportunity to commit the most heinous of acts. And another family member just might be the cause of it all. #KillaVanilla #AppleCaramel #UpsideDownCake #karendevanie #annevarner #familyannihilator #murderousaffair Indie Podcast Promo: Decayin' with...
Nov 20, 2023•34 min•Ep. 137
This episode brings a recipe for Apple Cinnamon Muffins from Karen. She bakes up warm, apple-ly treats that smell of cinnamon, toasted pecans, and KillaVanilla. The recipe is from beyondfrosting.com. Anne gives us a case out of Concord, NC, where a police officer meets an untimely death but not in the line of duty. #KillaVanilla #QuinnWitherspoon #spousalhomicide #embezzlement Indie Podcast Promos: Witches Talking Tarrot Casting Views
Nov 11, 2023•33 min•Ep. 136
In this episode, Anne shares a copycat recipe that mimicks Starbucks's Caramel Apple Spice drink. Karen introduces a social media app the ladies have never heard of and then recounts the horrendous acts of a guy with too many letters in his name. In his killing spree, he picked women who were homeless and or prostitutes because he did not think anyone would care enough to investigate their disappearances. He was right until he murdered Sarah Butler, who was not a prostitute but was a college stu...
Oct 27, 2023•28 min•Ep. 135
OctoBoo was an OctoBust so we talk OctoBalls and a murderous OctoBeast in school principal's clothing. Karen shares her recipe for some delicious peanut butter protein balls because we all need more protein! Anne unpacks the tragic story of a family annihilation - four promising lives cut short for selfish reasons. The case was solved using bugs. These bugs enabled investigators to draw a map of where the killer traveled in his murderous mission. Fascinating! Indie Pod promo: Twisted & Uncor...
Oct 22, 2023•26 min•Ep. 134
Serial Killer September continues with Anne presenting the story of a monster named Randall Woodfield, also known as "The I-5 Killer. There we so may chances to stop this monster, but a broken system enabled him to escalate from a tallywhacker exposed to a truly dark and twisted man. Karen continues Cereal Killer September with a recipe for Count Chocula cookies. Indie Pod Poromo: Super Familiar with the Wilsons - Amanda and Josh Wilson talk about super familiar subjects in a relaxed podcast - f...
Sep 23, 2023•33 min•Ep. 133
Serial Killer September continues! First, Karen puts her own spin on a recipe for Puppy Chow. As usual, she just cannot leave a recipe alone and has to make it her own. Is it a success, or is it a failure? Next, Anne narrates the horrific crimes of creepy Australian Ivan Milat, also known as the Backpacker Murderer. Of course, there's chatter as the girls crack themselves up with their witty and not-so-witty comments. Indie Podcast Promos: Decaying With The Boys - so happy to have these dudes ba...
Sep 13, 2023•31 min•Ep. 132
The ladies kick off Serial Killer September with a knockout! First, Anne shares her recipe for Brown Butter Rice Crispy Treats. She gives a great tutorial on how to make brown butter and turns out some fancy mouth treasures. Then, Karen unfolds the mysteries surrounding the Colonial Parkway Murders that are thought to have been committed by a Serial Killer who has not yet been caught. At least 8 people (ages 14-27) lost their lives to a deranged killer along the 23-mile stretch of highway that c...
Sep 07, 2023•36 min•Ep. 131
The sisters try a new bourbon, Anne bakes a Boozy Cherry Pie, and endless inappropriate laughter ensues. Karen offends the US Postal Service, and there is a call for Serial Killer insurance. Karen covers the evil doings of NC/SC Serial Killer Daniel Printz. His victims were Edna Suttles, Leigh Goodman, Delores Sellers, and Nacy Rego. His other victim was his entire family. Indie Pod Spotlight: Super Familiar with the Wilsons #recipeforcherrypie #boozycherries #passportpaperwork #chickencock #bou...
Jul 21, 2023•49 min•Ep. 130
It's Karen's turn to bake, so she brings out a recipe for a delicious and easy Blueberry Cobbler that she adds Killa Vanilla to. Anne catches us up on True Crime's current events. Then she narrates the heartbreaking story of the victimization of Nohema Graber, a beloved Spanish teacher from Fairfield High School in the small town of Fairfield, Iowa. While recording, the sisters sip on a new cocktail, Bourbon Cream by Buffalo Trace. Indie Pod Spotlight: Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast with Jill #b...
Jul 14, 2023•57 min•Ep. 129
This case was sent to us by a listener named Erin. HI, Erin! Anne reveals a winning recipe for a delicious Pound Cake and redeems herself from an early Pound Cake disaster. Karen unpacks a case that draws eerie similarity to the case of their book, CLICK, CLICK, CLICK. Set in a community within Henrico County, VA, this is a case of Mortal Frenemies. Dean Scott Phillips was described as a confident, thriving teenager on his way to chase his future at Virginia Polytechnical Institute and State Uni...
Jul 06, 2023•32 min•Ep. 128
Karen shares a delicious recipe for Browned Butter Bourbon Banana Bread that is a sock knocker offer. It's nutty and banana-ee and did we mention Bourbon? Anne narrates the harrowing story of Tim McLean who boarded a bus in Canada and was minding his own business when his worst nightmare joined him. This case was sent in by a listener named Dean. Thanks, Dean!! Indie Pod Spotlight: Casting View - a fun British spot of good times #TransCanadaHighway #brownedbutter #busridefromhell #truecrimecomed...
Jun 30, 2023•30 min•Ep. 127
During this episode, Anne shares the recipe for Perfect Peach Pie from @sallysbakingaddiction. Karen refuses to taste it. Karen tells the sad story of a senseless murder that took away a stand-up guy. Rosalio Gutierrez, Jr. was a popular father of 2 children with a big heart that made his mom proud to call him her son. When he started dating Sadie Beacham, he had no idea the danger that was lurking. Unaware of Sadie's unhinged ex-partner, Junior became the target of horrible violence. We congrat...
Jun 21, 2023•30 min•Ep. 126
You've heard of Carpool Karaoke? Well this isn't it, but it is an episode recorded from the car. Annd and Karen finally get a quick episode recorded! In this episode, they discuss some current court cases in the news. It's great to finally catch up and discuss some crazy court #LoriVallowDaybell #BryanKohberger #Idaho4 #WisconsinDismember #Vandersloot #NataleeHolloway #KouriRichins #childrensbookmurderer #courttv Copyright: Sugar Coated, LLC
Jun 13, 2023•30 min•Ep. 125
