A slow clap for voice assistants? - podcast episode cover

A slow clap for voice assistants?

Mar 13, 202417 minSeason 2Ep. 71
--:--
--:--
Download Metacast podcast app
Listen to this episode in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episode description

Why is it that I have 1000 planners/calendars/whiteboards and still forget stuff all the time? It’s not you, it’s them: they don’t ask you to attend to them, they are passive things that don’t ask you to attend to them. David and Isabelle dig into why voice assistants (like Amazon’s Alexa, Google Assistant, Apple’s Siri) are a potentially useful neurodivergent accommodation strategy—and no judgment if you value your privacy above the outsourcing your working memory. Covering visual timers, what to avoid if you’re setting up a reminder program, and the power of a slow clap.  


—-

Isabelle does not like to be scheduling, she likes to have scheduled. She does not like to holiday, she likes to have had a holiday season. During the recent holiday break, it was a structureless day, the kids were home, Bobby was working, and Isabelle was in one room all day, and realized how much of her executive functioning short circuited, and also how much her memory is reliant upon changing rooms, and sequences of physical actions, all of which were missing because everyone was on break and out of routine. So she found a cheap system for a voice assistant. And it has been game changing for her family. It doesn't have to live inside her head, the routines, the rhythms. There is an external nag doing the nagging for her and the rest of the family. She wonders why all her planners and lists and things don’t do it but this voice assistant does? David explains that it’s because it comes to you, you don’t have to go to it to get the information. Unless it exploded or fired out papers into the world, you have to attend to it to be reminded. It’s a partner in executive functioning. Instead of having to outsource it to your partner so much. You can program skills, sequences of actions, routines, etc. Kids are learning a whole sequence but I don’t have to teach them all the time. A lot of people ask us for parenting help, and we can talk about all the strategies to do to change behavior. The most important thing you can do is notice when they’re doing something good. When it tells them to do the thing, and they do this thing, you get to come in and celebrate them and notice it. This is a big gift it has given Isabelle and her family: instead of interacting around a stress point, and we get frustrated with the system instead of with each other.  You can program it to applaud, and it has a feature where you get it to slow clap, and Isabelle names they  have a legit slow clap in the house, and the kids love it. What you’re seeing is why this works, it is a legit intervention. Those kinds of systems are not always helpful for people. Isabelle learned the hard way that it was left on storytelling for too long and wild and they had to wrangle in a more soothing bedtime routine. But as David reminds us, if you’re not listening to it as it reminds you, you will learn to never listen to it. Same as with a visual timer, you have to keep yourself to it, because otherwise you are learning to ignore. Isabelle has a certain feature where she has to answer a question to a reminder, the beeping doesn’t go away unless you interact with it. Also, setting up timers with music, setting environmental cues through music and setting up an ambience with parts of their routine. David never uses timers, because he only uses them when it’s go-time. He’s a person who really values privacy. It’s an emotional battle, unless you’ve gone through the options to change your phone settings, they are listening to it. The different options are essentially a whiteboard that speaks to you, a diary that buzzes after you, a friend that doesn’t forget—you do have those resources if you don’t have this device. This is also so you know you can find options that aren’t digital—but be careful of overly depending on people, because dependency breeds aggression, and that is one of the things about these robot overlords, are you can be as dependent as you want on them and be as aggressive as you want to be and it doesn’t hurt a person. When kids get frustrated with it, or I get frustrated with it, it’s happening to an object rather than to yourself, or someone else. Isabelle casts no judgment on those who choose privacy over these devices, because she tried one out a few years back and she was very much against it, it felt creepy to her. She didn’t really explore it or work with it. The thing that changed her minds was the realization of how much of the working memory and routine and reminders this offloads, the difference is it’s not on her to remember. So she’s like “go ahead and sell me all the dog food, because it's worth it.” David is a good person, he’s not worried about the things it finds out about me…so it would sell me the fruit leather? But it might be so clever it would question if David really wants 4 cases of 500 of them. So David decides he would NEVER get one because he doesn’t.

What is Bluey? 

Isabelle notes: Brace yourself, this show is powerful and not just for kids/parents/caregivers of kids. 7 minute episodes with brilliant writing and solid visuals all teaching you how to be a human modeled by cartoon dogs. Special ND note: Many fans argue that the shows titular character is a ND tribe member (I welcome her with open arms); there is more overt mention in the episode “Army," which features a character named Jack (who continues on in the show) who many argue represents a neurodivergent kid—to watch him find connection and confidence is pretty incredible....OH THE FEELS.
----

Cover Art by: Sol Vázquez

Technical Support by: Bobby Richards

Special Thanks to Bluey. Best show that sums up real life for kids (and grownups) with humor, compassion, and just plain brilliance. Watch “Flat Pack.”

Transcript

Isabelle

Hello. I'm Isabelle, she, her, hers. And I'm David, he, him, his. And we're 2 therapists with ADHD who sit down to have some chats about ADHD. We can't promise we'll stay on topic or be professional or even remotely mature, but we can promise that you'll end up looking at you or your loved one's beautiful neurodivergent brain in a shiny new way. This is not a therapy session. This is something shiny.

David

I love it.

Isabelle

Do you like it?

David

That's amazing. And can this just be the intro? You saying that and me freaking out about how amazing it is?

Isabelle

Yeah. Can I

David

you tapping your voice?

Isabelle

That could be that could be our first intro. So without further ado, welcome to Something Shiny.

David

I'm David.

Isabelle

I am like my mind is blown. My mind is just so blown. Can I tell you something that can I tell you my ADHD story actually? Yeah. Okay.

Because I love the track we're on, but I also don't wanna forget to share this. So I had this experience over the holidays where, you know, all routines, all rhythms lost. Speaking of a lot of little yucks, constant little yucks, Like, it's also I think we talk about this ahead of the holidays, but it's also a time of year where everyone expects it to be big yums. And in actuality, at least for me, it's a ton of little yucks, a lot of big yucks, you know, grief, loss, pain, blah. And then a little like certain certainly some yums, but like you gotta fight for those yums.

What I love is actually the period of time after the thing, after the holidays, after routine has returned and it's done. Like, I talk about it. I don't like scheduling things. I like having schedules. I don't like the holidays.

I like having experience for holidays. Does that make any sense? This, in my head, somehow relates to the, like, little yuck thing. So had this day, and it was, like, just it was literally that day you described where actually be partly in my head, I think I previously looked at this as just structureless lost feeling. Right?

Like like a day where I had no structure, I technically had nowhere to be. The kids had nowhere to be. Bobby was working, and so it was on me to kinda fill our time with something. And I was like a rat that was starving for water that was simultaneously treading water. I don't know if that's a good metaphor.

Like, I, like, literally feel like more of my executive functioning short circuited that day than ever. And I realized and this is gonna sound like a duh. Of course, we say this all the time. But again, I forget everything and so I'm always remembering this. What I realized is, you know what I did differently?

I was in one room for a really long time. That actually never happens. Oh my gosh. Wait a minute. Ton of my memory and remembering what happens next comes from the physical space I am standing in that cues me, like, literally. I realized I have a route in the morning. Like, oh, I'm with the kids in the bathroom. And when I'm in the bathroom, I remember we gotta do the the the the the the. And then I move us here, and then I move us here, then I move us here. But I didn't move.

I was able to just sit in one spot, but it's like my brain had nothing to cue it. Yeah. Yes. So I borrowed a hack, and actually if I have a few clients who've talked about this, and this is, like, we can edit this out or we can throw this in. I borrowed a hack which is, a lot of tech savvy clients have talked a lot about things like Alexa or Siri or something out in the world that's gonna remind you and cue you. And, like, there's all these cool articles about how to create a system to, like

David

Mhmm.

Isabelle

Just create a ton of reminders and, you know, like, you you use it as your external memory. Great sale going on. I picked a system. I'm not even gonna disclose what. I don't need to endorse it, but I picked a type of system that was very, in my mind, very cheap, like, no more than I'd spent on, like, you know, a nice dinner or something.

And I just was like, I'm gonna test it out. I'm gonna put it in, like, 2 places. I'm gonna program it to say a couple things or to do a couple things for me, and I'm gonna see how this works. David Kessler. Mhmm. If it is not the best thing that's ever happened to this family, I don't know what is. You know why? Because suddenly, I don't have to hold all that. There's something else. It's so much better than a little list on the on the I I wish I could get to know.

David

With executive functioning.

Isabelle

It is. But it's help me understand why it's different. I have so many calendars and lists that do nothing

David

on it. Don't get your attention. They're they're totally sitting there waiting for you to attend to them. That's the big difference. So you can have things written down in a 1000000 different places, but unless they literally exploded at a certain time or started firing papers out into the world, like, you wouldn't attempt to them.

Right? Versus this thing that's tied into your house system that goes, good night. It's about you're supposed to do that. I don't know why it's a weird accent like that, but, like, whatever kind of accent it it shoots out.

Isabelle

Side note, it we totally have it rigged to be Australian accents because why would we not? We adore Bluey. And it sounds like one of the characters were Bluey. It's like So it's tall. It's I can't do it. It's so good, though. It's so good.

David

But it becomes the externalized memory for you. And then we can flip it on the other side for you. It is the the partner that you can make, hey. Tuesday at 6. Remind me to call the blah blah blah because your partner might not remember that, but also an Alexa will be like, it's Tuesday at 6 if you call the blah blah blah. And you're like, thank you.

Isabelle

And That's exactly what's happened.

David

Yeah.

Isabelle

I am not angry about it as much. Yeah. It Bobby does not get mad at me. It's weird. I get mad at him about this. The kids? I don't know how. I knock on wood. I don't wanna jinx it. I created a little program because you can program skills. You can program sequences of actions. You can, like, literally, you can have it be like, I'm setting a timer. I'm gonna play music. What would you like to hear? And then it's gonna go up like you program the whole sequence in.

And then Yeah. So I don't have to keep going into a room. Did you do it? Did you do it? Did you do it? They are learning a whole sequence, but I don't have to do the work of teaching it all the time. Wait.

David

What?

Isabelle

All I have to do is stand in the room. It's so nice.

David

Hold on. Wait. Wait. We have a lot of people that ask us about, like, parenting help and, like like, how to help with young ones with with, you know, neurodivergence and all this kind of stuff. And, like, we can get into the strategies of talking about all these different things you can do to change behavior.

Isabelle

Yeah.

David

The most important thing we can do is notice when kids are doing something good. So the moment they're in this whole thing with whatever, you know, the the thing in your house is like the robotic voice telling him to do the thing When it tells him to do the thing and then you see them doing the thing, that's the moment for you to be like, you're doing this thing. That's awesome. You remembered. And they're like, I don't even remember.

This thing told me, it's like, nope. You made the decision to do this thing.

Isabelle

Exactly. No, David. And that makes me feel so good because suddenly I'm interacting around a stress point and a huge sore spot, like cleaning up, brushing teeth. I'm interacting with the kids. And when, the system doesn't work right, we both get frustrated with it instead of with each other. And then it's funny. Yes. Like, it's just different. And then they're pissed that they're getting told to do it again. I'm like, I don't know.

Take it up with the computer. Like but the best part, can I tell you, you can program it to, like, applaud, and it has this feature where it starts

David

Slow clapping?

Isabelle

Slow clap. And so I start the slow clap and then I join in, and then Bobby where we starts to join in and we like a legit slow clap.

David

This is amazing.

Isabelle

It's amazing. And the kids love it. They're like, oh, I'm getting a slow clap.

David

I think I think what what you're seeing is, like, all the reasons why that works and that there are, like, legit reasons why it works, and it is a legit environmental intervention.

Isabelle

Yeah.

David

It is not those kinds of systems are not always helpful for people.

Isabelle

Oh, I can see. Yeah. I well, we already learned that the fact that we left it on and we introduced the kids to story time destroyed bedtime for, like, 3 nights until we figured out a way to, like, kinda shut it down and then just, like, play a much more soothing story that we use, for example. Yeah. Like, it's a very big learning curve.

David

Yeah. The the other thing that that I know to be true is the way we, as humans, attend to reminders is very important. And so, like, as long as you are actually doing what the reminder is asking you to do and not learning to ignore it, this becomes a really successful intervention. But if you have too many things that Alexis or whatever or Google or whatever the thing, I don't know, these are, like, whatever it's doing, if you're not listening to it, you will learn to never listen

Isabelle

to it. Exactly. Yes. No. I I know that to be true. It's like it's not dissimilar to, like, visual timers. Right? Like, it's like, if you decide you wanna use that to build time pressure, you gotta hold to it. You gotta actually stop when the timer goes off. You can't just, like, cheat the whole time because you're right.

Then all you're learning is like, oh, please disregard what I just said. You know? Which side note, there's, something I have found is there are certain features where she will like, she's a person. The entity, the robot overlord gives me a question, and I actually have to answer it. And that I found I've inserted in more reminders because of what that makes me do.

It does actually make me say something. I can't just ignore it. I actually have to say something because it becomes like that seat belt. Like, it doesn't go away. And then I it's easier for me to switch tasks.

But, again, early stages, rave reviews. Side note, also just in terms of creating ambiance and environments and external cues, we have timers set up with different music. So the music itself becomes like this cool operation existing operation, establishing a vision, establishing operation. Like, we've got the silver. We're really into smooth jazz in this house. We've got variations on smooth jazz at its core.

David

I wanna just exist in in opposite, but not in contradiction.

Isabelle

Yeah.

David

Because for me, I don't use very many timers at all because when I use a timer, it is, it is like, it is like the the thing I have to attend to. So I'm very limited on the timers that I pull out because when I do, it's like it is such and, like, it is such an environmental shift that I'm like, go time. Like, ears get pinned back. It's a rare thing. Here I go.

And so I've operated without any of these, like, things in my home. I am a person I just wanna say this. I'm a person that really values privacy.

Isabelle

No. I that that's what I was gonna say. It's, like, legit, that was a huge consideration. And

David

No. But there's no judgment. No. But it's all like, no judgement on it. This is literally, like, it's it's a it's such an emotional battle that isn't even real.

I mean, like, if unless you've gone through, like, the the 1,000,000 different options in your phone to make sure that your phone isn't always listening to you, like, it is. So, like, this isn't about, like this is more about, like, my perception or, like, my belief than, like, the reality of, like, my intervention. Right? But, like, I do wanna, like, say that this is why, like, the Alexa or the Google or the, like, the WeGo I don't know the the different options, but, like, they are essentially a whiteboard that speaks to you. They are a diary that buzzes after you.

They are a friend that doesn't forget. And, like, the reason why I'm trying to make all these analogies is like this. We do have those resources if you don't want to get this device. Like, totally

Isabelle

like

David

be careful on how much we ask of other people because dependency causes aggression, and that's the safest thing with one of these robot overlords is you could be as dependent as you want on it because aggression towards it doesn't come back to you.

Isabelle

Exactly. And that's again, when I named that the kids get frustrated with it, and I get frustrated with it. And literally what I see is instead of me getting increasingly impatient with the kids or myself, I'm getting frustrated with this thing. And then she says something ridiculous, because she usually does. And then we all laugh, and suddenly I'm like, oh, yeah.

What am I getting frustrated about? It's a robot. You know, like, oh, I shouldn't demean the robot. But, like, I could not agree more around the privacy question, and there is zero judgment around whatever decision you make or don't make. I kind of made and just to, like, disclose for myself, like, we actually did.

We, like, inherited an old device, like, a couple years back, and I was the one who militantly was like, no. No. No. It's listen you know, like, I was very uncomfortable with it. I did not appreciate the sensation that something's just waiting on standby. And, like, I and I didn't use any of it. Right? Like, I kinda just was like, I don't I don't see how this helps. Like, I didn't really figure it out. I think the thing and I'm not trying to sell people on this.

I'm just naming how what changed it for me is the realization of the thing you just said. I'm like, that's exactly it. Because I have I don't know how much money I've probably blown. I mean, I could show you the 6 giant whiteboards we have in this room alone. Like, the amount of things I have invested in as visual cues and reminders to remind myself of the schedule to help the kid and also mostly for kids to help them learn it too so that I'm not the walking schedule and to help Bobby know where we are and the nanny, you know, who doesn't know where we are.

Like, it's just the amount of energy and labor that goes into creating things like this that this offloads Mhmm. Is the piece I didn't I don't think I understood. And the thing you just said about, like, it's also something that the difference is it's not on me to remember. That's the piece that I'm like. Yeah. Please, please know my spending habits and sell me more dog food. I welcome it. You know, like, I'm not not dismissing it because it's also very scary.

David

No. But yeah. Isabel, that's the thing that, like, is also the thing that I just questioned with myself because, like, I'm I'm honestly a good person. I'm not really worried what any of these things are gonna find out about me. And like,

Isabelle

I'm almost like, oh,

David

I'm curious. It it gets the fruit leather that I like. Right? And, like, start suggesting it to me on random look. And I'd be like, yes. Send me all the fruit roll ups you can or whatever. But, like

Isabelle

But you know what it would do, David? It would go, are you sure you want to because it like, so knows you're spending hours. It'll go, are you sure you need 4 cases of 500 of

David

If it wait. Seriously, we

Isabelle

prompt you. It would

David

prompt that to me.

Isabelle

Yeah. I'm in a gym. I'm never buying

David

this thing.

Isabelle

Then prompt you.

David

No. I don't want judgment from electronics. Yes. I said 4 cases. Don't ever judge me, electronic voice. I'm gonna have an inappropriate amount of food here. And you know what? I might give some of it away. Maybe it doesn't go bad. But are you sure you won't be plugged in all the time?

Isabelle

Oh, I love that so much.

David

Thank you so much for listening.

Isabelle

If you ever had that

David

thought where you think, hey, I have nothing. Stop. Remember, you're suffering. Something's shiny.

Isabelle

That's right. Just as you are. If you like what you heard and you want to hear more free episodes of this podcast, please subscribe, rate, and review anywhere you listen to podcasts. We're on Instagram as something shiny podcast. And if you're looking for more information, useful links, definitions, visuals, everything we can think of and more is on our website at something shiny podcast dot com, and it's all free. Thank you so much for listening, and we'll see you in 2 weeks.

Transcript source: Provided by creator in RSS feed: download file
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android