Small Town Murder - podcast cover

Small Town Murder

James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whismansites.libsyn.com
Two comedians look at a small town, what makes it tick, and a murder that took place there. In depth research, horrible tragedy, and the hosts' comedic spin on the whole thing. New episodes every Thursday!!
Last refreshed:
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

Creepy Killer Motives - Wakefield, Massachusetts

This week, in Wakefield, Massachusetts, when two people are shockingly murdered, it leads detectives down a rabbit hole of mystery, with enemies, business associates, and even possible mafia connections. They end up settling on a much more personal, and nasty motive, all stemming from having fun times, at a lake house. It's a twisted story, filled with conspiracy, lies, partial truths, affairs, and maybe even some reasonable doubt! Along the way, we find out that no one loves mechanical bulls mo...

Jun 26, 20252 hr 58 minEp. 607

Kinky Cut Up Murder Insanity - Green Bay, Wisconsin

This week, in Green Bay, Wisconsin, one of the craziest stories, in recent history. A woman, with a strange past, gets together with her ex-boyfrined, while her husband is in prison. They have a drug fueled good time, until she decides that she doesn't want to stop choking him, during an intimate time. Police end up finding parts of him, scattered throughout a basement, and in a Crock Pot box. She also attacks her lawyer, in court, says she had sex with Jeffrey Dahmer, and more!! Along the way, ...

Jun 20, 20251 hr 13 minEp. 606

Serial Butcher Killer - Parkersburg, West Virginia

This week , in Parkersburg, West Virginia, what looks like a simple drug murder, at first, turns out to be anything but that. It turns out to be the work of a psychotic serial killer, who loves nothing more than cutting people into pieces, and even leaving heads displayed for maximum effect. He commits many more murders, and when he's finally caught, he scares even the most hardened detectives with his cold blooded violence!! Along the way, we find out that you can get a mansion in West Virginia...

Jun 19, 20253 hrEp. 605

Death Of The Dog Lady - Bellevue, Iowa

This week, in Bellevue, Iowa, a woman is horribly murdered, at her own business, just as she arrived for work. Her call to 911 recorded her last moments, and a name, that she screams out in terror. With all the evidence, including post-it notes, pointing at one man, he goes on the run. A manhunt ensues, with police worried that his survival skills will make him a tough one to catch. Will they find this maniac, on the run?? Along the way, we find out that horses should apparently not participate ...

Jun 14, 20251 hr 12 minEp. 604

Murder By Moonlight - Chappaqua, New York

This week, in Chappaqua, New York, a brutal murder sends this extremely upscsale area into a panic, with ideas of a shadowy killer, lurking in the darkness. But the real story makes people begin to look in their own homes for monsters, after a prominent attorney's family suffers what appears to be a violent tragedy, but what turned out to be a diabolical, and well planned cold blooded murder! Affairs, scamming, and much more lead to the truth!! Or does it? Along the way, we find out that fires w...

Jun 12, 20252 hr 59 minEp. 603

Real Life Murder Songs - Farmville, Virginia

This week, in Farmville, Virginia, four people are found, unrecognizably brutalized, in an otherwise quiet neighborhood. This leads detectives to the family's teenage daughter's online love interest, a "horrorcore" rapper, who came to visit, after dropping out of school, due to being picked on. Will he confess all the horrific details, or will he insist on his innocence? Along the way, we find out that the town wasn't named after an annoying app based game, that "horrorcore" rap has quite a dive...

Jun 06, 20251 hr 19 minEp. 602

Angriest Serial Killer Around - Chester, Pennsylvania

This week, in Chester, Pennsylvania, a young woman, who happens to be a college athlete, disappears into the night, after leaving a bar. Her car is found, by the side of the road, door open & radio on, but her terribly brutalized body isn't found until the next day, with strange burns & other awful outcomes. After clearing a very guilty looking suspect, another, even guiltier looking man is found. His past makes it obvious that he's capable of such horrors. What he tells a cellmate is in...

Jun 05, 20252 hr 59 minEp. 601

Bigfoot Murder Conspiracy - Allen, Oklahoma

This week, in Allen, Oklahoma, when two old friends decide to spend the day "noodling" (pulling fish from a mud hole, using only your hand), the day takes a sideways turn, when mystical forces intervene, specifically, Bigfoot. At least that's what the surviving friend claims. He saysd he only killed, so he could avoid being the victim of a conspiracy between his friend, the US Army, ancient natives, and a family of Bigfeet! But did he just use a bit too much "breakfast meth"?? Along the way, we ...

May 30, 20251 hr 15 minEp. 600

#599 - Madness Of A Murderous Maniac - Summerville, Georgia

This week, in Summerville, Georgia, a maniac is on the loose, going on a rampage of violence. These acts range from running a man over, and attempting to invade a trailer home & stabbing one of the residents. This is nothing compared to what police find, when they finally set up a roadblock. What they find, is the most horrifying thing imaginable... including a foot in the backseat, ,and a human heart, on the floorboard. This is only the start of his madness, as he acts so unhinged, that sta...

May 22, 20253 hr 4 minEp. 599

#598 - Cookies Solve Murders - Stowe, Vermont

This week, in Stowe, Vermont, a young woman trades in the corporate city life, to hopefully spend her time as a "ski bum" in the Vermont mountains, but disappears, while enjoying the outdoors. Her bike is left, leaning against a tree, while she was nowhere to be found. Eventually, detectives not only find her body, but figure a lot out, due to the cookies she was eating. Then, they link the whole thing to a man, who was under their nose, the whole time! This leads to a huge change in the way the...

May 17, 20251 hr 11 minEp. 598

#597 - Talkative Serial Killer - Kellogg, Idaho

This week, in Kellogg, Idaho, when a family is murdered in their home, it leads detectives on a frantic hunt for two more victims, in an attempt to save them from a vicious serial killer. The hunt lasts almost 2 months, as the hope of finding them alive, begins to fade. Will they be found alive? The killer turns out to have killed before, and even defends his depravity through a series of blogs that will make your head spin!! Along the way, we find out that silver mining seems pretty dangerous, ...

May 15, 20252 hr 59 minEp. 597

#596 - Messy Methy Murder Conspiracy - Belle Fourche, South Dakota

This week, in Belle Fourche, South Dakota, a trip to a friend's house to buy some meth, turns into a horrifying three day session of brutality, when a man is duct taped, and seeming driven all over town, in the trunk of car. He's also stuffed into a tool box, among other atrocities. Several people witness this, and no one does anything to help. Eventually, everyone involved thinks it's "no body, no crime", but they are very much mistaken! Will anyone lead police to the body?? Along the way, we f...

May 10, 20251 hr 13 minEp. 596

#595 - More Than A Family Feud - Quincy, Illinois

This week, in Quincy, Illinois, when a "perfect couple" begin divorce proceedings, things are anything but perfect. They go back & forth with accusations & demands. This continues, until one of them is found, brutally murdered, in their own home. Could an off the cuff remark, on the gameshow "Family Feud" be a key to the whole thing, or is there more of a mystery? As the evidence piles up, with incriminating internet searches, the real killer comes in to focus! Along the way, we find out...

May 08, 20252 hr 58 minEp. 595

#594 - Family Murder Spree - Chugiak, Alaska

This week, in Chugiak, Alaska, a senseless murder is quickly solved, when one of the participants goes to police, and spills all the details. The problem is, this only leads to more murder, when the killers seek revenge on the one who squealed. An elaborate plan is hatched, among a family of criminals, leading to a huge explosion, and the wrong people being killed. Luckily, someone in the conspiracy had a conscience, and unravels the whole thing!! Along the way, we find out that in Alaska, you a...

May 03, 20251 hr 11 minEp. 594

#593 - Jerry Springer Show Murder - Sarasota, Florida

This week, in Sarasota, Florida, a love triangle explodes into a savagely horrible murder, after the trio end up on The Jerry Springer Show. These complicated relationships resulted in many days in court, and much police interaction. But it all finally comes to a head, when their episode of Jerry Springer airs, causing one of the lovers to get so angry, that the only way to fix it, is cold blooded murder!! Along the way, we find out that south Florida is circus country, that World War II could h...

May 01, 20252 hr 54 minEp. 593

#592 - Murder Texts Are Forever - Clifton, Arizona

This week, in Clifton, Arizona, forgotten text messages solve the case, when a man is killed in what seems like an incident of road rage, until they discover that 14 shots were fired at the victim, leading detectives to believe that it's very personal. There are several suspects, including his fiance, who acted suspiciously & his ex-wife, who he was battling for child custody. Then there's whoever has been stalking, and taking pictures of him. It turns out to be more diabolical than anyone c...

Apr 26, 20251 hr 13 minEp. 592

#591 - Best Friends Murder - Hudson, Ohio

This week, in Hudson, Ohio, when a woman comes to police with a story about having a dead man, buried in her yard, it leads to the unraveling of an insane tale, complete with burglaries, fires, lies, and the most cold blooded murder possible. The story involves a pair of friends, who end up at odds, and group of people, who may have helped pull this murder off, without even knowing! Will everybody get what's coming to them?? Along the way, we find out that a "Sausage Fest" can actually be very d...

Apr 24, 20252 hr 59 minEp. 591

#590 - Murdering As A Family - Jonesboro, Arkansas

This week, in Jonesboro, Arkansas, when someone is brutally murdered, in their own kitchen, a huge mystery unfolds. It seems like there are plenty of people who wanted this person dead, including the man's own father. But when a tip is called in to detectives, the terrible plot becomes clear. It turns out to the a cold, calculated plot that involves a conspiracy, with 4 people in on the murder plans!! Along the way, we find out that the potential for tornados in this town are way scarier than an...

Apr 19, 20251 hr 11 minEp. 590

#589 - Pig Farm Murders - Wimer, Oregon

This week, in Wimer, Oregon, detectives are called out to a small, rural farm, to investigate a minor matter, but end up finding half of a human leg on the property. This leads to a massive investigation, and the realization that the owner of this property may have been killing workers, and feeding them to the pigs! Somehow, it gets even weirder, from there, as we find out just how many have met their fate, in the pig pen!! Along the way, we find out that Bigfoot is very easily confused with a b...

Apr 17, 20252 hr 56 minEp. 589

#588 - Four Letter Murder - Falkner, Mississippi

This week, in Falkner, Mississippi, a teen love triangle leads to some weird situations, when two friends go out with the same young lady. Everything seems solved when one of the teens disappears, leaving the other to date the girl. But the allure of sex causes a confession to murder, even though it's later recanted. Small town politics play a big role, with rumors flying, and people fleeing town, and a Christian Slater movie being made about the whole thing!! Along the way, we find out that som...

Apr 12, 20251 hr 13 minEp. 588

#587 - Confessions Of A Monster - Gastonia, North Carolina

This week, in Gastonia, North Carolina, when bodies start being found in remote locations, detectives must piece together the last brutal hours of these lives. After speaking to many people, detectives find one particular man, who has too many coincidences with all the victims. He shockingly confesses to everything they're suspicious of, then begins to tell police about even more murders!! Along the way, we find out that bands named after dirt bikes might not be that great, that smoking crack is...

Apr 10, 20253 hr 2 minEp. 587

#586 - Never Trust Your Cousin - Clanton, Alabama

This week, in Clanton, Alabama, when a woman is found, brutally murdered, in her trailer, the main suspect is someone who was stalking her, but he has a solid alibi. This brings detectives to a more disturbing conclusion. The woman's cousin was seeing a man with an extremely troubled past. When we find out just how troubled, it's no surprise that he could do something like this, but who was helping him definitely is!! Along the way, we find out that peaches aren't just in Georgia, that there are...

Apr 05, 20251 hr 11 minEp. 586

#585 - Serial Killer's Secret Graveyard - Kingston Township, Pennsylvania

This week, in Kingston Township, Pennsylvania, what begins as a simple search for a missing criminal pharmacist, quickly turns into the discovery of a makeshift graveyard, in a man's yard, that may have up to 12 burned, bashed & buried bodies. The more investigation that happens, the more the layers begin to peel off, revealing a brutal serial killer & his accomplices! But will a homemade cemetery, in his own yard, be enough to convict?? Along the way, we find out pierogis are best eaten...

Apr 03, 20252 hr 59 minEp. 585

#584 - Killer Homecoming King - Powell, Wyoming

This week, in Powell, Wyoming, a college girl's disappearance from a dorm party sends the whole town on a massive search. It's a mystery, until one particular student arrives at his dorm, covered in blood. His roommates decide to turn him in, but that's just the start. He lies about what happened, until confronted with the evidence. When a truly dark tale emerges, we find out about a very creepy past, making it obvious, he was stopped before he could become a serial killer!! Along the way, we fi...

Mar 29, 20251 hr 12 minEp. 584

#583 - Charming Serial Killer - Kirkland, Washington

This week, in Kirkland, Washington, what first appears to be a simple, yet horrifying murder, turns into a serial killer, stalking the area, and leaving women posed in terrible & suggestive positions. This posing makes everyone sure that they're dealing with one killer. This killer is known as "charming & likable", with many friends, and even connections to the police. But he's also a ruthless murderer, who would never stop, unless he was caught!! Along the way, we find out that Costco's...

Mar 27, 20252 hr 57 minEp. 583

#582 - Seven Murders & One Lie - Elkland, Missouri

This week, in Elkland, Missouri, when seven family members are brutally murdered, in two different homes, the lone survivor tells a tale of killing the murderer, after being wounded by him. The killer looks to be a teenager, who just snapped, due to too much responsibility for the family farm. But nothing turns out to be anything like it seems. The truth turns out to be a much more disturbing story, that leaves everyone in complete shock!! Along the way, we find out that we don't don't know anyt...

Mar 22, 20251 hr 13 minEp. 582

#581 - Sexy Sunday School Teacher Slaughter - Enid, Oklahoma

This week, in Enid, Oklahoma, when a very upstanding couple is attacked, it leaves the husband dead, and the wife with a bullet wound. The problem is, nothing is as it seems. This nice, Sunday school teaching couple has also had some problems, mainly that this injured wife has been having affairs with seemingly everyone they know. Including a fellow Sunday school teacher, who looks extremely guilty. But was she in on it?? Along the way, we find out how food trucks originally started, that no mat...

Mar 20, 20252 hr 59 minEp. 581

#580 - Beauty Shop Butcher - Roebuck, South Carolina

This week, in Roebuck, South Carolina, police are called to beauty salon, to find the owner, horribly attacked & murdered, hanging from a duffle bag strap. There are several suspects, including her husband, a prisoner who confessed, and a young man, who told everyone that he wanted to date the dead woman. Even with DNA, it's a mystery, until a chance meeting causes a witness to come forward, unraveling the killer's whole world. Was this the only time he's killed? Along the way, we find out t...

Mar 15, 20251 hr 12 minEp. 580

#579 - Millions To Murder - Sunnyside, California

This week, in Sunnyside, California, a slaughter of three people, in an upscale suburban home, makes the area fear for their lives, but this turns out to be anything but random. It's actually a very calculated plan, concocted by a young man who idolized jailed stock swindlers, and murderous members of "The Billionaire Boys Club". This ruthless act allows him access to millions of dollars, and spend cash like the Menendez brothers!! Will he ever pay?? Along the way, we find out Ludacris is inesca...

Mar 13, 20252 hr 57 minEp. 579

#578 - Video Poker Playboy Murder - Lake Charles, Louisiana

This week, in Lake Charles, Louisiana, there seems to be multiple people with motives for murder, when a brutally murdered man is found, on a dirt road, seemingly murdered while changing a tire. His wife & her best friend are suspects, along with the woman he's having an affair with & that woman's husband, and possibly a few others. Will cell tower data, and some statements to detectives that don't quite add up, convict someone for murder?? Did the right people even get arrested? Along t...

Mar 08, 20251 hr 12 minEp. 578
Hosted on Libsyn
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android