FRIDAY DRINKS: A BNPL Regulation Conversation - podcast episode cover

FRIDAY DRINKS: A BNPL Regulation Conversation

Jul 14, 202235 min
--:--
--:--
Listen in podcast apps:
Metacast
Spotify
Youtube
RSS

Episode description

Happy Friday! Kick back with the ladies as we wrap the week, celebrate some excellent money wins, and chat about the latest news from over the ditch in New Zealand that Afterpay is now available on alcohol sales. Strap in for a regulation conversation between the gals! Plus we answer a Money Dilemma about how to get over trauma post bankruptcy.

If you or anyone you know needs support, here are some places than can help...

Beyond Blue

The National Debt Helpline online or phone: 1800 007 007

Acknowledgement of Country By Natarsha Bamblett aka Queen Acknowledgements.

The advice shared on She’s on The Money is general in nature and does not consider your individual circumstances. She’s on The Money exists purely for educational purposes and should not be relied upon to make an investment or financial decision. Victoria Devine and She's On The Money are Authorised Representatives of Infocus Securities Australia Proprietary Limited ABN 47 097 797 049 AFSL - AFSL 236523.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcript

Speaker 1

Hello, my name's Santasha Nabananga Bamblet. I'm a proud yr the Order Kerni Whoalbury and a waddery woman. And before we get started on She's on the Money podcast, I would like to acknowledge the traditional custodians of the land of which this podcast is recorded on a wondery country, acknowledging the elders, the ancestors and the next generation coming through.

As this podcast is about connecting, empowering, knowledge sharing and the storytelling of you to make a difference for today and lasting impact for tomorrow.

Speaker 2

Let's get into it.

Speaker 3

She's on the Money, She's on the Money.

Speaker 2

Hello and welcome to She's on the Money, the podcast for millennials who want financial freedom. Today is Friday, which means it is time to sit back with our friends with a bevy in hand, to unpack our favorite moments of the week, and of course to celebrate you ow incredible.

She's on the Money community. As always, we're going to be sharing our favorite money weeds, We're going to discuss what's making news in the finance world, and we're going to help to answer a very juicy money question, which this week is all about bankruptcy and money trauma. But first it is time to recap the week that was. Missus Jesse Goiucci talk us through Monday's Money Diary episode.

Speaker 4

So Monday's diarist was Uber hardworking t out she was an Uber driver, which I found really interesting because I think I said when we were on the call V, I don't think I have ever had an Uber driver?

Speaker 2

How you did? You did? Actually, since you recorded that episode, we flew to Sydney and on the drive from the hotel to the airport to come home, what did we have? Jess a female driver, and I'm pretty sure I said to her, you're my first. I was like, Jess, check this out. This is so aligned to our content this week. We have to mention it. We didn't mention it to her because we're kind of like awkwardly sitting in the back pig like, do well this is cool or not?

Speaker 4

Yeah, But it was really interesting to talk to her about what it kind of looks like because I have caught many an Uber, but I've never really thought about I guess what it's like on the other side in terms of, you know, how do you pick and choose? Do you actually make good money or is it one of those things where it's actually not that worth it.

Speaker 2

I hear mixed bag stories right where people like it's not worth it, rah rah. But then you actually looked at that money, dar and I was like, oh, sis is making them? Yeah, it seems pretty lucrative.

Speaker 4

And we picked her brain around the safety as a female as well, which is something that's very front of mind for me just as an anxious woman in general. So it was really interesting to get her perspective on that and while worth listen, I loved it.

Speaker 2

I felt like it was an uber good episode. Jessicricci Again, let's move on Georgia kid Dandy, feeling good Dandy. I always like asking you how you are because you've always got a creative response. YE was like, Jess, how are you? You'd be like good, not bad. I saw a TikTok the other day. Actually that was like Australians never say how they feel. Like if you ask them how they are, you'd be like, oh, not bad. And you have to like fill in the blanks, like why can't you just

say you are well? You have to just say, oh, I'm not bad? How far is it not far? Like come on, I'm like, we never tell you the direct answer, We just tell you what it's not.

Speaker 3

That is true, that's true. Well I'm dandy so can confirm that. But on Tuesday this week bit of a twist, a little surprise Tuesday, we just could.

Speaker 2

Not wait to get that episode in your ears. And by that, I mean I clicked Tuesday instead of Wednesday when uploading the episode. Sorry, not sorry, Let's call it a very.

Speaker 3

Cute mistakey accident. We spoke all about travel insurance, which was it's top of mind for a lot of people because everyone is on the mouth you coast right now, how is this I mean much you just got back from you.

Speaker 2

But we won't on their mouth coat. No, And I feel like every man in his influence that is over there at the moment, really are I just I'm envious. They're sipping apparole, they're going on boats, they're going around the como l like, can you stop.

Speaker 4

I've got to go to work, and hopefully they're insuring themselves as well.

Speaker 3

Exactly right, Well, what we learned in the episode is that the most important thing to ensure is actually yourself. So we want comprehensive insurance, ladies, If you want to know more about that. If you do have travel plans lined up, then it's definitely the episode for you.

Speaker 2

But TLDRG, the most important thing to ensure it is actually yourself. It's not your camera or your phone or your assets. It's actually about making sure that you're safe and secure. So if you can't be bothered listening to it, kind of want to spoil it for you, because I think it is so genuinely important and it still baffles me to this day that so many people be like, it doesn't really matter. I don't want to waste my

money on insurance. And literally, Jess, when we went overseas, I was like, oh, book it for us, We'll work it out later because I just want to make sure you not only have good insurance, but I know it went through. I was crazy about it. But in what else is karazy g King on tour segue to the money wins? All right, Georgia King, what have you got for us this week? For our budget direct money wins? They were absolutely I want to say thump and they

were really really good this week. So who thinks that who reads our money diary's theread and goes this is thumping?

Speaker 3

I don't know what I meant to say, but anyway, here we are. There's eight of them, so brace yourselves.

Speaker 1

Yeah.

Speaker 3

First one for the day comes from Kimberly money Win. My small business is finally thriving and doing the best it's ever.

Speaker 2

Done, crying emojis status.

Speaker 3

The next one comes from Sarah. My home insurance is currently due for renewal. I shopped around and completed quotes with a few different insurers online, as I do each.

Speaker 2

And every year, water Queen, so smart.

Speaker 3

But I couldn't find any cheaper than my renewal amount, so I phoned the existing insurer and asked for a discount. They knocked one hundred and forty dollars off the annual premium.

Speaker 2

Money Win. That is a very good call to make. But also you could just see that call as you making one hundred and forty bucks exactly, Jesse. If I gave you one hundred and forty bucks to make a phone call, would you do it? Absolutely? But when all the time for true, it's true, George. I actually made her call my gym one time because I was too scared to cancel my membership. I can remember this. Yeah, I feel like it was an ordeal because it was a nightmare to get out of. There was like forms

and we had to go in. I just I'm traumatized. Shit done, She does alrighty. The next week comes from Tory.

Speaker 3

Money you win. My partner and I booked our first holiday together in over five years yesterday, and I had budgeted for it, so it didn't feel like it was setting me back or that I was taking it from somewhere that I shouldn't be such a nice feeling. Well done to you, Tory. Make sure you get travel insurance.

Speaker 2

Make sure you get travel insurance, and also how much of a better holiday you're going to have now you're not stressed about money on exactly and like saving up for.

Speaker 3

It instead of after paying you.

Speaker 2

I love the Late Queens.

Speaker 3

Yes, exactly right. The next week it comes from Tathy. This one's a bit a PSA which I saw you commented on in the group, Jess, so.

Speaker 2

It must be good getting involved. This stuff is good.

Speaker 3

It comes from Kathy. I read about the Medibank Private Live Better app in this group a year or so ago, and I downloaded it. You earn points through logging any health and well being activities you've participated in.

Speaker 2

Each day.

Speaker 3

You can then sink your fitness trackers to it. You earn points that can then be swapped for rewards like added as vouchers, AirPods, smart watches, and so on. Then a few months ago I had enough points to replace my fitbit that had died, and I now have enough points to claim a two hundred dollars payment towards health insurance premiums. Yes, probably pase this, bloody brother.

Speaker 2

I feel like it sounds a little bit like my AIA Vitality membership which I've mentioned before, which comes with my insurance. Because if I make enough steps and I do the health checks and all of the stuff in the app on there, I mean, I could get into it, but there's a lot to it. You actually get a

discount on your insurance. So like I'm always trying to make sure that I make my steps and I'm healthy and I do my optical check every year and do all of my stuff because you get different amounts of points for different activities that you do that will contribute towards your health. And I think it just makes sense.

Like these health insurance companies, you're like, this is some money win, this makes sense, but it's a win for them as well, because if they've got healthier customers, the likelihood of you actually claiming on insurance is lower, so you're less likely to be sick, but you're also saving money. Like it's a winner for everybody. It is much genius.

Speaker 3

From that remarkable high, I'm now going to take us through some money losses. But's I thank you all made me laugh, so prauss yourselves. The first one comes from Lisa money loss. I went to see Frozen, the musical I'm issuing this weekend with my child. They asked for an O laugh plush, and I thought, why not? Seventy five dollars Later, I knew where I was moving forward. I will now be asking the cost of something before saying yes again seventy five dollars for a whole loss flush.

Speaker 2

You're kidding me, Okay, okay, out of contu. You're a kid in yourself, mate. Just and I went to Disneyland recently and I did buy an e or toy. How much that's it?

Speaker 3

You?

Speaker 2

I can't but it was probably very expensive and I gave it to my dog, So I just feel like that was the most expensive thing I've ever bought. Oh, bless okay.

Speaker 3

The next loss comes from Allie money loss. My partner got blind, drunk and got a taxi alone from Melbourne to Geelong Friday time. I don't think it's meant to be funny, like I'm so sorry, Ellie. That sucks, but we've also all been there.

Speaker 2

I hope he's part and not the shad.

Speaker 3

I had this.

Speaker 2

Idea, like, you both know Steve, my partner well, like I can imagine if he'd done something like that and turned up at home, he'd be like, I'm home. Aren't you excited?

Speaker 5

Did get me?

Speaker 2

He would be so stoked. I had mom early jess are you excited? No, no, I'm not good.

Speaker 3

And the next one comes from Angelica money Win. I scored two hundred dollars off my wedding reception dress, down from five hundred dollars, which is incredible money loss. As I was traveling to the dress shop, I ended up getting a speeding fine. So evens out, I am going to end it on an inspirational note today, ladies. It comes from Teagin money Win. I got a promotion at work, but the salary wasn't quite what I expected it to be. I thought about taking the easy option and just accepting

it and signing the paper. As it was already super excited to get the promotion. I decided to sleep on it and woke up the next morning and wrote a list of points as to why I was worth more. I went in feeling confident and stated the facts and then gave them my number. They rang me on Friday and said they were proud of me for going back and they've rounded the number up. Thank you. She's on the money for giving me the skills to achieve this.

Speaker 2

What a good place to leave it. I love that, Georgia. I thought you were taking a few liberties going I've got eight this week. I was like, oh do you? But all of those absolutely made the cut. It has been great, gee celebrating some of your budget Direct money wins Budget Direct winner of Canstar's Insurer of the Year Award twenty twenty two. Budget Direct Insurance solved with that, my friends, let's go to a quick break and then we're going to dive straight into some very juicy money topics.

All right, let's dive straight back in, miss Jessica. She I believe you have a piece of content you would like to discuss with the group.

Speaker 4

Of course, now don't turn off when I say this word after pay, I.

Speaker 2

Don't turn off. Georgia gets through spicy, she gets through heated. She's literally just like stood up. I'm ready.

Speaker 4

I know we talked about out to pay a lot, but we got reasons so Eddy dms because over the weekend. This is in Auckland, New Zealand. But I wouldn't be surprised if they tried to roll it out here as well. A bottleo rolled out after pay in their store, which means that obviously you can break down your payment of alcohol into full for.

Speaker 2

Yeah, a kind of them.

Speaker 4

Been a lot of criticism around this, beyond what we normally talk about, and I thought it was a very interesting conversation because alcohol is obviously a control old substance, there's an addictive substance, and in Australia, and I know we talking about New Zealand, but there's definitely a history of culture relating to bad habits when it comes to over consumption of alcohol. And the criticism that we're seeing is people saying this shop shouldn't do it. It's so unethical.

If people can't afford a drink, they shouldn't buy a drink. This is going to enable people who arguably maybe are in a bit of a bad place to purchase more than they would normally be able to because they can afford more. And the debate it kind of sparked was really interesting because I think it comes down to, ethically, is the responsibility on the store owner? So let's say it's a small business, because it didn't roll out in like a Dan Movies, I think it was an independent

Is it the store owner's job to regulate that? Is it our job as consumers to keep an eye on what we're doing, or more broadly, should the government be stepping in and keeping an eye on these things? Where does that responsibility lie? Because at the moment, it really seems like everyone's kind of going, not my problem, not my circle's, not my monkey's, and nothing's being done, and these policies or these steps are being put in place that really, in my opinion, kind of pushed the boundaries

of what is and isn't okay. But that's also totally a personal perception thing, and so I wanted to see what you guys kind of thought about it.

Speaker 2

Well, given I'm basically best friends with Jacinda Arjurn, let me for her. At our next meeting, I'll just bring it up and be like, hey, could you fix this, and she'll be like, no problems, babe, got you, and we'll organize it all. But I think from my perspective again, I'm obviously not that stoked with it, But if we compare it to other industries. We were talking and it

hasn't come out yet, it'll come out next week. We have a money diary with a woman who is a sex worker, and she was saying that payment terminals often kick sex workers off those terminals because they think that they're generating money that is maybe not as klosher as it could be, and they see that as a high risk industry, so they say no, thank you. So it's

the platform taking the responsibility. And then also looking at the way Australia governs financial advisors and accountants and you know, financial platforms, it's actually very different to the way it is managed around the world. So Jess, you and I are actually going to a conference in September in the US. It's a finance conference so that we can learn about how other people are producing money content internationally, and we are so genuinely excited. Actually low key, I'm speaking at

the event. I am stoked. But in America, the onners is put on the consumer and they say the consumer has to go do their own research and make the decision that's right for them. In Australia the opposite is true, and you're seeing this a lot at the moment in the media with financial advisors being come down on like a town of bricks when it comes to acid regulations and finfluences, you know, coppying a lot of heat at

the moment for the content they produce. Because in Australia, the onners is put on the content creator, or the onners is put on the business. So if you then apply this to this particular situation, I look at it and I go, yeah, it's in New Zealand. There are friends across the ditch. Yes, they're not governed by the

same rules and regulations here in a Australia. But from my perspective as an Australian, I would then assume that the onus is on after pay to regulate that and not allow things like alcohol or tobacco or gambling on

their platforms because it's not an essential item. I think you guys and I sit in a very privileged position where we get to look at after pay as something that is, you know, the big bad wolf, and we do need to look at it from a little bit more of a less entitled view and go, gin, know what, there are people out there that need this to get by.

It's something that they're using that is enabling them to have a good lifestyle or change their lives in a way that they weren't able to before, whether that's because they can't access credit or they have you know, we've heard stories in our community, people like the I use after pay all the time because I only have sentling and I just need to get through the next pay, and you know, I'm really responsible with it, but I might be buying Christmas presents where I might be buying

things that my kid needs for school, or more recently, I've spoken to people and they're like, the it's so good. I know that you don't like after pay, but I've been paying for doctors of moments on that that otherwise I would have been really stressed about that my kid needed. And I go, wow, like, there are some good reasons to use it, But then alcohol, to me, that's a luxury that's not something that is a necessity. It's something that can be used and abused, and it just is

not putting our community in the right position. And the messages I'm getting a test to that, like they genuinely break my heart. It's making me go, oh, I wish I could do more, but what can you do? This isn't even happening in our country.

Speaker 3

Well, a lot of the people that are going to be using after pay in bottle shops if this does become a thing across the board and infiltrates into the Australian marketplace as well. They're people that can't afford alcohol from where they're at currently. They're in these bad, bad positions and it's really exploiting extremely vulnerable people. That's why I don't like after pay full stop. But to move into this alcohol space is just makes me very mad. We saw it maybe like six months ago, maybe a

little bit longer. You can now like after pay your cocktails.

Speaker 2

Yeah, and it's not just to pay right, like we highlighted on our She's on the Money stories, payoh, which is a company that purely exists for bars, restaurants and food providing services. And I was just like, what there's a food specific buy now, pay later, Like where's the line,

Like how does that work? And I think my biggest gripe with it is that it's just not regulated in the same way credit would be, because a lot of people are gonna jump up and down and be like, Victoria, you can go and put a bottle of vodka on your credit card tomorrow. Yeah, but like there's checks in

place for you to be able to do that. They've checked your financial history, they've checked your serviceability, they've checked whether you can repay that loan, because that's basically what it is, whereas those same restrictions don't apply to after pay, So to me, it's a really slippery slope.

Speaker 3

So yes, obviously my disdain for after pay is very You had it for just a little bit of disdain, but I wanted to play the devil's advocate here, ladies, because we, as we've said on the podcast, are heading into a recession.

Speaker 2

Things. Don't get that word around here. We are having a good data now, but things are really really tough.

Speaker 3

The cost of living is ridiculous right now, and small businesses are facing that crisis as well. So we know that after pay is really good for small business. So how do they kind of balance that ethical dilemma of wanting to use after pay to attract more consumers and customers while also dealing with the ethical ambiguity of offering a service that might put customers in a precarious situation.

Speaker 2

It's such a hard position because you look at it and you go pragmatically. After pay makes a lot of sense for small business. Statistically, Gee, the stats on the after pay website say the average Australian small business merchant sees are thirteen percent uppleiest in rev you by partnering with after pay, which equates to around thirty two thousand

dollars in new revenue annually. Like, if I was a small business and it doesn't matter what I was selling, if I was selling candles or stationery, or if I had a bikini business, like, I would look at it and go well, from my perspective, I just want to sell my product and get my product on more people's shelves. And a good way to do that is to increase

the ways people can pay. And you know, if I'm selling candles and I go oha, my candles are only like thirty dollars each or fifty dollars each or whatever inflation has made them these days. What is my responsibility? Like should I stop Jess from paying for one of my candles because she really wants it in four separate payments? Like Jess is a very I'm using you as an example, my friend, But Jess is a really financially conscious person.

I know what your savings habits are, and I know that if you used a platform like after pay, you would probably be using it because you're cash flowing or you're like, oh well, I gave myself this budget and cashlow plan and I only have this amount to spend per week, so I'm going to take it out of

my cash flow plan for the next four weeks. This makes sense, and you can use it really constructively and for the people that just want to use it as a cash flow tool, like are you taking something away from them by worrying about the people that aren't as responsible? And how responsible are you for people's actions? Like obviously, I care so much about our community and want them to be in the best possible position, so I jump

up and down about it. But Georgia, how much of a responsibility is it on you to manage your friends' finances or the decisions they make if they're a grown adult.

Speaker 3

Yeah, it's such a hard one because it does it comes down to the individual. But what's missing in that piece is the education. And we're doing our best atchoes on the money to explain the details of all of this, and you know, Piers through the marketing that is really confusing and makes us feel like things are okay when they're really not. So I don't know who's responsibilities. It's really really hard.

Speaker 2

It is right because it's like I feel like it's my responsibility as a financial advisor to education you guys. But I also say often like I don't care what you do with your money as long as you're educated and you know that the decisions you are making are the right ones for you. I really want to be able to put the onus back on you and say, well, gee, if you go and make that decision, that's on you, Like, I'm not going to judge that situation. That's not my position.

If we took this and put it in any other stream of life, whether that's sex or religion, money is that other spicy topic that people don't like talking about. How much do I have to control over your religion, or your sex life or any of that. Why should I then have a say over you know, my client's financial life. Do you know what I mean? Like, unless you've come to me as an advisor and said I want financial advice from you, Victoria, I don't think it's

any of my business to dish out advice. This podcast is educational because I want you to want to educate yourself, but if you're listening to it, it's because you want that already, right, Like, yeah, it's about where the onus is, but it's also about when do you expect the government to step in? And if this word happened in Australia, which it basically has already with buy now, pay later platforms like Payoh, where's the line where does the government

step in and say, you know what? We know that the Australian population does not have good financial literacy, so therefore there needs to be a few steps here to put them in the best possible position. Whereas if they could be like oh no, like financial literacy is a core pillar of our education system and they've been doing it since prep. They know, well, that might be a different story. But till then, I think that there needs to be a bigger governing body that makes sure that

we are in the best possible position. In the same way that the government has restricted the sale of tobacco and have restricted the sale of alcohol to people under the age of eighteen, and like they've made all these other rules to protect us, why is this not an extension of that?

Speaker 4

And I think because we're treading unprecedented waters here with you know, I think businesses like after pay and buying our pay lader platforms in general are really pushing and testing the boundaries to see what they can and can't get away with, and they, you know, would have really big teams in the background working to find how they can be compliant in the most bendy way possible for them.

I'm a big believer in the power of the people, and what I would say to all of our friends in New Zealand and all of our friends in Australia, should we, you know, come to this point make a report.

Speaker 2

In New Zealand.

Speaker 4

The Commerce Commission which is ComCom dot Govte dot NZ. They're the regulating body here in Australia. It's consumer Affairs and one of their dot points on their website it says that their role is to regulate credit contracts and Consumer Finance Act, which protects consumers when they borrow money

or buy goods on credit. And so while it's not a direct line of credit, they're definitely borrowing money to gen and that I would suggest, if you feel the same way that we do, send them a nice email. There's a big red button that says make it very same. They make it really easy and say to them, hey, I'm really concerned about the direction this is going. This seems really unethical, and I think it's something you should look into because if enough people start making that complaint,

it will trigger an investigation. And that's all you can really do is try to facilitate change. But it requires people to take that little step and do something about it. So that's what I would personally suggest, because I do think that right now these platforms are kind of seeing what they can get away with, and it's up to us as a community and just as human beings to say, actually, it's not good enough, yeah, and to talk to.

Speaker 3

Each other about it as well. If you have mates that you know use after pay and would be tempted by something like this, if you are in New zealand talk to them about it, help them out with that education. If they're not share these.

Speaker 2

Podcasts with them exactly, if you don't even have to sit them down and be like, okay, Georgia, I was thinking, you need to Xpyz. You can bring finance topics up in really non confrontational ways where you put the onus back on you, and you'd be like, oh my gosh, I was listening to this great podcast the other day and they were saying x y Z Jess. If you haven't le to it, I'll send you the link, because honestly,

it made me really think. And you just don't have to say, oh my gosh, yes, So I noticed you use after pain, and I just don't think that's a good thing. Like it's not your job to tell people what to do with their money, but I think it's everybody's job to increase the level of financial literacy we have.

And once we get to a point where I genuinely feel like our community is financially literate, I'll probably not be as vocal on these platforms because I'll be like cool, like they exist, but I know people use them responsibly, like and I know that people understand the repercussions of their decisions. And I know that people are in a pretty good position because they've you know, structured things right,

But we can't genuinely say that. And I think that that's why we're so uncomfortable, because we're looking at it going. There are so many people that are gonna, you know, end up in compromising positions because of this, because they just don't know any better. And I mean, that's a really beautiful thing that we care. But you also have to go how much of this is our responsibility, how much of it is the responsibility of the government, and how much is a product responsibility?

Speaker 3

Lots to think about, ladies, But I reckon it's probably time for a little money dilemma.

Speaker 2

If we're interested, Oh would love that.

Speaker 3

That's how to listen, Hi, Beert, have you got a money dilemma you just can't solve that. She's on The Money Team is here to help. Every week we tackle your dilemmas, both big and small, to answer your most burning money, career and life questions. To get involved, simply head to our website and leave us a quick voice recording and you may just find yourself on the show. Now, let's take a listen to today's money dilemma.

Speaker 6

My husband and I had to start over again after being bankrupt from our business. We have done an amazing job saving We got a twenty percent deposit together, purchased.

Speaker 5

A block of land and in our building. However, I am petrified of having not so much money in the account I just keep thinking back to when we had nothing. We've worked so hard and I know we have money in the accounts and we are quite stable, but I have a massive fear of looking at the bank accounts and I just don't know what to go, where to go from here? We have no other debts apart from a home loan. Please help me.

Speaker 2

I really feel for her.

Speaker 4

She sounds like genuinely stressed, Like that's my first thought, Like off the back of.

Speaker 2

That, yeah, actually I don't. That tone of voice was, SI, oh, I'm not in a good place with this.

Speaker 4

I totally get being stressed out. I think like I've obviously never been through bankruptcy myself. But we did a really good episode actually on it a couple months ago. But I would highly recommend it because we spoke a lot about the stigma and how it can actually be a really positive choice for somebody if you're making it and it's the right decision for you, which I think is a great thing. But I can totally understand how going through something like that could really bring out a

lot of anxiety. And we refer to earlier as a little bit of trauma, you know, that real stress around Oh my gosh, Like I don't want to find myself back in that position where things are so difficult and I'm making these really hard choices do impact my future and do impact my ability to borrow money. I'm sure that they would have had to jump through some hoops to get this mortgage that they've got, which is very exciting. Congratulations, Yeah, super exciting. But I can totally see how that would

be really anxiety inducing. And I think that it's probably a little bit bigger than you know, normally we'd say, hey, look at your.

Speaker 2

Cash flow system. It's not that at all.

Speaker 1

Is that.

Speaker 4

I think it's a much bigger issue, and V, I'd love to know what you suggest she kind of do to help deal with those feelings.

Speaker 2

I think the first thing that I would say here is you are validated in your feelings, and even though quote you're better, that doesn't mean that there's not trauma there. And I think validating that financial trauma exists is really important because it's scientifically proven that you can be traumatized from your financial situation. Bankruptcy includes so much more than like, oh, Jess, you had to file for bankruptcy and you skip down the lane and you're in a better position to hurry,

you'll be able to get a mortgage later. Like, there's so much stress and energy during that process that actually needs working through. So in this circumstance, I would recommend, and this is not just a bankruptcy, if you've been through any type of traumatic event, financial or otherwise, I

would seek therapy. And I would be going to talk to a professional counselor or psychologist, or I'd be going to talk to my GP asking for a mental health care plan and just saying, look, I need to work through these things because anxiety is real and we need to find ways to not only cope with that, but really understand the root cause. And you still feeling anxious about money even though you're quote in a better position, is an indicator that you are not fully across, that

you're not over that line. We're not over that at all and you actually need to delve deeper into that. I do find this to be very common in people who experience bankruptcy or go through a similar process, because you end up wanting to stick your head in the sand, Like bills make you so anxious and you don't want to open another one because what if it's a bill that is not expected? What if it's a fohone bill

that's above and beyond what you had anticipated. What if it's the mortgage company calling you and saying, well, actually you accidentally paid your mortgage into the wrong account and you're now behind three months. Like I'm not saying that those things are true, but when you're anxious, you dramatize everything and you make everything seem much worse than it

actually is. And we need to work on that because as a fellow anxious person, that impacts your ability in your relationships, in your ability to derive an income, in your ability to you know, be physically healthy. Like, these things impact you so deeply. It's not funny. And I think that we don't really talk about and I don't think we've talked about financial trauma on the podcast before, but I pulled up a few stats about it for you, guys.

It has a definition. Financial trauma is a moment in someone's life where things changed and a belief and image about their relationship with money turns around in a negative way. So obviously that makes sense to me. But one thing that I thought was really interesting is I was reading an article on the Nation Child Traumatic Stress Network, which is an American website, but often when it comes to finances, America is actually a lot more progressive when talking about

things like financial trauma. Australia I feel like it's genuinely ten years behind when it comes to finance content. But I found this article that said researchers have revealed that socioeconomic status can be linked to a majority of anxiety disorders, which later can manifest into PTSD, which is post traumatic

stress disorder. Food insecurity, financial worries, housing instability, along with living in vulnerable conditions can wear a one psyche like this is not just me going, oh my gosh, guys, get some help, like genuinely research that was done by the APS. So the Australian Psychological Society found that money

was the number one stressor for employed people. So it makes sense that we're all stressed about money, But I just don't think we give it enough credit to say that you can be traumatized from your personal financial situations,

like whether it is bankruptcy. And I guess that sits on one end of this spectrum with things like financial abuse and going through really dramatic situations all the way through to you know, the situation I was in where I had a personal loan and I just couldn't sleep at night and I was super stressed about being able

to pay it. So now whenever we talk about personal loans or you know, I'm talking about trying to afford things, like, I get that twang in the back of my head that makes me feel a little bit sick in my stomach because I go, oh, I don't want to be there, Like I just don't want to be in a compromising position. And even when we were in Europe recently, just so like I had that pit in my stomach, I was like,

am I reverting to old behaviors? Not because I was going into debt or using credit or doing anything that I don't want to do, but because I wasn't tracking my money as closely as I usually do. And for me, that's my safety net. Is always knowing in the back of my mind what I'm spending, what I'm saving, what that looked like for this week. And I remember there was one particular point I was like, I don't know

how much I've spent this week. This gives me anxiety, knowing full well I could afford it because I'd already budgeted for it and I knew what was going on, and like we had these budgeting spreadsheets, but I didn't know how that budgeting spreadhere sheet fit into my personal budget.

And I was like, oh, I feel a bit anxious, and I had to go away, and like I looked up my budget and looked at my bank accounts and made sure i was all comfy and all happy and I'm in the very privileged position where it was all fine. But like even me who's in a fine financial position now was a bit like, oh, that gave me the ick because I never talked about it, Like why would I talk about my personal owner paid it off?

Speaker 3

Yeah, yeah, that trauma kind of becomes a part of your money story.

Speaker 2

I guess, yeah, exactly, And I don't think we address it for what it actually is, and that that's trauma

and we need to get through that. So I guess, in a roundabout way of answering this question, our answer isn't like do your budget and do your cash flow, which we would recommend to absolutely anyone, But I think you need to have a chat with someone about this situation, about the experience you've been through, because it was genuinely traumatic and you're probably carrying a lot of the weight of that experience that you can probably let go of now.

Speaker 4

And if you are struggling with anything like that, we'll pop a link in the show notes to Beyond Blue. They're a really fantastic charity who do a lot of work in the mental health space, particularly around depression, anxiety and those kinds of things. They're not for profit and they do fantastic, fantastic work, So if you are struggling, please feel free to reach out to them.

Speaker 2

Yeah, and our friends at the National Debt Helpline. If you ever feel super stressed about money or you're in a bit of a pickle, please feel free to pick up the phone and have a chat to them. As we've said before, like it's free financial counseling and they will put you on track to be in the best possible position. But both of those resources, the resources that I would personally reach out to if I found that I was finding a little bit overwhelming.

Speaker 3

Perfect place to end it today, ladies, let's rip into the boring but important stuff.

Speaker 2

Oh, I can't wait.

Speaker 1

Gee.

Speaker 3

The advice chaired on She's on the Money is general in nature and does not consider your individual circumstances. She's on the Money exists purely for educational purposes and should not be relied upon to make an investment or a financial decision. And we promise Victoria divine and She's on the Money are authorized representatives in Focused Securities Australia Proprietary Limited ABN for seven zero nine seven seven nine seven zero or nine as two three six five two three.

See you on Monday, guys, See you next week, guys,

Transcript source: Provided by creator in RSS feed: download file
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android
Open in Metacast