Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast from Rotten Tomatoes) - podcast cover

Rotten Tomatoes Is Wrong (A Podcast from Rotten Tomatoes)

Rotten Tomatoes art19.com

Why do fans love some Rotten films and hate some Fresh ones? What did critics make of a cult classic before it earned its cult status? In this bi-weekly podcast, hosts Jacqueline Coley, Mark Ellis, and guests go deep and settle the score on some of the most beloved – and despised – movies and TV shows ever made, directly taking on the statement we hear from so many fans: “Rotten Tomatoes is wrong.”

Last refreshed:
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

136: After Dark #5: Our 25 Favorite Stoner Movies with Brian Perez

It's almost every stoner's favorite time of the year, 4/20, and what better way to celebrate than to talk about the movies that make us laugh, make us contemplate life, and most importantly, make us hungry? Today, producer Brian joins Mark and Jacqueline to discuss our 25 Favorite Stoner Movies and 20 Best Movies to Watch High according to Rotten Tomatoes. Do you agree with these lists? Do you feel like we left out any essential stoner classics? And what is your favorite movie to watch on 4/20? ...

Apr 13, 202345 minEp. 136

135: We're Wrong About... Super Mario Bros. (1993) with Andre Meadows

With 'The Super Mario Bros. Movie' heading to theaters, we look back at Nintendo's first attempt at bringing their iconic Mario to the big screen with 'Super Mario Bros.' from 1993. Host of 'Black Nerd Comedy' Andre Meadows joins Mark and Jacqueline in bringing his unrequited love for the original Mario brothers movie starring Bob Hoskins and John Leguizamo. While the critics and audience agree on a 29% Rotten score for the film, Andre believes the score should be much higher, mostly for how mem...

Apr 06, 202352 minEp. 135

134: After Dark #4: Celebrating RT25 with our Favorite Movies of 1998

To celebrate 25 years of Rotten Tomatoes, guests Clarke Wolfe and Winston A. Marshall join Mark in reminiscing about some of our favorite movies from 1998. From the comedy blockbuster 'Rush Hour' to the romantic drama 'Practical Magic,' we cover all that 1998 had to offer. Does anyone remember the Jonathan Taylor Thomas Christmas classic, 'I'll be Home from Christmas?' Winston sure does and has an amazing story about it. Check out all that and more all on today's 'After Dark' special episode! If...

Mar 30, 202347 minEp. 134

133: We're Wrong About... Keanu Reeves's Rotten Movies (The Replacements, Hardball, Knock Knock)

With the fourth installment of the 'John Wick' franchise heading to theaters tomorrow, we decided to take a look at some of our favorite Keanu Reeves films that didn't score so high on the Tomatometer. On today's show, special guests Clarke Wolfe and Winston A. Marshall join Mark to present a Keanu movie they would defend to eternity. In chronological order of release, Mark chose 'The Replacements' from 2000 and Winston chose 'Hardball' from 2001, which are both Rotten at 41% on the Tomatometer,...

Mar 23, 202358 minEp. 133

132: After Dark #3: Mark Stole Someone's Starbucks Order & The Impending Writer's Strike in Hollywood

On this next installment of the Rotten Tomatoes 'After Dark' series, Jacqueline and special guest Heather Grace Hancock give Mark grief for mistakenly taking someone else's Starbucks pickup order. Later in the show, all three discuss just how much they love being dog-owners even with all the stresses that come with owning a furry animal. And finally we give insight to the rumored writer's strike that's bound to shake up the entertainment industry. If you'd like to give your thoughts on this epis...

Mar 16, 202346 minEp. 132

131: We're Wrong About... I Know What You Did Last Summer with Heather Grace Hancock

While some may know screenwriter Kevin Williamson as the creator of the 'Scream' franchise, people might forget he wrote a little film called 'I Know What You Did Last Summer' that left teenagers afraid of hook-wielding madmen on the loose. Is 'I Know What You Did Last Summer' the Diet-Coke to 'Scream's' regular Coke? Or are there memorable moments and standout performances in this 1997 horror classic? Actor Heather Grace Hancock joins Mark and Jacqueline to discuss not only what they did last s...

Mar 09, 202347 minEp. 131

130: After Dark #2: 'The Last of Us' and Should Travis Kelce be People's Sexiest Man Alive?

On this next installment of the Rotten Tomatoes 'After Dark' series, Matt Knost joins Mark and Jacqueline to talk 'The Last of Us' that's currently streaming on HBOMax. Is it one of the best television series ever created? Will it sweep all the Emmys come awards season? And will Pedro Pascal be coined People's Sexiest Man Alive? That last question is up for debate as Jacqueline gives her take as to why the 'Sexiest Man' belongs to Kansas City Chief's Tight End Travis Kelce this year. Follow come...

Mar 02, 202341 minEp. 130

129: We're Wrong About... Rocky IV with Matt Knost

It's time to put on those boxing gloves and head to Russia to start training because this week on 'Rotten Tomatoes is Wrong,' we are talking about the 1985 classic 'Rocky IV,' starring Sylvester Stallone and Dolph Lundgren. Is this movie campy goodness, or is its 37% Rotten Tomatometer score accurate? Did Sylvester Stallone singlehandedly bring down Russian communism with his quintessential speech at the end of the film? Comedian and host of the podcast 'Settle the Score' Matt Knost joins Mark a...

Feb 23, 202354 minEp. 129

128: We're Wrong About... Wet Hot American Summer with Lon Harris

Hey all you campers and camp counselors! We’re going way back and taking a look at one of Ant-Man aka Paul Rudd’s earliest comedies, Wet Hot American Summer, which is currently Rotten at 38% on the Tomatometer. Is it a travesty that such a beloved cult classic is rated so low on the Tomatometer? Some of us think so, while others agree with its score. Writer and podcaster Lon Harris joins Mark and Jacqueline as they discuss whether Rotten Tomatoes is wrong about Wet Hot American Summer. If you'd ...

Feb 16, 202353 minEp. 128

127: We're Wrong About... The Cell with Daniella Pineda

We are jumping right back in to the dark recesses of Vincent D'onofrio's serial killer Carl Stargher's mind and talking about the psychological thriller 'The Cell' from 2000. Is this Jennifer Lopez and Vince Vaughn horror film, Rotten at 45% on the Tomatometer, a cult classic? Or is it a visual spectacle that's best left buried in our memory? Actress Daniella Pineda ('Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom,' 'Plane'), joins Mark and Jacqueline to discuss all this and more! If you'd like to give your tho...

Feb 09, 202352 minEp. 127

126: Special Episode: The Fan Favorite Golden Tomato Award Winners!

It's that time of year where the Golden Tomato Awards are given out to the best movies and television shows of 2022! On today's episode, we discuss the winners of the 'Fan Favorite' movies and TV series that were selected by you, the fans, at RottenTomatoes.com. Special guest Roxy Striar shares her opinion with Mark and Jacqueline on whether the fans got the best movies and TV shows of the year right or wrong, and boy does she have some choice words! Fan Favorite Movies 2022 : RRR Top Gun: Maver...

Feb 02, 202350 minEp. 126

125: We're Wrong About... The Last Airbender with Steph Sabraw

Superstar writer, director, and producer M. Night Shyamalan has been entertaining audiences for nearly three decades and with that comes mega-hits and huge misses. His new movie 'Knock at the Cabin' hits theaters in February and is already looking to crush it at the box office, so we decided to take a look back at his most ambitious film to date: 'The Last Airbender.' 'The Last Airbender' from 2010 is often cited as one of the worst movies of all time and has an abysmal 5% Rotten rating on the T...

Jan 26, 202352 minEp. 125

124: We're Wrong About... Angel Has Fallen with Candice Cruz

Everyman action star Gerard Butler's latest film 'Plane' has landed in theaters, so we decided to take a look at the third entry in his 'Has Fallen' franchise, 'Angel Has Fallen,' which is currently Rotten at 39% on the Tomatometer but boasts an astounding 93% Audience Score. What did general audiences see in this thriller that the critics didn't? Is it the best of the franchise? And are we excited for more Gerard Butler action to come? Actress and NBC LX entertainment expert Candice Cruz joins ...

Jan 19, 202351 minEp. 124

123: We're Wrong About... Bride of Chucky with Dorina Arellano

With the new killer doll horror movie M3GAN now playing in theaters, we look back at the cult classic Bride of Chucky which features arguably the most iconic killer doll of all time. Does Bride of Chucky deserve its criminally low score of 47% Rotten on the Tomatometer? Or were the critics right to bash this campy, self-aware product of the late ‘90s? Self-proclaimed Queen of Horror Dorina Arellano joins Mark and Jacqueline to discuss all this and more! If you'd like to give your thoughts on thi...

Jan 12, 202353 minEp. 123

122: We're Wrong About... Our Top 10 Movies of 2022 (Part 2)

Happy New Year from our team here at Rotten Tomatoes is Wrong ! As we get settled into 2023, we are still taking a look back at our favorite films of 2022. In the second part of this two-part series, Mark gives his top movie of 2022 as Jacqueline still evades the question. Now that we've revealed Mark and Jacqueline's complete lists, are there any movies that we may have missed or movies you don't agree should be on the list? Jacqueline's List: Triangle of Sadness NOPE The Woman King Everything ...

Jan 05, 202350 minEp. 122

121: We're Wrong About... Our Top 10 Movies of 2022 (Part 1)

As we wrap out the year, Mark and Jacqueline look back at some of their favorite movies of 2022. In this first part of a two-part episode, we cover the first 5 films from their lists in no specific order. Do you agree with these movies being some of the best of the year? If you don't hear your favorite movie in this episode, check back next week to see if it made the list! Jacqueline's List: Bones and All Devotion The Inspection Good Luck to You, Leo Grande Black Panther: Wakanda Forever Mark's ...

Dec 29, 202250 minEp. 121

REPLAY: We're Wrong About... The Holiday (With Special Guest Billie Piper)

Original Airdate: 08/26/2021 Special guest and Rare Beasts writer-director Billie Piper takes on the Grinches who called Nancy Meyers' modern yuletide classic an over-egged, rotten Christmas mess. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info .

Dec 22, 20221 hr 1 min

REPLAY: We're Wrong About... How the Grinch Stole Christmas (Movie Review)

Original Airdate: 12/24/2020 Charming as an eel or just the thing to grow your heart a few sizes every holiday season? We're tackling Ron Howard's garish – or utterly charming? – take on Dr. Seuss in our latest podcast episode. If you'd like to give your thoughts on this movie or have another movie you feel like Rotten Tomatoes got wrong, email us at RTisWrong@RottenTomatoes.com . See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-se...

Dec 15, 20221 hr 3 min

REPLAY: We're Wrong About... Love Actually (Movie Review)

Original Airdate: 12/17/2020 To many, it is perfect; to others, problematic. But is this ensemble Christmas rom-com deserving of the yearly tar-and-feathering it gets from its haters? We're breaking it down in our latest podcast. If you'd like to give your thoughts on this movie or have another movie you feel like Rotten Tomatoes got wrong, email us at RTisWrong@RottenTomatoes.com . See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-...

Dec 08, 20221 hr 11 min

120: Rotten Tomatoes... After Dark #1 (Special Episode)

It's after dark here at Rotten Tomatoes and that means our hosts Mark Ellis and Jacqueline Coley get to let their hair down, open a bottle of wine (metaphorically speaking), and talk about what's been on their minds since they started this podcast over 100 episodes ago. In this episode, we'll get to know our hosts a little more as we've removed the confines of a script or any sort of structure. Did you know Mark does stand-up all across this great country? And that Jacqueline is secretly a "fash...

Dec 01, 202254 minEp. 120

119: We're Wrong About... Hook with Brett Sheridan

With Steven Spielberg's Oscar-frontrunner The Fabelmans releasing into theaters, we decided to take a look back at one of the only three Rotten films he's ever directed; his very Rotten 1991 film Hook ! With an all-star cast that includes the likes of Robin Williams, Dustin Hoffman, Julia Roberts, Maggie Smith, and many more, how can this film be rated so low on the Tomatometer? Comedian and actor Brett Sheridan joins us today to find out! Is Hook really an underrated gem filled with magic and w...

Nov 24, 202253 minEp. 119

118: We're Wrong About... Goodfellas vs. Casino with Scott Mantz

It's legendary filmmaker Martin Scorsese's 80th birthday this week so we decided to pit two of his iconic mob movies together to find out which one reigns supreme. Is 1990's Goodfellas , Certified Fresh at 96% on the Tomatometer, actually better than Casino from 1995, which is Certified Fresh at only 79%? Esteemed film critic and host Scott Mantz joins us to discuss these two groundbreaking films as well as break down all of Scorsese's filmography on today's show! If you'd like to give your thou...

Nov 17, 202253 minEp. 118

117: We're Wrong About... Jingle All the Way with Brian Perez

Christmas season is right around the corner and that means holiday shopping is in full effect! What better way to celebrate the mayhem that is Black Friday than to talk about Arnold Schwarzenegger's chaotic adventure to find his son a Turbo Man doll in the holiday classic Jingle All the Way ! While co-host Jacquline Coley has some thoughts on Jingle All the Way , Producer Brian Perez joins us to defend this movie and explain why Rotten Tomatoes is wrong about its 19% on the Tomatometer . Is Jing...

Nov 10, 202250 minEp. 117

116: We're Wrong About... Step Brothers (Movie Discussion)

Comedian extraordinaire Hal Rudnick joins Mark Ellis and Jacqueline Coley to talk about the 2008 smash hit comedy Step Brothers ! This movie has the honor of gracing the cover of Rotten Tomatoes’ own book, Rotten Movies We Love , and our panel is here to spread all their love for this hilarious comedy. Should Step Brothers be fresh on the Tomatometer? Do raunchy comedies not get the respect they deserve with critics and audiences alike? What is the all-time greatest scene that still keeps us cra...

Nov 03, 202252 minEp. 116

115: We're Wrong About... The 10 Scariest Horror Movies Ever (Movie Discussion)

Writer and actress Dani Fernandez is in studio with Mark Ellis and Jacqueline Coley discussing whether the Rotten Tomatoes user-generated list of the 10 Scariest Horror Movies Ever lives up to its name! Are "iconic" horror movies like The Exorcist from 1973 necessarily the scariest? Or do we have modern horror movies that absolutely deliver on the chills? What are some of the scariest scenes of all time that keep us up at night? The panel answers all these questions and more! If you'd like to gi...

Oct 27, 202255 minEp. 115

114: We're Wrong About... Event Horizon (Movie Discussion)

Continuing on with our Spooky Season theme, horror aficionado and podcaster Claire Lim joins Mark Ellis to talk about why "Event Horizon" is such a beloved cult classic. Does "Event Horizon" deserve its awfully low Tomatometer score? Or do its haunting imagery and incredible performances make it one of the most terrifying movies of our generation? Mark and Claire answer all these questions in this epic lovefest for "Event Horizon." If you'd like to give your thoughts on this list or have another...

Oct 20, 202252 minEp. 114

113: We're Wrong About... The Nightmare on Elm Street Franchise (Movie Discussion)

It's the middle of Spooky Season and we have Nightmare on Elm Street superfan and writer/director Christian Ruvalcaba joining Mark Ellis and Jacqueline Coley to discuss whether the ranking of the classic horror franchise is accurate or not. Should "Wes Craven's New Nightmare" be higher than the original film or is "A Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors" the best entry? And was the Tomatometer a little too harsh on the epic matchup of "Freddy vs. Jason?" The panel answers all these question...

Oct 13, 202253 minEp. 113

112: We're Wrong About... Guillermo del Toro’s Top Ten Films (Movie Discussion)

Self-proclaimed "Queen of Darkness" and 1/3 of "The Whirl Girls" Dorina Arellano joins Mark Ellis this week discuss Guillermo del Toro's Top Ten Movies as ranked by the Tomatometer in preparation for his series "Guillermo del Toro's Cabinet of Curiosities!" Should Guillermo's 2006 movie "Pan's Labyrinth" be No. 1 and "The Devil's Backbone" from 2001 be second on the list? Should "Blade II" from 2002 crack his top 10, and if so, which movie would you swap it out with? Dorina and Mark answer all t...

Oct 06, 202253 minEp. 112

111: We're Wrong About... The Mighty Ducks Trilogy (Movie Review)

What's the best Mighty Ducks movie out of the trilogy and how are these beloved '90s films all rotten? Winston A. Marshall joins Mark Ellis this week to answer these questions and share his love for the franchise, Gordon Bombay, and the Bash Brothers! See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info .

Sep 29, 202250 minEp. 111

110: We're Wrong About... The Back to the Future Trilogy (With Special Guest Topher Grace)

Award-winning actor Topher Grace ( Spider-Man 3 , That 70's Show ) joins Mark Ellis this week to chat his love of "Back to the Future" and its sequels, how they rank for him, why the first in the trilogy may be the best film ever made and gives us a spot-on Marty McFly impersonation you don't want to miss. Topher is currently the star and executive producer of ABC's "Home Economics", now in its 3rd season, and you can check out his podcast "Minor Adventures with Topher Grace" that sees him takin...

Sep 22, 202259 minEp. 110
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android