Book 1 - 08: The Potions Master & The Tempest (Act V, Scene I)

We're reading Chapter Eight, The Potions Master this week and thinking about the themes addressed in Prospero's speech in Act V, Scene I of William Shakespeare's "The Tempest". Honestly, this episode could also be known as "A Study in Snape", as we attempt a thorough analysis of his character. We discuss Snape's great ambition and unfulfilled potential. We pose the question: what makes a good teacher, and compare Snape and McGonagall's approaches to their subjects. We also debate whether respect can be demanded, or must it essentially be earned?