To celebrate 300 episodes of the podcast, Matt and Shelby are answering listerner questions from our loyal fans. What are their real jobs? What are there favorite movies? Why are they still hosting this podcast nearly seven years later? The answers are within.
Jun 12, 2025•1 hr 17 min
Shelby did not get into Candid Campus Couture and Matt did not have a poster of Megan Fox in his dorm, but they still related to a lot of the millenial cringe going on in Overcompensating Season 1. Plus who doesn't want to hear Matt discuss being straight in college and Shelby try not to be homophobic during pride month?
Jun 05, 2025•1 hr 1 min
No one has been talking about Taylor Swift so we figured that we would do it.
Jun 04, 2025•1 hr 1 min
Mission Impossible has its final reckoning—but don’t call it a part two!! We’re talking about the end of an era with more stunts, more exposition, more villains and even more questions.
May 29, 2025•54 min
PS You're Wrong* takes on Thunderbolts* or The most annoying people you know take on the best Marvel movie in quite some time.
May 22, 2025•58 min
Shelby is still older than Matt and in honor of her turning another year more ancient, we're discussing her favor genre of movies: disaster flicks and more specifically those starring Gerard Butler. From terrorists destroying the White House to dragons destroying gardens to Xerxes destroying 300 Spartans, there's a lot of disaster to go around. But maybe the greatest disaster of all is Gerard Butler's career? Let's unpack.
May 15, 2025•1 hr 38 min
After some technical difficulties, we're delivering last week's main episode this week instead. Halfway through recording our episode on the latest Hunger Games book, Matt's audio cut out, so we re-recorded the back half of the episode. However, that means there are some points we discuss twice in this episode and some we don't hit on at all. May the odds ever be in your favor as you piece through this episode, and we'll be back in a few weeks when Shelby returns from her Japanese vacation....
Apr 22, 2025•1 hr 8 min
Blue Origin sent Gayle King screaming into space. Aimee Lou thinks SNL went too far. Weezer has Coachella but they also have legal problems (attempted murder). For love it or hate it, Matt declines Drop and Shelby’s returned to The Last of Us.
Apr 15, 2025•55 min
“I’m just a people pleaser,” we say as we finally get to dedicate an entire episode to White Lotus S3. With incest, female friendship, and blood money in the balance, was Mike White able to stick the landing on his most ambitious season yet? There might not be tsunamis, but there’s still a lot (for brothers) to love.
Apr 10, 2025•1 hr
Olivia Munn asks the brave question about Katy Perry’s ASStronauts. SNL *is* god's country. Team Gabby had their first crisis of faith. And Minecraft is…succeeding? For love it or hate it, we’re both gaga for The Studio so you better watch it.
Apr 08, 2025•41 min
Matt and Shelby discuss unicorns, big pharma and the prospect of being ripped in half for your boss.
Apr 03, 2025•44 min
Ben Platt's dad is flying across the country, Matt is listening to religious podcasts and Shelby has thoughts on The White Lotus Season 3.
Apr 01, 2025•46 min
Snow Woke is finally out but is it as bad as every corner of the internet seemed to expect? With bad press, controversial stars, an ableist issue, and about a billion worldbuilding questions, we have plenty to say about Disney's latest live action.
Mar 27, 2025•52 min
Barely anything happened this week in the news but we somehow managed to run long and talk about random things such as Justin Bieber and Selena Gomez's relationship from 15 years ago.
Mar 25, 2025•49 min
Dina and Simone can't be with us today, but Matt and Shelby are on hand to discuss bodies stuffed in bean bags, if paparazzi members get invited on press trips and cults.
Mar 20, 2025•51 min
Jonathan Majors and Kanye West are back again. Lucky us. Also Matt and Shelby argue about Yellowjackets and discuss White Lotus Season 3.
Mar 18, 2025•32 min
From creepers and sauces to cloning and robots, Matt and Shelby discuss the latest Bong Joon-Ho film in depth.
Mar 13, 2025•53 min
Much to discuss this week including more Blake Lively drama, Meghan Markle's new show, Lady Gaga's new album and the state of the world as a whole.
Mar 11, 2025•52 min
From Anora and Emilia Perez to Demi Moore and Adrien Moore, Matt and Shelby have a lot of opinions on the 2025 Oscars.
Mar 06, 2025•1 hr 12 min
Katy Perry is going to outer space and Shelby has some thoughts on that. Also Matt and Shelby break down this season of The Traitors.
Mar 04, 2025•43 min
For the 7th year in a row, Matthew and Shelby are ranking every movie they've seen from best to worst. Will Shelby drag down a campy musical? Will Matthew tank the placement of a summer popcorn flick? Where will Madam Web land? Listen to find out how all 105 movies faired.
Feb 27, 2025•2 hr 18 min
Shelby and Matt see if they are one as they discuss the bloodiest Oscar’s Best Picture entrant, The Substance. With love for Demi Moore and hate for the sledgehammer of a message, there is a lot of gore to sift through to get to a very obvious point.
Feb 13, 2025•43 min
Shoutout to sports on their big day. We talk the Eagles, Kendrick Lamar, Taylor Swift and what the smaller awards may mean for the Oscars. Plus Shelby struggles to see oscar contenders and Matt reveals the first real dud this dumpuary.
Feb 11, 2025•39 min
Matt and Shelby are discussing AI, dating and of course What We Do in the Shadows on this week's episode of the pod focused on Companion.
Feb 06, 2025•45 min
Emilia Perez might be a bigot. Justin Baldoni and Blake Lively told to stop tainting the jury pool. Grammys delivered on all fronts. Lady Gaga is making commercial music. And Beyoncé is finally going on tour. For love it or hate it, Shelby recommends Sugarcane and Matt tries to convince yall to like You’re Cordially Invited.
Feb 04, 2025•52 min
The Oscars may love Emilia Perez but we’re stuck wondering who this is for.
Jan 30, 2025•46 min
Matt and Shelby spend most of their time breaking down the new Oscar nominees, but then there is also some chit chat about Traitors and Presence at the end. Plust Taylor Swift and Blake Lively because why not?
Jan 28, 2025•43 min
A bit of a hodge podge episode that does include content related to Blake Lively, a Polish Nobel Prize Winner and Keke Palmer.
Jan 23, 2025•57 min
2025 is bringing with it a whole slate of new films from this weekend's Keke Palmer comedy to Avatar 3. Shelby and Matt break down 30 movies heading to theaters in 2025, trying to separate the best from the worst.
Jan 16, 2025•1 hr 29 min
Dracula is coming. Look busy.
Jan 09, 2025•53 min