Support for NPR comes from ADP. Say you're a nhr and solar flare adds an extra hour to each day. How would this impact business? ADP designs forward thinking solutions to help your business take on the next anything. ADP. Always designing for people. This is Planet Money from NPR. I have to start this episode off with some personal news. I am pregnant. Thank you. I also have a toddler.
So I've already been through the having a kid Rigamarole here in the US, which is how I know it is not a good deal. Having a kid in the US is extremely expensive. Our government is one of just like a handful of countries worldwide that does not offer any form of paid parental leave. We have functionally no public daycare. So knowing what I know, it would be irrational of me to have more kids here if I can avoid it.
Especially when it is my understanding that other countries are offering way better deals. Tons of benefits and straight up cash for having babies. And one of the reasons why there are such good deals out there is because governments around the world are struggling with labor force participation. Having enough workers and getting the most possible out of them. And maybe the biggest driver, a lot of countries are facing a problem in their population demographics.
They have a ton of aging workers and not enough new babies being born to become future workers and taxpayers. So I have something they need, babies, they have something I need, money, social services and functioning public infrastructure. Let's make a deal! Hello and welcome to Planet Money, I'm Mary Childs. Today on the show, we are going to go around the world shopping for the very best deal. So you don't have to.
And along the way, we will find out why those deals exist in the first place. The history behind these somewhat creative solutions to what could be existential problems. We're going to go to Sweden, Singapore, South Korea, Estonia, Canada. Let's find out who's going to give me the best bang for my offspring.
This message comes from Apple Card. You earned up to 3% daily cash on every purchase. That's 3% on products at Apple, 2% on all other Apple Card with Apple Pay purchases, and 1% on anything you buy with your titanium Apple Card or virtual card number. Visit apple.co slash card calculator to see how much you can earn. Apple Card issued by Goldman Sachs Bank USA Salt Lake City branch. Subjects accredited approval, terms apply.
This message comes from NPR sponsor Intuit TurboTax. TurboTax experts make all your moves count, filing with 100% accuracy and getting your max refund guaranteed. So whether you pay your kids tuition, sold crypto or moved states, switch to TurboTax and make your moves count. See guaranteed details at TurboTax.com slash guarantees. Experts only available with TurboTax live. So we are embarking on this quest to respond rationally to the incentives offered worldwide to parents and families.
And this is to some degree window shopping. I'm not a citizen of every country, so I won't be eligible for a lot of these benefits, at least not in the near term. And my situation is very near term, but I don't know. Maybe they're willing to bargain. Let's find out. So first, I want to set some parameters for what we are shopping for. There are three big things that I'm looking for. The number one is a nice, long, guaranteed paid leaf. I think we just don't have in the United States.
Anything shorter than three months in my opinion is inhumane, so that is my minimum. The second thing I'm looking for is sort of the absence of a thing, because no country has solved the career injury of motherhood. You can get mommy tracked with dead end assignments. A woman's pay takes a hit after becoming a parent. Instantly, men's pay goes up. So maybe as a clumsy proxy for this, we can use the pay gap between men and women. The smaller the pay gap, the better.
For reference in the United States, it is 16%, meaning on average women make 84 cents for every dollar a man makes. Number three, childcare. So I can do my fulfilling and fun job. I currently pay $2,000 a month for preschool for one child, and it was the hunger games to get into a program at all. I have heard that elsewhere, other governments provide childcare or subsidize it, and it's good, and I'm curious.
Okay, so now I know what I want. The bare minimum, at least three months leave, ideally more, a reasonably small pay gap and affordable childcare. Let's see what we can find. First up, Singapore. Because one of the most compelling things about all these countries trying to incentivize more babies is that a lot of them will just straight up give you money. Cash bonuses for babies. There are few incentives economists like more than cash.
And Singapore's is the biggest cash bonus I have seen, as much as $24,000 in cash and matching savings. Also, on offer for me in Singapore, three months per end to leave, government subsidized childcare, a gender pay gap of 14% and that giant cash bonus. So we are already doing better on all fronts than in the United States. Of course, Singapore does not offer all this out of the kindness of its heart. It's trying to solve a demographic problem.
People in the country are having fewer and fewer babies. For the government, it has been a decade's long struggle. I mean, this is partly a happy problem. It's a consequence of success, right? This is behavioral economist Donald Lowe. He worked for the Singapore government for almost 15 years. And the history behind all of this, the way Singapore got to be handing out that cash bonus, starts like 50 years ago in the 70s. When the worry was the opposite, too many babies.
At that time, we were afraid that we wouldn't be creating enough jobs. We didn't have enough land to go around. And our economy, our resources may not be able to keep up. Singapore in the 70s was focused on getting people to have fewer children. The country's founding prime minister, Lee Kuan Yew. He was the one in the 70s who said, the buffer is still too high, so let's have a stop at two policy. Stop at two kids. Singapore started rolling out policies.
Disincentives to discourage people from having kids, like your taxes, parental leave, and hospital costs worsened with subsequent kids. But beginning in the 1970s, Singapore also started enjoying strong economic growth. And the more economic development, generally the better the education and employment opportunities for women. And the more education women get, the fewer babies they have. With rapid economic development, buff rates were going to fall on their own.
And so you pile on this disincentive, this punitive tax measures and other forms of punishment for people who have more than two children. You're going to have even larger fall in buff rates than you would already have. People were stopping it too. And then they stopped at one. And then zero. Eventually, the prime minister was like, hold up, this is a bad trajectory. We are on track for two few children.
Which through an economic lens can become catastrophic. It means fewer future workers, which means lower future consumption. And it means who's going to pay your future taxes, who's going to fund all those pensions you promised. There's a name for this problem. It is the dreaded, inverted pyramid. Lots of retired old people at the top, then fewer working age people supporting them, and even fewer babies. This is looming in Italy, in China, lots of places. And it can create all kinds of problems.
So Singapore's government was like, yeah, let's unear reverse this. Suddenly in the mid 80s, the policy was flipped. The prime minister in 1983 made a big speech during the National Day rally and said, our new challenge now is to reverse the falling birth rates. They started saying, have three or more parentheses if you can afford it close parentheses. Like that was a real government slogan. They rolled out programs to incentivize people to have kids.
What are called pro-natalist policies. Better parental leave, tax benefits, cash payments at birth. Maybe people get money for having babies. They will have babies. But Donald says it's really hard for a government to pull off a huge policy and culture 180 like that. Especially one that feels so overtly utilitarian. And for all that, Singapore's fertility rate has fallen basically continuously. It is now one. That's how many kids on average a woman will have over her lifetime.
Which Donald says, hey, maybe there's a more positive way we could view this. I think it is actually very optimistic. It's very promising in the sense that instead of looking at this with gloominess, we should be saying that actually it marks older populations, people living longer, women having more options and choosing the right to your children. That is a triumph of human development. That's a triumph of economic development.
But if you're a government worried about your population, that number is too low. The magic number you want is 2.1. That is the replacement rate. How many births are necessary to maintain a stable population? Replace the parents plus a little extra for safety. Anything less than that and you are demographically in trouble. So in Singapore, they're considering other options. I think government is more or less given up now. It says we'll simply focus on maintaining the population.
And since we can't do it through having citizens have enough children, we would just have to allow more immigration. Immigration. Imagine that. If you need workers and there are people who want to come into your country and work, I don't know, it makes sense. And for Singapore, this has been effective. Its population would be declining, word it not for immigration. Which is great for me personally, a potential future immigrant.
Though I would need to be there for 10 years before I could become a citizen and qualify for all of the benefits. And as you know, I do not have 10 years. So I asked Donald what he thought about where Singapore should fall in my rankings. I would say it's particularly generous. Really, but the cash bonus, it's like $24 grand. Yeah, but you know that the cost of raising a child, especially in the expensive city like Singapore. Oh yeah, I got a paper for an apartment.
Okay, so for my narrow purposes today, it's actually not a resounding recommendation onto our next country. Basically every single person we talk to for this story referenced the Nordic countries as the leaders in parental benefits and support. So next up, Sweden. I called up Nicholas Lothgren at this Swedish social insurance agency. Oh, I've been working with these issues for at least 20 years now. So you've seen children grow up all the way.
Yep, yep. Wow. Any any successful cases that you can think of? My own, of course. His kids are now 27 and 29. That is very big, huge success. So I explained to him what was on offer, my problem tunity. So I am here to try to see if we can make a deal. I have babies. You have social support programs. Let's see what we can do. Yep, just come over. Move to Sweden immediately. Okay, in Sweden, the deal is parental leave is very long. You get 16 months, the first 13 at 80% pay.
Government provided daycare starts at one year old. You are guaranteed a spot and it is at most 163 dollars a month. But to me, the most compelling thing about Sweden's offer is actually embedded in why Sweden started these benefits in the first place. It is a story of a quest for gender equality. And that begins decades ago in the aftermath of World War II. Nicholas says the country had two big problems it wanted to solve. First, a labor shortage. Not enough workers.
After a second World War, we needed more people in the industry. We needed a big labor force. And therefore we saw that we needed more women to join the labor force. And the government saw an easy solution. There was a whole cohort of people who weren't in the formal workforce. At the time, Sweden had one million housewives. So Sweden was like, why not get all those housewives in the labor force?
But at the same time, most women started to ask questions like, okay, if we should attend the labor force, who will look after the children then? Great question, women. So Sweden started offering childcare centers. But then women were like, wait, so we're supposed to go to work and then come home and also do work? Women started to ask questions like, well, if we should work two jobs, why should men only work one job? Why should they just work in the labor force and not at home?
Great question. Again, women. So Sweden realized if it wanted more of its people in the labor force, if it wanted women workers, it would need to promote gender equality. And one way Sweden tried to do that was to entice men to do more at home. It created an incentive for them to take parental leave. And research does show that men taking leave helps them bond with the baby, the babies obviously love it.
But more relevant for our purposes, it helps foster equality at home in unpaid labor like tourist splitting. And it makes leave taking normal. If men take leave, that can reduce how much women get punished when they take leave. So one incentive Sweden came up with is this, both parents get 240 days and a big chunk of those days are non-transferable. Use it or lose it. This is the papamona, or daddy quarter. And it's been pretty effective.
Men in Sweden now take about 30% of the parental leave up from 0.5%. Guess what else? Today we have one of the world's highest labor force participation, not only for the population in total, but also a very small gender gap between men and women. So I guess over 80% of all women work in the labor force. Do you know your pay gap off the top of your head? I guess pay gap is about 7% or something like that. Seven single digits? Yes, it's somewhere there. I didn't know that was possible.
So Sweden made huge progress getting more women into the workforce, but it had that second problem. That dreaded inverted pyramid was looming. Its fertility rate was too low. So to incentivize more children, Sweden started giving parents cash every month per kid. But pretty close before we introduced the benefit, the fertility rates had gone up already. We didn't see that reformed affected actually the fertility rates.
The one thing Sweden actually has noticed that clearly impacts fertility rates macroeconomic conditions. If the economy is doing well, more babies. If it crashes, fewer babies. And Nicholas says Sweden isn't overly troubled by the fact that they don't really know how effective the policies actually are. We don't have evidence for the connection, so to speak. But we believe that a system that is generous, that also aims at gender equality, those systems will also have good fertility rates.
And I would never imply causation, but Sweden's fertility rate is 1.8. Not a placement level, but not too far off. And Nicholas says Sweden feels pretty satisfied about its two goals of more women in the workforce and more babies. This is a technical question. How long do you have to live in Sweden to get the benefits? Just wondering for a friend. Actually, if you are entitled to live here, you will get the benefits like child allowance, housing allowance, and maintenance support.
And so from day one, actually. So if you're allowed to live here, you will get benefits. Yes, from day one. I could just move right now. Yes, you will get it from day one. But the insurances like parental insurance. So you have to have been working here for at least 240 days before you're insured. I don't have 240 days. No, so after 240 days, you will be covered. But not before that. Yeah, that is not ideal for my particular situation. Let's keep going.
After the break, a country that can point to a policy that literally caused more babies. And a country that takes a little bit from Singapore and a little bit from Sweden. This message comes from NPR-sponsored Dell Technologies. Dell is celebrating with anniversary savings on their most popular tech, like the XPS13+. So you can make the everyday easier with Windows 11. Save now at Dell.com slash deals. This message comes from NPR-sponsored Chevron.
Methane management is a critical part of achieving a lower carbon future. Chevron is taking action to keep methane in the pipe. They're committed to evolving facility designs and operating practices. And they've trialled over 13 advanced detection technologies, including drones and satellites. That's energy in progress. Learn more at chevron.com slash methane. Support for NPR and the following message come from our sponsor Whole Foods Market.
Taste the Mediterranean through March 19th with savings on beef short ribs, Sock Eisman, and more regionally inspired finds from Whole Foods Market. Support for NPR and the following message come from this is Small Business, a podcast for aspiring and emerging entrepreneurs. Wondering how to price your product, hire your first employee, attract new customers through social media? This is Small Business is the show for you. Here actionable advice on how to bring your dream to life.
On this is Small Business, an original podcast from Amazon. Listen now wherever you get your podcasts. Okay, the country I have heard the most about in the providing parental support arms race. And one of my leading contenders here is South Korea. South Korea has been absolutely throwing benefits and money at its fertility rate, which is currently 0.7. Well below replacement, that magic number 2.1. They have spent over $200 billion on programs in just the past 16 years alone. So here's the deal.
A robust leave, a year for each parent, a $1,500 cash bonus at birth, great daycares. It's like all the perks of Sweden plus a cash bonus like Singapore, I'll be it smaller. And this kind of sounds like the total package, like maybe the best deals so far. And it just so happens, we know someone who's had kids in South Korea. Friend of the show Elise, who host of Ted Talks daily. I opened NPR Soul Bureau in 2015 and lived there and had two children there.
At a natural birthing center, she says it was lovely. I actually credit Korea for such really memorable and poignant experiences in giving birth. The perks don't end there. The lactation stations are giant and people are very kind to children. You know, kids eat free everywhere. There's giant kid cafes. Moms get like good parking spots and designated places on the subway. And all these things, there's these knots towards wanting to be family friendly.
But then culturally, it's still very hard for women to make that decision. Hard to make the decision to have kids, which sounds like the big problem in South Korea. It has all these great policies, but something's just not sticking. Women are dropping out of the workforce after having kids at an alarmingly high rate. And even though South Korea has a kind of daddy-quadopolicy like Sweden, men are just not taking leave that much.
So you can bring these policies over, but they don't necessarily work if all of your cultural norms, both at work and within family units, within homes, don't change along with it. Because the norm in South Korea is this very intense office culture. You succeed by working long hours, which is one approach for getting more out of your workers. Like work is more of a sprint, versus in Sweden where it's more of a marathon. At least told me this is compounded by gender dynamics at work.
For decades, Korea has had the widest pay gap of the 38 most developed countries in the world. Women there get paid 30% less than their male counterparts. And gender dynamics at home don't help. Dita Shoe, men in Korea do the least amount of housework of everyone in those 38 countries. And that is not what I want personally, and it's not what a lot of women in South Korea want personally either. There's an entire movement of feminists in South Korea that are like no marriage, no children women.
And part of the reason is because they don't want to be cogs in a system. They don't want to feel as though in this structure that is already really hard on women, that they're just here to produce babies. So all of this was not what I was expecting, honestly. Despite the great offer on paper, I'm going to have to reconsider where South Korea is in my rankings. So next up, we're going to go to a country with one of the longest leave policies in the known universe, Estonia.
My name is Kaira Sarap and I'm director of Chenero, or Falei Bridge, right? I told Kaira about my mission to find a new home where I could afford all my children. I hope it's a stolen out, but you have to consider we have a good winters. Everything gets great. No such thing as bad weather, only bad clothes. Is that the saying exactly that's what we say here's Estonia's offer 18 months of leave at 100% pay.
There is a salary cap, but 18 months also affordable take care starting at 18 months. Great, great, great. I'm listening. Now, Kaira says Estonia has a slightly different reason for offering these benefits. We were part of Russia, basically, like a little bit more than 30 years ago. And when we gain our independence, you know, the importance to our own country was more country. And you want to help repopulate basically Estonia's.
The current government, she says, is cool with immigration, especially if those immigrants can come work, especially in the tech sector, and pay tax. But the explicit motivation behind these pro-natalist policies was more Estonians, which hits on one of the very real undertones of all this. Not just here, but everywhere. The goal is a specific type of baby. Countries are aiming for more babies from their native population when there are plenty of other great babies all around the world.
But Kaira says, since Estonia started offering these benefits, it's made progress on its goal of more Estonians. Its fertility rate has climbed from 1.37 in 2003 to 1.77 now. And there's this one policy that they say has been demonstrably effective at getting more babies. It's what Kaira called a speed benefit. Normally, when people go back into the labor force, they face that motherhood penalty. They might need to work part-time. They might not go back at all.
Estonia's speed benefit means if parents have their next kid fast enough within three years, for this next leave, they get 100% of their pre-first baby salary. This is the one thing you can actually measure the most. These researchers have been shown the second and third childbirth is being increased the most. So the speed benefit actually working. And I can see it through my friends as well. Everybody who has second or third child, their pre-close age gap.
Okay, that is very cool from an economics perspective and an Estonia demographics perspective. But for me personally, speed benefits kind of irrelevant because I'm definitely done after this. And I am a little concerned about daycare since it starts at 18 months. That might be a challenge if I want to get back to work before then. So, onto our last country, I called up Jenna Suds, the Minister of Families, Children and Social Development. In Canada, the greatest country in the world.
Interesting. I'm going to need substantiation for that enormous claim, but I'm open to it. She is an economist. I did do my master's degree in economics here in Ottawa. And frankly, consider myself an economic minister given the portfolio that I lead here. Oh, go on. Reality, right? When families succeed, when parents succeed, it contributes to our economy full stop. And so many of the so-called social policies that we put forward here in Canada are really, really strong economic policies.
Jenna jumped right into the details. First up, which actually for me is the main draw for Canada, child care. Because Canada started offering $10 a day child care. And those are Canadian dollars. So in US dollars, it's more like $7 a day, which is far less than what Jenna had to pay in Canadian dollars when she was putting her kids through child care. It was a mortgage payment. You know, families often were spending at least $1,500 if not more a month per child.
You know, that delta between what they're paying now versus what you would have paid pre-policy is actually their mortgage payment. Literally still the case for me that my mortgage is less than my child care for one child. In the course of reporting for this episode, I was surprised to learn that affordable child care might actually be my number one priority. It's what's causing me the most pain right now, getting on to years long wait lists for care I can't afford. $7 a day sounds so nice.
It's actually a little more expensive than some of the other countries in our cohort here, but it is still a huge improvement for me. And it starts earlier than the others when the babies are little. Canada sees all this as an investment. It's calculated that for every dollar it invests in early learning. It gets back a lot more. Anywhere from a dollar 50 to $2.80 depending on socioeconomic factors.
That's from the child's now enriched development paying off down the road and from parents rejoining the workforce. Now we're seeing here in Canada, the women's participation in the workforce has reached record levels at 85%. And to contrast that, that's 9% higher than in the US. I feel a little called out. I do. I'm sorry, but I've got a point out. We do a great job at this in Canada and it's because we've prioritized it. And all this is so great, Jenna says.
But Canada still has to think about keeping its population stable. Also, notably you can't put babies to work for a while. So any near term gaps in the labor market require a more immediate solution. We're welcoming on average about 500,000 people a year right now. And they're helping where we need them. They're contributing to our economy. It's miraculous, frankly. Music to this future immigrants ears. I hope they desperately need podcasters.
Are there any other things I should consider like why Canada? I think you should get your visa application in soon and get here. Okay. TikTok. And that completes our world tour. We went to Singapore, Sweden, South Korea, Estonia, Canada. And we got some really compelling offers. It is time to declare a winner. And I will say there are so many moving parts to each of these packages and each part is kind of difficult to compare if not impossible.
But in the end, I feel like the best all-around packages were in Canada and Sweden. But then I looked up the pay gap in Canada and it is not better than in the US. So I guess that means I am moving to Sweden. It's always tough to compete with the Scandinavian country on these grounds. But there are two wrinkles here. These may want more babies, but they don't make it easy to emigrate. Generally, I would need proof of work or at least income or wealth.
And I have not mentioned this to NPR beyond this very podcast. So I'm not sure how interested they are in sponsoring my work visa. And the second wrinkle, it is too late for me. I can't just show up today and get paid to be on leave. I would have had to be paying taxes. I would, however, be eligible for child care immediately. Which is material because did I mention I'm having twins? So yeah, in my case, everything's a little extra acute. And this world tour wasn't comprehensive.
We considered so many countries, but some didn't really stand out. Or frankly, didn't get back to us in time. So if you are a country and you want to offer a better deal, call me. I'm open. We are at Planet Money on most social platforms. We are Planet Money at npr.org. A lot of the prices you see at the supermarket make so little sense. Like, why do stores charge the same amount for milk that will expire in three days as they do for milk that won't expire for another two weeks?
And that is a puzzle, right? Why? Why are they changing the price? Don't they realize these dynamics? Well, we visit the grocery store of the future to see what it would be like if supermarket prices actually did make sense. That's next time on Planet Money. The James Need produced today's episode. It was edited by Jess Zhang, fact-checked by Sierra Wattas, and engineered by Sina Lafredo. Alex Goldmark is our executive producer.
A huge thank you to Sorry Curve for holding my hand through this entire process. Thank you also to Jane Welfogle, Mary Brinton, Katarina Ang, Peter McDonald, Leana Simstrom, and Anya Nilsson and Abigail Leonard. Abigail's book, For Mothers, is coming out in 2025. I'm Mary Childs. This is NPR. Thanks for listening. Support for NPR comes from ADP. Say you're a nature, and solar flare adds an extra hour to each day.
How would this impact business? ADP designs forward-thinking solutions to help your business take on the next anything, ADP, always designing for people. Support for this NPR podcast and the following message come from EasyCator, committed to helping companies from nonprofits to the Fortune 500, solve food for work, from ordering online for meetings and team lunches, to managing food spend for your whole organization. EasyCator can help you simplify your corporate catering needs.
Over 100,000 restaurants nationwide, plus budgeting tools and payment by invoice. Learn more at EasyCator.com. From an Iraq war cover up to towns ravaged by opioids to the roots of our modern immigration crisis, embedded explores what's been sealed off and undisclosed. NPR's original investigative podcast reveals why these stories and the people behind them matter. Listen to the embedded podcast only from NPR.