Pie Break! - podcast cover

Pie Break!

Pie Break is a podcast about Magic's color pie and where it intersects with the real world. Each week, Dan and a guest will go through a real life concept and try to map it onto a color identity.
Last refreshed:
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

Casual Friday: Zada & Tymna/Kraum

Another Casual Friday, another set of decks in need of the Lasagna treatment! This week's decks come from WinOnUpkeep and Simon! This marks the end of season 3! What does that mean? Rachel and Dan are going on a little vacation! The hosts are taking some much needed post-covid time to go see friends and family and will return to their regular posting schedule in late July! See you then!

Jun 27, 202139 minSeason 1Ep. 73

Sizzle & Steak: A Very Special Episode

Once again everyone is fighting and once again nobody seems to understand why. We've released next week's episode early to talk about some of the recent issues in the EDH Twittersphere and to present our own model for Rule Zero conversations.

Jun 24, 202143 minSeason 1Ep. 72

Identity Crisis: Gruul

Identity Crisis, The Commander Sphere's in-depth examination of Magic's color pie, is BACK and getting into color pairs! First up is Gruul! Red and Green put their heads together and the results are...not particularly bright! But they're tough as hell.

Jun 20, 202136 minSeason 1Ep. 71

Casual Fridays: Yennett and Ghen

The inaugural episode of Casual Fridays features decklists for Ghen, Arcanum Weaver and Yennett, Cryptic Sovereign! These decks come from patrons Joe and Fitz! To become eligible for a future episode of Casual Friday, just pledge at our $10 level!

Jun 18, 202152 minSeason 1Ep. 70

Modern Horizons 2 Set Review

Another new set is upon us and this one is BIG. Check out the best legends, reprints, and new cards for your decks!

Jun 14, 20211 hr 9 minSeason 1Ep. 69

The Seven Casual Commandments

STOP getting stuck in games you were never going to enjoy to begin with and START asking the right questions that'll lead you to the playgroup of your dreams

Jun 06, 202135 minSeason 1Ep. 68

Where Two?

Dan and Rachel have been back out in the world getting games in! It's good to be back but the format has changed. The power gap has never been more apparent and the hosts try to get to the bottom of how best to deal with it.

May 31, 202135 minSeason 1Ep. 67

The Milk Episode

By popular demand, Dan and Rachel discuss which magical creatures would produce milk, what that milk would be like, and how much money it would take to get them to consume said milk. May god have mercy on us all.

May 24, 20211 hrSeason 1Ep. 66

Identity Crisis: Green

It's green's time to shine! What can you attribute to the color that has everything? Turns out, a whole lot!

May 17, 202150 minSeason 1Ep. 65

Where To?

Rachel and Dan talk about the impending return of in-person EDH and how the format, players, and community have changed in the wake of our forced year-long pause.

May 10, 202143 minSeason 1Ep. 64

Story Speedrun: Strixhaven

Rachel and Dan go through the story spotlight cards from Strixhaven and give you a (very condensed) update on what's going on at everyone's favorite bird-filled school for magic children.

May 03, 20211 hr 1 minSeason 1Ep. 63

Identity Crisis: WHITE

The journey through the color pie continues with the color of church & soldiers! Magic's most rules-obsessed color finally gets its identity crisised.

Apr 26, 202154 minSeason 1Ep. 62

Commander 2021 Set Review!

Dan and Rachel's favorite legends and new cards from the new Commander product!

Apr 19, 20211 hrSeason 1Ep. 61

Strixhaven Set Review

Time to go back to school! Rachel and Dan pull their favorite cards and their favorite legends to help get your brain brewing before Strixhaven comes out later this month!

Apr 11, 20211 hr 9 minSeason 1Ep. 60

Identity Crisis: Blue

Before our Strixhaven and Commander 2021 set review episodes hit, the Sphere has squeezed in one more installment of Identity Crisis! This week: BLUE. Blue seeks perfection through knowledge and that means it's for NERDS. Also, we talk about types of comedy's alignment within the color pie and the mystifying nature of Chicago dive bars.

Apr 04, 202154 minSeason 1Ep. 59

Identity Crisis: Black

Join Rachel and Dan as they continue the Identity Crisis series by taking a dive into the swamp! MaRo has described black as the most Machiavellian of Magic's five colors, referring to the color's ultimate goal as "power through ruthlessness." The hosts discuss what that means in a fantasy context and then how it applies to the world at large. Hint: Capitalism!

Mar 28, 202146 minSeason 1Ep. 58

Identity Crisis: RED

In the first installment of a new (hopefully) 32 part series, Rachel and Dan try to break down what color identity means in relation to the real world. Sure, we all know what card mechanics are Red but what about hot dog toppings? Hairstyles? Historical figures? Your hosts get to the bottom of what makes Red Red.

Mar 21, 202151 minSeason 1Ep. 57

Deckbuilding in Quarantine

So we've been inside for a year. Not ideal! Rachel and Dan talk about how a year of remote/solo commander play has effected the way they build decks and interact with EDH as a whole. Note: The audio is a little wonky on this, we're working to make sure this addressed by next week.

Mar 15, 202140 minSeason 1Ep. 56

85 Minutes Of Goofs With Gavin Verhey

Rachel and Dan were lucky enough to sit down with Senior Designer Gavin Verhey to talk about Gavin's history with the game, what it's like to design it, and how Commander brings people together. Rachel and Dan also help Gavin design some brand new sets for 2022. They may not be real but they ARE terrifying.

Mar 08, 20211 hr 25 minSeason 1Ep. 55

The 2021 Prediction Episode

Rachel and Dan place their bets on what's going to happen to Magic in 2021! Also: stories about donating blood!

Feb 22, 20211 hr 9 minSeason 1Ep. 54

The Counter Spell Debate

Over the course of the last handful of years, something has changed in Magic. Counter spells stopped being polite and started being rude as hell. Rachel and Dan discuss the silliest counter spell names and play a little game.

Feb 15, 202149 minSeason 1Ep. 53

Lasagna Tier Staples

Rachel put together a list of cards that can help you build decks that do big things without sacrificing the table's good time. Check it out!

Feb 08, 20211 hr 3 minSeason 1Ep. 52

The Mulligan Episode

An episode that is ostensibly about the many different types of mulligans gets off the rails almost immediately and becomes a discussion of neg-centric midwestern restaurant chains and whether or not the dog from Air Bud is dead (He is)

Jan 31, 202142 minSeason 1Ep. 51

Our Top Kaldheim Top 10!

It's new set season which means it's time for Rachel and Dan's top cards they're looking forward to. This week the hosts break down the good, the goofy, and the bad-but-interesting. Also: they try to piece together the lore situation! It's still confusing!

Jan 25, 202157 minSeason 1Ep. 50

Tribe Tribal

Kaldheim previews are here and changeling is BACK. Dan and Rachel talk about tribal support and look at some of Kaldheim's story cards!

Jan 18, 202135 minSeason 1Ep. 49

Lasagna Tier EDH: Explained

Rachel and Dan have joked a lot about power level on the podcast, but what does it truly mean to play at Lasagna Tier? This is the episode where you can finally find out. Open your mind and perfect the art of playing in concert with the table.

Jan 11, 202132 minSeason 1Ep. 48

GOOD VIBES ONLY: Episode Four

UNLOCKED! After being a patron exclusive, Good Vibes Only is being released as our holiday gift to you! Two installments of this D&D adventure will be dropping every week for the next two weeks in lieu of the show's normal episodes. Enjoy a comedic trip to Theros while Dan and Rachel take a couple weeks off! Regular episodes will resume on January 11th!

Jan 06, 202156 minSeason 1Ep. 47

GOOD VIBES ONLY: Episode Three

UNLOCKED! After being a patron exclusive, Good Vibes Only is being released as our holiday gift to you! Two installments of this D&D adventure will be dropping every week for the next two weeks in lieu of the show's normal episodes. Enjoy a comedic trip to Theros while Dan and Rachel take a couple weeks off! Regular episodes will resume on January 11th!

Jan 04, 20211 hr 7 minSeason 1Ep. 46

GOOD VIBES ONLY: Episode Two

UNLOCKED! After being a patron exclusive, Good Vibes Only is being released as our holiday gift to you! Two installments of this D&D adventure will be dropping every week for the next two weeks in lieu of the show's normal episodes. Enjoy a comedic trip to Theros while Dan and Rachel take a couple weeks off! Regular episodes will resume on January 11th!

Dec 30, 20201 hr 6 minSeason 1Ep. 45

GOOD VIBES ONLY: Episode One

UNLOCKED! After being a patron exclusive, Good Vibes Only is being released as our holiday gift to you! Two installments of this D&D adventure will be dropping every week for the next two weeks in lieu of the show's normal episodes. Enjoy a comedic trip to Theros while Dan and Rachel take a couple weeks off!

Dec 28, 202038 minSeason 1Ep. 44
Hosted on Libsyn
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android