EPISODE 32 - This Little Piggy.....Part Two - podcast episode cover

EPISODE 32 - This Little Piggy.....Part Two

Jul 25, 202355 minSeason 1Ep. 32
--:--
--:--
Download Metacast podcast app
Listen to this episode in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episode description

Send us a text

We reel you into the chilling discovery at Pickton Farm, the sequence of events leading to Pickton' eventual arrest, and a forensic overview of his unspeakable crimes. We don't just recount, but dissect, analysing not only the Picktons' actions but also the community's response, and the justice that was meted out. We venture into the mindset of a serial killer, discussing the influence of traumatic experiences.

Support the show

Thank you for listening. If you would like to see any of our videos and photos please check out the links below. If you like what you hear please be sure to like and follow as it really helps us keep doing this!

Subscribe to the show and get access to the BLAM episodes @
https://www.buzzsprout.com/2115848/subscribe


Please follow us @
https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100089047737544&sk=about
https://www.instagram.com/perplexedpodcasts/
https://www.tiktok.com/@perplexedpodcasts?is_from_webapp=1&sender_device=pc

Please subscribe to our channel @
https://www.youtube.com/@perplexedpodcast/featured

Please support the show @
https://www.buzzsprout.com/2115848/support

Buy us a coffee @
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/perplexedpod

Use this link & code to start your first podcast and grab your voucher. Using this code will support our show too so it's a win win!!
https://www.buzzsprout.com/?referrer_id=2096726

Much love

Transcript

Passport Mishap and Plane Delay

Sarah

She's like Josie and I . You know , Josie and I are going to South Africa , Uh-huh . Well , it was the day that we was going to South Africa and it was me and you going . She wasn't Josie , it was me , and you going oh she's been replaced . Yeah , because you're much kinder to me .

Kate

Oh , I can still see her shadow . Get down , get down . She's not gone yet !

Sarah

The airplane had pulled up in front of my mom's house and we , as it does , we was going to get on it and even though it was pulled up in front of my mom's house I'd been staying at my mom's by how we hadn't come from there . We'd come from my mom's house . It was actually around the corner . It was a bit strange .

And my mom drove me round to the airplane and she was like oh , are you forgetting something ? And I was like oh , I don't think so . And then I was like oh my God , my passport . I've forgotten my passport . And my mom was like Don't worry , I've got your passport , don't worry . And I was like oh my God , thank you so much , mom , thank you .

And then she gave it to me and when I showed it to the airplane man , it was my dad's passport and I was like oh , that's so funny . And then I said to the airplane man I was like Right , just five minutes , I promise you , we live just around the corner . And said to my mom my passport is on the windowsill , right as you go in the front room .

It's on the windowsill . You can't like don't fuck about , just go in , get it . We've got the airplane man's waiting for us , so she goes off and me and you stand there and I'm trying to like delay this airplane , man and the my mom's taken ages to get my passport .

Kate

When you're saying airplane man , do you mean the pilot ?

Sarah

Yes , okay , yes , and we're trying to delay him . And he was like like we need to go , we're going to be late , we need to go . And I was like just like one minute , she's on her way and she comes back . And she's like I've got your passport , I've got your passport . So I was like yes , and I'm getting too excited .

So I showed the pilot my passport and I noticed that it was a baby , one of me . It was an old passport and it had my baby phone , though , and I was like , ah , and I said it was really , really faded and really like hard to see . And I said to him will that get me through the airport ? And he went , that won't even get you on a train , love .

I was like , oh no . So I said to her right , I will go back and get my passport . And I said to you I was like Kate , hold this plane , do not let it go . It feels like standing in front of the plane but like making sure that it didn't go . And I raced off to get . Yeah , this plane was just parked on the drive .

My mum's drive is like really steep and it was just parked on the steep driveway , so we don't know if you came back with your passport .

Kate

You just left me standing in front of a plane going stop . Yeah , Did I tell the plane . You shall not pass .

Sarah

Because I feel like it would have done yeah .

Kate

With my stuff , yeah , morning .

Sarah

Morning , morning , morning , and I feel really good today .

Kate

It's not a Sunday . That's why I'm so glad .

Sarah

I'm so glad , You're so glad it's a Thursday so I read a post yesterday and it said not only is it not Friday , it's not even Thursday .

Kate

I'm working this weekend . Weekends Don't really mean anything to me anymore .

Sarah

No , when I worked in retail , it didn't bother to me whether it was a Friday or not , because I was working on the weekends , so it didn't bother me .

Kate

Don't bother me none . Well , I'm not working on Sunday . I've got Sunday off .

Sarah

Right , let's . Shall we crack on with part two , because I'm dying to know how the rest of the story plays out , because you left .

You said in the previous episode how Willie was such a great guy and I didn't say that , listen , he's such a great guy , so nice , he's such a gentleman , he's a stand up and he actually , for his debut opening , rushed his hair . Such a great guy , hi .

Kate

Look , if you want me to be holding planes up for you need to treat me right , right , welcome to part two . Is that for me ? You won't , yes , but everyone . Thanks for our vast audience . I'm going to do trigger warning for this one . So trigger warning .

Graphic Descriptions of Violent Serial Killings

There is graphic descriptions of extreme sexual violence , some animal abuse , defilement of many bodies and there is also a brief mention of rape . So it's going to be a fun episode . Let's go Just like I say now . I'm sorry , right ? Also , there's lots of names in this , so I do . That's because there's lots of victims .

Exactly , I do apologise for my rubbish pronunciation . That was my cha , I'm sure , sure .

Sarah

I , just my foot was uncomfortable , so I went to move my foot and my chair went back in there . I did a fart noise and I Sorry , it's my foot , my chair on the floor .

Kate

Right , so have you got yourself and your bodily functions under control .

Sarah

I don't know about that . No , never , never never .

Kate

So Lynn Ellingson had walked in and found Willie Picton butchering the girl that they'd picked up just hours before . If you remember , that's where we left off in part Vividly , vividly , you remember that .

And Ellingson said that there was a large lump of something on the wooden block and it had sticky blood , soaked hair hanging from it , and she agreed to keep her mouth shut about what she'd seen that night . If Willie paid her some like drug money , basically so that she could go and get high After seeing that , don't blame her .

I mean , if you saw something like that , I would say anything to not be hanging on a hook next to her .

Sarah

Well , yeah , but I wouldn't be bargaining . I won't say anything , because long as you baby , are you not in a position ? You don't have the upper hand there . Yeah , I know .

Kate

I guess . Yeah , I guess that was the way their friendship was , though , I suppose . So maybe she was just like listen , sling me some drug money . Maybe it was more believable . Do you know what I mean ? Like I'm not , I'm not bothered about that , just give us some money so that I can go and get high . Of course , I'm not going to say anything .

Sarah

Bitch , you can , you know me .

Kate

Willie and Willie , just sort of thought , you know , I mean it didn't didn't do him justice because she ends up testifying at his trial . Spoiler alert there . So I'll start with a timeline so that you can appreciate the true proportions of Willie's absolute heinous business .

Sarah

Yeah , great , great one .

Kate

Yeah , they all left , they all shot out my . September 1977 . Cindy Beck was last seen In 1991, . The relatives of a growing list of missing women and advocates for sex trade workers organized an annual Valentine's Day remembrance to push for better police protection for sex workers . And it still goes on every year oh OK , don't you know ? December 1995 .

Diana Melnick was last seen On October 1996, . Tanya Holick was last seen January 1997 , kerry Koski , june 1997, . Helen Hallmark was reported missing . September 1998 , vancouver police set up a team to review the files of the women that gone missing as far back as 1971 .

January 1999 , jacqueline MacDonald was reported missing 1999 , was Georgina Papin , brenda Wolfe and Jennifer Firminger was last seen April 1999, . Police post a $100,000 reward for any information on the missing women . So by this point , like 1999 , 2000 , that kind of year they were the police were really starting to see an issue coming up . Which years too late .

Sarah

Yeah , well , it took them 10 years .

Kate

Yes , march . However , even though they started with this , it still continued . March 2001, . Patricia Johnson was last seen April 2001, . Heather Bottomley is reported missing August 2001, . Serena Abbotsway was reported missing In September 2001, .

The police and the Royal Canadian Mounted Police formed Project Evenhand to take over the stagnant police investigation for the missing women because they just weren't getting anywhere . To be honest , I don't know whether they just weren't getting anywhere or whether they weren't fully investigating yeah doing it well enough .

I mean , they weren't doing it well enough , and even they admit that now . October 2001, . Diane Rock is reported missing . November 2001 , mona Wilson by January 2002 , the task force had 50 names on the list . It was in early February 2002 , when the police finally managed to get a warrant 2002 .

Sarah

Yeah , and that's not even in a time where there wasn't any forensics Like DNA was a thing then , yeah , exactly .

Kate

So they finally managed to get a warrant to search the Picton Farm . Willie had been one of the many suspects on the case of the disappearing women . Until now , police had failed to find any concrete reason to search the premises . I mean , he's got a frigging Picton Farm people , you don't need to be in the police force to find that suspicious .

It's a bit of a famous thing , isn't it Like never trust anyone who's got a Picton Farm , anyway . So now they had their chance . They had a tip off about a stash of illegal firearms . I mean , part of me wonders if they did actually have a tip off or whether they were like we need to search that farm . Oh , we got a tip .

But anyway , they had a tip off about stash of illegal firearms and it gave them what they needed to search the farm . But the warrant , what they found was so much worse than they thought . So the police did find the illegal firearms , strangely enough , but they also found a lot of items belonging to several of the missing women . They found purses , ids .

They found an ID that belonged to Heather Bottomley and an asthma inhaler that belonged to Serena Abbotsway . Both brothers were arrested immediately and David was actually released . The next day A further search warrant was obtained and by this time the police had turned the place inside out .

What they found was the work of the most prolific serial killer that Canada has ever seen . The officers discovered human skulls that had been cut in half like that , with mummified hands and feet bound up inside oh , I know . Bloody clothes and jaw bones with teeth .

Photos of the remains of a woman later proved to be Mona Wilson , in a rubbish bin , a Spanish fly aphrodisiac , several pairs of handcuffs , night vision goggles and a.22 revolver with a dildo on the barrel . Oh , prepare yourself .

Willie was asked about this and he said that he used it as a silencer when he used to shoot the pigs Right , right , this is horrible . I mean not the rest of it isn't , but the dildo was found to have the DNA of Picton on it and one of the victims . Forensic said at least one of the women had been shot in the vagina whilst being penetrated with it .

Oh my God , I know .

Sarah

You know , you know we had that discussion I'm not gonna digress too much because I'd like to discuss it at the end . But you discussed like where is that line where they go from citizen to murderer ? But then you've also then got where's that ? Line where they then start picking dildos to gums , I don't know .

Kate

I don't know whether it's you know , like they say with drugs where they say you know , or marijuana . It's a gateway drug . It leads on to you know Coke , and then Coke leads on to heroin and yeah . I don't know if it's maybe something like that where you know , once you've gone over that lip of I've kind of started now .

Sarah

Now I'm bit bored with that , so I'm gonna step it up and I'm gonna go and do this and I'm gonna , yeah , but that needs to be in you , though , doesn't it that level of depravity , that need , or that want to do , or the imagination to do Something that's disgusting . I know Something like that . That's not just a oh , I've killed , and that wasn't enough .

Actually , I'm gonna try something else that doesn't occur in everybody .

Understanding the Dark Side

Kate

I think you know , when you were saying about thing about pedophiles , and you were saying that that's always in you . I do believe that . I do believe that for Willie Picton , he probably always had that side , that dark side , that just wicked evil , that festering shit . That's somewhere in your psyche , in your soul , whatever it is .

But my thing is , when you go from being a normal person , a normal person , to the outside world , you either take that step to then become a murderer or you don't . And there's probably billions and billions of people on this planet that have got that dark side in them . But what is it that's stopping that ? Is it the love of their family ?

Is it the fact that they wouldn't be able to let their partner down or their parents down , or there's something that's holding that back and holding it in ?

And for other people , they either don't hold it in or something happens in their life that then they can't hold it in anymore , and then it comes out and then they start killing , or I wish I knew , because this is a conversation I had with Josie the other day when we was watching about the pedophile was that I don't know about you .

Sarah

The one . I don't know about you , but I understand that pedophiles are attracted to children and that's something that they can't help . The same is being gay or being straight . That's something that you can't help .

Kate

Yeah , it's not a choice .

Sarah

Yeah , it's not a choice , but they know that it's wrong . To this they cover up .

Kate

I think no , is choosing to act on it .

Sarah

Yeah , but they're not choosing to not get help or they're the same as being a murderer . If you've got that in you and you think , god , I'd really love to murder someone , I think if that was me , I'd probably seek help .

Kate

Yeah , but yeah , and I do think with that , I do think it is on par with pedophiles , because you don't necessarily choose to be a certain way or have certain . You can't choose to have certain feelings . You fall in love with who you fall in love with , and I don't I mean that as a rule for everyone not pedophiles , but as in being gay .

Well , how many times in my life have I heard someone say , yeah , but that's your choice , it's up to you , and they feel like they're saying the right thing and it's like it's not my choice . If I had my choice , I wouldn't be gay , because it's been .

At times it's been really difficult and when I was a teenager and I was finding myself and I used to go to a gay club in Chelmsford , it was scary , you know , it was scary , and this was in the 90s , you know , and it was .

We would come out and there would be groups of people other kids , teenagers that just wanted to beat people up because they knew that it was kicking out time at a gay club or pub . It wasn't a club , so that's how they got their kicks , you know . They would come down and they would stand outside and it was scary .

And it's like so for me when people used to say to me yeah , but that's your choice . You know , it's never been my choice . I would never . It would have been much easier for me to have fallen in love with a guy , had a normal existence . I had to hide it from many people because I didn't feel comfortable enough .

And even now , even now , in this day and age , there will still be people that will assume that Claire is not my partner . Oh , you know , is this your friend ? Or even when we're at the hospital , oh , you know , your friend can wait there , and you know , and things like that .

And it's like no , she's not my friend , she's my partner , she's actually my fiance now , you know , and things like that . Even when I had a , they wanted to do an ECG and she said about oh , hang on , I just need to pull the curtain and that . And I said that's my partner .

So , and she went oh , sorry , sorry , you know , it happens all the time but it's not a choice and I get that with pedophiles . I understand that it's not a choice but , like you said , they know it's wrong , they know it's illegal .

There are pedophiles that I've seen , you know , on certain documentaries that have chosen to , you know , hospitalize themselves and have the chemical castration , you know , and things like that . And I think I don't think bad of them because they've never acted on it . And I think that must be really hard , it must be , really hard to feel something like that .

Imagine for us if you're in love with Josie and I'm in love with Claire and someone came up to us and said that's illegal , which in some places it is . Yeah you know that's illegal . If you act on that you're gonna go to prison . You know you're breaking the law . Get help . If you feel like that , you get help . I think do you know what ?

Good for you you didn't act on it . When you act on it , you're the scum of the earth . Yeah , that's . I can't get past that . You're taking someone else's choice away . You know children can't make that choice to be in a sexual relationship because they're children .

You know , when people murder and rape and do things like that , it's like that whole thing in it where you hear kids saying I think most kids go through it when you say to them don't do that , and they go I can if I want , you know , and it's like , no , you can't .

You need to get used to this world telling you no because if you're like I can if I want attitude gonna end up in prison . Yeah , there were several heads and limbs in the freezers and the deeper the police dug , unfortunately , the more they found . There were bags and bags of blood stained clothes . There was a big blood stained mattress .

Clumps of hair and small bones were found everywhere at the farm . There were packs of ground meat in the freezers which , when tested contained the DNA of several of the victims , so he actually processed .

One of the investigators , darryl Hetherington , kept pigs herself , so she went off to check the animals and she found that the pigs were without food , without water and the pens were like literally filling up with muck . One of the sales had recently given birth but the piglets had slid down into the muddy yard and they were all dead .

There were other pigs in horrendous state . One was unable to stand because its leg was so infected that it was just rotting away while it was still alive . She called the vet straight away and several of the pigs had to be put down . The following day she brought food from her own farm and fed the other pigs that were all still relatively okay .

But I mean , god bless her . Like there's all that going on and she's witnessing one of the most horrific like murder crime scenes that they've ever seen . And she was off at her farm getting food and bringing it back for the pigs and for the piggies , I know , bless her .

British Columbia Health officials issued an alert for anyone who had meat from the Picton's farm . Oh , can you imagine ? Oh God , and they were A recall ? Yeah , it was . They were told to hand it in place , but you can take human flesh . Yeah , and it did .

Sarah

Oh no .

Kate

Yeah , I know so . People that had been buying meat from the Picton's farm , which they had done for like years and years and years . They'd been fed other meat . Lisa Yields was in absolute disbelief when the news broke . Do you remember ? Lisa Yields was like the other another one of Willie's , like close friends . They were quite good mates .

But she'd worked with Willie for years on the farm and she'd taken hundreds , several hundreds of pounds of ground meat every month to distribute to the many meat shops all over the area . And she was just like Jesus Christ .

Sarah

Wasn't Lisa the one that so they had these driving licenses and was like , why have you got these ? And she suspected that he was the reason that the girls were missing and then went . Nah , I don't trust it .

Kate

She's not gonna say . She's not gonna say yeah , yeah .

Sarah

Did she like human meat in a ground up beef ?

Kate

She liked that do ya , lisa , yeah , but this was when she had the realization that she said she'd eaten a lot of meat from the farm oh , and it would have had human remains in it . And she thinks that that's how she contracted hepatitis C , which is rank in it . Yeah , not great .

I mean to get like hep C anyway , but to get it through eating people Moving on . Even though some of the meat was obviously like human remains , it's also worth mentioning that even the meat that was pork , it was from pigs that have been fed on human remains .

Sarah

God . Probably like rotten pigs as well .

Kate

Yeah , well , apparently I was reading in the book as well .

I didn't include it , but Lisa I think it was Lisa that said that quite often Willie would take pigs and things and other animals like cows and things like that from the meat market and he would get it for a really good price because he would process meat that was like from animals that had like abscesses and things like from animals that would quite clearly be

diseased and ill with different things and he would get them cheap and then he would just process the meat and sell it off like nothing . So it's probably a lot of people that were ill from his meat anyway .

Yeah , the wood chipper at the farm had part of a foot in it and the pig stars , when dug over , were found to have a lot of teeth and bone fragments in the bottom of the stars . So obviously they'd just been put in the stars and the pigs had just worked through what they could eat . A wrist bone was found as a DNA match for Georgina Papins .

More and more pieces were discovered as the police dug . There were toes and heel bones and human ribs . There was a lot of that that was found . Many pieces of vertebrae were found and they showed that they had been cut with a reciprocating saw Showing that the body had been cut in half lengthwise .

Whilst hung up , exactly the same way that Picton did with the pigs , picton hid the skulls and hands and feet as they were obviously human , but we can only assume that he passed the arm and leg bones off as animal waste to the rendering plant , as no arm and leg bones were ever found at the farm , so they must have been shipped off .

Willie Picton was a small framed man . He weighed about £155 , which is about 11 stone , remember Ratface . So he was of a rat frame Gawnt , yes , and he'd been butchering women for years and just feeding them to the pigs . Oh , it's just sick . Willie Picton had an undercover officer placed in his cell with him after he was arrested .

Yeah but I watch that video .

Sarah

I put it on TikTok .

Kate

He then confessed to this officer that he'd murdered 49 women and his biggest regret was that he needed just one more to make it to the Big 5.0 . I'm glad he didn't .

Sarah

Yeah , he goes on about that a lot , doesn't he ? Yeah , he's really gutted about that .

Kate

The officer suggested the best way to dispose of a body was in the ocean and Willie replied I did better than that a rendering plant . So I mean that is what he did . The rendering plant thought that there was like , because there was funny chunks of meat in there bits and they were saying it's unlikely that they would do that .

Picton lured the girls back to his place with the promise of drugs and money . He then raped them and murdered them in the most horrific ways . Some of these victims were stabbed to death , some were injected with antifreeze , some were strangled , others were shot .

So he really tried a whole array of murder and he said after that he would bleed them and gut them , chop them up and feed them to the pigs . Whatever the pigs left , he would just send the rendering plant . On 22nd of February 2002 , picton was charged with two counts of first degree murder , which was Serena Abbotsway and Mona Wilson .

On the 2nd of April , three more charges were added Jacqueline Macdonald , diane Rock and Heather Bottomley . On the April 9th , a sixth charge was added , which was Andrea Joesbury , followed soon after by Brenda Wolfe , september 20th . Georgina Papin , patricia Johnson , helen Hallmark and Jennifer Firminger were also added October 3rd .

Heather Chinook , tanya Hollick , sherry Irving and Inger Hall were added , bringing the total to 15 .

On 26th of May 2005 , 12 more charges were added , which was Cara Ellis , andrea Borhaven , deborah Lynn Jones , marnie Frey , tiffany Drew , kerry Koski , sarah DeVres , cynthia Felix , angela Jardine , wendy Crawford , diana Melnick and Jane Doe they don't know who she was bringing the total of first degree murder charges to 27 .

Forensic pathologists spent the next two years sifting through 370,000 cubic yards of mud and pigment to find the pieces of the missing women . The trial began in 2006, . The judge decided to split the trial into six and 20 , with one being dismissed due to lack of evidence and because they didn't know who this Jane Doe was or when she was killed .

So they had like zero evidence to prosecute him for that , which is really sad that they just have never found out who she was . And she met this hideous , brutal end to her life , and no one knows anything about her . These six were chosen by the judge as the judge deemed them to be materially different to the other 20 . Picton pled not guilty Right .

Sarah

Prick Wasn't me , I don't know how all that happened .

Kate

The trial pushed ahead , with the jurors struggling to cope with the horrific stream of photos that were placed in front of them . The judge had to call recess several times because the jurors were just too shaken to continue .

On the 9th of December 2007 , after nine days of deliberation , the jury gave its final verdict and they found Willie Picton guilty of six counts of second degree murder . On the 11th of December 2007 , supreme Court Judge James Williams sentenced Willie Picton to life in prison , with no eligibility for parole for 25 years .

Apparently , that's the highest punishment possible . That's crazy , isn't it it is .

Willie and Dave Picton's Crimes

Upon sentencing , the judge said Mr Picton's conduct was murderous , and repeatedly so . I cannot know the details , but I know this . What happened to them , as in the women , was senseless and despicable . There is nothing I can say to express the revulsion the community feels about these killings .

The women who were murdered , each of them , were members of our community . They were women who had troubled lives . Each of them found themselves in positions of extreme vulnerability . They were persons who were in the ugly grasp of substance abuse and addictions , persons who were selling their bodies to strangers in order to survive .

As Judge Williams read the sentence , two of the female jurors wiped away their tears and Willie Picton finally showed some emotion . He smirked You'd punch his face in , wouldn't ?

Sarah

you yeah , yeah , I'm up in your sentence , yeah yeah , right , okay , you like that .

Kate

I have another one . Yeah , no , I'd be like , okay , if you feel like that now you're going to do 10 of those years without any lights on . I mean , that's one of the many reasons I'm not judge . Yeah , oh , you like that , all right , no water . Eight years , no water ? Oh , like that , all right , 10 .

I know I'd be a rubbish judge , but that's definitely you know . Like we say about your buttons , you get people smirking . Such a massive button for me . Well , like when you're trying to tear the kids off , they're like any kind of smirking , like I just absolutely hate it . It's a proper button pusher . And it's like people smirk Like I become aggressive .

I'm like , why are you fucking smirking ? Why are you laughing ? Oh , I can feel it giving me the rage now . No one's even trying , it's only me that's smirking .

Sarah

You've pissed yourself off . I'm trying to now recall back any time that I've ever smirked during the podcast . Yeah , it's not very often . I get told off , so it's not like a , you know .

Kate

I don't tell you off , it's not very often I do anything wrong . Look , I hold up planes for you , Pody . I know you do . I wouldn't smirk at you . There were numerous appeals after this , but by August 2010, . This feels like recent .

Sarah

I know when I was like looking it up and stuff after the first one I was obviously googling and it said like the 2000s . I was like what I know ? The 2000s seem like yesterday , don't they Not like ?

Kate

20 years ago , they seem really , really close .

Sarah

So all of these murders like serial killers generally I associate with the 80s .

Kate

Yeah , it's funny , isn't it ? I do too , but a lot of them are a lot more recent . I mean , when I talk about like 2001 , 2002 , that feels recent to me . But the 90s feel recent to me as well . I think the 90s that's not that long ago . It was , I know . But I think like that about Channel 4 .

I remember when Channel 4 came out , we only had BBC One , bbc Two and ITV . That was it . And the telly went off at midnight .

So you'd put it on and it would say like this ends our broadcast , and then it would play a little tune , and then it'd be , and then it would be like that for I don't know , like 10 minutes , 15 minutes , and then it would go to snow .

Sarah

Yeah , I remember in the mornings they didn't really play anything . Programs used to start at like seven or something .

Kate

Yeah , and then they brought out Channel 4 . And I was like , ooh , a new channel .

Sarah

It was a bit of a risk channel Channel 5 was a big deal though , weren't it ?

Kate

I'd kind of got over it . I'd already witnessed the beginning of Channel 4 . And I was like , ooh , a new channel . So , bellatime , channel 5 was out . I was like , eh , just hang on Netflix yeah . Yeah , exactly , and I remember when Netflix was just DVDs and they used to post the DVD out to you .

Sarah

Yeah , gosh , so weird didn't it yeah . They used to have that posted DVDs and we have digressed ?

Kate

Yes , so well . So there were . So there was numerous appeals after , but by August 2010 , british Columbia Crown officials ruled that there would be no trial for the remaining 20 women's deaths because Picton was already serving six life sentences consecutively .

So , yeah , that's not enough , I know , but the reason that they did that was because they wanted to spare the families the yeah , like traumatic Trialing , yeah , and the thing is that that was like one of the most traumatic trials that had gone on , and that was six of the women . You imagine doing that for 20 .

Sarah

Yeah , it damaged a lot of people .

Kate

Yeah , it was , and the jurors as well . It would have been horrendous for the jurors to go through that . It was bad enough to do it for the six . But also , that aside , they also wanted to save the court system the money , because with the six women's trial that they had , it cost just over a hundred and two million dollars for those six women .

Sarah

And I think that's crazy .

Kate

Yes , it's mad . So you think , even if it was just that again , it's such a lot of money and he's never coming out of prison . Yeah . You know he's six life sentences . He had to do consecutively so that and then he would have to wait like 25 years before even being considered for parole .

So , yeah , you know , I guess the judges are like you know what we need to do ? A little bit of damage limitation on all sides . The police have apologized unreservedly to the families of the victims and the local community for their sluggish response and failure to see the monster in their midst .

Today , picton is 73 years old and he is serving life in Port Cartier , a maximum security prison in Quebec . David Picton denied all knowledge of his brother's crimes and , according to reports , he was seen in the downtown Vancouver area where his brother found his victims in 2011 .

But his exact whereabouts remains a mystery and when I was looking , when I was researching some of this on the internet , I actually saw that there was a post not a missing poster , but it was like a missing poster with a picture of Dave Picton saying there's been reports that Dave Picton has been seen in this area .

If you see this man call this number and all that , so everyone , because we don't know , do we ? He could have been . He could have been involved in a lot of it . He was a spiteful git . Yeah , dave Picton . So who's to say that he wasn't involved in it ? Yeah , who knows , maybe he's got the potential to continue it on .

Sarah

Yeah , yeah , he's to say that he didn't even know . He must have known . I'm sticking out of the bloody grinder .

Kate

Exactly If the police can go in there and search around a few bits and go straight away .

Sarah

Yeah , and there was there was a piece of cargo hanging up and skulls feet , hands , yeah , all stuffed in freezers .

Kate

There was heads . No , I don't believe that he didn't know anything about it . So , yeah , of course people are going to want to know he's whereabouts . Do you know what I mean ? If he's in and amongst your community , you're going to want to know .

Dave and his sister Linda brought a lawsuit against the Royal Canadian Mounted Police , the Mounties , for damages to the property , the RCMP , the audacity , I know . Apparently , the Mount is disturbed , disrupted , killed and destroyed various plants .

Sarah

Yeah , but do you know why ? Do you know why they did that ?

Kate

Yeah , because your brother was murdering people . Yeah , they were killing , disrupting , disturbing and destroying people , jesus Christ . Yeah , so they said that they upset the vegetation and the fish in the pond .

Sarah

Yeah , yeah , yeah , I can imagine they were heartbroken . Yeah , yeah .

Kate

I bet they were gutted about all of that . They also stated that the RCMP had demolished , removed , destroyed and rendered uninhabitable various buildings and equipment on the property . To this day , this matter has not been resolved . Yeah , I don't suppose it would .

The province has a 10 million lian on the property to secure the recovery of legal expenses relating to the Picton trial . I'm not surprised if it cost them like 100 and something million . Today the farm has been completely dismantled and all that remains on the site is a few mounds of earth with a chain link fence around it .

Friends and family of the deceased women would like to see it turned into a memorial park , but currently the only residents there are Canadian geese .

Serial Killer Mindset Discussion

What do you reckon ?

Sarah

I need to get your thoughts on it because I'm a little bit fuming about the brother and sister and that they'd have the audacity to try and claim damages to the property .

Kate

They're just those kind of people , aren't they ? They're just somewhat of the ridiculous is an understatement .

Sarah

Yeah , I reckon here he goes , go on , I'll have a drink . Yeah , we were talking about having that in you , about all of this hatred , yeah , that I don't want to call it Evil , evil , yeah . But I also feel like it probably stemmed from when his cow got murdered and hung up on the hook .

I think that's traumatised him from a young age , and because trauma can change the chemistry in the brain , can't it ? Yes , it does so at a young age , doesn't it ? At a young age , I think that was a very traumatic event for him .

Seeing that and witnessing that and then , being at a young age as well , taught how to slaughter the pigs , that all kind of desensitises you to what he's doing basically . So to do that to something else wouldn't be any different . So I think that it stemmed from that , from when his cow was murdered and hung up , and he's witnessed that .

I think that's why , then , he did the same thing to his victims .

Kate

I think a lot of it is as well because he could In his head , because from all reports of people that knew him they'll say no , he did genuinely try and get these girls cleaned up and sorted out and that . And I think maybe somewhere along the road he's thought in his own head they're lost cows . And then he had all the means of doing that , didn't he ?

Without getting caught . He did it a lot . He did like 49 times he killed someone . He did what he wanted to do with them . He killed them . He processed them exactly like he would with the pigs . He only had small bits to hide , if you like , so he only had to hide the head , hands and feet . They didn't really do ?

Sarah

that did he ? No , he stored them . He didn't hide them .

Kate

But , you know , and then he would give what he gave to the pigs to finish off , probably saved himself money on pig food as well , and then thought , you know , I'll take the rest to the rendering plant , and then it's gone and done and nobody , no crime .

You know , and I think after he did that a few times he probably thought it maybe gave him a sense of like power . He must have had some kind of enjoyment out of it when he did it .

Sarah

Yeah , the thing is with having too much power and like too much money and things like that is that you will never get what you want . It's the same as I watched a documentary about fame yesterday and it said that people want to be famous , but when they acquire that , it's not what they want .

So they're always striving to achieve something and that's why they've got all this money and then they go down the route of drugs and things like that , because they're still not getting what they think that they want or what they need . So I think it's a similar thing .

Yes , and that in the previous episode you said that he just wanted to be normal and he kept saying to people I want a normal life , and I think that's because he knew inside himself that he wasn't normal . So he wanted to be normal and do normal things because he didn't feel normal , and then he finally relented to the fact that that's never going to happen .

So I'll just do what I want to do .

Kate

Yeah , but he also did it in secret , so it was a bit like he's dirty , dirty secret , wasn't it ? You know like , even when he had Ellington , when he had his friend there , and he was like , yeah , let's go and get hooker . And she was like all right , you know , can we get some drugs as well ? And he was like , yeah , sure you know .

She went off and went to a room , I don't know , slept , had a nap , got high , whatever it was she was doing , and he thought , well , I've got hooker now , so I'll go and do it . But his first reaction when she came to the barn and was like , oh my God , he was like be quiet .

Yeah , yeah , he knew what he was doing , but he didn't ever try and like include someone in on it or anything . You know it was like he's . It became his enjoyment . I think yeah , I think he just enjoyed doing it and I actually don't think he was aware that he'd like he was trying to get to the big 5-0 . I don't believe that .

I don't think he would have had any idea of how many women he killed . Yeah , and I think it was when they said you , you are going to be like . We've found evidence of like 49 women .

Sarah

I think they've put .

Kate

I'm going to be in prison , so I might as well look like a you know badass .

Sarah

Yeah , I think 49 names to the people , or something like that , wasn't it ?

Kate

Yeah .

Sarah

I don't understand it because I don't . I don't think that , no it's , it's .

Kate

It's definitely perplexing to try and get inside the mind of someone that can do like the worst things imaginable yeah that , that level of depravity as well , yeah , so it completely complete disregard to the body and yeah , and that , that life , but I do my own heading .

Sarah

Yeah , I know yeah . Because you go around in circles and you think Because I always say I genuinely believe that everything happens for a reason .

Kate

Yeah .

Sarah

I do believe that . But when it comes to things like that , like murder and stuff , I always think what , what , why , what was gained out of that ? What was the reason behind that ? Why did that happen ? And what ? What did the universe ? What was the point ?

Kate

to try and tell us and yeah , yeah , you do feel like that . Yeah , what's your ?

Sarah

point yeah , what are you trying to teach everybody ? I don't , I don't , I don't get it , do you ?

Kate

Let us know what you guys think . Yeah , we don't , we don't get it , we don't understand . But we would love to hear some other perspective on it , because I just I don't understand it If let's get inside a killer's head and just see , because that's less face it .

That's why we're all here , that's why we're all listening and talking , because we just feel some sort of urge to get in the side .

Sarah

The mind of yeah , we're fascinated by things that you don't understand , I think that's why everybody goes . Oh , you're watching a series of videos , your killer documentaries and you know reading books on child abuse and things like that .

And it's oh , it's strange to say that you enjoy watching those things or you enjoy reading about those things , because it's it's a strange thing to enjoy , but it's a fascination because you don't understand it . So you've got to consume all of this information to be able to .

Kate

I think it's human . Yeah , crime gets some kind of understanding .

Sarah

Yeah , we're programmed to try and understand things , absolutely so you're not weirdos , it's a normal human , I mean that's a bold statement . It depends to what level you've enjoyed the story .

Kate

What level weirdo are you ?

Sarah

Let us know If you have enjoyed listening to our episodes . Make sure you rate us and leave us a review , on whatever platform you are listening .

Kate

We absolutely love hearing from you guys , so you can also help support our show by donating to our Buy Me a Coffee link . We will make sure that you get a massive shout out and a big thank you in our next week's episode .

Sarah

You can also follow us on social media . At Perplex Podcasts . We're on Facebook , instagram and if you want to see more videos and blooper reels , subscribe to our TikTok and YouTube channels .

Kate

You can also email us your stories at perplexpodcastsatgmailcom .

Sarah

And you can find all the relevant links in the episode descriptions . Thanks for listening , bye , bye .

Kate

Who are you seeing ?

Sarah

He's going to meet a boy , a boy , a very gay boy . Oh , meeting a gay boy ? Yeah , and we're going out with him and his husband tonight to bingo , aren't we ?

Kate

Well , that's very gay .

Sarah

Ah , yeah , yeah . They're our gay couple friend , aren't they ? You are our gay couple friend .

Kate

I was going to say Bye .

Transcript source: Provided by creator in RSS feed: download file
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android