Get ready for a thrilling ride as we dive into the most baffling and shocking murder mysteries that will leave you speechless! From cold cases to recent crimes, we're counting down the most mind-boggling whodunits that will keep you on the edge of your seat. With twists and turns at every corner, these true crime stories will make you question everything you thought you knew about humanity. So, if you're ready to have your mind blown, then join us as we explore the most jaw-dropping murder myste...
Mar 05, 2025•12 min
In the small town of Truro, Nova Scotia, a mysterious disappearance shook the community to its core. 3-year-old Dylan Ehler vanished into thin air, leaving behind a trail of unanswered questions and a family desperate for answers. Join us as we delve into the baffling case of Dylan Ehler's disappearance, exploring the events surrounding his vanishing and the investigation that followed. From the initial search efforts to the theories and suspects that emerged, we'll examine every aspect of this ...
Feb 21, 2025•5 min
Sometime during the night of Monday, November 15, 1971, in the Fort Hill section of Charleston, West Virginia, Dr. Charles Cotrell and his wife Betty were shot in the den of their home. Many believe the answer to the question of who killed the Cotrells came 6 days later when the Cotrell's son, Charles Jr., died in a deliberate auto accident. Others, however, are not so sure.
Feb 07, 2025•5 min•Season 2Ep. 3
Today, we dive into the chilling cases of Shannon Paulk and Heaven LaShae Ross, exploring the events surrounding their disappearances and murders. Shannon and Shae, as her parents and friends called her, disappeared within 2 years of each other in Alabama and many think the cases could be connected. #smalltownmurders #unsolvedcrimes #unsolvedmurders #murdermystery #crime #mystery #truecrimecommunity #truecrimestories #alabama #alabamahistory
Jan 31, 2025•5 min•Season 2Ep. 3
Bardstown Kentucky is known as the most beautiful small town in America. It is also home to a string of unsolved murders that may or may not be connected. Connect with us on social media and listen wherever you get your podcasts.
Jan 25, 2025•5 min•Season 2Ep. 1
On the morning of October 4th, 1988, 11-year-old Annette Saygers was last seen standing at a bus stop near her home in Mount Holly, South Carolina. Despite Annette reportedly leaving behind a note explaining her absence, she has not been seen or heard from in over 30 years. Neither has her mother, Korrina Malinoski, who disappeared eleven months before Annette. What happened to this mother and daughter? Did they leave together? Did Annette's mother come back for her as stated in the note? If so,...
Jan 24, 2025•5 min•Season 2Ep. 1
This week we begin our 2-part series on family annihilator John List. Link to Patreon, Merch, and pretty much everything else about us https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod Link to our sponsor DB Journey https://bit.ly/37cP8YP
Sep 04, 2021•2 hr 43 min
This week we begin our 2-part series on family annihilator John List. Link to Patreon, Merch, and pretty much everything else about us https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod
Jul 11, 2021•2 hr 36 min
This week we discuss the murder of Mary Faye Hunter. Link to Patreon, Merch, and pretty much everything else about us https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod Link to our sponsor Baxter Blue https://baxterblueglasses.pxf.io/c/2544961/1031264/11471 Promo for Ye Olde Crime Podcast
Jun 01, 2021•1 hr 11 min
This week we discuss the murders of civil rights activist Harry Moore and his wife Harriette. Link to Patreon, Merch, and pretty much everything else about us https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod Link to our sponsor Real Sleep https://www.realsleep.com/discount/POD Use the code "POD"
May 13, 2021•1 hr 16 min
This week we discuss what was really going on at the Lamb Funeral Home in Pasadena. Here's a clue...it wasn't good. Link to Patreon, Merch, and pretty much everything else about us https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod Link to our sponsor Skin Store https://www.skinstore.com/pod.list
Apr 29, 2021•1 hr 15 min
This week we conclude our discussion of the Texarkana Phantom Killer. We go in depth into the background and evidence against suspect H.B. "Doodie" Tennison. Link to Patreon, Merch, and pretty much everything else about us https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod Link to our sponsor Skin Store https://www.skinstore.com/pod.list
Apr 22, 2021•2 hr 58 min
This week we continue our discussion of the Texarkana Phantom Killer. We go in depth into the background and evidence against suspect Youell Swinney. Link to Patreon, Merch, and pretty much everything else about us https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod Link to our sponsor Skin Store https://www.skinstore.com/pod.list
Apr 15, 2021•2 hr 55 min
This week we continue our discussion of the Texarkana Phantom Killer. Link to Patreon, Merch, and pretty much everything else about us https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod Link to our sponsor Podgo https://podgo.co/
Apr 08, 2021•2 hr 47 min
This week we begin our discussion of the Texarkana Phantom Killer. We dive into the first three attacks. Link to Patreon, Merch, and pretty much everything else about us https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod Link to our sponsor Skin Store https://www.skinstore.com/pod.list
Apr 01, 2021•2 hr 57 min
This week we conclude our 5-part series on The Colonial Parkway Murders by discussing theories and suspects. Link to our stuff: https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod Link to Audible: https://audibletrial/onecrime
Mar 09, 2021•2 hr 7 min
This week we continue our deep dive series on The Colonial Parkway Murders by discussing the murders of Annamaria Phelps and Daniel Lauer. Link to our stuff: https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod Link to Audible: https://audibletrial/onecrime
Feb 08, 2021•2 hr 35 min
This week we continue our deep dive series on The Colonial Parkway Murders by detailing the disappearances of Keith Call and Cassandra Hailey. Link to our stuff: https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod Link to Audible: https://audibletrial/onecrime
Jan 29, 2021•2 hr 30 min
This week we continue our deep dive series on The Colonial Parkway Murders by detailing the double murder of David Knobling and Robin Edwards in September of 1987. Link to our stuff: https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod Link to Audible: https://audibletrial/onecrime
Jan 20, 2021•2 hr 48 min
This week we begin our deep dive series on The Colonial Parkway Murders by detailing the double murder of Catherine Thomas and Rebecca Dowski in October of 1986. Link to our stuff: https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod Link to Audible: https://audibletrial/onecrime
Jan 11, 2021•2 hr 37 min
This week we conclude our discussion on the disappearance of Sharron Phillips from Brisbane, Queensland, Australia in 1986. Link to our stuff: https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod
Jan 01, 2021•2 hr 33 min
This week we begin our discussion on the disappearance of Sharron Phillips in Queensland, Australia in 1986. Link to our stuff: https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod
Dec 23, 2020•2 hr 32 min
This week we discuss the Casanova Killer, Paul John Knowles. We detail his 6 month killing spree, wonder if a bad name can actually make you a serial killer, and learn the importance of an accurate intelligence test. Link to our stuff - https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod
Dec 11, 2020•2 hr 48 min
This week we conclude our discussion of the Peyton-Allan Murders. We discuss more suspects and theories, ask the age old question of how long should it take to "catch up", and find out if Courtney Cox has been prowling around Portland. Link to our stuff: https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod
Dec 04, 2020•2 hr 11 min
This week we dive into the murders of Larry Peyton and Beverly Allan. Join us as we discuss the events leading up and the circumstances surrounding the murders, share our weird dreams and allow our porno sides to come out. Link to all of our stuff: https://linktr.ee/onecrimepod Listen to our paranormal podcast Out In The Sticks Here: https://www.spreaker.com/show/out-in-the-sticks...
Nov 19, 2020•1 hr 28 min
This week we discuss the Westfield Watcher, who stalked a family in New Jersey. We read the menacing letters sent by this still unknown individual, talk cucumbers and their various uses, and find out what really goes on at your local Trader Joe's. Support the show at https://patreon.com/onecrimepod Visit cbdMD at cbdmd.t7c9v8.net/onecrimepod Email us at onecrimeatatime@gmail.com Listen to Out In The Sticks at https://anchor.fm/out-in-the-sticks Sources: https://www.thecut.com/2018/11/the-hauntin...
Nov 06, 2020•2 hr 23 min
In honor of the Halloween season, this week we are discussing the real story behind The Amityville Horror. Join us as we detail the murders of the Defeo family, discover that even a man who abuses his family can have a jazzy side, and find out if it's possible to get off on a murder charge by creating a fake brother in law. Email us at onecrimeatatime@gmail.com Support the show! https://www.patreon.com/onecrimepod or https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/my /profile Support our sponsors! Audible - htt...
Oct 29, 2020•2 hr 33 min
This week we conclude our discussion of the Zodiac Killer. Join us as we discuss suspects and theories, reveal if Ed Sullivan is actually a viable suspect and ponder the question of who would call themselves Goldcatcher anyway? Email us at onecrimeatatime@gmail.com Support the show! https://www.patreon.com/onecrimepod or https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/my /profile Support our sponsors! Audible - http://www.audibletrial.com /onecrime Online-Therapy - https://www.online-therapy.com/?ref=188903 ---...
Oct 23, 2020•2 hr 8 min
This week we continue our discussion of the Zodiac Killer. Join us as we read his letters and dive into the psyche of The Zodiac, discuss the importance of seatbelts, and find out if it really is all about the buttons. Email us at onecrimeatatime@gmail.com Support the show! https://www.patreon.com/onecrimepod or https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/my /profile Support our sponsors! Audible - http://www.audibletrial.com /onecrime Online-Therapy - https://www.online-therapy.com/?ref=188903 --- Send in ...
Oct 23, 2020•2 hr 51 min
This week we continue our discussion of the Zodiac Killer. Join us as we go through the last canonical murders attributed to the Zodiac killer, debate how calm is too calm and find out why men should always listen to a woman's intuition. Support the show! https://www.patreon.com/onecrimepod or https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/my /profile Support our sponsors! Audible - http://www.audibletrial.com /onecrime Online-Therapy - https://www.online-therapy.com/?ref=188903 --- Send in a voice message: ht...
Oct 08, 2020•2 hr 40 min
