We kick off this episode with a terrifying update on Luka Magnotta, and then read some letters from listeners who've met people with even worse names than X Æ A-12 Musk . Then we finally get into this week's episode: the kidnapping of Sherri Papini. In 2016, the California "super-mom" was abducted while out jogging (pro tip: this is why we never jog), only to be abruptly released a few weeks later. But some of the details of her disappearance don't quite add up. Danny, Sara, & Casey discuss ...
Feb 10, 2026•1 hr 8 min
You sick f*cks asked, for it, so we're covering Sarah and Jennifer Hart, who fostered 6 children and then one day committed an unthinkable murder-suicide, driving themselves and their children off a cliff. It's truly a, shall we say, hartbreaking case. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Feb 10, 2026•1 hr 4 min
NATC is going ripped from the headlines this week to investigate the whereabouts of JJ Vallow and Tylee Ryan, who have been missing since September from Rexburg, Idaho. Danny, Sara & Casey walk through the twisted web that is this family tree, complete with multiple “suspicious” deaths and a cult. Shouts out to East Idaho news for a very clutch & thorough timeline of this crazy case. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices...
Feb 10, 2026•47 min
Brace yourself, NATC fam, because this episode isn't for the faint of heart. We're going across the pond to discuss the crimes of Fred and Rose West, which include child abuse, rape, murder, and that's not even the half of it. Casey, Danny, and Sara talk about Fred's upbringing and early crimes, all the way up to him meeting his second wife Rose and building a literal house of horrors. Sources: https://www.biography.com/crime-figure/fred-west https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/6998695/fred-rose-west-...
Feb 10, 2026•55 min
Everyone has been going crazy for Netflix's Killer Inside: The Mind Of Aaron Hernandez, so the investigative detectives who make up the elite squad known as the Not Another True Crime Podcast hosts are on this one. Hernandez was many things: a pothead, a star footballer, a regulation hottie, and really, really bad at getting away with murder. Casey, Danny, and Sara discuss Hernandez's brief but dramatic fall from grace as well as the Netflix documentary that everyone's talking about. Learn more ...
Feb 10, 2026•1 hr 9 min
Casey, Danny, and Sara bullsh*t about life in quarantine before diving into the mysterious disappearance of Jennifer Kesse. The 24-year-old Orlando woman went missing on her way to work on January 24, 2006, and basically vanished into thin air. We go into the few details there are about Jennifer's disappearance and recent updates, and of course tell you who we think did it. http://charleyproject.org/case/jennifer-joyce-kesse https://www.nbcnews.com/dateline/family-refuses-give-search-jennifer-ke...
Feb 10, 2026•1 hr 7 min
The NATC Pod crew tackles one of the most requested cases from the fans: the disappearance of Susan Cox Powell. This case has everything: Mormons, a creepy father-in-law, pancakes, a missing woman, and a horrifying twist. Casey, Danny, and Sara break down the case and share their theories as to what happened to Susan. They also play a new game called “my habit that would get me murdered by a serial killer”. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices...
Feb 10, 2026•59 min
The NATC Podcast crew breaks down the craziest moments from Netflix’s Abducted in Plain Sight. From aliens to a hand job, it’s a wild ride from start to finish. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Feb 10, 2026•48 min
In part two of the Laci Peterson murder episode, Danny, Casey, and Sara talk about Scott Peterson's trial, all the evidence (or lack thereof) the state had against him, plus all the shenanigans that went down in the media and in jury deliberation. It's the final episode of 2019, so we also spitball what other cases we want to cover in 2020. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Feb 10, 2026•1 hr 1 min
In part one of a two-part episode, the NATC fam is talking about the case that put Nancy Grace on the map: the murder of Laci Peterson. Fittingly, Laci went missing on December 24, 2002 and was found dead in April 2003. This week, we are going over Laci's final moments and talking about Scott's sketchiness. Then stay tuned for next week when we cover the trial and our theories! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices...
Feb 10, 2026•56 min
Due to popular demand, the NATC Pod gang is doing a deep dive into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann, a 3-year-old British girl who went missing while on vacation with her family in Portugal. They discuss what happened the night she went missing, the shitshow of an investigation (@ Portugal Police), and share theories of what could have happened to her. They also debunk common misconceptions about this case and debate whether watching the entire Netflix documentary on the topic was worth it....
Feb 10, 2026•1 hr 16 min
It sounds too shady to be true, but somehow it is. Rebecca Zahau, girlfriend of millionaire Jonah Shacknai, was found with her hands and feet bound, naked. Her death was ruled a suicide but many, including her family, don’t think that’s the whole story. Danny Casey And sara go over all the strange circumstances surrounding her tragic death and of course the theories. Check out "Over MY Dead Body" by Wondery! https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/over-my-dead-body/id1447892344 Learn more about yo...
Feb 10, 2026•57 min
The NATC crew is back with another Wait, What? where we talk about the hottest true crime documentary du jour. This Wait, What? is all about the murder of 12-year-old Garrett Phillips who was found dead in his home in Potsdam, New York. Police quickly honed in on a suspect... but was it the right guy? Watch the HBO doc, then listen here. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Feb 10, 2026•52 min
This week, the NATCP team went down under to one of the craziest cases in Australia. Kathleen Folbigg is one of the most notorious serial killers, who is spending over 30 years for killing her four kids. Should be an open and shut case, but is it? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Feb 10, 2026•57 min
We're giving you your first taste of Not Another True Crime Podcast season 2 with our first ever "Wait, What?" reaction series. We introduce two brand-new cohosts, Casey Balsham and Danny Murphy, and play a new segment called "Crime and Punishment." Then Sara, Casey, and Danny discuss the buzzy Michael Jackson documentary "Leaving Neverland." They talk about the most shocking revelations, hardest moments to watch, and what the accusations mean for Michael Jackson's legacy. Learn more about your ...
Feb 10, 2026•55 min
The JonBenét Ramsey coverage continues with part two, where we go through the police investigation into JonBenét’s murder, the Ramseys’ weird af attitude towards the media and the police, and finally, the moment you’ve all been waiting for. Wait for it—the theories on who killed JonBenét Ramsey. Will Hannah and Sara solve this famous case? Listen to find out. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Feb 10, 2026•1 hr 23 min
You all asked for it, and you got it—by popular demand, Not Another True Crime Podcast is covering the JonBenét Ramsey murder. This sh*t show of a case is divided into a two-part episode. Part one is all about the actual scene of the crime and what went down at the Ramsey house on Christmas Day, 1996. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Feb 10, 2026•59 min
Anybody who's seen Space Jam knows Michael Jordan took a year off from dominating the NBA in 1993 to try his hand at baseball. Sara sits down with Andrew Jenks, filmmaker and host of the What Really Happened? podcast, to delve into a conspiracy theory that Jordan really tried baseball because he was forced into a year-long suspension. But investigating this conspiracy leads them both to the murder of James Jordan, Michael Jordan's father. Two men were convicted of the murder, but one is claiming...
Feb 10, 2026•44 min
Remember a time before a disappearance would send everyone down social media rabbit holes? Us either, but Maura Murray’s disappearance was one of the first. The 20-year-old nursing student vanished without a trace days after Facebook launched, making it one of the most well-known and frustrating cases of the 2000s. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Feb 10, 2026•1 hr 7 min
In this Criminal Minds -inspired episode, Sara and Hannah recount the f*cked up life of Robert Hansen, an OG incel and real-life serial killer who kidnapped women and released them into the Alaskan wilderness, where he literally hunted them down. Yes, we mean literally in the true sense, and not in the way millennials say it. Find out why Robert Hansen is the reason they say “it’s always the quiet ones you gotta watch out for”. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices...
Feb 10, 2026•1 hr 3 min
On December 18, 2011 (a bad year, evidently), 23-year-old Phoenix Coldon went out for a drive in the middle afternoon and hasn’t been seen or heard from since. But this case starts sketchy and gets sketchier. For one, her car was found hours after she left her house. It was found with the engine running. In traffic. With no sign of her. We will rehash all the murky evidence surrounding Phoenix’s disappearance and try to get to the bottom of how someone can up and vanish in the middle of the afte...
Feb 10, 2026•1 hr 14 min
Danny, Casey, and Sara start this episode off by trying one of the fans’ super secret serial killer trait, and boy is it a scary one. Then in this three-for-one episode, they tackle 3 different people who died on their honeymoons. Did their new spouses kill them, or were these horrible accidents? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Feb 10, 2026•1 hr 4 min
“Hello, it is I, the Nigerian Prince.” Sound familiar? In this special bonus episode, Sara interviews Faraday Okoro and Oscar Hernandez, the director and producer (respectively) of the film Nigerian Prince, out now. Sara, Faraday, and Oscar discuss the film and what it’s like to get sent to live in Nigeria against your will. (Yes, that really happened.) They also talk about why emails from Nigerian Princes always have so many typos. Finally, they discuss some signs you’re getting conned, and the...
Feb 10, 2026•26 min
Sara and Danny are back with a round-up of some current and ongoing stories from the past week's headlines. First up is the ever-present Elizabeth Holmes, who is once again doing whatever it takes to avoid serving her sentence. Next, there are some harrowing updates from the Lori Vallow trial. Then, a viral video reveals that a wanted serial sex offender who faked his own death in the US, has been found in Scotland using a fake name, accent, and potentially several medical ailments. And finally,...
May 01, 2023•31 min
This week, Sara and Danny kick off the show with some updates on Billy McFarland and Elizabeth Holmes. Then, they dive into the unsolved murder of Serge Rubenstein - draft dodging, café society denizen who made his millions through currency manipulation and stock fraud, and was so unlikable that even the Rabbi read him for filth at his own funeral. RESOURCES: https://eastsidefeed.com/odds-and-ends/death-of-a-scoundrel-and-the-unsolved-murder-of-serge-rubenstein/ https://www.nydailynews.com/true-...
Apr 24, 2023•40 min
This week, Sara and Danny catch up on the Trump indictment and Jen Shah's prison book list, before discussing the actual OG Ponzi schemer, Adele Spitzeder. An actress, womanizer, dog mom, philanthropist, nepo baby... literally what can't this b*tch do (other than successfully run a bank without ending up in prison)? To wrap up the show, they dream cast their own made-for-tv movie about Adele: We Could Have Had It All . RESOURCES: https://www.aier.org/article/adele-spitzeder-the-queen-of-confiden...
Apr 17, 2023•1 hr 5 min
This week, Sara and Danny examine the unsolved case of Long Island's very own missing heiress, Alice Parsons. They discuss her unhappy marriage to an oil heir-turned squab farmer (turned squab paste manufacturer), and how his affair with a mysterious Russian housekeeper may very well have lead to Alice's disappearance and probable death. Fake ransom notes, messy evidence, and fights over fortunes abound! To wrap up the show, they play a round of "Edible Dish or Death Wish?", where they try to su...
Apr 10, 2023•50 min
Sara and Danny dive into one of the most notorious con men in history: Frank William Abignale. Popularized by Catch Me If You Can, he has been immortailzed as the ultimate jet-setting conman, but as it turns out, we might've all been conned by the man himself. To end the show, they play a round of "Con Me If You Can!" where they try to fool each other into believing some lie's about themselves. Resources: The Greatest Hoax on Earth: Catching Truth, While We Can by Alan C. Logan https://www.biogr...
Apr 03, 2023•1 hr 6 min
This week, Sara and Danny kick off the episode with a brief update on the Madeleine McCann story, for which we might be beginning to get some answers for. Then, they dig into the episode, taking us all the way back to the 1920s to talk about Ruth Snyder. They kick it off with some background facts about Ruth and her husband Albert, and the affair she led with a salesman that was the beginning of the chain of events that would lead to the murder of her husband. They also talk all about the sensat...
Mar 27, 2023•46 min
Sara and Danny take a look at one of the most well-known mysteries from Australia, the death of the Somerton Man. They dive into the unexplained circumstances under which the body of the unidentified man was found, and the few clues that investigators were able to find. They also get into the cryptic piece of paper found in his pocket, which only said "Tamam Shud." Then they discuss the various theories that have been circulated throughout the years about the identity of the man and the cause of...
Mar 20, 2023•58 min
