20. The Disappearance of Kiplyn Davis: Keep the Porch Light On

May 2, 1995, fifteen-year-old Kiplyn Davis heads to school after a small argument with her dad over waking up too late to put on makeup. She never came home from school that day, and while the case is "solved," there is still a lot of question over it - like where is her body? The boys involved received less than great sentencing, due to the lack of a body. There is so much about this case that I want to go over and over and over.

Sources:

Investigation Discovery, "Nightmare Nextdoor - S8E1, Stealing Beauty."
ABC4 - Utah
The Salt Lake Tribune