Mountain Mysteries: Tales from Appalachia - podcast cover

Mountain Mysteries: Tales from Appalachia

Hailey and Holly www.buzzsprout.com
Welcome to Mountain Mysteries: Tales from Appalachia, a true crime podcast hosted by Holly and Hailey. Join us each week as we dive into murders, missing persons cases, and other spooky and paranormal happenings in the mountains of Appalachia.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

Tonetta Carlisle

In 1989 Tonetta Carlisle disappeared from her home in Chattanooga Tennessee and has never been seen again. A suspect has been presented but there are no solid answers. Her mother is still holding out hope that answers will come. Support the show

Mar 28, 202436 min

Execution Gone Wrong

This week, we dive into the case of Doyle Hamm, a convicted killer who was sentenced to death. Doyle is one of the few people in US history who survived his own execution. Support the show

Mar 21, 202455 min

Who Killed Justin?

When a young child is found dead on his parents' property, police question if those closest to the child may have been responsible. After years of questions without answers, DNA evidence would point them right to a cold-blooded killer. Support the show

Mar 14, 202451 min

Poplar Hill Haunting

This week, we travel to Hillsborough, NC and experience the haunted history of the Poplar Hill Mansion. The home has a plethora of deaths which have led to some terrifying hauntings! Renters of the home have run screaming! Support the show

Mar 07, 202437 min

Death Row Granny

Velma had a normal life... marriage, kids, a home. Her life seemed normal, that was until she started her murder spree. Velma's crimes made her infamous, largely because she was one of the only grandmothers sitting on death row. Join us this week as we learn more about this 'death row granny'! Support the show

Feb 29, 202442 min

The Short Family Homicide Part 2

This week we follow up with the investigation into the murders of Mr. and Mrs. Short along with the abduction of their daughter Jennifer. Where is Jennifer? Who took her and what was the motive? Learn more as we conclude with part two. Support the show

Feb 22, 202449 min

The Short Family Homicide Part 1

Join us this week as we dive into the Short Family Homicide. When both parents are killed and their daughter goes missing the town rallies together to search for her. Who killed the Short parents, and where is Jennifer? Support the show

Feb 15, 202441 min

The Colonial Parkway Murders

This week we are traveling to Virginia to discuss the Colonial Parkway Murders that occured between 1986-1989. In recent years, it is believed that several other homicides may be tied to the same killer. Support the show

Feb 08, 202439 min

The Ruthless Murder of Pearl Bryan

Pearl Bryan had it all...wealth, beauty, charm and social status. The one thing she didn't have was true love. When she finally found the man of her dreams, he turned out to be evil incarnate. Join us as we travel to Kentucky and reveal more about this unspeakable crime. Support the show

Feb 01, 202451 min

Letchworth Village

Join us this week as we travel to New York to discuss the Letchworth Village. This village was designed to be the new future for the care of those with mental illness. However, overcrowding and abuse infiltrated the village. We dive into the history and some of the horrific tales from the village. Support the show

Jan 25, 202449 min

The Winecoff Hotel

Join us this week as we discuss the tragedy of the Winecoff Hotel. This incident would prove to be the most deadly hotel fire in American History. We discuss the history, the event, and some spooky guests who never checked out. Support the show

Jan 18, 20241 hr

The Ghost of Nell Cropsey

A young woman is found dead in Elizabeth City, NC. Was it her suitor or another man? Legend says her ghost haunts the home where she was last seen. Support the show

Jan 11, 202428 min

Flat Rock Church

This week we travel to Flat Rock, NC to visit the Flat Rock Church. This church has its own spooky history and a few ghostly visitors to discuss. Support the show

Jan 04, 202434 min

Serial Killer Henry Gaskins

This week we dive into the case of Henry "PeeWee" Gaskins. This guy liked to talk and confess to things, but was any of it accurate? Support the show

Dec 28, 202338 min

The Murders at Richards Mansion

When two Tennessee sisters and a young man are killed, the case is quickly closed, which leaves everyone scratching their heads. Years later, will new evidence lead to answers? Join us this week for a puzzling case! Support the show

Dec 21, 202338 min

The Tragic Case of Katie Autry

When a fire alarm awakens students living in the Poland Hall Dormitory, most think it's a drill. To everyone's horror there has been a fire, but so much more. A young girl has been brutalized and is clinging to life. Join us this week as we discuss the story of Katie Autry. Support the show

Dec 14, 202341 min

The Church Hill Tunnel

A day late, but there's a great story headed your way tonight! This one features a semi-collapsed tunnel underneath a prominent Richmond community. It's not just any tunnel... some say, it's haunted! Support the show

Dec 07, 202329 min

The Hollywood Cemetery

This week we travel to Virginia to the Hollywood Cemetery. We dive into its history and some local haunts! Support the show

Nov 30, 202332 min

Rapid Fire Questions with Holly and Hailey

Happy Thanksgiving! While we spend time with our families enjoy this fun episode where we ask each other some rapid fire questions and find out how much we truly know each other. We will see you next week for another haunted tale! Support the show

Nov 23, 202324 min

Madalina Cojocari

This week we are in Cornelius North Carolina discussing the missing person case of Madalina Cojocari, a 12 year old girl. There are many theories out there but the most important thing is finding her. Support the show

Nov 16, 202339 min

Heath High Shooting

They didn't know when they woke up that something as common place as going to school would turn into a fight for their lives. Join us this week as we discuss the Heath High School Shooting from 1997. Support the show

Nov 09, 202353 min

The Salem Witch Trials

This week we bring you a spooky historical tale. The Salem Witch Trials both fascinate and horrify us! Enjoy this story, perfect for spooky season! Support the show

Nov 02, 202327 min

Who Killed Betty?

This week we travel to Kentucky to discuss the case of Betty Gail Brown. She was found in her car on Oct. 27 1961. Who killed her 62 years ago? Support the show

Oct 26, 202337 min

Annabelle the Doll

This week we tell the spooky tale of Annabelle the Doll. Her haunted history may be too much to believe. Let us know what you think! Support the show

Oct 19, 202346 min

The Haunted North Bend Trail

Join us this week as we travel to West Virginia to the North Bend Trail. Its a beautiful location with great hiking, scenic views and maybe a few ghostly friends. Sources: https://wvstateparks.com/park/north-bend-rail-trail/ https://nuttyhiker.com/haunted-brandy-gap-tunnel-west-virginia/ https://www.appalachianhistory.net/2020/10/haunted-tunnels-the-silver-run-ghost-and-the-lost-tunnel.html Support the show...

Oct 12, 202335 min

The Disappearance of Asha Degree

Join us this week as we head to Cleveland County NC. Asha Degree was a beautiful young girl with her whole life ahead of her. Asha disappeared from her home and was last spotted on the side of the highway. Her family has not given up hope on finding Asha and neither should we. Support the show

Oct 05, 202341 min

The Chili Scandal

The fall sickness is in the air. This week we pulled from the vault of patreon to make sure you had an episode to enjoy! Patreon folks, we will make it up to you we promise! This week we dive into a famous lawsuit; the Wendy’s Chili scandal! Support the show

Sep 28, 202320 min

Forest Park Cemetery

This week we travel to Brunswick New York. This cemetery has a crazy history and has had some unfortunate occurrences. Oh yeah, there are also some ghosts. Sources: https://exemplore.com/paranormal/A-Doorway-to-Hell-Forest-Park-Cemetery Support the show

Sep 14, 202334 min

Appalachian Omens

Join us this week as we dive into some of the omens that surround Appalachian culture. How many of these have you heard of? Support the show

Sep 07, 202339 min
Hosted on Buzzsprout
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android
Open in Metacast