Los Angeles in the nineteen forties was a sprawling city of nearly two million people. It was founded as a Spanish pueblo in seventeen eighty one and had grown from a dusty frontier town into a booming metropolis. The discovery of oil, the arrival of the railroads, and the birth of the film industry had transformed it into one of America's most dynamic cities. By nineteen forty three, World War II had raciaped Los Angeles into a massive industrial complex.
Aircraft plants worked around the clock. Shipyards along the harbor built vessels for the Pacific Fleet. Women took jobs that were once reserved for men, building plain ports and welding ship hulls while their husbands, brothers, and sons fought over seas. The population had exploded. Workers flooded in from across the country seeking jobs in the defense industry. Housing with scarce resources were rationed. Everything felt temporary, uncertain, Yet life went on.
People still fell in love, got married, had babies. Families still gathered around kitchen tables. Mothers still rocked their babies to sleep in the quiet hours before dawn. In early maren which of nineteen forty three, The weather in Los Angeles was unusually mild, spring was arriving earlier that year. It was the kind of weather that made everything seem possible, hopeful. Even on the morning of March eighth, nineteen forty three,
that hope was shattered. Los Angeles police received a phone call that would send officers rushing to an apartment in the city. It was a quiet residential address, the kind of place where young families were supposed to thrive, where the signs of a baby crying should have been nothing more than the normal rhythm of domestic life. But something
had gone terribly wrong. What officers found inside that apartment exposed one of the most devastating and least understood medical crisis that could follow childbirth, a crisis that doctors in the nineteen forties had no framework to recognize, no language to describe, and no tools to treat. It was a discovery that raised questions about how a mother's mind could betray her in the most catastrophic way possible, Questions about what happened when the very biology meant to protect new
life instead destroyed it. Questions that in nineteen forty three, nobody knew how to answer twenty six year old Joseph Chalfo came from the kind of family that built Los Angeles one generation at a time. His father, Ross had been born in Italy in eighteen ninety two and made the crossing like millions of others, carrying little more than determination and the belief that American meant possibility. He settled in Los Angeles, worked himself into the ground, raised his
children in the Titan hit Italian community. Like so many young men. In nineteen forty three, Joseph worked the graveyard shift at a shipbuilding company, welding together the vessel that would carry the war effort across the Pacific. His wife, Rosary, was twenty two. She'd married young, like most women did back then. According to Joseph's sister, Mary Sodare, Rosary was a model wife. The couple lived in an apartment on
a seventy ninth Street. On the twenty first of February nineteen forty three, Rosary gave birth to a baby boy. They named him Ross, after Joseph's father. Rosary stad in the hospital for about a week. It was standard practice back then, giving new mothers time to recover under medical supervision before returning to the demands of home. Joseph went straight back to work the graveyard shift, didn't care that
he'd just become a father. And Rosary came home the E seventy ninth street with a baby's son, entering that strange, suspended reality that every mother knows, the sleepless hours, the endless fading, the beautiful yet terrifying responsibility of keeping something so small alive. She should have been fine, she wasn't. Joseph Shelfer pulled up to the apartment on E seventy ninth straight, just as dawn was breaking. It just worked another graveyard shift, eight hours of welding in the shipyard.
The apartment was dark. That stopped him cold. Rosary and baby Raw should have been inside. There should have been light switched on the ordinary chaos of early morning with a newborn. He sat in the car for a moment, staring at the darkened windows. Then he got out, cross to the front door, fitted his cane to the lock. Inside, the darkness was complete. It took Joseph's eyes a moment to adjust. Rosary was sitting in the living room, perfectly still. Baby Raw was on her lap. He asked his wife
why she was sitting in the dark. She turned her head towards him. Slowly. Her eyes found his face that didn't quite focus, like she was looking through him, at something only that she could say. She remained silent for a few moments. Then she said she thought there was something wrong with Ross. Joseph crossed the room and lifted his son from her arms. The baby was fine, he was just fussing. Joseph said, he was probably just hungry. He told Rosary to get a bottle and feed him.
He then handed Ross back to her and headed towards the bedroom. He needed sleep. The shift had been long, and he had to be back at the shipyard in less than twelve hours. He didn't know that this would be the last normal moment of his life. The next morning, Joseph woke up to find Rosary perched on the edge of the bed. Something in her posture made him go still. She was looking at him, but her face was strange, an expression he'd never seen before, blank and distant and
somehow already gone. She spoke quietly, almost calmly, and said, I've just killed the baby. Joseph bolted from the bed and ran towards the kitchen. His mind racing, thinking that his wife had dropped Ross there'd been an accident, but what he found was no accident. As before warning, the next section contains graphic descriptions of violence against a newborn baby. Joseph's eyes swept the kitchen, searching until they locked onto the breadboard. On the counter. There was a small pick
blanket lying on top of it. Ross's legs were poking out. Joseph reached out with shaking hands and pulled the blanket back. He recoiled instantly. I saw him escaping him. That wasn't quite a scream. The baby's head had nearly been severed in the sink. Beside the bread board lay a butcher knife with a nine inch blade. Next to that lay a bottle that was almost empty. Joseph tried to speak. He tried to ask Rosary what had happened, but she just stood there in silence. His hands were shaking so
badly he could barely dial the phone. He called his father first, Roschelfo lived nearby. Together. When his father arrived, they called the police. Officer A. M. Young was the first to respond to the scene. He found Joseph, Chlfo and hysterics gesturing wildly towards the bedroom. Rosary was sitting on the bed, completely still, with her hands folded in her lap. Young approached her carefully and asked, what's wrong, kid. She then looked up at him with those same distance
eyes and said, I killed my baby. The officer would later say that it nearly knocked him off his feet the camway, that she said it like she was reporting the weather. He then went to the kitchen, where he found exactly what she'd described. Rosary Shelf was arrested on the spot. Officer Young tried talking to Joseph, tried to piece together what could have led to this, but the
young husband could barely breathe through a sobbing. He finally said, I can't understand why she did such a horrible thing. She'd been happy all the time, she wanted the baby, and seemed happy after it came, happy after it came. Those words would echo through the investigation, through the trial, through every attempt to understand what happened in that dark apartment on each set ninth Street, because that's what everybody remembered.
Rosary had been happy, a model wife, excited about motherhood, and then, just two weeks after giving birth, she'd done the unthinkable. The question that nobody could answer was simple and impossible. Why. At police headquarters, Rosary Shelfer sat in a wooden chair, staring at nothing. She was in shock. The detectives tried to be gentle. What had happened? Why? Rosary didn't want to talk, But eventually something broke through. She said quietly, I was making baby clothes and I
wanted a girl. Tears then started, her voice stead flat, mechanical as she continued, I got a butcher's knife, laid the baby on the bread, I cut its head off. She paused, and then said, I went into the bedroom and woke up my husband and told him I killed the baby. After that, Rosary said nothing. She retreated back into silence. Captain Nelson orders a psychiatric evaluation before filing charges. Even in nineteen forty three, with their limited understanding, something
about this case didn't fit the usual patterns. This wasn't a crime of passion, It wasn't rage or jealousy or greed. It was something else entirely. Detectives could see that. Meanwhile, Joseph was still talking to detectives, trying desperately to make sense of the impossible his story started to shift, or maybe he was finally saying clearly through his shock and grief. He had first said that Rosary seemed happy, but then
his comments changed. He said that Rosary had actually been moody since they'd come home from the Hall Hospital with baby Ross. He said that she was withdrawn and she wouldn't eat her talk unless she was forced to. There was something else, something that had worried him, but that he'd dismissed his normal new mother anxiety. Rosary had become convinced that something was wrong with Ross, Joseph told them once she said she feared the baby was ill or
abnormal because it didn't cry much. He said he tried to reassure her. He had even brought in a doctor to examine baby Ross, then a priest, hoping that religious authority might calm her fears where medical expertise had failed. They both assured Rosary that baby Ross was perfect, but the reassurance never took hold. The fear kept circling back. Joseph said she seemed perfectly happy right after the baby was born, but I remember she once said something about
hoping it would be a girl. He was describing a mystery he couldn't name a transfer metion he had witnessed, but couldn't explain what he didn't know. What almost no one knew in nineteen forty three was that he just outlined the textbook progression of postpartum psychosis. The medical community in the nineteen forties had virtually no framework for understanding
what could happen to a woman's mind after childbirth. Pure peril insanity has been documented since the eighteen hundreds, mentioned in dusty medical journals and case studies, but by the nineteen forties that knowledge had somehow been lost or dismissed. There was no clear distinction between postpartum depression, postpartum anxiety, and the catastrophically dangerous condition known as postpartum psychosis. New Mothers who struggled were labeled hysterical, weak willed, bad mothers.
The shame kept them silent, The stigma kept them suffering alone. Most women experienced the baby blues, that wave of sadness and overwhelming the days after delivery, when hormones crash and exhaustion sets in. Up the eighty percent of new mothers feel it, but it passes. Postpartum depression is different. It affects ten to twenty percent of mothers and goes far deeper. Persistent hopelessness, worthlessness, despair. Women feel disconnected from their babies,
unable to bond convince their feeling. The guilt is crushing, the intrusive thoughts are terrifying. Postpartum anxiety often comes alongside it, overwhelming worry and fear that won't quiet. Mothers become hypervigilant, obsessively checking if the baby is breathing, convinces something's wrong despite all evidence to the contrary, panic attacks, raising thoughts,
heart palpitations. Rosaries repeated fears that Ross was ill or abnormal, despite a doctor and a priest both confirming he was perfect. That was textbook postpartum anxiety. But what Rosary likely experience was something far more dangerous. Postpartum psychosis effects only one to two in every one thousand berths, but when it strikes, it's a psychiatric emergency. It typically develops suddenly within the first two weeks after delivery, exactly Rosary's timeline. It's not
depression or anxiety, it's a complete break from reality. Women experiencing postpartum psychosis have delusions, hallucinations, and severe confusion. Their moods fluctuate wildly lucid one moment, completely altered the next. Joseph had seen exactly that Rosary seemed perfectly happy right after the baby was born, then suddenly moody and unreachable. Women with postpartum psychosis can hear voices commanding them to
harm themselves or their baby. They develop bizarre beliefs about their baby, that the baby is possessed defective needs to be saved through death. Their thinking being becomes disorganized and irrational. They might go days without sleep, which further deteriorates their already fractured mental state. The condition requires immediate psychiatric hospitalization.
The risk of infanticide or maternal suicide is significant, and what makes it particularly insiious is how it can escalate in ours, not days, and how a woman in its grip mepp here normal at times, making it nearly impossible for family members to recognize the dangers until it's already too late. A husband sees his wife acting strangely and thinks new mother tiredness hormones. It'll pass. By the time he realizes it won't past, the tragedy has already occurred.
In Rosary's case, the science had been there all along. The moodiness that Joseph couldn't explain, the irrational conviction that something was wrong with a healthy baby boy, the need for repeated reassurance from both medical and religious authorities, reassurance that never stuck, never penetrated, whatever dark certainty had taken root in her mind. And then the comments about hoping for a girl in a healthy state of mind. That might have been a fleeting thought, one of those harmless
what ifs that every parent has. I wonder what my daughter would have been like. But in a mind fracturing under the weight of postpartum psychosis, it con fester and twist become something darker and more dangerous. Rosary Chaffo needed help, but in nineteen forty three, that help didn't yet exist. The coroner's jury took less than a day to reach the conclusion Rochalfo's death was a homicide. During the hearing,
Joseph took this and broke down completely. He tried to describe that moment his wife perched on the edge of the bed, telling him calmly that she'd killed their son, but the words kept dissolving into sobs. His sister, Mary testified next. She told the Chord about Rosary's obsession with the idea that something was wrong with Ross, how she had fixated on the fact that he rarely cried, as
if his quietness was proof of some invisible defect. Doctor Roy Hooper, who had delivered the baby, confirmed what everybody already knew. Ross had been perfectly normal, perfectly healthy. The autopsy showed that there was nothing wrong, But then doctor Hooper revealed something that cast Rosary's mental state into sharper relief. In the two weeks after Ross's birth, Rosary had shown up at his office repeatedly, sometimes multiple times a day.
Each visit was the same. She said that something was wrong with her baby. I know that something's wrong, she said. No amount of medical reassurance could ever reach her. When Rosary was called at the stand, she appeared only briefly. She stared vacantly ahead, mumbled her name when asked, then covered her eyes with her hands, like a child hiding from something terrible. Nobody questioned her about what had happened. She wasn't there, not really. Judge Byron Walters charged her
with murder and ordered her held without bail. After her appearance, doctor Paul de River provided an update on his psychiatric examination. He said he wasn't getting anywhere. Rosary sat in silence during their sessions, occasionally mumbling I don't know to question. She didn't seem to hear. She'd gone somewhere that no one could follow. The preliminary hearing came a month later. For the first time since her arrest, Rosary showed emotion.
She cried as Joseph testified that she he hadn't she had a single tear since Ross was born, not during labor, not when she first held him, not in all the days that followed. It was as if something essential had been severed inside her and naw hearing Her husband described it an open court. Whatever dam had been holding everything together finally broke. Rosary was ordered to stand trial for murder. Meanwhile,
Ross was laid to rest in Holy Cross Cemetery. His gravestone bore his name, with the word Junior carved above it. A small life briefly connecting one generation to the next, then gone. In April, Rosery returned to court to enter her play not guilty by reason of insanity. Rosary Shelf was escorted into the courtroom on the eighteenth of May
nineteen four three. The trial was brief by design. Both the prosecution and defense had agreed to a bench trial, no jury, just Judge Charles Frick, serving as the sole arbiter of Rosary Chalfo's faith. He was sixty one years old, and he'd been sending people to their deaths for sixteen years. He presided over almost every major murder case in Los Angeles for two decades, earning a reputation as the judge who'd sent more convicts to California's guest chamber than anyone
in the state's history. But it was his court demeanor that defined him. According to one prosecutor's son, Judge Frick would take his prosecutors aside over launch hours and educate them on how to introduce evidence. He continued, stating he prided himself in knowing criminal law better than anybody. He thought of himself as infallible, intended to look down at counsul and looked on at people that he didn't agree with.
Just two months before Rosary shelf who appeared before him, Judge Frick had presided over one of the most controversial trials in Los Angeles history the Sleepy Lagoon case. After the murder of a young Mexican American man, Judge Frick sat all defendants together, isolating them from their lawyers. He denied their request to get haircuts or clean clothes before appearing in court. The trial became a symbol of racial injustice in wartime Los Angeles, occurring against the backdrop of
the Zoots suit riots. Later, the Second District Court of Appeal reversed the convictions unanimously. They found that Judge Frick had conducted the trial in a biased manner, violated the defendant's constitutional rights, and that there was no evidence against any of them connecting them to the death. This was the man who would decide Rosary Shelfo's faith. However, when three psychiatrists testified that Rosary was insane, Judge Fick listened Parkin.
Doctor Samuel Ingham, and doctor E. J. Van Meader had examined Rosary extensively. All three of them had reached the same conclusion she had been insane at the time of her son's death. Rosary sat through the testimony staring straight ahead, her face empty of expression. Whatever had animated her during the preliminary hearing was gone again. She'd retreated back into that unreachable place. Joseph sat in the gallery, looking shattered.
Two months since that terrible morning, and the incomprehension was still written across his face. Judge Frick then announced his decision without fanfare. Guilty of second degree murder but insane Rosary Chauffeur would be confined to Camarillo State Mental Hospital indefinitely. Joe stood up as the bailiff's move to escort his wife from the courtroom. He was crying as he reached
as he pulled her into an embrace. Joseph then kissed grocery, this woman who'd been his wife, who'd been a mother for two weeks, who'd done something unthinkable while her mind was breaking apart. When Camarillo State a Mental Hospital opened its doors in October of nineteen thirty six, it was the largest psychiatric facility in the world. The sprawling campus of Mediterranean style buildings sat on former Mexican land. Grant Territory designed a house up to seven thousand patients in
over seven hundred staff. It looked like a college campus, manicured lawns, Spanish mission architecture, a bell car that would later become iconic. The facility was never completely fenced, giving it a deceptively open, benign appearance. But behind those picturesque facades Camarillo represented did both the promise and the horror
of mid twentieth century psychiatry. The hospital's population exploded almost immediately, from just four hundred and ten patients in nineteen thirty six to one thousand and eighty two in nineteen thirty seven, and then two thousand, five hundred and one in nineteen forty one, four thousand, one hundred twenty three in nineteen forty five, and over seven thousand by nineteen fifty seven.
By the nineteen fifties, crowding was so severe that patients were forced to sleep on mattresses and hallways and wait in line to use bathrooms or exercise areas. When Rosary arrived in nineteen forty three, the hospital was in the
midst of what administrators considered revolutionary psychiatric treatment. Doctor Frostick, who had established one of California's first insulin therapy units the hospital, claimed that insulin could cure both schizophrenia and manic depression, as long as the conditions had not had enough time to get ahead start. The treatment was brutal by any measure. Patients were injected with massive doses of insulin to induce daily comas over several weeks, typically six
days a week for a run two months. They remained comatose until doctors survived them with glucose solution. The insulin ward had white cabinets on rollers with emergency and big red letters filled with syringes of glucose, sedatives and adrenaline for when things went wrong. And things went wrong often some patients never woke from their comas. Many suffered fainting spells, sweating, restlessness, and rapid weight gain from wildly fluctuating blood sugar levels.
Doctor Frostick also used metrisol, described as a powerful stimulant producing violent shock and convulsions, although he claimed that insulin was safer. But insulin's shock therapy wasn't the only treatment the Camarilloo offered. The hospital also performed lobotomy, electroshock treatments, hydrotherapy, isolation, and restraints, experimental therapies that would later be recognized as inhumane.
They even injected non diabetic patients with insulin to cause shaking in the brain and injected syphilis patients with malaria in attempts to affect the cure. A nineteen forty Los Angeles Times report stated that of California's twenty one thousand, eight hundred and eighty four state mental hospital patients, fifty two percent were schizophrenics, ten percent were manic depressives, and
the rest were alcoholics and syphilitics. Women like Rosary, who were suffering from postpartum psychosis weren't even a recognized category. They were simply lumped in with everyone else, subjected to whatever treatments the doctor's thought might work. In nineteen seventy six, the Ventura Condy District Attorney investigated more than one hundred deaths at Camarillo over a three year period, with charges
of murder or manslaughter potentially being filed. The investigation focused on seventy nine deaths, including cases of drug overdoses, strangulation, and possible gross negligence by hospital staff. Electroshock therapy didn't end at Camarillo until the nineteen seventies, and the hospital finally closed amid grand jury investigations. This was where Rosary Shelfo would spend the next several years of her life.
Records from this error are sparse and often sealed. However, evidence suggests that Rosary remained at Camarillo for several years. Whether she improved gradually or suddenly, whether she ever fully underso what she'd done, whether the hospital's treatment helped or simply allowed time to do its slow work of healing, these details are lost to history. What is known, how is that eventually Rosery was released, she returned to a world that had moved on without her. The war had ended,
some of the men had come home. The city she'd left had transformed again, the temporary urgency of wartime giving way the suburban expansion and the long strange dream of the nineteen fifties. Joseph had divorced her, an act of survival, perhaps, or simply an acknowledgment that the marriage had died on March eighth, nineteen forty three, along with their two week old son. Rocery eventually remarried a man named James Elliot.
She built a quiet life far from Los Angeles, far from seventy ninth Street, far from the bread board in the pink blanket and the kitchen where her mind had shattered completely. She never spoke publicly about what happened. She never gave interviews, She never tried to explain the unexplainable. Some silences are far too deep for words. Rosary Shelfo passed away on the seventeenth of June nineteen eighty one. She never had any more children. She wasn't buried with
her son. Today we understand postpartum psychosis as a medical emergency. We have protocols, warning signs, psychiatric interventions that can prevent tragedies like roth Shelfo's death. But even now, eighty years later, the condition remains dangerously underrecognized. New mothers suffering from disturbing thoughts often say silent, terrified that they'll be judged as
bad mothers, or worse, have their children taken away. The stigma that Rosary Shelfo faced in nineteen forty three hasn't disappeared. It's just taken subtler forms. Every year, postpartum psychosis claims lives, infants and mothers, both because families don't recognize the symptoms until it's too late, because women suffering from delusions and hallucinations don't seek help, because we still, somehow expect motherhood to be purely joyful, purely natural. Purely safe. Rosery Shelf
wasn't a monster. She was a twenty two year old woman whose brain chemistry betrayed her at the most vulnerable moment of her life. She was a casualty of medical ignorance, of a society that had no framework for understanding what was happening to her, of a moment in history when mental illness was shame rather than sickness. In another time, with proper care, she might have been hospitalized the first time she showed up at doctor Hooper's office convinced that
something was wrong with a perfectly healthy baby. Ross might have been placed temporarily with family. Rosary might have received treatment, recovered an event, reunited with her son. Instead, a two week old baby died on a bread board in a dark kitchen in Los Angeles, and a young mother lost
her mind, her son, her husband. In any chance that the life she had imagined when she chose the name Ross, honoring the grandfather who had crossed an ocean to give his family a future, the tragedy isn't just what Rosary did. It's that no one knew how to save her from doing it well. That is it. This episode of morbidology as always thank you so much for listening, and i'd like to say a massive thank you to my newest supporters up on Patreon, Jenny, Emma, Gavin, Jamie, and Nicole.
The link to Patreon is in the show notes if you'd like to join. I upload ad free and early release episodes behind the scenes, and I also send out merch along with a thank you card. I also do bonus episodes of Morbidology Plus that aren't on the regular podcast platforms, and these are also available on Apple subscriptions. Remember to check us out at morebiology dot com for more information about this episode and to read some true
crime articles. Until next time, take care of yourselves, stay safe, and have an amazing week.