330: Kelsey Smith Briggs

So small, in fact, that it doesn't even have a stoplight. Most residents here own their own homes, with many retirees drawn to its peaceful streets and friendly neighborhoods. This was a time where everyone knew everyone, and families moved to Maker for exactly what it promised, the security and innocence of small town America, far removed from the dangers and complexities of city life. But on the eleventh of October two thousand and five, that sense of safety would forever

be shattered. Paramedics were dispatched to a modest home along a quiet street. What happened in that house and the devastating chain of missed opportunities that led to it would expose a very broken system. Kelsey Smith Briggs was born on the twenty eighth of December two thousand and two in Oklahoma City. She was the daughter of Red Dawn Smith and Lance Briggs, a couple whose love story began the way so many small town romances do. They had met in the halls of Maker High School. Lance was

the football player, read the cheerleader. She was once even a candidate for homecoming queen, with Lance proudly on her arm. Back then, their smiles and photographs told the story of two teenagers wrapped in the promise of forever, but that promise didn't really take shape until after graduation. The couple's early years together weren't without hardship. Before they marry married,

Ray became pregnant, but she suffered a miscarriage. Still, they pressed forward, exchanging vows on the porch of her parents' home on the fifteenth of July two thousand, But the fairy tale was short lived. Lance's mother, Kathy, would later describe those years as chaotic. They battled all the time. They had a terrible marriage for two years. They both drank, they parted too much, They did all the wrong things.

But the fighting wasn't just words. Less than a year into their marriage, Ray told police that Lance had slammed her against a wall and pressed his forearm against her throat. She said the argument sparked because she hadn't supersized his McDonald's value meal. Lance was arrested and charged with a misdemeanor, eventually pleading no contest. He was placed on probation and ordered to take anger management classes. But even that incident

was tangled in conflicting stories. Cathy claimed that Raylegh admitted she'd made the whole thing up, that Lance had simply taken her cads to stop her from going out, and in retaliation she called police. According to Cathy, Ray tried to have the charges dropped, but she was told she could face trouble herself for filing a false report, so the charges stood. There were other arguments, more trouble. Eventually, the couple filed for divorce, finalizing it in July two

thousand and two. By then, Ray was pregnant again. When Kelsey was born that December, Ray insisted that another man was the father, but Lance pushed Freddie na test. Three months later, he learned the truth. Kelsey was his From then on, Kelsey's life was split between two households and two parents who could hardly stand to be in the same room together. The bitterness ran deep, and, as one relative put it, the hatred between them became unbelievable. It

was just unreasonable. At times, Ray had primary custody. She and Kelsey lived with Ray's mother and her ailing father. Ray worked with the elderly, took shifts at a manufacturing plant, and studied at Seminole State College. Lance meanwhile remarried Tying the Knot with a woman named Ashley Liddle in June of two thousand and three. Kelsey quickly bonded with her new stepmother. When Lance was called the active duty in Iraq with the U. S. Army Reserve, Kelsey was two

years old and already full of personality. She loved afternoons at the park, especially the swings. She twirl her hair the same way she twirled the yarn locks of her cabbage patch doll as she drifted off to sleep at night. Disney's brother, Beaar, was on constant rotation. At a baby pageant, she took home title of Miss Personality. Kelsey was also a regular at Miss Julie's Giggles and Grinn's Daycare, where owner Julie Sebastian remembered her as fearless and fun. She

said she was a happy child. She would play, she would hang in there with the other kids. She would do everything they did. Outgoing smart, she did what she wanted. On the surface, Kelsey's world was filled with all the ordinary joys of a toddler's life, swings, story books, and stuffed toys. But beneath that, the tension between the adults in her life simmered, and soon they would have robbed

in ways that no one could take back. In two thousand and four, when Ray's father passed away, she and Kelsey left her mother's house and moved into an apartment in Maker. Life was in transition, and before long another major change was coming. On the night of October fifteenth, Ray found herself at hot Rod's, a bar in nearby Shawnee. The lights were low, the music loud, and somewhere between the crowd and the dance floor, she met a man

named Michael Lee Porter. Before the night was over, the two were dancing together, and soon they were more than dance partners. Friend said that Porter fell hard. Wendell Kelly Junior remembered it vividly. When he got with that girl, he was in a daze. He was so in love with her. If she said jump, roll over backwards, he'd did it. Porter had two children of his own, eight year old Whitney and little Michael, who was just two

years old. He was financially secure, at least on the surface, having taken over his family's magnet manufacturing business after both of his parents died. As president of Midwest Industries, Incorporated, he oversaw a dozen employees producing magnets used in anything from cell phones to computer keyboards. His sister actually owned the company, and to outsiders, he looked like a man with his life in order. So when Kelsey's grandmother Kathy

heard about him, she was hopeful. She recalled, we had heard that he was a really nice guy, and we were excited for her. That she was with somebody that had two children of his own, and we thought, great, they'll be a great family. But not everybody shared her optimism. Some of Porter's own friends felt uneasy. Wendell recalled that girl had a temper. She'd throw tantrums. His bookkeeper when it'da ward went as far to warn him directly, there's too much drama in her life right now, you need

to stay out of it. But still the relationship moved quickly. Ray was in the middle of a messy divorce, but within months she and Kelsey had packed their things and had moved to Porter's home in Shawnee. By April the next year, they were married. There's a photo from that day, taken on the court house steps. Porter's in a pullover shirt, jean shorts, and tennis shoes. Ray stands beside him with Kelsey in her arms. They look for the moment like a new family ready for a fresh chapter. But behind

the smiles, Porter's financial world was crumbling. He'd quietly lost his Shawnee home and lied to cover it up, telling some people he had sold it, others that he'd least or rented it. In truth, he had nowhere to live. That problem was solved when he brought Ray's mother's house

just outside. Maker Gaylas Smith sold it to them for a reduced price of two hundred and forty thousand dollars, a chance, it seemed, for stability, But what should have been a fresh start for Kelsey and her blended family was anything, but beneath the surface, tension and trouble were already building, the kind of pressure that would eventually shatter everything. It wasn't long after Ray moved in with Michael Porter

that the first signs of trouble began to appear. In January of two thousand and five, Kelsey came to the attention of authorities she had a broken collar bone. Ray took her to the emergency room for treatment, saying she had fallen out of bed on January eighth while sleeping at home. But just days later, while Kelsey was staying with Lance and his wife Ashley, they noticed something that went far beyond a simple fall. Kelsey had bruises across her face and body, abrasions on her neck and bottom,

and that same broken collar boone. The bruises were in various stages of healing, some fearing, others fresh. To Lance and Ashley, it was unmistakable somebody had hurt her. If you're dealing with hair issues such as thinning or sharing, but feel totally stuck on what to try next, I get it. There's so many products out there and it's hard to know which ones are active going to do anything that's exactly why I gave Neutrophil a closer look.

It's not just hype. It's physician formulated, clinically tested, and even recommended by dermatologists. After having my baby girl, I started noticing more shedding than usual and my hair just didn't feel as full as it used to. I was skeptical about trying another supplement, but I decided to try Nutrifal's postpartum formula and I'm really glad I did. My hair feels so much thicker now, and it's given me such a confidence boost during a time when I really

needed it. And they have different formulas depending on where you are in life. Whether you're looking at women's, women's vegan, women's balanced postpartum, or even men's formula, there's something for everyone. Neutrofoil is the number one dermatologists recommended hair growth supplement brand,

trusted by over one and a half million people. You can feel great about what you're putting into your body since Neutrofhil hair growth supplements are backed by peer reviewed studies in NSF content certified the gold standard and third party certification for supplements. See Thicker, Stronger, faster growing hair with less shedding in just three to six months with neutrophil.

For a limited time, neutrofil is offering my listeners ten dollars off your first month subscription and free shipping when you go to nutrifoil dot com and enter the promo code morbiroology ten. Find out why nutrifoil is the best selling hair growth supplement brand a neutrifoil dot com spelled nut r fo l dot com promo code morbidology ten.

That's neutrafil dot com promo code morbidology ten. The physician at Unity North Hospital in Shawnee shared their concerns the facial bruises that appeared on January thirteenth hadn't been there when she was traded for the collarbone injury four days earlier. The pattern of bruising suggested not an accident, but a baiting, possibly with an object such as a hairbrush. When Lance was asked if Ray could have caused the injuries, he admitted that if she had been drinking and got mad,

she could go overboard. Ray insisted that the bruises on Kelsey's face were from the fall out of bed. She also claimed that when Kelsey went to visit Lance and Ashley, she didn't have any of the other bruises. Despite the injuries in the doctor's concern, Kelsey went home with her mother.

On January twenty first, Rahd took her to see another physician, doctor Deborah Catcher, who noted child is extremely fair and bruises may show through more than the average child than be visible for a longer period of time, but by now the Department of Human Services, also known as DHS was involved. On January twenty fourth, during an emergency hearing, Kelsey was sent to live with her paternal grandmother, Cathy. A child welfare investigation concluded that Kelsey had been abused

while in her mother's care. In interviews, re admitted she had spank to Kelsey on the diaper with her hand, but denied seeing any bruises. DHS recommended that Kelsey not be returned to her mother's custody because her safety couldn't be assured. While Nance was serving overseas in the military, he agreed to his parents being Kelsey's guardians. By February, Ray was granted modified visitation, including on supervised visits, as long as Michael Porter wasn't present, but according to Cathy,

she actually had her more than we did. Actually recalled that almost every visit ended the same way. It was almost constantly, every time she brought her back there was something wrong or something had happened. On March twenty fourth, two thousand and five, a third referral was made when Kelsey was seen at a medical facility for a bruise on her nose and right knee, along with a closed head injury. The report said she'd been at her mother's

home when she fell over. The child welfare worker noted it was unknown whether the injuries were intentional, but recommended that all visits be supervised to prevent further harm. Then came April fourteenth, during what should have been an enjoyable family adding to the zoo, Kelsey reportedly twisted her foot. By the time she was examined, she had a spray and ankle, bruising on both arms, and bruises on her

lower back. Some were yellow with age. One bruise on her left arm was the size of a half dollar, just below the elbow. Kelsey said she had bitten herself, though it was unclear if there were actual teethmarks. Another bruise on her right arm was black, pencil thin and less than an inch long. On her lower back and spine were multiple small bruises, no larger than a dime.

The most alarming discovery came on April twenty fifth. Ray brought Kelsey to the DHS office, where workers immediately saw that she whimpered constantly and she refused to walk or crawl. They ordered Ray to take her to the emergency room immediately. X rays revealed the horrifying truth, bilateral fractures on both her legs, left and right leg. An orthopedic surgeon at ou Medical Center examined Kelsey on the second of May. His conclusion was clear the injuries were the result of abuse.

Significant force would have been required, the kind caused by violently yanking or twisting a child's legs. His reports stated that the injuries didn't match the explanations given by the family. DHS informed the district attorney that allegations of abuse were in the process of being confirmed. There were also concerns that Porter had been at Ray's home when Kelsey was there, in direct violation of the court order. But on April twenty ninth, yet another referral came in. This time Kelsey

had new facial injuries. There was bruising across the bridge of her nose that extended to her eyebrows and not by her right eye, and finger shaped marks on her cheeks. The collar believed that somebody had grabbed her face. Ray claimed that Kelsey had been sleeping in bed with her steps as when her stepsister accidentally elbowed her. A DHS worker called this explanation laudible. By May third, Kelsey was once again placed in DHS emergency protective custody and moved

to live with her maternal grandmother, Gayla Smith. Court battles over costoy intensified. On the fifth of May, Ray sought to terminate the guardianship, insisting she had completed all court ordered requirements. Despite the mounting evidence of abuse, some people still believed that Kelsey should be returned to her mother's care. At a June hearing, the judge heard from a dozen witnesses, including DHS workers, a court appointed special advocate, and both grandmothers.

The DHS worker recommended that Kelsey remain with Gayla and that any return to Ray should be phased in. Cathy agreed she wanted Kelsey back with her mother. Eventually, but only once the truth of the injuries was uncovered. But the Special Advocate recons commended immediate reunification. In the end, the judge sided with that advice. Kelsey was returned to her mother's home under the Community Home Base Service supervision. Cathy was stunned. She was convinced that either Ray or

Porter was responsible for the abuse. She contacted everybody she could think of, even writing a letter to the first lady plating for help, But the court's position was clear. The focus was on reunifying the family, not keeping them apart. The incidents didn't stop, and now the change wasn't just on Kelsey's body, it was in her eyes, her voice, her very spirit. The vibrant little girl who once loved

swings and story books was beginning to fade. By August two thousand and five, the changes in Kelsey were becoming impossible to ignore. On August, second, HBS workers noted disturbing new behaviors. Kelsey had begun harming herself and suffering from night terrors. Two weeks later, on the nineteenth of August, she was in a car accident. Four days after that, she was refusing to eat. When Kathy saw her granddaughter for the first time in weeks. She was unprepared for

what she saw. She recalled, we were expecting to walk in there and see this happy, healthy little child, and oh, my gosh, that's not what we saw. She was horrified. Kelsey looked frail, withdrawn and nothing like the lively little girl she remembered. Kathy immediately filed a complaint with DHS. On the twenty ninth of August, a DHS worker visited the home observed bruises on Kelsey's face and across her nose. They were explained away as a result of the recent

car accident, but there was more. Kelsey had lost significant weight and her once bright personality had dimmed. She was timid, cautious, almost afraid to move. September brought more troubling signs. On the sixth of September, Kelsey had a blister on her Eyelid Ray explained that she had been washing Kelsey's hair with adult shampoo when soup got in her eye, and Kelsey had rubbed it until a blister formed. Not long after,

Kelsey was spotted outside the home alone and unsupervised. Even Kelsey's physician, who had followed her case for months began raising alarms. In a letter to the Lincoln County Court dated August thirtieth, she recommended that Kelsey remain in one stable home so she could be properly evaluated for possible seizure activity. That medical warning was serious enough that the

court placed new limits on certain visitation arrangements. But no matter the restrictions, the decline in Kelsey's spirit was undeniable. Over the course of the year, the spark that had once to find her was disappearing. At daycare, she was no longer the bubbly, curious child who loved to play. She'd become withdrawn, aggressive, sometimes biding and punching others without warning. She didn't know what was going on, recalled Julie, a

daycare worker who watched the transformation firsthand. Kelsey's hair even began falling out. She stopped dating, and she refused to nap. She just changed completely, Julie said. The joy in Kelsey was being replaced by a confusion, fear, and a quiet kind of resignation, as though the world had become a place where bad things simply happened and there was no way to stop them. It was the eleventh of October two thousand and five, two year old Kelsey Smith Briggs

was at home with her mother Ray. That evening, Kelsey was supposed to go to the movie with her grandmother, Gayla, something she'd been looking forward to before the auting. There was one more routine step in the long chain of court oversight that had become part of Kelsey's life. DHS worker Patty Bonner arrived for a scheduled home visit, the eighteenth such visits in summer, each one ordered by the

court to check on Kelsey's welfare. Patty later described Kelsey that afternoon, It's just like a normal two year old girl. She was playful, climbing over her mother and smiling. But Patty also noticed that when Ray left the room, Kelsey became anxious, her energy shifting from carefred to uneasy in just a matter of seconds. Michael Porter raised new husband wasn't there. He was at work and, by all accounts, in high spirits. The company he ran had just secured

a twenty thousand dollars deal. When he left the shop, he was on cloud nine. His coworker, Wendell would later say Patty did notice a Nicolson sized bruise on Kelsey and a band it on her finger. Still, there was nothing that seemed on the surface to demand immediate alarm. She left it around one thirty pm. Not long afterwards, Porter returned home. When he arrived when Kelsey were napping together.

A short while later, Ray woke, left Kelsey in Porter's care and went to pick up his daughter, Whitney from school. What happened next took less than ninety minutes, but it would change everything. Sometime after Ray left, Porter dialed nine one one. His voice was urgent. He told dispatchers that Kelsey been napping when he heard a strange grunting sound. When he checked on her, she looked as though she was having a seizure. Her body was rigid, her neck arched,

her hands and jaw were clenched. She had a history of seizures, he said. He claimed he tapped her on the face, shouted her name, splash coal water on her, blew in her mouth, even tried chess and press essions before calling for help. Then he ran outside, creatling Kelsey in his arms, waiting for the ambulance. Paramedics arrived and worked frantically as they sped towards Prague Hospital by the time they arrived, Kelsey was gone. The truth of her

final moments would come later. In the cold, clinical light of the medical examiner's office, Kelseie's body told a horrific story. There were bruises across her ribs, chest, side, and back. There was bleeding in her intestines, bruising on her scalp and face, a tear in her upper gum, blood in her ear, and one tonil was missing. Her cause of death was blunt forced trauma to the abdomen. The pathologist explained that the injury could have been caused by a knee,

a punch, or by being squeezed with tremendous force. There were also injuries to the genital area, though it couldn't be determined if they were the result of sexual abuse. This was clearly no accident. Two year old Kelsey Smith Briggs had been killed. After Kelsey's death, Michael Porter and Ray Smith were separated and placed into interrogation rooms. Almost immediately, they turned on each other, each pointing the finger for

the injuries that killed Kelsey. Right Old detectives that after DHS worker Patty Bonner left that afternoon, she and Kelsey lay down for a nap Porter came home from work at about two thirty pm. She said. Fifteen minutes later, she left to pick up Porter's daughter from school, a task she claimed that Porter had asked her to do. According to Ray, Kelsey was fine when she walked out the door. She also painted a picture of a strange

relationship between Porter and her two year old daughter. Porter, she alleged, was jealous of Kelsey, accusing Ray of neglecting his children, a year old Whitney and two year old Michael. Ray's mother, Gala, confirmed that she had heard that tension before. Just a week earlier, She recalled, Porter had yelled at Ray, you don't care about anything but that thing in the back.

That thing was Kelsey. When detectives questioned Porter, his version of events initially matched Raise, at least on the surface. He said he found Ray and Kelsey asleep when he came home. He also confirmed that Ray left at two forty five to pick up his daughter, but in his telling, that was unusual. He claimed he was the one who normally collected Whitney from school, and that Ray's sudden departure didn't sit right with him. He even said he told her to wait that he would do the pick up himself,

but said that she rushed out the door anyway. This directly contradicted Ray's claims that Porter had asked her to go. Porter told investigators that are on fifteen to twenty minutes after Ray left, Kelsey began grunting and appeared to have a seizure. When asked if he would take a polygraph examination, which, while not admissible in court, can sometimes be used investigations, Porter refused. He told detectives he had a bad situation with the polygraph once before. Michael Lee Porter was the

only one of them arrested. He was charged with first degree murder in order to be held on one million dollar bill. The news stun people who knew him. His bookkeeper, Nita, described him as a loving father and stepfather. She said she'd go in there and set on his lap and play on his computer. He'd come out in the office and get her cookies or candy bars. The mother of his son, Alicia Bruce, echoed that sentiment when she said, I've never seen him hurt a child. That's just not

Mike's personality. He loves his kids and not just his own. I wouldn't have any problem leaving Mike alone with our son today. In the eyes of the investigators, though it was simple. Only one adult had been in the home when Elsie suffered her fatal injuries. That made Porter the only one arrested. At least for now, Ray continue to insist she had no role in her daughter's death. In a prepared statement, she declared, I believe my daughter was murdered.

This has devastated me and my family. I had nothing to do with hurting my daughter, and anyone who implies that I had anything to do with this is wrong. Porter, for his part, also proclaimed his innocence from jail. He wrote to his secretary at Midwest Industries, reach out to everyone you can and let them know that I'll be back. Have faith that the truth will be revealed. When Kelsey's

history with Child Protective Services became public, outreach followed. Many asked if she had been failed, if more could have been done to keep her safe. DHS spokesman George Johnson resisted that conclusion and stated, I'm not willing to say that the system failed this child. Who Ever did this to this child not only failed this child, they failed the Oklahoma standard and the American way of life. You

don't do these things to children. He pointed to the challenge of cases such as Kelsey, staring, you don't have someone old enough to be a credible witness about what's happening to them. Associated District Judge Craig Kay defended his own decision to return Kelsey to her mother. He said, when there's no evidence to show the child as in imminent danger and apparent completes all their obligations under DHS's treatment plan, I'm required by law to return that child

to the parents. Ask exactly what I did followed the letter of the law. Kelsey's family, her father and her grandparents, had fought to protect her. Now they were channeling their grief into advocacy. Her grandfather, Royce Briggs, said, it's a grassroots effort made up of people who are frustrated with the system. There aren't cracks in the system, there are creators. On the ninth of November, a round two hundred people gathered outside the state capital. Many carried signs with Kelsey's photo.

Others read let the Children's Voices be heard and Justice for Kelsey. Her grandmother Cathy told the crowd, we always said Kelsey's life had purpose, and we feel her purpose is to save other kids. Her father Lands added, I can't believe it happened. Our gold noise to keep it from happening to anyone else. He subsequently filed the fifty million dollar lawsuit against the state, demanding a full overhaul of day Hess. Ray wasn't at the rally. Days later,

the reason emerged. She was four months pregnant with Porter's child. From behind bars, Porter fad for divorce. Ray responded by requesting half their Marrital assets, attorney fees, and financial support for the baby. In a statement, she said, I'm not associating this child with the father. This is my own child. The circumstance chances surrounding this event are not the fault of the baby. Jadson's learned the truth that Porter was

struggling financially and on the brink of bankruptcy. She thought that he was wealthy that she could live a life of luxury at home. Then in December came another surprise. Porter's bill was slashed to two hundred and fifty thousand dollars. His sister put up the family's business as collateral. He walked out of jail shortly after Michael Porter's release, state Representative Chris Stale announced plans to push legislation to reform

Oklahoma's child protection system. It was first called the Child Protection Reform Act, but Stale said he would rename it the Kelsey Briggs Law. The bill aimed to create stronger review procedures and allow greater input from those advocating for a child's welfare. It would also give judges and DJs the authority request investigative help from the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation. While the bill moved forward, the case took another turn. Towards the end of February. Ray was arrested

and charged with child neglect and enabling child abuse. Prosecutors alleged that she knew or should have known, that Kelsey was being abused and allowed it to happen. Although investigators still believed it was Porter who bagged Kelsey to death, they said that Ray's in action made her culpable. She was released on twenty five thousand dollars bill. Two months later, she gave birth to a baby boy, but because of the felony charges against her, he was automatically placed into

state protective custody. Not long after, lawmakers approved that Kelsey Briggs Act. Cathy said the bill might have saved her granddaughter's life. She stated, this tragedy is something a child should never have to go through. We can't bring Kelsey back, but we can do something. Lance filed two lawsuits, one against the state and another against physicians doctor Kelly Coons and docor Andrea Bart. He accused them of failing to recognize and report abuse when trading Kelsey's broken legs and

collar boone. Then in July, there was another bombshell. Michael Porter was now charged with sexually abusing Kelsey. Her body had been exhumed for a second autopsy, and doctor Dean Hawlly, a nationally recognized expert from Indiana University, confirmed sexual abuse, noting a genital terror and bruising. The following month, Governor Brad Henry signed the Kelsey Smith Briggs Bill into law.

Both Ramporter pleaded not guilty to all of the charges against them, and the judge ordered separate trials, with Porter's case to be heard first. On the third of February twenty seventeen, just before his trial began, Michael Porter appeared in court and announced that he was accepting a please He sobbed as he pleaded guilty to a reduced charge of enabling child abuse. In exchange, prosecutors drop the first

degree murder and sexual abuse charges. Porter was sentenced to thirty years in prison, with a requirement to serve at least twenty five and a half years before being eligible for parole. His attorney, Paul Sutton, said Porter was the only one willing to accept responsibility for his role in Kelsey's death, but maintained his client didn't kill her, instead

pointing the finger at her mother Ray. For the first time, Porter claimed that in July of two thousand and five, he heard Ray yelling and Kelsey crying, and then saw her strike the child in the stomach. He admitted that he never reported it. His defense attorney, Sutton said, Michael has agreed to assist the District Attorney's office in any way he can. We all hope that the continued search for the truth results in true justice. Kelsey's grandmother, Gaila,

remained convinced that Porter was the killer. She said, you can make anything look good on paper. Cathy was less certain, saying she believed that Porter might actually be remorseful. Behind the scenes, it was revealed that prosecutors had built a strong case against him. Porter's own daughter told her skill counselor Catherine Reynolds that he sprang to Kelsey real hard one time and hid her head against a brick wall.

She was only eight years old at the time, and she told Reynolds that Porter acted nice to Kelsey when people were around, but was mean when nobody was looking. Another witness, Janie Cotton, said she once asked Kelsey about an injury to her leg, and Kelsey told her Daddy Mike kicked me out of bed DHS worker and at Swinford was prepared to testify that she twice overheard Kelsey say Daddy Mike had hurt her. In total, five witnesses were ready to tell the jury they had heard Kelsey

blame her injuries on Porter. With that kind of testimony waiting, Porter's defense team likely knew that an acquittal was impossible. The play deal was their only option. In March, Ray was additionally charged with child abuse or in the alternative, permitting child abuse. It was an unusual charge, meaning that prosecutors wanted jurors to convict her either for directly harming Kelsey herself or for allowing Michael Porter to harm her.

Her defense team quickly filed the motion requesting that the trial be moved to neighboring Creek County, a request that the judge approved. While preparations for trial were underway, a reporting to Kelsey's murder was released, revealing major feelings by DHS. The report folled the DHS workers for failing to investigate

why Kelsey was repeatedly injured. It found that they may not have considered the danger Kelsey was in as serious enough to warrant to their investigation, despite her having two broken legs and broken collarbone at different points before her death. The report stated that after such injuries, DAHS could have contacted police immediately. The Oklahoma Commission on Children and Youth concluded that Kelsey's death exposed major systemic problems in how

the state handled child abuse cases. Among the changes it called for were better training for police officers, prosecutors, and child welfare workers. Then in July, jury selection began in Creek County. By the ninth the panel of seven women and five men had been chosen. The next morning, Ray was escorted into the courtroom and seated alongside her defense attorneys. During opening statements, prosecutor Richard Smotherman told jurors that Kelsey

had been beaten to death. He explained that her injuries were so severe her pancreas had burst, calling her death the final chapter in a horrible tragedy. He detailed the pattern of injuries that Kelsey had endured in the year leading up to her murder. He stated, we know the abuse didn't stop because she's not here. That day should never have happened. Smith was either causing the abuse herself or she knew about it and she did nothing to

stop it. Rai's attorney, Steve Huddleston, condered by declaring her innocence. He told the jury that Michael Porter had been the one abusing and ultimately killing Kelsey. He stated she loved her daughter, her daughter was her life. Testimony began with graphic photographs from the Medical Examiner's office showing Kelsey dressed in a T shirt and a blood stained diaper. Jurors were then walked through her previous injuries, the broken legs,

the broken collar bone, and the numerous bruises. DHS workers testified about their investigations and the explanations Ray had given for the injuries. One worker said she believed police had been notified after Kelsey's broken legs, although evidence suggested they hadn't. Her grandmother, Kathy he testified about Kelsey's appearance on the twenty seventh of August. She told the jury she was different.

She looked like she had lost her spirit. Ashley, who was formerly married to Kelsey's father, Lance, also testified, I felt something wasn't right, that she was being abused. The prosecution's most unexpected witness was Michael Porter himself. Prosecutor Smotherman openly told jurors he believed that Porter had sexually assaulted and killed Kelsey, but nevertheless he called him to the

stand anyway. Wearing an orange jumpsuit and shackled at the wrists, Porter admitted he had made a mistake by not reporting Ray for abuse when he saw it. He testified, I said a lot of things to cover up for her. I would have rather believed anything than my wife killed her. According to Porter, he had witnessed three incidents of abuse, including Ray punching Kelsey and the stomach with a closed fist, jerking her from the car, and throwing her into a

chair just two day before she died. During cross examination, Huddleston accused Porter of being the real killer and of sexually assaulting Kelsey. He pointed out that Porter had called Kelsey's grandmother before calling nine one one the day she died, and revealed that Porter had put a dib wrong Kelsey after finding her gravely injured. Huddleston said, you knew what you did, and you didn't want anyone to find out

that she was naked from the bottom down. Huddleston also challenged Porter's credibility by asking why, if he had truly witnessed abuse, he had written a letter and testified on Ray's behalf during a custody hearing. You never saw Ray Dawn hurt Kelsey, and that's the truth, he argued. He added that no loving parent would leave their own children alone with somebody they believed to be abusive, yet Porter had done exactly that. Other witnesses also described seeing Ray

mistreat Kelsey. Gene Snyder testified that into on thousand and four, he saw Ray swatt Kelsey three times inside the entrance of a convenience store, holding her by the arm as the child tried to sit down to avoid being spanked. He said, Ray then picked Kelsey up and slung her over the front seat of the car into the back. Ray's former boss, Deborah Gilbrith, recalled Ray being upset because

police were investigating her for abuse. Ray ad made it to Zebra that she had spanked Kelsey with a hair brush over her diaper, a story which was corroborated by former co worker Mildred Johnson. Deborah also testified about another incident in which Kelsey told her that Daddy Mike was mean. Deborah urged Ray to look into those comments because she was supposed to be her daughter's protector. Instead, Ray brushed it off. She called Kelsey little miss attitude and said

she was just jealous. DHS worker in s Swimford described a supervised vis at which she heard Kelsey say Daddy might hurt my head. Ray laughed and told her daughter that was impossible because porter hadn't been around her. The prosecution then closed its case with expert witness doctor Robert Block and doctor Andy Sullivan, who testified that Kelsey's injuries were consistent with battered child syndrome. They further revealed that her legs had been broken at different times, clear evidence,

they said of repeated abuse. Ray's mother, Gaillis Smith, was the first to take the stand for the defense. She told the jury that Ray had wanted an autopsy performed to find out how Kelsey died, while Porter had opposed it. According to Gailly, their suspicions about Porter had started to grow in the weeks before Kelsey's death. One afternoon, she said that Porter had taped Kelsey's eyes shut while playing. It wasn't a joke to Gaila. We were starting to

watch him, she told the jury. The testimony then shifted to Rai's demeanor in the aftermath of her daughter's death. Pastor Charles Percy recalled finding her in the hospital, cradling Kelsey's lifeless body, asking him to pray with her, and pleading to know why her little girl had been taken. Porter was there too, and, according to Percy, his reactions seemed strangely exaggerated. The pastor described him making agonizing sounds, spouncing off the wall, and beating his fists against the floor.

Percy admitted, it bothered me. It really troubled me that he was responding the way he was responding. Officer Scott Morrison offered a similar account. Outside the hospital, he said that Porter was pounding on the bed of a pickup truck, muttering over and over, She's never going to forgive me. It later emerged that in the days after Kel's death, Porter had threatened to take his own life. When the

defense rested, the trial drew to a close. The jury deliberated for just two hours and forty minutes before returning to the courtroom. The public gallery filled as the verdict was read read on Smith guilty of enabling child abuse. The jury recommended a sentence of twenty seven years. They could have given her life. Ray bowed her head and wept,

I don't understand. Help me. Later, adjur summed it up bluntly and said it was pretty obvious she knew what was going on and seemingly didn't do anything about it. For Kelsey's family, it was some measure of justice. Her grandmother Kathy said the verdict sends a message to other abusive parents that they will be held accountable if their children are injured. Ray, however, continued to insist the entire case was a conspiracy, claim she never knew her daughter

was being abused. She said, I never ever thought Mike would have hurt Kelsey if I would have thought that I would have ran with her and left everything else behind. Then I would have turned him in. Kelsey was my best friend in the entire world, and it hurts so bad for people to say the things they'd do. I didn't hurt Kelsey, and I didn't sit back and let it happen. If I could have seen into the future, I never would have dated Mike Porter. It was a

statement heavy with irony. Ray had been warned again and again that her daughter was being abused. She had chosen to look the other way. When sentencing came in September, Ray was asked if she had anything to say. She didn't ask for mercy, she didn't claim innocence. Instead, she turned to Kathy and said, Kathy, I forgive you. Cathy's

response was swift and cutting. She's demented for years. Kathy had been the driving force behind bringing Read to justice, making sure she was charged for her role in Kelsey's death. Lance True said that Ray's words showed no remorse, not for what she had done and not for what she had failed to do protect her child. The wrongful death lawsuit against Kelsey's doctors was dismissed for having no legal

cost of action, but the suit against the state remained. Eventually, the family reached a settlement five hundred and twenty five thousand dollars from the state plus another one hundred thousand dollars from a private agency. From her prison cell, re demanded half, the judge denied her. In the end, all she was left with was the same thing she had on the day Kelsey died empty hands. Well, that is

it for this episode of Morbidology. As always, thank you so much for listening, and I'd like to say a massive thank you to my new supporters up on Patreon, Victoria, Diana, Kathy, Sonya and Leah. In addition to Patreon, Morbidology is now up on Apple Subscriptions, where you can get ad free

early release and bonus episodes of Morbidology. Plus the support upon Patreon and Apple subscriptions here see go such a long way and helps to defray the costs of hosting subscription services and freedom of information requests, and I am eternally grateful. Remember the check is out at morbidology dot com for more information about this episode and to read some true crime articles. Until next time, take care of yourselves, stay safe, and have an amazing week,