#886 - Konstantin Kisin - A Plan To Save The Western World

So, are you right-wing? No, I'm still not right wing. I think you're referring to an article in a video I did saying the title of which was fine, call me right wing. And it's basically just me saying I'm tired of like defending myself against this allegation. I'm still not right-wing, but if it's really important for people to frame me in that way, that's fine. They can do it. Why is right-wing a disparaging marker?

I think the political realm in which we operate, the framing is, I think, deep down, if people are honest, it's like the caricature of the left is that they're wrong but well-meaning. And of the right is that they're like... factually more correct but evil callous callous and evil and cruel and nasty and so even if you're right you're still wrong kind of that that's kind of the way people seem morally morally wrong exactly

And I think that's what I noticed, right? Because my journey into all of this world, as you know, was like, hey, guys, maybe free speech is quite important. Oh, right wing. I was like, what? And then I just gradually discovered, you know, thinking that you should be allowed to speak freely makes you right wing, which when I was in my early 20s, you know, George Carlin and Bill Hicks, these were my heroes when I was growing up, these great comedians.

who were getting arrested like George Carlin for routine, like the seven words you can't say on TV or whatever, whatever it was. So. That flipped without me realizing that it happened. It was a left-wing thing or maybe a universal thing. And then it became a right-wing thing. you know, thinking your country's not all bad became right wing. And we can go down the list of all of those things. So I just, I think that it's basically what a lot of people call you if what they want to do is discredit.

things that you're saying because they don't actually have a counter argument to what it is that you're saying and we can't really be fully aware of somebody's intentions so castigating lambasting the moral foundation that it's based on and saying, oh, it's coming from a place of judgment or impoliteness or uncouthness or callousness or whatever is kind of a easy slime to throw at someone maybe.

Yeah, and it makes people question people's motives. And a lot of people find people's motives more interesting than the results of the things that they're advocating. So if you go and, you know, try to create this beautiful utopia in which everyone's equal.

and you end up killing 50 million people in the process, well, you know, that wasn't real communism. You were well-intentioned, but you didn't quite live up to the ideals of this great philosophy. Whereas if you actually do things that work... but you have the wrong intentions or you're a bad person, then people don't seem as interested in that. And I find that quite an interesting thing because I was in Hungary earlier this year and they have a very actually right-wing government.

under Viktor Orban. And one of the things that I found out is they were very keen to deal with abortion in some way. They wanted to reduce the number of abortions in Hungary. But they looked around the world and they realized that abortion as a political issue doesn't work. It's an issue that actually loses votes for the right, even if people tend to agree with the position.

somehow it still ends up being a vote loser and it's a bad thing to do. So what they've been doing, you probably know, is pursuing very pro-family policies more generally. If you have X number of kids, you get this tax break. If you have this number of kids... If you have three kids, the woman... never pays its income tax again for the rest of her life. Exactly. And what they've found is without actually legislating much about abortion...

they've reduced the number of abortions in half simply by pursuing policies that make families more appealing for people to have. Isn't that interesting, creating a... positive vision for the thing you want as opposed to a negative vision against the thing you don't want exactly that's like that seems a very upside down sort of world we've just come out of the

US presidential election campaign. And in that, so many, you know, whatever the most effective political ad of the last few decades was, we are not that. It was mostly about, we are not that. Yeah, Donald Trump is for you. But the entire thing was Kamala Harris is doing this, trans surgeries for immigrants and documented, et cetera, et cetera. We are not that. They identified the binding together of an in-group.

of the mutual othering of an out group. And I understand that it's effective. It's maybe even more salient to humans to go like, well, that's a threat. That's something that's not right. Something to avoid. Maybe it even does bind us together more effectively, but it doesn't feel like a particularly hopeful. view for the world and uh yeah i wonder if i wonder if that can

be adjusted a little bit and we can have a little bit more sort of upward vision as opposed to kind of backward defensiveness against other things. Well, I think if you look at the two campaigns that we just saw, I actually thought that... You know, we went to the Nazi rally in Madison Square Garden. Yeah. Well, we were kind of there in just like, let's see what's going on here, capacity, rather than joining in with the salutes.

I would say, actually, if you dig down into the core of the Trump campaign, its message is actually very positive. I would argue, which was the Make America Great Again thing. And what we saw at the rally too, it was really about... People who love their country and wanted to be successful. That's what I saw there. When I looked at the Harris campaign or the way that she conducted interviews or the way she responded to challenging questions, that was all entirely pivoting to how evil and wrong.

and bad trump is so by the end of the campaign i don't think many people knew what she stood for whereas with trump at least Look, the political side of like, these are the bad guys, we're not like them. That's always going to be part of politics. But actually, I did think I came away from the, to my great surprise, actually. very relieved that Trump did win and very hopeful for the world as a result, which...

is not a position I thought I would be in before the election, actually. But I think going to that rally really changed my mind about a lot of this. You introduced me a long time ago, not introduced me to Thomas Sowell, but certainly kind of... repopularized some of those ideas. And one of the ones I wanted to bring up is something I heard you say recently, we've replaced things that work with things that sound good. This sort of optimizing for

optics over outcomes. Maybe you could say something like that. Dig into that a little bit more for me. Why is that a salient? quote in the modern world. Well, what his quote about that, Thomas Sowell's quote about that, is that's the history of the modern West of the last 30 or 40 years.

And I think it's universally true. I mean, we're sitting here in London, for example, where the mantra is, diversity is our strength. And the more it's evident that that... has flaws in it the more we double down on on the statement right so um a lot of this is uh sloganeering versus reality and i think it's really been amplified by social media to a great extent because i think

Things that are not possible in the real world are possible online. Online, you're an avatar, which can change its sex. It can change its... everything about it. You can be effectively whoever you want to be online. You can make statements that are never stress tested. Correct. They're tested only by whether...

they get likes or they don't get likes. And you see this on the left and the right. There are things both the far left and the far right will say that are absolutely not in any way related to the truth. But they are very appealing to people's... feelings and so they'll do that. Look, the reality is the truth is very unpopular. And it always has been because the truth is messy, unpleasant, complicated. The truth probably doesn't agree with you on a lot of things just necessarily because...

It's not going to fit exactly to the worldview that you have. So it's very unpleasant and it's much easier to engage in sloganeering. for yourself as well as for society. There's a H. L. Mencken quote, something about simple answers to complex problems are often wrong, that it would be nice if we could constrain down. a lot of the issues that we're seeing to something that kind of wrangles the chaos into order but i don't know uh the chasing for simplicity to me just

a lot of the time seems to be retrofitting a new problem to an old solution that you've had for a long time. Everything is because of... And this, again, happens on both sides. Yeah, and I think usually the easiest telltale sign of working out that someone's full of shit is if they have a simple, single explanation for all the problems that they identify.

And they're not willing to recognize the trade-offs in these situations. So I think in answer to your question, why is this happening, even more so now, I just think we live in a world where we're much more governed by... emotion and feeling than we are by the heart you know i'm reading um churchill's diaries of world war ii right now and it's funny to the extent to which the stuff that he clearly takes for granted and describing things um is

would now be completely abhorrent to our sensibilities. Well, for example, one thing I actually didn't know was the evacuation of the British Expeditionary Force from Dunkirk. People would have seen the movie. That only was possible because... There was a unit at Calais, which is further south of Dunkirk, which was basically ordered to stand to the death. So we were like, we're going to sacrifice all these people. They're going to die so we can save these people. And they did. And they did.

Wow. Do you know how many people died? I don't know, but they fought almost to the death. Then they pulled out the commanding officer. They gave him a direct order. You have to get on this boat and leave and leave your men behind.

because we're going to need you later. And then they allowed the small remnants of the British unit to surrender, right? If you look at the way we talk about many conflicts that are happening at the moment, there is no recognition that... casualties are part of conflict for example right this has now become completely abnormal to our way of thinking and so there are lots of things in which

we've moved on to this illusory world that exists in our heads in which everything is supposed to be perfect. Therefore, if it's not perfect, it's someone else's fault. That's the, there are no solutions, only trade-offs insight from soul again. Why I've been thinking, I've been pretty obsessed with that quote over the last couple of months, actually. Why is this?

need compulsion for perfection or hatred of small flaws what's the driving force or dynamic behind that do you think is there something that's is it so here's my theory here's my pet theory before maybe you give yours um if we can predict the weather in venezuela tomorrow uh if we have been able to get planes to fly in the sky and put them out on the moon why is it

that I need to encounter traffic? Why is it that civilians need to be caught in a crossfire during war? Why is it that we can't fully control a global pandemic, et cetera, et cetera? It seems like we have mastery in so many areas and yet not in all, which gives us a...

disproportionate impression of our ability of mastery over everything. That's my like bro science theory. I totally agree with that. I think that that is really it. And then if you drill down a little bit further into that, one other thing. that's worth adding is that we're living through the era of mass customization. We have been for some time, especially if you live in America. And what I mean by that is if you go to a drinks machine or a vending machine in the US, right, you can have...

First of all, you've got eight choices. You can have Fanta, and then you can have each one of them in like... eight different flavors you can have lemon fant or orange fant or a raspberry all of that right so you can not only do we control most of the things around us we get to choose exactly how we want it you can At your fingertips you have...

I don't know, 100,000 pairs of different shoes that you could buy. Same with T-shirts. So everything that we now consume, we have a level of choice that's completely unprecedented, which gives us an illusion of really high levels of control over everything. It's not just that we've really kind of got on top of infant mortality and all of these other things. Not only that, you can design your baby.

You can have your baby exactly the way you want or you will be able to very soon. So in many ways, we are. masters of our environment. So why can't we deal with this or with this or with that? And look, it's a noble and worthy thought. It just can't be taken to extremes. When the reality is telling you this isn't working. And also, I think part of the other reason is, as I say, I think social media, I don't know if we've talked about this before. I think we haven't. Social media fundamentally.

change the way politics is conducted in a profound way that I don't think anyone's aware of, especially if they're on the younger side of things. Because I remember... a few months ago maybe a year ago i was uh bored in the evening sitting around and i was on youtube and this debate popped up between two people most your audience have never heard of uh william haig who was the leader of the conservative party in the uk

the time or the deputy leader perhaps and John Prescott who was the deputy leader of the Labour Party at the time. And John Prescott was this blue collar working class guy, couldn't put a proper sentence together to save his life and whatever. And William Haig, who actually is also working class, but he went to like a, I think he went to a grammar school. So he had this very...

posh, well-spoken accent. And it was the ultimate clash. But what happened was because there was no social media, they were not pandering to that. They were not trying to pander to their audience. Yeah, they were in the room together. And the way that that whole like standoff, that debate was conducted is William Hague would make fun of John Prescott for not being able to. talk basically the late John Prescott I should say but John Prescott to his great credit

He didn't feel like, oh, I'm going to get offended here and then I can get 10,000 retweets and talk about working class people and the snobbery. He was like, well, on this side of the house, we may get the words wrong, but we get the judgment. In other words, it was a fight conducted on a kind of gentlemanly understanding that there are certain things that we don't do. Like a boxing match, you don't punch the other guy in the balls. And politics... to a larger extent until

First, the 24-hour news cycle and then the social media environment was really conducted in a somewhat different way. I'm not saying it was not nasty occasionally or there wasn't that going on, but the incentive structure was different and incentives are everything. structure now is to do whatever it is that gets you the most attention. That is not necessarily the thing that gets the most constructive.

progress being made outcomes at all and that's one of the fascinating things if you meet a lot of politicians as i now do you see them in an environment outside of the house of commons or outside of congress or whatever They're not nearly as antagonistic towards each other as they pretend online. So they're tuning that up in order to garner support, to get attention, to get- Look at how I own the libs or the right or whatever, you know.

You can insert your own thing there. Even, I suppose, from an individual perspective, without how it impacts the other side, look at how passionately I fought for our own cause. And look how much of a victim I am, which is increasingly a thing that's adopted across the political spectrum.

Yeah, I read this great article by Gwinder a couple of months ago called The Rise of Neo-Toddlerism. Do you read this? I haven't, no. So, I mean, it's kind of contained in the name that he talks about modern... social campaigns uh being like adult toddlers he says if every time that a toddler threw a tantrum they got front page news and a ton of attention online they would continue to do it you know

Even if a lot of the time there being, I don't know many people that supported throwing paint over a Van Gogh painting or whatever, throwing soup over a Van Gogh painting. But they definitely generated a lot of headlines and attention is kind of akin to, well, there's some things going on, like they're paying attention to me. Maybe this could be good. This could end up to people paying more care to the problem that I think is very salient.

I kind of get the sense that our inability to distinguish good attention from bad attention and just be able to like attention at all costs in an attention economy is always positive for the most part, unless it's like.

unbelievably negative comments that you're getting back for the most part people are just going to like yay my side boo the other side uh so yeah i think it reinforces uh focus on garnering drama using drama to garner attention pretty much at all costs uh i think that's why a lot of the time politics to me especially in the uk when i listen to the debates that are going on i just think like

What are you talking about? What is this discussion? It's nothing. It's nothing. There's no substance to it. There doesn't seem to be anything that's like a hardcore deliverable. It's always surface level issues. It's never actually getting to the root of anything. There's never any sort of definable. concrete, falsifiable statements, claims, demands that are being made, even if it's not you that's in power. I don't know. It's rhetoric. A lot of it is rhetoric. It is.

Sleep isn't just about how long you rest, but also how well your body stays in its optimal temperature zone throughout the night. And this is where 8 Sleep comes in. Just add their brand new Pod 4 Ultra to your mattress like a fitted sheet and it automatically cools down or warms up.

It's got integrated sensors that track your sleep time, sleep phases, HRV, snoring, and your heart rate with 99% accuracy. It even starts cooling or heating your bed an hour before your bedtime. And that's why it's been clinically proven to increase... total sleep time by up to one hour every night. I've been using my eight sleep mattress for years and I literally can't imagine life without it. I'm on the road at the moment in London and it feels medieval.

to not have an actively cooled and heated mattress topper. It is a total game changer. Best of all, they have a 30 night sleep trial so you can buy it and sleep on it for 29 days. And if you don't like it, they'll give you your money back. Plus they ship.

internationally. Right now, you can get $350 off the Pod 4 Ultra by going to the link in the description below or heading to 8sleep.com slash modernwisdom using the code modernwisdom at checkout. That's E-I-G-H-T sleep.com slash modernwisdom and modernwisdom.

A checkout. Trump victory. Do you think that a Trump victory can inspire a broader movement across the world? I think places like the US and Argentina have got their mojo back a little bit. At least it feels like that. They've kind of got confidence back. uh is this is is that just the

post-coital glow of an election victory? Or is there something more going on? Well, what's interesting to me was that, so we were in the US before the election, during the election, and after the election. And on the day of the election, We flew from Austin in Texas to LA. And all the people that we know in Austin were like, what are you doing? You're going to LA for the riots for when Trump wins. You know, there's going to be. And when we got to LA.

And we were there on the night of the election. And then we were there for a week after. Literally, there was nothing. There was no reaction of any kind. And I think that was because the scale of the victory. was very, very important. It's like nobody can pretend that America didn't vote in this direction anymore. It wasn't Russia collusion. It wasn't blah, blah, blah. It was like Americans...

looked at this and went on balance. We prefer this. I thought that was very important. As for whether that has a chance to spread, well, look, America is the place where we all download our memes. Right. So I always think of the example of during the summer of BLM when we had protesters in this country, in London, in front of police officers saying hands up, don't shoot.

in front of cops that don't carry guns. It's good. Like, that's not a real thing. You've just downloaded the meme, yeah? And you're misapplying it here. about something that really doesn't affect British people in anything like the same way. And I think that possibility is there. I hope it's there. And by the way, I'm not someone who thinks that... the Trump presidency is nailed on to be a positive thing for the world. It's not guaranteed. It's an opportunity.

And it really fundamentally depends on whether he's able to govern and deliver the things that he promised to the American people. One of the fascinating things as well, and this is actually something Francis, my co-host on trigonometry pointed out, is if you look at the... The kind of the lineup of the Trump campaign. The people at the very top of that are all Democrats, former Democrats. Trump, Elon, Vivek.

Tulsi, RFK. They're all former Democrats. And so what you're looking at is not a... uh this super right-wing coalition actually it was really a broad movement that won people over on the promise of a number of things improving the economy uh cutting government waste uh closing the border dealing with illegal immigration and

sorting out the geopolitical situation. But none of those things are particularly right wing, actually. And he stayed away on the campaign trail from a lot of the more controversial issues like abortion, for example. He was actually, you know, very... centrist about that now

If he can deliver on those things, if he can close the border and deal with illegal immigration, if America's economy is booming and if, you know, Elon and Vivek take an axe to the government bureaucracy and it's still standing and able.

to function in the same way that X is still standing after he fired 80% of the people, I don't see how that doesn't inspire people around the world. I don't see it. Because if you look at all of the Western world, I would say there are two... problems they're not unrelated entirely but they're very big problems in their own right uh it's the demographic issue and the government debt issue right almost every country in the western world there are some exceptions is running

close to a hundred percent of gdp levels of debt all right we are so indebted we actually i don't think there is a way to solve that problem without growing your way out of it You just can't inflict that much pain on the public and survive electorally. There would be so many restrictions placed that it would be...

there would be social unrest to the point where the country gets destroyed. Well, look at what happened in the UK. The Conservatives came in and said we needed some austerity. They cut the government expenditure. I don't remember what the number was, but I think it was like 1% or something. And everyone went, the Tories are killing people. So how do you cut it? I mean, we just saw this in France, right? Right. Yeah. So...

The only way to probably to deal with it at this point, if you can deal with it, is to grow your way out of it, right? The UK economy on a per capita basis is smaller now than it was in 2007. People in this country are poorer per head of population than they were before the financial crisis. We still haven't recovered. The only reason our economy is actually growing, I use inverted commas for people who are listening, is that we import lots of people

who they don't increase, they reduce our income per head because they're low-wage people. But the politicians can say... Well, our economy has grown because, look, we've added this person who earns it 12 grand a year or something. Right. So if Trump can actually unleash the talents and ingenuity of the American people.

and allow them to start businesses, to grow the economy, real growth of the economy, which I suspect he will because all you really have to do is make energy cheap and then the economy will grow. I mean, this is what people don't understand about net zero and all of this other nonsense that we've got going on here is energy is included in the price of everything.

Our electricity prices are way higher than most other countries. I think they're four times the ones in America. So you tweet that. Yeah. It's Bjorn Lomborg's tweet that I tweeted. Basically, when you make energy more expensive, you make everything more expensive. That's why all manufacturing… Everything needs energy. Everything needs energy. So GDP is energy transformed is the line.

Right. So if Trump's policy of drill, baby, drill means that energy in America is cheaper, that alone will make a big difference. Then you add to that cutting of government regulation and waste of that can happen. Then you put those two things together and you've got real economic growth. Amazing. You close the border. I'm not talking about like mass deportations or any of that because none of that I don't think is realistic or is going to happen. And you already see people.

close to the administration rolling all of that back. Actually, you know, I had an interview on Winston Marshall's show with the head of the Heritage Foundation saying, well, you know, we're going to be able to get rid of 100,000 criminal illegal aliens, but everyone else is going to be voluntary or something. And you're just going, okay, so we're talking.

more realistically now. But if you close the border, which is a big problem in all of the Western world, as we know, right? Illegal immigration on a large scale that nobody voted for. If you do that... You destroy DEI and all of this world crap in the institutions. Who wouldn't sign up for that when they're given the option? So it can inspire that sort of...

or revival in the Western world. And I hope that it does if he's able to govern properly. And I hope that he does that. And one of the things that I really hope that Trump administration is able to do is not... do not make the mistakes they had to perhaps make the first time, which was to actually consider the opinion of the mainstream media as important. Because what this election really showed that we just had...

This was the first podcast election. Everyone's talked about this to death, right? But what I think that means is that this could be the first podcast administration. Well, I'm not saying that's universally positive, by the way. But what I'm saying is, if the New York Times writes yet another piece about how Trump is Hitler for improving relations between Israel and Saudi Arabia or something, right? He doesn't actually have to give a shit. He could just...

government. He's got the mandate. He's not going to run for another term. He's got the Congress. He's got the Senate. He's got the judiciary. He's got everything under his control. If he could just resist the natural inclination to go after people who go after him. In the same way as you wouldn't necessarily go after an independent student newspaper that said it too, because it's such small fry, low impact.

that you probably, it's not worthy of a response. We shouldn't overdo, we shouldn't like overpraise ourselves. The New York Times has a huge audience. Of course, but if it's from reputation. perhaps, or relevance to the people that you care about. I remember, it's funny, I don't use TikTok, but stuff like clips and stuff get repurposed onto that.

I think I checked it after I hadn't been on the desktop thing for like six weeks. And it turned out that five weeks ago, I'd been involved in some like brouhaha on some video. I remember looking at it and going, huh, how silly. Like, you know, this.

platform that I don't use had a bit of drama around something that I said I still stand by uh like isn't that it's it and then huh I don't care about the potential impact and what people said because it's in a domain that I don't really care about yes but then obviously the next step is well why do you care about what youtube says or what instagram says or what people that reply to your newsletter say what people on twitter say like you know it i'm aware it's a basic bitch insight but

sort of opened my eyes a little bit like that. And I wonder whether it's the same. If legacy media has derogated its credibility so much that now most people just think, I really... care about what you say yeah maybe it gets a lot of circulation maybe even gets a lot of clicks but it's kind of another the media equivalent of the boy who cried wolf it is i i again i try to caution people to against being too

convinced of this because the New York Times, I don't know the exact numbers, but I think it has like 10 million paying subscribers, right? So there's clearly a lot of people in America who read the New York Times and think it's good and believe it. The point I'm making about Trump is, I think it's fair to say, I don't think I'm going out on a limb here, to say that the New York Times doesn't like Donald Trump. I think it's fair to say that CNN and MSNBC do not like Donald Trump.

Right. So why would he care that they have said the same thing they've said about him 10,000 times already? instead of just governing. He's got the mandate. He's got everything he needs to actually govern. Just ignore those people. Just ignore them and govern and do the things.

When I say ignore them, I don't mean do crazy shit just because you've got all the power. I mean, deliver the things you promised to the American people. And that was the thing that irritated me about his first presidency. He was like, you can dislike.

Donald Trump you can dislike the policies that he advocates but if he's been elected it is his duty to implement the policies that he ran for because that's what people voted on and you are now criticizing him for doing that that doesn't make any sense to me in the same way

Like if Keir Starmer in this country is a left-wing leader implements the policies on which he was elected. I don't know what they are because he didn't articulate any during the campaign. But if that were to happen, then I'd be like, well. I can't complain. I can say I don't like these policies, but I can't criticize him for doing it because that's what people elected him to do. So my point with Trump, just to finish the answer to your question is, if he can govern well,

and deliver the things that he promised, which is a strong economy, closer of the border, dealing with the woke shit, etc. I don't see how that wouldn't be inspirational. However, there are... two factors that I would say that make me less optimistic about the UK in particular than the US. So we can download the meme, but we have a parliamentary system, which means that...

Donald Trump really, he had to win primaries as one man, and then he could build his team after that. And none of them had to get elected. Elon Musk, Vivek, Tulsi, RFK, they didn't have to get elected with him. In this country... You know, the closest thing we have to Trump is Nigel Farage. Nigel Farage has a party which has five MPs and has a lot of the popular vote in this country. But...

In order to win, there's 650 seats in the House of Commons. You're probably going to need 300 plus seats to actually win outright. That means you have to have 300 people. who get elected in their local area as the local MP. So that means you kind of need 300.

little Nigel Farage's, if that's the metaphor. That's very difficult. The other thing is for all the talk about, you know, the American election being the podcast election, I don't know that the podcasting breakdown in this country is necessarily... favorable to the center right or the center or the... Well, who do we know in this country? Boris went on Stephen's show. Yeah.

But Stephen, he's not a political operator. Correct. Diary of a CEO. Correct. Yeah. Who else have we seen? You had the lady that did that budget and was briefly PM. Liz Truss. Yes, you had Liz Truss. You did. Yeah, we had her on. And we had Suella Braverman on. Yep. I mean, except for...

Except for you guys. I imagine James O'Brien probably has some people on every so often. Well, there's a couple that you're missing. Rory. So Rory Stewart and Alistair Campbell. We've had Rory on the show. I like Rory as a person. I don't know if you followed their coverage pre-election. I followed it with great interest. Yeah. So they were, and again, this is not an attack on them as individuals, but they were wrong about everything.

not only were they wrong about everything, they massively doubled down after being wrong about everything. So in the days before the election, Rory Stewart was saying, well... You know, these polls showing that it's neck and neck, they're completely wrong. People are afraid to say the truth, which is that Kamala is going to smash this. And on the night of the election, when he was clearly proven completely wrong, he was like, well, I was wrong on the facts, but I was not wrong to be optimistic.

or whatever it was and you're just going okay well just take all that aside these people have no idea what's going on in reality in america they were just completely wrong they are Probably the most popular podcast when it comes to politics in this country. I think it's Goalhanger that does the network that that's a part of. I think in...

In the top 10 for the Americans listening, the top 10 podcasts on Apple Podcasts, which skews a little bit older, in the UK, Rory Stewart is in maybe two or three of them regularly.

And Goalhanger has maybe four or five. That one network. And again, I like Rory as a person. He's a lovely man. He's been on the show. I found him very interesting. And he's been on our show. And we happily have him back. And I'd happily... have alistair back although i i rate him less but um not back i'd rather have alistair i'd happily have alistair on my point though is that quite a lot of people in britain are living in a in this imaginary world

which is reinforced for them by people that they instinctively lean towards. And they're not as aware as you are because you live in the US or as I am because I get a chance to travel there. of actually what's going on. And I only realized this, you know, this year, because this year is, I've been to America loads of times before, but this year was the year that I actually went to like real America. I've been in Utah and Oklahoma City. Fuck me, that's real America. And Tulsa.

and El Paso in Texas and Fort Worth and Sugar Land and all these other places, as well as your DCs and your New Yorks and Nashvilles and all of that. I really had a chance to Colorado. I was in and I traveled around it. So I got a chance to actually meet like real American human beings. And I realized that the reason that. people in Western Europe don't understand what's happening in America is because they've never been there. So if you are a BBC journalist, what is America to you?

Well, America is what people like you, i.e. the media elite, tell you that it is, right? And then if you go to America, you go to New York, D.C. or L.A. These are all places. that are massively Democrat. They're super dominated. You know, I think Washington DC voted like 92% for Kamala Harris in this election, something like that. So you end up in these places that are not, whether you think, you know, Democrats are the best or the worst or whatever, it doesn't really matter. My point is.

They spend a lot of time among people and in places. whose views are not representative of the country and so when you are a british citizen watching the news you're really watching people who are deeply embedded into an echo chamber whose echo chamber also tells them that their opinions are the virtuous ones to have. And so that to me, it's therefore not surprising to me that you even have prominent Tories in this country who were saying they're pro-Kamala.

Very difficult to stress test that. You mentioned sort of Trump has the opportunity, very clear set of objectives. Also, I can't even remember what it is, the House, the Senate, the popular vote, the blah, blah, the blah, blah, the money, the technology. the talent. What happens if Trump fails to deliver change? That's an interesting question.

all of the things that many of us have been saying about the decline of the West are going to come back a hundred times because what you then see is there's literally no way out. It's unfixable. There's no way out. There's no way out. So the reason I think a lot of people were relieved as I was, was at least in this selection. The Trump one. Yeah. The feeling for me was, well, at least there's choice.

In the UK, you don't have choice. On the issues that I care about, which is our country being prosperous, immigration being beneficial to the country. I'm pro lots and lots of immigration. As an immigrant. if it's beneficial to the country. I'm against even small levels of immigration that are detrimental to the country. And I'm completely against illegal immigration for that reason. And as you know, the woke shit grinds my gears.

On all of that stuff, we don't have a choice in this country. We haven't had a choice for 14 years. The conservative government that's just left is virtually indistinguishable from the Labour Party that's just come in to the point where the Labour leader is attacking the conservatives for their failure on mass immigration.

And everyone's going, he's got a point. I mean, he's going to make it worse, but he's got a point. Do you know what I mean? So in America, at least the feeling was, well, okay, they actually have choice. They can choose. If you don't want this continued slide into managed decline, you can vote for something else. Pivot. If you vote for that something else and you don't actually end up having that choice.

then you're in deep trouble. And as you probably know, in the fringes of right-wing discourse, the Curtis Yarvins of the world...

Not super familiar. I've met Curtis, but I'm not super familiar. He's an interesting guy, but it's not even about him specifically. There are a lot of people who up until this point were increasing in profile because they were saying something that... I don't necessarily agree with, but I see the logic of, and that is what good is democracy if you can't vote for the things that you want? If you can't vote your way out of this...

Is that democracy or is that a fake democracy? And therefore, if it's a fake democracy, then you're not living in a place of choice. You're living in a place where there's a tyrannical authoritarian structure that's telling you, you must have net zero. You must. have woke you must have dei it's just got a much more sophisticated delivery mechanism that makes you feel like you're playing the game you're living in the matrix right you're being given this

soma, whatever you want to call it. You're being given this drug that makes you feel like you're living in some kind of... On a piece of ballot paper. Yes. But actually, you're living in hell in which you're stuck... with the things that you hate. And even if the majority of you get together and vote against this, it will still happen. The same outcome occurs. So their argument is...

Democracy is not working. Why don't we look at alternatives and alternatives are, you know, that's why that explains the fascination that. as I say, fringes of the right increasingly have with the Putins of the world. Because it's like, well, this is like a strong man who actually fixed his country, you know. And if Trump fails... I don't see why those voices wouldn't get louder That's very interesting I can't see a logical reason why that wouldn't be the case Do you?

No, I mean, you can continue to sort of play the game. I'm sure that... People that don't like Trump would say, yeah, but he was inefficient. He was unable to do this thing. It's because the policies were pointing in the wrong direction. We can fix it through a different pathway, et cetera, et cetera. But given that there was a majority of people that voted for him.

It not being disheartening and disenchanting to the democratic process, especially with all of the power of the smartest guy in the world, the companies and the rockets and the fucking dance moves on stage and stuff. What else did you want? But yeah, I'm fascinated by that question. What happens in four years time if change hasn't been delivered? If you can't fix it when you've got the Senate, the Congress, the popular vote, the tech bro oligarchs.

David Sacks now. David Sacks, you've got a lot of the new media on your side, which is so powerful now in America. You've got literally everything you could possibly have. You as president are independently wealthy. It's your last term. You don't have to pander. to anybody if a good successor sat in the same organization already if you can't fix it then well how do you fix it

That would be the question a lot of people ask in that situation. So Trump must not fail because if he does, that in many ways was the last chance that the West had of turning things around. What happens if it goes well? You mentioned about Trump has the opportunity to hard reset sort of the Western world. I think if he does well, if the economy grows rapidly and sustainably.

if he closes the border and deals with illegal immigration and crime, if he ends DEI and all of this neo-racism in the institutions, if he makes energy cheap. if he ends the foreign conflicts that he promised to end, I think that is something that is an undeniable proof that what he... that movement offers is better than what we had. That's why people voted for him the way that they did. And that means that will give massive inspiration to people around the world.

especially the Western world. I think that's undeniably the case. Do you think it would give inspiration to the UK? I think it will. That does not mean for the reasons that we already discussed that that will necessarily, that does not mean that that will necessarily result in... a political victory, but that will give inspiration to people around the world for sure.

Something that I was, I actually thought about this. I was in Brisbane on the day of the election. So I was moving seamlessly from my workout playlist to the Daily Wire's live stream, like just switching between the two, you know, it's one in the afternoon or something on Wednesday.

for me as I'm watching results come in slowly. And as it became increasingly likely that it seemed like a Republican victory was afoot, I actually thought about you and your position, your particular distaste for right-wing snowflakes. And I wondered, being on the outside for the last four years or so,

allows you to have this sort of anarchistic, rebellious, sort of sexy, problem-identifying, but not needing to be solution-proposing sort of group. I wondered whether... you thought there's an opportunity for that right-wing snowflakeism energy to appear more or less now that that side is in power. I wondered if you considered that. Yeah, I think actually what Trump's election will do, and I really realized this particularly when we went to the Trump rally.

in Madison Square Garden is, I think it... if he's successful in particular, it has the power to entirely deflate that fringe of the right that has become very much like the woke left in the way that it operates, the cancel culture, the identity politics, the grievance. mongering i the trump uh one of the things that those people are obsessed about is israel and jews and trump is the most philo-semitic president the united states has had for decades so um

And he doesn't need them. And I don't think he's ever really particularly... Wasn't it interesting that on October 7th he was with Ben? Was he? Yes. I didn't know that. I can't remember where they went. Ben and him... some sort of ceremony type memorial thing. And I remember thinking at the time, fuck, like I see a lot of loud voices on Twitter that have a problem, a big problem on the right, from the right. And there's like Fuentes adjacent kite sort of type people.

And I thought, holy fuck, that might have damaged part of the campaign. Maybe that's lost a significant number of votes. Yeah, and that's what happened when I went to the rally in Madison Square Garden, because full of Jews. full of Israel flags. And every time anyone mentioned Israel or like, I mean, one guy was on stage and just went, we're going to crush Jihad. And I was like, and everyone was just loving it.

So I think one of the reasons I actually talk less about that fringe of the right now, even though I just find them intellectually very irritating because they're not very bright, is that... I don't think they're relevant, truthfully. And so I don't really talk about it too much. I, you know, James Lindsay's trolling them and I enjoy that. And I like trolling these idiots, but generally speaking.

What I saw in America was they have no purchase in the Trump movement whatsoever. And if Trump is successful, these people will become utterly irrelevant. And and by the way. quite a lot of those people you know i don't know if you remember the lauren chen situation but there was the revelation that some of these people were being funded from russia um and you know when you see this some of these people like a week before the election saying trump's not my guy or whatever you go

Are all those likes on Twitter really organic? Everyone's had these. Are they really? Because I don't see this reflected in real life. No. I think when it comes to social media... Our reality is being distorted in a hundred different ways. And one of them is undoubtedly foreign operations. Yeah. Undoubtedly. Yeah. A couple of times I've.

triggered some of the tripwires, like kicked one of them. I intend to sort of stray into those circles. I had a conversation with Rudyard Lynch, what if alt-hist guy, and he did a... And you say, an interesting treatise on why Nick Fuentes is a Fed. And that got clipped and put on Twitter. Fed, I thought you said something else. Maybe that too. And I was blown away by not only the replies, the pace of them. Like, where the fuck? Are these people just sat online? It's absurd. So, yeah, there's...

Some fuckery. Oh, no, I'm being trolled by a bot farm. Oh, God, I feel terrible. There's an amount of fuckery. In other news, this episode is brought to you by Function. Did you know that your annual physical only screens for around 20 biomarkers? That leaves a lot of gaps when it comes to understanding your health, which is why I partnered with Function. They run lab tests twice a year that monitor over 100 biomarkers. They even screen for 50 types of cancer.

at stage one. They've got a team of expert physicians that takes that data, puts it into a simple dashboard and gives you actionable recommendations to improve your health and lifespan. They track everything. from your heart health to your hormone levels, thyroid function. Plus, Dr. Andrew Cuban is their scientific advisor and Dr. Mark Hyman is their chief medical officer. So you can trust that the data and insights you receive are scientifically sound.

and practical. Getting your blood work analyzed like this would usually cost thousands, but with Function it's only $500. And right now you can get the exact same panels I get. plus bypass their 400,000 person wait list by going to the link in the description below or heading to functionhealth.com slash modern wisdom. That's functionhealth.com slash modern wisdom. So, okay, the opposite side of this, like, it's almost...

Kind of done to death, but I wonder if there's something novel to talk about here around Trump's victory being a death blow for overreaching progressivism and stuff like that. We've been saying in one form or another, peak woke. It was summer of 2020 or whatever it might be. I, again, bro science theory, I have this idea that...

You have this sort of conceptual inertia that maybe even if things on the internet have moved on, if these ideas have caught hold in the real world, there's this momentum, this big juggernaut, this lumbering behemoth, which is like...

boomers and my parents i had this idea that uh a news story hasn't reached full mainstream significance when it's on the front page of the new york times or when it trends on twitter but when your dad messages you about it on facebook messenger like that's when you know it's happened

two or three times I think over the last few years. One being... rogan's cnn debacle during covid where he messaged me and said i see your friend mr rogan is in the news again i'm like wow like that's hit a you know 60s year old northeast of the uk father and then uh mid-22 where he messaged and said, that Andrew Tate's a nasty piece of work, isn't he? T-A-I-T. I was like, Tate, you have reached full mainstream significance because my dad is talking about you. But all of that together.

to say there are many worlds that you inhabit. And if you're an agile, online, degen, ex-user, power user type thing, I think you have a skewed perspective of how sort of nimbly... things are moving along. So how have you come to sort of conceptualize this and the trajectory of the sort of progressive? Well, I think the geography is very important here. So I've done it in the UK.

or Australia or in Canada, we've remotely reached peak work because DEI and all of this other stuff is so deeply embedded in the institutions and in politics. I mean, look at London. London is run by a guy who's painted the crossings rainbow colors and the police rainbow colors and all of this stuff, right? And I know those are trivial things, but they're symbolic of very strong underlying things where people are being...

hired or fired based on the demographic characteristics and so on. In the US... Yes, Trump and people like Chris Rufo and Elon and Vivek, they have an opportunity to absolutely dismantle from the ground up all of these. ideological introductions that have occurred over the last ten

Even if structurally they can't get into Yale or into Harvard or into Netflix or whatever, they can go a little bit more upstream from that. But most of this stuff is in government. So if you can strip affirmative action hiring from... government institutions, then everything else will naturally follow. The corporations never wanted to be woke. They just felt they had to.

Yeah, that's interesting. Incentives as opposed to like ideology. Yeah. And, you know, the Jaguars of this world, they're not going to benefit from that, from what's coming. So I think that there's a big opportunity for a reset. in america but even so it's like you've got the virus and it's infected you and you are still sick

but you have the potential to start recovering. That's kind of how I see it. In the rest of the Western world, I don't think we're, I think woke is going to run and run for a long time. Given that you're downstream, hopefully from the US though. if that is. But I really don't, until the political leadership changes, I don't see how it changes. Because if, even if, you know, you could tell me, well, look, Gen Z men are not woke. Great. What are they ruling?

What are they deciding? Who gives a shit what they think? You know what I mean? Other than me and you. So the political power to change the things that are embedded in institutions. That's what this is about. That's why Trump has a chance to reset it in the US. Then hopefully it's inspirational to the rest of us. What's your assessment on the state of the UK at the moment? At the moment, I think it's fucked.

I really do. You know, I love this country. I really do. But at the moment, I feel like... Have you ever heard that Mickey Flanagan joke about going to Brighton? So Mickey Flanagan is a very famous, very successful British comedian. And I remember he did a show in Brighton and he talked about, you know, the contrast between London, the big city and Brighton, the seaside town that he comes in. And he went, you know, you get on the train in London, you're really stressed and you're just...

You get on the train, it's full, it's packed, it's uncomfortable. And then you just, you get off at the station and bright and you, you smell the sea air and you can feel the ambition just draining out of you. It's kind of how I feel about the UK. And I know that. And the reason I'd say that is that all the bright and talented people that I know are leaving. Anyone who can.

is uh all the rich people are leaving this country has lost more millionaires than any other country except china now if you compare the populations that tells you three percent right so we're losing the people who have created the jobs who are going who are creating the jobs and who are going to create the jobs and one of the reasons is they look at the environment that we're operating in we've talked about high energy prices but

This government has decided that the people who it needs to tax are the businesses, basically, particularly the smaller side businesses, which is where so much creativity really happens. And then there's all sorts of other things about infrastructure, housing, demographics that are going on that I don't.

You know, we talk about net immigration figures and what no one really talks about is the fact that what we're actually doing is we're chasing out all the people who create wealth and have wealth, who pay the taxes, and we're replacing them with people coming in. towards the bottom of the jobs market at best, if they're actually working at all.

And so your net immigration figure of 900,000, that includes you having lost some of your best people and replaced them with people who are not contributing. That's very interesting. Your net doesn't account for the cohorts that have gone and the cohorts that have come in. And it's probably not like... alike. Yeah. And so everyone I know who actually had a successful business that's portable, they're moving to Dubai.

They're moving to America. They're moving to all sorts of other places. And what they say is very simple. Well, look, I want my kids to go to a school where they're not taught that they're trans. I want to pay reasonable taxes.

which in some places is like zero percent um i i want a clean safe street which you do not have you know i want um i don't go on the tube very much these days just from a you know um and i'm not in london that often actually uh and i went on the tube the other day during daytime it was like i don't know five six o'clock

And there was kids running absolutely rampant all over it, jumping over barriers, not paying, pushing each other on the escalators, smashing the stop button, like really causing genuine nuisance. And I watched. the staff watch them jump over barriers and do nothing. Correct.

I got some data. Recent data reveals a 56% increase in tube crime with thefts up by 83% and robberies doubling in 23-24. And this extends more broadly. I saw the Labour government's talking about, you know, they're going to reduce crime. Well, street crime is up very significantly. And one of the reasons it's up is that it's not really being dealt with by the police. I mean, anyone who I had my car broken into a few years ago.

Windows smashed. There was a CCTV camera right above it. I called the police. You can't call. I had to email the police. Because they don't answer the phone unless it's like, you know, someone's been misgendered or something, you know. And they emailed me back saying, we've investigated. We can't find anything.

Right under a CCTV camera, here's your crime reference number. There was a viral video that you probably would have been seeing of a guy who deliberately left a bike on the street with a... Geolocator. Directly outside of Scotland Yard? Yeah. He got nicked.

They tracked it down to the house where it was being stored. They gave the police the information. The police said, we've looked into it. Here's your crime reference number. We can't do anything. And then once the video caught sufficient fire, they got an email back from the police saying,

reopened your case great news exactly now by the way i i don't want this to come across as if i'm criticizing police officers because i know police officers and i know that a lot of them really are working very very hard uh but the priorities and the results as they have for set from above don't seem to manifest themselves in this kind of low-level crime being addressed now you might say well you know there's some kids not paying for the tube who cares

Well, actually, the broken window series is entirely correct. If you are observing people engage in low-level criminal behavior, it makes people feel much less safe about the overall experience because they know that, well, if they're not going to enforce... this, well, what reason do I have to think that if my phone gets stolen? The subtext is that more serious things also won't be looked at with care. And they aren't.

And they aren't. I know people who've left because of single incidents. I know a really wealthy guy who left the UK because she was walking out of a restaurant in Mayfair with a nice watch on his wrist and his pregnant wife. Three guys jumped out of a van with balaclavas on, smashed him to the floor, punched him a few times, pushed his pregnant wife aside, got the watch off him, got back in their van. Police don't give a shit.

No real investigation, nothing. Why? Why are these crimes in the UK, why is this sort of social fabric disintegrating like that? I think it's partly because the economy isn't growing and so there's not a lot of money to be put into policing. And when you think that net zero is the way to prosperity, i.e. driving up energy prices.

because you want to feel green or whatever, you want to reduce Britain's contribution to global climate change from 2% to 1%. You know, that's the great ambition. Well, then you're not going to have money. And when you don't have money, you can't pay police officers. And when you don't have police officers... people engage in crime. I mean, this is just to add additional context for the northerner in the room. This is in London. Yeah. I think the UK has the sixth biggest economy in the world.

heard this really phenomenal explanation, which is the UK is not the sixth biggest economy in the world. UK is a very poor country attached to a very rich city. London has the six biggest economy in the world. No one gives a fuck about Newcastle. No one cares about Carlisle or Wrexham, except for Ryan Reynolds. Manchester. Manchester, like a little bit.

Like a tiny, teeny, tiny little bit. Birmingham, a teeny, tiny little bit. Everywhere else can go and get fucked. Like anything basically north of Birmingham can just fall off a map. And, you know. I wrote this thing after the riots that occurred a few months ago. I read it. Yeah. If you can remember that, I basically, my thesis was, I saw some videos of my old hometown, Middlesbrough.

And there were street marches. These people hadn't joined. It looked like they were maybe walking to the place where the main march was going to go on, but it's kind of classic sort of British Larry Louty behavior.

These people weren't carrying slogans. They weren't chanting anything. It didn't seem like they were there for a particular purpose. And there were houses that looked like they'd been recently built, a classic working class British street, you know, terrace, terrace, terrace, terrace, terrace, all the way along. This was a house that had those people. of stickers still on the windows that looked like they were sort of freshly created. You see one of the people pick up a big brick.

Just throw it through the window of this house that doesn't have anybody in. It's not like it's the house of an immigrant or the house of an enemy or the house of somebody from the other political party. It's very difficult to describe this to somebody that didn't spend half of their life, 18 years, in a northern working class town at a state primary, state secondary, state sixth form college. That was me.

I spent 11 years, no, 13 years in full-time education, right, around these people. I know these people. I know the way that they feel. And it's this ambient malevolence. They're disgruntled. They're unhappy. They feel stuck. And they don't know why. They're mean. They're mean about it. And the synopsis that I came up with was that...

Immigration wasn't the reason, it was the excuse for this kind of antisocial behavior. And we don't even remember ASBOs. I haven't fucking heard ASBOs in ages. Antisocial behavior order for the Americans. And it was the youths on street corners that would sort of, you know.

push and jumble granny as she tries to go to the corner shop to get milk and stuff like that they'd be issued with an anti-social behavior order which meant they sort of couldn't leave the house and they shouldn't go to certain areas kind of like a weird sort of curfew type thing and um that culture

in the uk and i'm sure it's everywhere i'm sure that working class towns and all the rest of it people don't necessarily have much in way of upward mobility they don't have much to distract them maybe they're a little bit despondent maybe they haven't had the right role models fatherless homes all of these things i understand

But that culture in the UK is so fucking self-defeating because it is a gravitational well that keeps people stuck to the floor as much as possible. That this is as good as things are going to be and the best use of your... agency and self-authorship is to break things, not to build things. And I know that intimately well. This ambient malevolence, it's like the air before a thunderstorm starts.

And that was what I saw in that video. It really got to me. It's the first time that I've seen something on the internet that really got to me and that really fucking got to me. So yeah. Well, I know what you mean. And I think the answer to that, and I know I keep banging on about net zero in this conversation, but the answer to that is to scrap net zero because.

what those people need is meaning and purpose. And for the vast majority of working class men, the primary source of meaning and purpose is going to be a job. And when you have a job that is... a meaningful job that you're making something you're building something that you're making good money that you're providing for your family that you feel like you have upward mobility and upward mobility doesn't have to look like

i grew up in newcastle and then i started a youtube channel now i live in austin texas mobility might be you know i made 30 grand a year for 10 years and now i'm making 35 and now i've got a promotion at work and now i own a home i own a home right Most people really don't need very much to be happy, to be honest. And it's a tragedy that in most of the Western world, and especially in the UK, the thing that we used to consider...

What is the American dream? The American dream is you arrive with nothing but the shirt on your back and your kids go to university, you have a house, maybe a small business, you pass it on to them and their children are... Better off. Really better off.

Well, if those people that you're talking about, where I agree with you, there's an underlying malevolence, and it's not malevolence, it's anger, really. It's frustration. It's frustration and anger. And what is that anger about? Well, the anger is about the feeling that... you're not going to be able to do the things that you thought you would. And what are they? Well, you get a job, you get a house, you have some kids.

They're going to be slightly better off than you. You're going to have dignity. You're going to have community. You're going to be respected. Meaning mastery. Right. Now, if you have a society which has effectively said, we're going to do. a green accounting trick. We're going to take your jobs. We're going to put them in India. We're going to put them in China where they're going to make the same steel or the same cars or the same whatever they used to make. They're going to do it dirtier.

Of course they are because it's a much less developed country. And then we're going to import that steel and we're going to import those cars back into the UK so we can pretend that we're green. Well... You combine that with this person no longer having a job and our economy, as I said, we're poorer now than we were in 2007.

What did you expect? Disgruntled. There's this feeling, there was always this feeling, but I can never put my finger on it, of kind of being forgotten in the northeast of the UK. It's like, on the outside a little bit, even... within a community on the outside of culture. Even- Even little things like the way that you were represented in media, like a story about Newcastle that hit the national press was like a...

whimsical fucking cottage industry piece or something like that. I said I was going to show you this video. Can we do one more thing on just that? Absolutely. So one of the things that we've talked about in the UK is like, well, we need to build infrastructure. We need to build transport. links and it's like why do you need a better train line to nowhere yeah um and and so what you really have to do is you have to

And that's why, you know, I was talking to Mary Harrington, who I know you're a fan of too, at our Christmas party, actually. And she was saying something I really have been thinking about as well, which is, I think... if we're in the offering solutions space, the solution for the UK is to accept the reality. That's always the first bit of the solution is to accept the reality that, you know, a slogan of make Britain great again, isn't going to work because we're not going to.

We're not going to recolonize India. Do you know what I mean? We're not going to rebuild the British Empire. What I think we could do if we really wanted to, but this would require both a political and a cultural shift on a level that would be extremely significant, would be... To recognize that over the 20th century, Britain went from being the center of Western civilization to being the provincial part of it. We're on the periphery now. The center of Western civilization after World War II.

during World War II, I would say, shifted from Britain to America. We are now effectively a... the European outpost of American civilization. It's a great point. That's what we are. Now, what does that mean? Well, what that means is we have to lean in to that.

That means we have to download the right memes from America. Instead of downloading the hands up, don't shoot meme, what we should be downloading is, okay, we want economic growth memes. How do you do that? Well, you're going to have to make energy cheap.

slash regulation, et cetera. You're going to have to do the right trade deals with that world, right? That means all sorts of other things that we borrow from them and apply to ourselves as opposed to thinking that we know best. We clearly don't. Otherwise, our society wouldn't be as screwed up as it is. And part of that is you're going to have to give people in deprived parts of the country work.

And you're going to have to find ways of employing them and actually creating things that are of value. And that means, yes, we in the UK may end up paying more for some of the things that they make, but that money is going to go to your neighbor. instead of a perfectly nice guy in India doing the same job. Yeah.

If we want our society to hold cohesively together some of the extremes of the globalization process, that is the reason why those people in Newcastle are angry and malevolent, mean and nasty. We're going to have to find ways to act.

And that means not chasing out the people who are job creators. And that means not pricing them out of the country by making business impossible. I think those of us in podcastistan... maybe over-index on what nice words and inspirational memes can do that I'm not convinced you can self-development mantra your way out of structural problems.

You know, it's all well and good trying to give people some upward aiming sense of hope and all the rest of it. But when there's really sort of structural problems, the physics of the system that these people are sort of involved in is very difficult. I'm not convinced that... that reframing you just need to sort of think more positively or do whatever like that's well they're both true in the sense that if you are a teenager in newcastle listening to this conversation

The world is your oyster. Correct. Look at Chris, right? Look at Chris. Look at other people who inspire you. You have the opportunity. You have access to the global economy with the internet and everything. You can make it. You can do that. But at a structural level... level of society. Not everyone who went to your school had the ability to become Chris Williamson. A lot of them just needed to have a great job in the local factory. That would have been the right solution.

Trust really is everything when it comes to supplements. A lot of brands may say they're top quality, but few can actually prove it, which is why I'm such a massive fan of Mementos. They make the highest quality supplements. on the planet. Three of the products that I use every day to support my brain, body, and sleep are omega-3s, creatine, and magnesium L3N8. Dr. Rhonda Patrick and Andrew Huberman have all extolled the virtues, and honestly, I try to limit the number of supplements I rely on.

But when I have these consistently, they make a massive impact on my cognitive performance and my strength and my health. Momentus are literally unparalleled when it comes to rigorous third-party testing, so you can be sure that what you read on the label is what's in the product and absolutely nothing.

else. If you're going to spend time and money on supplements, you need to make sure that they have what they say they have in them. Best of all, Momentus offers a 30-day money-back guarantee, so you can buy anything that you like, try it for 29 days, and if you do not love it, they will give you your money. back and they ship

internationally. Right now, you can get 20% off all of the products and that 30-day money-back guarantee by going to the link in the description below or heading to livemomentous.com slash modernwisdom and using the code modernwisdom at checkout. That's L-I-V-E-M-O-M-E-M.

N-T-O-U-S dot com slash modern wisdom and modern wisdom at checkout. I had this idea. So my housemate said for the first time in his life, his sister had a baby recently and he... held this kid and for the first time he realized why men went to war for their family because it was the first like new blood relative maybe that he'd ever held something like that and

We came up with this idea, and I think that it's true, that kind of relates to declining birth rates, that there's a mimetic sense to motherhood, like a mimetic desire for motherhood. If there's fewer mothers, it begets less people being mothers around you, which makes you less likely to see the beauty of motherhood, which makes you less... And the same thing goes for sort of this situation that he had. And I wonder whether there's something similar with this talent exit.

uh you know the most agentic people the most self-authoring people uh the ones who would break the mold that would uh push back against the tall poppy syndrome you are losing ever more of there is a dearth of precisely the

countervailing force that you want to the worst parts of some of British culture, the bottom up stuff, not the top down stuff. And it seems like a... recursive cycle and I appreciate that I have perhaps contributed to that after 15 years of coaching maybe a thousand 18 to 25 year olds in a desperate attempt to try and move culture I'm like pull the record, like I'm going to go somewhere else. Anyway, I was going to show you this video. So this is a TikTok of an American guy who...

spent six months in the UK, in London, and he's describing his experience. I've cut a little bit into this, but he's basically said his grandparents were British. He sees himself a little bit as British, and this isn't meant to be as a dig at British people. So we'll have a... have a watch of this the people there don't seem like they're having fun they seem like they're constantly trying to escape misery they seem like their work is just

so depressing and that the joke is that everything is depressing and bad and like that's the entire sense of humor it's like this all sucks um let's just make jokes about it the class system It's so obvious and weird. Like there are just upper class people, lower class people, and you're just born into it. And the accents, you can tell based on people's accents. And that's weird. In America...

It's pretty much like you have to give it to us or to America that you just earn your way. And I know there's lots of, you know, people, you get born into things, you're lucky. But if you... get rich. If you move up in your class, you're just able to. In England, it's like, you're never going to really be upper class if you're born lower class. They'll always know that you're not because it's about culture.

It's not just about money. It's about the way you act. And there's a lot of inter-class anger and weird feelings. And also, I just want to say, there's a lot of anger in the culture. I was at a lot of games, soccer games, Premier League games, things like that. And the fans are so angry. Like it's not like America where people get mad or whatever.

you know but it's like normal it's like they're a little mad in england they're like so pissed the whole time they're just looking for for like reasons to let their anger out And there's so much anger. There's so much swearing. There'll be a six-year-old just yelling the C word. It's like, what the hell? What's going on here? It's like borderline. I'm looking around thinking like, this is uncivilized.

Six-year-old yelling the C word. That's what makes Britain great. Make Britain great again. No, he's bang on, man. He's bang on. Look, I do think part of it is the weather, to be honest. Dude, it's huge. It's a huge...

massive influence you know what it's like you come out to austin texas when was the first time you came out this year february something like february march maybe march time i actually don't like the weather in austin to be honest march is fine march is fine well you only came in march and then you Back in October. Yeah, between November and March, the weather in Austin is fine. Beautiful. But if you spend a week in LA and you just look around, oh, I can see why these people are happy.

Because the weather is really nice. I think that's part of it. But that is the country. Okay, unless we're going to get to the stage where we can terraform the ozone layer above the UK, this isn't going to change. So what do you need to do? Compensate. Yes. Exactly. You have to compensate for it. And the compensation for it is like if you go to central London, the nice parts of it, it's a beautiful place. It's a beautiful place. And when...

On those three days a year when Britain is sunny, it's the most beautiful country in the world. But what you have to do is make the other things in this country so good that it trumps. It trumps that. And that means people have to have a better quality of life than they otherwise do. And that means they have to be able to afford a home. That means they have to be able to raise their kids.

and all the rest of it. You know, I was very persuaded by a book by a guy called Desmond Morris called The Human Zoo, in which he talked about the fact that essentially all the...

problems that we see in modern human society are exactly the problems you get if you put animals into those exact conditions. So in a zoo... the animals that are there they have much less space than they need they may be surrounded by other animals that they don't necessarily want to be surrounded by and all sorts of other things and they have the exact same outcomes in terms of interpersonal violence

mental health failure to reproduce and on and on and on so partly this is just a problem of the fact that we have a very very broken housing market which prices people out of it and you know the houses here are very small So most people end up flat sharing in central London or whatever, living four to a flat. Well, are you going to expect those people to be happy?

Are you going to expect them to have kids? That's personal space. That's personal space. And then all of the other things that build on top of it. So you have to have a fundamental shift in the way that this country operates. And in order for that to happen, maybe we need to hit that, you know, alcoholics rock bottom. What do you make? You mentioned it earlier on. What do you make of Starmer's recent comments on immigration?

Well, he is saying the Tories failed, which we all know is true, but I don't think he's going to make things any better. So I think this situation is going to continue the way it's been going because, as I say, we know this from having people like Suela Bravman on our show.

He basically said, you know, the reason I as Home Secretary, the person in charge, could not reduce immigration was not actually the thing that most other people are saying, which is, you know, the civil service doesn't let you, although I'm sure parts of that are true. It's that our own government didn't want it to happen. And the reason is they know that if we reduce mass immigration, we are going to have a problem with the economy.

Because the headline figure will be, well, we're no longer growing by the amazing figure of 0.7%. We're actually not growing. We're going to have to be honest with the British people about that. So yeah, I think that until people are prepared to be very honest, that's not going to happen. This is why I use the metaphor of hitting rock bottom. That's, as you well know, that's when you actually confront the reality of where you are.

Have you reached out to Dominic Cummings? Yeah, he's coming on the show, Shane. Unreal. I mean, the most recent episode that I saw, I can't remember who the podcast was, but he was talking about how, would you say, curated... and fabricated a lot of the press. governmental sort of press opportunities are people sort of walk down and they could get the photo outside of 10 Downing Street and they're going, this is very, very important. And there's a script that's followed. It's like fake meetings.

everything there's very much a uh house of cards style optics management thing who's talking about how basically most of the mps consider that all they're doing is looking for their feature within the newspaper for that particular week, that's considered a win. Not impact on the country, not doing good things for the electorate.

It's even more scary in the UK because in America, you kind of think about the sort of vanity. I'm aware that that's just a stereotype. In the UK, you would think, well... No one even fucking cares. Evidently you do within the small bubble of Whitehall or Westminster or wherever it is that you are. But yeah, this over-concern, and maybe this is fed into by the British predisposition pre-

sort of obsession with class, with what is my place within society? How can I ensure that I maintain? How's my optics management thing going on in image control? We are not attracting the best talent. Any talent that does get there is being perverted by bizarre incentives.

any change that does need to be made is curtailed by a combination of those two things, by the fact that there's nobody competent around you to fucking deploy it. And anybody that is competent is distracted by other things. In the same way as Americans rail against the fact that... whatever percentage, some absurd percentage of time is spent doing fundraising. Like more than 50% of the time is spent doing fundraising.

I would guess something not too dissimilar happens in the UK, but around this image management, going to the right meetings. And Rory Stewart said this. Rory Stewart's book said this too. He describes in... like exquisite detail the smell of these people so it's sort of like stale beer and cheap cologne covered over with cheap cologne and um i don't know these are people that are fucking running the country that mean you have spent most of our lives in.

This is the thing that a lot of people will say in response to this, which is, you know, those that do remember, remember the 70s. I don't remember the 70s. I wasn't born, neither were you. But what they will tell you is the reason Thatcher ended up being so popular. she came in at a time when literally the dead weren't being buried and rubbish was piling up in the streets or shortly after that and she created an

A country full of aspiration and drive and a willingness to do business and cut regulation and all of this other stuff. And this is why we talk about, you know, the Trump victory has the potential. But as we've been discussing. There's a long, long way to go and a lot of things need to get turned around. My view on it is that it's my duty as someone who's an immigrant to this country, to whom this country has given a lot.

uh it's given the opportunity to be who i am uh to give it my best shot in terms with the tiny amount of influence that i have to do everything that i can but i'm not i'm not I'm not wedded to the idea of going down with the ship.

And this is the point I would make about, you know, there's a lot of sneering about this idea of the talented and the wealthy and the successful leaving. Oh, these are mercenary people. We didn't want them anyway. A lot of them really aren't mercenary at all. A lot of them would have much rather stayed in.

the UK. A lot of them would have much rather had their business in the UK. A lot of them would have much rather created jobs in the UK than in Dubai or in Texas or somewhere else. A lot of them would love to be here. But the problem is the only people who do end up staying are people who are either too rich to care. In other words, they don't mind.

paying 50 tax because they've got so much money they've got their children in a nice school or whatever they're protected from most of the crap that the rest of us have to deal with and so they just you know enjoy going from the club in mayfair to the house and in wherever and and they have

great life and there's no reason for them to leave and then everyone else who can't physically leave because they just don't have the opportunity to do that but the the slice of people in the middle a lot of them really don't want to leave i don't want to leave the uk i really like it here What do you think you're going to do? I'm going to wait and see. But the point I'm making to you is people who are by the fortune of the opportunities they have.

not wedded to this country, but not rich enough or successful enough to be able to cope with what's happening. That space of people are not mercenary at all. They are just being forced out. And if I'm one of them, I will hate and regret that. But I'm not going to stay forever in a country that I think is declining and going into degradation. Why would I? And particularly as a father. My wife and I, you know, I'm 40.

something years old by the by the end of my you know i will live out my life in this country comfortably even if the you know the crime and the whatever continues to go though i'll be able to afford to live in a part of the country or move further and out from the big cities or whatever that i can live the next 40 or 50 years without really things being terrible but why would I condemn my children to that when

I have the opportunity to offer them a better life. And that's really the question that people will be asking. And the people who run our country and the people who make these decisions have to ask themselves. What are they offering to the next generation that's going to make them want to be here as opposed to seeing this country like many other countries have been seen in the past as a sinking ship from which you want to escape? What are you doing to prevent that? That's the question.

We'll get back to talking to Constantine in one minute, but first, I need to tell you about Element. For the last... Three years, every single day, I have started my morning with Element. It's a tasty electrolyte drink mix with everything that you need and nothing that you don't. You might not be tired. You might not need more caffeine. You might just be dehydrated. Proper hydration is not just about drinking sufficient water.

having the right amount of electrolytes in your body to let yourself use those fluids. Element contains a science-backed electrolyte ratio of sodium, potassium and magnesium with no sugar, no coloring, no artificial ingredients or any other. junk it's a game changer this orange salt first thing in the morning

tastes phenomenal. And they have a no questions asked unlimited duration refund policy. So you can buy it, try the entire box. And if you don't like it for any reason, they'll give you your money back and you don't even need to return it. That's how confident they are that you'll love it.

Right now, you can get a free sample pack of all eight flavors with any box by going to the link in the description below or heading to drinklmnt.com slash modern wisdom. That's drinklmnt.com slash modern wisdom. We have touched on it a couple of times already. Give me your assessment of the state of legacy media. at the moment, maybe the post-mortem, post-election, their level of credibility. I think MSNBC's ratings recently...

collapsed to its lowest since July 19th, 2004. 38,000 total viewers in the 24 to 54 age group, a 30-year age bracket. Look, there's a lot of, I have an article in my Substack, which is also a video called The Real Reason the Mainstream Media is Dying. And I think there's actually a lot of economic and other drivers of this. People in our space like to go, oh, they've been discredited. Well, actually, if you apply the same standards to new media, most of the new media is equally discreditable.

Correct. It's not exactly showering itself in glory. No, and it's, you know, the amount of fact-checking that happens... Just held to way less rigorous standards. Right. That's basically... all the differences. It's like people on a podcast who will have some crazy guy on who's talking completely nonsense. What did you expect? It's just, you know, it's me. We're just shooting the shit. Right. Have a bigger audience than...

MSNBC or CNN, who then go, look at how they got this tiny fact wrong. So there's a lot of this bullshit going on, I think. Agreed. But the real reason is that I think the real shift is less about that, actually. And I think a lot of it is. to do with the economics of how media works. If you think about what a news channel is or a newspaper is, it's basically they are buying individual creators, packaging them together.

and offering it to people as a package. You no longer need to do that because algorithms exist and you're able to curate your own stuff. And it also doesn't really make financial sense for the content creators. Nobody could... put you on tv now and it's not because

um of of the because you think tv is discredited it is because they don't have the audience to offer you or the money to offer you or whatever because it makes more sense for you to cut out the middleman and go straight to your audience the same for me with my sub stack it's the same me with trigonometry on youtube so what's happening is the mainstream institutions are simply losing the ability to maintain the top talent and over time

you will see that must customization that we talked about with drinks applied to content as well. And probably, you know, the next big thing is going to be some sort of thing on your phone which curates on an algorithm basis.

all the content that you like from different platforms, as opposed to being like, hey, I'm going on YouTube and I'm seeing this. If you had a thing on an app on your phone that went, well, here's the newspaper article you really want to go to read, the sub stack from whoever. the video from whoever etc a couple of tweets that are yep exactly um so

The economics of the whole thing are changing. And there's just a lot more competition now. So people have way more choice. And so you can go to wherever your particular preferences are being panned to in the best possible way. And you can get exactly the thing. Or outrage. Or outrage or whatever. And, you know, as I say, for better or worse, you're going to get exactly what you want. What's your thoughts on this? I guess.

bifurcating, trifurcating of social media networks. A lot of liberal type people leaving X over the last month. Also, some going to Blue Sky, some just swearing off of this altogether. The Guardian made a hefty exit note. I wonder whether they'll be back at some point. What are the implications? of not only people being within their own echo chambers on the same platform, but being within their own echo chambers now that are entire universes apart.

Yeah, I don't think that's really happened in the sense that people think it's happened. I think what's happened is a lot of people have made loud exits. I don't think that the vast majority of those left-wing people have left to X. Some have. They post more on Instagram now or whatever. But broadly speaking, nobody wants to be on the third best social media platform. The network effect is very real. And so I don't think we're actually going to split off into our own.

political commentary websites because the interaction is quite valuable with different sites. But we will see how that evolves. I mean, one of the things I am hopeful with X is that I was incredibly grateful to Elon for buying it and for the changes that he's made but I do think there's more work to do things that he himself identified when he took over like dealing with the bot issue and it has become a bit of a cesspit

It really has. The shitposting is real. Yeah, and so... Do you think Trump would have got in if Elon hadn't bought X? Nobody knows. I suspect not, but...

maybe he would have done. I don't think anybody really knows. I think Elon's support and X was a big factor. Cool thought experiment. But I really hope that over time what happens is... uh elon continues to improve x and there are improvements that could be made and certainly finding a way like i don't need to see the n-word in every reply do you know what i mean

Do you see what I'm saying? Like that, that would be quite nice. And, and I'm sure there's, there's ways of dealing with that. You know, Eric Weinstein, when we had him on, we had him. kind of back and forth and I sort of accused them of not having solutions and I don't have solutions exactly but I think the problem Jordan Peterson put his finger on a long time ago is that online anonymity causes a lot of issues. Online anonymity is also extremely valuable, but there's got to be some way.

of finding some kind of golden solutions only trade-offs right that yeah it what was it that he once said um anonymity online has driven the proximate price of being a prick down to zero And so my point is, I'm not a snowflake who's triggered by some unpleasant word in the thing. I just recognize that.

If we're going to have a public square, the most retarded person ever shouting the most offensive word that he can think of the loudest is probably not conducive to a healthy discussion. And also, is it an enjoyable environment to be in? You want to go on to social media? You know, everybody's seen this. It was Tristan Harris or the litany of limbic hijack techniques that we've seen from...

intermittent schedule rewards to designs being taken from gambling and casinos and stuff, all of that stuff. Even if that is all happening, at least trying to restrict down to make it an enjoyable experience. If you're going to hack my... fundamental psychology to get me addicted to this app. At least have the thing that I'm addicted to, the content that I'm addicted to be something that once I finish up, I go,

So I went to this Spotify event in LA a couple of weeks ago. They announced this new creator partner program thing. And I went there and I got to sit down with Alex Nordstrom, who's president. And he told me...

Roman Wassermuller as well, who's like the head of podcasting, told me the same thing. He said, we want the hour that people spend on Spotify every day, no matter what it is, but they're specifically talking about podcasting. We want that to be the best hour of their day that they spend on their screens.

that they look back at it and they have no regrets. And they think that made my life better when we leave. And I don't know how many other apps, membership services and sites and stuff like that can say the same thing. How much did they pay you to say that? Nothing yet. But I think it's genuinely true. When I reflect on my own experience, when I reflect on my own use of these sorts of platforms,

I can't always say the same thing for YouTube. I need to be more disciplined on YouTube. It's like a tool that can be used for good or evil on YouTube. And then as we get more toward Instagram, it sort of skews a little bit darker. five times a year that i go into tiktok i'm like oh my god uh it's a potent fucking fuel um substack i would say for me is even more reliably

better. Well, Substack's amazing. Hours spent than on Spotify, but more effortful. Yes, you have to read. Exactly. Even if I listen, you know, voiceovers and stuff like that. But yeah, I'm just, I really, really hope. that that that energy can kind of be a little bit more infused. And I'm aware that that is going to damage time on site, that that's going to reduce interaction, that's going to reduce engagement, that's going to make companies less profitable in some ways or whatever.

I wonder whether the post-content clarity that people have after they've spent a bit of time on something can end up winning over outrage. triggering porn at all costs and um yeah i i that makes sense to me around like There's every other reply. There is a lot of shitposting on X now because it's like the shiny new toy where people can say pretty much whatever they want. And it's just not a superbly enjoyable experience.

as much of the time as I would like it to be. It should be able to be easily fixed. Should it? I would hope so. I think that if you can curate your algorithm in a manner where you can say, hey, I want to step in. I'm not limiting free speech at all. Like that's not the sort of stuff I want to see. I don't see music from very many jazz bands on Spotify. You know, the YouTube algorithm.

tends to show me stuff for the most part that i actually agree with youtube doesn't outrage upon you all that much with opposing point of view now maybe that's echo chambery and obviously lots of content creators that you like may find something not that you agree with but something they disagree with which you will also disagree with um but i get the sense that

There could be more work to be done. That being said, I follow 101 people on Twitter, which is a very good way to just constrain down reality to the point where most of what you see is fine. But I'm aware that that's a... And you can mute people who are rude or whatever or block them. Even that, the muting and the blocking thing... announced an update to that relatively recently, I think. Yeah, the blocking thing. People you've blocked still see your stuff. Hmm. Yeah.

Odd. I don't know. I think it would be good. You tweeted about something actually that I missed. I've been largely offline for the last month. So I check in briefly, see what's going on, and then fuck the fuck off again. You tweeted about people removing pronouns. from their ex-bio. What have I missed here? Is that a thing? Is that a trend that's going on? Yeah, yeah. After the election, a lot of people, AOC did it, among other people.

What I said about that is they were sheep when they put them in their pyres and they're sheep now when they're removing them. And I think that's true. And the point I was trying to make is not that I don't welcome people doing that. The point I was trying to make is that... A lot of people...

make decisions not on the basis of what they think is right or true or moral or whatever, but on the basis of what other people are doing. And it's an important thing to keep in mind when we talk about a lot of these social movements because they're really driven by a very small number of... people who seem to have currency or power in that environment. And that's a kind of reassuring thing in many ways about the possibility of change. We talked about the UK and how stuck it feels at the moment.

All it takes is a significant number of high status people to have a different perspective. And that perspective then becomes the dominant one, as we saw in America with the Trump election. So, but yeah, there is a readjustment happening in response. to the landslide that Trump managed to secure. Yeah, I mean, we saw this. I think my favorite examples of this are how quickly the word politically correct became sort of-

impossible to use unironically. And then the word woke, the feedback mechanism on woke was what felt like to me within six months, that it was a word nobody used, a word that certain people used in an unironic way. almost immediately alchemized into a word that could not be used unironically. And now there needs to be something else, socially aware or whatever. I'm not sure what it is. And that's one of the situations. I always question a little bit the...

power of ridicule for creating social change. I think part of that is just that the UK has tried to sort of piss take its way out of many problems without much profit or success. But that is one of those examples where you think it was a word that people didn't like and very quickly had pushback against it and it was here and gone before you even knew it. You know what I mean? Yeah.

Yeah, well, that can happen, especially when the underlying concepts are as ridiculous as they are. People will then use, and you're right, it was very funny because you literally had people writing articles in The Guardian about why they're woke. And then like six months later saying, oh, well, these right wing people are calling us woke. Yeah. You had this interesting perspective about a lesson that societies don't last forever.

cultures and empires providing additional perspective when thinking about cultural issues, obviously something pretty salient to you given where you were born. What is that additional? perspective or insight? What's the lesson that should be taken away from that? I can't remember who said this, but there's this very famous line that things that can't last forever won't. If something can't go on forever, it won't.

And so when we look at the direction of Western society over the last 10, 15 years, we talked about it in the UK, we've talked about it in Europe, and to some extent. in the united states unless trump really is able to turn it around um if you run very high levels of debt If you have high levels of crime, if you have high levels of illegal and legal immigration that fundamentally change the values and culture of a country, if you refuse to prioritize the citizens of your own country.

and say we want to take care of our people if you refuse to Pursue economic growth at the cost of other things, which that's what you have to do because everything is trade-off. So if you want more economic growth, you might have less climate obsession or whatever. have a situation where young people can't advance as we've talked about if we have a situation where large communities of people don't have access to meaningful work on and on and on if that goes on for a period of time

I know from my Soviet experience that societies don't always last forever. And then if you actually look at history, you know that no society lasted forever, ever. So when things are bad and continually so and keep getting worse, and this is maintained over a period of time, and on top of that, you're told actually this is the right way to go, it's not unreasonable in that situation to say, well, If we carry on going in this direction, this is going to end badly. Now...

At the same time, people like me who make this point often get accused of like scaremongering and whatever, you know, and it's true. Like I remember in the 90s when I was talking to my dad about my job prospects, he was like, look, definitely don't be a lawyer because. on current trends by the year 2000, everyone in the world is going to be a lawyer.

Surprise, surprise, not everyone in the world is a lawyer. And so societies do change track over time and people change track over time. But it's the job, I feel, of people like me who've had that experience of knowing that society doesn't last forever to remind people. that like it's all all our civilization is is like a big jenga block like you can pull some out and it will stay standing but if you pull all of the cause bits out yeah

is actually capable of collapse. This isn't guaranteed to last forever. It's one of those people that takes their relationship, their significant other for granted over and over again. And they don't do the things that need to keep the relationship on track. And then one day.

the relationship breaks down and that person leaves them. And I get it. You know, the vast majority of Western citizens are, historically speaking, very passive, very, very unwilling to revolt, very unwilling to engage in violence, very unwilling to overthrow the government, very comfortable by comparative standards. to previous centuries ago where it's literally like, well, I could die tomorrow of disease and hunger, starvation, because you're not looking after me, or I could...

try and overthrow you. Like, what do I really have to lose? Most people in the West are not like that. And so the people in charge are very insulated and protected. There's a level of comfort that sedates the populace from doing that. Yes, I get it. But you've got to recognize that that's...

that can change over time. And I would really like us not to push as far as we possibly can to find out where that line is, where you piss people off enough. Do you see what I mean? Why don't we just like- Is that a risk, do you think? Not right now, but it was in the summer in this country. We had riots in this country from people who, as you rightly say, you know, the media and...

other people tried to call them far right. I thought the vast majority of them were not remotely political at all. So what does that tell you? It tells you that there's a significant body of the population. who are very, very, very frustrated. There's some kindling there. The kindling is undoubtedly there. And by the way, not just among those people. You saw from the Muslim community the feeling that like, well, we've got to go and tool up and be in the streets to defend ourselves.

you have those two forces rising at once, it's not a good outcome. And so, no, I'm not saying... Again, like when I had this, I don't know if you saw my conversation with this journalist about Elon Musk. It's a recorded conversation with him trying to... interrogate me about why i agree with elon that is civil war it's a video on our channel it's done crazy numbers because he's trying to it shows you all the sleazy old school approaches that was it for your channel or for somebody else

Fire Channel. Who is it? It's like NBC journalist versus Constantine kissing about Elon Musk or something like that. And he tries to catch me out and it really doesn't end well for him. But the broader point is Elon said... looking at the riots in the uk the logical conclusion of this or something like that is civil war and i think he's right that doesn't mean that i think we're there now it doesn't mean that i think we're

guaranteed to get there and that we can't intervene and it certainly doesn't mean that we can't intervene i think the reason that elon and i are both saying this is a possibility is we'd like it not to happen but for it not to happen things have to be improved. And my invitation to the people who have the ability to change things to the extent that they do...

is to recognize that, yes, we're not there right now, but you carry this shit on for another 20 years, you have no idea what the situation is going to be like. It's strange that that sort of rhetoric is sometimes interpreted as a threat. It's like I'm not... This isn't me saying that this is an outcome that I'm looking for, but just like head in sand. This isn't an option. This isn't going to happen. You're being overblown.

I don't know, man. You're right. But it happens in everything. You know this. Like I actually know personally somebody whose mother went to the hospital because she had diabetes. And the doctor said, if you keep up the diet that you have. you will die and have very serious complications as a result of your diabetes because you are obese. And that person, who's my friend's relative, reported the doctor.

for being offensive or whatever and this is what people often do it's like if you say if you only eat ice cream you're actually going to get fat and and be unhealthy people sort of like they they blame you for telling them that truth And this is the same thing. It's like nobody who's predicting that we're heading in the wrong direction wants us to be heading in the wrong direction. On the contrary. But you get blamed for warning about the things that end up.

happening and it doesn't make any sense to me so i just to be clear i want the west to be prosperous successful. I want it absolutely unashamedly to be the dominant civilization in the world. I don't want any of this multipolar bollocks. Our civilization is the best civilization on the planet. Its values such as they were classically.

not a lot of all this other rainbow bullshit, are the right values. They're the best values human beings have ever come up with. Freedom in every form. Liberty. The capitalist model, which has... Areas that need managing carefully, but broadly speaking, it's about unleashing the talents of human beings and rewarding them for cooperation. And all of these other things that we've developed over time, they are the best values.

I'm not saying we have to go and impose them on anybody else. In fact, that's not how freedom works. People have to buy into it. And so I'm not into going and... bombing Iraq into democracy, bombing Afghanistan into freedom, because clearly it doesn't work. But our civilization is the best. Our civilization needs to be strong, confident, prosperous.

and united. And that is very far from where we are. And that's the goal I'd like us to be working with. So when I say we're heading in the wrong direction, what I mean is let's head in this direction instead. Yes, yes, yes, yes. I'm interested in how your worldview's changed since becoming a dad. You know, somebody that spent a good bit of time sort of thinking about this stuff. How am I positioned within society, within culture, with, you know.

broad perspective on different cultures, different backgrounds, the directions that things can go in, the time that you spend professionally doing this stuff. But then you have a very visceral experience, which is mini me in the world. What have you...

What have you learned? Has much changed? Have you been surprised by anything? First of all, it changes you in a way that isn't conscious, first and foremost. So I remember literally like... a week after finding out that my wife was pregnant, I was driving into the studio, someone cut in front of me and I, and I,

I later realized I hadn't reacted in the way that I used to react. So in the past, I would have been like, what are you doing? And I was just like, you know what? I've got somewhere to be. I haven't got time for this bullshit. So it changes you in that way. It's a very humbling experience for a number of reasons. One of them is my firm belief is that you can never be happy until you've forgiven your parents.

I don't think it's possible. I don't think a human being can be happy until they've forgiven their parents. Forgiving isn't the same as condone accept that what they did was right in every way. You just can't be happy and fulfilled until you've let go of the resentments that everyone has towards their parents one way or another. Everybody has them. Even the people who had the best childhood, there was still, you know.

When they put the egg on your silver plate, you know, there was something imperfect about it or whatever. So one of the things that really helps with that, I found, is that... you've got the mini me as you say and you suddenly recognize oh wait i am doing the best with the resources that i have and i'm not perfect and then i look back at my parents so my parents had me when my mother had been 18 for four days

My dad was 20. I was an accident. There were two deeply impoverished students in Moscow in the Soviet Union in the 1980s. There were no books about raising kids. There was no internet. There was no, can I Google this? Can I Google that? My mom tells the story to this day of how one day when I was a toddler, she...

came home and discovered me as a toddler, maybe not even came home, maybe she was in that other room or something. And I had this triangular pack of milk that I was glugging, this carton of milk that we had in the Soviet Union.

drinking it and she was horrified because she was using that milk to make the porridge or whatever and that was the only milk that we could afford that day so when i look at that versus the opportunity i have with my son and compare it gives me a lot more compassion for them and the way that they were versus uh the way that i am now so you found in some ways reflection, healing of your own childhood in fatherhood. Yeah. Now, to be honest with you, I don't think that...

Having a child isn't going to solve all those problems, but it's certainly a helpful factor in understanding the context of that. And it's just very humbling in understanding your own imperfections, recognizing that you don't always behave in the best way. And then actually taking action to remedy that and realizing this, I've gone to the next level.

now i have to be at the next level i have to be better i have to be uh you know i have to deal with the shit that i still haven't dealt with that i didn't realize i had and all of that stuff so on a personal development perspective amazing then

It connects you fundamentally, I believe, with the past and the future in a way that nothing else does. It connects you with the past in the sense that you recognize that you are just... passing on some things that happened for centuries before you got here and also that you're the custodian of the future and that your child is going to be the custodian of the future too so to that extent it makes me think much more

inclusively about the country that I live in. It makes me want to contribute more to be a more positive influence in the world to improve the society that I live in.

Or as we talked about earlier, to find one that matches my values and creates the opportunities I want for my children going forward. So it makes me really, really care about the place that I live in because I know that I will be living here even... after i'm dead see what i mean um so that's another one it also uh it it puts a lot of strain on the relationship you have with your wife because you've suddenly got less time less time together

More things are difficult, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And so that means you have to go to the next level as a couple. You really have to up your game together. And that's, that's been really. Did your background, I'm interested.

People might not know this, but you've done quite a bit of sort of emotional work, things, courses, so on and so forth that we've spoken about. Two elements that I'm interested in, whether or not you're... inner work, emotional, personal development side stuff, you think that that contributed to maybe being a bit more robust as a parent for these and also your time in the business.

building up the business, like operationally effective as a person managing spinning plates, like having to deploy orders, you know, oh, there's none of the nappies that we need from this store that we, you know, like just that kind of logistical.

Yeah, and the management of human beings too, right? I heard this great thing, just as an aside, I wanted to share with you Warren Buffett's three things that you need in people that you... employ um it was integrity intelligence and energy and he was like and people think that the worst you could possibly have is someone who's low integrity low energy and low intelligence and he's like

That is not true. The worst thing you can have is someone who's high energy, high intelligence, low integrity. Yeah, working incredibly hard at making things worse. Yeah, or stealing company money or whatever it is.

But anyway, yeah, of course. Jordan said this to me, actually. I remember talking about this and he asked me, uh about you know what difference running trigonometry had made and i talked about managing people and he was like oh yeah running a business is like a fatherhood by proxy which i think to some extent it is hopefully your employees are not bawling their eyes out and shitting their pants every two hours but nonetheless depends how many episodes we try to do in a day

But yeah, of course, you're more prepared. I mean, the one thing I say to everybody who asked me this is like, whatever it is that you know is lacking in your skill set. get it sorted before you become a parent. Like if you don't know how to ride a bike.

learn to ride a bike before you become a parent if you don't have to drive a car learn how to drive if you don't have to manage your emotions learn to do that before you what was the thing or was there anything that uh in retrospect uh like potential father constantin you'd have been like hey man you've got nine months like fucking that's a good area that you could focus on so you don't need to do it once he's arrived the most important thing is um

I think it's a mistake most people made. My wife and I definitely made it, which is once the child is born, you totally forget about your relationship. And you're just like, how do we actually... like keep this baby alive, and you don't go out on dates and you don't spend time together with each other. The romance can suffer. It's not just romance, it's the connection.

It's fundamentally the connection. And so there's a danger that you become business partners who are dealing with a difficult problem as opposed to a couple who's... like a couple and then the baby is kind of there you know what i mean and so there was definitely a period where we didn't do enough of that so now we're like having a day every week making sure that we're spending time together you know having lots of conversations

Lots of flowers, lots of all of that. Just really making sure that the relationship is first, the parenting is second in the sense that you can't really be a good parent if your relationship is not working optimally. So that's definitely, definitely very important. And then I believe that all performance in every area ultimately comes down to how psychologically.

aligned you are with who you want to be you know so if you whatever psychological issues you have they are going to be the thing that affects whether you're a good boss or not whether you're a good dad or not whether you're a good husband or not all of those things so that

feeling of continually working on yourself. I'm reading a book now that somebody in LA gave me about how to be a good husband. The next one is how to raise boys. The next one is, you know, so that's what, that's where my focus is now is how do you.

improve in those areas and one of the reasons i'm so obsessed with that is it's like the impact is the greatest you know a two-year-old really takes on the lessons of whatever it is that you're a very permeable sponge yeah uh but but perhaps irreversibly so so you really want to make sure that you're like

You can't squeeze the crap out of the sponge again. So you want to make sure that you're at your best. Is that a motivating force for you? Already somebody who, you know, like maybe lots of the people that are listening who don't yet have kids. Open aiming, self-authoring, agency, intentionality, all of those things. And then you think, oh, you know, the RPM limiter is already bouncing off the top. And then you realize that there's five more gears that you could step into from a...

obsession, intensity, intentionality standpoint now that you're doing something for somebody else? Yeah, it's interesting. I don't mean to be picky with the metaphor, but it's not like there's five more gears vertically. It's not like there's a sixth and a seventh and an eighth gear. It's more like... Like when you are one of the driven people like us and you're obsessed with your work and you love what you do and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.

can be tempting to just go, well, there's this other area of life, which is personal relationships, where it's like, well, as long as I'm making enough money and being successful out here, I don't really need to worry too much about that. I fundamentally don't believe that, which is why...

In some ways, I really admire people who don't have an amazing woman by their side, as I've been lucky to have, who are still able to be successful. Because I know that for me, there's no fucking way that would have happened.

that i really needed to be pulled back into like as the success of our channel has happened and everything else i've really had to be dragged back into okay this is a time to go back to the thing you did 10, 15 years ago where you go, okay, the relationship isn't exactly how I want it.

let's focus on this let's work on this um and so it's i find life is like those five bars that you're trying to balance at the same time and as this one goes up this one is slipping and and whatever so i'm just trying to raise all of them at the same time as much as i can and that means you know i look at you traveling around the world

way more than i could possibly do and doing things that i might not be able to do and like i'm i'm spending that time with my son to me that's a worthwhile trade-off and then you'll get to that stage at some point where you'll be like i can't wait I can't wait. And, you know, my friend a few years ago in Austin said to me, successful guy, big business, besotted, smitten with his new partner. And they're starting to talk about engagements and kids and all the rest of this stuff.

And he said, I realized I spent most of my 20s and half of my 30s making myself into the person I wanted to be as a father. And I saw how beautiful way to alchemize all of the stuff you do. Because there is a kind of... sterile isolation to doing things just for yourself.

Even if they're grand, even if they are you enacting your logos forward, actualizing your purpose and stuff, and they can still give you meaning. But there is, especially if you've got to some... degree of success which is maybe why people that reach success uh struggle even more so because they realize that success wasn't filling the hole that they thought it would do um and there is a little bit of me that thinks well how great if you kind of get to You get to benefit twice.

from this thing you did all of this work because you wanted to fix yourself and maybe the reason you wanted to fix yourself was to become successful so you could be validated and have social recognition and stuff like that maybe that's not like the most superbly virtuous alignment but it sort of put you in the right direction And then later on, you realize that all of that work has this additional second benefit.

that somebody who wasn't obsessed to do that, regardless of what the motivation was, you now have this beautiful foundation that you can then pay forward. And I think that's a really lovely type of alchemy, I think. You know that quote, I'll butcher it, but what does it profit a man to gain the world and lose his soul or something like that? And the way I look at success is what does it profit you to have millions in the bank?

If the people around you are miserable or don't exist, what have you, you know, the fulfillment you get from family is incomparable. Now. If you're living in the bedsit and struggling to pay the bills... It puts so much strain on your life that it's very difficult to enjoy. And some people, you know, are saints and are able to actually enjoy that in difficult circumstances. You know, people always go, well, money can't buy you happiness.

It can make it a lot easier to be happy. That's for sure. Poverty can make you miserable. Yes. And all money is is a tool. So if you use that tool to solve problems that get in the way of your happiness, it can. make you happy my friend george talks about people that say money doesn't buy you happiness never met p diddy's neighbors the difference you buy this expensive house fuck you realize it's next to p diddy you spend a tiny bit more money now you have earplugs uh that

It's very much how you deploy it. Yes. And so I think success, especially for a man, is a great thing to pursue. And one of the reasons is that... If you want to be more successful, you're going to have to be better. You have to work on yourself. You have to get better as a human being. Hopefully. Hopefully. Not everybody does. But once you've got that success.

And you are making good money and you're, you know, whatever. Something Jordan said to me when we were on tour together, he said, the best place to store excess resources is in your reputation. That's interesting. What's that mean to you?

What it means is once you're doing well, the best thing that you can possibly do with the extra resources that you have is to help other people, is to make opportunities for other people, is to... be somebody to other people benefit from knowing is to be good to your family too in you know in some respect so the resources that you have whether it's money or connections or whatever are really best deployed into other people around you because that's how

you're going to have the best possible life. And I think that's fundamentally true. It gives me way more joy to buy my wife something than to spend that money on myself. Correct. And the same for, you know, seeing my son's eyes light up when he... something happens that we now can afford that we couldn't before think about this you know i imagine as the uh recovering workaholic or maybe still recovering workaholic um the the you may be and i almost certainly will have to be that

I'm not recovering. I love work. I will always love work. But think about it this way. There's this lovely insight from James Clear where he says that if you're already at a level of material comfort, trading quality of life for more money is a bad deal. The...

level of success, the level of material comfort, so on and so forth. One of the best gifts that you can give, which is totally non-obvious, is to say, I'm going to leave additional revenue on the table. I'm going to leave additional life experiences, travel the world less, do fewer live events, which all of this stuff you can do. could do more in order to do that and how much does son's eyes light up from new toy truck versus from daddy being at home for an additional

five hours a week. And that's one of those sort of hidden metrics. It's never going to appear on a balance sheet somewhere, not objectively. very much is something that you need to dedicate a good bit of time to. Yes. And I remember I had a very interesting conversation with Bill Ackman. It was a private one, but I don't imagine he would mind. He probably has talked about this elsewhere in public. Him and I were just having lunch.

And his wife is amazing in her own right. Oh, yeah. She's like a super genius, like ex-model, PhD, fucking like interstellar person, right? She's incredible. Lovely human being. Just wonderful. They both are great people, actually.

But Bill was saying to me, Bill is one of the most successful investors in the history of capitalism. And he showed me a graph where there was like a massive dip in the company valuation and then it just goes massively back up. And he went right at the bottom and he said, this is when we got together and he said this is not an accident he said when your personal life is good you inevitably succeed in everything else because it's the foundation from which you operate and so that

that happiness and joy that he has from being married to a woman he is clearly just passionate and passionately in love with who's great for him he's he says that that is a big part of his business success and i have no doubt that that's true uh you know when when the foundation of everything that you're doing is strong it's so much easier to do everything else it's probably you i mean i'm hardly an expert on bodybuilding but

But I imagine if you've got a weak core and you do lots of really heavy lifting, it's probably not that good for you, right? And so to me, family and the relationships you have with the people around you are really that core that you build everything else on. It's very interesting.

Constantine Kissin, ladies and gentlemen. Dudes, I appreciate the heck out of you. I always love having a chat. Where should people go? I'm going to keep up to date with everything you're doing. My sub stack, ConstantineKissin.com and Trigonometry, the YouTube channel and podcast. Highly recommended. Also, I think that you have done a great job. of uh writing a book and selling it by the sentence we do the article then you get early access on that that's monetized then that gets

put into a spoken script that people can watch on the YouTube, then that'll get clipped. Everyone's copying that now, have you noticed? I have somewhat. It is a price that you're going to pay for finding anything that's effective. Oh, I love it. I love it. This is one of the things that people get very upset in our space.

about like stealing ideas and i'm like they're not stealing they are take the proof of concepting what i've done precisely correct that's great i want more great people to be doing exactly the thing that and this is i was not always like this this is one of the things i've learned and actually the

The person I've learned that from is Rogan, undoubtedly. Because he's like, you should have a podcast. Everyone gets a podcast. Whereas most people mentality when they're ahead of everybody else is like... Yeah. No, stay out. Shut it down. And Joe's like, there's enough in this world. More for everybody. There's more for everybody. And that, let's grow the pie instead of obsess about how we divide the pie thing. It's a much nicer way to operate as well. It's the best.

It's awesome, man. I really think that the stuff that you're putting out, this sort of position that you guys have carved for yourselves is super interesting. And long, mate, continue.

Well, I appreciate you as well, man. And you've had amazing success this year. So congratulations. You're going to cut this out like last time. Last time I said, well done, congratulations. And you cut it out of the episode. Don't do it again. Okay. Dean, did you listen to that? Stop it. All right. Appreciate you, man. Until next time. Thanks, brother. Appreciate it.