John and Daryn discuss a series of brutal murders that occurred in small town Logan, Ohio, for which the very suspicious Dale Johnston was arrested and imprisoned. But is Dale guilty, or is the real killer still on the loose? Check out Detective's Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder ...
Sep 01, 2019•38 min
John talks about his recent psychic reading and its bizarre accuracy. Daryn recalls some of her psychic readings as well as being tormented by a mouse over the weekend. Sign Up for Oxygen's Detective's Den! The next e-mail will be full of exclusive Martinis & Murder content, swag and giveaways! https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our Facebook group? Clink the Link to chat wit...
Aug 29, 2019•45 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Donald Harvey, a hospital employee who seemed to be nearby for a suspicious number of patient deaths. Check out Detective's Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher...
Aug 25, 2019•40 min
John and Daryn interview ask each other their most hard-hitting and thought provoking interview questions. Check out Detective's Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Ins...
Aug 22, 2019•22 min
John and Daryn are joined by author Maureen Callahan to discuss her new true crime novel, American Predator , about the crimes of Israel Keyes. Check out Detective's Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jt...
Aug 18, 2019•1 hr 31 min
John and Daryn are joined by Sherri Shepherd to talk about her role in the film Brian Banks . They also chat with Gia Mantegna about her new Snapchat series The Dead Girls Detective Agency . Check out Detective's Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on ...
Aug 15, 2019•44 min
John and Daryn are joined by Buddy Day to discuss his relationship with Charles Manson, and his film about the women in The Family. Check out Detective's Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on T...
Aug 11, 2019•48 min
John and Daryn discuss an odd comment made by a friend, and regrettable fashion trends they followed in high school. Check out Detective's Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthras...
Aug 08, 2019•21 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Paul Gruber, whose daughter became suspicious of his welfare when his handwriting changed in the cards he sent to her. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram Follow Daryn:...
Aug 04, 2019•27 min
John and Daryn talk their hatred of robocallers, their feelings about clowns, and their dream crime-related jobs. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram Follow Daryn: @CarpeDaryn on Twitter, @CarpeDaryn on ...
Aug 01, 2019•23 min
That's right everyone!! This week John and Daryn discuss the case of Henry Louis Wallace (The Motherf***ing Taco Bell Strangler), who brutally murdered a slew of employees at the Taco Bell he managed. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on...
Jul 28, 2019•42 min
John and Daryn are joined by Sara and Casey from Not Another True Crime Podcast, to discuss their serial killer qualities, crime and punishment, and running a crime pod! Check out Not Another True Crime Podcast HERE ! Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow Jo...
Jul 25, 2019•32 min
John and Daryn are joined by Nancy Grace to discuss her opinions on the case of Michelle Carter and Conrad Roy. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram Follow Daryn: @CarpeDaryn on Twitter, @CarpeDaryn on In...
Jul 23, 2019•13 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Michelle Carter, whose relationship with Conrad Roy seemed like an innocent first love, but quickly became deadly. National Suicide Prevention Lifeline: 1-800-273-8255 Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher ...
Jul 21, 2019•1 hr
John and Daryn discuss a recent run-in with subway seafood, the NYC blackout, and answer fan questions. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram Follow Daryn: @CarpeDaryn on Twitter, @CarpeDaryn on Instagram ...
Jul 18, 2019•28 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Nick Godejohn, who murdered Dee Dee Blanchard, the unstable and abusive mother of his girlfriend Gypsy Rose. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram Follow Daryn: @CarpeDar...
Jul 14, 2019•50 min
John and Daryn talk recent July 4th vaycays, their interview with Nancy Grace, and answer fan questions. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram Follow Daryn: @CarpeDaryn on Twitter, @CarpeDaryn on Instagram...
Jul 11, 2019•22 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Robert Berchtold, a predator who wormed his way into the Broberg family's good graces in order to pursue a relationship with their very young daughter. Plus exclusive interview with Jan Broberg about her experience with Berchtold. Check out Oxygen's Detective's Den! Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis an...
Jul 07, 2019•1 hr 9 min
John, Daryn, and Matt talk their fun experiences with the NYC pride parade! Plus exclusive interview with Nancy Grace to discuss her upcoming Oxygen series 'Injustice' and more. Injustice with Nancy Grace premieres Saturday, 7/13 at 6/5c. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_Th...
Jul 03, 2019•42 min
Ken Rex McElroy was murdered in the middle of a busy town, but nobody seems to know anything about his "mysterious" death. Check out Oxygen's Detective's Den! Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram Follow D...
Jun 30, 2019•39 min
John and Daryn share their coming out stories, and John regales us with tales from his European adventure. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram Follow Daryn: @CarpeDaryn on Twitter, @CarpeDaryn on Instagr...
Jun 27, 2019•38 min
John and Daryn discuss the events of the Ted Bundy murders, and speak with Bundy attack survivor Kathy Kleiner. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram Follow Daryn: @CarpeDaryn on Twitter, @CarpeDaryn on In...
Jun 23, 2019•38 min
John and Daryn discuss John's upcoming trip to visit the Spice Girls, strange tourist deaths in the Dominican Republic, and Oxygen's DetectiveDen Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram Follow Daryn: @CarpeD...
Jun 20, 2019•17 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Sabrina San Millan, a housewife who turned to religion in an attempt to make her family more wholesome, but ended up finding a deadly affair partner instead. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter...
Jun 16, 2019•35 min
John and Daryn relive the fun (and ridiculous) events of CrimeCon 2019! Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram Follow Daryn: @CarpeDaryn on Twitter, @CarpeDaryn on Instagram Mail: You can send us things! Se...
Jun 13, 2019•27 min
John and Daryn discuss Keri Murphy, a sixteen year old who would do anything to continue dating a much older girl, despite her parents' protests. Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “biggest fan” yet. Download our YARN story here: http://bit.ly/mmyarn2019 Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martin...
Jun 09, 2019•37 min
John and Daryn listen and respond to special messages from Deadicators. Many thanks to Miles The Bartender and Maggie The Bartender for providing our transition sound effects!! Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “biggest fan” yet. Download our YARN story here: http://bit.ly/mmyarn2019 Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat wit...
Jun 06, 2019•15 min
John and Daryn are joined by Vince Averill to discuss the untimely and brutal demise of Pro-Wrestler Bruiser Brody. Check out Vince's podcast We Watch Wrestling and stay tuned for more Vince in this Sunday's episode. These 5 Types of Working Dogs Do Important Jobs: https://www.oxygen.com/types-working-dogs-jobs-trained Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “biggest fan” yet. Download our YARN story here: http://bit.ly/mmyarn2019 Shop for Martinis ...
Jun 02, 2019•47 min
John, Daryn, and Matt are joined by Vince Averill to recap their attendance at the recent My Favorite Murder book launch party, and to discuss Daryn's recent birthday celebration. Check out Vince's podcast We Watch Wrestling and stay tuned for more Vince in this Sunday's episode. Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “biggest fan” yet. Download our YARN story here: http://bit.ly/mmyarn2019 Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxyg...
May 30, 2019•35 min
John and Daryn discuss Carmen Montelongo, a young woman whose preference for older men seemed harmless until her boyfriend friend went missing around the same time Carmen's mom received two huge plant pots for mother's day. Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “biggest fan” yet. Download our YARN story here: http://bit.ly/mmyarn2019 Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join...
May 26, 2019•47 min
