It’s Cryptic Out There - podcast cover

It’s Cryptic Out There

It's Cryptic Out There podcasters.spotify.com
“It’s Cryptic Out There” is a monthly podcast hosted by Justin and Josh, delving into bizarre crime cases, paranormal incidents, and conspiracies. Visiting real locations, they interview those tied to the stories—think murders, hauntings, UFOs, and possessed objects—unpacking the sinister and mysterious with a mix of investigation and eerie storytelling. Hotline: (615) 447-8258 https://www.instagram.com/itscrypticoutthere Email: itscrypticoutthere@gmail.com
Last refreshed:
Follow this podcast in the Metacast mobile app to refresh it and see new episodes.
Download Metacast podcast app
Podcasts are better in Metacast mobile app
Don't just listen to podcasts. Learn from them with transcripts, summaries, and chapters for every episode. Skim, search, and bookmark insights. Learn more

Episodes

#39 - Cryptic Hotline #4 - Paranormal Orbs in Bedroom/Chupacabra Caught on Camera in Texas?

Welcome back to another episode of "It's Cryptic Out There!" In this episode, Justin and Julia sit down to hear a Cryptic Hotline call that came in describing a bizarre encounter with orbs that terrified the caller. Then, Justin looks into the viral story about an unknown creature that happened at a Amarillo Zoo in Texas. This unexplained photo has experts curious and creeped out. Could it be a hoax, a Chupacabra? You be the judge. Then lastly, another Texas story involving a man being chased do...

Jun 20, 202234 minSeason 2Ep. 39

#38 - The Girl in The Hoodie: Victims Reach Out About Their Encounters w/ Jerry Smith or "Angie Renee" Part 2

In this wild episode, Justin and Josh discover new information regarding Jerry Smith and his history of employment. What is discovered is quite shocking as they debunk an alleged claim when Justin travels to Blacksburg Virginia's Centro Taco Bar. A story came out the same time Jerry died that the bar was serving laced mixed drinks to patrons. There was a theory that Jerry once worked there and may have done the drugging. However, is this true? Then, the two read off another story from the hotlin...

Jun 14, 20221 hr 4 minSeason 2Ep. 38

#37 - The Girl in The Hoodie/Isi Etute and Jerry Smith Trial/Did The Jury Get It Right? Part 1

Welcome to It's Cryptic Out there! In this episode, Justin and Josh invite Hunter Stevers on the show. Justin's former co-host to podcast "Unhelpful Advice." Last year, Virginia Tech Football player Etute matched with a tinder account called "Angie Renee." Meeting for oral sex the first time, Etute was concerned this person was a catfish account. He would later go again a different night with two other football players. Etute discovered that this Angie was in fact a man by the name of Jerry Smit...

May 30, 202253 minSeason 2Ep. 37

#36 - The Cryptic Occurrences of Lucid Dreaming and Sleep Paralysis

Justin and Josh discuss the definition of Lucid Dreams and Sleep Paralysis. They dive into what the two are and their personal experiences. Some of what is told is quite chilling. Cryptic Hotline: (540) 358-1583 https://www.instagram.com/itscryptico... https://www.facebook.com/groups/25315... itscrypticoutthere@gmail.com https://www.youtube.com/c/JTimeFilms...

May 22, 20221 hr 13 minSeason 2Ep. 36

#35 - Human Hamburgers! Serial Killer Joe "The Cannibal" Metheny

Welcome back to the show! In this explicit, gruesome episode, Justin is joined with Josh and Julia as they dive into the case of serial killer Joe Metheny. Joe is known for killing the innocent and popularly known as a Cannibal that would use his victims flesh to mix in with his meat. Not only would he eat his victims, but he would sell meat sandwiches at his small "Meat Stand" business. Justin researches his upbringing and reads off Joe's sinister confession. VIEWER AND LISTENER DISCRETION IS A...

May 18, 202248 min

#34 - Dogman Creature In Narrows Virginia/Feral People In Smoky Mountains and National Parks

Welcome back to It's Cryptic Out There! In this episode, Justin and Josh return to the show with a special guest discussing the viral video that came out several months ago about a Truck Driver seeing a Supernatural Creature! Possibly, an alleged "Dogman." The three discuss the origin story and how it came about in the late 1800s and then again in the late 1980s. Then, Josh discusses the ongoing theory of "Feral People" and how people witness these wild people in our national parks. Buckle up fo...

May 09, 20221 hr 1 min

#33 - The Virginia Tech Massacre/Intense Story From An Employee Part 2

Welcome to Part 2 of The Virginia Tech Massacre series. In this episode, I was sent a story from Josh's mother Vickie Ferrell as she lets me read her story about her time working during the tragic mass shooting that took place in 2007. Also, there is a big announcement at the end of the episode. Cryptic Hotline: (540) 358-1583 https://www.instagram.com/itscrypticoutthere/ https://m.facebook.com/groups/2531530113816495/ crypticfilespodcast@gmail.com

Apr 30, 202218 minSeason 2Ep. 33

#32 - The Virginia Tech Massacre "The Question Mark Kid" Part 1

TRIGGER WARNING - LISTENER DISCRETION IS ADVISED Welcome back to another episode of It's Cryptic Out Out There! In this episode, I researched the tragic event that happened April 16, 2007. The Virginia Tech Massacre shooting. This story is the most sensitive subject our my area and for those who may have experienced that day personally or know someone that did, please take this with caution. There are triggering moments from the researched I gathered so this may not be for everyone. I did my bes...

Apr 16, 202238 min

#31 - My Friend Can See The Dead w/ Andy Wilburn

Welcome to It's Cryptic Out There! Today we have one of the most intense and heavy conversations on this show. Justin has a conversation with retired investigator Andy Wilburn about his ability to see the dead and how he can communicate with them. Andy starts off by discussing the discovery of his gift and what it entailed growing up. He dives into his belief on the after-life and theories behind it, he explains how he envisions spirits to better help comprehend for other and he then tells one o...

Apr 04, 20221 hr 44 minSeason 2Ep. 31

#30 - Human Soup For Dinner! Cryptic Stories w/ Your Hosts

Welcome back to another episode of It's Cryptic Out There! Justin and Josh are back again with a different episode that they hope will continue down the road. A free form episode where the two discuss cryptic stories! First, Josh talks about his first ever encounter with something paranormal, second, Justin introduces Josh to the creepy YouTube video, "Blank Room Soup" which has created various theories over the internet. If you wish to watch the video yourself, here is a link! https://www.youtu...

Mar 25, 202241 minSeason 2Ep. 30

#29 - Telekinesis Kid Has A Name and Cryptic Past/Part 3

Welcome to the final part of the local Telekinesis/House of Demons story! In this episode I discover various elements to close this chapter. Josh reacts and gives his take on what is said. There were big surprises that left me unsettled in my chair. As some things are left to be alone... Hope you enjoy this concluding episode! Cryptic Hotline: (540) 358-1583 https://m.facebook.com/groups/2531530113816495/ https://www.instagram.com/itscrypticoutthere crypticfilespodcast@gmail.com...

Mar 15, 202229 minSeason 2Ep. 29

#28 - Demonic Voices/A Local Tells His Story About The House of Demons/Part 2

Welcome back to Part 2 of House of Demons! In this episode, I talk over the phone with a local and he tells his story about going to the haunted house on Fletcher's Mountain in Giles County VA. What he describes is one of the spookiest things I have ever heard! He gives his thoughts on what is in the house and what dark forces kept him from going back. CALL THE CRYPTIC HOTLINE: (540) 358-1583 https://www.facebook.com/groups/2531530113816495/ https://www.instagram.com/itscrypticoutthere/ crypticf...

Mar 10, 202228 minSeason 2Ep. 28

#27 - House of Demons In My Hometown? 1970s Paranormal Story about Possessed Boy w/ Josh Ferrell

What is up Cryptics! In this episode, I look into a forgotten story that had happened in my hometown which involves a young boy having supernatural powers that police saw first hand. However, some claims that it wasn't the boy causing these unbelievable actions. Some say that the house is extremely haunted with demonic activity. I bring on my good friend Josh to tell a story that involves him and correlates to this mystery. CALL THE CRYPTIC HOTLINE: (540) 358-1583 https://www.facebook.com/groups...

Mar 06, 202242 minSeason 2Ep. 27

#26 - Returning To The Podcast/Cryptic Apartment Reddit Stories

I am back! Sorry for the hiatus! A lot of things have happened over the past few months! As I will discuss. In this tune up episode, I will discuss the rebranding of the show and what to expect. I then read off cryptic Reddit stories that may keep you up at night… Call the Cryptic Hotline: (540) 358-1583 https://m.facebook.com/groups/2531530113816495/

Feb 28, 202231 minSeason 2Ep. 26

#25 - Morgan Harrington & The Serial Killer Taxi Driver

Welcome Cryptics to another episode! We kick the new year off with a story that I personally kept updates on as it hit home with yet another Virginia Tech Student tragically murdered. This is the story of Morgan Harrington who lived life to the fullest until one unfortunate night by the hands of Virginia Serial Killer Jesse Matthew. helpsavethenextgirl.com https://www.amazon.com/Murdered-Dead-Good-Lillian-Vance/dp/9937623774 Cryptic Hotline: (540) 358-1583 Subscribe to the Patreon! www.patreon.c...

Jan 03, 202233 minSeason 2Ep. 25

Episode 24: Cryptic Hotline #3 - FBI Shutting Down Caldwell Fields Murders Arrest? TRUE OR FALSE?

DROPPING THIS PATREON EXCLUSIVE! This was a call I received when covering The Caldwell Fields Murders. I interviewed former Camp Tuk-A-Way host Roy E. Glass on Episode 17 of the Cryptic Files Podcast and he told me off air about a story he never told anyone. Well, now he gave me the opportunity to share this shocking news about the FBI shutting down an arrest years ago. Enjoy this unheard story. Is it true? You be the judge. CRYPTIC HOTLINE: (540) 358-1583 https://www.instagram.com/crypticfilesp...

Dec 23, 20215 minSeason 2Ep. 24

Episode 23: The Uncanny Valley - Is Artificial Intelligence Society's End?

Hello Cryptics! In this episode, Justin riffs on the Uncanny Valley theory and how it is one of the most disturbing things he has ever seen. He dives into the recent news about artificial intelligence and how it is involving more human-like. Are Robots going to end society? You be the judge. CRYPTIC HOTLINE: (540) 358-1583 https://www.instagram.com/crypticfilespodcast www.patreon.com/crypticfiles Email: crypticfilespodcast@gmail.com

Dec 15, 202135 minSeason 2Ep. 23

Episode 22: Staying The Night at A Haunted Hotel

I made a trip with the family to Natural Bridge and stayed at the alleged haunted Natural Bridge Hotel. My investigation turns dark as bizarre things happen throughout the stay and I’m told cryptic stories from the staff. CRYPTIC HOTLINE: (540) 358-1583 https://www.instagram.com/crypticfilespodcast https://m.facebook.com/groups/2531530113816495/ EMAIL:crypticfilespodcast@gmail.com www.patreon.com/crypticfiles

Dec 01, 202146 minSeason 2Ep. 22

PATREON ANNOUNCEMENT/$5 A Month/Link in Description

Hello Cryptics! By the title I think you know what this announcement is about! Yes, I decided to make a patreon for this show in order to provide more content for you all fans. Not only will this patreon subscription will benefit you all, but it will help the show grow and provide new stories and places I can research. HERE IS THE LINK TO SIGN UP FOR THE PATREON! https://www.patreon.com/crypticfiles

Nov 20, 20217 min

Episode 21: McKamey Manor Extreme Haunted Attraction/Grave Robbing For Morons

Hello Cryptics! Welcome to the Halloween Special and Season 1 Finale of Cryptic Files! In this epic episode, I dive into researching the infamous "Grave Robbing For Morons" and try to figure out if it is a legitimate tutorial home video on grave robbing and selling human remains on the black market or if it is just a fictional home video made by teenagers. Then, we learn the origin story behind America's Most Extreme Haunted House Attraction "McKamey Manor." The attraction was created by controv...

Oct 29, 20211 hr 11 minSeason 1Ep. 21

Episode 20: Interview w/ Crime Thriller Author Sarah Warburton "You Can Never Tell"

Hello Cryptics! In this bonus episode for season one, I invite local author Sarah Warburton on the podcast to discuss her latest psychological crime thriller "You Can Never Tell." We talk about her upbringing and success on becoming an author and we dive into her methods of storytelling. I highly recommend checking her book out! Here are some links to get to know her! Hope you enjoy! https://www.sarahwarburtonauthor.com/ https://www.instagram.com/sarahwarburtonauthor/?hl=en https://www.amazon.co...

Oct 16, 202130 minSeason 1Ep. 20

Episode 19: The Vampire Clan Double Homicide - Rod Ferrell "Vesago"

Hello Cryptics! In this episode, I research the case of Rod Ferrell or "Vesago" and The Kentucky Vampire Clan Double Homicide. Murray, Kentucky in the late 90s had a special group of individuals that joined in the night. I'm talking vampires! Well, so they say. These so called vampires would come out at night and conduct in blood rituals, sexual activities and drug use. One group, however, took their vampire belief to the extreme as they would set out on a rescue mission to pick up a fellow vamp...

Oct 01, 202130 minSeason 1Ep. 19

Episode 18: The Caldwell Fields Murders - Interview w/ Ex Cop Lisa Gardner Part 3

Hello Cryptics! In the third and final part (as for right now) to the Caldwell Fields Murders I talk to ex-cop Lisa Gardner who ever since the murders, has been obsessed with trying to solve this case. She tells me her story on what made it personal, her background in the police force, and her theory on what happened that night. Lisa has high hopes about this case and where it stands to this day. CALL THE HOTLINE: (540) 358-1583 https://www.instagram.com/crypticfilespodcast/ https://twitter.com/...

Sep 09, 202154 minSeason 1Ep. 18

Episode 17: Cryptic Hotline #2 - Camp Tuk-A-Way Sets The Record Straight/Fan Calls In To Tell Scary Story

Hello Cryptics! In this episode, Justin talks to the former director of Craig Creek Road's Camp Tuk-A-Away Roy Glass III. Roy, informs Justin and the listeners that the camp had no correlation with the night of David and Heidi's murders. Roy explains the story from his perspective and how the camp actually helped out during the investigation with supplying water for the officers and adding surveillance video around the camp. Additionally, he talks about a story that many don't know... At the end...

Sep 04, 202147 minSeason 1Ep. 17

Episode 16: Cryptic Hotline Phone Call #1

Hey Cryptics! In this episode, I receive a voicemail on the Cryptic Hotline by a man who lives in Arizona but is from Virginia. He lets me know that he as questions and a history that surrounds Caldwell Fields and the time of David and Heidi's murder. I call him back and was dumbfounded by what he told me not only about Blacksburg Virginia but the bizarre history the New River Valley contains. Buckle up for this one and watch your back, it's cryptic out there... Cryptic Hotline: (540) 358-1583 P...

Aug 31, 202125 minSeason 1Ep. 16

Episode 15: The Caldwell Fields Murders - Interview w/ "The Bulldog" A Private Investigator Part 2

In Part 2 of The Caldwell Fields Murders, Justin calls Private Investigator "The Bulldog" to discuss his investigation of David and Heidi's murder. The Bulldog gives his backstory on his journey into becoming a private investigator and how this case in particular became very personal for him. He informs Justin the mistakes the police made during the time of the murders and he tells his theory and possible suspect of the case. This is an intense one guys. Call the Cryptic Hotline: (540) 358-1583 ...

Aug 29, 20211 hr 15 minSeason 1Ep. 15

Episode 14: The Caldwell Fields Murders - Heidi and David Part 1

Craig Creek Road File Heidi Childs and David Metzler were two young adults in love. They had their life set as they would attend Virginia Tech University to help better their careers. On the night of Wednesday, August 26th 2009, the two would be abruptly murdered during a late night date in the area of Caldwell Fields. Their killer or killers are still out free and living life. In this episode, I research the backstory on these two lovers and the moments leading up to their final night. This is ...

Aug 26, 202129 minSeason 1Ep. 14

Episode 13: Reading A Listener's Message/Lucid Dreaming

In this episode, it is a continuation from the Premonitions episode where I asked listeners to call the hotline or write in a response about the premonition subject. I read off a creepy, yet fascinating story about a listener's "gift." Later, I ask if anyone has ever experienced Lucid Dreaming? Or even, lucid nightmares? CALL THE HOTLINE: (540) 358-1583 Follow Cryptic Files https://www.facebook.com/groups/2531530113816495/ https://www.instagram.com/crypticfilespodcast/ Email: crypticfilespodcast...

Jul 31, 202113 min

Episode 12: TRIGGER WARNING - The Sex Chamber/David Parker Ray aka "The Toy-Box Killer"

LISTENER DISCRETION IS ADVISED Welcome to Cryptic Files! In this episode, Justin tells the story about David Parker Ray, mostly known as "The Toy-Box Killer." Throughout the 80s and 90s, David Parker Ray was an American kidnapper, torturer, rapist and suspected serial killer. Ray would take young women to his torture trailer and would keep them for however long he wanted. He was not the only the one involved with these disgusting crimes either. This episode is highly disturbing and will cause ni...

Jul 20, 20211 hr 8 minSeason 1Ep. 12

Episode 11: Cryptic Hotline (540) ‪358-1583‬/Premonitions

Hey Cryptics. This is a different episode. I recently lost a family member and had a weird occurrence before getting a call from my father. It has freaked me out ever since then and the tragic loss has really changed my outlook on life. My grandfather has passed away and my whole family is dealing with this sad situation. As for that, it is really hard to comprehend what happened as this is the first big death I have experienced from a loved one. Roy Smith was a great person and a true believer ...

Jun 25, 202116 minSeason 1Ep. 11
For the best experience, listen in Metacast app for iOS or Android